Archived
chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1,253 @@
|
||||
====================================================================================================
|
||||
LOPP L133 | A USDT seller | July 7, 2023 | Taiwan
|
||||
====================================================================================================
|
||||
|
||||
STATUS new
|
||||
|
||||
PROPOSED RECORD [new case from Lopp's list, PR 234; read by two readers; flags and obtained re-read 2026-10-17 under the owner's definitions (empty = unknown); no operator has reviewed it; no stats2 id yet]
|
||||
date July 7, 2023
|
||||
victim A USDT seller
|
||||
location Sanchong, New Taipei
|
||||
country Taiwan
|
||||
description A USDT seller who came to a fake purchase of 95,000 USDT in New Taipei was locked in the robbers' car, choked and pinned down while they took the phone holding the wallet; the seller refused the passcode and escaped. Three men were sentenced to 7 years 1 month to 7 years 4 months.
|
||||
detention yes
|
||||
violence_torture yes
|
||||
drugs_alcohol (unknown)
|
||||
weapons no
|
||||
theft yes
|
||||
life_taken 0
|
||||
venue_of_control attacker's or third-party space
|
||||
held_duration minutes
|
||||
arrests convicted
|
||||
demanded the phone's unlock passcode, to move the USDT; the fake trade was 95,000 USDT for TWD 3,035,250
|
||||
taken the seller's iPhone 12, sold by one robber the next day for TWD 8,500 and later returned; no USDT moved
|
||||
notes Single source: the New Taipei District Court first-instance judgment of 27 February 2025, primary record. All parties are anonymised in the body (丙 乙 丁 defendants, 戊 complainant); the caption names 曾博鴻, 郭晉宏 and 謝守政 but does not map them to the codes, so no one is named in the summary. Weapons no: the baseball bat stayed in the boot and was never shown to the seller, as the rulings on 72 and 233 (the court's 'carrying a weapon' conviction rests on the bat being within reach). Attack Robbery without a weapon: theft by force with no weapon shown, brief holding in a parked car, not taken away. Venue: the robbers' car, stationary, so attacker's or third-party space. Outcome Escaped: the seller unlocked the door and jumped out; the robbers then fled. Targeting Online contact or advert: 「C」 first contacted the seller on Telegram; the judgment does not say how 「C」 found the seller. Targeting accuracy Unknown: the court could not establish any USDT in the phone. Theft yes: the phone was taken and sold, though later returned (assets later recovered still count). Location: the planned spot was Carrefour Sanchong Ren'ai 2 and the case went to the Sanchong precinct; the final meeting street is redacted. Pepper spray and a knife were ordered by 「奇異博士」; the judgment does not say they were brought. No appeal judgment fetched.
|
||||
|
||||
CHANGES OF 2026-10-17
|
||||
drugs_alcohol: no -> (empty)
|
||||
re-read note: Weapons no by the 72/233 precedent: the baseball bat stayed in the trunk and was never shown; the court still convicted two defendants of robbery carrying a weapon. The strangling was done by hand, so it is violence and not a weapon. The phone was sold the next day and later returned to the victim.
|
||||
|
||||
FOUR-STEP LABELS
|
||||
targeting Online contact or advert
|
||||
targeting_accuracy Unknown
|
||||
who_was_attacked Holder
|
||||
approach P2P trade
|
||||
attack Robbery without a weapon
|
||||
outcome Escaped
|
||||
obtained Devices or seed
|
||||
|
||||
PEOPLE ATTACKED
|
||||
Holder: 1 (the USDT seller who got into the robbers' car)
|
||||
|
||||
PUBLIC SUMMARY [plain English, the text the site shows]
|
||||
On July 7, 2023, a Telegram user called "C" contacted a USDT seller in New Taipei, offering TWD
|
||||
3,035,250 for 95,000 USDT, and set the trade for 22:50 near a Carrefour in Sanchong. A second
|
||||
organiser, "Doctor Strange", had one man recruit two others. When the seller got into the back of
|
||||
the car to trade, the driver locked the doors and asked to see the phone holding the USDT. As it
|
||||
came out, the man in the back seat choked the seller and the driver dropped his seat back to pin the
|
||||
seller down, took the phone and demanded the passcode. The seller refused, unlocked the door and
|
||||
jumped out after 3 to 5 minutes, with grazes to the wrist and knee. The robbers fled, and one of
|
||||
them sold the phone the next day; they got no USDT. On February 27, 2025, the New Taipei District
|
||||
Court sentenced the three to 7 years 1 month to 7 years 4 months for aggravated robbery.
|
||||
|
||||
CASE DETAILS [internal evidence record, quotations in the original language]
|
||||
**Victims:** The complainant 戊○○, anonymised in the judgment, who came alone at night to trade
|
||||
virtual currency ("告訴人於天色已黑之夜晚,為從事虛擬貨幣交易,經被告丙○○之要求而單獨1人進入本案自小客車"). The judgment does not give a name
|
||||
or sex.
|
||||
**Attackers:** 丙○○, who plotted with Telegram users 「C」 and 「奇異博士」 (Doctor Strange); 乙○○, recruited
|
||||
by 丙○○; 丁○○, recruited by 乙○○. The caption names the defendants 曾博鴻, 郭晉宏 and 謝守政 without tying them
|
||||
to the codes. 丁○○ said he came only to collect a debt from 乙○○ and did not know of a plan to rob;
|
||||
the court found he shared the intent to rob ("足認其與丙○○、乙○○就結夥三人以上強盜部分確有犯意聯絡及行為分擔").
|
||||
**Attack Method:** On 7 July 2023 「C」 contacted the seller on Telegram offering TWD 3,035,250 for
|
||||
95,000 USDT, to trade at 22:50 outside Carrefour Sanchong Ren'ai 2 (家樂福三重仁愛二店). 「奇異博士」 told 丙○○ to
|
||||
find accomplices and to prepare pepper spray and a small knife; 乙○○ left a machete at 丁○○'s shop and
|
||||
kept a baseball bat in the car's boot. To avoid CCTV the meeting was moved to another street
|
||||
(address redacted). The seller got into the left rear seat; 丙○○, driving, locked the doors and asked
|
||||
to see the phone holding the USDT. The plan from 「奇異博士」 was to grab the phone, control the victim's
|
||||
hands, beat the victim and force out the passcode.
|
||||
**Violence Used:** Detention: locked in the robbers' parked car for 3 to 5 minutes by the seller's
|
||||
own account ("在車上的時間應該有3至5分鐘"). 丁○○ choked the seller with his left arm and 丙○○ dropped the seat
|
||||
back to pin the seller down, while demanding the phone's unlock code. The seller kept the screen
|
||||
locked, refused the code, unlocked the door and jumped out, suffering grazes to the left wrist and
|
||||
left knee and pain in the left shoulder. The bat stayed in the boot and was never taken out
|
||||
("雖未將棒球棍自後車廂取出使用"); the court still convicted 丙○○ and 乙○○ of robbery while carrying a weapon, and
|
||||
丁○○, who was not shown to know of the bat, of robbery by three or more.
|
||||
**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** The target was the USDT in the phone (the trade amount 95,000 USDT); the
|
||||
passcode was demanded. Only the phone was taken. The seller testified that a blue phone was taken
|
||||
and a green one left behind; the court found the phone taken was the green iPhone 12 and put the
|
||||
difference down to memory. 丙○○ sold it the next day at a 3C shop for TWD 8,500, and the phones were
|
||||
later returned to the seller. The seller said 59,470 USDT were in the phone and lost when it was
|
||||
reset; the court did not accept this: the seller had told police another phone also held USDT, and
|
||||
the exchange (現代財富科技) showed no transactions or withdrawals on 7 July 2023
|
||||
("自難認定本案手機內泰達幣遭被告3人轉出之事實").
|
||||
**Status:** The seller reported to the Sanchong precinct; police traced and arrested the three. New
|
||||
Taipei District Court judgment of 27 February 2025 (113 年度訴字第 362 號): 丙○○ 7 years 2 months and 乙○○ 7
|
||||
years 1 month for aggravated robbery by three or more carrying a weapon; 丁○○ 7 years 4 months for
|
||||
aggravated robbery by three or more. The TWD 8,500 and the bat confiscated. 「C」 and 「奇異博士」
|
||||
unidentified.
|
||||
|
||||
OPEN QUESTIONS FOR THE OWNER
|
||||
(none)
|
||||
|
||||
SECOND READER
|
||||
rewritten after the second reader: summary: cut to about 870 characters (dropped the bat in the
|
||||
boot, the sale price and the police tracing)
|
||||
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: removed 'Open to appeal to the Taiwan High Court'
|
||||
(it rested on the cut appeal notice, paragraphs 83-86)
|
||||
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: 丁○○'s debt defence is now answered with the kept
|
||||
finding in paragraph 61, since the paragraph that rejects the debt story (63) is not kept
|
||||
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: added the blue/green phone discrepancy from kept
|
||||
paragraph 44, as the reader suggested
|
||||
|
||||
LOPP'S ENTRY
|
||||
July 7 2023 | Chien Huan-ju | New Taipei, Taiwan
|
||||
A Telegram organizer nicknamed 'Doctor Strange' recruited two accomplices for a fake purchase of
|
||||
95,000 USDT (~TWD 3,035,250) in Sanchong; the seller was locked in the car, choked and immobilized,
|
||||
and her iPhone containing the wallet torn away. She refused to give the passcode and escaped with
|
||||
wounds to wrist and knee; the phone was resold the next day for TWD 8,500.
|
||||
differs: Lopp: victim 'Chien Huan-ju' and 'her iPhone'; the judgment anonymises the complainant as 戊○○ and gives neither name nor sex.
|
||||
differs: Lopp: 'her iPhone containing the wallet'; the court found it not established that the phone held USDT.
|
||||
differs: Lopp: the seller 'escaped with wounds to wrist and knee'; the judgment adds pain in the left shoulder.
|
||||
|
||||
LINKED SOURCES
|
||||
1. https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=PCDM%2C113%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C362%2C20250227%2C1
|
||||
|
||||
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||||
FETCHED ARTICLE 1
|
||||
Source judgment.judicial.gov.tw
|
||||
URL https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=PCDM%2C113%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C362%2C20250227%2C1
|
||||
Published (not given)
|
||||
Retrieved 2026-10-16T14:29:31Z via raw HTTP retrieval (status 200); page furniture cut by paragraph range (kept 2, 6, 9, 12, 16-19, 21-22, 29-32, 34, 37-39, 43-50, 54-55, 57-58, 61-62, 66-68, 71-72, 74, 78, 99-107, 126-142 of 161), article text unchanged
|
||||
Language as published (kept in the original language, not translated)
|
||||
Length 10,843 chars
|
||||
Integrity sha256 69f20714314fa8baa18b5d9732a1224d4ed0dad73e360ccd3ca015c17a77c724
|
||||
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||||
臺灣新北地方法院 113 年度訴字第 362 號刑事判決
|
||||
|
||||
被 告 曾博鴻
|
||||
|
||||
被 告 郭晉宏
|
||||
|
||||
被 告 謝守政
|
||||
|
||||
丙○○犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜罪,處有期徒刑柒年貳月。
|
||||
|
||||
乙○○犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜罪,處有期徒刑柒年壹月。
|
||||
|
||||
丁○○犯結夥三人以上強盜罪,處有期徒刑柒年肆月。
|
||||
|
||||
扣案如附表編號1、2、4至6所示之物均沒收;未扣案丙○○之犯罪所得新臺幣捌仟伍佰元沒收,於全部或一部不能沒收或不宜執行沒收時,追徵其價額。
|
||||
|
||||
一、丙○○與通訊軟體TELEGRAM(下稱飛機)暱稱「C」、「奇異博士」之人於民國112年7月7日前某日共謀以假買賣、真強取虛擬貨幣之方式強盜第三人,「C」於112年7月7日某時許,以飛機聯繫戊○○佯稱欲以新臺幣(下同)303萬5,250元交易9萬5,000顆泰達幣,雙方約定於同日22時50分許,在新北市○○區○○街00號即家樂福三重仁愛二店前進行交易。「奇異博士」指示丙○○另覓共犯以利實行控制戊○○人身自由以強取其手機與存放其內之泰達幣之計劃。丙○○遂先覓得乙○○,再由乙○○覓得丁○○一同為之。嗣「奇異博士」指示丙○○準備辣椒水、小刀等物,丙○○、乙○○即超出原先三人議定之結夥三人強盜之犯罪計畫,提升其等犯意至結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜之犯意聯絡,由乙○○攜帶足供兇器使用之如附表編號2所示棒球棍,並置入車牌號碼000-0000號之自用小客車(下稱本案自小客車)後車廂內,由丙○○駕駛本案自小客車搭載乙○○(坐於副駕駛座)、丁○○(坐於右後方)抵達家樂福三重仁愛二店等候,嗣因「C」為避免強盜過程遭監視器拍攝,乃向戊○○表示交易地點改至新北市○○區○○街00號前。戊○○到場後,丙○○向戊○○表示需至本案自小客車內交易,戊○○自左後車門上車後,丙○○即將車門上鎖,並向戊○○假藉須檢視泰達幣數量是否足夠為由,要求戊○○提供存有虛擬貨幣之手機以供檢視,待戊○○取出如附表編號7所示之綠色iPhone手機(下稱本案手機)時,丁○○旋以其左手勒住戊○○脖子,丙○○同時將椅背放倒以壓制戊○○之活動空間,以上開強暴手段,至使戊○○不能抗拒,而由丙○○強取本案手機得手,並隨即轉交由乙○○持有,且持續逼問戊○○本案手機螢幕解鎖密碼,以利其等將戊○○本案手機內電子錢包之泰達幣轉入自身掌控之電子錢包,然因戊○○拒不告知密碼,且循機開啟車鎖、車門而逃下車,並因而受有左側腕部擦傷、左側膝部擦傷、左側肩膀疼痛之傷害,乙○○旋即駕車搭載丙○○、丁○○逃逸,丙○○、乙○○、丁○○因而僅取得本案手機,而未能順利奪得泰達幣。丙○○則於翌日即112年7月8日將本案手機攜至址設新北市○○區○○路0段000號之「I.W House 3C shop」店變賣,並獲得價金8,500元。嗣因戊○○報警處理,經警方循線拘提丙○○、乙○○、丁○○,並經其等同意搜索而扣得如附表所示之物。
|
||||
|
||||
二、案經戊○○訴由新北市政府警察局三重分局報告臺灣新北地方檢察署檢察官偵查起訴。
|
||||
|
||||
一、訊據被告丙○○、乙○○固坦承上開客觀事實,惟否認所為構成結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜罪;被告丁○○固坦承丙○○、郭守政為交易虛擬貨幣委請其陪同在場,其在車上有勒住告訴人脖子等事實,惟否認結夥三人以上強盜取財犯行,被告3人及其等辯護人分別以下列言詞置辯:
|
||||
|
||||
㈠被告丙○○辯稱:我認為我的行為是構成結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜取財未遂罪,因為我沒有拿到虛擬貨幣,所取得之本案手機係告訴人所交付等語;其辯護人則以:本案丙○○不法所有意圖在於取得泰達幣,但最終並未取得任何泰達幣,此部分應認僅構成未遂,就手機部分而言,係丙○○發現自己之手機被告訴人拿走後,基於補償心態而變賣,此部分丙○○應構成侵占罪;丙○○為本案犯行時,尚將開山刀放置在丁○○店內,應無攜帶兇器犯案之故意等語為被告丙○○置辯。
|
||||
|
||||
㈡被告乙○○辯稱:我認為我的行為是構成搶奪未遂罪,因為並未達至使告訴人不能抗拒之程度,也未拿到虛擬貨幣,手機部分是告訴人自己交給丙○○,針對手機我沒有不法所有意圖等語;其辯護人則以:卷內事證不足證明告訴人受有泰達幣損失,且告訴人得自行開門下車,並未達至使不能抗拒之程度;變賣手機為丙○○一人所為,與乙○○無關等語為被告乙○○置辯。
|
||||
|
||||
㈢被告丁○○辯稱:我是為了拿回乙○○積欠之欠款而陪同前往,並不知悉丙○○、乙○○有搶奪之意圖,在車上勒住告訴人脖子是因為看到被害人手往後伸,主觀上以為告訴人要拿武器,當時我坐在他旁邊覺得自己受到威脅,所以才有上開行為等語;其辯護人則以:丁○○係因乙○○要求而陪同丙○○、乙○○前往,乙○○告知不陪同則不償還欠款,丁○○在車上時丙○○、乙○○均未告訴丁○○應如何遂行本案強盜犯行,丁○○主觀上並無強盜犯意,且亦不知悉車上放有棒球棍,請為無罪之諭知等語為被告丁○○置辯。
|
||||
|
||||
㈠本案係告訴人與「C」約定於112年7月7日22時50分許在新北市○○區○○街00號交易泰達幣,由丙○○依「奇異博士」指示,覓得乙○○,再由乙○○邀約丁○○於上開時地與告訴人交易泰達幣,被告3人到場後,「奇異博士」又於群組指示丙○○找尋無監視器之處所進行交易,遂將地點更改至新北市○○區○○街00號。告訴人到場後,丙○○稱須在本案自小客車上進行交易,告訴人乃進入本案自小客車左後座,坐在駕駛座之丙○○旋將車門上鎖,並要求告訴人提出手機以利檢視是否有足夠泰達幣進行交易,而丁○○則於告訴人取出本案手機時以左手勒住告訴人脖子,丙○○亦同時將椅背放倒以壓制告訴人。丙○○取得本案手機後即將之交予坐在副駕駛座之乙○○,並逼問告訴人手機解鎖密碼,嗣告訴人趁隙逃離而受有左側腕部擦傷、左側膝部擦傷、左側肩膀疼痛之傷害等情,為被告3人所不爭執,且據證人即告訴人於本院審理時證述在卷(見本院卷第316至335頁),並有新北市政府警察局三重分局112年7月9日搜索扣押筆錄暨所附扣押物品目錄表(見偵一卷第85至89、115至119頁)、被告與「奇異博士」之飛機對話紀錄(見偵一卷第150至154頁)、監視器畫面擷圖(見偵一卷第141至144頁)、本案自小客車內扣案物品照片(見偵一卷第144至149頁)、新北市立聯合醫院112年7月8日乙種診斷書(見偵一卷第155頁)、本案自小客車及BPK-0170號車輛詳細資料報表(見偵一卷第159至161頁)、新北市政府警察局三重分局Cellebrite擷取報告-丙○○(暱稱「江鴻」)及乙○○(暱稱「直」)之對話紀錄(見偵二卷第5至65頁)、新北市政府警察局三重分局刑案現場勘查報告所附新北市政府警察局112年8月21日新北警鑑字第1121636096號鑑驗書、內政部警政署刑事警察局112年8月2日刑紋字第1126004333號鑑定書(見偵二卷第83至112頁)、丁○○提供與乙○○之LINE對話紀錄(見本院卷第183至185頁)在卷可稽,此部分事實首堪認定。
|
||||
|
||||
⒉被告3人為不法強取告訴人之財物,由丙○○將車門上鎖,於告訴人取出手機時,隨即將手機奪去,並把駕駛座椅背放下以便控制告訴人,且多次質問告訴人解鎖密碼,丙○○為監看告訴人,遂將手機交給乙○○,以確保告訴人無其餘反抗動作,於上開過程中均由丁○○壓制告訴人頸部等事實,業據證人即告訴人於本院審理時證稱:駕駛(即丙○○)問我有無帶虛擬貨幣,叫我打開手機內虛擬貨幣帳號給他看時,他就將手機拿走,他將我手機快速搶走時,後面有1人(即丁○○)用手勒住我脖子,我無法拿回手機,駕駛要我將密碼解開,手機被駕駛拿走後,有交給副駕駛座的人(即乙○○),我先把車門門鎖打開後,才把車門打開,並且跳下車,在車上的時間應該有3至5分鐘等語明確(見本院卷第319至324、331頁);核與證人即共同被告丙○○於審理時證稱:「奇異博士」指示我把告訴人接上車後,確定手機內泰達幣餘額,確認後就把手機搶過來,當告訴人上車後,我先鎖住車門,和告訴人發生拉扯時,有把椅背放下想壓制告訴人,我們有講好當告訴人一上車,丁○○要控制告訴人,於是丁○○就勒住告訴人脖子,為了確保告訴人沒有做其他動作,把手機交給乙○○由我看著告訴人等語(見本院卷第298、302、304至305、309頁)、被告乙○○於準備程序時供稱:告訴人和丙○○一起上車,丙○○說要交易,先看手機裡泰達幣的資料,丙○○確認後就把椅背放下來,押著告訴人,我印象中丁○○有抓告訴人等語(見本院卷第137頁)、被告丁○○於準備程序與審理時供稱:告訴人上車坐在我旁邊,看到丙○○與告訴人對話,後來發生衝突,我有看到丙○○伸手拉扯告訴人,我有去拉告訴人的手,在車上有勒住告訴人脖子等語(見本院卷第83、361頁)相符,上開事實,堪以認定屬實。
|
||||
|
||||
⒊綜上可知,告訴人於天色已黑之夜晚,為從事虛擬貨幣交易,經被告丙○○之要求而單獨1人進入本案自小客車,此前其並不知悉車內另有被告乙○○、丁○○,而其甫進入車內,丙○○即將車門上鎖,復藉端發生衝突並拉下椅背,欲壓制其行動,丁○○亦從旁勒住其脖子已制止其欲奪回手機之行為舉措,衡以告訴人斯時人單力薄,又身處狹窄密閉空間,被告3人具有明顯人數、體型之優勢,復又遭丁○○強勒脖子,脖子屬人身要害部位,其在受此等壓制之過程中,丙○○仍一再要求其說出手機解鎖密碼,堪信一般人處於同一情境下,均認為被告3人隨時可能對自己之生命、身體安全造成重大危害,身心必處於極為恐懼、害怕不安之狀態,足認被告3人於案發當時所為之強暴行為客觀上顯足使人達於不能抗拒之程度甚明。
|
||||
|
||||
⒋被告乙○○及其辯護人雖辯稱:告訴人尚能自行逃脫,顯見並未達不能抗拒程度等語,然判斷告訴人是否達不能抗拒之程度,揆諸上開說明,應以一般人之心理狀態為標準,且不以實際上有無抗拒行為為依據,而一般人處於上開情境,足堪認定已達於不能抗拒之程度,業如前述,縱告訴人係自行打開車門門鎖進而逃離本案自小客車,僅屬告訴人為求防衛生命或防護財產等自保之本能反應,自不能據此認定被告3人所為強暴行為尚未達於至使告訴人不能抗拒之程度,被告乙○○及其辯護人上開辯詞即不可採。
|
||||
|
||||
⑴告訴人於警詢時證稱:駕駛(即丙○○)叫我打開手機確認虛擬貨幣後,與副駕駛(即乙○○)將我手機搶走等語(見偵一卷第66頁);於偵查中證稱:我下車前拿了1支手機,發現是對方的等語(見偵一卷第270頁),核與證人即共同被告丙○○於審理時證稱:我跟告訴人說要確認他手機有無泰達幣,他從口袋拿出本案手機,我可以從外觀辨認手機型號,取得手機交給乙○○後,有逼問他手機解鎖密碼,看到告訴人打開車門下車時,原本想將本案手機丟回去,卻丟成自己放在大腿上如附表編號6所示之手機等語(見本院卷第306、309頁);被告乙○○於準備程序供稱:丙○○跟告訴人說要交易,需先看手機內泰達幣資料,告訴人手機交給丙○○後就沒有還給他,告訴人下車時,我叫丙○○把手機丟給他,但是丙○○丟成自己的手機等語(見本院卷第137頁)相符,從上開證述可知,告訴人上車後因丙○○要求告訴人查看有無足夠虛擬貨幣以供交易,告訴人取出本案手機時,旋遭丙○○奪取並交予乙○○,且告訴人趁隙逃下車前並未拿回本案手機之事實,堪以認定。
|
||||
|
||||
⑵告訴人雖於本院審理時證稱:手機型號已經忘記,我被取走的手機是藍色的(即如附表編號8所示),掉在車上是綠色的(即本案手機),下車前有從副駕駛座的人(即乙○○)手上把藍色手機拿回來,藍色手機內沒有虛擬貨幣等語(見本院卷第330、333、335頁),然告訴人取出手機既係為供丙○○確認其內泰達幣之數額,理應係取出存有泰達幣之手機方屬合理,從而,告訴人證稱係取出藍色手機供被告3人檢視,是否合於事實,已非無疑;且告訴人趁隙逃下車時,丙○○誤將如附表編號6所示、由丙○○所有之手機丟出,業據證人即共同被告丙○○、乙○○證述明確,且互核相符,應可信實,且告訴人斯時既受椅背壓制,復受丁○○勒脖,實難想見其如何趨身向前並搶回位在副駕駛座之乙○○手中之手機,衡以本案距離審理時已事隔甚久,此部分容屬告訴人就細節部分所生之記憶瑕疵,仍應認本案被告3人強盜所得財物應為如附表編號7所示之本案手機,附此敘明。
|
||||
|
||||
⒊本案被告3人謀議強盜之財物係告訴人手機內存放之泰達幣一節,此據被告丙○○、乙○○坦承在卷(見本院卷第367至368頁),而虛擬貨幣並非實際存在之物,須借助載體存續,例如存放在冷錢包或交易所APP內,從而,如欲取得泰達幣,必先取得告訴人之手機後,方能操作其手機將泰達幣轉出。復觀諸丙○○與「奇異博士」之對話內容略以:「奇異博士」指示丙○○人手需3位,確認後應加入同一群組;丙○○於建立「錢(圖案)」群組,將「奇異博士」邀進群組後,「奇異博士」旋指示丙○○準備辣椒水、小刀、小隻八打等物,並交代強盜流程為待告訴人到指定地點後要求其進入車內點鈔,核對手機,在告訴人拿手機出來時,立刻搶走手機,並控制告訴人,一定要控制雙手,開始毆打告訴人,拿走手機之目的在於避免告訴人掛線,並要求務必讓告訴人說出密碼解鎖手機,有被告與「奇異博士」之飛機對話紀錄(見偵一卷第150至154頁)在卷可佐。從上開對話訊息可知,本案之強盜計畫為丙○○要求告訴人進入本案自小客車交易時,須提供內有存放泰達幣之手機供丙○○檢視,此時由丙○○找尋之人手須立即控制告訴人,將本案手機納入被告3人實力支配下,並逼迫告訴人提供本案手機解鎖密碼,從而,能否取得本案手機即屬本案強盜計畫不可或缺之一環,應認本案強盜所欲取得之財物本即包含手機與泰達幣。而本案即照「奇異博士」指示之上開流程進行,由被告3人分工合作控制告訴人及取走本案手機,顯係被告3人避免告訴人利用手機求救及便於後續操作手機轉出泰達幣,則自被告丙○○強奪告訴人之本案手機並將本案手機交由乙○○掌控時,客觀上告訴人對手機已喪失控制權,此時告訴人遭搶走之手機已處於被告3人持有並隨時可攜離之狀態,而在被告3人實力支配下,所為已屬既遂。
|
||||
|
||||
⒋況被告丙○○事後即將本案手機拿至通訊行變賣並獲取價金8,500元,業據被告丙○○坦承在卷(見本院卷第310頁),並有新北市政府警察局三重分局112年7月9日搜索扣押筆錄暨所附扣押物品目錄表(見偵一卷第115至119頁)、手機收購同意書(見偵一卷第125頁)在卷可憑,益徵被告3人於取得手機後自居為所有人地位將其變賣,足認本案已達既遂之程度。
|
||||
|
||||
⒌本案尚難認定被告3人已取得告訴人本案手機內泰達幣:
|
||||
|
||||
⑴公訴意旨雖認被告3人控制告訴人並搶走告訴人本案手機,脅迫告訴人告知手機密碼並將告訴人手機內泰達幣轉出等語。惟查,證人即告訴人於本院審理時證稱:我把螢幕鎖起來後並沒有說出手機解鎖密碼等語(見本院卷第321頁),核與被告丙○○、乙○○於準備程序、審理時之供述相符(見本院卷第137、211頁),是告訴人既已將手機螢幕關閉,亦未因丙○○逼問而告知密碼,被告3人自無可能操作本案手機轉出泰達幣。
|
||||
|
||||
⑵再者,證人即告訴人於偵查及審理時證稱:我手機內放有5萬9,470顆泰達幣,只有本案手機內有虛擬貨幣,我只有一個電子錢包,手機因為被重置,無法登入錢包確認泰達幣下落,我的損失就是上開數量之泰達幣等語(見偵一卷第270至271頁、本院卷第328至330、334頁),可知告訴人因迄今無法登入電子錢包,而認遭被告3人強盜5萬9,470顆泰達幣,惟證人即告訴人於警詢時亦證稱:我另一支手機也存有泰達幣等語(見偵一卷第73頁),則告訴人證稱僅有本案手機內存放泰達幣一節,供述前後顯有歧異,已難據此認定本案手機內確存有泰達幣,且告訴人之虛擬貨幣帳戶於112年7月7日並無任何交易紀錄或提領紀錄一節,有現代財富科技有限公司112年11月16日現代財富法字第112111602號函及所附帳戶資料(見偵二卷第139至147頁)在卷可參,自難認定本案手機內泰達幣遭被告3人轉出之事實,又本案手機如係重置設定,僅為告訴人無從登入帳戶檢視,亦不能據此推論被告3人取得5萬9,470顆泰達幣。基此,自難單憑證人即告訴人上開證述,逕予認定被告3人已取得泰達幣。
|
||||
|
||||
⑶惟本案被告3人意在取得手機後,再透過手機取得存放其內之泰達幣,已如前述,是被告3人縱未取得泰達幣,但並不影響其等施用強暴手段進而取得本案手機之強盜既遂犯行之成立,是否取得泰達幣毋寧僅係強盜所得財物多寡之問題,自不得以被告3人並未取得泰達幣,逕認本案未達既遂,被告丙○○、乙○○與其等辯護人以上詞置辯,即非可採。
|
||||
|
||||
⒊丙○○、乙○○均知悉本案自小客車後車廂內原有棒球棍1支、開山刀1把,於丙○○搭載被告乙○○、再前往搭載丁○○時,乙○○僅將開山刀自後車廂取出,並放在丁○○店內,然棒球棍仍放置在後車廂內等情,業據被告丙○○、乙○○坦承在卷(見本院卷第301至302、311、341、359頁),核與被告丁○○於審理時供稱:我有看見乙○○將開山刀放在我這邊等語(見本院卷第362頁)相符,堪認被告丙○○、乙○○均知後車廂放有棒球棍1支之事實。參諸棒球棍屬質地堅硬之物,若持以朝人體強力攻擊,客觀上足以對人之生命、身體及安全構成危害,並使人失去反抗能力,核屬具有危險性之兇器,則被告丙○○、乙○○雖未將棒球棍自後車廂取出使用,但於本案犯行時既已將之放置在屬其等觸手可及範圍之後車廂內,隨時可取之用以行兇,揆諸上開說明,此部分當屬攜帶兇器無訛,被告丙○○及辯護人以開山刀放置在丁○○店內,並無攜帶兇器故意等語置辯,即難認有據。
|
||||
|
||||
⒋關於被告丁○○是否知悉後車廂內放有棒球棍一節,依憑上開供述內容,固可認定被告丁○○知悉後車廂內原放有開山刀,但參諸證人即共同被告丙○○於審理時證稱:在車上沒有人提到後車廂有棒球棍等語(見本院卷第302頁),核與證人即告訴人於審理時證稱:在車上沒有人提到後車廂有棒球棍等語(見本院卷第325頁)相符,是被告丁○○之認知範圍僅為開山刀從本案自小客車移置在其店內,其是否知悉後車廂內尚放有棒球棍,已有疑問,且卷內並無其他積極證據證明丁○○知悉上情,則被告丙○○、乙○○另行提升犯意至攜帶兇器強盜之情節,已逾越與被告丁○○原先議定之結夥三人以上強盜犯罪計劃,難認屬被告丁○○可預見之範圍,自不能令被告丁○○遽負此部分罪責。
|
||||
|
||||
⒈被告丙○○於偵查及準備程序均供稱:乙○○知悉我與「奇異博士」共謀強盜,我邀約他也是為了犯本案強盜犯行一事等語(見偵卷第281頁、本院卷第211頁),觀諸2人對話紀錄內容所示:於112年7月3日3時59分許,丙○○傳送「有份工作可以參考」,乙○○回問報酬是否有5或100,丙○○回以「做了才知道」,乙○○便詢問是否需事先準備東西;於112年7月7日14時31分許,丙○○向乙○○索要飛機資訊,乙○○將「@wwe63、暱稱鍾離雨」回傳給丙○○;於同日21時20分許,乙○○傳送「我沒帶到辣椒水、等等我開山放他車上、已被我們撤的時候人家追」等訊息給丙○○,丙○○回以「正在問」;於112年7月8日15時49分許乙○○傳送「他們昨天的處理了嗎」,丙○○回以「聯繫方式不是在你那裡嗎」,乙○○則回覆「昨天到現在都沒密我」,丙○○要求乙○○繼續追蹤;於同日18時24分許,乙○○傳送「問他說車馬費嗎」,丙○○回以「你說手機跟車子」;於同日18時53分許,丙○○傳送「等一下來載我去處理手機的問題」;於同日19時21分許,乙○○回「好」,有新北市政府警察局三重分局Cellebrite擷取報告-丙○○(暱稱「江鴻」)及乙○○(暱稱「直」)之對話紀錄(見偵二卷第10、14、45至46、55至57、60至64頁)在卷可查。從上開對話訊息內容可見,乙○○與丙○○於案發前已討論需事先準備何物與報酬計算方式,案發後亦一同商討應如何獲取報酬及如何處理手機等問題,從上開內容足堪認定乙○○知悉當日係為強盜告訴人手機跟泰達幣而為本案行為。
|
||||
|
||||
⒊復觀諸丙○○與「奇異博士」飛機對話紀錄略以:被告建立「錢(圖案)」群組,將「奇異博士」邀進群組後,先詢問「奇異博士」強盜流程,「奇異博士」要求丙○○將本案共犯加入群組,丙○○回以另一人並無飛機,會統一說明情形,並詢問本次交易地點;「奇異博士」於案發前確認丙○○是否已抵達指定地點及確認現場情形,丙○○回以已到達指定地點;於22時33分許,「奇異博士」告知泰達幣是9萬5,000顆,現金是302萬6,500元及告訴人車牌號碼;於22時55分許,「奇異博士」詢問現在狀況如何,暱稱「鍾離雨」即回稱「手機在對方哪、掛掉、速度」(見偵一卷第151至153頁)。綜合上開對話紀錄內容可知,乙○○即為飛機暱稱「鍾離雨」之人,其加入丙○○建立之群組後,亦可透過「奇異博士」所傳送之訊息知悉本案犯罪流程為丙○○以車內放置現金及點鈔機為由,待告訴人上車後,由丙○○、丁○○分工合作,將告訴人壓制後取得手機並逼問手機密碼,在告訴人趁隙掙脫逃下車且取得丙○○之手機時,乙○○立即傳送訊息告知「奇異博士」須掛掉電話,並於案發後隔日與丙○○一同討論如何處理與「奇異博士」間之車馬費以及手機事宜,亦徵乙○○知悉丙○○不僅須控制告訴人、取得手機後應繼續取得泰達幣,況丙○○取得手機後亦有轉交與乙○○,使丙○○得繼續控制告訴人,業如上述,足見被告乙○○對手機亦具有不法所有意圖,且主觀上亦具備結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜犯意,而與丙○○有犯意聯絡及行為分擔,被告乙○○與其辯護人以上詞置辯,顯係卸責之詞,不足採信。
|
||||
|
||||
⒉被告丁○○於偵訊及審理時供稱:當丙○○與告訴人發生口角爭執並拉扯,我離告訴人最近,有抓住告訴人的手、壓制告訴人,我有勒告訴人脖子等語(見偵一卷第229、361頁),核與證人即告訴人證述取出手機時便遭丁○○同時勒住脖子之情節相符(見本院卷第321、331頁),並與證人即共同被告丙○○於偵查中證稱:出發前有講好,丁○○要在告訴人拿手機時動手等語(見偵一卷第285頁);於本院審理時證稱:我們有講好當告訴人一上車,丁○○就要控制住告訴人,後來丁○○就勒住告訴人脖子等語(見本院卷第305頁);被告乙○○於準備程序時供稱:我有跟丁○○說要搶告訴人手機內虛擬幣等語(見本院卷第137頁)相符,綜上可知,丙○○與乙○○已告知丁○○應在告訴人進入車內後進行控制,丁○○即以勒住告訴人脖子之行為對其進行控制,並由丙○○對告訴人逼問手機解鎖密碼,足認其與丙○○、乙○○就結夥三人以上強盜部分確有犯意聯絡及行為分擔。
|
||||
|
||||
⒊被告丁○○雖辯稱:因交易虛擬貨幣有很多現金,乙○○遂要求其陪同進行交易,當時看到告訴人手往後伸,才有壓制告訴人之動作等語,然其於準備程序時及審理時供稱:我上車後就在車上滑手機、打電動,並未在車上看到現金等語(見本院卷第83、361頁),則丁○○既未見大量現金存放,已顯與乙○○告知之情節不符,卻未加以詢問丙○○、乙○○,其辯詞已屬可疑。再者,證人即告訴人於審理中證稱:我把螢幕鎖起來後,丁○○就把我壓著,扣住我的脖子,我當天帶一個包包,斜背背在前面等語(見本院卷第321、330頁),丙○○於審理時證稱:我取得手機詢問告訴人密碼時,告訴人有想把手機拿回去,丁○○就勒住告訴人脖子等語(見本院卷第308、311至312頁),依當時情形,若告訴人欲取回手機,應係往前方即駕駛座之位置挪移以取回手機,且其包包亦放在其身前,可見告訴人應無可能將手往後伸之理,且如欲制止告訴人取物舉動,亦可以控制告訴人雙手方式為之,而非直接出手勒住告訴人脖子,亦徵該舉動係依丙○○指示所為,被告丁○○上開辯詞僅為事後卸責之詞,尚不足採。
|
||||
|
||||
一、按刑法第321條第1項所列各款為竊盜之加重條件,如犯竊盜罪兼具數款加重情形時,因竊盜行為祇有一個,仍祇成立一罪,不能認為法律競合或犯罪競合,但判決主文應將各種加重情形順序揭明,理由並應引用各款,俾相適應(最高法院69年度台上字第3945號判決先例意旨參照)。故核被告丙○○、乙○○所為,均係犯刑法第330條第1項、第321條第1項第3、4款之結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜;被告丁○○所為,係犯刑法第330條第1項、第321條第1項第4款之結夥三人以上強盜罪。
|
||||
|
||||
二、被告丙○○、乙○○、丁○○與「C」、「奇異博士」就上開結夥三人以上強盜犯行,有犯意聯絡及行為分擔,均應論以共同正犯。
|
||||
|
||||
三、爰以行為人之責任為基礎,審酌被告丙○○、乙○○、丁○○正值青壯,不思循正當方式獲取金錢,被告乙○○受被告丙○○之邀請進而邀集被告丁○○,竟以佯裝購買泰達幣為名、實則欲以強盜手機之方式,進而奪取泰達幣結夥強盜財物,被告丙○○、乙○○更攜帶棒球棍為之,對交易安全、社會治安損害甚鉅,所為應嚴予非難;被告丙○○、乙○○於犯後坦承客觀事實,被告丁○○否認犯行,被告3人均未與告訴人達成調解或賠償損失之犯後態度;兼衡本案犯罪手段、動機、告訴人所受損失,及其等於審理時自述之智識程度、家庭及經濟狀況(見本院卷第364頁)等一切情狀,分別量處如主文所示之刑。
|
||||
|
||||
㈠被告丙○○取得本案手機後,變賣所獲價金8,500元等情,業據被告丙○○坦承在卷(見本院卷第310頁),並有新北市政府警察局三重分局112年7月9日搜索扣押筆錄暨所附扣押物品目錄表(見偵一卷第115至119頁)、手機收購同意書(見偵一卷第125頁)在卷可查,此部分即屬被告丙○○之犯罪所得,未據扣案,亦未實際合法發還告訴人,爰依刑法第38條之1第1項前段規定,對於被告丙○○宣告沒收,並依同條第3項規定,於全部或一部不能沒收時,追徵其價額。
|
||||
|
||||
㈡如附表編號7至9所示之手機,業經證人即告訴人於本院審理時證稱:在本案自小客車內之手機都有取回等語(見本院卷第334至335頁),亦有贓物認領保管單在卷可憑(見偵一卷第93頁),足認告訴人所有之手機均已合法發還告訴人,爰依刑法第38條之1第5項規定,不予宣告沒收或追徵。
|
||||
|
||||
扣案如附表編號1、4至6所示之手機係供被告3人聯絡本案犯行所用,扣案如附表編號2所示之棒球棍1支,於被告丙○○、乙○○犯本案強盜犯行時,同在現場,均屬供犯罪所用之物,業據被告3人供承在卷(見本院卷第340、343頁),依刑法第38條第2項前段規定,均應予宣告沒收。
|
||||
|
||||
中 華 民 國 114 年 2 月 27 日
|
||||
|
||||
2
|
||||
|
||||
棒球棍
|
||||
|
||||
1支
|
||||
|
||||
丙○○所有。
|
||||
|
||||
3
|
||||
|
||||
開山刀
|
||||
|
||||
1把
|
||||
|
||||
丙○○所有。
|
||||
|
||||
與本案無關。
|
||||
|
||||
7
|
||||
|
||||
iPhone 12手機
|
||||
|
||||
1支
|
||||
|
||||
戊○○所有。
|
||||
|
||||
顏色:綠色。
|
||||
|
||||
IMEI碼:00000000000000
|
||||
|
||||
業經發還與戊○○。
|
||||
|
||||
8
|
||||
|
||||
iPhone手機
|
||||
|
||||
1支
|
||||
|
||||
戊○○所有。
|
||||
|
||||
顏色:深藍色。
|
||||
|
||||
9
|
||||
|
||||
iPhone手機
|
||||
|
||||
1支
|
||||
|
||||
顏色:玫瑰金。
|
||||
|
||||
業經發還與戊○○。
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user