Archived
chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -670,3 +670,149 @@ Flags and facts:
|
||||
- **DB id 399** (owner) — confirmed by the victim directly: the Santiago (Gurabo) October 2025 robbery reported by Diario Libre, 7 Días, N Digital and De Último Minuto is this case; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (USDT sale arranged over Telegram, ambushed in an apartment, tied up, about US$400,000 moved from his phone per the press, left in Bonao in another province); the record's $750,000 against the press's about $400,000 is logged as a contradiction; the Instagram post https://www.instagram.com/p/DWhihZeGNtC/ is the Policía Nacional's wanted notice (30 March 2026) for four suspects, not the victim's post; two suspects surrendered about 1 May 2026, the alleged ringleader arrested about 12 May; staged under staging/399/ (pending merge into the dossier).
|
||||
- **DB id 444** (owner) — accept: keep the record's facts on France 3 Grand Est (12 May 2026, police sources: husband who invested in crypto as the target, 31 March, gagged, van found on rue du Jura with both suspects inside, threat video to the husband, plan to cut off a finger); log DNA's same-day account as a contradiction for Sofia (target a wealthy friend in Dubai, €600,000 demanded, found in the Neuhof forest, suspects arrested afterwards, no video); weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon in any source; tape, ropes, face coverings); violence_torture → 0 (found "saine et sauve"); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping stands.
|
||||
- **DB id 482** (owner) — theft → unconfirmed (CNEWS via police: "Aucun dégât ni aucun vol n'a été constaté", he held only 3,000 euros; tv78: the accounts held about 3,000 euros; Journal du Coin: transfers of a few thousand euros, about 3,000 euros taken, no source given); weapons unconfirmed; other flags as triaged.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Owner rulings — 2026-10-06 (cases with no person confronted)
|
||||
|
||||
Closes the question parked on 2026-09-30 (`disputed-scenarios.md`). New twelfth scenario: Burglary, defined in `DEFINITIONS.md` (wording approved by the owner the same day).
|
||||
- **DB ids 3, 6, 10, 57, 62, 66, 101, 105, 112, 198** (owner) — scenario was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Burglary (group A: crypto ATM thefts, nobody confronted). On 105 the fire extinguisher aimed at bystanders during the getaway goes in notes (owner).
|
||||
- **DB ids 21, 349** (owner) — scenario was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Burglary (group B: mining hardware, nobody present).
|
||||
- **DB id 99** (owner) — scenario was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Burglary (group C: house under renovation, nobody present).
|
||||
- **DB ids 383, 449, 450** (owner) — scenario was Home Invasion; now Burglary (group C: nobody home).
|
||||
- **DB ids 54, 158, 71** (owner) — scenario was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Burglary → Dodged Attack (failed ATM thefts, nothing taken from the machine). Both labels apply; the sequence set earlier for 158 (batch 06), 71 (batch 13) and 54 (batch 14) was Dodged Attack alone.
|
||||
- **DB id 45** (owner) — remove from the database.
|
||||
- **DB ids 24, 195** (owner) — keep in the database. The label for each is still to be set.
|
||||
|
||||
## Owner rulings — 2026-10-07 (four-step outcomes)
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 52** (owner) — outcome → escaped: the victim escaped (jumped from the balcony) and was not held; the old Dodged Attack label does not make the case "foiled". General rule stated with it: the outcome list has no "failed attack"; an attack that was stopped before anyone was under the attackers' control is foiled, and every other case takes the outcome that happened to the victim. Recorded in step-rulings.json.
|
||||
- **DB id 54** (owner) — outcome → foiled: the theft was interrupted and nobody was confronted.
|
||||
- **Outcome list** (owner) — new value "fought off": the victim, or someone with them, resisted physically and the attackers gave up and fled. All cases to be rechecked for it (recheck/).
|
||||
- **Who was attacked** (owner) — a couple or family attacked together is holder plus relative or partner; all cases to be rechecked for more than one victim (recheck/).
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 36 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-36.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-36.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-36.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 218** (DA) — theft → 1 ("the one object they took was a MacBook. With 'find my' turned on", her post on X via the Daily Star, no crypto obtained, a device taken counts as in 474 and 153, and no text says it was recovered, so the recovered-item rule of 188 and 495 does not apply); notes → deterred after she fired at the intruders, by her own account "I believe I shot one of them" (the record's "husband fired 3shots" goes: neither Daily Star text has a husband or a count of shots, and the record's own description has her shooting an attacker); description → Streamer Amouranth revealed the value of her Bitcoin wallet in a social media post, then an armed gang pulled her from her bed, beat and pistol-whipped her and held a gun to her head to make her log in to her phone, and by her account she shot one of them and they fled with only her MacBook ("screenshot" is in no text on file, Daily Star: "revealed the value of her Bitcoin wallet in a social media post asking followers if she should sell the assets that earned her a whopping $20 million in November last year"); arrests → a group of teenagers aged 16 to 19 arrested and charged, three of them with aggravated kidnapping and aggravated robbery with a deadly weapon, two still in custody on bonds of $150,000 and $200,000 (court documents obtained by FOX26, via the Daily Star follow-up, number arrested not stated, no verdict on file); date 2 March 2025 kept ("in the late hours of the 2nd March"); victim Kaitlyn Siragusa and location Houston, Texas kept; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (crypto demanded, no amount or coin named, none obtained); sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept (record's scenario: Home Invasion alone; Costly Fame rests on the Daily Star's "The attack comes after" the wallet post, with no police statement on how she was chosen, as 96); flags otherwise unchanged: kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 (beaten, pistol-whipped, scalp laceration needing stitches), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1, life_taken stays 0 (one intruder shot by her account, no death reported); held duration not stated; targeting vector = public profile / social media (the outlet's link); outcome note for the recheck pass: control was gained and the gang ran after she fired, so the owner's value "fought off" (2026-10-07) fits and the batch file's "foiled" does not; source notes: one URL carries two Daily Star texts (the report of 3 March 2025 on the fetched page, the arrests follow-up in the sheet, whose own URL is not recorded and should be found), the record's "YT" has no link on file, everything rests on her posts on X relayed with "claimed" and "apparently", and the closing paragraphs on Valkyrae, Cinna and Emiru are another incident, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 219** (DA) — description → Man sold cryptocurrency to a buyer in Kowloon City and, on his way home with the cash, had the plastic bag holding approximately HK$318,000 snatched from behind by an unidentified man who fled ("an unidentified man approached him from behind and snatched the bag", Dimsum Daily, which has no stick and no beating, and the record's own notes and flags say the same); location → Cheung Sha Wan, Hong Kong ("on Lai Wan Road, near the Lai Chi Kok Government Offices", so Lai Chi Kok is the landmark, and the trade was on Sung Wong Toi Road in Kowloon City); money_wanted → approximately HK$318,000 in cash taken (kept in Hong Kong dollars with no conversion, HK$ trap noted, and the value of the crypto sold is not stated); coin_type → cash (HKD), no crypto taken (coin sold not named, as 27 and 94); victim → 41-year-old man surnamed Wong; notes → no violence, just snatched the bag. He was on his way home to Wah Lai Estate, the suspect, about 1.75 metres tall in a black long-sleeve top, fled towards King Lai Path, and police classify the case as a robbery; arrests → none (suspect at large on 14 March 2025, nothing later on file); date 13 March 2025 kept ("late Thursday night", 11.39pm, in a report of Friday 14 March 2025); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Assault - Mugging kept (record's scenario: P2P Trade Gone Wrong alone; gap: the report does not say the robber was the buyer or connected to him, as 83 and 375); flags unchanged: kidnappings stays 0 (a snatch in passing, clarification 3), violence_torture stays 0, drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 0, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown, business counterparty possible (robbed on the way home from the trade, no link stated); single source, the sheet text and the Wayback copy match.
|
||||
- **DB id 221** (DA) — date → 24 March 2025 ("Rodrigo Perez was kidnapped on March 24", stated twice); location → São Paulo, Brazil ("on March 24 in São Paulo"; the record's Ipiranga is in no source on file and moves to notes marked pending source trace, owner rule of 2026-10-01); victim → Rodrigo Perez, Spanish businessman (named by Bitcoin.com News, "linked to several financial crimes in Paraguay and Ecuador" and wanted by Interpol for his "alleged participation in a series of crypto-linked schemes"); description → Man detained by men in fake police uniforms, taken in an official-looking truck to a makeshift prison, held five days tied to a bed and drugged with sleeping pills, by his account close to $50 million in cryptocurrency was taken from him, and he escaped on his own after drugging his guard (five days, not a week; the $50 million is "taken", in his statement to authorities, not demanded; two attackers is implied by "the second kidnapper", not stated); notes → alleged scammer, wanted by Interpol, kidnapped by men in fake police uniforms, then drugged the man guarding him with the same sleeping pills and fled. One of the kidnappers is a retired military policeman. Ipiranga as the district: pending source trace; money_wanted → close to $50 million in cryptocurrency taken, by Perez's own account to authorities (no demand reported, and nobody but Perez is cited for the figure); coin_type → cryptocurrency, coin not named; weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon named anywhere in the article, which mentions only fake police uniforms, an official-looking truck and the restraints, as 116, 396 and 401); violence_torture → unconfirmed ("tied to a bed, drugged with sleeping pills, and subjected to harassment": no blow or injury described and "harassment" is not explained, the restraint sits in kidnappings and the sedation in drugs_alcohol as ruled in 88; DA call following the second reader's note in the batch file, owner may keep 1); arrests → Ronaldo Batista, a retired military policeman, arrested when authorities raided the holding place and confessed, the second kidnapper at large; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Authority Misuse alone); flags otherwise unchanged: kidnappings stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 1, theft stays 1 (on his own statement), life_taken stays 0; held five days, outcome escaped; targeting vector = unknown (not stated; authorities do not rule out gang involvement "given Perez's alleged history of financial fraud"); source notes: single source, a Bitcoin.com News rewrite of unnamed "local media", so a Brazilian report is worth adding before publication; the closing wrench-attack paragraph is commentary, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 224** (DA) — description → Gang posing as officials of the FIA, the Counter-Terrorism Department and intelligence agencies kidnapped him in PIB Colony, took him to a warehouse in Steel Town, questioned him about his Bitcoin business, accused him of illegal Hundi/Hawala dealing, took his iPhone and said they would contact him about money later, then dropped him on Sharea Faisal (Dawn, from the arrested suspects' statements in a CTD press release; "forces him to hand over Bitcoin" goes because no transfer is reported, and "police" is narrower than the article); violence_torture → unconfirmed ("They asked him about Bitcoin business and threatened him that he was involved in illegal work of Hundi/Hawala": a threat only, no blow or injury described, and the account is the suspects' own as relayed by the CTD, as 469 and 393); victim → Mohammed Ismail; location → PIB Colony, Karachi, Pakistan (seized there, held at a warehouse in Steel Town, dropped on Sharea Faisal "near a stop"); arrests → four of six to seven suspects arrested near Parking Plaza in Saddar: Imtiaz alias Salman, Ubaid Rehman alias Abi, Shahid alias Moosa and Saleem (no charge or court step on file); date 13 April 2025 kept ("in PIB Colony on April 13"); money_wanted stays empty (money was to be discussed "later on", no amount stated) and coin_type stays empty (no crypto reported taken); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (owner ruling of 2026-09-30: warehouse in Steel Town, a place the attackers control; the record's scenario still reads Express Kidnapping); flags otherwise unchanged: kidnappings stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (the gang "carried arms", three pistols recovered at the arrest), theft stays 1 (the iPhone only), life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated (the batch rationale's "released the same day" is not in Dawn, which says only 'short-term' of the gang's kidnappings in general); the verified summary's "Shahra-e-Faisal" should follow Dawn's spelling "Sharea Faisal"; targeting vector = unknown (they asked about his Bitcoin business, how they knew of it is not stated); single source, a CTD press release that Dawn reports with "claimed".
|
||||
- **DB id 228** (DA) — victim → 28-year-old Italian man, name not released (ABC News: "whose name has not been publicly released by authorities", Reuters: "not identified by name in court"; the record's "Michael V.T. Carturan" is in neither source on file and no source names anyone else, so the name comes off pending source trace and returns with a source); description → Two crypto investors allegedly lured an Italian man to a SoHo townhouse, bound him and tortured him for about 17 days, with beatings, electric shocks and cuts from a small chainsaw, to get his Bitcoin password, which he did not give up before he escaped (two men are indicted, not one, "businessman" is in neither source, and every detail is allegation at arraignment); notes → Prosecutors say he was lured from Italy by threats to have his family killed, and the defence says he was free to leave and went out to church, clubs and dinners. Held about 17 days per ABC News and the NYPD, three weeks per Reuters. He escaped on 23 May when Woeltz went to fetch a laptop and ran to a traffic enforcement officer, per ABC News, or when the two left the house to retrieve his phone and he found a uniformed police officer, per Reuters (replaces "Italian went voluntarily to their house", which is the defence position alone; 6 to 23 May is 17 days); location → SoHo, Manhattan, New York (Woeltz's eight-bedroom townhouse); money_wanted → his Bitcoin password demanded, no amount stated, nothing obtained; coin_type → BTC; theft → unconfirmed ("he was stripped of his electronics and passport", ABC News, and the defendants "took the alleged victim's devices", Reuters: taken on arrival as part of the confinement, whether he got them back is not stated, and no crypto moved; DA call as 437, owner may set 0 or 1); reports → ABC News, Reuters (the record lists ABC only, Reuters is url_2); arrests → John Woeltz, 37, arrested 23 May and William Duplessie, 33, surrendered 27 May 2025, both indicted on a dozen counts including kidnapping, assault and coercion, pleaded not guilty on 11 June 2025 and held without bail, next hearing 15 July 2025, no verdict on file (a 24-year-old woman arrested on 23 May is not being prosecuted; Commissioner Tisch: "There may be others"); date 6 May 2025 kept (his arrival and the start of the meeting); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Malicious Invitation - SocialEng alone; ABC News: "allegedly lured the man to New York from Italy", then bound and held at the attackers' townhouse); flags otherwise unchanged: kidnappings stays 1 ("bound by the wrists", NYPD Chief Chell: "a kidnapping for roughly 17 days", disputed by the defence and noted), violence_torture stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 1 (forced to smoke crack cocaine, as alleged), weapons stays 1 (pistol-whipped, small chainsaw, a gun recovered), life_taken stays 0; outcome escaped; targeting vector = acquaintance / business counterparty (Chell: "They all know each other", "a dispute over crypto money"; Reuters: fellow crypto investors who "had communicated with each other electronically for years"); source notes: the prosecutor is Kahn in ABC News and Khan in Reuters, the items recovered differ (a saw, crack cocaine, a gun and Polaroids per ABC News, a chainsaw, a loaded pistol and a photograph per Reuters), and the teaser headlines in both fetched pages and Reuters's line on three French cases are not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 229** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 (owner ruling of 2026-09-06, which lists 229; "claims he was drugged and abducted", "I passed out for what I assumed to be 20 to 30 minutes" while the driver took his passcode and "a couple of passkeys" and drove him from Soho to Golders Green; it rests on his account alone, and the Met logged a phone theft "following a ride in a taxi"); violence_torture → unconfirmed ("As I was getting out, he drove off and hit half my body, scraping my leg up", left "unable to walk" for days; an injury as the driver left, not stated to be deliberate or used to coerce; DA call, owner may set 1); description → American tourist says a fake Uber driver drugged him with a spiked cigarette, drove him off, took his phone and drained about $123,000 in XRP, BTC and smaller coins from his wallets (the drugging is his belief: "he now believes" the cigarette was spiked, "no tests were ordered"); money_wanted → about $123,000 in crypto and assets taken, his revised estimate (about $150,000 when he reported it, per the Met statement, both noted); coin_type → XRP and BTC, plus smaller coins (XRP wallet from about $73,000 to under $1,000, Bitcoin wallet from $50,000 to under $10); location → London (picked up outside The Roxy, Rathbone Place, Soho, put out near Childs Way, Golders Green); notes → Jacob Irwin-Cline believes he was robbed with the help of scopolamine, a powerful sedative. No toxicology test was done, scopolamine is his own guess, and he had drunk around three whiskey sours. His phone was taken and his laptop remotely wiped. Reported to the Met, Action Fraud, the FBI's IC3 unit and Uber; arrests → none ("No arrests have as yet been made", Met Police); date 9 May 2025 kept (left the bar about 1.30am on Friday 9 May, XRP left his account about 1:50am); victim kept; sequence Authority Misuse → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Express Kidnapping kept (owner rulings of 2026-09-30, fake Uber driver, and 2026-10-01, 229 stays Express Kidnapping; the record's scenario reads Malicious Invitation - SocialEng alone); flags otherwise unchanged: drugs_alcohol stays 1 (as alleged, as 92), weapons stays 0, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; held 20 to 30 minutes by his own estimate, outcome released; targeting vector = opportunistic by his account ("they just got really lucky"), although the driver called out his app alias and he believes a second man held the real Uber account (the owner's reading of 2026-10-01: a fake Uber ring taking riders); format note: with kidnappings 1 the verified summary's "Possible detention" should read "Detention", which is also what `batches/validate.py` accepts, text left untouched here; single My London interview plus short statements from the Met, Action Fraud and Uber; the "Devil's Breath" passages on the Adrian Murphy killing and a 2015 Paris gang are other cases, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 230** (DA) — arrests → none as of 15 May 2025, later 25 people charged over the series of abduction plots that includes this attempt, and a suspected mastermind of the series arrested in Tangier (Blockchain Magazine: "No arrests have been made as of May 15, 2025"; traced on file under other records: Cryptonews under 350, "prosecutors charged 25 suspects linked to multiple abduction plots, including attempts on Paymium CEO Pierre Noizat's daughter"; the article filed as Article 2 under 235, Badiss Mohamed Amide Bajjou arrested in Tangier and "French authorities are also probing Bajjou's possible involvement in the series of kidnappings or attempted kidnappings in May, Le Parisien said"; the reports on file under 448 and 451 have the alleged instigator "Badiss B." arrested in Tangier on 3 June 2025, which reads as the same arrest, not confirmed by a source naming both); description → Attempted abduction of a crypto exchange CEO's daughter in the street in daylight, filmed by an onlooker: three masked men tried to force her into a van and were driven off by her partner, who was beaten, and by passers-by. A suspected mastermind of the 2025 series was later arrested in Morocco, with his part in this attempt under investigation (replaces "Ringleader was later arrested", which no source states as fact for this case); victim → daughter of Pierre Noizat, CEO and co-founder of Paymium, 34, attacked with her partner and their 2-year-old son (named by Blockchain Magazine only; Le Parisien names neither the man nor the company); location → rue Pache, 11th arrondissement, Paris; notes → The daughter of a cryptocurrency boss was the subject of an attempted kidnapping in the 11th arrondissement of Paris. Three hooded men tried to force her into a van at about 8:20 a.m. Le Parisien's first report has passers-by "fearing to intervene", while Cryptoast has the attempt routed by the father and passers-by and Blockchain Magazine has a shop owner throwing a fire extinguisher. The van is Chronopost-branded in Le Parisien and Cryptoast, a white van with a fake logo in Blockchain Magazine. Whether the child was also being forced in differs. Blockchain Magazine alone has her five months pregnant, seizing the gun, and the husband treated for facial injuries; reports → Le Parisien, Blockchain Magazine, Cryptoast (the sheet text filed under the Blockchain Magazine URL is Le Parisien's report of 13 May 2025 by Courtine, Derveaux and Bonnaud, whose URL is not recorded; the Cryptoast page https://cryptoast.fr/nouvelle-tentative-kidnapping-liee-crypto-que-sest-il-passe/ is on file under 433 as url_4, was taken off 433 in batch 24 and belongs here; url_2 is a YouTube video, not transcribed); date 13 May 2025 kept; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (nothing demanded or taken); sequence Costly Fame → Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Dodged Attack alone); flags unchanged: kidnappings stays 0 (she was never got into the van, control never gained, clarification 3, as 447), violence_torture stays 1 ("suffering blows from the kidnappers", Le Parisien), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (a handgun dropped, "which we do not know if it is real or fake", Le Parisien; "later identified as an Airsoft gun" and the husband "beaten with blunt objects", Blockchain Magazine; replica noted as in 361 and 136), theft stays 0, life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = relative of a public crypto executive, how the attackers chose her not stated (as 447); outcome note for the recheck pass: the family resisted and the men fled, so the owner's value "fought off" (2026-10-07) fits and the batch file's "foiled" does not; source notes: Blockchain Magazine cites Reuters, CNN, BFMTV and CryptoBriefing without links, so its extra detail is single-sourced; its round-up of other cases (the severed finger of May 2025, Balland, the December 2024 father, Las Vegas) is not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 232** (DA) — description → Crypto founder abducted near his home by armed men in military uniforms who claimed to be UPDF security operatives, held at gunpoint and forced to transfer $500,000 in crypto, according to his own company, which claims at least 48 similar attacks have been identified in Uganda (every detail is the company's claim: "according to a formal statement from Mitroplus's Afro Token Project account on X", "allegedly forced", "Mitroplus Labs claimed", and Decrypt had no reply from Mitroplus Labs or the UPDF; "at least 48" is the body's figure, Decrypt's summary bullet says "over 48 ... though most remain unreported", and the body says many cases were dismissed "at the influence of their ring"); money_wanted → $500,000 in crypto transferred under coercion, per Mitroplus Labs (taken, not a demand); coin_type → Afro Token (a meme coin on Tron) for the coerced sale, coin of the other transfers not stated (Decrypt: "The cryptocurrency used for the other coerced transfers is unclear, though some amounts were reportedly sent to a Binance wallet"); location → Bunamwaya Road, Kampala (near his residence); notes → The assailants posed as UPDF security agents, per the company's statement. The same company alleges a ring of informants posing as crypto traders, rogue law enforcement officers and two Chinese nationals, so whether the uniforms were fake is open; arrests → none reported; date 17 May 2025 kept ("On Saturday, May 17th 2025", the company's statement); victim Festo Ivaibi kept; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Authority Misuse alone; gap: where he was held and for how long are not stated); flags unchanged: kidnappings stays 1 ("abducted", "held at gunpoint"), violence_torture stays 0 (gunpoint and duress, no blow or injury reported), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; outcome not stated beyond "he is now safe"; targeting vector = tip-off, as alleged (informants posing as crypto traders, per Mitroplus Labs); mark low-confidence (single source built on the victim's company's own statement, no police or UPDF confirmation, as 43 and 199); the second half of the Decrypt article (Balland, the broker with broken ankles, the father freed in a raid, the CyVers and Nym comments) is other cases and commentary, not used.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 37 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-37.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-37.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-37.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 234** (DA) — victim → ten Korean men invited to the meeting, two of them taken up to the room and tied, none named (Cointelegraph: 'invited 10 Korean men to the hotel. Two were called to the room while the others waited in the lobby'; the record's 'Unidentified man' counts one); location → hotel in Gangseo District, Seoul ('at a hotel in Seoul's Gangseo District'); description → three Russian nationals posed as parties to a peer-to-peer crypto deal, invited ten Korean men to a hotel, ambushed the two called up to the room with a replica handgun and a telescopic baton, tied their hands with cable ties and tried to take 1 billion won in cash; one of the victims escaped and raised the alarm and the suspects fled without the cash (Cointelegraph, relaying JoongAng Daily; 'allegedly' kept); money_wanted → 1 billion won in cash, approximately $730,000 per Cointelegraph, the sum the suspects tried to take, nothing taken ('they tried to steal 1 billion won (approximately $730,000) in cash'); coin_type → cash (KRW), no cryptocurrency demanded or moved (the crypto deal was the pretext; as 94, 41 and 27); notes → one man in his 20s arrested in Busan on 27 May on charges of assault and attempted robbery, the other two left South Korea before the exit ban was filed the next morning, Interpol's help requested; police found a replica firearm, batons, vests and a money counter in the suspects' room; reports → Cointelegraph, relaying JoongAng Daily (the JoongAng report is not on file); arrests → some (one of three); date 21 May 2025 kept ('occurred on May 21'; the year is the record's, the report's own date is not on file); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('tying their hands with cable ties'); violence_torture stays 1 ('ambushed the victims with a replica handgun and a telescopic baton'; police 'found one man bleeding in the lobby', whom the article does not identify as one of the two tied up; charge of assault); weapons stays 1 (replica handgun and telescopic baton; replica noted, as 136 and 432); theft stays 0 ('prompting the suspects to flee without the cash'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated; targeting vector = trade lure (staged P2P deal; how the contact was made is not stated); source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same Cointelegraph page; its context items (the Manhattan case, the Noizat family attempt of 13 May, the bodyguard-demand item) are other matters, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 236** (DA) — date → 23 May 2025 (TN, dated 28 May 2025 in the text and in its URL: 'El hecho ocurrió el viernes por la noche'; 28 May 2025 was a Wednesday, so the Friday before it is 23 May; the record's 27 May was a Tuesday); location → Palermo, Buenos Aires, a first-floor apartment at Ravignani 1596, at Gorriti ('en un edificio de la calle Ravignani 1596, en la intersección con Gorriti'); victim → Russian couple who run a cryptocurrency business, a woman of 30 and her partner of 27, not named (TN); description → two Chechens who had rented a first-floor apartment for the previous two nights invited the couple to dinner on the Friday night and tied them up; a ransom of 43,000 dollars in digital currency was paid by a compatriot friend who lives in Partido de la Costa, after a conversation with the captors; the two suspects are reported to have flown from Ezeiza to the United Arab Emirates in the hours after (TN hedges kept: 'habrían pagado un rescate' in the subheading, 'habrían tomado un vuelo'); money_wanted → 43,000 USD in digital currency, paid as ransom by a friend (TN: '43 mil dólares en moneda digital', US dollars, not pesos; the sum first demanded is not stated); coin_type → digital currency, coin not named (TN: 'moneda digital'); notes → around 11 p.m. the woman called for help in English from the balcony, staff of the neighbouring restaurant called 911 and City Police found the couple tied ('habían sido maniatados'); TN also calls the couple 'liberada' after the payment, both accounts noted; the two main suspects were identified and carry Interpol red notices, TN prints no names; case with the PFA's Departamento Antisecuestros Sur under judge María Romilda Servini; arrests → none (both suspects left the country); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('maniatados'); violence_torture stays 0 (no blow or injury described); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); theft stays 1 (ransom paid by the friend); life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated (dinner on Friday night, cries at about 11 p.m.); targeting vector unknown (the couple worked in crypto; how they knew the two men is not stated); summary: 'both were named as the main suspects' → identified by police, not named; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same TN page; the two 'Leé también' teasers are unrelated, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 237** (DA) — violence_torture → 1 ('He was also beaten during the incident'; 'the trader has been given six days of French work incapacity benefits, according to Europe 1', Cointelegraph via MSN); theft → unconfirmed (he 'was released on Saturday after he revealed he couldn't pay and showed the kidnappers the low balance in his account'; no transfer or loss is stated, and the article does not say the balance was left untouched; the writer proposed 0, the rule for an unstated loss is unconfirmed, as 116 and 392); money_wanted → 50,000 EUR in crypto demanded, $57,000 per Cointelegraph, nothing reported paid ('demanding he hand over 50,000 euros ($57,000) in crypto'); coin_type → crypto, coin not named; victim → 26-year-old crypto trader who makes TikTok content, 40,000 followers, not named; description → a crypto trader who makes TikTok content was reportedly seized by four men on the Friday night as he returned home to Juvisy-sur-Orge, forced into a stolen vehicle and beaten, with 50,000 euros in crypto demanded; he was released on the Saturday after he said he could not pay and showed the low balance in his account ('reportedly' kept; the record's 'after opening his wallet and finding a tiny balance' is replaced by the article's wording); notes → six days of work incapacity; France's Organised and Specialised Crime Division is investigating; where he was kept between Friday night and Saturday is not stated beyond the stolen vehicle; reports → Cointelegraph (Stephen Katte), syndicated on MSN, relaying a Europe 1 report that is not on file; arrests → none reported; date 13 June 2025 kept ('snatched on Friday night'; 13 June 2025 was a Friday; the MSN copy carries no date, so the day rests on the record); location Juvisy-sur-Orge kept; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('forced the trader into a stolen vehicle'; 'released on Saturday'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = public profile / social media (TikTok trader; the article does not say that is how he was chosen); summary: 'nothing was taken' → no transfer or taking reported; source notes: the msn.com link is THIN on fetch, the sheet's copy of the MSN page is the only text.
|
||||
- **DB id 238** (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon anywhere in Entrevue, and the seizure itself is not described; the only line on force is 'aurait subi des violences pour livrer ces informations'; writer proposed 0; DA call, as 396 and 401 where the abduction is not described; owner may set 0); money_wanted → a Ledger key plus 5,000 EUR in cash, demanded and handed over ('déposer une clé Ledger ... accompagnée de 5 000 euros en espèces, dans un sac à remettre devant l'immeuble'; 'impossible de savoir si la clé contenait effectivement des fonds'; the record's 'unknown amount' is replaced, the unknown being what the key held); coin_type → crypto on a Ledger key, contents unknown, and cash (EUR); description → a 23-year-old man was abducted on Tuesday 17 June 2025 in Maisons-Alfort while looking for a parking space; his partner, drawn home by a message about a work emergency, was told by video call to leave a Ledger key and 5,000 euros in cash in a bag in front of the building; an accomplice collected it and the man was released in Créteil several hours later, at about 5 p.m. ('from his wife' → from his partner: Entrevue says 'sa compagne' and 'la jeune femme', never wife); notes → planned abduction by well-informed captors ('très informés'); the partner followed the instructions without telling the authorities ('wife cooperated' → partner); investigators say he 'aurait subi des violences' to give up the details, and he came back 'sain et sauf' (conditional kept); Val-de-Marne judicial police seized for 'enlèvement et séquestration en bande organisée'; where and how he was seized and where he was held are not stated; arrests → none reported in this case (the article's 'interpellations' are in other files of the same kind); date 17 June 2025 kept ('mardi'; Entrevue is dated Friday 20 June 2025, so the Tuesday is 17 June); location Maisons-Alfort kept, released in Créteil; victim '23 y/o man' kept; sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('a été séquestré mardi à Maisons-Alfort'; 'relâché à Créteil'); violence_torture stays 1 on the hedged line ('aurait subi des violences', single-line basis as 456); drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 1 ('Un complice passe récupérer le sac'); life_taken stays 0; held duration hours ('plusieurs heures plus tard, vers 17 heures'); targeting vector unknown (how the captors knew of the key is not stated); summary: 'organised detention' → séquestration en bande organisée; source notes: single source, Entrevue of 20 June 2025; ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same page; the Vaulx-en-Velin teaser is unrelated, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 240** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ('The gang then locked Sriharsha, Benjamin, and others inside the shop before fleeing the scene'; 'The complainant and others managed to get out by opening the shop's shutters', Yes Punjab; locked in, explicit quote, after control was gained at knifepoint, as 77); description → Sriharsha V. brought Rs 2 crore in cash to a shop at MS Palya Circle, Vidyaranyapura, to have it converted into USDT through a middleman, Benjamin Harsha; while the money was being counted, six to seven men (six in the headline) barged in at about 4.30 p.m., two pulled knives and threatened to kill, took the mobile phones and the cash and locked the group in the shop (drop '$240,000': no dollar figure appears in the article, the conversion is the record's own); victim → Sriharsha V., 33, businessman from Kengeri New Town, with two friends (named in the article from his police complaint); location → a shop at MS Palya Circle, Vidyaranyapura, Bengaluru; coin_type → cash (INR), no cryptocurrency changed hands (the cash was to be converted into USDT); notes → he had raised the Rs 2 crore from savings and loans to buy machinery in Germany for a cold-pressed oil business; a friend introduced him to Benjamin Harsha, who asked him to bring the cash; after the group got out through the shutters, 'Benjamin and two of his associates fled the scene, according to the FIR'; the article does not state that Benjamin was part of the gang; the gang warned the victims not to go to the police; Sriharsha says he saw the attackers' faces; arrests → Benjamin Harsha and one other person detained and questioned, no arrest or charge reported ('detained Benjamin and another individual, and questioning them'); money_wanted Rs 2 crore kept ('Rs 2 crore in cash' throughout); date 25 June 2025 kept ('The incident occurred on June 25'; report dated 27 June 2025); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space kept; violence_torture stays 0 (knives drawn and death threats, no blow or injury described; the lede's 'attacked a businessman with a knife' noted); weapons stays 1 ('two of the assailants pulled out knives'); theft stays 1 ('snatched their mobile phones and stuffed the Rs 2 crore cash into a gunny bag'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated; targeting vector = business counterparty (the meeting was arranged through the middleman; whether he tipped off the gang is not established); summary: remove Benjamin Harsha from 'Attackers', the article has him locked in with the others and then detained for questioning; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same Yes Punjab agency copy; trailing site content not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 242** (DA) — weapons → 1 ('l'un d'eux soit interpellé, en possession d'un hachoir', BFMTV; 'arrested nearby, in possession of two knives and a hachoir', the English write-up in the sheet's first column; a cleaver in both, the two knives in one; no source says a blade was shown inside the home, so the flag rests on what the attacker carried when arrested after the attack, as 172 and 213; DA call, owner may set unconfirmed); notes → targeted through social media over the couple's cryptocurrency holdings, on the arrested man's own statement ('il dit avoir ciblé le couple, via les réseaux sociaux'); the two got into her home and one punched her about ten times in the face while, per the English write-up, the other tried to reach the flat's private rooms; aim reported as her wallet credentials (English write-up only); drop 'demanded ransom' (no ransom in either text; the inquiry is for 'tentative de vol avec violence'); 'husband and police helped' → BFMTV has the husband and children witnessing the scene and the two fleeing, the English write-up credits the husband's intervention and the arrival of the police, both noted; taken to hospital 'en urgence relative', then filed a complaint; victim → a woman who owns cryptocurrencies, attacked at home in front of her husband and children, not named; reports → BFMTV, plus an English write-up by another outlet filed in the sheet under the BFMTV label and URL ('According to BFMTV reports and confirmed by Le Figaro'), outlet and URL to be found; arrests → some (one man arrested nearby, the second still sought); description kept ('une dizaine de coups de poing au visage', 'devant son mari et ses enfants'); date 7 July 2025 kept ('ce lundi 7 juillet'; 7 July 2025 was a Monday); location Suresnes kept; coin_type crypto kept; money_wanted stays empty (no amount in either text); sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list: entry into the home followed by a beating; no restraint or duration in any source); violence_torture stays 1; theft stays 0 (attempted robbery; nothing reported taken); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = social media (the arrested man's statement); summary: 'the attackers fled when the husband appeared' matches neither text and goes; 'forced entry' → got into her home, method not stated ('ont réussi à rentrer dans son domicile'); the batch file's outcome 'foiled' is for the outcome recheck under the ruling of 2026-10-07 (she was beaten inside her home); source notes: ARTICLE 2 is the English translation of the fetched BFMTV page, one source; the English write-up's 'tailing and home invasion' method, its link to a coming wave of extortion and its advice sections are that outlet's commentary, not used; the Balland, Palaiseau and Paris 11th passages are other cases.
|
||||
- **DB id 243** (DA) — weapons → 1 ('he was set upon by six men, who tased him in the chest', Daily News; the glossary's Weapons entry lists tasers; as the stun gun in 181); money_wanted → about 900,000 yen, 'equivalent to more than $6,000' per the Daily News, wired from a bank account and sent from a cryptocurrency account (the record's flat '$6000' loses the source currency and the 'more than'); description → a 38-year-old man told the NYPD that six men set upon him at his car in Flushing on 8 July 2025, tased him, drove him to an unknown location, handcuffed him at some point and held him for 10 days until he gave them about 900,000 yen, more than $6,000, by bank wire and from a cryptocurrency account ('$6,000' → about 900,000 yen); location → Flushing, Queens, New York, at 31st Rd. and Union St. where his car was parked, held at 'an unknown location'; notes → the whole account is the victim's statement to police ten days after he was taken ('he tells NYPD' in the headline); he was dropped back at his car on the morning of Friday 18 July 2025, drove to NewYork-Presbyterian Queens, called 911 just before 5 a.m. and decided he did not need treatment; 'It was not clear why the suspects targeted the victim or how wealthy they believed he was'; arrests → none reported; date 8 July 2025 kept ('on July 8', the day he was taken; report of 18 July 2025); victim '38 y/o man' kept; coin_type 'wire and crypto' kept, coin not named; sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('drove him in their car to an unknown location'; 'He was handcuffed at some point'; 'held him for 10 days'); violence_torture stays 1 (tased in the chest); theft stays 1 ('he gave them about 900,000 yen'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration days; targeting vector unknown; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same Daily News page; its closing paragraphs on the May Manhattan case (Woeltz and Duplessie) are another incident, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 244** (DA) — description → four police constables of Mata Ka Than Police Station allegedly took over Dilip Gaud's car while he and Ramesh Sharma were parking on 14 July 2025, drove the two to the station, held them from about 4 p.m. to about 8.30 p.m. and, under threat of false criminal charges, extorted Rs 2 lakh in cash and had cryptocurrency transferred from Dilip's phone, about Rs 8.6 lakh in USDT per Subkuz; the four were suspended after a departmental inquiry and arrested on Thursday 17 July 2025 (drop '$9,000 USD': no dollar figure in either report; drop 'fired': 'were suspended following a departmental inquiry', 'All the suspended policemen were attached to the Police Lines', and no source reports a dismissal; 'allegedly' and 'reportedly' kept, the account is Dilip's complaint); notes → the four are Narsingh Ram, Rakesh Poonia, Laduram and Jagmal Ram; 'later were fired' → suspended and arrested, no dismissal reported; cash: Rs 50,000 from each of the two, then Rs 1 lakh withdrawn by Ramesh with Dilip's wife's ATM card (report by Dinesh Bothra), given by Subkuz as Rs 1 lakh in cash and Rs 1 lakh from the wife's ATM; the crypto went 'to an associate of the policemen'; the two were made to sign documents; Dilip's iPhone was held for a time and no arrest notice or written action was shown to him (Subkuz); case registered at Mahamandir Police Station under the BNS; the reports differ and both versions are kept: the complainant's surname and address (Dilip Gaur of Ramdev Nagar in the Bothra report, Dilip Gaud of Banar Road in Subkuz), the place (a mall near Manji Ka Hatha against a showroom in Pawta), the uniforms (Jagmal in uniform with three or four others in plain clothes, against four uniformed policemen in a white car) and Rakesh's part (one of the four and present at the station in the Bothra report, 'another constable' at the station in Subkuz); victim → Dilip Gaud & Ramesh Sharma kept, with the spelling Gaur (Bothra report) noted as a variant; location → Jodhpur, Rajasthan: seized while parking at a mall near Manji Ka Hatha (Bothra report) or a showroom in Pawta (Subkuz), held at Mata Ka Than Police Station; reports → Subkuz, plus the report by Dinesh Bothra of 17 July 2025 quoting DCP (East) Alok Srivastava, filed in the sheet under the Subkuz label and URL, its own outlet and URL to be found; arrests → some (the four constables arrested on 17 July 2025; 'another police officer, currently posted elsewhere, is a suspect in the case too', not yet arrested); money_wanted kept (Rs 8.6 lakh in USDT, Subkuz only; Rs 1 lakh in cash and Rs 1 lakh from the wife's ATM card); coin_type 'USDT, cash' kept; date 14 July 2025 kept (both reports); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('allegedly abducting and unlawfully detaining two people'; 'took Gaur and Sharma to Mata Ka Than Police Station'; 'released around 8.30 pm'); violence_torture stays 0 (intimidation and threats; Dilip 'forcibly removed' from the driver's seat, no blow or injury described); weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); theft stays 1; drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration hours; targeting vector unknown (neither report says why the two were picked); summary: the surname is recorded as Gaud with Gaur as the variant, not the other way round; source notes: ARTICLE 2 is a three-line stub of the Subkuz page; the fetched Subkuz page is interleaved with unrelated headlines and ends in editorial comment, not used.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 38 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-38.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-38.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-38.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 245** (DA) — weapons → 1 ('A weapon allegedly used in the kidnapping was also recovered from the accused', Gujarat Samachar, type not stated, the hedge is the article's, a weapon recovered from the accused as in 213 and 172); description → three men, one of them an acquaintance with whom he had discussed a USDT cash exchange, called the trader to meet a customer near Bapunagar Toll Plaza at about 2 a.m. on 15 July 2025, forced him into a black car with tinted glass and no number plate, beat him and demanded a transfer of 50,000 USDT while moving him between locations through the night, the Ahmedabad City Crime Branch rescued him by afternoon after his father called the police control room; money_wanted → 50,000 USDT demanded (about ₹42 lakh per Gujarat Samachar), no transfer reported; coin_type USDT kept; notes → police give the motive, on preliminary investigation, as a pending financial dispute with Pandey linked to cryptocurrency dealings, he was assaulted repeatedly for his wallet credentials and taken to hospital with significant injuries, the article's timings do not fit together ('five-hour chase' against a seizure at about 2 a.m. and a rescue 'by afternoon') and it calls the family both 'retired' and 'serving' Army, police were still checking 'attempted laundering of the cryptocurrency', so theft 0 needs a follow-up source; victim Prince Pandey kept (named in the article, cryptocurrency trader, son of retired Army Subedar Major Pankaj Kumar Pandey); location → Ahmedabad (seized near Bapunagar Toll Plaza, the other locations not named); date 15 July 2025 kept ('around 2 am on July 15', rescued 'on Tuesday', 15 July 2025 was a Tuesday); reports → Gujarat Samachar (record spells it 'GujaratSamahar'); arrests → all (Karan Tarunbhai Nair, 19, Harsh Ajaybhai Thakkar, 21, Kripalsinh Govindsingh Vihol, 25, police still checking whether others were involved); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept (the record's scenario holds only Malicious Invitation, the article supports all three labels, the order of the first two differs from 117 and 77 and is left for the label audit); kidnappings stays 1; violence_torture stays 1; drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 0; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = acquaintance / business counterparty (Karan Nair, earlier USDT exchange talks, pending financial dispute); held duration hours, outcome rescued; source notes: the sheet text and the fetched page are the same article, the fetched line 'Summarized by AI; it may make mistakes' is site furniture.
|
||||
- **DB id 247** (DA) — money_wanted → 400,000 EUR demanded ('Tu nous donnes 400 000 euros et c'est fini', as hotel staff reported it to police, Le Parisien), with 2 million EUR in bitcoin as the value the victim gave for the seized hard drive and 40,000 EUR as the nightclub debt investigators mention (the record's 2M is the hard-drive value, not the demand); coin_type bitcoin kept; notes → 'his Ledger wallet with $2M of crypto on it' becomes a hard drive containing 2 million euros in bitcoins plus his iPhone 13 Pro Max (the victim's statement, no Ledger named, euros not dollars), per initial findings the five are linked to a nearby nightclub where he allegedly owes 40,000 euros and 'The goal was to make him pay the bill by force', he said the same men had displayed a weapon in an incident the week before; description → five men are suspected of having threatened, taken away by force and beaten a guest of the Peninsula Hotel who is said to work in cryptocurrency, and of stealing 2 million euros in cryptocurrency from him, anti-crime police arrested the five the same evening (keep the suspicion and the conditional, 'La victime, qui travaillerait dans le milieu de la cryptomonnaie'); flag 'motive not established' ('Nouvelle affaire criminelle autour de la crypto à Paris ? Ou une banale affaire de recouvrement ? Il est encore trop tôt pour le dire'), kept in the database under the owner rule of 2026-10-01, as 96 and 493; victim Unidentified man kept (guest of the Peninsula Hotel); location → Paris (Peninsula Hotel, avenue Kléber, 16th arrondissement, taken towards the Arc de Triomphe, arrests in the 8th); date 5 August 2025 kept (Tuesday 5 August, staff called police at 7:15 p.m.); reports → Le Parisien (record spells it 'LePArisien'); arrests → all (five men in custody at the first judicial police district for extortion); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('emmenée de force du côté de l'Arc de Triomphe'); violence_torture stays 1 ('violentée', 'beaten and threatened'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (the only weapon in the article was shown the week before); theft stays 1 (hard drive and iPhone per the victim, whether police recovered them at the arrest is not stated, and the recovered-items rule would apply if they were); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = business counterparty, claimed (the nightclub debt); held duration and how he got free not stated; source notes: the French original on file stops after its second paragraph, so the debt, the hard drive, the iPhone, the earlier weapon incident and the custody rest on the sheet's English text alone.
|
||||
- **DB id 249** (DA) — description → a group of Chinese nationals resident in Sri Lanka allegedly abducted a fellow Chinese businessman at about 9 p.m. on Friday 22 August 2025, took him away in a vehicle, held him in a building for about a day and transferred approximately USD 60,000 online during his confinement, then abandoned him on a roadside on the afternoon of Saturday 23 August (police via Newswire, all hedged 'allegedly' and 'reportedly'), 'until he hands over' dropped (the suspects made the transfer), the record's '60,000 USDT' is in no source on file and is kept marked 'pending source trace' (owner rule of 2026-10-01); money_wanted → approximately USD 60,000 transferred online (Newswire, no demand figure stated); coin_type → not stated (USD per Newswire, the record's USDT pending source trace); flag 'crypto link not established' (the single source names no cryptocurrency), kept in the database under the owner rule of 2026-10-01; victim → Chinese businessman who operates a store on R.A. De Mel Mawatha, Colpetty; location → Colpetty, Colombo (place of abduction, the building where he was held not located); date 22 August 2025 kept ('last Friday (22)', 22 August 2025 was a Friday); notes → treated at a private hospital in Narahenpita for injuries sustained during the abduction, complaint filed with Colpetty Police 'last evening' per the 25 August report; reports Newswire kept; arrests → none reported (investigations under way); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1; violence_torture stays 1 ('injuries sustained during the abduction'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); theft stays 1 ('robbed him of approximately USD 60,000'); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector unknown (fellow nationals, how he was chosen not stated); held duration 'about a day', outcome released; source notes: the sheet text and the fetched page are the same Newswire article.
|
||||
- **DB id 252** (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (the only basis is the charge 'extortion by an organized gang with a weapon', no weapon described, as 487, the writer proposed 1); description → a young Swiss national was kidnapped in Valence, held for several days and found tied up in a house near the Valence-TGV station, the kidnappers demanded a ransom in cryptocurrency, the GIGN freed him on 31 August after a tip-off on 30 August and seven suspects were arrested (Bitcoin.com, relaying the Lyon prosecutor's statement), '4 days' becomes 'several days' in the text, and the record's '4 days', 'possible mistaken identity' and the age of 23 are kept marked 'pending source trace' (owner rule of 2026-10-01, the fibo-crypto timeline on file under 473 repeats the record's wording and is not an independent source); victim → young Swiss national, from the canton of Vaud per 20 minutes ('Un Vaudois', on file under 494), age 23 pending source trace; notes → tip-off on 30 August that a ransom in cryptocurrency was being demanded, close to 150 gendarmerie judicial police and GIGN personnel, case under the Lyon JIRS; money_wanted → ransom in cryptocurrency demanded, amount not stated, no payment reported; coin_type → cryptocurrency, coin not named; date 29 August 2025 kept, approximate (in no source on file, Bitcoin.com gives only the tip-off on 30 August and the raid on 31 August, its standfirst's 'on August 31' is the rescue); location Valence, Drôme, France kept (found in a house near the Valence-TGV station); reports → Bitcoin.com, plus the 20 minutes line on file under 494; arrests → some (seven arrested and brought before an investigating judge on charges including kidnapping and arbitrary detention of a hostage to obtain a ransom, extortion by an organised gang with a weapon and criminal conspiracy, whether that is everyone involved is not stated); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1; violence_torture stays 1 ('Un Vaudois avait notamment été kidnappé et torturé pendant plusieurs jours près de Valence (F)', 20 minutes, on file under 494, a round-up line used as in 381, Bitcoin.com itself says only 'found tied up', the writer proposed unconfirmed); drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 0; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector unknown; held duration days, outcome rescued; source notes: Bitcoin.com is a second-hand relay ('According to a report') and calls the rescue a 'kidnap attempt', French reporting should be added before publication, its closing paragraphs on Balland, the Paymium family and government measures not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 253** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ('the victim was forced into a dark-coloured van by five unknown suspects', 'The suspects later released the victim', Waterloo Regional Police release via CambridgeToday, already on the owner's list of 2026-09-06); violence_torture → 1 ('While inside the van, the victim was physically assaulted', 'serious but non-life-threatening injuries'); weapons → 1 ('threatened with a fire arm'); theft → 1 ('forced to transfer money into a cryptocurrency wallet'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; money_wanted → money transferred into a cryptocurrency wallet, amount not stated; coin_type → cryptocurrency, coin not named; victim → a youth, age and gender not stated ('an injured youth', the verified summary's 'he' and 'his' have no source); description → a youth was forced into a dark-coloured van by five unknown suspects, physically assaulted inside it, threatened with a firearm and forced to transfer money into a cryptocurrency wallet, then released, and was taken to hospital with serious but non-life-threatening injuries; notes → 9:48 p.m. is when police responded to a robbery report at Saginaw Parkway and Townline Road, not the time of the abduction, the release does not say whether the van moved with the victim inside or how long the victim was held, the suspects were last seen travelling on Townline Road and are described as five males in their twenties in dark clothing and face coverings; location → Cambridge, Ontario, Canada (area of Saginaw Parkway and Townline Road); date 5 September 2025 kept; reports → CambridgeToday (record 'CambridgeT'), reprinting the police release; arrests → none (active investigation, appeal for witnesses and footage); sequence Express Kidnapping kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-01, the record's scenario field says Kidnapping, the sources do not say how the victim was chosen, gap noted); targeting vector not stated; outcome released; source notes: the live URL refused the refetch, the sheet copy is the only text on file.
|
||||
- **DB id 256** (DA) — description → three men and a woman climbed the fence of the property of a 42-year-old cryptocurrency professional in Rambouillet at about 9 a.m. on Friday 26 September 2025, he saw them and called police, and all four were arrested, per the first findings they had planned to go after him because of his cryptocurrency activity ('ils auraient planifié de s'en prendre à la victime', conditional), what they meant to do is not stated ('to kidnap him' is the record's reading and 'entrepreneur' is not Le Parisien's word, which is 'un nouveau professionnel de la cryptomonnaie'); notes → the victim alone is said to have seen them and called, police surprised a man and a woman still on the property (not said to be in the house), the man with a switchblade and the woman with a fake handgun, a third suspect was arrested in a Renault Clio parked in the street and the fourth stopped a little further on as he fled on foot, 'Aucun préjudice financier ou corporel n'est à déplorer'; victim 42 y/o man kept; location Rambouillet, Yvelines, France kept; date 26 September 2025 kept ('Ce vendredi matin', 26 September 2025 was a Friday); money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (nothing demanded); reports Le Parisien kept; arrests → all (the four in custody with the Versailles brigade de répression du banditisme, no charge on file); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Home Invasion kept (the verified summary's 'foiled at the fence' should read stopped inside the grounds, the four had already climbed in); kidnappings stays 0; violence_torture stays 0; drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 (the switchblade, the handgun was fake); theft stays 0; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector unknown (his cryptocurrency activity, how he was identified not stated); outcome foiled; source notes: the Wayback copy is untrimmed, its teaser lines (a Paris 'tentative d'enlèvement', the Farid El Haïry case, Lyon, a bakery, a British woman) and the closing paragraph naming David Balland belong to other stories and were not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 263** (DA) — description → a trader named Waleed was abducted from the Kahna area by CCD Inspector Javed Iqbal, Constable Tauseef and two unidentified accomplices, who raided his home in plain clothes and took his laptop, three mobile phones and the CCTV DVR, he was released after his family handed over a ransom negotiated down from Rs50 million to Rs4 million, drop '$45K' (the article gives rupee figures only) and 'Bitcoin trader' as a stated fact ('Investigators believe the suspects targeted the victim due to his alleged involvement in Bitcoin trading, though police officially referred to him only as a "businessman."'); money_wanted → Rs50 million demanded, reduced to Rs4 million after negotiation, ransom handed over by the family near the Lahore Orange Line Station; coin_type Rs kept (rupee ransom handed over at a drop-off point, no cryptocurrency demanded or taken in the article); notes → forced to call his family twice during captivity, death threat on the second call, the family was made to change drop-off locations several times, a rented vehicle was used, the complaint to Kahna Police is said to have started the investigation while officials call the arrests a 'planned sting operation', case kept on the crypto link by occupation (investigators' belief, as 123); victim Waleed kept (named in the article); location → Kahna area, Lahore (dateline Lahore, where he was held not stated); date October 2025 kept, day unknown, unverified (the article prints no date); reports The Express Tribune kept; arrests → some (Inspector Javed Iqbal and Constable Tauseef arrested and handed to CCD Model Town, the two accomplices unidentified); sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion → Kidnapping kept (the record's scenario field says Kidnapping alone); kidnappings stays 1; violence_torture stays 0 (death threat only, 'safe return'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); theft stays 1 (ransom paid, laptop, phones and DVR taken); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = occupation (alleged Bitcoin trading, how the officers knew of it not stated); held duration not stated, outcome released; source notes: the last five lines of the Wayback copy are the site's comment-form messages, not article text.
|
||||
- **DB id 266** (DA) — description → four young Toulouse residents aged 18 to 24 received in the apartment of one of them two men they had met through an online sales site, the visitors took a weapon out of a suitcase and ordered them to transfer 20,000 dollars in virtual currency, the transfer failed, and the two took smartphones, identity papers, money and keys and locked the four in the apartment, the four climbed over a balcony to raise the alarm ('gunpoint' becomes a weapon of a kind not stated, 'Les « invités » ont ouvert une valise et sorti une arme', and 'traders' becomes holders of virtual currency, the article does not call them traders); victim → four young Toulouse residents aged 18 to 24 (record 'Multiple'); money_wanted → 20,000 USD in virtual currency demanded, transfer failed ('la transaction a échoué'); coin_type → virtual currency, 'type bitcoin' (20 Minutes); date → late October 2017, day unknown ('fin octobre'); location → Busca neighbourhood, Toulouse, France (the apartment of one of the four); notes → met the suspects through an online sales site (kept), loss was smartphones, identity papers, money and keys, the charge is 'séquestration, vol avec arme et tentative d'extorsion', where séquestration means unlawful confinement and the sheet's English 'kidnapped' and 'kidnapping' are mistranslations (nobody was taken anywhere); reports → 20 Minutes (3 December 2017 per its URL, relaying La Dépêche du Midi, which is not on file); arrests → all (two men aged 19 and 34 arrested the week before the report, one in Blagnac, the other in Saint-Girons, Ariège, charged and placed in pre-trial detention, no verdict on file); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('avant de les enfermer à l'intérieur de l'appartement'); violence_torture stays 0 (no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('sorti une arme', kind not stated); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = online lure (online sales site); held duration not stated, outcome escaped; source notes: the fetched block still carries site furniture (a Wordle line, a services menu, the teaser 'La «bulle» du bitcoin va-t-elle éclater?'), not used, and the sheet's row 18 scenario fix is already listed under the spreadsheet fixes.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 39 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-39.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-39.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-39.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 270** (DA) — description → an Odessa man who came to buy cryptocurrency was beaten and robbed by a suspect and his accomplices at a flat rented for the meeting, damage nearly 1,500,000 UAH (Bizlim: 'the assailant and his accomplices beat the man and stole his mobile phone, jewelry, and money'; drop 'Several men', the number is not given, and drop 'bitcoin', the article says only 'electronic currency' and 'cryptocurrency'); money_wanted → nearly 1,500,000 UAH, about 57,000 USD per Bizlim, as the total damage covering the money, the mobile phone and the jewellery ('caused the citizen damage amounting to nearly 1,500,000 UAH'; the split is not stated); coin_type → cash, no crypto taken (the coin he came to buy is not named); notes → the attackers rented an apartment on General Petrova Street for a short term and arranged the meeting there, so the flat was not their home ('rented an apartment on General Petrova Street in Odessa for a short term'; the Russian original has the suspect luring him 'к себе' by deceit); location → General Petrova Street, Odessa, Ukraine; victim → Odessa resident, not named; date January 2018 kept, day unknown; reports Bizlim kept (the English sheet copy and the Russian original agree); arrests → some (main suspect in custody without bail and indicted under Article 187 part 4, accomplices still sought, no arrest date given); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept (the order differs from 117, 41 and 77, where Malicious Invitation comes first; left as verified and listed for the label audit); kidnappings stays 0 (beaten and robbed in the rented flat, the article does not say he was held or how the encounter ended; DA call, owner may set 1 as in 143 if a beating in the attackers' flat is read as holding); violence_torture stays 1 ('beat the man'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none named); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure, how contact was made not stated; source notes: one source, a report of the Odessa prosecutor's indictment with no publication date.
|
||||
- **DB id 271** (DA) — victim → the occupants of a rented home on Ballouville Road, none named: the female renter, an occupant pistol-whipped on the head, an occupant attacked with an electric cattle prod, and a child implied by the charge 'risk of injury to a child' (second report, which also lists 'five counts of first-degree threatening and four counts of second-degree reckless endangerment'); description → two Rhode Island women were arrested over a March home invasion in Killingly in which occupants were pistol-whipped and attacked with an electric cattle prod, and police say it stemmed from a Bitcoin account the renter had opened in the name of one suspect, who 'wanted passwords and money she said was stolen from her' (the stealing is Delannoy-Jodoin's claim relayed by police, so drop 'used it to steal her money' as fact; '2 women invaded' becomes two recognised and arrested, since 'two of the people that reportedly forced entry' leaves the number of intruders open); notes → the renter was chased into a bathroom, an intruder used a hammer to break in, and she escaped to a neighbour's house, one suspect told the other to 'shoot the victims', and the account dispute keeps 'allegedly'; money_wanted → passwords and money tied to the Bitcoin account demanded, no amount stated, and money, cell phones and a television taken; coin_type → BTC (the account in dispute; no crypto reported taken); location → Ballouville Road, Killingly, Connecticut; date March 2018 kept, day unknown (neither text prints the year; 2018 fits the archive snapshot of 18 October 2018 and nothing more); reports → Yahoo Finance, which syndicates the CCN story, plus a second and fuller local report pasted in the sheet with no URL (find its URL); arrests → some (Monique Delannoy-Jodoin, 59, of Manville and Beatriz Viruet, 38, of Providence arrested and charged, bonds of $250,000 and $100,000, whether they were the only intruders is not stated); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (forced entry followed by beating, clarification 1); violence_torture stays 1 ('pistol-whipped and attacked with an electric cattle prod'); drugs_alcohol stays 0 (the narcotics inquiry into Delannoy-Jodoin is a separate Rhode Island matter); weapons stays 1 (pistol, electric cattle prod, hammer); theft stays 1 ('The suspects stole money, cell phones and a television'); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = acquaintance (the renter recognised two intruders and had opened the account in one suspect's name); source notes: the site summary's 'tried to break into with a hammer' follows the garbled CCN sentence, the second report has the door broken; the CCN paragraph on a Miami shooting and the Yahoo teaser headlines are other matters, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 272** (DA) — description → a Kyiv cryptocurrency miner was seized near his home in the Podilsky district, hooded with a sack, forced into a car and driven out of the city, gave up his apartment keys and where he kept his money under death threats, lost $50,000 and was released in Brovary (Ain.UA; 'extorted' goes: prosecutors say he was kidnapped 'to demand a ransom', the charge is 'robbery by prior conspiracy' under Article 187 part 4; 'caught 8 months later' becomes two brothers detained, reported on 26 November 2018 by the URL date); money_wanted → $50,000 taken, form not stated; coin_type → not stated (the article gives only '$50,000', reached through 'the keys to his apartment' and 'information about where he kept his money'; no cryptocurrency is said to be taken); location → Podilsky district, Kyiv, driven outside the city and released in Brovary; victim → cryptocurrency miner, Kyiv resident, not named; date March 2018 kept, day unknown ('in March of this year'); reports Ain.UA kept; arrests → all (two brothers born in 1988 and 1984 detained and charged, custody petition sent to the Podilsky court, no conviction); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('put a sack over his head, forcibly pushed him into a car, and took him outside the city'); violence_torture stays 0 (hooded, pushed into a car and threatened with death, no blow or injury reported; same reading as 7, 207 and 19, so the writer's proposed 1 is not taken; owner may set 1); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons → 0 (no weapon appears anywhere in the article, as 76 and 34); theft stays 1 ('After taking $50,000 from the victim'); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown (they waited near his home; how they knew of his money is not stated); case kept on the victim's occupation, as 123; source notes: the OFF-CASE? flag on the ain.ua page is a matcher artefact, the Russian page is the right article; the page's teaser tail (Porsche, martial law, Musk, retirement, time management) not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 273** (DA) — theft → 1 ('In the end, the thieves took Kez's laptop, phone and his dog, Rambo', Vice; the dog came back a year later through its microchip, so the recovered-items rule of 188 and 495 does not apply); money_wanted → laptop, phone and the dog Rambo per Vice, with the record's list (dog worth an estimated £1,000, Apple MacBook, gold bracelets, gold wedding ring) kept and marked pending source trace (owner rule of 2026-10-01: The Sun is cited in the record and is not on file; in Vice the £1,000 is the reward he offered for the dog); notes → two machete-wielding men demanded 'money, drugs and watches' and ordered him to empty a safe and flip his mattress, one walked him around the house prodding him with a knife, punched him three times and stabbed him, leaving a machete wound in his arm, and no cryptocurrency was asked for; description kept, with 'crypto trader' as his occupation before the robbery ('Before the robbery, Kez had been a cryptocurrency trader'); victim → Kieran 'Kez' Hamilton, 21; location Manchester, England kept; date November 2018 kept, unsupported on file (the article gives no date for the attack; mark approximate); reports → Vice on file, The Sun cited with no link or text on file (trace it); arrests → some ('One of the attackers - since jailed', offence not named, second man not mentioned); sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list); violence_torture stays 1; drugs_alcohol stays 0 (the attackers demanded drugs, none was used on him); weapons stays 1 (machetes, knife); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = public profile / social media, as the victim believes ('I got stabbed because of my Instagram presence'), together with local rumours that he was a cash-rich drug dealer; case kept on the victim's occupation, as 123 and 52; source notes: the site summary's 'no arrest is recorded' and its loot list need redoing from this line; Vice's passages on Hitham, PewDiePie, John Terry, Kim Kardashian and the Houston art case are other incidents, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 279** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (the only substance is a threat prop, 'a syringe tinged with what they said was HIV contaminated blood (actually red ink)', and nobody was drugged; red ink passed off as blood is no drug, so the leverage reading of 170 and 391 does not reach it; DA call, owner may set 1); victim → 'Le', an HCMC businessman and bitcoin investor, with his wife, children and brother-in-law (VnExpress calls him only 'a man named Le'; the record's full name Le Duc Nguyen is in no source on file and is marked pending source trace); location → intercepted at Dau Giay Town, Dong Nai province, on the road from Bao Loc, driven two hours and dropped by a road in District 2, Ho Chi Minh City; description → a group organised by businessman Ho Ngoc Tai, which included two serving HCMC police officers, intercepted his family's car, threatened them with a fake gun and a syringe of red ink said to be HIV-contaminated blood, beat him during a two-hour drive and took 168 bitcoins worth about $1.63 million ('Cops used' goes: Tai 'enlisted the help of' the two officers, the article says 'the group' used the gun and syringe, and seventeen people are charged); notes → one earlier attempt on 12 May 2020, when Mai Xuan Phot ran his motorbike into Le's car on the Thoi Dai Bridge and Le drove away, a 'private investigator' hired for VND25 million and 'Mai Xuan Phot, a detective hired by Tai' appear without the article saying whether they are one person, 'at gunpoint' becomes a fake gun, and phones and cameras were taken to destroy evidence; money_wanted → 1,000 BTC demanded through a call to his brother, 168 BTC worth around VND37 billion, $1.63 million per VnExpress, plus other property worth around VND45 million taken; coin_type BTC kept; date 17 May 2020 kept ('Five days later', counted from 12 May); reports VnExpress International kept (sheet copy and fetched page carry the same text); arrests → all ('The culprits were arrested in June', year not printed, the two officers, Tai and 14 others face robbery charges, no trial date set, so the status needs a refresh before publication); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (owner, 2026-10-01; gap: the article does not say the officers used their office during the seizure); kidnappings stays 1; violence_torture stays 1 ('the group beat Le'); weapons stays 1 (fake gun and syringe shown as threats, noted as fake, as 136, 432 and 361); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = business counterparty (Tai's group traded with Le and blamed his advice for their 2018 losses) and surveillance (a hired detective mapped the family's routines); source notes: one source.
|
||||
- **DB id 288** (DA) — violence_torture → unconfirmed ('He pleaded guilty to felony assault', a first-degree assault plea for the drugging itself, 'an intent to inflict serious bodily injury by the drugging'; no blow in the account, and the drugging is already carried by the drugs flag, as ruled in 88; the earlier assaults the prosecutor cited are other occasions); date → May 2021, day unknown (the record's 1 May is in no source; the only date printed is 14 May, when the mother called police, some days after he was found; the year is not printed, the article is dated 3 February 2022 by its URL); notes → the father had made his son a partner in the investing account, and the Washington Post speaks of 'their bitcoin holdings' and 'their investment accounts', on which the father had put the two-step lock, so 'the dad's BTC' becomes bitcoin from the account they shared, two-thirds converted to Ethereum, and whether the father got the $400,000 back is not stated; description → son drugs his father's tea with a benzodiazepine and moves $400,000 in bitcoin out of the account they shared; money_wanted $400,000 kept ('he moved $400,000 of bitcoin to an account he could control'); coin_type BTC kept; victim → the father, surname Ghershony, first name withheld at his request (Washington Post); location → Bethesda, Maryland, his loft apartment in the Bethesda Row district; reports → Washington Post is the only original source, CoinMarketCap and Futurism are rewrites with no URL in the sheet, and CoinMarketCap misstates the first charge, which was attempted first-degree murder; arrests → convicted (Liam Ghershony pleaded guilty to first-degree assault: 125 days in jail, two months of residential treatment, 20 years of suspended time); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept; kidnappings stays 0 (unconscious two days, not held: 'left his dad passed out and alone in the apartment', as 151, 124 and 88); drugs_alcohol stays 1 ('the powder was a benzodiazepine'); weapons stays 0; theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0 (four days in hospital with severe dehydration and acute organ dysfunction); targeting vector = family / partner (his son, a partner on the account); source notes: the sheet copy ends with a job 'waiting tables at a restaurant in Rockville' and the archived copy of 24 July 2025 with 'a job at a take-out deli', so the page was edited between the two.
|
||||
- **DB id 290** (DA) — weapons → 1 ('robbery under knife-point' in the court's charge and in the women's complaint, and 'threatening them with blunt objects' in one victim's statement; both versions of the kind of weapon kept; the record's own note already says knifepoint); description → four men robbed three women of the cash they had brought to a fake Bitcoin deal in Al Nahda, Dubai (drop '$100,000', which is in no source on file; Gulf Today gives no dollar figure; 'Africans' is Gulf Today's own description of the gang); money_wanted → a bag with Dhs300,000 brought for the deal plus a second bag with Dhs63,000, other valuable items and the women's passports (article body); the joint fine of Dhs342,000, called 'a fine equal to the stolen money', and the headline's Dhs350,000 do not match the body and are logged as unresolved, as in 76 and 108; coin_type → cash (AED), no crypto taken; notes → the conviction and the complaint say knifepoint and one victim describes blunt objects, the women counted four men and their driver 'saw two Africans threatening the three women', and the driver wrote down the getaway car's plate; location → Al Nahda, Dubai, UAE; victim → three women, not named, one the buyer and two friends she brought; date August 2021 kept, day unknown ('Earlier in last August', in a report dated 14 February 2022 by its URL); reports Gulf Today kept; arrests → convicted (four sentenced to one year in jail, a joint fine of Dhs342,000 and deportation, one of them a fugitive; three arrests are reported); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space kept; kidnappings stays 0 (threatened in their own car and the bags snatched, no holding described, clarification 3; DA call, owner may set 1); violence_torture stays 0 (threats only, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure (a man offered her cryptocurrency for Dhs300,000; how contact was made is not stated); source notes: one source; the site summary's Attack Method line has the typo 'An man'.
|
||||
- **DB id 292** (DA) — description → two men attacked a cryptocurrency miner as he was leaving his home in Tomsk, one threatened him with an object resembling a gun and brought him back inside his apartment, the accomplice came in, and they forced him to transfer 86 BTC out of a wallet holding 90 ('Armed' keeps the article's hedge: 'an object resembling a gun' in the account, 'at gunpoint, authorities said' in the lead); notes → one man took him back in and the second came in afterwards, the home is an apartment, the suspect caught in St Petersburg pleaded guilty and returned 35 million roubles, close to $479,000 per Bitcoin.com, and how long he was held and how it ended are not stated; money_wanted → 86 BTC transferred, worth more than 360 million roubles at the time, over $4.8 million per Bitcoin.com; coin_type BTC kept; location Tomsk, Russia kept; victim → cryptocurrency miner, Tomsk resident, not named; date October 2021 kept, day unknown ('The crime took place in October 2021'); reports → Bitcoin.com, relaying Bits.media; arrests → all (both men in custody and charged with robbery by a group on an especially large scale, one pleaded guilty, trial at the Kirovsky Court of Tomsk still to come); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (brought back inside at the threat of a gun-like object and made to log in and transfer); violence_torture stays 0 (threat and coercion only, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('an object resembling a gun', hedge kept as in 29); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown (how the men knew of his holdings is not stated); source notes: one source with no publication date; its closing paragraph on a mining farm near Moscow and a tether robbery in Moscow covers other incidents, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 293** (DA) — money_wanted → three servers and 150,000 roubles ($2,040) in cash (Reuters: 'three servers and 150,000 roubles ($2,040) in cash'; '3 bitcoin miners' is the record's reading of 'servers'); coin_type → cash (RUB) and mining hardware, no coin taken ('BTC' goes); victim → a family in Sukhumi, not identified (the article places the raid in a list of robberies of miners and does not say the family mined); description kept (it matches the Reuters sentence); notes kept (the Reuters sentence, attributed to police); location Sukhumi, Abkhazia kept; date December 2021 kept, day unknown ('last month', counted from the 6 January 2022 dateline, is the month of the police statement); reports Reuters kept; arrests → some ('police said they made one arrest', two masked men); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('held a family at gunpoint'); violence_torture stays 0 (no blow or injury in the one sentence on this case); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('at gunpoint'); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0 (the article's 'One man was killed' bullet belongs to the October country-house shooting and stays out of this record); targeting vector = unknown; source notes: the case rests on one sentence of a Reuters feature; the garage break-in, the October shooting, the warehouse attempt and the Chernomorenergo shots are other incidents, not used; held duration not stated.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 40 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-40.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-40.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-40.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 296** (DA) — money_wanted → Dh300,000 in cash brought to buy Bitcoin, plus other valuables in the bag (headline: 'robbing woman of Dh300,000'; body: 'a woman wanted to buy Bitcoins for Dh300,000' and 'They stole the bag of money and other valuables'; the bag's contents are not itemised; the record's Dh342,000 is the fine, 'Judges ordered them to pay a fine of Dh342,188'); coin_type → cash (AED), no crypto taken; date → February 2022, approximate (16 February 2022 is the date of the Gulf News report on the verdict; the robbery date is not stated); victim → a woman buyer and the two friends who came with her ('two men threatened them with an axe'; the suspect 'was identified by the women'); location → Al Nahda, Dubai ('a parking area between buildings', per the driver's statement); description → a woman who wanted to buy Bitcoin for Dh300,000 went to Al Nahda with two friends to meet the seller; two men with an axe threatened them and took the bag of money and other valuables while two others watched the area; the four left by car; notes → the driver said the pair were back 'After two minutes' carrying 'bags and a laptop'; a passer-by heard the women and recorded the car's number; the article calls the counterparty 'the seller' in one line and 'the buyer' in the victim's quote; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space kept; kidnappings stays 0 (a two-minute robbery in a parking area, nobody held; clarification 3); violence_torture stays 0 (threat only, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('two men came carrying an axe'); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure (how the meeting was arranged is not stated); arrests → convicted: all four charged with robbery, one year in jail then deportation, fine of Dh342,188, verdict open to appeal within 15 days, nothing later on file; reports → Gulf News (one article, two copies that match).
|
||||
- **DB id 297** (DA) — theft → 1 ('Dh1.7 million had been stolen from a safe that belonged to his trading partner'; the partner 'saw the house in a mess and the safe open, with the cash missing'); description → a group came to his residence saying his 'address was incorrect'; when he tried to close the door they pushed him and entered, put a knife to his neck after he fell, tied him with plastic rope, took the safe key from under a table and stole Dh1.7 million in cash from the safe; drop '$450K' (no dollar figure in the article, the record's own conversion); money_wanted → Dh1.7 million in cash, kept in dirhams; coin_type → cash (AED), no crypto taken; victim → bitcoin trader, plus his trading partner, who owned the safe and the cash ('The second victim' in the court account); notes → drop 'not injured' and 'on the fence' (the article does not say whether he was injured; it reports the push, the fall, the knife at his neck and the rope, and the fine is 'for assaulting a bitcoin trader'); standfirst: 'The victim's hands and feet were tied during the robbery'; he 'managed to untangle himself' and called his partner and the police; how long he was tied is not stated; date → March 2022, day unknown ('Last March' in a report of 6 September 2022); location → Dubai, district not stated; sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Home Invasion kept (wrong-address pretext at the door, no claimed role, so Authority Misuse not applied, as 79); kidnappings stays 1 (tied in his own home; clarification 1); violence_torture stays 1 (pushed to the floor, knife to the neck, 'assaulting'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('the men put a knife to his neck'); life_taken stays 0; summary: 'he was not otherwise injured' → injury not stated; targeting vector = unknown (not stated); arrests → convicted: four men caught, confessed and jointly fined Dh1.7 million; no prison term reported; reports → Khaleej Times; the teaser headlines in the untrimmed fetched page (pardon, Sharjah allowance, US-Iran items, traffic fines, flights) not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 298** (DA) — money_wanted → Dh 4,120,000 in cash ('stole Dh 4,120,000'; the headline rounds to 'Dh4 million'); coin_type → cash (AED), no crypto taken; description → nine robbers knocked on the door of his company's headquarters, entered, assaulted him and took Dh 4,120,000 in cash by force; drop 'over $1,000,000' (no dollar figure in the article) and 'invaded' (no forced entry described: 'knocking on the door of his company and entering'); victim → owner of a Bitcoin trading company, not named; location → Al Nakhil area, Dubai (his company's headquarters); date → April 2022, day unknown ('last April' in a report of 3 October 2022); notes → workplace, not a home; whether anyone was tied or held, whether he was injured and how the attack ended are not stated; sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, gap: no weapon is named (business premises, listed under Armed Robbery in the 2026-10-06 note); kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list: entry into his office followed by an assault to take the cash; no holding described, noted as in 438); violence_torture stays 1 ('They attacked him and stole the cash'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none named; 'robbed by force'); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown; arrests → convicted: all nine identified and arrested, three years in prison then deportation (Dubai Criminal Court); reports → Khaleej Times; the fetched page is cut after two paragraphs, so the knock at the door, the arrests and the sentences rest on the sheet copy of the same article.
|
||||
- **DB id 301** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 (owner ruling of 2026-09-06, clarification 2: 'the suspects robbed the factory early in the morning and tied up the security personnel on duty'; the police chief gives this as 'the modus operandi used' without saying on which of the two nights); weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon named; the only pointer is 'an investigation paper under Section 395/397 of the Penal Code', which the article does not explain; as 117 and 410; DA call, owner may set 0); date → 20 May 2022 kept, the second of two incidents at the same factory ('stolen in two incidents, on April 27 and May 20'); one record for the series, as 9, 173 and 179; description → an aluminium factory was broken into early in the morning on 27 April and 20 May 2022, the security personnel on duty were tied up, and 180 bitcoin mining machines were stolen over the two incidents; drop '12 men rob' (twelve is the number arrested; three more are sought and the arrests are said to solve 'three bitcoin machine robbery cases in the North Klang area', so the number of robbers at this factory is not stated) and 'ASICs' (the article says 'bitcoin machines' and 'bitcoin mining machines'); money_wanted → 180 bitcoin mining machines, 'a loss of hundreds of thousands of ringgit' (no exact figure); coin_type → empty kept (hardware, no crypto taken); victim → owner of the aluminium factory (who lodged the report; not said to be present) and the security personnel on duty, who were tied up; location → West Meru industrial area, near Klang; notes → how and when the guards were freed is not stated; no injury reported; sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept (guards held during the theft, so not Burglary; owner ruling of 2026-10-06 names 301); violence_torture stays 0 (tied, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0 (the only drug reference is the suspects' own records); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown; arrests → some: twelve men aged 20 to 40, one Indonesian, arrested in nine raids on 26 and 27 May 2022 and remanded five days; three sought (Tan Jian Farn alias Q-Peng, 37; Herman Petrus, 41; Abdul Rahim Mohamad Ali, 33); no charge or verdict on file; reports → The Vibes (Bernama, 30 May 2022); the third North Klang robbery is not described and gets no record.
|
||||
- **DB id 303** (DA) — theft → 1 ('stole the bag which contained Dh183,000, three phones, documents and bank cheques'); description → a broker came to the investor's home to check the cash he wanted to use to buy Bitcoin and left promising to return with the seller within 15 minutes; minutes later the broker phoned to say the seller was hesitating, then two men knocked, assaulted and immobilised him, threatened to kill him and took the bag; drop '~$50,000' (no dollar figure in the article); money_wanted → Dh183,000 in cash, plus three phones, documents and bank cheques; coin_type → cash (AED), no crypto changed hands; victim → Asian investor, plus the friend who suggested the investment and passed on the promoter's number, counted by the court as the second victim (what he lost and whether he was present are not stated); notes → 'the victim's home was the agreed upon meeting place' → the broker inspected the cash at the home and then said 'the seller was hesitating to complete the deal at the residence'; how the two men got in is not described ('He then heard a knock on the door, and was assaulted'), so the summary's 'forced their way in' goes; how long he was immobilised and how it ended are not stated; location → Mankhool area, Dubai; date → July 2022, day unknown ('last July' in a report of 28 November 2022); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('assaulted by two men who immobilised him' inside his residence; clarification 1); violence_torture stays 1 ('robbed and assaulted inside his residence'; death threat); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none named); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure through a friend's referral (the friend 'gave him a promoter number to buy Bitcoin'; how the promoter reached the friend is not stated); arrests → convicted: two people jailed for three years, fined the stolen amount and ordered deported; three people appear in the account (the broker and two robbers) and the article does not say which two; reports → Khaleej Times; the teaser headlines in the untrimmed fetched page (pardon, Sharjah allowance, marriage scam, school fees, flights) not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 304** (DA) — date → 13 September 2022 ('On Sept. 13, 2022, multiple suspects with weapons allegedly entered the home'); description → multiple suspects with weapons, some of them impersonating police officers according to Richmond RCMP, allegedly entered the home of a middle-aged couple, who were allegedly assaulted, bound and held for several hours; the suspects fled with $10 million in cryptocurrency and several luxury items (the account is alleged throughout: charges laid, no trial yet); money_wanted → $10 million in cryptocurrency and several luxury items; 'a large portion of the cryptocurrency has been recovered' (RCMP); the article does not say US or Canadian dollars; coin_type → crypto, coin not named; location → north Richmond, B.C.; notes → victims 'suffered non-life-threatening injuries but were badly shaken up'; the article announces 11 charges and lists ten counts; how the couple got free is not stated; sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('bound and held for several hours'; charge of unlawful confinement); violence_torture stays 1 ('allegedly assaulted'; three counts of assault; injuries); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('multiple suspects with weapons'; charges of 'robbery with a weapon' and 'use of an imitation firearm during a robbery', the firearm an imitation, noted as in 136); theft stays 1 (with the recovery noted); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown (not stated); arrests → some: one man, Jin Da Xing, 34, of Richmond, charged with 11 offences and remanded awaiting trial; the other suspects not accounted for; the report is dated 23 November 2023 and the status needs a refresh before publication; reports → Richmond News.
|
||||
- **DB id 308** (DA) — description → prosecutors allege Colivas met the man for drinks; when he offered to drive her home, three men jumped him and drove him off against his will; he was bound with zip ties and threatened with having his fingers cut off unless he paid a $20,000 ransom, transferred $40,000 to the kidnappers' accounts, and was then driven to his own home, where several luxury items were taken before he was released; drop 'lures Saudi royal to her home where he was imprisoned' (the only home in the account is his own); money_wanted → $20,000 demanded as ransom, $40,000 transferred (Cryptonews relaying news.com.au; US or Australian dollars not stated), plus several luxury items taken from his home; coin_type → BTC ('a Bitcoin scam that netted $40,000'; 'the stolen $40,000 worth of the token'); violence_torture → 1 (Colivas 'pleaded guilty to kidnapping, extortion, recklessly causing injury, theft, and gun possession', so an injury is admitted; the article does not describe it; the zip ties and the finger threat are on file; DA call, owner may set unconfirmed as in 88); victim → 23-year-old member of the Saudi Arabian royal family, unnamed, who 'reportedly traded digital assets'; location → Moorabbin, Melbourne, Australia (Moorabbin per the Herald Sun post embedded in the article; 'Melbourne' is the record's own and appears in no text on file); date → February 2023, day unknown; notes → 'extorts for 20k usd' → 20,000 demanded, 40,000 paid; where he was held between the abduction and the drive home, and for how long, is not stated; sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('driven off against his will'; 'bound with zip ties'); drugs_alcohol stays 0 (they met 'for drinks'; no spiking reported); weapons stays 1 (plea to 'gun possession'; 'held him at knifepoint' per the Herald Sun post, both noted); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = not stated (how the two came to meet is not on file); arrests → convicted: Colivas, 24, pleaded guilty and received a community corrections order on 16 December 2024; nothing on file about the three men; reports → Cryptonews (Julia Smith, 16 December 2024; the sheet holds the same piece twice, and the second copy's 'Bitcoin Sets Price Records' section is not used); the cryptorank.io link returns an aggregator shell with no text on this case and should be replaced by the Cryptonews URL, which is not on file.
|
||||
- **DB id 309** (DA) — coin_type → not stated: Dh42,000 of her money was taken and the gang converted it into bitcoin afterwards ('robbing a woman of Dh42,000 ... converted her money into bitcoin'; 'they demanded that she transfer her money to their account'; the first article's headline says 'using cash to buy bitcoin'; neither article says in what form she held it); money_wanted → Dh42,000 kept (GDN: BD4,300); date → April 2023 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; neither article carries a date of any kind); location → Dubai Investments Park, Dubai (the meeting place; where she was held is not stated); description → kept, with the order of events fixed: the gang held her for several hours and then left her on a street with her hands tied and a plastic bag on her face ('After several hours, they left her on a street'); the summary's 'left on a street for several hours' goes; notes → evidence found in 'their homes' (first article) or 'one of their homes' (GDN), both noted; she 'was eventually able to run' to the police; victim → unidentified woman, a cryptocurrency investor; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept, gap: no source says she was moved from the meeting place, 'kidnapped' is the first article's word only; kidnappings stays 1 (held several hours, hands tied); violence_torture stays 1 ('assaulted, electrocuted, stripped off my clothes, and photographed'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 (electric shock device, found at the arrests); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = insider (her own driver, who 'knew that she was a cryptocurrency investor'); arrests → convicted: all four sentenced to three years and deportation; the Dh42,000 fine is in the first article only; reports → GDN and a second outlet; the two texts are swapped against their links: the gdnonline.com URL holds the GDN text that the sheet stores as 'Article 2' with no URL, and the text stored under that URL (headline 'Dubai: 4 expats jailed for robbing woman of Dh42,000, using cash to buy bitcoin') is another outlet's, presumably Khaleej Times per the record's reports field; find and add its URL.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 41 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-41.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-41.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-41.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 312** (DA) — date → late May or early June 2023, day unknown (Finance Magnates of Thursday 15 June 2023: 'robbed of his digital assets at gunpoint in his Tel Aviv home two weeks ago, according to the Israeli financial site, Globes on Wednesday'; no text prints the day, so the record's 'June 2023' may be a month late); description → an Israeli crypto entrepreneur told police that robbers broke into his Tel Aviv apartment, beat him and forced him at gunpoint to transfer all his crypto holdings to their wallets (hedges kept: 'Was Allegedly Robbed', 'was reportedly robbed', 'told police'; the account is his report to police relayed from Globes); notes → the wallet provider froze the transfers and conversions as suspicious, so 'neither the robbers nor the entrepreneur has access to the cryptocurrencies'; he left Israel and 'remains nearly penniless'; 'Today, a severed animal head was placed near the entrepreneur's door, along with a hateful graffiti message. The Israel Police announced that an investigation has been opened regarding this incident' (ARTICLE 1; the text does not say who placed it, so 'They later left an animal head' is replaced); money_wanted undisclosed kept (no amount in either text); coin_type crypto kept (coin not named); victim kept (identity not revealed); location kept (his apartment in Tel Aviv); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (broke in, beat him, held at gunpoint until the transfer; clarification 1), violence_torture stays 1 ('beat him mercilessly'), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 ('at gunpoint', both texts), theft stays 1 (the transfer was made; the flag notes that the funds were frozen afterwards, as 209), life_taken stays 0; arrests → not stated (the number of robbers, how the robbery ended and how long he was held are not stated either); targeting vector unknown; source notes: ARTICLE 2 and the fetched block are the same Finance Magnates page; ARTICLE 1 is filed under that URL but is a different text ('Gun threat: Crypto entrepreneur robbed at his home in Tel Aviv') whose origin is not recorded, and it is the only text with the animal head and the graffiti, so find and link its source; the second half of the Finance Magnates page (Wallingford, Iowa, Oxfordshire 2018, the Russian blogger, Pavel Lerner, the New Jersey man) is other cases, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 317** (DA) — date → 13 October 2024, about 5 a.m. ('The 59-year-old victim was abducted outside his home at 5am on October 13', Malay Mail of 30 October 2024); location → Iskandar Puteri, Johor ('the businessman's kidnapping in Iskandar Puteri on October 13'; Johor Baru is the dateline and the place of the police press conference and the remand hearings); victim → 59-year-old Johor businessman, not named; description → abducted outside his home while preparing to take a ride-hailing car to Senai International Airport for a business trip; released after a ransom of RM20 million was 'allegedly paid'; money_wanted → RM30 million demanded at first, 'reportedly lowered after negotiations'; RM20 million 'allegedly paid'; RM7.2 million recovered by police; coin_type → not stated for the payment; the recovered part was RM1.95 million in cash, S$1 million (RM3.3 million) in foreign currency and 400,000 USDT (about RM1.75 million); notes → 'cash and 400k USDT taken' becomes: the cash and the 400,000 Tether are what police recovered, the form of the RM20 million payment is not stated; the three recovered parts add to RM7.0 million against the RM7.2 million stated (logged); suspects organised in three groups (planning and abduction, disposal of items, ransom handling); police declined to comment on 'the alleged family ties between one of the suspects and the victim'; where he was held and the day of release are not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept; weapons → 1 ('police seized a Beretta pistol, 250 live bullets and a pair of handcuffs from the suspects'; the article does not say the pistol was used in the abduction; weapon confirmed through the arrests, as 213 and 385); violence_torture → unconfirmed (no blow, injury or treatment in captivity described; as 435 and 407); drugs_alcohol → 0 (none reported); kidnappings stays 1, theft stays 1 (payment reported with 'allegedly'), life_taken stays 0; arrests → some: all on remand, none charged at publication, one suspect at large; the article's counts differ (11 local suspects including a woman plus two men and a woman from Vietnam; remand extended for 10 local suspects including two women, plus a local man arrested in Senai; '10 men and three women' per the Johor police chief a week earlier), all logged; investigated under Section 3(1) of the Kidnapping Act 1961; targeting vector unknown (possible family tie to a suspect, not confirmed by police); crypto link: 400,000 USDT inside the recovered ransom, no crypto holding of the victim reported, tag 'crypto as extraction rail' as ruled for 376; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and the fetched block are the same Malay Mail page, the Versa advertisement and the Google prompt not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 321** (DA) — victim → retired teacher, mother of a man who works in cryptocurrency management and lives in Portugal ('Uma professora aposentada foi sequestrada'; 'a mulher sequestrada é mãe de um homem que trabalha com gestão de criptomoedas'; owner ruling on 321 already says change the victim to the mother); weapons → 1 ('mantida em cativeiro por mais de 12 horas, sob a mira de arma de fogo', g1 Pernambuco); location → seized leaving the Fórum Desembargador Benildes de Souza Ribeiro, Imbiribeira, Recife; held in Olinda; released near the Ouro Preto neighbourhood, Olinda; money_wanted → 5 BTC paid by the son (R$3.3 million at the rate of the time; the g1 headline rounds to R$3 million; the sheet translation's '$' is R$); coin_type → BTC; reports → g1 Pernambuco (the record says 'Pernambuco'); date 21 March 2025 kept ('O sequestro aconteceu no dia 21 de março de 2025'); notes → at least two men in the car, a vehicle with a cloned plate; the two women arrested 'teriam recebido parte do pagamento do resgate em criptoativos'; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; violence_torture stays 0 (gun threat only, no blow or injury reported; threat-only cases stand at 0 in 420, 403 and 442; DA call, owner may set 1 under the glossary's 'threats and physical intimidation'), kidnappings stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 0, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; arrests → four people arrested on temporary warrants, announced 13 August 2025 (two in Abreu e Lima and Olinda, two in Extremoz, RN; two of them women), charged with extortion through kidnapping and money laundering; police call them 'os quatro responsáveis' and say investigations continue; targeting vector = social media and surveillance ('passaram a monitorar diariamente as redes sociais desse negociador de criptoativos'; her addresses and routine identified); source notes: ARTICLE 1 is a machine translation of the g1 page in the fetched block, the Portuguese original used where they differ ('Reef' for Recife); the page's video list, newsletter block and unrelated teasers not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 322** (DA) — theft → unconfirmed ('Les malfaiteurs auraient réclamé entre 5 à 7 millions d'euros sous forme de virement en échange de sa libération'; a demand only, no payment or loss stated, and he 'a finalement été libéré lors d'une opération' of the police; DA call, the writer proposed 0 and the owner may set 0 as in 396 and 401); weapons → unconfirmed ('armed' rests only on the charge 'extorsion en bande organisée avec arme'; no weapon described and what severed the finger is not stated; as 487 and 411; DA call, owner may keep 1); money_wanted → 5 to 7 million euros demanded, in the conditional, as a transfer; nothing reported paid (the record's '$5M' and the description's '5M EUR' are both off the source); coin_type → not stated ('sous forme de virement'; no coin named, drop BTC); victim → man in his fifties, father of a French cryptocurrency entrepreneur who heads a company based in Malta and France (drop 'millionaire', not in the article); description → abducted about 10:30 a.m. on Thursday 1 May 2025 in the 14th arrondissement of Paris, held for ransom, found with a severed finger and freed on the night of Saturday 3 May in Palaiseau (Essonne) in an operation coordinated by the BRI of the Paris judicial police with the BRB and the brigade criminelle; location → Paris, 14th arrondissement (seized); freed in Palaiseau, Essonne; date 1 May 2025 kept (Le Parisien of Saturday 3 May: 'jeudi vers 10h30'); notes → the dwelling where he was held 'était calfeutré, probablement en vue de réaliser des vidéos de mise en scène de l'otage'; summary artefacts to fix: 'BIS' is the BRI, and 'apartment ... being sealed off' renders 'le logement ... était calfeutré' (dwelling, not apartment); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 ('retrouvé avec un doigt sectionné'), drugs_alcohol stays 0, life_taken stays 0; arrests → some (four suspects arrested and placed in custody; whether that is the whole group is not stated; investigation opened for organised-gang abduction, hostage-taking and extortion); targeting vector = family of a holder (the son's crypto business; how the father was chosen is not stated, as 392 and 396); reports → Le Parisien (3 May 2025, confirming Actu17); source notes: ARTICLE 1 is a machine translation of the Le Parisien page in the fetched block (Wayback snapshot of 18 May 2025), one source; the closing paragraph on David Balland is another case (209), not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 334** (DA) — theft → 1 ('No total, eles conseguiram somente R$ 6.813,28 via Pix', Livecoins; only the crypto theft failed, as 455 and 153); money_wanted → 2 to 4 million reais in cryptocurrency targeted, none obtained ('a vítima não possuía acesso à sua carteira de criptomoedas no local'); R$6,813.28 obtained via Pix; coin_type → cryptocurrency, coin not named (targeted); the sum taken was reais via Pix; description → lured to Goiânia for a business meeting by Josemar Alencar Linhares de Oliveira, held at gunpoint in a car by two armed men while the driver posed as a fellow victim, beaten and made to try transfers for about an hour and a half; the crypto theft failed and R$6,813.28 was taken via Pix; thrown from the car at about 30 km/h during a police chase on the GO-020 (three ribs fractured, internal bleeding); two attackers died in the confrontation with police; the alleged mastermind was arrested on arrival in the USA ('foi preso assim que chegou nos EUA'; drop 'Miami', no city in the source; 'Attack failed' holds for the crypto only); date → June 2025, day unknown, between 24 and 30 June ('chegou em Goiânia no dia 24 de junho' is the arrival; the attack came 'Logo após saírem do hotel' with no day given; Josemar flew out 'no dia 30 de junho, uma segunda-feira, logo após o ocorrido'); victim → businessman from São Paulo, not named; location Goiânia kept (GO-020 towards Bela Vista); notes → the testimony also holds a debt reading: 'a vítima supostamente devia R$ 500 mil por uma comissão de assessoramento de uma transação de criptomoeda com um terceiro. Portanto, poderia se tratar de uma cobrança de dívida por Josemar'; Josemar 'se apresentou como assessor do então presidente da Assembleia Legislativa de Goiás', and the article does not say the claim was false, so the summary's 'posed as' becomes 'introduced himself as' (only Gabriel is 'outro suposto assessor'); Livecoins calls the crime a 'sequestro relâmpago'; sequence Authority Misuse → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept (owner rulings of 2026-09-30 and 2026-10-01; the glossary's Authority Misuse covers 'real or fabricated positions', so the unproven falsity of the advisor claim does not contradict the label; flagged for the owner's information); kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 ('dando socos em sua cabeça'; thrown from the moving car), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (two firearms, per the sentence), life_taken stays 2 (two attackers, Gabriel Pires de Lima and Tiago Oliveira Rocha, killed in the confrontation with police; the victim survived); arrests → convicted: Josemar sentenced on Wednesday 24 September 2025 to 12 years and 9 months for extortion as intellectual author (he denies involvement); two attackers dead; the third man in the car never identified; targeting vector = business counterparty (approached in February; an alleged commission debt); outcome: put out of the moving car by the attackers and picked up by a truck driver; source notes: ARTICLE 1 is an English translation of the Livecoins page in the fetched block, one source written from the court file; the WhatsApp, OKX and social-link lines not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 340** (DA) — date → 18 October 2025, about 10:30 p.m. (The Jakarta Post of Friday 24 October 2025: 'the incident occurred on Saturday at around 10:30 p.m.', as the Bali Police spokesperson said 'on Tuesday'; the Saturday before that Tuesday is 18 October; the record's 23 October is a Thursday and has no source; inferred, noted); description → Russian influencer says he was forced into an Alphard by two men in black ski masks near Sanur Beach, taken to a house in Jimbaran, allegedly beaten and tased, and made to hand over his phone and transfer about US$4,600 in cryptocurrency; three more men arrived and demanded US$1 million, which he said he could not pay; released several hours later (hedges kept: 'has claimed', 'According to Sergei's statement to police', 'allegedly', 'Sergei further claimed'); money_wanted → about US$4,600 in cryptocurrency transferred, plus his mobile phone; US$1 million ransom demanded afterwards, not paid; coin_type Crypto kept (coin not named); location → seized near Sanur Beach, Bali; held at a house in Jimbaran, South Kuta; released in a field near the Apurva Kempinski Hotel, South Kuta; victim Sergei Domogatskii kept (named by Bali Police); notes → he says the attacker was another Russian; injuries to his right arm; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 ('allegedly beaten and tased'; arm injuries), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (taser, on his statement; as 160 and 181), theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; arrests → not stated (the text on file ends after five paragraphs of a Premium article); targeting vector = public profile (popular influencer; how he was chosen is not stated); source notes: ARTICLE 1 and the fetched block are the same Jakarta Post page, quoting Bali Police through Kompas.com; arrests, suspects and police findings may sit behind the paywall, so a second source is worth fetching.
|
||||
- **DB id 349** (DA) — date → autumn 2021, month not stated (Reuters of 6 January 2022: 'one autumn morning'; the record's September is an assumption and the year is inferred from the article date; keep September only as an approximate placeholder); notes → quarter field reads 2021-Q2 beside month 9 and does not match the record's own date (2021-Q3 for September); Reuters gives him the pseudonym Valeri ('preferred not to use his real name'); he could not go to the police because the mining was illegal and 'tried to track down the thieves himself but to no avail'; victim 'Unidentified 31 y/o' kept (the pseudonym stays out of the victim field, as 395); description kept ('Thieves had broken in overnight, taking with them 20 mining servers worth about $10,000'; the garage door was 'bust open', nobody present); money_wanted kept (20 mining servers worth about $10,000); coin_type stays empty (hardware, no crypto taken); location Abkhazia kept (town not stated); sequence Burglary kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-06, group B: mining hardware, nobody present; the record's scenario field still reads Armed Robbery in Public Space); kidnappings stays 0, violence_torture stays 0, drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 0 (the guns in the article belong to other incidents), theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; arrests → none (no police report; nobody identified); targeting vector unknown; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and the fetched block (Wayback snapshot of 1 December 2023) are the same Reuters feature on the whole wave; its other incidents are not used here and are already records: the October country-house shooting is DB 102 and the Sukhumi family held at gunpoint is DB 293; Victor's botched warehouse burglary and the shots at Chernomorenergo are context; format point for `summary-overrides.json`: the Violence Used line opens with 'None' where the procedure asks for the opening 'No detention', so `batches/validate.py` reports this case.
|
||||
- **DB id 350** (DA) — description → a 35-year-old former cryptocurrency trader was kidnapped and held between Paris and Saint-Germain-en-Laye; the kidnappers sent a photo of him on his knees with his hands tied to an acquaintance in Algeria and demanded 10,000 euros from that contact, who alerted police; nothing was paid and he was found walking home at about 4 a.m. on the Wednesday (replaces 'from his wife': no wife appears in any text; 'the victim's acquaintance', Cryptonews citing Le Parisien); money_wanted → 10,000 EUR demanded, not paid ('failed to extract a €10,000 ransom'; the record's '$10,000' is euros); coin_type → not stated (no text says the ransom was asked in cryptocurrency; the crypto link is his former trade, as 123); notes → the demand was made of the contact ('demanded €10,000 from the contact'; the lead says 'from his contacts'), not of the victim; drop '10k USD'; his phone was geolocated to the 10th arrondissement; 'investigators work to verify his statements about the incident circumstances' (hedge kept); forensic traces taken from his clothing and skin; weapons → 0 (none mentioned in the three texts; hands tied and strangled; DA call, the abduction itself is not described); drugs_alcohol → 0 (none mentioned); date 26 August 2025 kept (police alerted on Tuesday night, found Wednesday about 4 a.m.; ARTICLE 2 is dated Thursday 28 August 2025, which fixes the Tuesday as 26 August; when he was seized is not stated); victim → Alexandre, 35, former crypto trader (first name only; 'Alexander' in ARTICLE 2); location → between Paris and Saint-Germain-en-Laye, place of holding not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('on his knees with his hands tied'), violence_torture stays 1 ('facial swelling and injuries after being strangled'), theft stays 0, life_taken stays 0; arrests → none ('no strong leads' at the time of ARTICLE 2); targeting vector unknown; source notes: both texts are rewrites of a Le Parisien story that is not on file, worth fetching; ARTICLE 2 has no URL recorded and is another outlet's write-up (bylined Manmit Kahlon, 28 August 2025), find and link it; the second half of the cryptonews.com page is other cases, not used (the poker player's father in Paris is DB 322, Balland is 209); this cryptonews URL is also stored by mistake with the AseanNow text of DB 476 (batch 20).
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## Batch 42 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
||||
|
||||
Field comparison of the cases verified by the older method. Taken from `batches/contradictions-42.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-42.json`. Cases needing the owner are in `batches/decisions-42.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 353** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ('Нападавшие угрожали оружием, заковав охранников в наручники', Bits.Media: guards handcuffed at weapon-point to execute the theft, clarification 2; already on the owner's list of 2026-09-06); money_wanted → not stated (the damage 'может значительно превысить 1 млн', could significantly exceed 1 million, no currency named; the record's '100 million rubles worth of Bitcoin miners' belongs to the page's last paragraph, a separate Irkutsk 'mining hotel' case, and is dropped); notes → four containers holding 100 video cards were taken, with processors, servers and the storage holding the surveillance recordings, and the article never mentions Bitcoin (replaces '100 million rubles worth of Bitcoin miners'); victim → a mining farm on the warehouse territory of the VkusVill retail chain, operator not named, and the warehouse guards (the article names no supermarket and does not say who ran the farm); description → four masked men entered the warehouse, threatened the guards with weapons, handcuffed them and took four containers holding 100 video cards and the surveillance storage; location → Kuchino, a village near Domodedovo, Moscow region; date July 2022 kept, day unknown (the item is dated 20 July 2022 and gives no date for the attack); coin_type stays empty (hardware taken, no crypto); arrests → none (police were searching when the item ran); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept (guards threatened and held, so Armed Robbery and not Burglary under the boundary of 2026-10-06, as 301); violence_torture stays 0 (no blow or injury reported, and the article is silent on injuries), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 ('угрожали оружием', kind of weapon not stated), theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; targeting vector unknown; held duration and how the guards got free not stated; source notes: one Bits.Media item held twice (sheet copy in English, Russian original), the WEAK anchor flag is a matcher artefact and the article is the right one, the Irkutsk paragraph not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 362** (DA) — date → 30 September 2025 (Europe 1 is stamped 10:05 on 1 October 2025, a Wednesday, and places the threat on 'mardi après-midi' with the phone handed over 'Dans la soirée', so the Tuesday is 30 September; month and quarter fields follow: 9 and 2025-Q3; as 186 and 172); weapons → 0 (no weapon in the article, the two are described only as 'cagoulés'); description → a woman with her two children was threatened by two hooded men who handed her a mobile phone for her husband, an independent cryptocurrency investor, and threatened to harm the family if he did not answer the calls (no demand, sum or coin is reported; 'Chantage' is the headline's word); notes → the phone was a Samsung with a prepaid card and rang four times that evening, the husband did not answer, filed a complaint at the police station and handed the phone to investigators, and local police put the home under surveillance; victim → a mother and her two children, the husband being the target; coin_type → empty (no coin named and nothing demanded); money_wanted stays empty; location Val-de-Marne kept (where she was approached is not stated); arrests → not stated; sequence Dodged Attack kept, gap: an extortion opened at a distance, with no label of its own; attempted list added: extortion of the husband through calls to the prepaid phone, under threat to the family; kidnappings stays 0 (threatened and handed a phone, nobody held), violence_torture stays 0 (threat only), drugs_alcohol stays 0, theft stays 0, life_taken stays 0; targeting vector unknown; source notes: one Europe 1 exclusive held twice (the sheet copy is an English rendering of the same text); the sheet's archive.is link is the Kharkiv mispaste already ruled on (spreadsheet row 259) and the record's Europe 1 URL is the right one; the teasers at the foot of the fetched page not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 364** (DA) — weapons → 0 (no weapon mentioned, blows only: 'managed blows over his face', as 27 and 39); arrests → some: the lookout, a 31-year-old, was held by the victim until police arrived and then arrested, and the man who took the cash was still sought ('The 31 year old was subsequently arrested while the suspect with the cash is still being sought'); description → a man who came to a noon meeting in central Limassol to buy cryptocurrency was struck across the head and face as he waited in his car, and one of the two men he was to meet ran off with a backpack holding 100,000 euros in cash; money_wanted → 100,000 EUR in cash brought to buy cryptocurrency, taken; coin_type → cash (EUR), no crypto taken; date 24 December 2024 kept (the headline says Christmas Eve; the fetched text prints no year, so 2024 rests on the sheet); location Limassol kept; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept (the trade was the approach, as 137, 143 and 104), gap: an unarmed snatch with blows at a planned trade; kidnappings stays 0 (a snatch in passing, clarification 3), violence_torture stays 1 ('hit across the head'), drugs_alcohol stays 0, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure (he 'had set up the exchange with two men'; how they found him is not stated); his injuries and any treatment not stated; one source (in-cyprus / Philenews); Limassol CID was looking for possible accomplices.
|
||||
- **DB id 367** (DA) — arrests → some: one 33-year-old man arrested on 17 December 2024 in a joint operation of the SDVR and the Kobra unit, kept in custody by the first-instance court, named by bTV on its own information as Krasimir Stanev, and the accomplices not identified ('За съучастниците си - задържаният не казва нищо. Работата по установяването на самоличността им продължава'); description → two men who introduced themselves as police stopped the victim near his home in Lyulin 3 at about 22:00, put him into a grey jeep driven by a third person, threatened him with a pistol to transfer 14 bitcoin within 24 hours, drove him around for about an hour, took four debit cards, used an electroshock device on him and left him in Lyulin 1 (drops 'They failed to get any BTC', which no source says, and 'were arrested 2 months later' for both men); notes → at least three people took part (he saw the faces of the two men and not the driver's), he was told once that he would be taken to the Suhodol lake and drowned, the attackers were to contact him again about the transfer and he reported the attack the same evening, whether any bitcoin was paid is not stated, and the searches found a GDBOP badge and an interior-ministry association card (fake, per bTV), a black airsoft pistol and a blue police lamp in the car; money_wanted → 14 BTC demanded within 24 hours, payment not stated; coin_type → BTC (the four debit cards move to notes); location → Lyulin district, Sofia; date 7 October 2024 kept, confirmed ('Датата е 7 октомври', piece dated 21 December 2024); victim 35-year-old man kept ('Ivan' is bTV's pseudonym and stays out); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-01); kidnappings stays 1 (put into the jeep and driven around for about an hour), violence_torture stays 1 (electroshock device used), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (pistol and electroshock device; the article does not say the airsoft pistol found at the arrest was the gun in the jeep), theft stays 1 (four debit cards), life_taken stays 0; targeting vector unknown (pre-selection implied by the 14 BTC demand, not stated); source notes: Wayback copy of a bTV piece; an earlier bTV report of the same case is teased on the page and is not on file; the page furniture and the GDBOP businessman teaser are other matters, not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 369** (DA) — money_wanted → £500,000 demanded from his crypto account, lowered to £50,000, settled at £2,000 from his current account (The Times; he held £6.71 in crypto); coin_type crypto kept, coin not named; arrests → convicted: Davina Raaymakers, 20, Adlan Haji, 28, Alexander Khalil, 30, and Omar Sharif, 24, admitted blackmail at Isleworth crown court and were awaiting sentence (guilty pleas to blackmail, not a kidnap conviction; the article gives no time between the attack and the arrests); description → Belgian barber told a woman he met on TikTok and Instagram that he was a successful crypto dealer, was invited to a luxury flat in London and led instead to an Airbnb bedsit in Shepherd's Bush, where a gang held him for nine hours and demanded £500,000 in crypto when he held £6.71 (drops 'quickly caught', which has no timing behind it); notes → held a machete to his neck and a knife to his leg, punched and kicked him in the stomach and showed him a video of an apparent stabbing, took his passport, phone and Louis Vuitton wallet, forced him to call a friend in Belgium for money, and the friend called Belgian police, who contacted Scotland Yard, then the gang took him by taxi to St Pancras the next morning and returned his passport and phone, the Flying Squad met him there and traced the gang through the Airbnb booking and phone data (replaces 'After torture and threats', a word the article does not use); victim → Quentin Cepeljac, 21, Belgian barber; location → Shepherd's Bush, London; date 5 May 2024 kept, year unverified on file (the article says 'May 5 last year' and the copy on file carries no publication date; the Wayback snapshot is of 26 July 2025); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 (punched and kicked), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (machete and knife), theft stays 1 (£2,000; the wallet's return is not mentioned), life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = online lure (befriended on TikTok and Instagram after his own claim to be a crypto dealer); the verified summary's 'number not recorded' is contradicted by the four named defendants; source notes: the Times subscription notices and the closing teaser not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 370** (DA) — money_wanted → 200 BTC demanded, lowered to 100 BTC, and about US$1.6 million in cryptocurrency transferred (Cryptonews, from the court documents); coin_type → BTC demanded, coin of the transfer not named; description → family held and tortured in their home by four men, two of whom posed as Canada Post staff delivering a parcel, and about US$1.6 million in cryptocurrency taken (the '13 hours' and the '$2M' are the MSN headline, kept in notes as pending source trace); notes → the men demanded access to the father's digital assets, all three were bound with zip ties, the family was beaten, both parents were waterboarded and threatened with mutilation, the daughter was forced to undress, filmed and sexually assaulted by one attacker, and she freed herself, got out and called 911 (Cryptonews); pending source trace on the MSN page, which returned no text: '13 hours' (Cryptonews says 'hàng giờ', hours), '$2M' (body figure about US$1.6 million), the mother's accounts being emptied and the daughter alerting neighbours; date 27 April 2024 kept, the attack ran across 27 and 28 April 2024 ('ngày 27–28/4/2024'); arrests → convicted, one of four: Tsz Wing Boaz Chan pleaded guilty in May (year not stated) to break and enter, unlawful confinement and sexual assault and was sentenced to seven years, and nothing has been released on the other three; reports → MSN (headline only on file), Cryptonews (Vietnamese edition); victim Family kept (father, mother and daughter; the daughter's age is not stated); sequence Authority Misuse → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Home Invasion kept (owner ruling of 2026-09-30, 370 is on its list); weapons stays 1, pending source trace (owner rule of 2026-10-01: record details in no source on file are traced, and the flags they support stay as recorded until the trace succeeds or fails; Cryptonews names no weapon, so the writer's 'unconfirmed' becomes the fallback if the trace fails); kidnappings stays 1 (zip ties), violence_torture stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 0, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; gap: sexual violence has no violence category (as 459); targeting vector = talk in his own community (the prosecutor: he had shared what Bitcoin he held 'trong cộng đồng người gốc Hoa', among people of Chinese origin; 'local' in the verified summary is not in the text); source notes: the Cryptonews round-up tail of other wrench attacks not used; trace the MSN text or the court judgment before green.
|
||||
- **DB id 371** (DA) — money_wanted → US$100 million demanded at first, lowered to US$50 million, then US$20 million, then to an agreed figure that is not disclosed, paid in USDT by his wife ('The kidnappers initially demanded $100 million USD'; the record's '$100 million USDT' mixed the opening demand with the payment currency); coin_type USDT kept (cash converted to USDT and sent to the kidnappers); notes → the bodyguard, who was also his driver, tipped off the kidnappers and was present during the captivity (the record's 'tipped the victim off' reverses it), the victim was hooded, handcuffed and held blindfolded for six days, 12 to 18 December, with stun guns, heated coils and a knife scratched across his chest in the first two days, and by his own words 'there was no real torture' and 'they barely beat me', yet he had two surgeries for burns and for bruises from shackles and handcuffs, his wife withdrew cash under police escort and converted it to USDT at the 9 Dynasty Casino in a Manila hotel, and he had never used crypto before; description → Chinese businessman kidnapped for six days in the Philippines on a tip from his own bodyguard and released after his wife paid a ransom in USDT; victim → Chinese businessman known as 'K', a nickel-mining contractor; location → Philippines, city of the abduction not stated (seized just outside his residential compound, released in a field in Cavite, ransom exchanged in Manila); date 12 December 2022 kept, confirmed ('On the morning of December 12, 2022, around 10 a.m.'); arrests → some: the bodyguard arrested in May (year not stated), the gang's number two, a Filipino aide about six months later, and the couple known as 'Andy Lau' and 'Li Na', all in custody with no verdict when he spoke; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (construction-worker uniforms, owner ruling of 2026-09-30, 371 is on its list), gap: insider as the initiation; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 (burns and shackle wounds needing surgery; the account disagrees with itself on how far the abuse went, both readings in notes), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (knives, stun batons, heated coils), theft stays 1 (ransom paid, sum not disclosed), life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = insider tip-off (his bodyguard, as DEFINITIONS.md lists for 371; the bodyguard judged him wealthy from a truck-launch event in Davao); kept and tagged 'crypto as extraction rail' (no holder targeted, as ruled for 376); single source, the victim's own account in a WuBlockchain podcast that the outlet says 'was transcribed using GPT and may contain inaccuracies', nothing independently reported, allegation framing kept.
|
||||
- **DB id 372** (DA) — location → seized outside 100 Steeles Ave. in Thornhill (the article's opening line says she was bundled into an SUV in Vaughan), held and tortured in the garage of a home in Barrie, Ontario; arrests → convicted, two: the youth S.M. found guilty in 2024 of kidnapping, forcible confinement and failure to comply with bail and awaiting sentence, and Keyron Moore, 39, sentenced on 22 August (year not stated) to 13 years, 10 to serve after credit, for using a firearm to kidnap her, while the man who grabbed her ('Orange Hoodie Guy') 'has yet to be identified by police' and 'It's still unclear who organized or paid for the men'; notes → she escaped through the garage's back door and had a neighbour call 911, a member of the public who ran to help was shot at three times and not hit, Moore, armed, threatened to shoot her if she did not perform fellatio on him, at the garage several young men bashed her feet, hands, thighs and knees, stripped her, put a sock in her mouth, burned her hands with a lighter and her hair, threatened her with a wrench, dug a screwdriver into her and ran along her body a syringe they said held heroin and could kill her, which police later found held fentanyl (replaces 'She escaped and the attackers were caught'); description → a woman was grabbed in Thornhill, driven to a home in Barrie, tied to a chair, stripped naked, hit on the legs with a hammer and burned while the men demanded $1 million in bitcoin; money_wanted → $1 million in bitcoin demanded, nothing paid; coin_type → BTC; date 1 November 2022 kept, confirmed ('It all began on Nov. 1, 2022'); victim A.T. kept (publication ban); drugs_alcohol stays 1, as a threat only (the syringe was drawn along her body 'under the threat of injection' and nothing was administered: drugs used as leverage, as ruled in 170 and applied in 391; the writer's 'unconfirmed' is not taken; DA call, owner may set unconfirmed); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1, weapons stays 1 (firearm, hammer, wrench, screwdriver, lighter), theft stays 0 (she escaped and no payment is reported), life_taken stays 0; gap: sexual coercion has no violence category (as 459); targeting vector unknown (she had become involved in cryptocurrency credit cards and was taken after a meeting about them with a friend; who chose her is not stated); attackers → Moore driving, the unidentified man who grabbed her, S.M. and several young men at the garage, number not stated; source notes: Wayback copy with a paywall marker, may be cut short; the fetched headline differs from the URL slug, same article; the Barrie homeowner 'was given fentanyl in return for the use of his home', which is payment to him and not part of the drugs flag.
|
||||
- **Who was attacked** (owner, 2026-10-07) — family members who were not present were not attacked. A relative counts only when confronted, held, hurt or contacted by the attackers. Applied: **DB id 60** → holder only.
|
||||
- **DB id 218** (owner, 2026-10-07) — outcome → fought off: the attackers fled because her husband shot at them. The verified summary does not state the reason; this rests on the owner's knowledge of the case.
|
||||
|
||||
## Owner decisions, 2026-10-08
|
||||
|
||||
Machine-readable form: step-rulings.json and structural-ops.json.
|
||||
|
||||
- **Rule restated:** a family member who was not present and not in the attackers' custody was not attacked; a relative who only negotiated or paid the ransom does not count. All 93 cases carrying "relative or partner" were re-read by two readers: 81, 195 and 238 lose the label; 86 keeps it (the mother met the gang at her door when they drove her son there), open for the owner.
|
||||
- **DB id 58** (owner) — she was killed: life_taken → 1, outcome stays killed.
|
||||
- **DB id 468** (owner) — outcome → killed, life_taken stays 1.
|
||||
- **DB id 222** (owner) — accepted: attack Armed Robbery, outcome fought off.
|
||||
- **DB id 231** (owner) — keep the three Chinese citizens as the attackers; no rewrite.
|
||||
- **DB id 233** (owner) — accepted: weapons → 0 (knife in the car, never shown to the victims), date stays 18 May 2025; the same weapons answer for 421, 426 and 472.
|
||||
- **DB id 235** (owner) — do not transcribe the video; the record stays as it is.
|
||||
- **DB id 248** (owner) — accepted: carry both accounts of the entry, remove the notes that come from the Suresnes article, rewrite the summary from the Oslo sources.
|
||||
- **DB id 285** (owner) — Theft by deception; the case stays.
|
||||
- **DB id 315** (owner) — accepted: date → 3 October 2023; one record, the second home in notes.
|
||||
- **DB id 365** (owner) — accepted: merged into 323 and removed; 323 dated November 2024.
|
||||
- **DB id 368** (owner) — drugs_alcohol → unconfirmed.
|
||||
- Still with the owner: 246, 299, 307 (details requested).
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user