Killers of 5Dimes Sports Book Convicted in Costa Rica Court

Tico TimesCOSTA RICA\'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

A password will be e-mailed to you.

No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

Costa Rica Proposes Major Overhaul of Courts and State Oversight

Costa Rica Escalates Court Fight With Criminal Complaint Against Judges

Costa Rica Orders AyA to Compensate Customers Over Excess Water Charges

Costa Rica’s Economy Slows as Central Bank Warns of El Niño Risk

What the Judicial Coup Fight in Costa Rica is Actually About

HomeCosta RicaKillers of 5Dimes Sports Book Convicted in Costa Rica Court

A Costa Rica court has convicted nine persons in the murder/kidnapping of 5Dimes founder Sean “Tony” Creighton.

Creighton was kidnapped in September of 2018 when two Costa Rica traffic officers pulled over his Porsche, stole the car and handed him over to the perpetrators of the crimes after what was later found to be a year long plot.

“5Dimes Tony” had been at the forefront of online gambling in Costa Rica for nearly two decades. Unlike other sports book owners Creighton tried to maintain a very low profile after seeing many of his competitors extradited from Costa Rica and convicted in United States courts on gambling related charges.

He did not dress like a multi-millionaire, preferring t-shirts and short pants. He avoided body guards despite his wealth, in an attempt to avoid the attention it would attract.

He also avoided putting his name on any legal papers and entrusted his close inner circle of trusted employees to be the face of his activities. In Costa Rica it is not illegal to take bets on sports in the United States, so Costa Rican citizens are often used as “front persons” in these businesses.

When Creighton was taken the kidnappers demanded a five million dollar ransom with a hard deadline. Unable to come up with that amount in time the family sent one million dollars via Bitcoin as the kidnappers demanded. 5Dimes Tony was never released. He was just 43 at the time of the kidnapping.

Speculation ran rampant in the online booking world. Before the kidnapping Creighton was expected to enter into a plea deal in a United States criminal investigation that had uncovered his illicit activities in accepting and transferring money to and from the United States. Many thought he had just taken the money and ran off on one of his false passports to avoid prosecution.

Much of that speculation came to an end almost a year later when allegedly his body was found in a shallow grave in t he Pacific town of Quepos, Costa Rica. Allegedly, because many suspect that the body was never properly identified and was an “Epstien” style cover up by local authorities. His widow later settled the case for $47 million dollars with the United States government but was able to retain ownership of the sports book operation.

Those convicted of the crimes were found to be members of his entrusted inner circle at 5Dimes and their family, along with the two traffic cops that pulled him over. It was said at trial that he was killed when he recognized one of his former employees as one of the kidnappers.

The crew that took him were tracked from Costa Rica, to Panama, Cuba and finally in Zargoza, Spain. Legal experts were able to find them via the Bitcoin money paid to the kidnappers.

In order to avoid a lengthy trial and the potential sentences that could result, the defendants agreed to a deal with prosecutors. Most of those convicted received a maximum sentence of 35 years.

Where Fixed Internet Still Does Not Reach in Costa Rica

Nearly three in ten Costa Rican households have no fixed internet, and the gap sits in the rural and coastal areas that show up most often on relocation shortlists.

Costa Rica Cuts 2026 Growth Forecast as El Niño Raises Cost Risks

Costa Rica’s Central Bank has lowered its economic growth forecast for 2026 as weaker exports, slower household demand and the expected effects of El...

Costa Rica Files Constitutional Reform to Widen Extradition of Citizens

Costa Rica is preparing to make a big change to who it can send abroad to face trial. The government says it will ask...

Costa Rica Beats Haiti on Penalties to Reach U-20 World Cup

Costa Rica’s men’s under-20 soccer team qualified for the 2027 FIFA U-20 World Cup on Tuesday after defeating Haiti 5-3 in a dramatic penalty...

Costa Rica Reports Sharp Increase in Human Trafficking Investigations

Human trafficking investigations in Costa Rica have already surpassed the total recorded during all of last year, with sexual exploitation accounting for most of...

Costa Rica Investigates Jaguar Pelt Seized in Heredia Raid

An apparent jaguar pelt found inside a home during raids against a violent criminal group has opened a separate wildlife investigation alongside an organized...

U.S. Citizen Found Dead in Guanacaste as OIJ Investigates

The Judicial Investigation Agency is treating the death of a 75-year-old U.S. citizen found in Cabo Velas, Santa Cruz, as an apparent homicide possibly linked to a robbery at the property.

Starbucks Opens 33rd Costa Rica Store as Dunkin Expands

Starbucks has opened its 33rd store in Costa Rica while Dunkin' adds locations in Zapote and Sabana Este, intensifying competition in the country's coffee and doughnut market.

Costa Rica Approves Wildlife Crossings Law to Protect Animals

Costa Rica’s Legislative Assembly unanimously approved a bill today requiring wildlife protection measures in new and existing public infrastructure projects, a major legal step...

The week's top stories, weather & insider tips — delivered every Sunday. One email, zero clutter.

🔒 Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Costa Rica Detains 56 Peruvians Working Illegally at Gold Mine

Former Herediano Executive Pleads Guilty in U.S. Gambling Case

Dollar Stuck Near ₡450 as Costa Rica Keeps Policy Rate

San José’s Parque Central Closes for Six Months of Renovation

Costa Rica Airport Laser Incidents Reach Record High