feat(verify): official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted; 11 cases moved to Kidnapping

This commit is contained in:
StellarCrow
2026-10-01 10:59:31 +02:00
parent 005b95db8a
commit 8f45fbf445
3 changed files with 31 additions and 27 deletions
+5 -5
View File
@@ -108,11 +108,11 @@ How the attackers selected and found the victim, recorded separately from the sc
This absorbs the "prior acquaintance / insider" attribute proposed earlier today. Population of the field across the 393 cases is a separate pass; the scenario-sequences.json gap notes tagged preparation, insider, acquaintance and leak are the starting list. This absorbs the "prior acquaintance / insider" attribute proposed earlier today. Population of the field across the 393 cases is a separate pass; the scenario-sequences.json gap notes tagged preparation, insider, acquaintance and leak are the starting list.
## Owner's rule on Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping (2026-09-30) ## Owner's rule on Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping (2026-09-30, revised 2026-10-01)
The two glossary entries overlap on duration ("minutes to hours" against "hours to weeks"). The owner's rule settles the overlap: The official sense of express kidnapping applies (OSAC: "almost always crimes of opportunity"; Humanitarian Outcomes: "generally opportunistic and will not have involved much planning").
- **Express Kidnapping**: the victim is seized in public and made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle. - **Express Kidnapping**: the victim was not pre-selected, was seized in public, and was made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle. All three conditions are needed.
- **Kidnapping**: the victim is taken to a place away from the public where the attackers hold them (a building or a remote outdoor spot), or transported over a long distance, or a ransom is demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. - **Kidnapping**: everything else: a pre-selected victim (surveillance, a tip-off, a lure, a staged meeting), or a victim taken to a place away from the public where the attackers hold them (a building or a remote outdoor spot), or transported over a long distance, or a ransom demanded from third parties, whatever the duration.
Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label. First applied to case 93 (held in a cell at the officers' station: Kidnapping). Cases whose label changes under the rule are listed in corrections-approved.md as they are ruled on. Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label. When the sources say nothing about how the victim was chosen, the case stays Express Kidnapping and the gap is noted. Applied 2026-10-01: 91, 279, 334, 182, 202, 137, 462, 456, 80, 19 and 367 moved from Express Kidnapping to Kidnapping; 229, 253, 34, 434, 394, 357, 172 and 7 stay Express Kidnapping.
+4
View File
@@ -274,3 +274,7 @@ Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-11.md`; evidence in `batches/bat
- **Kidnapping → Express Kidnapping (owner)** — DB ids 172 (van, own funds; supersedes 'Kidnapping kept per the charge'), 80 (taken on a drive and made to transfer), 7 (held in vehicles until morning), 19 (held in a van for two hours while his apartment was emptied). - **Kidnapping → Express Kidnapping (owner)** — DB ids 172 (van, own funds; supersedes 'Kidnapping kept per the charge'), 80 (taken on a drive and made to transfer), 7 (held in vehicles until morning), 19 (held in a van for two hours while his apartment was emptied).
- **Stay Express Kidnapping (owner, borderline cases)** — DB ids 279 (forced to call his brother to move 1,000 BTC), 367 (14 BTC demanded within 24 hours), 462 (driven to Cravinhos; holding place not stated). - **Stay Express Kidnapping (owner, borderline cases)** — DB ids 279 (forced to call his brother to move 1,000 BTC), 367 (14 BTC demanded within 24 hours), 462 (driven to Cravinhos; holding place not stated).
- Not screened under the rule: the 24 Kidnapping cases with no venue recorded and the first 70 verified cases, which carry no venue field. - Not screened under the rule: the 24 Kidnapping cases with no venue recorded and the first 70 verified cases, which carry no venue field.
- **DB id 92** — accept: date 1 July 2021 kept, unverified (the Casa case study says only 'over the weekend' and 'this week'); attackers → a woman met on Tinder, probably with others (Lopp: she 'most likely handed the phone over to someone else, possibly a criminal organization'); notes → the attacker held one of five Casa multisig keys, so those funds could not be spent; a small amount of bitcoin left one exchange account; only the phone was taken (wallet, cash, cards and ID were left), so drop 'possessions'; sequence Malicious Invitation kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 1 as alleged: Casa suspects scopolamine or a benzodiazepine, weapons 0, theft 1); single line of sourcing (the victim's account relayed by Casa); no police report or arrest.
- **Rule revised (owner, 2026-10-01): official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted** — Express only when the victim was not pre-selected, was seized in public, and paid from their own funds on the spot or in a vehicle. Pre-selected victims are Kidnapping whatever the duration. Wording in DEFINITIONS.md.
- **Express Kidnapping → Kidnapping (owner, 2026-10-01)** — DB ids 91 (ten days of surveillance; so Authority Misuse → Kidnapping), 279 (private detective, staged accident), 334 (planned since February), 182 (pretext approach to a known coach), 202 (taken from his home, traders targeted), 137 (trade arranged with him beforehand), 462 (routine followed on social media), 456 (chosen for his crypto work, two cars), 80 (invited to Lahore), 19 (set up by a friend), 367 (14 BTC demanded; pre-selection implied, not stated).
- **Stay Express Kidnapping** — 229 (fake Uber ring taking riders), 253, 34, 434, 394 (recognised by chance in the street), 357, 172, 7. For 34, 357, 172 and 7 the sources do not say how the victim was chosen; gap noted.
+22 -22
View File
@@ -352,12 +352,12 @@
"279": { "279": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [], "gaps": [],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Group including two serving police officers (Authority Misuse); after a failed staged accident, the family's car was intercepted and they were held over a two-hour drive while forced to transfer (Express Kidnapping)." "rationale": "Group including two serving police officers (Authority Misuse); after a failed staged accident, the family's car was intercepted and they were held over a two-hour drive while forced to transfer (Express Kidnapping). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. A hired private detective mapped the family routine; a staged accident preceded the seizure."
}, },
"285": { "285": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
@@ -574,12 +574,12 @@
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [], "gaps": [],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Fake business meeting with hotel paid (Malicious Invitation); ambushed in the car at gunpoint, accounts drained, thrown out after about 90 minutes (Express Kidnapping). Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the posed as an advisor to the president of the Goias Legislative Assembly is a misuse of a claimed worker, driver or delivery position (DEFINITIONS.md, Authority Misuse clarification)." "rationale": "Fake business meeting with hotel paid (Malicious Invitation); ambushed in the car at gunpoint, accounts drained, thrown out after about 90 minutes (Express Kidnapping). Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the posed as an advisor to the president of the Goias Legislative Assembly is a misuse of a claimed worker, driver or delivery position (DEFINITIONS.md, Authority Misuse clarification). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. Planning began in February; a business meeting was arranged and the hotel paid."
}, },
"340": { "340": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
@@ -653,12 +653,12 @@
"367": { "367": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [], "gaps": [],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Two men posing as police (Authority Misuse) drove him around for an hour with a gun to his head demanding 14 BTC (Express Kidnapping)." "rationale": "Two men posing as police (Authority Misuse) drove him around for an hour with a gun to his head demanding 14 BTC (Express Kidnapping). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. The pair knew he held bitcoin and demanded 14 BTC; pre-selection implied, no source states it."
}, },
"368": { "368": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
@@ -976,7 +976,7 @@
"182": { "182": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -984,7 +984,7 @@
"a forced transfer carried out on the victim's own seized phone is not expressible in the labels" "a forced transfer carried out on the victim's own seized phone is not expressible in the labels"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "The five approached the coach on the pretext of wanting share-market guidance and got him into a car, then held him about three hours while the USDT was moved and released him the same evening — social engineering into an express kidnapping.", "rationale": "The five approached the coach on the pretext of wanting share-market guidance and got him into a car, then held him about three hours while the USDT was moved and released him the same evening — social engineering into an express kidnapping. Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. The five approached him as the author of a share-trading course and used a pretext to get him into the car.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",
@@ -1412,14 +1412,14 @@
"202": { "202": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
"a detention of about two hours in a police vehicle that ends in release as soon as the transfer clears sits between Express Kidnapping and Authority Misuse; only one label can be primary" "a detention of about two hours in a police vehicle that ends in release as soon as the transfer clears sits between Express Kidnapping and Authority Misuse; only one label can be primary"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "A police mobile with no number plate and men in plain clothes, with a serving CTD head constable among the accused (Authority Misuse); a detention of about two and a half hours with an immediate forced transfer and release (Express Kidnapping pattern).", "rationale": "A police mobile with no number plate and men in plain clothes, with a serving CTD head constable among the accused (Authority Misuse); a detention of about two and a half hours with an immediate forced transfer and release (Express Kidnapping pattern). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. Taken from his home; the kidnappers said they targeted crypto traders.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",
@@ -2055,7 +2055,7 @@
"137": { "137": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"P2P Trade Gone Wrong", "P2P Trade Gone Wrong",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -2063,7 +2063,7 @@
"the file gives no duration for the drive, so the brevity that defines Express Kidnapping rests only on the escape when the car stopped" "the file gives no duration for the drive, so the brevity that defines Express Kidnapping rests only on the escape when the car stopped"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "A cash-for-Bitcoin meeting arranged over social media turned into a robbery the moment he got into the car, and he was then held at gunpoint and driven around before escaping - a P2P trade that became a short mobile detention.", "rationale": "A cash-for-Bitcoin meeting arranged over social media turned into a robbery the moment he got into the car, and he was then held at gunpoint and driven around before escaping - a P2P trade that became a short mobile detention. Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. The trade was arranged with him over social media before the meeting.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,
@@ -2297,7 +2297,7 @@
"91": { "91": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -2305,7 +2305,7 @@
"the release does not say how long the man was in the car or whether it moved, so the difference between Express Kidnapping and a robbery carried out in a parked car cannot be resolved from the file" "the release does not say how long the man was in the car or whether it moved, so the difference between Express Kidnapping and a robbery carried out in a parked car cannot be resolved from the file"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Fake identity documents were the means of stopping the victim (Authority Misuse) and the cash and transfer were taken immediately in a car before the men fled the scene (Express Kidnapping).", "rationale": "Fake identity documents were the means of stopping the victim (Authority Misuse) and the cash and transfer were taken immediately in a car before the men fled the scene (Express Kidnapping). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. Ten days of surveillance after a tip-off.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": null, "venue_of_control": null,
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,
@@ -3476,7 +3476,7 @@
"80": { "80": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -3485,7 +3485,7 @@
"with no holding place and no duration on file, Kidnapping and Express Kidnapping cannot be told apart" "with no holding place and no duration on file, Kidnapping and Express Kidnapping cannot be told apart"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "An investment invitation brought two foreigners to Lahore (Malicious Invitation), after which they were taken from their hotel at gunpoint on a sightseeing drive and made to transfer crypto, which is Kidnapping on the file's own wording. Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a vehicle on a drive and made to transfer from their own funds.", "rationale": "An investment invitation brought two foreigners to Lahore (Malicious Invitation), after which they were taken from their hotel at gunpoint on a sightseeing drive and made to transfer crypto, which is Kidnapping on the file's own wording. Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a vehicle on a drive and made to transfer from their own funds. Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. Invited to Lahore under an investment pretext.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,
@@ -3771,7 +3771,7 @@
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -3779,7 +3779,7 @@
"two hours of mobile detention in a vehicle reads as Express Kidnapping, but the operation was planned around a known holder, which that label excludes" "two hours of mobile detention in a vehicle reads as Express Kidnapping, but the operation was planned around a known holder, which that label excludes"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "A friend lured him into a fake Uber where a man was waiting with a gun, and he was held in the van for two hours while accomplices emptied his apartment (Malicious Invitation as the lure, Kidnapping as the operation). Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the posed as the Uber driver is a misuse of a claimed worker, driver or delivery position (DEFINITIONS.md, Authority Misuse clarification). Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a van for two hours, no fixed holding place and no ransom from third parties.", "rationale": "A friend lured him into a fake Uber where a man was waiting with a gun, and he was held in the van for two hours while accomplices emptied his apartment (Malicious Invitation as the lure, Kidnapping as the operation). Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the posed as the Uber driver is a misuse of a claimed worker, driver or delivery position (DEFINITIONS.md, Authority Misuse clarification). Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a van for two hours, no fixed holding place and no ransom from third parties. Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. Set up by a friend who staged the fake Uber.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",
@@ -6620,7 +6620,7 @@
"462": { "462": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -6628,7 +6628,7 @@
"an impersonation staged for a camera, with hotel staff filming it as a legitimacy prop, has no field" "an impersonation staged for a camera, with hotel staff filming it as a legitimacy prop, has no field"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Two men in Polícia Civil clothing used a paper presented as an arrest warrant and handcuffs to take him out of the hotel (Authority Misuse), then drove him away and made him transfer cryptocurrency before releasing him the same day (Express Kidnapping).", "rationale": "Two men in Polícia Civil clothing used a paper presented as an arrest warrant and handcuffs to take him out of the hotel (Authority Misuse), then drove him away and made him transfer cryptocurrency before releasing him the same day (Express Kidnapping). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. The pair had followed his routine through his social media.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,
@@ -6745,7 +6745,7 @@
"456": { "456": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Costly Fame", "Costly Fame",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -6754,7 +6754,7 @@
"the three sources give three different elapsed times before he was found, so no single duration fits" "the three sources give three different elapsed times before he was found, so no single duration fits"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "A publicly visible crypto investor was blocked in traffic and taken from his own car by armed men who demanded crypto transfers immediately (Costly Fame), held in their vehicle while R$15,000 was moved and more was demanded, and escaped the same morning (Express Kidnapping).", "rationale": "A publicly visible crypto investor was blocked in traffic and taken from his own car by armed men who demanded crypto transfers immediately (Costly Fame), held in their vehicle while R$15,000 was moved and more was demanded, and escaped the same morning (Express Kidnapping). Changed 2026-10-01 by owner ruling (official sense of Express Kidnapping adopted, DEFINITIONS.md): the victim was pre-selected, so Kidnapping. Chosen for his crypto work, two cars coordinated to block his Porsche.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,