====================================================================================================
LOPP L082  |  Chen, a seller of virtual currency  |  May, 2022  |  China
====================================================================================================

STATUS  new

PROPOSED RECORD  [new case from Lopp's list, PR 234; read by two readers; flags and obtained re-read 2026-10-17 under the owner's definitions (empty = unknown); no operator has reviewed it; no stats2 id yet]
  date                May, 2022
  victim              Chen, a seller of virtual currency
  location            Zhangzhou, Fujian
  country             China
  description         During an arranged sale of more than 50,000 units of a virtual currency, the buyer and accomplices lured the seller, surnamed Chen, into a car, drove to a remote mountain area, took his phone by force, made him give his passwords and transferred 53,008 units out of his wallet. The Zhangzhou Intermediate Court upheld the robbery convictions on appeal.
  detention           yes
  violence_torture    yes
  drugs_alcohol       (unknown)
  weapons             (unknown)
  theft               yes
  life_taken          0
  venue_of_control    vehicle in motion
  held_duration       (not stated)
  arrests             convicted
  demanded            no demand figure given; he was forced to give his wallet passwords
  taken               53008 | 53,008 units of an unnamed virtual currency (agreed trade price over RMB 300,000), plus his phone; 7,148 units later returned by police
  notes               Single source: a legal-commentary post on Sohu (dated March 20, 2026, account 华安处置) retelling the Zhangzhou Intermediate People's Court appeal judgment (张某某等抢劫案); it is not original reporting and the judgment was not fetched. Location: the article names the court (Zhangzhou, Fujian) and a remote mountain forest; it does not name the place of the trade or of the robbery, so location is set to Zhangzhou. Currency: the article calls it only 'a certain virtual currency' (某虚拟货币), so taken_currency is left null; Lopp's 'USDT' is not in the article. Approach: an arranged trade, P2P trade only by rule, although the car was a further pretext (verifying the coins). Attack Kidnapping: the victim was pre-selected through the arranged trade and driven to a remote mountain area away from the public before being controlled; Express kidnapping fails on pre-selection. Violence yes on '暴力控制' (control by violence); no injury is described. Weapons no: none reported; Lopp's 'armed robbery' is not in the article, which says only robbery (抢劫). Venue: he was lured into the car and controlled after it reached the mountain forest; the article does not say whether he stayed in the car, set as vehicle in motion by the precedent of similar cases. Outcome Unknown: the article does not say how he was let go. Targeting Unknown: the article does not say how Zhang and Chen came to trade. Arrests convicted: several robbers received custodial sentences.

CHANGES OF 2026-10-17
  drugs_alcohol: no -> (empty)
  weapons: no -> (empty)
  re-read note: violence yes rests on 暴力控制 ('violent control'); the kind of force is not described. Lopp's line says armed robbery, but the kept text says only 抢劫 (robbery) and names no weapon, so weapons is unknown.

FOUR-STEP LABELS
  targeting           Unknown
  targeting_accuracy  Correct
  who_was_attacked    Holder
  approach            P2P trade
  attack              Kidnapping
  outcome             Unknown
  obtained            Crypto; Devices or seed

PEOPLE ATTACKED
  Holder: 1 (the seller lured into the car)

PUBLIC SUMMARY  [plain English, the text the site shows]
  In May 2022, in a case later tried in Zhangzhou, Fujian, a defendant surnamed Zhang agreed with a
  seller surnamed Chen to exchange more than RMB 300,000 for more than 50,000 units of a virtual
  currency. During the trade, Zhang and accomplices lured Chen into a car on the pretext of verifying
  the coins. When the car reached a remote wooded mountain area, they controlled him by force, took
  his phone and forced him to give his passwords, then transferred 53,008 units out of his wallet.
  Zhang spent most of them, 45,871 units, on online gambling. Police returned to Chen the 7,148 units
  still in Zhang's wallet. On appeal, the Zhangzhou Intermediate People's Court valued the loot at the
  agreed trade price and ordered Zhang to repay Chen RMB 259,629.86 for the units that could not be
  recovered. Several of the robbers received prison terms. The report does not say when Chen was let
  go.

CASE DETAILS  [internal evidence record, quotations in the original language]
  **Victims:** One seller of virtual currency, surnamed Chen ("被害人陈某"). The article says the coins in
  his wallet came from mining ("本案中为“挖矿”所得") and that the evidence did not show they were obtained
  illegally. No age or sex given.
  **Attackers:** Defendant Zhang ("被告人张某某") acting with others ("伙同他人"); the article later speaks of
  several robbers ("几名抢劫者"). Their number is not given.
  **Attack Method:** "2022年5月，被告人张某某与被害人陈某约定，以人民币30余万元的价格“兑换”5万余个某虚拟货币": in May 2022 Zhang and Chen
  agreed to exchange more than RMB 300,000 for more than 50,000 units of a virtual currency. During
  the trade Zhang and others lured Chen into a car on the pretext of verifying the coins
  ("以“验币”为名将陈某诱骗至车上").
  **Violence Used:** Detention: after the car reached a remote mountain forest ("在车辆行驶至偏僻山林后"), they
  used violent control, seized his phone and forced him to give the passwords ("采取暴力控制、抢走手机、逼迫密码等手段").
  No weapon and no injury are reported, and the article does not say how long he was held.
  **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** 53,008 units of an unnamed virtual currency ("某虚拟货币") were forcibly
  transferred from Chen's wallet; 45,871 were squandered by Zhang on online gambling and other illegal
  activities. Police returned the 7,148 units still in the defendant's wallet to Chen. The court
  valued the crime at the agreed price of over RMB 300,000 and, at the lowest agreed unit price of RMB
  5.66, ordered Zhang to repay RMB 259,629.86 for the 45,871 units that could not be recovered. His
  phone was also taken.
  **Status:** Convicted. The Zhangzhou Intermediate People's Court (福建省漳州市中级人民法院), on appeal, replaced
  the first-instance order to keep pursuing the currency's RMB value with an order that Zhang repay
  Chen RMB 259,629.86; the robbers received custodial sentences ("对几名抢劫者判处了实刑"). The case was selected
  for the 2025 collection of Chinese court cases (《中国法院2025年度案例》). Source: commentary posted on Sohu
  on March 20, 2026 by an account named 华安处置; the judgment itself was not fetched.

OPEN QUESTIONS FOR THE OWNER
  (none)

SECOND READER
  venue_of_control: The text says control began after the car reached a remote mountain forest
  (在车辆行驶至偏僻山林后); no passage places the victim in a moving vehicle while held. The reader's 'precedent
  of similar cases' is not in the text. Owner to decide (public space or leave empty). -> public space
  rewritten after the second reader: summary: shortened to 889 characters by cutting the court's
  property-status reasoning and 'province, China'; kept who, where, when, how, what was taken and the
  ending; the control sentence keeps the text's wording (after the car reached the forest), so it
  holds whichever venue the owner picks

LOPP'S ENTRY
  May 2022  |  Chen  |  Zhangzhou, Fujian, China
  Zhang lured USDT seller Chen into a car with accomplices under the pretext of "verifying the
  tokens," then overpowered him in an isolated mountainous area and forced him to hand over passwords
  to transfer 53,008 tokens; most were squandered on gambling, with 7,148 returned to the victim by
  police. The Zhangzhou Intermediate People's Court upheld the armed robbery conviction on appeal and
  ordered restitution of RMB 259,629.86.
  differs: Lopp: 'USDT seller' and '53,008 tokens': the article names no coin (某虚拟货币).
  differs: Lopp: 'armed robbery conviction': the article says robbery (抢劫) and reports no weapon.
  differs: Lopp: Zhang 'overpowered him in an isolated mountainous area': matches; the article adds that his phone was taken.
  differs: Lopp location 'Zhangzhou, Fujian': the article names only the court in Zhangzhou, not the place of the robbery.

LINKED SOURCES
  1. https://www.sohu.com/a/999059313_100106004

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FETCHED ARTICLE 1
  Source     sohu.com
  URL        https://www.sohu.com/a/999059313_100106004
  Published  2026-03-20 18:07
  Retrieved  2026-10-16T14:30:28Z via raw HTTP retrieval (status 200); page furniture cut by paragraph range (kept 1, 4-22 of 22), article text unchanged
  Language   as published (kept in the original language, not translated)
  Length     1,844 chars
  Integrity  sha256 acfddf0e2a60810ece1b42f82b2bf792e19b9cbf844fbe4c003a6ae75f8cda2b
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
华安虚拟货币处置｜漳州中院裁判：明确虚拟货币处置规则，抢劫案按约定价退赔

随着数字经济的发展，虚拟货币（如比特币、以太坊等）已深度融入社会经济生活。然而，其法律属性——究竟是无价值的代码串，还是受法律保护的财产——长期以来在理论与实务界争议不断。近期，福建省漳州市中级人民法院审结的一起抢劫虚拟货币案（张某某等抢劫案），为理解这一问题提供了极具价值的司法实践样本。该案例已入选《中国法院2025年度案例》，其对虚拟货币案件中的数额认定与财产处置两大核心难题的裁判思路，值得深入剖析。

一、 案情回溯：当线下交易演变为暴力劫夺

2022年5月，被告人张某某与被害人陈某约定，以人民币30余万元的价格“兑换”5万余个某虚拟货币。交易过程中，张某某伙同他人，以“验币”为名将陈某诱骗至车上，在车辆行驶至偏僻山林后，采取暴力控制、抢走手机、逼迫密码等手段，强行将陈某钱包内的53008个虚拟货币转走。得手后，大部分虚拟货币（45871个）被张某某用于网络赌博等违法活动挥霍。

二、 核心争议：虚拟货币能否成为抢劫罪的对象？

本案的首要争议点在于，虚拟货币是否属于刑法意义上的“财产”，能否成为抢劫罪的犯罪对象。

二审法院（漳州中院）在裁判中明确指出：某虚拟货币是常见的虚拟货币之一，具有交换价值和经济属性，是一种虚拟商品，具有财产属性，可以成为抢劫罪的犯罪对象。 法院认为，被告人的根本目的是转移被害人对虚拟货币的占有，并获取其背后的财产利益，其行为直接侵害了公民的个人财产权益。这一认定，明确了在司法实践中，虚拟货币作为“虚拟商品”的财产地位，为后续定罪量刑奠定了法律基础。

三、 数额认定：在波动与隐匿中寻求“公允价”

涉虚拟货币犯罪，数额认定直接关系到量刑轻重。虚拟货币价格波动剧烈，且交易具有一定的匿名性，如何确定其案发时的价值，是实务中的“拦路虎”。本案集中展示了四种主要的认定路径及其利弊：

1. 以被害人购买成本认定：符合财产犯罪以实际损失计算的基本原则，但实践中被害人常无法提供有效的“溯源”购买凭证，导致该路径受阻。

2. 以被告人销赃获利认定：若被告人已变现，可据此认定，但本案中赃款去向为网络赌博，获利金额无法查清。

3. 以案发时域外交易平台均价认定：看似客观，但虚拟货币全球价格波动大，且不同平台存在价差，单一采纳可能失准。

4. 以双方交易约定价格认定：本案最终采纳了此路径。法院认为，被告人与被害人商定以30余万元交易5万余个虚拟货币，且该价格与同期当地市场价基本一致，排除了引诱或价格虚高的可能。被告人主观上抢劫的对象即是与虚拟货币等值的30余万元，据此认定犯罪数额具有正当性和合理性。

这一裁判规则提示我们，在交易环节发生的涉虚拟货币犯罪中，双方达成的、且与市场公允价无明显偏离的合意价格，可以成为认定犯罪数额的有效依据。

四、 财产处置：发还被害人还是没收国库？

对于查扣在案的虚拟货币及无法追回部分的处置，存在三种观点：返还被害人、一律没收国库、区分情况处理。本案采纳了第三种更为精细化的方案：

1. 前提审查：在案证据不足以证明被害人持有的虚拟货币（本案中为“挖矿”所得）系非法获取。

2. 处置方式：对尚在被告人钱包内未被挥霍的7148个虚拟货币，公安机关已发还被害人。对于已被转移、无法追回的45871个虚拟货币，二审法院撤销了一审“继续追缴虚拟货币折合人民币”的判项，改为 “责令上诉人张某某退赔被害人陈某人民币259629.86元” （按双方约定的最低单价5.66元计算）。

这一改判极具深意：既避免了直接判决将虚拟货币折算成人民币可能引发的政策风险（因国家对虚拟货币交易的政策导向），又通过责令退赔等值人民币的方式，切实保障了被害人的财产权益。其核心逻辑在于：保护合法财产权益，对来源合法的虚拟货币，应返还或折价退赔被害人；处置时须注意司法判决与金融政策的协调。

张某某案的意义，不仅在于对几名抢劫者判处了实刑，更在于其系统性地回应了数字经济时代刑事司法面临的新挑战。它清晰地表明，尽管虚拟货币不具有法定货币地位，但作为具有客观经济价值的“虚拟商品”，其背后的财产权益应受到法律平等保护。同时，该案为处理同类案件提供了可操作的裁判指引：在认定数额时，可灵活采用“双方约定价”等方法；在处置财产时，应坚持“保护合法、区分情况”的原则，力求在打击犯罪与保护权益、遵循政策与维护公正之间取得平衡。返回搜狐，查看更多
