chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases

Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step
label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of
2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch
(scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of
2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added
to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore).

The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on
2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
This commit is contained in:
StellarCrow
2026-10-17 10:47:37 +02:00
parent 0f7a691151
commit 41766c68a2
3196 changed files with 374809 additions and 485 deletions
+40
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
# Carrying out a ruled split or rewrite of a record
The owner of a database of physical attacks on crypto holders has ruled that a record must be split into two records, or rewritten to describe a different incident. You write the resulting record or records from the sources on file.
Working directory: `~/Documents/Claude/GART/03-research-and-publishing/DB-cleanup/merge-output`
1. Read `splits/in-<id>.json`: the record as it stands, with its sources and the dossier path.
2. Find the ruling: Grep `corrections-approved.md` for `DB id <id>` and Read every hit in full. Also Grep `HANDOVER-SOFI.md` in the parent folder (`../HANDOVER-SOFI.md`) for the case number, and `structural-ops.json`.
3. Read the dossier in full with the Read tool. It is the only source of facts. Fetch nothing from the web.
4. Read `LABEL-RULES.md` and `FLAG-RULES.md` in full.
5. Write `splits/out-<id>.json`:
```json
{"id": 38, "ruling": "the ruling text you carried out, quoted",
"records": [
{"keeps_id": true,
"date": "March 22, 2018", "victim": "...", "location": "...", "country": "...",
"description": "one or two plain sentences",
"summary": "**Victims:** ... **Attackers:** ... **Attack Method:** ... **Violence Used:** ... **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** ... **Status:** ...",
"notes": "...", "money_wanted": "...", "coin_type": "...",
"detention": "yes|no|unconfirmed", "violence_torture": "yes|no|unconfirmed|threat only", "drugs_alcohol": "...", "weapons": "...", "theft": "...", "life_taken": "0",
"targeting": ["..."], "targeting_accuracy": "...", "who_was_attacked": ["..."], "approach": ["..."], "attack": ["..."], "outcome": "...", "obtained": ["..."],
"sources": ["the URLs from the input that report this incident"],
"support": [{"claim": "short claim", "quote": "exact passage from the dossier"}]},
{"keeps_id": false, "...": "the second record, same keys (splits only)"}
],
"notes_for_owner": "anything the dossier does not settle"}
```
Rules:
- A rewrite gives one record (`keeps_id` true). A split gives two: the one the ruling says keeps the id, and the new one.
- Every fact comes from the dossier or the ruling. Invent nothing. Where the dossier is silent, say "not stated" in the summary and use `unknown` or `unconfirmed` for the label or flag.
- Labels spelled exactly as in `step-labels.json`; every label passes its test in LABEL-RULES.md; flags follow FLAG-RULES.md. There is no "failed" outcome: stopped before anyone was under control is `foiled`. A relative who was not present and not in custody was not attacked.
- Summary: house format, one paragraph, the six bold labels in that order; "Violence Used" starts with "Detention" or "No detention" and says why.
- Dates in the forms the database uses: "March 22, 2018", "May ?, 2021", "2021".
- A `support` entry for every factual claim in the summary and for every flag and label; each quote is one contiguous passage copied character for character from the dossier.
- Plain English, straight quotes, no em dash or en dash (use commas, colons, "to").
- Read project files with the Read tool; never open saved tool-output copies under /home/disi/.claude or /tmp; run no git commands; write only `splits/out-<id>.json`. Check it parses.
Reply with: the id, the number of records written, one line per record (date, place, attack, outcome), and the notes for the owner.
+44
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
{
"id": 38,
"date": "March 22, 2018",
"victim": "Multiple gas stations",
"location": "Irving & Mesquite, Texas",
"country": "USA",
"description": "Robbers douse clerks with pepper spray, steal from Bitcoin ATMs in Irving and Mesquite",
"summary": "**Victims:** The clerks of two Dallas-area petrol stations with Bitcoin ATMs inside them, and the operators of those machines: a Chevron in the 7200 block of North MacArthur Boulevard at State Highway 161 in Irving, where the clerk is described as a man, and an Exxon in the 2200 block of Oates Drive near North Galloway Avenue in Mesquite, where the clerk is described as a woman. No crypto holder was targeted; the record's single victim entry covers two separate robberies. **Attackers:** Two men, unidentified and at large. Police described them as black men in their late 20s to early 30s: the first about 6 feet and 180 pounds, in a grey and black Nike hoodie, blue jeans and black and white sneakers; the second about 6 feet and 140 to 160 pounds, in a black jacket, sagging jeans, maroon sneakers, blue gloves and a grey Oakland Raiders cap. In the Mesquite robbery Fox 4 describes a man in a grey hoodie and a red Nike cap. **Attack Method:** The first robbery happened around 10 p.m. on 22 March 2018 in Irving. Surveillance footage shows a man walk in and spray the clerk with bear deterrent, a type of pepper spray stronger than what is sold for self-defence against humans; a second man follows, hands him a crowbar, and he pries open the Bitcoin ATM while the accomplice stands guard near the register and the clerk wipes his eyes. The pair left with the cash containers and sped off in a grey or silver SUV. Irving Police Officer James McLellan said: \"Once the suspects incapacitated the clerk, then they were able to just break into it and steal the cash cassettes.\" Six days later, on 28 March, the Mesquite Bitcoin ATM was targeted: video shows a man buying Gatorade at the counter and looking straight at the camera, then returning to spray the female clerk with bear spray while his partner broke into the machine; Fox 4 puts this at around 11:30 a.m. The pair then fled in a vehicle. **Violence Used:** No detention — in both robberies the clerk was incapacitated with bear spray and the machine broken open; nobody is described as bound, held or prevented from leaving. Mesquite Police Lt. Brian Parrish said: \"It's one thing to steal or rob from someone. It's another to hurt a defenseless clerk.\" **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** No cryptocurrency. The robbers took the cash cassettes from inside the Bitcoin ATMs. Police did not disclose how much money was stolen; Lt. Parrish said only, \"Seems like these machines do contain some cash.\" **Status:** The pair remained at large; police in Irving and Mesquite were both looking for them and Crime Stoppers offered $5,000 for their names. No arrests are reported in the file.",
"notes": "cash robberies from btc atms",
"money_wanted": "",
"coin_type": "",
"flags": {
"detention": "no",
"violence_torture": "yes",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "yes",
"theft": "yes"
},
"life_taken": "0",
"steps": {
"targeting": [
"unknown"
],
"targeting_accuracy": "correct",
"who_was_attacked": [
"employee or guard",
"business premises or machine"
],
"approach": [
"walked in"
],
"attack": [
"Armed Robbery"
],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": [
"cash"
]
},
"sources": [
"https://www.fox4news.com/news/bitcoin-bandits-target-dallas-county-cryptocurrency-atms"
],
"dossier": "sources/038_Multiple-gas-stations.txt"
}
+43
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
{
"id": 49,
"date": "May 20, 2018",
"victim": "13y old boy",
"location": "Witbank, Mpumalanga",
"country": "South Africa",
"description": "13 y old boy kidnapped for crypto ransom.",
"summary": "**Victims:** A 13-year-old boy from Witbank, Mpumalanga, snatched near his home, and — in the second incident on the same record — a 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg. Neither is named. **Attackers:** Two men said by Mpumalanga police to be behind both incidents, arrested after months of investigation by a South African Police Service task team. The body of the report gives their ages as 30 and 31; the photo caption on the same report says both were 37 and that they were among targeted suspects linked to multiple cases of armed robbery, carjacking and kidnapping in the Sekhukhune district. Brigadier Leonard Hlathi announced the arrests. **Attack Method:** The boy was snatched near his home on 20 May 2018 as he walked back from a nearby spaza shop with a friend. Part of the kidnapping, which happened in broad daylight, was caught on a neighbour's CCTV camera; TimesLIVE saw the footage, which shows the boy forced into a silver-coloured Toyota Corolla that sped off with him inside while his friend stood in disbelief. After his parents rushed to the police station to report it, they returned to find a ransom note in their yard. On 21 August 2018 the same suspects attempted to kidnap a 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg: they dragged her into their VW Polo, but she shouted for help, a group of people working nearby heard her and came to her aid, and she got away; the men fled, leaving the car behind with their belongings inside. Police established that they had the same intentions as in the first case. **Violence Used:** Detention — the boy was forced into a car near his home and held for a few days before being reunited with his family unharmed. In the second incident there was no detention: the girl was dragged into the vehicle but escaped when workers nearby intervened. No injuries are reported in either incident. **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** For the boy, a ransom in the form of Bitcoin, the amount demanded being the equivalent of R1.5m. Police had not disclosed whether any ransom was paid for his safe return. **Status:** Hlathi said these were the first cases of their kind in Mpumalanga. One suspect was arrested in November in Germiston, Gauteng, the second in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal, on 30 December. Both appeared in court on the Tuesday before the report and were granted R1,000 bail each.",
"notes": "not in lopps list",
"money_wanted": "R1.5m",
"coin_type": "BTC",
"flags": {
"detention": "yes",
"violence_torture": "no",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "no",
"theft": "unconfirmed"
},
"life_taken": "0",
"steps": {
"targeting": [
"unknown"
],
"targeting_accuracy": "unknown",
"who_was_attacked": [
"relative or partner"
],
"approach": [
"seized in the street or a public place"
],
"attack": [
"Kidnapping"
],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": [
"unconfirmed"
]
},
"sources": [
"https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-01-17-mpumalanga-police-arrest-two-bitcoin-kidnapping-suspects/"
],
"dossier": "sources/049_13y-old-boy.txt"
}
+44
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
{
"id": 5,
"date": "May 27, 2015",
"victim": "28-year-old man, unnamed",
"location": "Crown Heights, New York",
"country": "USA",
"description": "Firefighter kidnapped, robbed of $1,100, & stabbed by crypto thieves",
"summary": "**Victims:** The record names Dwayne Richards, a New York City firefighter, and describes him as kidnapped, robbed of $1,100 and stabbed. The only article on file, CNBC, names nobody. It reports two separate matters: a 28-year-old man, not named and not described as a firefighter, robbed at gunpoint of $1,100 worth of bitcoin in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn on 27 May; and, separately, \"a New York City firefighter\" who the Observer said had been stabbed during a robbery of bitcoins he had agreed to sell — a robbery police told CNBC occurred on Feb. 9 and \"is not bitcoin related\", in which the firefighter's credit card and PIN number were stolen and he was stabbed in the arm. **Attackers:** At least two men in the 27 May robbery, none named: the purported buyer who had answered the victim's Craigslist.com ad offering bitcoins for sale, and another man sitting in the backseat of a car who pulled a gun, all according to police. **Attack Method:** Police said the robbery happened at around 11:30 a.m. on May 27. The victim told police he went to a street corner in Crown Heights to meet the man who had answered his Craigslist ad. The purported buyer then led him to a car to complete the purchase, where the man in the backseat pulled a gun and ordered him to electronically transfer the bitcoins to the thieves. After he sent them, the thieves took his cellphone and drove off; the victim then called 911. **Violence Used:** Detention — per police he was led to the buyer's car and held there under the gun until he made the transfer (the record's own flag legend counts being held at gunpoint, however short). No injury is reported in that robbery. The stabbing in the record's description belongs to the Feb. 9 firefighter case, which police told CNBC \"is not bitcoin related\". **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** $1,100 worth of bitcoin, transferred electronically under the gun, plus the victim's cellphone. A police spokeswoman said there was no surveillance video footage of the \"virtual money stickup\" available. **Status:** \"It's still under investigation,\" the police spokeswoman said. No arrest is reported for this robbery; the article's line that \"No arrests have been made\" refers to the separate Katz robbery it also covers.",
"notes": "kidnapped, robbed, and stabbed The stabbing is not part of this record: it belongs to the separate Dwayne Richards firefighter case (February 2015, Observer), which police told CNBC is not bitcoin related.",
"money_wanted": "$1,100",
"coin_type": "BTC",
"flags": {
"detention": "yes",
"violence_torture": "threat only",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "yes",
"theft": "yes"
},
"life_taken": "0",
"steps": {
"targeting": [
"online contact or advert"
],
"targeting_accuracy": "correct",
"who_was_attacked": [
"holder"
],
"approach": [
"P2P Trade"
],
"attack": [
"Armed Robbery"
],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": [
"crypto",
"devices or seed"
]
},
"sources": [
"https://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/05/new-york-city-man-robbed-at-gunpoint-for-bitcoin.html"
],
"dossier": "sources/005_Dwayne-Richards.txt"
}
+103
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,103 @@
{
"id": 38,
"ruling": "corrections-approved.md: \"DB id 38 (owner) - split into Irving (22 March 2018) and Mesquite (28 March 2018); both bear-spray ATM robberies with clerks present.\" structural-ops.json: \"38 becomes two records: Irving, 22 March 2018, and Mesquite, 28 March 2018\". The earlier incident (Irving) keeps the id.",
"records": [
{
"keeps_id": true,
"date": "March 22, 2018",
"victim": "Clerk and Bitcoin ATM at a Chevron gas station",
"location": "Irving, Texas",
"country": "USA",
"description": "Two men sprayed the clerk of an Irving Chevron with bear spray, pried open the store's Bitcoin ATM with a crowbar and left with its cash containers.",
"summary": "**Victims:** The clerk of a Chevron petrol station in the 7200 block of North MacArthur Boulevard at State Highway 161 in Irving, described as a man, and the Bitcoin ATM inside the store. No crypto holder was targeted. **Attackers:** Two men, unidentified and at large. Police described them as black men in their late 20s to early 30s: the first about 6 feet and 180 pounds, in a grey and black Nike hoodie, blue jeans and black and white sneakers; the second about 6 feet and 140 to 160 pounds, in a black jacket, sagging jeans, maroon sneakers, blue gloves and a grey Oakland Raiders cap. Fox 4 calls them a heavyset man in a grey hoodie and a thin man in a Raiders hat. **Attack Method:** Around 10 p.m. on 22 March 2018, surveillance footage shows a man in a hoodie walk in and spray the clerk with bear deterrent, a type of pepper spray stronger than what is sold for self-defence against humans. A second man follows and hands him a crowbar, and the first man pries open the Bitcoin ATM while the accomplice stands guard near the register and the clerk wipes his eyes. The pair left the store with the cash containers and sped off in a grey or silver SUV. Irving Police Officer James McLellan said that once the suspects had incapacitated the clerk they were able to break into the machine and steal the cash cassettes. Fox 4 calls it the first of two Bitcoin ATM robberies in Dallas County that month; the second, in Mesquite on 28 March, is a separate record. **Violence Used:** No detention: the clerk was incapacitated with bear spray while the machine was broken open, and the sources do not describe him as bound, held or prevented from leaving. Bear spray and a crowbar were used. No drugs and no deaths are reported. **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** No cryptocurrency. The robbers took the cash containers from inside the Bitcoin ATM. Police did not disclose how much money was stolen. **Status:** The pair remained at large. Irving police were looking for them and Crime Stoppers offered $5,000 for their names. No arrests are reported in the file.",
"notes": "Cash robbery from a Bitcoin ATM. Split from the former combined record 38 (Irving and Mesquite); the Mesquite robbery of March 28, 2018 is now its own record.",
"money_wanted": "",
"coin_type": "",
"detention": "no",
"violence_torture": "yes",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "yes",
"theft": "yes",
"life_taken": "0",
"targeting": ["unknown"],
"targeting_accuracy": "correct",
"who_was_attacked": ["employee or guard", "business premises or machine"],
"approach": ["walked in"],
"attack": ["Armed Robbery"],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": ["cash"],
"sources": [
"https://www.fox4news.com/news/bitcoin-bandits-target-dallas-county-cryptocurrency-atms"
],
"support": [
{"claim": "Date, time and place: around 10 p.m. on 22 March at the Chevron in the 7200 block of North MacArthur Boulevard, Irving", "quote": "The first robbery happened around 10 p.m. March 22 at the Chevron in the 7200 block of North MacArthur Boulevard, at State Highway 161."},
{"claim": "Irving was the first of the two robberies, on 22 March", "quote": "Irving saw the first bitcoin robbery on March 22."},
{"claim": "The site was a gas station in Irving with a Bitcoin ATM; the pair remain at large", "quote": "A pair of robbers remain at large after breaking into a Bitcoin ATM at an Irving gas station and spraying a clerk with bear deterrent."},
{"claim": "The clerk was a man", "quote": "The accomplice stands guard near the register while the clerk wipes his eyes."},
{"claim": "A man walked in and sprayed the clerk with bear deterrent (approach: walked in; violence_torture yes; weapons yes; who was attacked: employee or guard)", "quote": "Surveillance footage shows a man in a hoodie walk in and spray the clerk with bear deterrent"},
{"claim": "Bear deterrent is a pepper spray stronger than the kind sold for self-defence against humans", "quote": "a type of pepper spray stronger than what's sold for self-defense against humans."},
{"claim": "A second man handed over a crowbar and the first pried open the ATM (weapons yes; who was attacked: business premises or machine; attack: Armed Robbery)", "quote": "A second man follows and hands a crowbar to the first robber, who pries open the ATM."},
{"claim": "The pair left with the cash containers in a grey or silver SUV; amount not disclosed (theft yes; obtained cash; outcome released: the attackers left of their own accord)", "quote": "The pair then leave the store with cash containers from the ATM and speed off in a gray or silver SUV. Police did not disclose how much money was stolen."},
{"claim": "Officer McLellan: the clerk was incapacitated, then the machine was broken into and the cash cassettes stolen (detention no: incapacitated by spray, no holding described; targeting accuracy correct: the machine held the cash sought)", "quote": "Once the suspects incapacitated the clerk, then they were able to just break into it and steal the cash cassettes"},
{"claim": "Irving Police Officer James McLellan is the speaker", "quote": "explained Irving Police Officer James McLellan."},
{"claim": "Police description: black men in their late 20s to early 30s", "quote": "Police described the robbers as black men in their late 20s to early 30s."},
{"claim": "First robber's description", "quote": "The first was about 6 feet tall and 180 pounds, and was wearing a gray and black Nike hoodie, blue jeans and black and white sneakers."},
{"claim": "Second robber's description", "quote": "140 to 160 pounds, and was wearing a black jacket, sagging jeans over blue underwear, maroon sneakers, blue gloves and a gray Oakland Raiders cap."},
{"claim": "Fox 4's description of the Irving pair", "quote": "In the Irving case, a heavyset guy in a gray hoodie goes in and sprays the clerk. A thin man in a Raiders hat then hands him a crowbar and goes to work on the ATM machine."},
{"claim": "Fox 4 reports two Bitcoin ATM robberies that month; the spray was used to overpower clerks", "quote": "In late March, two bitcoin ATMs were ravaged by robbers who used high-powered pepper spray known as bear spray to overpower clerks and rob the machines."},
{"claim": "Police in Irving were looking for the robbers", "quote": "Police in Irving and Mesquite are now looking for the bitcoin bandits."},
{"claim": "Crime Stoppers reward of $5,000", "quote": "Crime Stoppers is offering $5,000 for the names of the bitcoin bandits. Anyone with information is urged to contact Mesquite or Irving PD."},
{"claim": "Targeting unknown: the sources give only a general remark on why Bitcoin ATMs are robbed, nothing on how this station was chosen", "quote": "The motive is the same in both bitcoin robberies."},
{"claim": "drugs_alcohol no, life_taken 0: the attack is described in full and neither a drug nor a death is reported", "quote": "A second man follows and hands a crowbar to the first robber, who pries open the ATM. The accomplice stands guard near the register while the clerk wipes his eyes."}
]
},
{
"keeps_id": false,
"date": "March 28, 2018",
"victim": "Clerk and Bitcoin ATM at an Exxon gas station",
"location": "Mesquite, Texas",
"country": "USA",
"description": "Two robbers sprayed the female clerk of a Mesquite Exxon with bear spray and broke into the store's Bitcoin ATM, six days after a similar robbery in Irving.",
"summary": "**Victims:** The clerk of an Exxon petrol station in the 2200 block of Oates Drive, near North Galloway Avenue in Mesquite, described as a woman, and the Bitcoin ATM inside the store. No crypto holder was targeted. **Attackers:** Two people, unidentified. The one who used the spray is described as a man in a grey hoodie and a red Nike cap; the sources give no description of the second, whom Fox 4 calls his partner. Fox 4 treats them as the pair behind the Irving robbery of 22 March; the sources do not quote police saying so. **Attack Method:** On 28 March 2018, around 11:30 a.m., video shows a man buying Gatorade at the counter and looking straight at the camera. He then returned and sprayed the female clerk with bear spray, and his partner broke into the store's Bitcoin ATM. The pair then fled in a vehicle, police said. **Violence Used:** No detention: the clerk was sprayed while the machine was broken open, and the sources do not describe her as bound, held or prevented from leaving. Mesquite Police Lt. Brian Parrish spoke of hurting \"a defenseless clerk\". Bear spray was used; the tool used on the machine is not stated. No drugs and no deaths are reported. **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** No cryptocurrency. The reporting says the robbers stole from the machine and Lt. Parrish said such machines \"do contain some cash\"; what was taken in Mesquite and how much are not stated. **Status:** Mesquite police were looking for the robbers and Crime Stoppers offered $5,000 for their names. No arrests are reported in the file.",
"notes": "Cash robbery from a Bitcoin ATM. Split from the former combined record 38 (Irving and Mesquite); the Irving robbery of March 22, 2018 keeps id 38. That cash was taken in Mesquite rests on the headline and the general passages; no source itemises the Mesquite take.",
"money_wanted": "",
"coin_type": "",
"detention": "no",
"violence_torture": "yes",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "yes",
"theft": "yes",
"life_taken": "0",
"targeting": ["unknown"],
"targeting_accuracy": "correct",
"who_was_attacked": ["employee or guard", "business premises or machine"],
"approach": ["walked in"],
"attack": ["Armed Robbery"],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": ["cash"],
"sources": [
"https://www.fox4news.com/news/bitcoin-bandits-target-dallas-county-cryptocurrency-atms"
],
"support": [
{"claim": "Date: 28 March, at a Mesquite gas station (who was attacked: business premises or machine)", "quote": "A bitcoin ATM at a Mesquite gas station was targeted on March 28."},
{"claim": "Place: the Exxon in the 2200 block of Oates Drive, near North Galloway Avenue; six days after Irving", "quote": "Six days later, a similar robbery took place at the Exxon in the 2200 block of Oates Drive, near North Galloway Avenue in Mesquite."},
{"claim": "Less than a week after the Irving robbery", "quote": "Less than a week later, a similar robbery took place at a gas station in Mesquite."},
{"claim": "Around 11:30 a.m. a man in a grey hoodie and red Nike cap sprayed the clerk; a second person broke into the ATM (weapons yes: pepper spray; attack: Armed Robbery)", "quote": "Around 11:30 a.m., a man wearing a gray hoodie and a red Nike cap sprayed the clerk with pepper spray. A second person then broke into the store's Bitcoin ATM."},
{"claim": "The man bought Gatorade at the counter and looked at the camera (approach: walked in, as a customer in a store open to the public)", "quote": "Video shows a man buying Gatorade at while at the counter who looks right at the camera."},
{"claim": "He returned and sprayed the female clerk with bear spray; his partner broke into the ATM (violence_torture yes; who was attacked: employee or guard; detention no: sprayed, no holding described)", "quote": "He then returns and sprays the female clerk with bear spray. His partner then breaks in the bitcoin ATM."},
{"claim": "The pair fled in a vehicle (outcome released: the attackers left of their own accord)", "quote": "The pair then fled in a vehicle, police said."},
{"claim": "The clerk was hurt, per Lt. Parrish (violence_torture yes)", "quote": "s another to hurt a defenseless clerk."},
{"claim": "The speaker is Mesquite Police Lt. Brian Parrish", "quote": "explained Mesquite Police Lt. Brian Parrish."},
{"claim": "The robbers stole from the Bitcoin ATMs in both cities (theft yes)", "quote": "Robbers douse clerks with pepper spray, steal from Bitcoin ATMs in Irving and Mesquite"},
{"claim": "Both machines were robbed after clerks were overpowered with bear spray (theft yes)", "quote": "In late March, two bitcoin ATMs were ravaged by robbers who used high-powered pepper spray known as bear spray to overpower clerks and rob the machines."},
{"claim": "The machines hold cash, per Lt. Parrish (obtained cash; targeting accuracy correct)", "quote": "Seems like these machines do contain some cash,"},
{"claim": "Fox 4 treats the two robberies as the work of the same robbers", "quote": "The motive is the same in both bitcoin robberies."},
{"claim": "Mesquite police were looking for the robbers", "quote": "Police in Irving and Mesquite are now looking for the bitcoin bandits."},
{"claim": "Crime Stoppers reward of $5,000", "quote": "Crime Stoppers is offering $5,000 for the names of the bitcoin bandits. Anyone with information is urged to contact Mesquite or Irving PD."},
{"claim": "Targeting unknown: nothing in the sources says how this station was chosen", "quote": "Surveillance footage captured incidents at a Chevron in Irving and an Exxon in Mesquite."},
{"claim": "drugs_alcohol no, life_taken 0: the attack is described and neither a drug nor a death is reported", "quote": "He then returns and sprays the female clerk with bear spray. His partner then breaks in the bitcoin ATM."}
]
}
],
"notes_for_owner": "1. Mesquite take: no source itemises what was taken in Mesquite. Theft 'yes' and obtained 'cash' rest on the headline ('steal from Bitcoin ATMs in Irving and Mesquite'), Fox 4's 'rob the machines' and Lt. Parrish's remark that the machines contain cash. If you want the stricter reading, set Mesquite to theft 'unconfirmed', obtained 'unconfirmed' and targeting_accuracy 'unknown'. 2. Same pair: Fox 4 calls both sets of robbers 'the bitcoin bandits' and the second article calls Mesquite 'a similar robbery', but no police statement on file says the same two men did both. The detailed police descriptions sit in the Irving passage, so they went to the Irving record only. The grey hoodie appears in both robberies. 3. Detention in Irving: the accomplice 'stands guard near the register while the clerk wipes his eyes'. I kept detention 'no' as in the existing record, since the text does not say the clerk was held or stopped from leaving; change to 'yes' if you read standing guard over him as holding him in place. 4. The Mesquite weapon flag rests on the pepper spray alone; the tool used on the Mesquite machine is not stated. 5. Sources: only one URL is on file (Fox 4) and it covers both incidents, so both records carry it. The second article in the dossier (the one with the addresses, times and police descriptions) has no URL recorded. 6. money_wanted and coin_type left empty on both, as in the original: nothing was demanded, no crypto was involved, and police did not disclose the cash amount. 7. The dossier's database block shows drugs_alcohol 1 and weapons 0 for the old record; the input record already had these corrected (no, yes) and both new records follow the corrected values. 8. Victim names are my wording ('Clerk and Bitcoin ATM at a Chevron gas station', 'Clerk and Bitcoin ATM at an Exxon gas station'); rename to fit the house style if needed."
}
+200
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,200 @@
{
"id": 49,
"ruling": "DB id 49 (owner) — split: this record keeps the 20 May 2018 kidnapping of the boy (Witbank); new record for the 21 August 2018 attempt on the girl (Aerorand, Middelburg), same two suspects. [corrections-approved.md] / 49 keeps the 20 May 2018 kidnapping of the boy; add a record for the 21 August 2018 attempt in Aerorand, Middelburg (Dodged Attack). [HANDOVER-SOFI.md, structural-ops.json]",
"records": [
{
"keeps_id": true,
"date": "May 20, 2018",
"victim": "13y old boy",
"location": "Witbank, Mpumalanga",
"country": "South Africa",
"description": "A 13-year-old boy was forced into a car near his home in Witbank and held for a few days. The kidnappers demanded a ransom in Bitcoin equivalent to R1.5m.",
"summary": "**Victims:** A 13-year-old boy from Witbank, Mpumalanga, snatched near his home. He is not named. **Attackers:** Two men, arrested after months of investigation by a South African Police Service task team. The body of the report gives their ages as 30 and 31; the photo caption on the same report says both were 37 and that they were among targeted suspects linked to multiple cases of armed robbery, carjacking and kidnapping in the Sekhukhune district. Police say the same two men attempted to kidnap a girl in Middelburg on 21 August 2018 (separate record). How they chose the boy is not stated. **Attack Method:** The boy was snatched near his home on 20 May 2018 as he walked back from a nearby spaza shop with a friend. Part of the kidnapping, which happened in broad daylight, was caught on a neighbour's CCTV camera; TimesLIVE saw the footage, which shows the boy forced into a silver-coloured Toyota Corolla that sped off with him inside while his friend stood in disbelief. After his parents rushed to the police station to report it, they returned to find a ransom note in their yard. **Violence Used:** Detention: the boy was forced into a car and driven away, and was reunited with his family a few days later. He came back unharmed. No weapon and no drugging are reported. **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** A ransom in the form of Bitcoin, the amount demanded being the equivalent of R1.5m. Police had not disclosed whether any ransom was paid for his safe return. **Status:** The boy was reunited with his family unharmed a few days later; how his captivity ended is not stated. Brigadier Leonard Hlathi said the cases were the first of their kind in Mpumalanga. One suspect was arrested in November in Germiston, Gauteng, the second in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal, on 30 December. Both appeared in court on the Tuesday before the 17 January 2019 report and were granted R1,000 bail each.",
"notes": "not in lopps list. The 21 August 2018 attempt on a girl in Aerorand, Middelburg, by the same two suspects was split from this record into its own record on the owner's ruling.",
"money_wanted": "R1.5m",
"coin_type": "BTC",
"detention": "yes",
"violence_torture": "no",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "no",
"theft": "unconfirmed",
"life_taken": "0",
"targeting": [
"unknown"
],
"targeting_accuracy": "unknown",
"who_was_attacked": [
"relative or partner"
],
"approach": [
"seized in the street or a public place"
],
"attack": [
"Kidnapping"
],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": [
"unconfirmed"
],
"sources": [
"https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-01-17-mpumalanga-police-arrest-two-bitcoin-kidnapping-suspects/"
],
"support": [
{
"claim": "Victim: a 13-year-old boy from Witbank; ransom in Bitcoin (coin_type BTC)",
"quote": "In the Witbank case, the suspects demanded ransom in the form of Bitcoins for the safe return of the 13-year-old boy."
},
{
"claim": "Date 20 May 2018; snatched near his home walking back from a spaza shop with a friend (approach: seized in the street or a public place)",
"quote": "The first victim was the Witbank boy, who was snatched near his home on May 20 as he walked back from a nearby spaza shop with a friend."
},
{
"claim": "Year 2018",
"quote": "The incidents happened in May and August 2018."
},
{
"claim": "Two arrested after months of work, alleged to be behind both incidents",
"quote": "Mpumalanga police, after months of hard work, have arrested two people alleged to be behind the kidnapping of a Witbank teenager and the attempted kidnapping of a girl from Middelburg."
},
{
"claim": "Task team of South African Police Service units; first cases of their kind in Mpumalanga; Brigadier Leonard Hlathi",
"quote": "These cases were the first of their kind in Mpumalanga and a task team comprising of different units within the South African Police Service was immediately established by police management to investigate this matter,\" said Brigadier Leonard Hlathi."
},
{
"claim": "Suspects are men aged 30 and 31; arrests in Germiston in November and in Ladysmith on 30 December",
"quote": "The suspects behind the kidnappings in the neighbouring towns are men aged 30 and 31. One was nabbed in November in Germiston in Gauteng, while the second was arrested in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal, on December 30."
},
{
"claim": "Photo caption gives both suspects' age as 37 and links them to other cases in the Sekhukhune district",
"quote": "The suspects, both aged 37 were part of targeted suspects linked to multiple cases of armed robbery, carjacking and kidnapping within the Sekhukhune district."
},
{
"claim": "Same suspects attempted to kidnap a girl on 21 August 2018",
"quote": "A few months later, on 21 August 2018, the suspects attempted to kidnap a 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg,\" said Hlathi."
},
{
"claim": "Broad daylight; part caught on a neighbour's CCTV camera",
"quote": "Part of the brazen kidnapping, which happened in broad daylight, was captured on a neighbour's CCTV camera."
},
{
"claim": "Boy forced into a silver-coloured Toyota Corolla (detention yes; attack: Kidnapping; no weapon, drug or violence reported in the described attack)",
"quote": "TimesLIVE saw the footage, which showed the moments the boy was forced into a silver-coloured Toyota Corolla"
},
{
"claim": "Car sped off with him inside while his friend stood in disbelief (taken away: Kidnapping)",
"quote": "which sped off with him inside, while his friend stood in disbelief."
},
{
"claim": "Parents found a ransom note in their yard; amount R1.5m (money_wanted; ransom asked of third parties: Kidnapping; the child in custody is a relative of those asked to pay: relative or partner)",
"quote": "After his parents rushed to the police station to report the kidnapping, they returned to find a ransom note in their yard. The amount demanded was the equivalent of R1.5m."
},
{
"claim": "Reunited with family unharmed a few days later (violence_torture no; life_taken 0; outcome: how captivity ended not stated); payment not disclosed (theft unconfirmed; obtained unconfirmed)",
"quote": "A few days later, he was reunited with his family unharmed. Police had not disclosed whether any ransom had been paid for his safe return."
},
{
"claim": "Court appearance on Tuesday; R1,000 bail each",
"quote": "The two suspects appeared in court on Tuesday and were granted R1,000 bail each, Hlathi said."
},
{
"claim": "Report date 17 January 2019",
"quote": "January 17, 2019 at 08:17 am"
},
{
"claim": "Targeting unknown and targeting accuracy unknown: the report gives no reason the boy was chosen and says nothing about anyone's holdings; the only statement on motive is the ransom demand",
"quote": "In the Witbank case, the suspects demanded ransom in the form of Bitcoins for the safe return of the 13-year-old boy."
}
]
},
{
"keeps_id": false,
"date": "August 21, 2018",
"victim": "13y old girl",
"location": "Aerorand, Middelburg, Mpumalanga",
"country": "South Africa",
"description": "Two men dragged a 13-year-old girl into their car in Aerorand, Middelburg. People working nearby heard her shout and helped her get away; police suspect the men planned a Bitcoin ransom demand.",
"summary": "**Victims:** A 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg, Mpumalanga. She is not named. **Attackers:** Two men, the same suspects police hold responsible for the kidnapping of a 13-year-old Witbank boy on 20 May 2018 (record 49). The body of the report gives their ages as 30 and 31; the photo caption on the same report says both were 37 and that they were among targeted suspects linked to multiple cases of armed robbery, carjacking and kidnapping in the Sekhukhune district. How they chose the girl is not stated. **Attack Method:** On 21 August 2018 the suspects dragged the girl into their vehicle, a VW Polo. She shouted for help, a group of people working nearby heard her, came to her aid and helped her escape. The suspects fled, leaving the car behind with their belongings inside. Where exactly she was seized is not stated. **Violence Used:** Detention: the girl was dragged into the suspects' vehicle and was in their hands until people working nearby came to her aid and freed her. No injury, weapon or drugging is reported. **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Nothing was demanded or taken. Police established that the suspects had the same intentions as in the Witbank case, where the ransom was demanded in Bitcoin, and suspect a similar plan had the abduction succeeded. **Status:** Brigadier Leonard Hlathi said the cases were the first of their kind in Mpumalanga and that a South African Police Service task team investigated them. One suspect was arrested in November in Germiston, Gauteng, the second in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal, on 30 December. Both appeared in court on the Tuesday before the 17 January 2019 report and were granted R1,000 bail each.",
"notes": "not in lopps list. Split from record 49 on the owner's ruling: record 49 keeps the 20 May 2018 kidnapping of the Witbank boy by the same two suspects. No ransom demand was made in this incident; the Bitcoin link is the police statement that the suspects had the same intentions as in the Witbank case.",
"money_wanted": "not stated",
"coin_type": "BTC",
"detention": "yes",
"violence_torture": "no",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "no",
"theft": "no",
"life_taken": "0",
"targeting": [
"unknown"
],
"targeting_accuracy": "unknown",
"who_was_attacked": [
"relative or partner"
],
"approach": [
"unknown"
],
"attack": [
"Kidnapping"
],
"outcome": "rescued",
"obtained": [
"nothing"
],
"sources": [
"https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-01-17-mpumalanga-police-arrest-two-bitcoin-kidnapping-suspects/"
],
"support": [
{
"claim": "Date 21 August 2018; victim a 13-year-old girl; place Aerorand, Middelburg; attempted kidnapping by the same suspects (attack: Kidnapping, attempt)",
"quote": "A few months later, on 21 August 2018, the suspects attempted to kidnap a 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg,\" said Hlathi."
},
{
"claim": "Dragged into a VW Polo; she shouted, people working nearby came to her aid and helped her escape (outcome foiled per the ruling: a third party interrupted; detention no; violence_torture no, weapons no, drugs_alcohol no: none reported in the described attack; approach: place of seizure not stated)",
"quote": "They dragged her into their vehicle, a VW Polo, but the girl shouted for help and was heard by a group of people working nearby, who swiftly came to her aid and helped her escape."
},
{
"claim": "Suspects fled, leaving the vehicle and their belongings; same intentions as in the first case (theft no; obtained nothing; life_taken 0)",
"quote": "The suspects fled the scene, thereafter leaving their vehicle abandoned with their belongings inside. During the investigation, it was established that they (suspects) had the same intentions as in the first case,\" Hlathi said."
},
{
"claim": "The abduction did not succeed; police suspect a similar Bitcoin ransom plan (coin_type BTC; no demand made, money_wanted not stated; a child taken as leverage for ransom: relative or partner)",
"quote": "In the Witbank case, the suspects demanded ransom in the form of Bitcoins for the safe return of the 13-year-old boy. Police suspect a similar plan in the second case, had the abduction succeeded."
},
{
"claim": "Same two suspects behind both incidents; Middelburg; arrested after months of work",
"quote": "Mpumalanga police, after months of hard work, have arrested two people alleged to be behind the kidnapping of a Witbank teenager and the attempted kidnapping of a girl from Middelburg."
},
{
"claim": "The Witbank kidnapping was on 20 May",
"quote": "The first victim was the Witbank boy, who was snatched near his home on May 20 as he walked back from a nearby spaza shop with a friend."
},
{
"claim": "Mpumalanga; first cases of their kind; South African Police Service task team; Brigadier Leonard Hlathi",
"quote": "These cases were the first of their kind in Mpumalanga and a task team comprising of different units within the South African Police Service was immediately established by police management to investigate this matter,\" said Brigadier Leonard Hlathi."
},
{
"claim": "Suspects are men aged 30 and 31; arrests in Germiston in November and in Ladysmith on 30 December",
"quote": "The suspects behind the kidnappings in the neighbouring towns are men aged 30 and 31. One was nabbed in November in Germiston in Gauteng, while the second was arrested in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal, on December 30."
},
{
"claim": "Photo caption gives both suspects' age as 37 and links them to other cases in the Sekhukhune district",
"quote": "The suspects, both aged 37 were part of targeted suspects linked to multiple cases of armed robbery, carjacking and kidnapping within the Sekhukhune district."
},
{
"claim": "Court appearance on Tuesday; R1,000 bail each",
"quote": "The two suspects appeared in court on Tuesday and were granted R1,000 bail each, Hlathi said."
},
{
"claim": "Report date 17 January 2019",
"quote": "January 17, 2019 at 08:17 am"
},
{
"claim": "Targeting unknown and targeting accuracy unknown: the report gives no reason the girl was chosen and says nothing about anyone's holdings; the only statement on motive is the suspected plan",
"quote": "Police suspect a similar plan in the second case, had the abduction succeeded."
}
]
}
],
"notes_for_owner": "1. Outcome of record 49 (the boy): the standing record says 'released', but the dossier only says 'A few days later, he was reunited with his family unharmed' and that police had not disclosed whether a ransom was paid. It does not say whether the kidnappers let him go, he was rescued or he got away, so I set the outcome to 'unknown'. Restore 'released' if you read 'safe return' as a release. 2. The girl (new record): the ruling says Dodged Attack, so the outcome is 'foiled' and detention is 'no', as in the earlier summary. The dossier says the men 'dragged her into their vehicle' before workers nearby 'came to her aid and helped her escape' and the men fled. Read strictly against LABEL-RULES and FLAG-RULES, that is a brief hold ended by other people, which would be outcome 'rescued' and detention 'yes'. Your call; I followed the ruling. 3. Who was attacked, both records: the dossier never says who holds crypto or whether either family holds any. 'relative or partner' is carried over from the standing record on the reading that a child was taken to make the family pay; the parents are named as the recipients of the ransom note only for the boy. 4. Approach for the girl is 'unknown': the dossier gives the suburb and says people were working nearby, but not whether she was in the street, at her home or elsewhere. 5. New record money fields: no demand was made, so money_wanted is 'not stated'; coin_type 'BTC' rests on the police statement that the suspects had the same intentions as in the Witbank case. Change it to 'unknown' if coin_type should hold only a coin that was demanded. 6. Suspect ages conflict inside the one source (30 and 31 in the body, 'both aged 37' in the photo caption, which is marked File/Stock Photo and may belong to another story). Both are kept in the summaries. 7. 'Mpumalanga' in the new record's location comes from the report naming Mpumalanga police and calling the cases the first of their kind in Mpumalanga; the Hlathi quote itself says only 'Aerorand, Middelburg'. 8. Both records cite the same single TimesLIVE URL. The boy is called 'a Witbank teenager' in one copy of the lead and 'a young Witbank boy' in the other; the age 13 is stated for both children.",
"applied_rules": "2026-10-08: record 49 keeps outcome released (the verified value; the dossier does not contradict it). The new record is rescued with detention yes: she was dragged into the vehicle and workers nearby freed her, and the owner's rule of 2026-10-07 limits foiled to attacks stopped before anyone was under control."
}
+47
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
{
"id": 5,
"ruling": "**DB id 5** (owner) — rewrite to the 27 May 2015 Crown Heights robbery (victim: 28-year-old man, unnamed; CNBC); the Dwayne Richards stabbing (February 2015, Observer) leaves this record and gets no record of its own (police called it not bitcoin-related).",
"records": [
{
"keeps_id": true,
"date": "May 27, 2015",
"victim": "28-year-old man, unnamed",
"location": "Crown Heights, Brooklyn, New York",
"country": "USA",
"description": "A 28-year-old man who had advertised bitcoins for sale on Craigslist was robbed at gunpoint at a car in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, and made to transfer $1,100 worth of bitcoin. The robbers also took his cellphone and drove off.",
"summary": "**Victims:** A 28-year-old man, not named in the reporting, who had placed a Craigslist.com ad offering bitcoins for sale. CNBC calls him a New York man; his occupation is not stated. **Attackers:** At least two men, none named: the purported buyer who answered the ad, and another man sitting in the backseat of a car who pulled a gun, all according to police. **Attack Method:** Police said the robbery happened at around 11:30 a.m. on May 27 in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn. The victim told police he went to a street corner there to meet the man who had answered his ad. The purported buyer led him to a car to complete the purchase, where the man in the backseat pulled a gun and ordered him to electronically transfer the bitcoins to the thieves. After he sent the bitcoins, the thieves took his cellphone and drove off, and he called 911. **Violence Used:** Detention, because per police he was held under a gun at the car until he made the transfer. The gun was a threat only: no physical violence or injury is reported. No drugs are reported. **Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** $1,100 worth of bitcoin, transferred electronically under the gun, plus the victim's cellphone. Whether anything was recovered is not stated. **Status:** \"It's still under investigation,\" a police spokeswoman said on June 5, 2015, adding that there was no surveillance video footage available. Arrests in this robbery are not stated.",
"notes": "Rewritten on the owner's ruling to the 27 May 2015 Crown Heights robbery. The record earlier named Dwayne Richards, a New York City firefighter, and described a stabbing. That is a separate robbery of Feb. 9, 2015, which police told CNBC \"is not bitcoin related\"; it has left this record and has no record of its own. The CNBC article names nobody in either matter.",
"money_wanted": "$1,100",
"coin_type": "BTC",
"detention": "yes",
"violence_torture": "threat only",
"drugs_alcohol": "no",
"weapons": "yes",
"theft": "yes",
"life_taken": "0",
"targeting": ["online contact or advert"],
"targeting_accuracy": "correct",
"who_was_attacked": ["holder"],
"approach": ["P2P Trade"],
"attack": ["Armed Robbery"],
"outcome": "released",
"obtained": ["crypto", "devices or seed"],
"sources": [
"https://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/05/new-york-city-man-robbed-at-gunpoint-for-bitcoin.html"
],
"support": [
{"claim": "Date, time and place: around 11:30 a.m. on May 27 in Crown Heights, Brooklyn", "quote": "The latest combination street-cyber crime occurred at around 11:30 a.m. on May 27 in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn."},
{"claim": "Year 2015: the article is dated 5 June 2015", "quote": "Friday, 5 Jun 2015 | 3:14 PM ET"},
{"claim": "Victim is a New York man robbed at gunpoint of $1,100 worth of bitcoin, per police (money_wanted $1,100, coin_type BTC, weapons yes)", "quote": "A New York man was robbed at gunpoint of $1,100 worth of bitcoin, police told CNBC.com on Friday."},
{"claim": "Victim was 28, unnamed, had a Craigslist ad offering bitcoins for sale, and went to a street corner to meet the man who answered it (targeting: online contact or advert; approach: P2P Trade; who_was_attacked: holder)", "quote": "The 28-year-old victim told police he went to a street corner there to meet a man who had answered his Craigslist.com ad offering bitcoins for sale, police said."},
{"claim": "At least two men: the purported buyer and a man in the backseat who pulled a gun and ordered the transfer (detention yes, violence_torture threat only, weapons yes, attack: Armed Robbery)", "quote": "The purported buyer then led the victim to a car to complete the purchase, where another man sitting in the backseat pulled a gun and ordered the victim to electronically transfer the bitcoins to the thieves, cops said."},
{"claim": "The victim sent the bitcoins, the thieves took his cellphone and drove off (theft yes; obtained: crypto, devices or seed; targeting_accuracy correct; outcome released; life_taken 0)", "quote": "After the victim sent the bitcoins, the thugs then took the victim's cellphone, and drove off, according to police."},
{"claim": "The victim called 911 afterwards", "quote": "The victim then called 911."},
{"claim": "Status: still under investigation, no surveillance video available", "quote": "\"It's still under investigation,\" said the police spokeswoman. She said there was no surveillance video footage of the virtual money stickup available."},
{"claim": "No arrest is reported for this robbery: the article's only arrest statement concerns the separate Katz case", "quote": "No arrests have been made in Katz's case."},
{"claim": "The firefighter stabbing is a separate Feb. 9 robbery that police called not bitcoin related, so it leaves the record (no physical violence, drugs or death in this robbery)", "quote": "But police on Friday told CNBC that that robbery, which occurred on Feb. 9, \"is not bitcoin related.\" The firefighter's credit card and PIN number were stolen, and he was stabbed in the arm, police said."}
]
}
],
"notes_for_owner": "1. Detention is set to yes on the FLAG-RULES line \"held at gunpoint until the transfer is made\". The article says the buyer \"led the victim to a car\" where a man in the backseat pulled a gun; it does not say the victim got into the car or how long he was kept there. If you read that as control never gained, detention becomes no. 2. Location is written as \"Crown Heights, Brooklyn, New York\" (the input had \"Crown Heights, New York\"); the article says \"the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn\". 3. The name Dwayne Richards appears nowhere in the CNBC article, only in the old database record and the ruling; the article says \"a New York City firefighter\". 4. The article gives no arrest, recovery or later outcome for the 27 May robbery, and the only source is dated 5 June 2015. 5. The dossier file is still named sources/005_Dwayne-Richards.txt and its header still carries the old victim name and scenario \"Kidnapping\". 6. The same article describes the Jan. 22, 2015 robbery of bitcoin dealer Dean Katz in Queens ($8,500 in bitcoin and $3,500 in cash, at gunpoint in a car); I did not check whether that incident has its own record."
}