Archived
chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L001", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm", "verdicts": {}, "reasons": {}, "alternatives": {}, "pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Same victim, place, date and event as stats2 407; both kept pages describe it."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L002", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "reject", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The kept text dates only the publication of the judgment (December 23, 2020), not the attack. No kept paragraph says when the meeting took place; 2020 is not supported as the attack year. Owner decides (leave year empty or accept 2020 as the judgment year).",
|
||||
"location": "Kept text names only the court (Wenzhou Intermediate People's Court) and the Rui'an prosecutors; no paragraph says where the meeting or threat took place. Wenzhou is the court seat, not a stated attack location. Owner decides."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 11-15 is right; 11-12 are headings/transition, harmless. 16 is a conclusion not about the case.", "status_notes": "New, no candidates; in scope (threat with replica gun and knife to take 1,000 BTC). Detention unconfirmed is defensible given a two-sentence account. Summary is about 990 characters, slightly over 900."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L003", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"case_details": "Violence Used says Zhang was 'stabbed inside it while they drove'. No kept paragraph says the car was moving during the stabbing; para 3-4 say only that he was pulled back into the car and stabbed, and that afterwards the two drove onto Provincial Highway 74. Delete 'while they drove'."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. Notes for the owner: the currency of 278萬元 and 562萬 is not written in the article (TWD is the reader's reading, matches Lopp and the Taichung setting, not converted). Reader's two open points (attack Armed robbery vs Kidnapping; arrests convicted vs some) are both defensible; I find no rule that settles them."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L004", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph gives a year; 14 January is the day the case was registered (para 2), and the abduction is dated only as 'about one and a half months' before the article. 2020 rests on Lopp's line alone. Owner decides (accept Lopp's year or leave the date open).",
|
||||
"summary": "Says the four were arrested 'from Charkhi Dadri, Rewari and Mahendragarh districts'. Para 3 says they were arrested from Mahendragarh and Dadri districts; Rewari is only the home village of one of them. Also attributes the watching and GPS chip to 'Police sources'; para 6 says only 'sources' (police sources appear in para 8, for the bitcoin-holder claim). The summary runs about 1,050 characters, over the 900 guide."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"summary": ["Replace the arrest clause with: the Dadri CIA unit arrested four suspects in Mahendragarh and Dadri districts; change 'Police sources said the gang had watched him' to 'According to sources, the gang had watched him'."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. Reader's open points (date; Seized in the street vs Vehicle intercepted) are genuine: the text does not say the car was stopped."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L005", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "reject", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'Finding the crypto already moved out' states it as a fact; the judgment says only that the attackers believed it had been moved out (因認梁文耀之虛擬貨幣均已轉出), and the court never establishes where the crypto was. Also 'kept ... two phones and his bag' is not exact: the bag, card holder and papers were thrown away on instruction, and one phone was seized from Liu's car and returned to Liang. About 1,020 characters, over the 900 guide.",
|
||||
"targeting_accuracy": "Wealth overestimated needs the text to show he held far less than the attackers believed, or none. The judgment shows only that the attackers got no crypto because they believed it was already out of the app; Liu's own estimate was 100 to 200 million. It does not show what Liang held. Unknown fits 'none of the above is shown'. Owner decides (the reader raised this as an open point)."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting_accuracy": ["Unknown"], "summary": ["Replace 'Finding the crypto already moved out' with 'Believing the crypto had already been moved out'; replace 'kept TWD 16,000 in cash, two phones and his bag' with 'took TWD 16,000 in cash, two phones and his bag, throwing the bag away'."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "The whole judgment sits in paragraph 3, so keeping 2-3 is the only option. Paragraph 1 is a bare label.", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. In scope: the flatmate chose Liang because he knew Liang ran a crypto investment business. Weapons unconfirmed is right (baton raised in the indictment, court found it doubtful). Venue 'vehicle in motion' is a judgment call: he was also pinned in his flat and beaten at a stop in the hills."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L006", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"description": "Says the fifth man 'Gugu' faces charges. Para 1 says four men answer to the court; para 2 and 4 say the group had a fifth known only by nickname, and no paragraph says he is charged.",
|
||||
"summary": "Same point: 'Four men ... and a fifth known only by the nickname Gugu were charged' is not in the kept text; only four men respond (para 1). Also 'beyond the attackers' control' adds 'attackers'' to the article's bare 'por motivos alheios' (para 3). The summary runs about 980 characters, over the 900 guide.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Status calls article 158 'extortion'. The kept text describes it only as the offence of threatening someone to obtain an economic advantage; 'extortion' is not in it. The Gugu point applies here too if the Status block says he is charged (it says 'known only by nickname', which is fine)."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"description": ["Four identified men face charges; the group had a fifth member known only as 'Gugu'."], "summary": ["Say four men were charged and the group included a fifth known only as 'Gugu'; write 'for reasons the order does not explain' or quote 'por motivos alheios' instead of 'beyond the attackers' control'."], "case_details": ["Delete '(extortion' from the Status block."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. Detention unconfirmed is defensible on a one-sentence account, same call as L002. Location 'Belém, São Paulo, São Paulo' adds the state, which the text does not name; harmless."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L007", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "reject", "drugs_alcohol": "reject", "weapons": "reject", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"violence_torture": "The kept text does not describe the encounter at all: only the place, the hours, the ransom demand and the participants. FLAG-RULES: 'no' is for a described attack that does not report it; 'unconfirmed' when the text is too thin to tell what happened. The reader itself calls these 'no by silence'. Owner decides.",
|
||||
"drugs_alcohol": "Same reason as violence_torture: no paragraph describes how he was taken or held.",
|
||||
"weapons": "Same reason: no paragraph says how he was taken, so a weapon is neither reported nor excluded."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"violence_torture": ["unconfirmed"], "drugs_alcohol": ["unconfirmed"], "weapons": ["unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. Outcome Unknown is right: no paragraph says he was freed or found. Obtained 'Nothing' rests on the hedged police line 'não teria sido pago'; theft no is consistent with it. The article does not name the victim, so the victim label is correct and Lopp's name is unconfirmed."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L008", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Whole judgment is one paragraph; keep 2-3 is the only option.", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. Notes for the owner: the summary runs about 1,040 characters, over the 900 guide (every fact checks).held_duration 'minutes' is an inference from the CCTV stamps (the judgment gives no duration of the holding, only seconds between exits). Targeting Acquaintance vs Other is a fair open point: the unwitting introducer Peng was a friend of the victim who pointed Chen to him; I find it passes the label test. The stored romanisations of the two named people follow Lopp, not the judgment."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L009", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. Date: the article itself gives two dates (para 1 '23 Ordibehesht', para 16 '23 Khordad'). June 12, 2020 (23 Khordad) is supported by para 16 and by the 26 Khordad arrest in para 12; I confirm it but the owner should see the conflict, and case_details does not name it (add one line). Summary is about 1,050 characters, over the 900 guide; every fact checks. Approach: Saeed texted from inside the meeting when it ended, which could also read as 'Let in by an insider' (delivered the victim); the street seizure is the plainer label, so I leave it. Targeting Surveillance rests on the stakeout from the car and the advance viewing of the house; thin but passable."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L010", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraphs 10 and 12 are subheadings of the article (10 heads the Beyoglu section, 12 reads 'all 6 remanded') and are cut without a stated reason; they carry no fact missing from the kept text. Harmless.", "status_notes": "New, no candidates. In scope on a thin basis: the pretext was buying bitcoin and 1.3 million TL was taken, but the account is one sentence. Notes for the owner: arrests 'all' rests on the lead 'gasp eden sahislar yakalandi' and the article does not say how many took part in this robbery (some is the alternative); attack Robbery without a weapon follows the label test only because no weapon is reported, while the four flags are unconfirmed, so the reader's open point (Armed robbery) is real. The summary spends most of its length on the other two robberies of the group; every fact in it checks."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L011", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "reject", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "The release says five people living on a rural property were kidnapped; no kept paragraph says where they were held, at the property or elsewhere.",
|
||||
"attack": "Home invasion needs occupants held in their own home. Paragraph 3 only says they were kidnapped ('sequestraram cinco cidadaos que se encontravam a residir numa propriedade rural'); it does not say the holding happened at the property. Kidnapping (pre-selected, carefully planned, 'sequestro' charged) is equally defensible; the owner decides.",
|
||||
"outcome": "No kept paragraph says how the holding ended; the release only says the transfer was made. Released rests on inference (the reader's own open point). The label test says unknown when the text does not say."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"attack": ["Kidnapping"], "outcome": ["Unknown"], "venue_of_control": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L012", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"summary": "Every fact is in the kept text, but it runs about 980 characters, over the 600 to 900 range. Trim, e.g. the Goiania distance or the search-warrant sentence.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'At least three took part in the abduction' is an inference from 'Dois deles sairam'; no kept paragraph gives a number of attackers. Say only that two of them left the car and fetched the computer."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L013", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"summary": "'On the afternoon of Friday... was kidnapped' : paragraph 5 says the police were alerted that afternoon ('Na tarde da ultima sexta-feira (18), a Policia Civil foi acionada'); no kept paragraph gives the time of the abduction. Also 'He had offered each kidnapper R$ 10,000' is hedged in the article ('teria oferecido'); state it as police said or alleged. Length is about 890, ok."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Theft no / obtained Nothing: the 'roubo majorado' charge in paragraph 14 does not say anything was taken; I agree with the reader's choice and leave the open point to the owner.", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L014", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"description": "'a third 17-year-old... in April 2021': the article, published April 28, 2021, does not give the month of the third arrest; April comes from the publication date. Say 'later'.",
|
||||
"summary": "Same: 'In April 2021 they arrested a third 17-year-old' is not in the text. Also about 930 characters, slightly over 900.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Same: 'the alleged planner was arrested in April 2021' is not stated in paragraphs 1 and 2."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Location 'Paullo, Milan' rests on the headline and the Milan juvenile prosecutor; acceptable.", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L015", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"targeting": "Lopp's line gives a drug-related debt as the motive, which fits Business counterparty (debt dispute) and is missing; Surveillance rests on 'several days of scouting', fine.",
|
||||
"approach": "Social invitation means a friend invited the victim out or in. The line says a woman visited the victim at home with wine; it does not say she was invited or that she let the attacker in. Not supported either way; Unknown, or the owner's call after the court decision is read."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting": ["Acquaintance", "Surveillance", "Business counterparty"], "approach": ["Unknown"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "The PDF page holds only compressed bytes; keep empty is right. Whole case rests on Lopp's line; the court decision must be read before use.", "status_notes": "no source holds: no article text could be read."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L016", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraphs 10 to 13 are a recap of a different gang (the Banda de la Cuarentena, gunpoint seizures, blindfolds); that is another story and should be cut. Keep 1-9.", "status_notes": "Out of scope holds: a kidnapping of a shop owner with the ransom paid in bitcoin; no paragraph says he held crypto or was chosen for it."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L017", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Only paragraph 17 is about this case. Paragraphs 2-13 (the 2023 dating-app case), 16 (2018 case) and 18 (January 2024 case) are other stories. Keep 17, plus at most 1 and 15 for context. Minor: case_details says the 2023 women 'drugged them'; paragraph 6 says 'habrian suministrado' (allegedly).", "status_notes": "New holds as a thin one-paragraph case; the 2023 case in the same article is a separate event."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L018", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"date": "No kept paragraph gives the date of the robbery; December 8, 2020 is the article's publication date (the reader's own open point). The rule wants the date of the attack.",
|
||||
"summary": "Opens 'On December 8, 2020', the same unsupported date.",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "Detention is unconfirmed and nothing says the man was held or controlled anywhere; 'public space' names the place of the attack, not of control. Leave empty."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["December ?, 2020"], "venue_of_control": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L019", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "reject", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"date": "Paragraph 8 gives only the complaint date, 17.12.2020; the order does not say the abduction happened that day. Lopp also says December 17, but his line is a lead. Same-day is likely, not stated.",
|
||||
"summary": "'On the evening of December 17, 2020' states the abduction day, which the order does not give (only the complaint date and the 6.30 pm time).",
|
||||
"held_duration": "The order prints the rescue date as 19.12.2021; 'days' needs the reader's correction to 2020 plus the unstated abduction date. Plausible, but an inference; leave empty or let the owner decide."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["December ?, 2020"], "held_duration": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Out of scope holds: kidnapping of a child with a ransom asked in bitcoin; nothing says the family held crypto."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L020", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "reject",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"description": "'was threatened with a telescopic baton' : Lopp's line says Chen 'pulled out' a baton and ejected Li; no threat is stated, and violence_torture is itself unconfirmed. Also 'left without both the crypto and the cash' is muddled, since the cash was the buyer's.",
|
||||
"obtained": "Cash: the CNY 670,000 was the buyer's own money, counted out by Li and kept by Chen; the line says Chen 'fled with both', but the attackers gained only the USDT from Li. The reader's own note says the cash was taken back."
|
||||
},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"obtained": ["Crypto"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Both pages are empty; keep empty is right.", "status_notes": "no source holds."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L021", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "every fact is in the kept paragraphs, but the text is about 1,250 characters, well over the 600 to 900 range; needs cutting (for example the Telegram/plate detail and the two-car handover)",
|
||||
"case_details": "'Nothing was recovered' is in no kept paragraph; para 41 only says the property passed to Ko and the unidentified accomplices and that Yang was found not to have shared in it. Drop that sentence or restate as 'no evidence Yang received any share'."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Court judgment; the kept set covers facts, victim testimony, findings, charges, sentence and date. Cuts are procedural.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "No stats2 candidates; new is right. Targeting Business counterparty rests on Ko being a repeat crypto customer of Hu; defensible, the judgment does not say how Ko learned of the collection."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L022", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "day is supported (the day before the 2 February... report of 3 February); the year 2021 is not in the article and rests on Lopp's line, as the reader noted",
|
||||
"summary": "confirmed; minor: the article says the accomplices rushed to 'the trade scene', the summary says 'into the room'; about 900 characters",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "110万元 carries no currency in the article; CNY is the reader's reading for a Xiamen report, not a conversion",
|
||||
"obtained": "Cash stands on the text; whether the USDT was sent is not stated (reader's open point is fair)"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L023", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "reject",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'In March 2021 S.A. demanded...' puts the events in March 2021; Lopp's line carries no date for the events (March 2021 is his entry date, and the reader's own note says the month of attack or arrests is unclear). Also 'invested ... in Istanbul' places the investment, which the line does not.",
|
||||
"attack": "Extortion without detention fails its test (nobody held) in a case where he was forced into a vehicle at gunpoint; the later threats at home are part of the same case. Kidnapping alone passes (forced into a vehicle, pre-selected adviser).",
|
||||
"obtained": "The line says only 'transferred an additional USD 10,000'; whether this was bank money (Cash) or crypto is not stated. Unconfirmed fits better than Cash.",
|
||||
"date": "rests on Lopp's date column only, as the no source status requires; not contradicted",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "the line is ambiguous (USD 30,000 more than the USD 7,000 repaid); reading it as a 30,000 demand is acceptable"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"attack": ["Kidnapping"], "obtained": ["Unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Both fetches failed (Cloudflare 403; Wayback 404 page); nothing to keep.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "no source is right; I could not fetch the archive.is link either (no web fetching allowed)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L024", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "'2022' is a guess: the article (23 Nov 2022) says 'over the last year' and dates none of the cases, so the crypto theft falls between about Nov 2021 and Nov 2022. No kept paragraph supports 2022 over 2021; the owner decides, or leave the date empty.",
|
||||
"life_taken": "0 is right for this single victim; the article does not link him to any of the 7 deaths",
|
||||
"approach": "other pretext (strangers offering drugs) is defensible; no better label"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Kept 1-14, 17-20 is the article; the teaser (15-16), tip-line box and copyright are cut correctly.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Out of scope holds: the gangs picked patrons by watches and phones, and the crypto victim gets one sentence in a 40-victim series."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L025", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "(1) 'The taxi driver had called police' rests on the testimony of the taxi driver in para 35, which the reader cut; no kept paragraph says it (para 25 says only 'after police received a report'). (2) 'had run a virtual currency dealing business together' states as fact what only Chi's police statement says, and the court found his accounts inconsistent (in court he said Yang gave him TWD 1 million to invest). (3) about 1,130 characters, over the 600 to 900 range.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'The taxi driver reported it' (para 35, cut) and 'Two promissory notes of TWD 1.6 million each found on Yang' (amount and owner come only from the appended exhibit table, paras 133-134, cut; kept para 68 gives the signer only). 'Nothing was paid or taken' is an inference, not stated.",
|
||||
"description": "'former partner in a crypto-dealing business' rests on Chi's contested police account; acceptable, but the summary should carry the dispute"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Para 35 holds the taxi driver's testimony (witness 劉河金: saw about 10 men grab his passenger, turned back and reported it) and the court's finding that nine men waited at the address; it is mixed with legal doctrine but contains case facts. Add 35 to keep, or drop the taxi driver claims. Paras 36-37 are fragments of 38 and are fine.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "No candidates; new holds."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L026", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"description": "'arrested ... in a hotel' : para 7 says police arrested the two 'on the spot' (当场) on the afternoon of May 11 and does not say where. The hotel is where they stayed and where Lai picked up cable ties 'near' it.",
|
||||
"summary": "'arrested them in the hotel' has the same problem; about 1,000 characters, at the upper edge.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'Both arrested at the hotel' is unsupported, same reason.",
|
||||
"date": "May 11 is the arrest date; the plot ran through May 2021 and no attack happened. Acceptable.",
|
||||
"approach": "the investment pretext was only planned, Peng was never lured; kept as the planned approach, consistent with foiled-plot handling, but the owner may prefer Unknown",
|
||||
"people": "empty list matches 'no rows when the attackers met nobody', although who_was_attacked says Holder; a rule conflict for plots, flagged for the owner"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Whole column kept; fine.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "new vs out of scope is a genuine owner call, as the reader's open point says: no attack, no contact, only preparation; the Foiled label covers plots stopped by arrest, so new is defensible."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L027", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "every fact I checked is in the kept paragraphs (one nit: 丁○○, who booked the room, is called an 'accomplice' but the judgment says he did not know of the plan and convicted him only of aiding deprivation of liberty), but the text is about 1,350 characters, far over the 600 to 900 range.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'searched their homes in June 2021': the kept para 16 gives no month (June appears only in the cut exhibit table); 'Open to appeal' rests on the appeal notice (paras 55-56, cut). Everything else I checked matches paras 12-17, 25-28, 31, 34-36 and 233-245.",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion is one of three defensible places (restaurant room, cars, roadside spot in the hills where he was held about three hours); accepted, not wrong",
|
||||
"targeting": "Unknown is right: the judgment gives the motive (profitable investing) and an introduction through a victim's friend, not how they were chosen"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L028", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "facts all match the kept paragraphs, but the text is about 1,130 characters, over the 600 to 900 range; trim the car-return and reporting detail.",
|
||||
"approach": "serving police is on the victim's account only, and the article says so; the police spokesman knew nothing of the case. Acceptable, as the reader noted.",
|
||||
"arrests": "empty is fine; the article reports none"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Candidate 93 is a different incident (July 14, 2021)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L029", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'one had lent him six bitcoins': para 5 says only that one of the businessmen 'fez um empréstimo de seis Bitcoins' and does not say to whom; case_details words it correctly ('one then lent six bitcoins'). Also about 1,050 characters, at the upper edge of the range.",
|
||||
"date": "May 29 to 31 matches the reported hold (29 May to police finding him on 31 May); acceptable",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space is fine; the penthouse was rented for him by a businessman and guarded by the third man (reader's open point is fair)",
|
||||
"weapons": "yes follows the police account of a gun 'que teria sido usada para ameaçar' him; fair, the open point is fair"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Para 2 (photo caption) cut correctly.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Borderline scope, which the reader handled as a business dispute: the ransom is in reais, but the dispute is over bitcoin he had been lent and money diverted into crypto, so new is defensible. Candidates 96 and 81 are different cases."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L030", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "reject", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'he and one partner split about $1.6 million after the third took about $300,000' misreads the testimony: of about $3.5 million, Aabis took about $300,000 and the other two 'split the rest down the middle', which is about $1.6 million each (para 1159 gives 1.6 million as the answer to 'how much was that', and on cross-examination (para 9059) he agreed he received over $1.4 million). The summary makes 1.6 million the total of the split, so his share would be 0.8 million. The description says 'a share of about $1.6 million', which is the better reading. The 'plea and immunity agreements' rest on two exhibit index lines only (paras 130, 135).",
|
||||
"drugs_alcohol": "detention is set unconfirmed on the ground that the text is too thin to tell what happened, and the attack is described in one sentence plus 'At gunpoint? Yes'; by the same test drugs_alcohol is unconfirmed, not no (FLAG-RULES: no applies to a described attack).",
|
||||
"country": "USA is inferred from his Florida residence; the robbery's place is not stated (reader's open point on location is fair)",
|
||||
"date": "2021 follows from 'Shortly after' the March 2021 theft; Lopp's June 2021 is not in the transcript",
|
||||
"weapons": "supported only by the extracted line 'At gunpoint?' followed by 'A. Yes.'; the PDF text layer interleaves lines (the preceding question 'Approximately how' has no visible answer), so this is the weakest support in the case, but the pairing reads correctly",
|
||||
"case_details": "confirmed; the '1.6 million split' wording copies the testimony and is ambiguous, but names the cross-examination figure of over 1.4 million"},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"drugs_alcohol": ["unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Excerpt choice covers identity, the SIM-swap proceeds, the robbery sentence, the Baretto information and the cross-examination; I found no other passage about his own robbery (searched 'invaded', 'robbed', 'gunpoint', 'Biscayne', 'kicked').",
|
||||
"status_notes": "new holds: robbed at home as a crypto holder, though the victim is himself a SIM-swap thief and the record is thin."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L031", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph gives the month of the attack. Paragraph 1 is the publication stamp (25.06.2021) and the article already reports four suspects caught and remanded, so the attack may be earlier than June. 'June ?, 2021' is the publication month, not the attack month."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L032", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"description": "'beaten with an air gun, bats and iron bars': paragraph 24 says Chiang fired the air gun (射擊) and beat Wu with bats and iron bars; nobody is said to have beaten him with the air gun.",
|
||||
"summary": "Length only: about 1,040 characters, over the 600 to 900 range. Every fact in it is in the kept text (checked sentence by sentence)."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"description": ["...was shot at with an air gun and beaten with bats and iron bars at a partners' meeting in Taipei..."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Scope is a real doubt, owner to decide; I lean out of scope. Wu was seized as a debtor in a contract dispute over the platform, the demand was TWD 10 million, and the USDT was his friend's, obtained because he had no cash (paragraphs 36, 49). Nobody is said to have targeted him as a crypto holder. Against: he developed a crypto platform and 200,000 USDT was taken."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L033", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The article gives no attack date; it is dated July 31, 2021 and already reports the attackers detained. 'July, 2021' is the publication month, so the attack may be earlier.",
|
||||
"summary": "'In July 2021 ... was robbed' rests on the publication date only (see date). All other facts are in paragraphs 5 to 8.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Two statements are not in the kept text: 'the cash he brought to buy the equipment' (the article only says they took about 300,000 rubles; it does not say he brought cash), and the gloss that art. 162 part 3 covers 'violence dangerous to life or the threat of it' (legal knowledge, not in the article). 'A fake sale' is also the reader's inference; the article says only that the sale did not take place."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraph 9 (2019 theft from a mining farm in a garage at Khimmash, 742 thousand rubles of graphics cards) is a different incident, not background to this case. Keep 1-3, 5-8.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Scope is a real doubt, owner to decide; I lean out of scope. The article says the victim came to buy a mining farm and had 300,000 rubles taken; it does not say he held any cryptocurrency, so nobody is shown targeted as a crypto holder."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L034", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph dates the attack; 'July, 2021' rests on Lopp's line alone (the reader's own note says so). The article (last updated June 3, 2022) only shows the attack was before that.",
|
||||
"summary": "'In June 2022 the Dubai Court of Appeal upheld the verdict' is not in the text: paragraph 2 says only 'Last updated: June 03, 2022' and gives no ruling date. Also about 1,000 characters, slightly over 900. The 'protective suits' wording is the reader's reading of 'PPE'. Other facts are supported.",
|
||||
"outcome": "Confirmed as Released (paragraph 11: dropped back in Dubai). Note paragraph 12 says he 'managed to escape'; the reader's open point stands for the owner."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L035", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "Confirmed with a caveat: 'July ?, 2021' rests on the complaint date (15 July, paragraph 2); the article gives no attack date, but the complaint came after the release, so the month is a safe reading.",
|
||||
"summary": "Length only: about 1,060 characters, over the 600 to 900 range. Every fact is in the kept text.",
|
||||
"targeting": "Acquaintance does not fit: the woman is not described as a friend or social contact of the victim. Asgar T. placed her in his home and she passed on his finances and bank details, which is the insider tip-off test (someone with inside access passed on holdings or movements; a handler who supplied the target). Surveillance (live location) is right."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting": ["Insider tip-off", "Surveillance"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L036", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"sources": "The stored original URL returned a Cloudflare challenge; only the web.archive.org copy loaded. The reader prompt says to store an archive link when it is the only copy that loaded, but the exact archive URL is not in the page file. Owner may prefer to add it.",
|
||||
"summary": "About 940 characters, at the top of the range; all facts supported."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L037", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "reject", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "reject", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"who_was_attacked": "The attackers met nobody: the plot was stopped on the road. The reader prompt says 'No rows when the attackers met nobody', and the Holder test requires the person to be confronted, held, hurt or threatened, or a remote-attack target. The reader justifies Holder by 'stats2 practice for foiled plots', which I could not check. Owner to decide; if that practice is real, confirm.",
|
||||
"people": "Same as who_was_attacked: the man was never reached, and the prompt says no people rows when the attackers met nobody.",
|
||||
"approach": "The text shows fake Civil Police uniforms found at the arrest but no approach, and nothing says they meant to pose as police to reach him. The label test is that the attackers posed as police; here nobody was approached."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"approach": ["Unknown"], "who_was_attacked": ["Other"], "people": []},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraphs 11-16 (heading and other attacks on crypto businessmen: Black Warrior man in Cabo Frio, Niteroi shooting, Curitiba shooting) are other stories, not the article about this case. Keep 2-10.",
|
||||
"status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L038", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The appeal is dated 31-08-2021 and gives no robbery date; 'August, 2021' rests on Lopp's line alone (the reader's note says so).",
|
||||
"attack": "Both labels are defensible and no rule settles it; owner to decide, I lean Kidnapping. He was taken to a room booked two days earlier by a fourth suspect with a forged ID, handcuffed and taped there by three men, after a pre-arranged meeting with a man he had dealt with before. Armed robbery is defined as 'without extended holding', and the text gives no duration.",
|
||||
"outcome": "Confirmed as Released, but it is an inference: the appeal never says how it ended; the threat about going to the police implies he was left free."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021"], "attack": ["Kidnapping"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L039", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "reject", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "Paragraph 4 says '올 8월' (this August) with no year, and the page carries no publication date. The year 2021 rests on Lopp's line alone.",
|
||||
"location": "The page names only the Seoul Central District Court (paragraph 2); the place of the attack is not stated. 'Seoul' is the court's seat, not the location of the attack.",
|
||||
"summary": "'In August 2021' needs the year, which only Lopp's line gives (see date). All other facts are supported; length about 860 characters.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'Source: Herald Economy via Naver' is not in any page text (the paragraph with the reporter's name does not name the outlet); it is an inference from the Naver URL."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["August ?, 2021 only if the owner accepts Lopp's year; the text supports 'August' alone"], "location": ["(empty, or Seoul if the owner accepts the court as proxy)"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L040", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "Confirmed: paragraph 10 dates the arrest to 31 August; paragraph 2 says the video came 'em setembro de 2021', which the reader records as a conflict. August 31 is the raid date, not necessarily the start of the captivity.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Minor: 'with links to crypto pyramid schemes' is firmer than paragraph 10 ('pode ter envolvimento'). Acceptable."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Scope is a real doubt, owner to decide; I lean out of scope. The victims were former members of a fraud group seized by their ex-accomplices, the ransom was R$ 350,000, and no kept paragraph says either man held crypto or that crypto was demanded. The only link is the indictment's phrase tying the extortion to profits of a 'pirâmide' and cryptocurrencies (paragraph 12)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L041", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "says 'São Paulo state prosecutors'; the kept text only says 'Ministério Público' (SP appears only after Monte Mor and Campinas), so 'São Paulo state' is unsupported. Everything else in the summary is supported; length about 890 characters."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"summary": ["Replace 'the São Paulo state prosecutors' with 'the public prosecutor's office (Ministério Público)' or just 'prosecutors'."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Candidate 96 (Rio de Janeiro state, August 2021 murder) is a different event."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L042", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Two problems. (1) 'were sent to trial': the text [10] says the case 'в ближайшее время поступит в суд', i.e. will go to court shortly, not that it went. (2) Length is about 1,100 characters, over the 600 to 900 target.",
|
||||
"case_details": "(1) 'Border guards had stopped the pair near the forest': [7] says only that a border patrol noticed them ('заметил наряд пограничников'), they had to drop the shovel and a protocol was drawn up; 'stopped' and 'near the forest' are not stated. (2) 'Injected with a drug twice in the flat': [6] says he was injected twice and taken to the forest, with no place for the first two injections."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"summary": ["Replace 'were sent to trial' with 'the case was about to go to court (April 2023)'; trim to under 900 characters, e.g. drop the list of seized items and the shovel detail."],
|
||||
"case_details": ["'Border guards noticed the pair, who had to drop the shovel; a protocol was drawn up for breaching the border-zone regime and they were released.' and 'injected with a drug twice, then once more in the forest'."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Candidates 292 (Tomsk) and 91 (Omsk) are different events. Year 2021 for 27 September rests on 'в июне 2021 года' in [3]; acceptable and flagged in notes."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L043", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Candidates 109 (Amsterdam, December) and 90 (Leeuwarden, June) are different events. Summary is about 960 characters, slightly over the 900 target; owner may trim. 'Two more men appeared, took his car key' reads as both taking it; text says one of them did."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L044", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Status is for the owner. [11] says the robbers approached 'para robarle el auto'; nobody is shown to have targeted him as a crypto holder, and the rack sale was only the lure. That fits the out-of-scope test (ordinary robbery, crypto incidental) better than 'new', so I lean out of scope. The reader's open point already carries this; I agree it is a real owner decision. Values themselves are supported either way. Minor: targeting_accuracy 'Correct' is weak (the text only shows the racks and car were there); 'Unknown' is also defensible. 'in Gerli' in the summary rests on a neighbour's self-description in [13]; [11] says only calle Honduras al 1600, Lanús. Date October 12 rests on 'ayer' in an article published October 13; acceptable."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L045", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph dates Hankin's robbery. The only date is [27]: a different victim (named on a stolen credit card, robbed two days before 11 Nov 2021) identified Hassan. Lopp's 'November 2021' is not confirmed for Hankin by the text; the support quote is about another victim. Owner decides between 'November, 2021' (Lopp only) and '2021' (the reader's open point); even the year is an inference from [27].",
|
||||
"case_details": "'the friend was not threatened' is not in the text ([13] and [14] only say the friend waited outside and knocked on the window). Everything else checked out."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021"], "case_details": ["Delete 'the friend was not threatened'."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-46 is too much. [40] to [46] are a separate section about other London crypto muggings (a Guardian report, a Coinbase user, a Ripple victim, an NPCC quote): other stories, not this case. [2] is a teaser about earlier unrelated BleepingComputer reports. Suggested keep: 3-39 (or 1, 3-39). [47] to [50] correctly cut. Same applies to L046 and L047 (identical page).",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Separate attack from L046 and L047: [34] says three robberies and [10], [15], [21] name three different victims. No stats2 candidates. Summary is about 1,040 characters, over the 900 target; owner may trim."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L046", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "reject", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph dates Mamuod's robbery. [27] dates only a different victim's identification of Hassan (11 Nov 2021). 'November, 2021' rests on Lopp alone; the reader's own open point offers '2021'.",
|
||||
"detention": "[15] says only that Mamuod was forced to pay after a pocketknife threat, 'in a similar fashion' to Hankin. Nothing says he was held, restrained or kept from leaving, and the reader left venue_of_control and held_duration empty, which does not fit detention yes. FLAG-RULES: thin text is 'unconfirmed'; 'no' would say control was never gained, which the text also does not show."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021"], "detention": ["unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-46 is too much: [40] to [46] are a separate section about other London crypto muggings (Guardian report, Coinbase user, Ripple victim, NPCC quote), and [2] is a teaser about earlier unrelated reports. Suggested keep: 3-39 (or 1, 3-39). [47] to [50] correctly cut.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Separate attack from L045 and L047: three named victims and 'three very serious robberies' ([34]). Notes for the owner: obtained 'Crypto' for Mamuod rests on [16] ('All such involuntary transactions ... from victims' smartphones, authorized by their fingerprints') and the general crypto framing; the asset is not named for him, so Unconfirmed is defensible but I let it stand. Description and summary describe Mamuod as a customer of the swap scheme; the text only says 'in a similar fashion', acceptable. Summary is about 830 characters."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L047", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "reject",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Says the other man 'was never identified'; [21] only calls him 'another unknown male'. The text does not say he was never identified later. Write 'an unknown man' instead.",
|
||||
"obtained": "[23] says Goloid 'handed over £2,500 to Hassan' with no asset named. [16] ('All such involuntary transactions ... from victims' smartphones') sits in the Mamuod passage, before Goloid is introduced, and [29] says only 'in the vast majority of crimes'. The reader's own open point is right: Unconfirmed."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"summary": ["Replace 'another man, who was never identified' with 'another unknown man'."], "obtained": ["Unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-46 is too much: [40] to [46] are a separate section about other London crypto muggings (Guardian report, Coinbase user, Ripple victim, NPCC quote), and [2] is a teaser about earlier unrelated reports. Suggested keep: 3-39 (or 1, 3-39). [47] to [50] correctly cut.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Separate attack from L045 and L046 (three named victims, 'three very serious robberies' [34]). Date 'November, 2021' is an inference, not a statement: [24] to [27] put Goloid's robbery a few days before the stop that preceded the 11 Nov identification, so early November is likely but the text gives no day or month for Goloid; I confirm it as the best reading, owner may prefer '2021'. Judgement calls the owner may want to look at: attack 'Robbery without a weapon' versus Kidnapping (taken to an underground car park, distance unknown), and venue 'public space' for that car park. Description says Hassan's arrest followed Goloid's report; text says police stopped and searched him a few days later. Summary otherwise supported, about 700 characters."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L048", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "reject", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "reject",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "reject", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "reject",
|
||||
"people": "reject", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'of central Portugal' is not in the kept text (it names Castelo Branco and Idanha-a-Nova only). Length is also about 1,050 characters, over the 900 target, and about half of it describes the September 2020 attack.",
|
||||
"theft": "[3] says only that the planned transfer was not made. It does not say nothing else was taken, and both attacks are called 'roubos'. FLAG-RULES: unconfirmed when the text does not say whether anything was taken. The reader's own open point on obtained points the same way.",
|
||||
"taken_as_stated": "'nothing taken' overstates [3]; it says the transfer failed, not that nothing was taken. Suggest 'planned bitcoin transfer not made; no other loot mentioned'.",
|
||||
"obtained": "'Nothing' needs the text to show nothing was taken; [3] shows only that the transfer failed. Unconfirmed fits (sources do not say).",
|
||||
"attack": "'No label fits' is hard to defend: [1] and [3] say five people were 'sequestrados' in a planned attack aimed at known bitcoin holders (charges: roubo agravado e sequestro). That is Kidnapping on the pre-selected, held-captive reading; the place of holding is not stated, so Home invasion has no more support. Owner decides between Kidnapping and No label fits.",
|
||||
"who_was_attacked": "The text does not say which of the five held bitcoin. The split 1 Holder + 4 Other invents a distinction. Either Holder for all five held (they were the targets of a bitcoin grab) or Other (sources do not say who was attacked); owner decides.",
|
||||
"people": "Follows who_was_attacked: 'one holder and four others' is not in the text. Alternative: one row, 5 people, role Holder or Other, at_least 0, detail 'five people held, relationship not stated'."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"theft": ["unconfirmed"], "obtained": ["Unconfirmed"], "attack": ["Kidnapping"], "who_was_attacked": ["Holder", "Other"], "people": ["{role: Other, people: 5, at_least: 0}"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "L048-1 is empty (TLS failure), correctly cut. L048-2 is a web.archive.org copy; [7] category tag correctly cut. The original policiajudiciaria.pt link did not load in the pipeline, only the archive copy did; the sources field lists the original URL only, which the owner may want to swap for the archive link per the reader prompt.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "No stats2 candidates. The release covers two attacks (September 2020 and November 2021); the 2020 one is not in this batch. drugs_alcohol 'no' sits beside violence and weapons 'unconfirmed' because the text is thin; acceptable by the silence rule, but note the inconsistency. Date 'November, 2021' is supported by [2]."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L049", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 2-6, 8 is right; [1] section tag, [7] teaser stub, [9] to [12] widgets correctly cut.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "In scope as a cash-side P2P trade robbery. Minor points for the owner, none a reject: summary is about 1,000 characters, over the 900 target; 'in some cases' near a school is the reader's hedge ([8] says the acts were near a school, not 'some'); arrests 'all' rests on seven indicted suspects and no one reported at large, the text does not say the gang is complete; people '2, at least' is a floor for 'several' ([8] 'כמה'), Lopp's '6 victims' is unsupported. Date '2021' rests on the article's publication date (25 Nov 2021) and 'in the last months'."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L050", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph dates the attack. The only date is the update line [2], 28 January 2022, which follows the first-instance trial and the appeal. 'November, 2021' comes from Lopp's line alone, which is a lead, not a source. Even '2021' is not stated; the text shows only that the attack preceded January 2022. Owner decides (reader's open point).",
|
||||
"description": "'all five were jailed for three years' is not in the text: [4] says 'the men' were sentenced and [12] says three of the five defendants were arrested; nothing says all five were sentenced.",
|
||||
"summary": "'sentenced the five' is unsupported for the same reason ([4] says 'the men' and 'the gang members'; [12] says three were arrested). Length is also about 1,000 characters, over the 900 target."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["2021 (inferred; owner decides)"], "description": ["Replace 'all five were jailed for three years' with 'the gang members were jailed for three years'."], "summary": ["Replace 'sentenced the five' with 'sentenced the gang members'; trim under 900 characters."]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-13 correct; [2] kept as the only date on the page.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "No stats2 candidates. Targeting Business counterparty rests on [7] (financial dispute); [9] adds the gang knew he held crypto. Lopp's '243 units', 'five transfers' and 'Asian nationals' are not in the article (reader's lopp_differences are right)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L051", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "States as fact that Su was taken 'to an empty lot in Renwu District'; paragraph 6 hedges it (疑強押至仁武區空地, apparently forced to an empty lot). Add 'apparently'. Also 'two men surnamed Su, 38, and Zhao, 34' reads as both surnamed Su. Every other sentence is supported; length is fine.",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "The only place named is the empty lot, and only as 疑 (apparently); Zhao was met at a meeting point in Nanzih. Neither is clearly a public space nor clearly an attacker-controlled space. Unsure, owner decides."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"venue_of_control": ["attacker's or third-party space"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 3-7 is right; 8-9 repeat the caption of 3, 1-2 rating notice, 10-11 promo.", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L052", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "About 1,050 characters, well over the 600 to 900 target (it narrates the October 19 incident in full). Also 'a police van cut them off' and 'officers grabbed them and told them to get in' paraphrase 'double-crossed them' and 'gripped him and his brother, asking them to enter their van'. Facts otherwise match paragraphs 1-18.",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "Paragraphs 3 and 6 show the occupants confronted in the apartment, then asked to come out of it to identify themselves; no kept paragraph says where they were held while he withdrew the money. Defensible as victim's private space, but the holding place is not stated. Unsure, owner decides.",
|
||||
"targeting": "Nothing in the text says how the officers knew of the November 10 victim. The only link is the October 19 stop, where he said he was a crypto trader after being stopped; that is a prior encounter by the same officers, not a stated reason for choosing him. Unknown fits the label test; 'Other' needs a stated reason."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"venue_of_control": ["victim's private space", ""], "targeting": ["Unknown"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep list correct: 5, 9, 14 are READ ALSO links.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right. The article covers two extortions by the same officers (October 19 street stop, N1 million; November 10 apartment, N700,000). One record dated November 10 matches Lopp's entry; the reader's open point about a second record for October 19 is a fair question for the owner."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L053", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"case_details": "The TWD 1 million refund ('A witness said Lu told her they took TWD 9.9 million and handed TWD 1 million back to one victim asking him not to call police') comes from the Li Wen-jie police-interview transcript, paragraphs 120-127, which the reader cut. Kept paragraph 132 mentions only the 990 figure, not the refund. Either keep 119-131 or drop the refund sentence. Everything else in case_details is in the kept text."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Cuts are mostly right (party list, admissibility boilerplate, statutes). Two gaps: paragraph 142 (the court's concluding finding that the facts are established) is cut, and the witness transcript 119-131 that case_details relies on is cut. Add 142, and 119-131 if the refund detail stays.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right; no stats2 candidates and not the same attack as L051 or L060. The summary is about 1,000 characters, at the top edge of the range but acceptable. Attack stays Armed robbery: the reader's open point (Kidnapping) is a real question for the owner, driven off in the attackers' car for about 25 minutes after pre-selection. Victim names are from the court judgment, not the press; the owner rule allows published names."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L054", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "reject", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "reject",
|
||||
"people": "reject", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "About 1,200 characters against the 600 to 900 target; trim. Facts match paragraphs 1-19 (the 'al parecer' hedges on the beating and the trunk are dropped, minor).",
|
||||
"who_was_attacked": "Relative or partner rests on 'Él y su padre mostraron interés en vender' (paragraph 5), which says the father wanted to sell, not that he was at the ranch, held or hurt. Paragraph 7 'Todos ... se trasladaron' and paragraph 12 'las víctimas' leave it open. By the owner's rule a relative must be present or in custody; the text does not show it. If Jiménez is the father (the reader's second open point) the row moves, still not an extra person.",
|
||||
"people": "Same reason: the Relative or partner row (the father) is not shown present or in custody.",
|
||||
"obtained": "Valuables rests on 'billeteras, documentos y otros objetos personales' (wallets, documents, personal items), which are not valuables in the label's sense (watches, jewellery, cars, machines). Crypto, Cash and Devices or seed are supported."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"who_was_attacked": ["Holder", "Bystanders or neighbours", "Other"], "obtained": ["Crypto", "Cash", "Devices or seed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right. Outcome Killed follows rulings 58 and 468 (a death in the attack gives Killed, deaths 1), so the reader's open point on outcome is settled by precedent."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L055", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "reject", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'Robillard blamed him for poor cryptocurrency investment advice that had cost him $2,000' is not in the text. Paragraph 25 says only that the man told investigators he had given poor crypto investment advice that led to Robillard losing $2,000; no paragraph says Robillard blamed him or that this was the reason for the attack. Rest of the summary is supported.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'The motive was a cryptocurrency investment loss' is the same unsupported link; no kept paragraph names a motive. The quoted sentence (paragraph 25) is fine; state it as the man's statement, not as the motive.",
|
||||
"targeting": "Business counterparty rests on the same unstated motive. Acquaintance (friends for about a year) is supported; the investment advice is a fact about the two men, not a stated reason he was chosen.",
|
||||
"outcome": "The report says he was held captive for about three hours, so the captivity ended, with no rescue or escape described. Under the owner rule (found alive, no rescue described: Released) Released fits better than Unknown, and L056 and L058 are set to Released on the same footing."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting": ["Acquaintance"], "outcome": ["Released"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep list is right; 1-10 menu, 14 trending promo, 22 related link, 30-31 footer cut.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Out of scope holds: the man was lured for sex and robbed and extorted by an acquaintance; no passage says he was targeted as a crypto holder or that crypto was sought. The $30,000 contract and $650 are in dollars."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L056", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "reject", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"theft": "FLAG-RULES: theft must agree with obtained, and 'unconfirmed' is the value when the text does not say whether anything was taken. The article only lists 'robbery' among the convictions and never says what was taken; obtained is set to Unconfirmed, so theft yes contradicts it. Defensible either way (a robbery conviction implies a taking); owner decides."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"theft": ["unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Page 1 is an empty timeout; page 2 (web.archive.org copy) is the whole article, 8 is the podcast blurb. Archive link rightly kept in sources because it is the only copy that loaded.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right; not the Karim Hassan cases (L045 to L047). Outcome Released rests on the owner rule (no rescue or escape described). 'On Monday' resolves to October 30, 2023 from the November 2, 2023 dateline."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L057", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm", "verdicts": {}, "reasons": {}, "alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep list right: 2 update stamp, 4 box heading, 10 and 25 photo credits cut; captions 11 and 26 carry facts.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Same attack as stats2 499: Monteverde and his business partner, Sainte-Anne-des-Lacs, December 2021, three masked armed men, face-unlock drowning ruse, 7.70 ETH plus watches and jewellery. 499 already holds this La Presse link, so no new sources."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L058", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-6 right; 7 video teaser and 8-9 policy blurb cut.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right. Minor notes only: the region 'Västra Götaland' is not in the article (Falköping's county, correct as geography); the weapons flag rests on the victim's account of a knife threat, which the article reports without doubt; taken_amount carries only the crypto figure, the cash and Pokémon cards are in taken_as_stated; outcome Released rests on the owner rule (no rescue or escape described)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L059", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "reject", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The support quote is the creation stamp of the report (Aralık 16, 2021), which dates the article, not the robbery. No kept paragraph says when the robbery happened, so even the year 2021 is unsupported (it could have been earlier). Lopp's December 2021 is no better supported. Owner decides; the open point should cover this, not only month versus year.",
|
||||
"summary": "Opens 'In 2021 ...', the same unsupported year. Replace with a statement that the report is dated December 16, 2021 and does not date the robbery. The rest matches paragraphs 3, 7, 8 and 10; length is fine.",
|
||||
"taken_usd_stated": "650000 is the headline total (title only, not a kept paragraph), while taken_amount and taken_currency carry only the 10 BTC. The pair is inconsistent. Paragraph 3 states about $500,000 for the 10 bitcoin; use 500000 or null."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"taken_usd_stated": ["500000"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep right; paragraph 1 is the agency dateline, 4-6 Google follow prompts. Paragraph 2 (date stamp) is fine to keep.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right. Detention, violence, drugs and weapons unconfirmed is acceptable under FLAG-RULES because the report is too thin to tell what happened. Attack Robbery without a weapon versus Home invasion is a fair open point."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L060", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'at a motorway rest stop' adds 'motorway'; the judgment says only 西湖休息站 (Xihu rest stop). Use 'rest stop'. All other sentences match paragraphs 42, 51 and the sentencing paragraphs; length about 980 characters, acceptable.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Lists the seven defendants' names from the judgment header ('the judgment's header lists 魏子傑, 劉世賢, 黃郁惟, 林韋辰, 李健銘, 余紹珩 and 松昱陽'), which is in paragraphs 7-29, cut as the party list. Either keep those paragraphs or drop the sentence. Every other fact and quotation is in the kept paragraphs."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep list sound for a 106-paragraph judgment: facts (42), findings on the organiser (49-56), legal assessment (66-73), appeal grounds and review (80-95), date (99). Cut 57-65 (Song's defence rebuttals) is acceptable; paragraph 96 is the tail of 95's sentence and could be kept.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New is right: not the same as L051 or L053. Targeting Other is acceptable (the broker found the buyer; the attackers did not choose him directly). Outcome Released: the attackers drove off with the suitcase after throwing him off the car."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L061", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"approach": "The text says only 'Kiedy otworzył im drzwi, obezwładnili go': he opened the door and was overpowered. No break-in or force on entry is described, so Forced entry (which needs force or a break-in shown) is an inference. Seized at or outside the home does not fit either, since they then worked inside the flat."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"approach": ["Unknown"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Summary runs about 950 characters, slightly over the 900 guide; 'sexual partner' softens the advert (a woman as 'niewolnica seksualna'), case_details has the real wording. '20 złotych monet' read as gold coins is a reasonable reading but not certain."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L062", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"venue_of_control": "No kept paragraph says the brother-in-law lived in the house; it says only that a family of three lived there and one of them held the bitcoin. 'Victim's private space' is not shown; the sources do not say where he was held beyond 'the house'.",
|
||||
"who_was_attacked": "Confirmed as an owner call: Relative or partner fits LABELS.md ('in the holder's place'); Wrong person or address and Holder (he was believed to be the holder) are also defensible. The reader's open point covers it.",
|
||||
"approach": "Confirmed on 'invadiram uma casa'; the prosecutor's quote says only 'entraram', so the force is the outlet's wording."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"venue_of_control": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L063", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "No kept paragraph gives a date or year for the attack (the page has no date). '2022' rests on Lopp's line alone and has no support passage. Without Lopp the date is unknown.",
|
||||
"approach": "Confirmed, but the owner rule 'a crypto trade meeting is approach P2P trade only' could be read to exclude the second label; the fake badge is a separate act in the car, so both are defensible.",
|
||||
"targeting": "Confirmed: the former driver is an attacker with inside knowledge; the text does not say he passed information on, so Acquaintance is the alternative if the owner reads Insider tip-off narrowly."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Summary is about 980 characters, a little over the guide. 'Dh8,000 in cash ... and her handbag' reads the handbag as separate; the source says 'including her handbag worth Dh7,200' (case_details quotes it correctly)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L064", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "reject", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The paragraph kept as support is the article's dateline (21 January 2022), the date of the report, not of the attack. No kept paragraph dates the attack; 'January, 2022' is an inference from the dateline.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Two errors. (1) 'Five suspects directly involved, among them a police officer': the text does not say the arrested policeman is one of the five. (2) Status says 'Seven people were placed in custody' and then lists eight (five suspects, the officer's brother, his fiancee, the victim); the text says seven were arrested (interpellation) and that those eight were put in garde a vue.",
|
||||
"approach": "P2P trade needs an arranged meeting to exchange crypto or cash. The text says only a fictitious agreement to transfer bitcoin; no meeting is described.",
|
||||
"outcome": "Rescued needs the victim freed by police. The text says police caught the gang in the act during the fake search, does not say the victim was present or freed, and then says he was himself placed in custody. Unknown fits what the text shows."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"approach": ["Social engineering: other pretext", "Authority misuse: fake police or official"], "outcome": ["Unknown"], "date": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Scope is doubtful. The man was a money changer in illegal currency exchange, lured with a fictitious bitcoin transfer deal and targeted for the cash proceeds of transfers; nothing in the text says he held crypto or was chosen for it. The owner may rule it out of scope. Theft/obtained 'unconfirmed' confirmed as defensible ('Ils esperaient derober', caught in the act), though 'no'/Nothing is arguable."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L065", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "'Police linked the attack to a $300,000 transaction involving bitcoin that went bad': the text says only that the invasion 'has been linked' to the transaction, not that police linked it. Fix: 'The attack has been linked to ...'. The closing sentence 'No source says whether anything was taken' is a statement about sources, not a fact of the case; cut it.",
|
||||
"date": "Confirmed: 'Monday' in an article published Wednesday 19 January 2022 gives 17 January 2022 (publication date from the page header)."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "who_was_attacked Other with the reader's open point is acceptable; targeting Business counterparty rests on 'transaction gone bad' only."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L066", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "About 1,100 characters, well over the 600 to 900 guide. 'In May 2025 the prosecutor's operation brought charges' dates the charges from the article date; paragraph 21 gives no date for the hearing.",
|
||||
"detention": "Confirmed as 'no' with the reader's open point: drugged unconscious for 18 hours, nobody reported restraining him. If the owner counts incapacitation as being held, detention, venue_of_control ('victim's private space') and held_duration ('hours') all change together."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraphs 22 and 24 are about a different proceeding (Betancur's domestic violence case, hearing of 19 May); they are not about this case and should be cut. Keep should be 2-3, 5-21, 25.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Scope kept: the lure was a woman posing as a crypto expert and his Ethereum was moved."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L067", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "reject", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"detention": "FLAG-RULES: silence in a described attack is 'no', not 'unconfirmed'. The attack is described (armed men, guard threatened, equipment carried out) and no restraint or holding is reported.",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "Follows detention: with nobody reported held, the value is 'none'. 'Victim's workplace' with an unconfirmed detention is inconsistent."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"detention": ["no"], "venue_of_control": ["none"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "case_details 'Violence Used' opens 'Detention not established'; the house format wants 'Detention' or 'No detention'. Fix together with the detention verdict."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L068", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "reject", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The article does not date the robbery ('veio a publico anunciar'); 'February, 2022' comes from the 18 February publication date and Lopp. The support passage contains no date. The summary's 'In February 2022' rests on the same inference.",
|
||||
"detention": "Silence in a described attack is 'no' (FLAG-RULES). The attack is described (robbed in an Uber, forced to unlock the phone, handed it over) and no holding or restraint is reported."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"detention": ["no"], "date": [""]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Out of scope confirmed: the target was the phone; nothing shows he was chosen as a crypto holder. Summary leads with the February 2022 date; adjust together with the date verdict."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L069", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"attack": "Kidnapping needs the victim taken away or held at a place the attackers control. The kept text says he was approached by three people in a car and forced to show his accounts and transfer crypto; no taking away or holding place is described. The charge name alone does not show it (the taking back to the guesthouse is only in Lopp's line). Armed robbery is the label the text shows; owner decides, as in the reader's open point.",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "Confirmed, but the figure 'quase R$ 1 milhao' appears only in the headline, and the support passage (the photo caption) does not contain it. 'Almost' is stored as 1000000.",
|
||||
"summary": "Confirmed; 'a court accepted charges' rests on the headline ('viram reus') and the teaser in paragraph 7."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"attack": ["Armed robbery"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraph 7 ('Justica aceita denuncia contra 4 acusados ...') is a link to another story, not article text; cut it. Keep 1-6, 8-9. The retrieval is also incomplete (no lead), as the reader noted.",
|
||||
"status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L070", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"description": "'asphyxiated her in her vehicle': the text says 'dentro del vehiculo' without saying whose (the reader's own notes say so). Also 'beat' and 'asphyxiated' are fine, but the vehicle ownership is not.",
|
||||
"summary": "Two unsupported specifics: 'a school in Barranquilla' (the text says only 'un colegio'; Barranquilla appears only for the Betania district) and 'pickup truck' (the text says 'camioneta', which is not necessarily a pickup). Use 'a school' and 'a vehicle (camioneta)' or 'a truck'."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Date 28 February 2022 is the day she was last seen; the text does not say the attack happened that day, but it is the date the article gives for the events. The article's 'el 1 de febrero' for the dumping is left out of the summary, which is correct."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L071", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Kept 1-12, 14-28 is the whole crypto.news article (collapse of Zondacrypto with the Suszek section in 16-19); only the embedded tweet 13 is cut. Acceptable.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Duplicate of stats2 485 holds: same victim, same date (March 10, 2022), same Czeladz meeting. The crypto.news link is already on 485 per stats2_url_match, so no new source."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L072", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "reject", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "reject", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "reject", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"summary": "Says 'an earlier text had demanded that E.Z. turn over his laptop with cryptocurrency'. That is paragraph 134 (the December 15, 2021 text to the associate), which the reader cut. Among the kept paragraphs only 70 mentions cryptocurrency (a November 2021 business deal) and none ties crypto to the laptop. Also about 1,000 characters, over the 900 target.",
|
||||
"case_details": "Quotes and facts from cut paragraphs: the December 2021 visit by Iza and bodyguards to the associate's residence (130) and the text demanding 'turn over his laptop with cryptocurrency' (134). Not in the kept text.",
|
||||
"detention": "Kept text says only that the brother 'seize[d] the individual' and then K.C. drove off. No holding, restraint or prevention from leaving is reported; a seizure with nothing after it is closer to a grab than to detention (FLAG-RULES: snatch cases are 'no', thin text is 'unconfirmed').",
|
||||
"targeting": "Business counterparty rests on 'They were involved in business arrangements in the past' (paragraph 64), which is about E.Z. and Iza. The victim was E.Z.'s associate, not Iza's business partner. Surveillance holds (K.C. hired to locate and surveil E.Z., 'tracking down E.Z. and his associate' in 164).",
|
||||
"who_was_attacked": "Holder needs the person believed to hold the assets. The kept text does not say the associate held the laptop or any crypto; he was robbed because of his link to E.Z. Other fits ('anyone else attacked').",
|
||||
"people": "Follows who_was_attacked: the row's role would become Other, detail 'associate of E.Z.'."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"detention": ["unconfirmed"], "targeting": ["Surveillance", "Other"], "who_was_attacked": ["Other"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Kept set includes paragraphs about other incidents: 60-65 (the November 21, 2021 RCSD report, stats2 106) and 34-40 (tax and luxury spending), 164 (long footnote on Telegram evidence about T.W./M.I.), 463 (payments to Deputy 3). It cuts 125-135, the December 2021 passage about the same associate, E.Z.'s dispute over the laptop and the 'laptop with cryptocurrency' text. The reader's own reason text says the November 2021 incident was cut, which it was not.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New (not a duplicate): stats2 124 is the March 30 attempt at E.Z.'s own residence and 106 is the November 2021 gas station incident, both different attacks. Scope: in the kept paragraphs the March 12 robbery is about a laptop and the crypto link (laptop with cryptocurrency) sits only in cut paragraph 134. If 125-135 are kept the entry stands as new; on the kept text alone it is borderline out of scope. Owner decides. Smaller points: outcome Released and approach Seized at or outside the home are weakly supported but acceptable; location is correctly left empty."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L073", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"attack": "Both Kidnapping and Express kidnapping pass the tests, and the reader chose differently from L077 for the same pattern. Text: stopped on a public road, no sign of prior selection, driven around, paid N100,000 at POS stands on the spot (his own N38,000 plus money friends sent to his account, which the officers watched). LABEL-RULES says Express kidnapping stands when the three conditions hold; Kidnapping is for pre-selected or third-party ransom cases. L077 (same facts shape) got Express kidnapping. Make the two consistent; I lean Express kidnapping."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"attack": ["Express kidnapping"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-15, 19-29 is right: 16-18 are 'read also' links, 30-32 copyright and contact.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Out of scope holds: the demand and payment were naira cash through a POS operator, the officers opened the Binance app only to call him a 'Yahoo boy' on a $23 balance, and nobody asked for or took crypto. Contrast L077 where the officers asked how much he had on the app and took crypto. The owner may still overrule."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L074", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"targeting": "Insider tip-off is defined as someone with inside access passing on the victim's holdings or movements. Here the former employee is himself the attacker and nobody passed anything on. The text gives 'once employed' and 'Because they knew each other'. Acquaintance (a social contact who turned attacker) or Other (former employee, say so) fits the words better. This is the reader's own open point; I would not accept Insider tip-off."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting": ["Acquaintance"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Whole 10-paragraph article kept; correct.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New; no stats2 candidate matches (March 16, 2022, San Francisco). Notes: summary is about 975 characters, slightly over the 900 target but every fact is in the text; the summary says 'before he could flee' where the article says 'before officials say he tried to flee'. Location with the neighbourhood is acceptable. Venue 'victim's private space' rests on 'home invasion', which the article never ties to her own home; accepted."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L075", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "reject", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject",
|
||||
"summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"location": "Kept text never says the motel was in Taichung. Paragraph 2 says Huang is 'from Taichung' (台中市黃姓男子) and paragraph 4 that the Taichung District Prosecutors Office charged; the motel's city is not stated (Lopp's line says Taichung). Probably right, but an inference. Owner to decide.",
|
||||
"description": "Says 'lured to a Taichung motel room' (same unsupported city). Also 'more than ten men': the text says 十多人 / 10餘人, people, not men.",
|
||||
"summary": "Two unsupported details: 'a motel room in Taichung' (city not in the text) and 'More than ten men' (text: 10餘人, people). 'Xu ... was behind the attack' is also an inference from the prosecutors' narrative. About 930 characters.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'A man surnamed Yu, in Taichung' repeats the unsupported city. Everything else (quotes, sentences, NT$30,000 proceeds, separate trials) checks against paragraphs 2-8."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"location": ["Taichung"], "description": ["same text with the motel's city and 'men' removed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 2-8 is the article; 1 is the audio notice, 9-10 login prompts, 11-28 other stories, 29-33 comment rules.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New and in scope (crypto dispute, passwords demanded to move crypto). Approach 'dating or sexual lure' rests on a woman posing as an ex-girlfriend inviting him to a motel; acceptable. Currency is written as 元 in the text; the reader leaves currency empty, which is fine. Arrests 'convicted' holds (Huang convicted at both instances, though now wanted)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L076", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "confirm", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "reject", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "reject",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"case_details": "The Violence Used block does not start with 'Detention' or 'No detention' as the house format requires, and it adds a legal definition of razboi ('an attack with violence dangerous to life or health or the threat of it') that is not in the kept text. Remove the definition and open the block with 'Detention: not stated'.",
|
||||
"drugs_alcohol": "The reader sets detention, violence and weapons to unconfirmed because the text is too thin to say what happened, but drugs_alcohol to 'no'. The same thinness applies; 'no' is for a described attack. Set unconfirmed for consistency (borderline, owner may prefer 'no').",
|
||||
"obtained": "The text gives the aim ('с целью хищения денежных средств фирмы, а также серверного оборудования') and 'ущерб более 5,7 млн', but never says what was taken. LABEL-RULES: nothing inferred from what usually happens. Unconfirmed is the literal value (the reader's own open point). Theft yes stands, since 'С похищенным имуществом ... скрылись' says property was stolen."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"drugs_alcohol": ["unconfirmed"], "obtained": ["Unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-6 right; 7-10 are subscription lines, view counter, read-also.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New and in scope by precedent of stats2 353 (mining farm robbery). Notes: attack 'Robbery without a weapon' is literal ('no weapon reported') while weapons is unconfirmed; acceptable. Taken_amount 5,700,000 RUB is the stated damage ('more than'), not an itemised loss; as_stated explains it. Summary about 830 characters and clean; 'razboi' is a transliteration, not a quotation."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L077", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-11, 15-22 right; 12-14 read-also, 23-25 copyright and contact.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New, in scope (officers asked how much he had on the Binance app and took $504 in crypto). Date April 1, 2022 follows from 'coming back on Friday' in an interview on Monday, article of April 6. Summary does not attribute to his own account but is accurate to the text. Consistency note: this case is Express kidnapping while L073 (same pattern) got Kidnapping; I rejected L073's attack for that reason."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L078", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-7 right; 8 is a read-also link.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New and in scope as a crypto ATM theft (same family as stats2 112). Figures check: 52,500 + 127,700 = 180,200 recovered; 286,000 - 180,200 = 105,800, but the article states 55,800 not recovered, and the summary repeats the article's figure, so the discrepancy is the source's. Owner may want it in the notes."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L079", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject",
|
||||
"summary": "reject", "case_details": "reject",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "reject", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "reject", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"description": "'two recruits warned the victim and helped police arrest both organisers' is wrong for Zhou: paragraph 13 says Tang and Dai helped police arrest Li; Zhou was arrested the same day by the police (被公安机关抓获).",
|
||||
"summary": "Two problems. (1) About 1,100 characters, well over the 900 target. (2) 'They bought restraint straps, tape and gloves': the text says they prepared (准备了) the tools; buying is not stated.",
|
||||
"case_details": "'the stun baton (电击棒) was never used on anyone' is not in the text; the paragraph only lists it among seized items. Drop that clause. The rest checks.",
|
||||
"who_was_attacked": "The attackers never met or reached Ruan. Holder requires being confronted, held, hurt or threatened in person, or the target of a remote attack. A foiled plot with no contact does not meet it; the reader itself notes it strains the rule. Owner to decide what who_was_attacked holds for a plot that never reached the victim (Other is the only label that fits).",
|
||||
"approach": "The plan was to pose as 防疫人员 (epidemic-prevention workers). That reads more like a worker ruse than a fake police or official; service ruse (worker) or 'other claimed role' are both defensible. Not settled by the text; owner decides.",
|
||||
"people": "LABEL rule: no rows when the attackers met nobody. Ruan was never met. The reader flagged the strain itself."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"approach": ["Authority misuse: service ruse (delivery, driver, worker)", "Authority misuse: other claimed role"], "who_was_attacked": ["Other"], "people": []},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-18, 39-40 is right: statute text and doctrine in 19-38 carry no case fact.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New. A plot that reached the preparation stage (scouting, travel to Ningde) and was foiled by the recruits is in scope by the foiled outcome. Weapons no follows the 72/233 rulings (stun baton seized, never shown). Detention no and outcome Foiled hold."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L080", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm",
|
||||
"summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm",
|
||||
"detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "reject", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm",
|
||||
"venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm",
|
||||
"demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm",
|
||||
"targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm",
|
||||
"people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {
|
||||
"summary": "'14 were blocked and returned to the couple' drops the hedge: the text says 'Estima-se que ... 14 já tenham sido devolvidas' (estimated returned) and, separately, that 'a maior parte' was blocked. 'the headline puts the holdings at R$ 2.5 million' names a source part and rests on a headline. About 1,050 characters, over the 900 target.",
|
||||
"violence_torture": "'threat only' needs a threat of harm. The text says the men overpowered (renderam) the husband and told him his wife was held; no threat of harm is stated and no violence reported. FLAG-RULES points to 'no'. Reader's own open point.",
|
||||
"approach": "'invadiram a residência' means they invaded the home; LABEL-RULES says the text must show force or a break-in, and the delegado says only 'foram até o apartamento'. The wife was seized 'em um determinado local' (unstated). Unknown is the literal value."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"violence_torture": ["no"], "approach": ["Unknown"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Keep 1-16 right. Paragraph 7 is a photo caption (names the delegado); harmless, though 17 (the other caption) is cut, so the treatment is uneven.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "New and in scope. Date 'May, 2022' follows from 'em maio' in a November 2022 article. Venue 'attacker's or third-party space' is acceptable although the husband was overpowered in his own apartment. Targeting Acquaintance holds (headline 'Amiga', recurring visits, insider information)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L081", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"approach": "Three of the five were not police (tradesman Ali Yılmaz, Oktay Çam, Selimoğlu) and were dressed in police vests to pose as police; that passes Authority misuse: fake police or official. Only serving police is set."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"approach": ["Authority misuse: serving police or official", "Authority misuse: fake police or official"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L082", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "reject", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Every fact is in the kept text, but the length is about 1,000 characters, over the 600 to 900 limit. Trim e.g. the last sentence or the court-reasoning clause.", "venue_of_control": "The text says control began after the car reached a remote mountain forest (在车辆行驶至偏僻山林后); no passage places the victim in a moving vehicle while held. The reader's 'precedent of similar cases' is not in the text. Owner to decide (public space or leave empty)."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"venue_of_control": ["public space"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraph 22 ends with the Sohu boilerplate 返回搜狐,查看更多; unavoidable in a whole-paragraph keep.", "status_notes": "Not the same attack as L079 (Ningde, April 2022, Mr. Ruan)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L083", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "reject", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "reject", "demanded_currency": "reject", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"description": "Says 'injected with a syringe'; the text says he was pricked ('înțepată') with a syringe with a thin needle and then felt faint. No paragraph says anything was injected.", "summary": "Same 'injected him in the abdomen with a syringe' is not in the text (pricked with a syringe, then felt faint). Also about 1,050 characters, over the 600 to 900 limit.", "drugs_alcohol": "No kept paragraph says a drug or sedative was given; it says he was pricked with a syringe and then felt faint and had tingling. By precedent (ruling 368, effect without a source saying drugged) this is unconfirmed.", "demanded_amount": "The EUR 3 million is an alleged debt to the London man, not a demand made to the victim; the attackers wanted account passwords and the EUR 200,000 to 300,000 was the victim's own promise. No demand figure is stated.", "demanded_currency": "Follows demanded_amount."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"drugs_alcohol": ["unconfirmed"], "demanded_amount": [null], "demanded_currency": [null]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Not the same attack as L078 (Timisoara ATM theft)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L084", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "reject", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Every fact is in the kept paragraphs (55, 60, 101, 107, 110, 115, 160), but at about 190 words (roughly 1,000 characters) it is over the 600 to 900 limit. Trim, e.g. drop the 'about forty minutes' clause or the glasses detail.", "targeting_accuracy": "Unsure. The court (para 115) speaks of 'de Bitcoin-account van [benadeelde partij 1]' as her account and a co-defendant was told 'een meisje Bitcoins had' (117), which may count as crypto confirmed as hers; but no holdings are shown. Owner decides Unknown or Correct."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting_accuracy": ["Correct"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Court XML nests sections, so paragraph 54 repeats 55; the chosen set covers charges, facts, identification, weapon findings, proof, sentence and damages.", "status_notes": ""}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L085", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "The reader's open point on attack (Armed robbery vs Kidnapping) is a fair one for the owner; the text does not show pre-selection or a long distance, so Armed robbery stands."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L086", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "reject", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"date": "The kept text says 'on June 11' and gives no year; 2022 comes only from Lopp's line (the page has no publication date). The reader noted this in notes but set a full date and raised no open point. Owner decides whether to accept Lopp's year.", "summary": "Opens 'On June 11, 2022', so the year is not supported by the kept text (same as date). Also about 1,000 characters, over the 600 to 900 limit; the sentence on the wives being sisters and the fall-out can be shortened."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"date": ["June 11, 2022"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Not the same attack as stats2 134 (Lucknow) or L088 (Nashik)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L087", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraphs 9-13 (El Campello digital-currency pilot) are background inside the article, kept under the reader rule; the owner may prefer to cut them.", "status_notes": "The open point on who_was_attacked (Relative or partner vs Holder) is genuine: paragraph 4 says 'sus criptomonedas' while paragraph 8 says the husband refused the keys."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L088", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "reject",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "(1) 'barred him from Nashik district and Aurangabad until the trial ends' is in paragraph 11, which the reader cut; (2) 'The abductors transferred 3.27 units' : the order says 'the unknown persons had transferred', it does not say the abductors did; (3) 'noting that nothing had been recovered from him' : the order lists 'no recovery from the present applicant' as part of the prosecution case, not as a finding of the court; (4) abduction, knifepoint and demand are stated as fact though the order gives them as 'the prosecution case'."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "L088-2: keep 3-7 omits paragraphs 8 (monthly reporting to the investigating officer) and 11 (ban on entering Nashik district and Aurangabad), both used in case_details and summary. Keep 3-8 and 11, or drop those facts. case_details is confirmed on the condition that 8 and 11 are kept. L088-1 (403 page) correctly empty. Location Nashik rests on the Satpur police station and the victim's residence, not on a stated place of seizure.", "status_notes": "Not the same attack as L086 or stats2 134."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L089", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Every fact is in the kept paragraphs (15, 20, 26, 12-13), but it runs to about 1,100 characters, over the 600 to 900 limit. Merge the cash and trade-pretence sentences and shorten the sentencing sentence."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "The reader's open point on detention (yes vs no) is real. Yes is defensible: paragraphs 26 and 27 find him alone in a car the defendants controlled, door locked, accelerating."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L090", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Every fact is in the kept text (paragraphs 2, 4, 5, 7, 8) but the length is about 1,050 characters, over the 600 to 900 limit. Shorten, e.g. drop the lookouts sentence or merge the stash and crypto sentences."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "", "status_notes": "Status new is acceptable but borderline: the plan (paragraph 2) was to take 'geld en drugs'; crypto appears only as something the kidnappers tried to get in the hut (paragraph 4). The reader's open point (new vs out of scope) is a fair call for the owner. The date rests on 'Een paar weken voor 25 juli 2022' (the plan), the attack day itself is implied, not stated."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L091", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Facts are all in the kept text, but the summary runs to about 990 characters, over the 900 limit, because of the drug seizure details (steroids, hashish, cash, scale) that have nothing to do with the couple's case. Cut those.", "attack": "Express kidnapping needs three things: not pre-selected, seized in public, made to pay from own funds on the spot or in a vehicle. The text says only 'sequestro relampago' on the Rodovia Ayrton Senna, restriction of liberty, and that a suspect received R$100k in crypto. It does not say how they were seized, where they were held or whose money was paid, and the reader's note that they were 'seized on a highway' is not in the text. Only the outlet's own term supports the label."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"attack": ["Kidnapping", "No label fits"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Only paragraph 5 (Leia tambem link) is cut; correct.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Out of scope holds: the article itself says it is not clear the couple held any crypto; crypto is only how the suspect was paid."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L092", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Length only: about 1,050 characters, over the 900 limit. Every fact I checked is in the kept text (minor: 'outside her home' is inferred from 'habia salido a recibir al sodero'). Trim the July 30 attempt and the migration detail."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Approach note for the owner, not a reject: the August 12 seizure of the former partner ended with the attackers taking control of her house, so Forced entry is an alternative reading to Seized at or outside the home."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L093", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "reject", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"attack": "Express kidnapping needs payment from his own funds on the spot or in a vehicle. The text says he was held 12 hours 'em posse dos sequestradores', beaten several times and not fed, and made to pay by PIX and a transfer; it does not say where he was held or that the payment was made at the spot of the seizure. A 12-hour holding with beatings is the Kidnapping test (held away from the public)."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"attack": ["Kidnapping"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraph 3 (a different bitcoin-investor case) is cut as another story; defensible, but it sits in the article's own background block like paragraphs 2 and 4. No value depends on it.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Summary is about 945 characters, at the top of the range; accepted. Date 'August ?, 2022' rests on the Aug 25 publication date plus 'nos ultimos dias'; fine. The open point on targeting (Unknown vs Public profile) is the owner's call."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L094", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "reject", "country": "confirm", "description": "reject", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "reject", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"location": "'Buffer zone, Nicosia district' puts the buffer zone in Nicosia district; the article names no place for the buffer-zone episode. Only the confinement house ('epar. Lefkosias') and the later encounter with his mother ('sti Lefkosia') are placed in Nicosia.", "description": "Says the fake police were 'of the north'; the article says only 'astynomikoi tou pseudokratous' (of the pseudo-state). 'North' is not in the text.", "summary": "Two problems. Length is about 985 characters, over 900. And 'the self-declared state in the north' adds 'in the north', which no kept paragraph says.", "targeting": "Acquaintance needs a friend or social contact turned attacker. The text never says the three men were his friends or contacts, only that they took him to the buffer zone on a hunting pretext. How they knew of his crypto is not said.", "approach": "Social invitation is for a friend or acquaintance inviting him (dinner, party, night out). The text gives a hunting pretext from men whose relationship to him is not stated, so the fit is Social engineering: other pretext."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"location": ["Nicosia"], "targeting": ["Unknown"], "approach": ["Social engineering: other pretext", "Authority misuse: fake police or official"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Date '2022' is safe; the open point on October 2022 is the owner's call. Minor: case_details says the EUR 50,000 from a suspect was 'part of the staging'; the text only says a suspect would give another EUR 50,000."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L095", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraphs 3 and 4 (two earlier unrelated cases) are cut as other stories; defensible, though they sit in the article's own background block like paragraph 2. No value depends on them.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Summary is about 935 characters; 'gave chase' is a loose reading of a garbled sentence ('foi iniciado um certo aos criminosos'). Date October 3 follows the dated source although October 3, 2022 was a Monday; the reader noted this. Open point violence yes vs threat only is a fair owner call (the flag test counts a shot officer as physical violence against a person)."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L096", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "reject", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"targeting": "The attackers are the two robbers (Mar del Plata); the neighbour who knew the trader's activity and had done business with him is the suspected informant ('Goni pudo haber actuado como informante'). That is an Insider tip-off, which the prosecutor's working theory supports. Business counterparty describes attackers who knew him from trades; the robbers are not shown to have. Owner may keep both."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"targeting": ["Insider tip-off", "Business counterparty"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Summary about 890 characters, fine. The 70 million pesos versus about 130,000 pesos in crypto plus cash discrepancy is named in case_details and notes; taken_amount follows the stated total, which is acceptable."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L097", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "confirm", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "In scope only as a Bitcoin ATM theft inside a general ram-raid; the store was not targeted for crypto. The owner may rule it out. The summary describes the second group's feigned-gun charge while the flags and labels leave it out, so violence_torture 'no' and the open point on who_was_attacked go together; if the owner counts the second encounter, violence becomes threat only."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L098", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Three points. (1) Length about 1,150 characters, well over 900. (2) 'The cash was never recovered': the kept text says only that the NT$1,712,800 is 'weian kou' (not seized) and that the victim has not been compensated; recovery is not stated. (3) 'shoved him hard into the counter': the victim says he was pushed into the counter, but the court finds he did not fall and only tilted toward it ('weixie'); the two accounts should not be merged. Also 'a seller he had dealt with' overstates a first Telegram offer."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "Paragraph selection is sound: facts, victim and co-defendant testimony, the court's finding on the shove, charge qualification and all three sentences are kept; admissibility, defence and statute text are cut. Paragraph 18 and 102 carry the confiscation figures case_details uses.",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Open point on outcome (Released vs Nobody held or hurt) is a fair owner call; the victim was confronted and shoved but never held. Violence 'yes' rests on the court calling the push a 'shibao xingwei' though too slight for quasi-robbery; acceptable."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L099", "status_verdict": "confirm", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "confirm", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Length only: about 1,100 characters, over the 900 limit. The facts match the kept text. Trim the street addresses and the payment logistics."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Scope is thin: a debt-collection kidnapping where the debt arose from a crypto scheme's money mule; no crypto demanded or taken and neither brother shown to hold crypto. Kept as new, in line with the debt-dispute precedent; the owner may rule it out. The EUR 500 taken (versus possibly EUR 1,000 in total) follows the civil-liability wording and is flagged in taken_as_stated."}
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
|
||||
{"key": "L100", "status_verdict": "reject", "pages_verdict": "confirm",
|
||||
"verdicts": {"date": "confirm", "victim": "confirm", "location": "confirm", "country": "confirm", "description": "confirm", "summary": "reject", "case_details": "confirm", "detention": "confirm", "violence_torture": "reject", "drugs_alcohol": "confirm", "weapons": "confirm", "theft": "confirm", "life_taken": "confirm", "venue_of_control": "confirm", "held_duration": "confirm", "arrests": "confirm", "demanded_amount": "confirm", "demanded_currency": "confirm", "demanded_usd_stated": "confirm", "demanded_as_stated": "confirm", "taken_amount": "confirm", "taken_currency": "confirm", "taken_usd_stated": "confirm", "taken_as_stated": "confirm", "targeting": "confirm", "targeting_accuracy": "confirm", "who_was_attacked": "confirm", "approach": "confirm", "attack": "confirm", "outcome": "confirm", "obtained": "confirm", "people": "confirm", "sources": "confirm", "name_withheld": "confirm"},
|
||||
"reasons": {"summary": "Length about 1,050 characters, over 900. It also leaves out that official sources said she drugged him ('la chica adormeció con droga'); the text gives only that he remembers drinking alcohol with her and woke sore. Facts stated are supported.", "violence_torture": "He woke 'completamente dolorido' with no cause given. That raises possible injury without attributing it, which is the 'raised and left open' case rather than silence. 'no' may be right; the owner decides."},
|
||||
"alternatives": {"violence_torture": ["unconfirmed"]},
|
||||
"pages_notes": "",
|
||||
"status_notes": "Status: out of scope is doubtful. The headline and first paragraph make the stolen Ledger hardware wallet the lead item, and the owner kept a theft-by-deception case (ruling on 285) in the database. No article passage shows he was chosen as a crypto holder, so out of scope is defensible too; this is the owner's call, not a clear error."}
|
||||
Some files were not shown because too many files have changed in this diff Show More
Reference in New Issue
Block a user