diff --git a/merge-output/batches/DECISION-RULES.md b/merge-output/batches/DECISION-RULES.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..75785bc --- /dev/null +++ b/merge-output/batches/DECISION-RULES.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +# Decision rules for owner-decision triage (2026-10-01) + +Owner instruction: approve the cases where the judgment is safe; show the owner only the cases that need human eyes or a decision. + +Inputs per case: `batches/contradictions-NN.md` (record-versus-article disagreements, flag proposals, gap notes, writer's note), `batches/batch-NN.json` (verified summary, sequence, flags with evidence, facts), `sources/_*.txt` (the dossier: record block, articles), `DEFINITIONS.md` (glossary plus owner rulings), `corrections-approved.md` (every owner ruling so far, the precedent base: read it in full before deciding anything). + +## Approve without the owner (mark "(DA)") + +A correction is safe when the article text on file states it and no owner ruling points the other way: + +- A flag proposed from an explicit quote: detention 1 for restrained, tied, locked in, held at gunpoint, forced into a vehicle or a room; violence 1 for a beating, injury, pepper spray, taser (rulings 160, 89, 84); weapons 1 for a weapon named; theft unconfirmed when no transfer or loss is stated; weapons unconfirmed when "armed" appears only in a charge or headline; drugs 1 as alleged when a source says the victim was drugged. +- Date, location, victim age or name, attacker count, amount, coin: changed to what the article says, with the article's hedges kept. Convert a weekday to a date only when the report's date fixes it; otherwise "month YYYY, day unknown". Note currency-sign traps (Argentine $, HK$) and unsourced dollar conversions: keep the source currency, drop or mark the conversion. +- Description rewritten to the article when the record overstates (e.g. "take millions in bitcoin" when nothing was moved; "armed" with no weapon). +- Scenario changes that follow a ruling already made: + - worker, driver, delivery, technician, insurance or official ruse at the door or in the street → Authority Misuse as the first label (ruling of 2026-09-30; cases 118, 90, 114); + - a crypto trade used as the lure → P2P Trade Gone Wrong as the first label (117, 104); + - victim held at the attackers' premises, or pre-selected and held in a vehicle → Kidnapping; Express Kidnapping only when not pre-selected, seized in public, paying from own funds on the spot or in a vehicle (rule of 2026-10-01 in DEFINITIONS.md); + - foiled attempt → Dodged Attack with the attempt listed (147, 84); + - a man shot or stabbed dead → violence_torture 1 (215, 102, 96); + - unconscious or drugged, not held → kidnappings 0 (151, 124, 88); + - "injury" in a conviction after a drugging → violence unconfirmed (88). +- Targeting vector noted (insider, acquaintance, business counterparty, surveillance, tip-off, leak from the victim's circle, displayed wealth, opportunistic, unknown). +- Source housekeeping: an OFF-CASE? flag that is a matcher artefact (the record's victim string never appears in a foreign-language page) is noted as "article is the right one"; round-up tails not used. + +## Escalate to the owner (mark "(owner)") + +- A scenario change with no precedent in `corrections-approved.md`, or a case that fits none of the eleven labels (park on the disputed list if it is an empty-premises theft: ATM, mining hardware, burglary of an empty home; otherwise escalate). +- Detention on the line between "held to execute the theft" and "a snatch in passing" (clarification 3) when the hold is more than a grab. +- Whether the case belongs in the database at all (no crypto link, motive not established, no person attacked, lawful police action). +- Two sources that disagree on a central fact (amount, who the attackers were, whether the victim was released) and the record must pick one. +- Anything that would need a new source to settle, and the writer's note says the record's details are in no source on file (as in 145, 138, 114: trace first). +- A record whose description is a different incident from the article (possible off-case link). +- A possible duplicate of another record, or an article describing further incidents that may deserve their own records (list them; do not create records). +- Victim named in the record but not in any source: approve the removal of the name only if no source names the person; escalate if a source names someone else. + +## Output + +One file per batch: `batches/decisions-NN.md`, two sections. + +`## Approved (DA)`: one line per case in the exact format of `corrections-approved.md`: +`- **DB id N** (DA) — field → value (evidence); ...; sequence A → B (reason); flags unchanged (list); arrests; source notes.` +Write "sequence X kept" when unchanged; "sequence was A; now B" when changed. Keep every claim traceable to the article text or a prior ruling. + +`## Needs owner decision`: one block per case, at most eight lines: a one-line TL;DR of the case, what is settled (DA), and the one or two questions for the owner with the evidence line for each side and the DA's recommendation. + +Also write `batches/decisions-NN.json`: `{"sequence_changes": {"": ["label", ...]}, "attempted_changes": {"": [...]}, "parked": [ids], "owner": [ids]}` listing only the cases whose sequence or attempted list changes under the approved decisions. + +Do not edit `corrections-approved.md`, `scenario-sequences.json`, `summary-overrides.json`, `DEFINITIONS.md` or anything in `sources/`. Do not fetch anything from the web. Never invent a fact: if the file does not say it, write "not stated". diff --git a/merge-output/corrections-approved.md b/merge-output/corrections-approved.md index 0f88ba8..960df76 100644 --- a/merge-output/corrections-approved.md +++ b/merge-output/corrections-approved.md @@ -285,3 +285,10 @@ Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-11.md`; evidence in `batches/bat - **DB id 85** — accept: coin_type → crypto keys, bank cards, computers, jewellery (drop 'cash': none taken from the flat; money was withdrawn later at an ATM with his card); amount unknown (no figure, coin or balance in any source); description → add forced to give up bank PINs, locked in a storage room, freed himself and called 911; sequence Home Invasion kept; all six flags stand (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1); no arrests; three sources all retelling one police release. - **DB id 84** — accept: victim age → 30 or 31 (born 1990, attack April 2021), not 35; location → Orikhiv, Polohy district, Zaporizhzhia region, the yard of his own house; description → three men pepper-sprayed him in his yard and tried to take a Bitcoin Antminer S9 (about 40,000 hryvnias); he fired a traumatic pistol and they fled (not a 'mining farm'); violence_torture → 1 (pepper spray, as in 160 and 89); weapons stay 1 (the attackers' pepper spray; the only firearm was the victim's); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space → Dodged Attack, attempted theft of the mining device; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, theft 0); all three detained the same evening; stays in the database regardless of the empty-premises decision (owner present and attacked). - **DB id 83** — accept: money_wanted → 120,000 ARS + USD 2,500 (about ARS 350,000; the headline's '$350.000' is Argentine pesos, at roughly 92 ARS/USD in March 2021), coin_type cash; drop the description's '$5k', 'armed' and 'at gunpoint' (no weapon in the report), weapons stay 0; victim → 26-year-old man (the initials 'F.T.' appear in no source); date 18 March 2021 kept ('this Thursday'; 18 March 2021 was a Thursday); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept, gap: the report does not say the buyers were the robbers; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 1; iPhone recovered); no arrests; the OFF-CASE? flag on the MendoVoz page is a matcher artefact, the article is the right one. + +--- + +## Batch 12 decisions — 2026-10-01 + +From this batch on, the DA (PAI) approves cases where the correction follows the article text or an existing owner ruling, and marks them "(DA)". Cases needing an owner decision are marked "(owner)". Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. +- **DB id 82** (DA) — description → robbers tore away the phone holding a wallet that showed a high five-figure sum; no transfer described; money_wanted → high five-figure amount in EUR (headline: nearly 100,000 euros), whether the coins were moved is not reported; kidnappings stay 0 (a seconds-long grab while the phone was pulled away reads as a snatch in passing, clarification 3; DA call, owner may set 1); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; other flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, weapons 0, theft 1); all four arrested; one source (Stadt Magazin).