====================================================================================================
LOPP L002  |  A bitcoin holder  |  2020  |  China
====================================================================================================

STATUS  new

PROPOSED RECORD  [new case from Lopp's list, PR 234; read by two readers; flags and obtained re-read 2026-10-17 under the owner's definitions (empty = unknown); no operator has reviewed it; no stats2 id yet]
  date                2020
  victim              A bitcoin holder
  location            Wenzhou, Zhejiang
  country             China
  description         Two defendants lured a bitcoin holder to an in-person meeting on the pretext of learning bitcoin trading, threatened the victim with a replica gun and a folding knife and demanded 1,000 bitcoin, and got nothing. A Wenzhou court convicted both of attempted robbery.
  detention           (unknown)
  violence_torture    threat only
  drugs_alcohol       (unknown)
  weapons             yes
  theft               no
  life_taken          (unknown)
  venue_of_control    (not stated)
  held_duration       (not stated)
  arrests             convicted
  demanded            1000 BTC | 1,000 bitcoin (prosecutors valued them at 52.69 million yuan)
  taken               nothing taken (attempted robbery)
  notes               Single source: a PANews roundup article (retrieved with a 2026 publication stamp; the text itself is from early 2023) that cites the judgment 《XX、XX抢劫罪一审刑事判决书》 published December 23, 2020. It is a retelling of the judgment, not original reporting; the judgment itself was not fetched. Location: the court is the Wenzhou Intermediate People's Court and the prosecutor the Rui'an City People's Procuratorate (瑞安市人民检察院), so the attack was probably in Rui'an, a county-level city under Wenzhou, but the article does not say where the meeting took place; location set to Wenzhou. Approach: the pretext was learning bitcoin trading techniques from the victim, set as a business or consulting pretext; 'Social engineering: other pretext' is the alternative. Outcome Unknown: the article does not say how the encounter ended; Lopp's 'he refused' is not in the article. Violence: threat only; the court's '以暴力、胁迫的方法' is the statutory robbery formula and names no act of violence. Weapons yes: a replica gun (仿真枪) shown as a threat and a folding knife. The victim's sex is not given; Lopp's 'him' is not confirmed.

CHANGES OF 2026-10-17
  detention: unconfirmed -> (empty)
  drugs_alcohol: no -> (empty)
  life_taken: 0 -> (empty)
  re-read note: Detention: the victim was threatened with a replica gun and then a folding knife at the meeting, but the text never says he was held or kept from leaving. Violence: the court's phrase '以暴力、胁迫的方法' is the statutory formula of the robbery article, not a described assault, so threat only stands. life_taken: the attempted-robbery verdict and 4-year sentence suggest nobody died, but the text does not say so.

FOUR-STEP LABELS
  targeting           Unknown
  targeting_accuracy  Unknown
  who_was_attacked    Holder
  approach            Social engineering: business or investment meeting
  attack              Armed robbery
  outcome             Unknown
  obtained            Nothing

PEOPLE ATTACKED
  Holder: 1 (the bitcoin holder met under the trading-lesson pretext)

PUBLIC SUMMARY  [plain English, the text the site shows]
  A first-instance judgment from Wenzhou, Zhejiang, China, published on December 23, 2020, concerns an
  attempted robbery of a bitcoin holder. The two defendants arranged an in-person meeting with the
  victim on the pretext of learning bitcoin trading techniques. There they threatened the victim with
  a replica gun and demanded 1,000 bitcoin, and when that failed they made further threats with a
  folding knife. They obtained nothing, and the court treated the robbery as attempted. The Wenzhou
  Intermediate People's Court convicted both of robbery, sentencing the principal offender to four
  years and the accomplice to two years and six months, with fines. The Rui'an City prosecutors valued
  the 1,000 bitcoin at 52.69 million yuan; the court set no amount because the sum sought was unclear.
  The report gives no date or place for the meeting and does not say how it ended.

CASE DETAILS  [internal evidence record, quotations in the original language]
  **Victims:** One bitcoin holder, not named and not described ("受害者", "原告", "被害人"). The article gives
  no age, sex or occupation.
  **Attackers:** Two defendants, a principal (主犯) and an accomplice (从犯), acting together ("结伙"). The
  judgment title in the article anonymises them as "XX、XX".
  **Attack Method:** "被告人以学习比特币交易技术为由线下约见受害者": the defendants met the victim offline on the pretext of
  learning bitcoin trading techniques. The article does not give the date or place of the meeting.
  **Violence Used:** No detention established: the article says the defendants
  "持仿真枪威胁原告交出1000个比特币未果，又持折叠刀对其进行威胁" (threatened the victim with a replica gun to hand over 1,000
  bitcoin, failed, then threatened the victim with a folding knife) and does not say whether or how
  long the victim was held. The court's wording "以暴力、胁迫的方法" is the statutory formula for robbery; no
  injury is reported.
  **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Demanded 1,000 BTC. Nothing was obtained: the court found the crime
  attempted ("判定犯罪未遂") and did not set a robbery amount because the amount of bitcoin sought was
  unclear. The Rui'an City People's Procuratorate valued the 1,000 BTC at 52.69 million yuan
  ("5269万元人民币") at the exchange rate of the time.
  **Status:** Convicted of robbery by the Wenzhou Intermediate People's Court (浙江省温州市中级人民法院) in a
  first-instance judgment published on December 23, 2020: the principal offender four years and a fine
  of 10,000 yuan, the accomplice two years six months and a fine of 6,000 yuan. Source: PANews roundup
  article citing the judgment.

OPEN QUESTIONS FOR THE OWNER
  1. (date) The article dates only the publication of the judgment (December 23, 2020). It gives no date for the meeting itself, which could fall in 2020 or earlier. Lopp gives 2020.
     set to: 2020  |  alternative: unknown year, on or before December 2020
     evidence: 以发布于2020年12月23日的《XX、XX抢劫罪一审刑事判决书》
  2. (detention) The victim was threatened with a replica gun and then a knife to hand over bitcoin, but the article says nothing about holding the victim or for how long. The flag rule counts being held at gunpoint until a transfer is made; here no transfer was made and the account is two sentences long.
     set to: unconfirmed  |  alternative: yes
     evidence: 持仿真枪威胁原告交出1000个比特币未果，又持折叠刀对其进行威胁

SECOND READER
  date: The kept text dates only the publication of the judgment (December 23, 2020), not the attack.
  No kept paragraph says when the meeting took place; 2020 is not supported as the attack year. Owner
  decides (leave year empty or accept 2020 as the judgment year).
  location: Kept text names only the court (Wenzhou Intermediate People's Court) and the Rui'an
  prosecutors; no paragraph says where the meeting or threat took place. Wenzhou is the court seat,
  not a stated attack location. Owner decides.
  rewritten after the second reader: summary: cut to the 900-character limit

LOPP'S ENTRY
  2020  |  Unidentified  |  Wenzhou, Zhejiang, China
  Defendants lured a bitcoin holder to a physical meeting under the pretext of teaching him bitcoin
  trading, then threatened him with fake weapons to make him hand over 1,000 BTC; he refused and they
  obtained nothing. The court found attempted armed robbery, sentencing the principal offender to 4
  years in prison and the accomplice to 2 years and 6 months.
  differs: Lopp: the victim 'refused'; the article says only that the threat with the replica gun failed ('未果') and does not say the victim refused.
  differs: Lopp: 'fake weapons'; the article names a replica gun (仿真枪) and a folding knife (折叠刀), the knife not described as fake.
  differs: Lopp date 2020 is the judgment's publication year (December 23, 2020); the article gives no attack date.
  differs: Lopp: sentences match (4 years; 2 years 6 months); the article adds fines of 10,000 and 6,000 yuan.

LINKED SOURCES
  1. https://www.panewslab.com/zh/articles/kc64bicx

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FETCHED ARTICLE 1
  Source     panewslab.com
  URL        https://www.panewslab.com/zh/articles/kc64bicx
  Published  2026-10-16T06:58:00.000Z
  Retrieved  2026-10-16T14:29:19Z via raw HTTP retrieval (status 200); page furniture cut by paragraph range (kept 11-15 of 16), article text unchanged
  Language   as published (kept in the original language, not translated)
  Length     405 chars
  Integrity  sha256 18b66073708b6459e952e913b7f606510cc93a104e968d776562a1dfab6a4f6b
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
抢币就是抢钱

而上述思路也在当下的司法判例中不断得到体现。

以发布于2020年12月23日的《XX、XX抢劫罪一审刑事判决书》[1]为例。被告人以学习比特币交易技术为由线下约见受害者，持仿真枪威胁原告交出1000个比特币未果，又持折叠刀对其进行威胁。

浙江省温州市中级人民法院认为，被告人以非法占有为目的，结伙以暴力、胁迫的方法劫取他人财物，其行为均触犯了《中华人民共和国刑法》第二百六十三条、第二十五条第一款，应当以抢劫罪追究其刑事责任，判处主犯有期徒刑四年，并处罚金人民币10000元；判处从犯有期徒刑二年六个月，并处罚金人民币6000元。

尽管该院因被告欲抢劫的比特币数额不明确而不予认定抢劫数额，但仍认为被告人为抢劫被害人的比特币而实施的行为非法，并判定犯罪未遂。且文书中明确提到，瑞安市人民检察院在庭审过程中，将1000枚比特币按照当时汇率折算为5269万元人民币，并以此指控被告人涉嫌抢劫。
