feat(verify): DA triage of batches 12-34: 158 lines approved or parked, 60 cases escalated to owner; 4 sequences set

This commit is contained in:
StellarCrow
2026-10-01 11:42:07 +02:00
parent 967e69e8a1
commit e6e1f09aab
49 changed files with 1362 additions and 8 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ A correction is safe when the article text on file states it and no owner ruling
- Description rewritten to the article when the record overstates (e.g. "take millions in bitcoin" when nothing was moved; "armed" with no weapon).
- Scenario changes that follow a ruling already made:
- worker, driver, delivery, technician, insurance or official ruse at the door or in the street → Authority Misuse as the first label (ruling of 2026-09-30; cases 118, 90, 114);
- a crypto trade used as the lure → P2P Trade Gone Wrong as the first label (117, 104);
- a crypto trade used as the lure → P2P Trade Gone Wrong in the sequence: after Malicious Invitation when the meeting itself was engineered (117: Malicious Invitation → P2P Trade Gone Wrong), first when the trade was the approach (137, 143, 104);
- victim held at the attackers' premises, or pre-selected and held in a vehicle → Kidnapping; Express Kidnapping only when not pre-selected, seized in public, paying from own funds on the spot or in a vehicle (rule of 2026-10-01 in DEFINITIONS.md);
- foiled attempt → Dodged Attack with the attempt listed (147, 84);
- a man shot or stabbed dead → violence_torture 1 (215, 102, 96);
+18
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"80": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
],
"77": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"P2P Trade Gone Wrong"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
73,
72
]
}
+29
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
# Batch 12 decisions (2026-10-01)
Criteria: `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Evidence: `batches/contradictions-12.md`, `batches/batch-12.json`, the dossiers in `sources/`. DB id 82 was decided earlier and is recorded in `corrections-approved.md`; it is not repeated here.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 81** (DA) — money_wanted → 100 BTC demanded at first, lowered to 50 and then 6; 4.78 BTC transferred by his business partner (the record's "4,78 bitcoins" is the sum sent, not the demand); notes → drop "broke into the business building": reception staff were paid 7,000 reais "to help the kidnappers enter the building with the victim", one of them supplied his routine and car, and two security guards were bribed (O Globo); "torture" → tied up, punched in the mouth, two teeth broken; holding place and duration not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected through insider information, so Kidnapping under the rule of 2026-10-01 whatever the holding place); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = insider tip-off (reception staff and bribed guards); arrests → ten people indicted, no arrest or criminal conviction stated, court ordered 250,000 reais in moral damages; outcome "released" is inferred (no line says he was let go); first sheet article is a Livecoins-sourced piece filed under O Globo, the O Globo page is on-case (WEAK anchor is a false positive).
- **DB id 80** (DA) — location → Lahore (taken from a five-star hotel there; Gujranwala is where the two arrests were made); description → drop "$93k" (in no source; it reads as the record's own conversion of Rs14.7 million): the two foreigners were taken hostage at gunpoint on a drive "to show them the city" and made to transfer Rs14.7 million of cryptocurrency, reported as bitcoin; money_wanted Rs14.7 million kept (both reports, twice in the second); the second report's opening "over $10 million" contradicts its own body and is not used (as with the sub-headline in 111); date February 2021 kept, unverified (neither report dates the incident or the arrests); victim count: the FIR's "along with three others" leaves open whether three more people were taken, noted; drugs_alcohol stays 1 (heroin sprinkled on them with a threat to expose them as drug smugglers: drugs used as leverage, as ruled in 170); sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (owner ruling of 2026-10-01: invited to Lahore, pre-selected); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (invited to Lahore to invest; how the contact began not stated); arrests → two arrested in Gujranwala, prime suspect Rana Irfan at large; outcome not stated; Daily Times URL blocked on fetch, the sheet text is the only copy.
- **DB id 79** (DA) — description → three people (two men, one woman) tricked the couple into opening the door ("They knock and deceive the victims into letting them in"), went in with a pistol and a knife, stayed 20 to 30 minutes and forced them to transfer bitcoin "worth millions" (unnamed sources to Aftonbladet; no currency; police would not comment on the loot); drop "1M+ SEK" (no source); notes → drop "money, jewelry, watches" as items taken (Åkermark's remark is general: "they were after money, jewelry, watches, or other valuables"); location → residential area in the northern part of Stockholm County (southern Roslagen police area); date 4 February 2021 kept, unverified (article says "last Thursday evening"; 4 February 2021 was a Thursday but the report's own date is not on file); sequence Home Invasion kept, gap: entry by an unspecified deception at the door (no claimed role shown, so Authority Misuse not applied, as in 397); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (police still examining what the perpetrators knew beforehand); arrests → all three caught, two men in custody, the woman released, police say more people may stand behind them; one source (Aftonbladet, THIN on fetch).
- **DB id 78** (DA) — date → 22 January 2021 (Cointelegraph: "around 7 p.m. local time on Jan. 22"; 23 January is the date of the local report and of the reward); victim → two FlyingAtom employees, a man and a woman, one in a medically induced coma; money_wanted → gold worth 450,000 PLN (about $120,000 per Cointelegraph), coin_type Gold kept, no crypto taken; case kept (target was a bitcoin-and-gold exchange office, a crypto business under the glossary's Armed Robbery; crypto link by occupation, as in 123); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, gap: a private office on the fourth floor of an office tower; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests → one man detained in Bydgoszcz who "may be related to the attack", FlyingAtom thanked police for the capture of the suspect, no charge or court step on file; first sheet block is a Polish local report filed under CT.
- **DB id 77** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("He said the four fled after locking the victim in the office": locked in, explicit quote; control was gained at knifepoint before the lock-in, so clarification 3 does not apply); description and money_wanted HK$3.5 million in cash kept (the proceeds of a completed USDT sale), plus her iPhone; coin_type Cash kept, the tokens she delivered were USDT; sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now Malicious Invitation → P2P Trade Gone Wrong (police say the gang "lured" her and may have done three earlier deals of HK$600,000 to HK$700,000 to win her trust; same order as 117); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → four (the buyer and three men from a back room with a knife or a rod); targeting vector = business counterparty (repeat buyer); arrests none; held duration not stated; one source (SCMP, two copies).
- **DB id 76** (DA) — weapons → 0 (no weapon appears anywhere in the report; four men jumped into the car and took the banknotes and two phones); description → drop "US$387,000" (the record's conversion): two buyers he had traded with before drove him from North Point and, after he transferred 15 bitcoins, four accomplices took back the HK$3 million in cash and two phones on a hillside near Shan Tsui Court, Tai Tam Road, and he was put out of the car; money_wanted → 15 BTC transferred plus HK$3 million in cash taken back (the report's own figures do not close: 15 at HK$235,000 each is HK$3.525 million, noted); date → January 2021, day unknown (the robbery was on "Monday"; the record's 5 January 2021 was a Tuesday and the report's date is not on file); location → Tai Tam Road near Shan Tsui Court, Chai Wan, Hong Kong (picked up in North Point); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (HK$1 million online trade the night before); arrests none, six suspects at large; one source (The Standard, two copies).
- **DB id 74** (DA) — date → December 2020, day unknown, before the 24 December report (the report says another kidnapper "was caught a day and a half after the crime"); victim → a Kyiv-based man in a cryptocurrency-related business, plus his wife as second victim (taken in another car, found held in a Ternopil hotel, no physical force used); money_wanted → $800,000 demanded under threat of death (victim's account), no payment or transfer reported (the headlines' "extorted $800,000" is not borne out by the bodies), coin_type → not stated; theft stays 1 on the stolen Toyota Camry (found a few kilometres away), no crypto taken; sequence Kidnapping kept (blocked by three cars, handcuffed into a car boot, held and tortured overnight); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests → four of seven (two arrested, one caught a day and a half later, the organiser surrendered), three sought, one reportedly abroad; how his captivity ended is not stated; LB.ua teaser tail (Kyiv brothers, Irpin gang) not used.
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 73 (owner)
TL;DR: four men assaulted three would-be bitcoin buyers carrying Dh500,000 in cash in an Al Barsha office, Dubai; the victims screamed and the four fled with nothing.
Settled (DA): date → August 2019 (second report: "The incident dates back to August 2019"; December 2020 is a court or report date); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted robbery of the Dh500,000; violence_torture stays 1 (both reports say the four assaulted the victims); kidnappings 0, theft 0; all four arrested and charged with attempted robbery; attackers "four Ukrainian defendants" (Gulf News) / "a four-member European gang" (second report), compatible.
Question: weapons. For 1: Gulf News, "The four defendants physically assaulted the victims and sprayed a deodorant directly on to the victims' faces" (a spray in the face reads as in 89). For 0: the second report, "one of them had used his body deodorant to spray on the robbers' faces" (the spray was the victims' defence).
DA recommendation: weapons → unconfirmed, both accounts in notes, and the description's "attack Bitcoin buyer with deodorant" reworded to "assaulted the buyers".
### DB id 72 (owner)
TL;DR: a Riga man planning to abduct, torture and kill a crypto holder for about 500,000 euros was detained by the Omega squad on 7 October 2020 while lying in wait; nobody was touched.
Settled (DA): date → 7 October 2020 (detention; plot intercepted in September; 22 October is the report date); victim → two intended victims (police later learned of a second planned abduction and murder); money_wanted → about 500,000 euros, cryptocurrency (ForkLog) / cryptocurrency and cash (State Police via Sputnik); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping plus extortion and planned killings; kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0; arrests: the organiser, who confessed and is held by court order, accomplices not identified; the OFF-CASE? flag on the ForkLog page is a matcher artefact (Riga and Latvia appear only in Russian), the article is the right one.
Question: weapons. For 1: "The criminal also prepared torture tools intended to be used if the victim refused to provide passwords" (prepared weapons in a foiled plot, as 205 and 213). For 0: the tools are not named, and no source says they were seized or carried on the day (205 had a knife carried on the day; 213 had weapons found).
DA recommendation: weapons → 0, prepared torture tools in notes; set 1 if the owner reads "prepared" as present.
+34
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,34 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"71": [
"Dodged Attack"
],
"70": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Kidnapping"
],
"69": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Home Invasion"
],
"61": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"71": [
"theft of the Bitcoin ATM from inside Mike's Produce"
],
"67": [
"a night-time home invasion robbery of a family's home in Irvington-on-Hudson for cash and the code to what the defendants believed was tens of millions of dollars in Bitcoin"
]
},
"parked": [
66,
62
],
"owner": [
63
]
}
+25
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
# Batch 13 decisions (2026-10-01)
Criteria: `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Evidence: `batches/contradictions-13.md`, `batches/batch-13.json`, the dossiers in `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 71** (DA) — scenario: a failed attempt just after 3 a.m. to take the Bitcoin ATM from the back wall of the closed Mike's Produce; nothing taken ("the suspects were unsuccessful in taking the Bitcoin ATM", Kelowna RCMP); sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Dodged Attack, attempted theft of the Bitcoin ATM (as ruled for 158; the group A decision in `disputed-scenarios.md` should cover this case with 158); victim → Mike's Produce (host of the ATM), with L&D Meats and Deli next door losing its front wall to the getaway truck; money_wanted → none (nothing taken); site summary: delete "Threats/intimidation" (no person appears in any account); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); attackers → two, not identified, white GMC Sierra; targeting vector = unknown (the machine, not a holder, was the target); arrests none; the Cointelegraph closing line about an earlier British Columbia ATM break-in is a different incident, not used.
- **DB id 70** (DA) — description → three serving SBU Cyber Department officers seized a crypto-trading businessman near a pub on Mykhailivska Street, Kyiv, beat him and held him until his wife transferred 7 BTC ("Police" → "SBU officers"); notes → pushed into a Volkswagen T5, his iPhone and apartment keys taken, two officers used the keys to take two laptops and a tablet from his flat, beaten with blunt hard objects for about an hour and a half, driven to a forest near Parkova Road, then held unrecorded at the Shevchenkivskyi police department; money_wanted → $200,000 demanded (refused), lowered to $80,000; 7 BTC paid from the wife's wallet (the equivalent of $80,000 then); date 1 October 2020 kept (court ruling of 28 August 2021 as reported); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (real officers abusing their posts are in the glossary's Authority Misuse; held at a building the attackers control, as 93); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 on the blunt hard objects, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = not stated (the officers "had reliable information" that he held significant funds); arrests → three officers charged, under house arrest and suspended, involvement of eight officers examined, no conviction reported; outcome "released" is the nearest value (one account says how he got free is unclear); a false detention report for extradition was filed afterwards; ForkLog's closing line on a staged blogger kidnapping is a different incident, not used.
- **DB id 69** (DA) — money_wanted → Bitcoin worth £6,000 at the time of the robbery plus £3,000 of grant money (mother: "nearly £10,000"); the record's £68,000 is the coins' value when The Sun wrote, keep only as a note; date → 2020, month not stated (the article says "last year" and "first week at university"; the record's September is unsourced; the article's own date is not on file, the copy is a Wayback snapshot of 26 September 2022); location → Canterbury, Kent (Canterbury Christ Church University accommodation); attackers → eight in the mother's account, three suspects refused charge per Kent Police; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (a new friend drew out his crypto holdings and, his mother alleges, invited eight friends who stormed his accommodation and held him at knifepoint for 20 minutes; as 197, and clarification 1 for the room); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0 with The Sun's "violent mugging" noted, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1 incl. a mobile phone, life_taken 0); targeting vector = acquaintance / friend (as 153, 179); arrests → none charged, case dropped after eight months on the evidential test; the friend's role is the mother's allegation, keep the hedge.
- **DB id 68** (DA) — weapons → 1 ("robbed of approximately $800,000 in Bitcoin at gunpoint"); theft → 1 ("forced to transfer the funds to the attacker's wallet"); location → not stated (country UK rests on "a Bitcoin trader from the United Kingdom", which describes the trader, not the scene); date June 2020 kept (month only, per the paragraph); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); attackers → one, not identified; arrests → "later arrested and sentenced to ten years in prison", no name, court or jurisdiction given; targeting vector = business counterparty (arranged sale to a buyer); source: one paragraph in a crypto.ro round-up whose subject is the Boytsov robbery in Bali (Lerner and Meza paragraphs not used); pending: re-source before green (no primary report on file).
- **DB id 67** (DA) — victim → residents of a family home in Irvington-on-Hudson; remove the name Ellis Pinsky and "hacker" (no source on file names the victims or uses the word; restore only if a source naming him is added); description → two men indicted for planning a night-time home-invasion robbery for cash and the code to what they believed was tens of millions of dollars in Bitcoin; no entry or contact took place; notes → "kidnap" → robbery plan; date → May 2020, 18 to 24 May (the indictment's conspiracy window; the record's 23 May falls inside it); location → Irvington-on-Hudson, Westchester County, NY (record's "Irvinton" misspelt); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted night-time home-invasion robbery; flags unchanged (all 0); attackers → Dominic Pineda and Shon Morgan, both 21, of Virginia; arrests → both arrested on 23 June and charged with conspiracy to commit Hobbs Act robbery (year of arrest not stated); targeting vector = unknown; one source (Daily Voice), the record's second link to the same page refused on fetch.
- **DB id 64** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 (three men entered the home, one with a machete, forced the homeowner to transfer his Bitcoin, and a woman was "thrown into a bedroom": forced entry followed by beating or holding, clarification 1); victim → a man (the homeowner) and a woman in the home, relationship not stated (drop "siblings"); description → drop "$200,000" (no source); money_wanted → the homeowner's Bitcoin, worth "anywhere between £100,000 and £1.2m when stolen" per the court; 23.5 BTC later converted and seized as £109,601; coin_type → BTC; notes → one man armed with a machete, another struck the woman repeatedly on the head with a personalised Toblerone bar until it was covered in blood; the homeowner's Audi was taken; date 18 March 2020 kept (BBC); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → three men in the house, not identified, plus the accomplice who received the coins, named John Ross Rennie, 29, in one BBC report and John Ross D'Alfonso, 28, in the other (both noted; the record carries no attacker name); arrests → only the accomplice convicted, of reset, cleared of robbery and assault; the three raiders not reported caught; BBC sidebar links not used.
- **DB id 61** (DA) — money_wanted → US$1 million in Bitcoin demanded; 1.4 million baht (S$62,400) in Bitcoin paid (AsiaOne: "more than $60,000", currency unstated); coin_type → BTC; date → January 2020, day unknown (the source gives only weekdays: arrival on a Thursday, report the next Friday, Lee arrested on the Sunday; the record's 8 January 2020 was a Wednesday); location → seized at a petrol kiosk on the way from Suvarnabhumi Airport, held at four places in forested areas and a hut in a paddy field, reported at Ongkharak Police Station, about 60 km from Bangkok; sequence was Kidnapping; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (an acquaintance allegedly persuaded him to fly in for a business deal and chose the stop; as 210 and 80); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → masked men, not identified; Kim Lee Yao Wei, first reported as a fellow hostage, named by Thai police as the alleged mastermind; targeting vector = acquaintance / friend (known through Bitcoin dealings); arrests → Lee arrested and charged; the masked men not; the actor said to own the car a person of interest; the account of the ordeal is Cheng's own (keep "allegedly", "Cheng claimed"); he was on bail on cheating charges in Singapore at the time.
- **DB id 66** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
- **DB id 62** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 63 (owner)
TL;DR: two masked men with a starter pistol and a knife held two men in a Carlisle house in February 2020, moved money between their bank accounts and tried to open crypto exchange accounts in the victims' names to deposit £3,500.
Settled (DA): kidnappings → 1 (both admitted two counts of false imprisonment); victim → two men (drop "couple"; the intended target was a third man living there); date → February 2020, day unknown; description → the exchange accounts were never authenticated (police alerted first), attempted £3,500 deposit; theft 1 on the games console, iPhone and moved cash; weapons 1 (starter pistol, knife); violence_torture 0; sequence Home Invasion kept; both convicted (six years nine months and six years).
Question: does the case belong in the database? For removal: the court heard the house was targeted because Barrett believed a man living there caused a crash that injured his girlfriend; no cryptocurrency was held, demanded or obtained, and money_wanted and coin_type are null. For keeping: the attackers forced the victims to open crypto exchange accounts to launder the money, which Cumbria Police call a first before a UK court.
DA recommendation: remove from the attack statistics (victims were not crypto holders and crypto was not the motive); if kept, flag it "crypto as laundering route only".
+12
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"60": ["Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Kidnapping"],
"53": ["P2P Trade Gone Wrong", "Kidnapping"],
"52": ["Dodged Attack"]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"52": ["a home invasion of the multi-millionaire's Oslo apartment", "armed robbery of his valuables at shotgun point"]
},
"parked": [57],
"owner": [58, 56, 54]
}
+35
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
# Batch 14 decisions — 2026-10-01
Triage of `batches/contradictions-14.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-14.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Case 57 is on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 60** (DA) — date → 16 January 2020 (LancsLive: "In January 2020" he had reached his withdrawal limit; the meeting was "on Sunday January 16"), conflict logged: 16 January 2020 was a Thursday and a Sunday 16 January fits 2022, so the year rests on the article's "In January 2020" (as with 108); location → Preston: the meeting was moved from the Travelodge in New Hall Lane to the Winckley Square apartments, paid for by Rahman, which the same report also calls "the hotel room"; he was let out of the car boot in Chorley; money_wanted → £20,000 demanded ("They said they knew he had £20,000"), his withdrawal limit was £10,000, nothing reported paid or transferred; coin_type stays empty (no coin named); attackers → four: Tasmina Rhaman, 21 (spelled Rahman in the later paragraphs), her 16-year-old cousin (machete), Takudzwa Murombedzi, 20 (balaclava), Albert Kahiya, 19 (driver); theft 1 rests on "his mobile phone taken from him" and the robbery pleas, no crypto reported taken; sequence was Malicious Invitation - SocialEng; now Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping (approached through a fake Snapchat profile, restrained in premises the attacker paid for, then driven around in a car boot; pre-selected, so Kidnapping under the rule of 2026-10-01); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; targeting vector = online lure (fake Snapchat profile; his success was "common knowledge"); arrests → convicted: Murombedzi and the 16-year-old pleaded guilty to robbery and conspiracy to kidnap (six years and five years, concurrent), Kahiya to conspiracy to kidnap (four years), Rahman to conspiracy to kidnap, sentencing set for 16 January; one source (LancsLive, two copies that match).
- **DB id 59** (DA) — location → Lucas area, along the Police Station axis of Abraka, Ethiope East local government area, Delta State (his residence); date January 2020 kept, day unknown (Vanguard's February 2020 report says "last month"; HeraldSheets dates the police confirmation of the arrests to 25 February 2020); money_wanted → $10,000 in BTC is the balance the attackers expected to find, per their confessional statements ("disappointed to find out that what was left when they struck was $400"), not a sum demanded of him; whether the $400 was taken is not stated; theft 1 rests on "They eventually left with the phone"; description keeps "shot dead", the suspects say they shot him twice "as he made an attempt to identify them while they were trying to open his account through his phone"; victim → Iroro Wisdom Ovie, father of two, PDP member; attackers → eight members of the Vikings confraternity named by police, four arrested including the victim's close friend and the local Vikings leader; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, beaten and held at his residence while they tried to open his account, clarification 1; violence_torture 1, a man shot dead as in 215, 102, 96; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 1; life_taken 1); targeting vector = leak from the victim's circle (his "bosom friend" told one suspect about the $10,000 in his Bitcoin wallet); arrests → some (four of eight in custody); sources: Vanguard and the HeraldSheets rewrite crediting Punch carry the same police-source quotes, so nothing is independently corroborated; HeraldSheets' closing safety advice not used.
- **DB id 55** (DA) — description "Man raided in office" → two masked men rang his office door late in the evening, forced him inside when he opened it, demanded money and cryptocurrency; he handed over cash and had to transfer cryptocurrency from his computer; they bound him with cable and duct tape and left him in the office; he freed himself and called police; notes → "armed with a pistol and a rubber truncheon" (the record omits the truncheon); victim → 30-year-old man; money_wanted "unknown" kept (ORF: "The amount is not yet known"); date 26 July 2019 kept, unverified on file (ORF says only "in the evening"); sequence Home Invasion kept (his office is his own space; the glossary's Home Invasion entry names an office, and the State Criminal Investigation Office called it the pattern of a home invasion); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, no blow or injury, he suffered shock; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 1; life_taken 0); outcome escaped (freed himself); held duration not stated; targeting vector = unknown; arrests none reported; the ORF page is the right one despite the WEAK anchor in auto-trim-review.md (the German original matches line for line); a follow-up report would be needed for the sum.
- **DB id 53** (DA) — money_wanted → 80 BTC (₹8 crore, $1.2 million per Newsweek) demanded for Luftan Shaikh and Mohammad Shazad, plus ₹10 lakh ($15,000) demanded from Malang Shah's family, both carried; coin_type → BTC (the ₹10 lakh demand names no coin); notes "two weeks" → held captive for 15 days in a flat in a high-rise building (the same report also says "more than two weeks"); victims → Luftan Shaikh, 19, Mohammad Shazad, 36, Malang Shah, 44 (Shah taken two days after the other two); attackers → seven arrested: Jitendra Kumar, Deepak Kumar, Anupam Soni, Pawan Kumar, Bhawani Singh, Lokendra Singh, Rahul Kumar; police found the flat after a suspect seen carrying a pistol in Bhakrota was caught; date 30 June 2019 kept, unverified on file (a Sunday, matching "the police operation on Sunday"; no calendar date printed in the report, and the captivity began about 15 days earlier); sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (lured by gang members "who claimed to be selling bitcoins at a low price", so the trade was the approach and P2P comes first, as 104 and 143; then held in the gang's flat); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 "beaten or tortured", drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 guns seized, theft 0 nothing reported paid, life_taken 0); outcome rescued; held duration days; targeting vector = trade lure (offer of cheap bitcoin), how the victims were found not stated; arrests some (seven); one source (Newsweek relaying the Hindustan Times and NDTV); the closing passage on a South African case not used.
- **DB id 52** (DA) — description kept ("Bitcoin millionaire escapes armed home invader by jumping off balcony"): on the afternoon of 14 May a man with a sawed-off shotgun forced his way into the apartment when the victim opened the door and said "Get down, or I'll shoot"; the victim ran onto the balcony and jumped from the second floor; "The robber did not get any valuables"; whether he was injured is unknown; victim → man in his 40s who has worked with cryptocurrency for nearly ten years, worth over 100 million kroner per his company's accounts; date 14 May 2019 kept (TV 2: "May 14 this year"); sequence was Home Invasion; now Dodged Attack, attempted: a home invasion of his Oslo apartment and armed robbery of his valuables at shotgun point (foiled attempt, as 147 and 84); kidnappings stays 0 (control never gained, he fled at once; clarification 3; DA call, owner may set 1); flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, threat only; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 0; life_taken 0); no crypto demand appears in the file, case kept on the victim's occupation (as 123); targeting vector = public profile (he "has previously appeared in public due to his success in making money with cryptocurrency"; the article does not link this to the attack); arrests → one man charged by the Oslo Public Prosecutor's Office, denies guilt, trial set for 17 and 18 October, arrest not stated; one source (TV 2, Norwegian original matches).
- **DB id 51** (DA) — weapons → 1 ("one threatened staff with a curved machete while the other smashed a Bitcoin machine off the shop wall with a sledgehammer"; the record's own notes already say machete); victim → staff of the Costcutter shop on St Leonard's Road, Far Cotton, Northampton (the Bitcoin machine was the target; Article 2: "threatened a shopkeeper with a machete"); date 12 March 2019 confirmed ("At around 8.30pm on Tuesday, March 12"); attackers → three masked men, one waiting outside; description → two went in, one held staff off with a machete while the other broke the machine off the wall, and they left on foot with it; amount in the machine not stated; sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept (glossary: armed robbery of a crypto ATM location, staff threatened); kidnappings stays 0 (staff threatened, no restraint or holding described; DA call as in 82, owner may set 1); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, threat only; drugs_alcohol 0; theft 1; life_taken 0); people were present and threatened, so the case is outside the disputed ATM group; targeting vector = unknown; arrests none reported; three copies of one police appeal on file, Article 2's sidebar teasers not used.
- **DB id 57** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 58 (owner) — Lørenskog, Anne-Elisabeth Hagen, 31 October 2018
TL;DR: wife of a property and energy investor vanished from home; ransom note, €9m in Monero demanded per Verdens Gang; by June 2019 police's main hypothesis is that she was killed and the kidnapping possibly staged.
Settled (DA): location → Lørenskog, about 20 km from Oslo; money_wanted €9m in Monero kept, sourced to Verdens Gang (police refused to confirm the sum, advised the family not to pay; nothing paid); life_taken 1 rests on lead investigator Tommy Brøske's "our main hypothesis has been modified – Anne-Elisabeth was killed", no body or arrest on file; violence_torture → unconfirmed (no assault described).
Question: does the case stay, and under what? For keeping: a ransom note and a Monero demand at a wealthy family's home. Against: no captivity was ever established ("unable to confirm that those people were holding Hagen"), police think the kidnapping was staged to disguise a murder, motive not established.
DA recommendation: keep, mark DISPUTED (as 171), kidnappings → unconfirmed, sequence Kidnapping kept as the police's first theory with the staging hypothesis as a gap.
### DB id 56 (owner) — Dehradun, Abdul Shakoor, 2019
TL;DR: alleged operator of a Rs 485 crore bitcoin investment scheme tortured to death in his rented house by five associates who wanted his account password.
Settled (DA): weapons → 0 (no weapon named: "beaten to death by five of his associates"); notes "pretending his wallet ... got hacked" → "allegedly told them that his bitcoin account had been hacked"; date 26 August 2019 unsupported on file (NDTV gives only "Thursday night" and "Friday"; keep, mark approximate); five arrested (unnamed), five more aides sought (Ashique, Arshad, Yasin, Rehaab, Muneef); kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, life_taken 1, theft 0 unchanged.
Question 1, inclusion: the victim is himself an alleged fraudster and the attackers his own associates chasing investors' money. DA recommendation: keep (crypto credentials extracted by torture is the attack the database records), targeting vector = business counterparty, gap noted.
Question 2, scenario: record Kidnapping; verified Home Invasion ("They arrived in Dehradun, where Shakoor had been living in a rented house, and pressured him for the password"; the only journey is his killers taking him to two hospitals afterwards). Entry method not stated. DA recommendation: Home Invasion, venue = victim's private space.
### DB id 54 (owner) — Birmingham, Bitcoin exchange, 15 July 2019
TL;DR: masked gang ransacked a Bitcoin exchange and tried to pull out its Bitcoin ATM with a rope tied to their car; police say nothing of value was stolen; nobody was confronted.
Settled (DA): theft → 0 ("confirmed that nothing of value was stolen from the business"); weapons → 0 (only "a rope attached to their car"); location → Birmingham (Sparkhill is in no source); description "hold up ... in front of dozens of witnesses" → raided and ransacked the building while witnesses looked on, then sped away; the cash motive is the owner Adam Gramowski's belief ("There are no BTC in the machine"); business name unresolved (URL slug "bitcoin-embassy", body "Bitcoin exchange"); the closing sentence on a February attack is another case.
Question: follow 158 (attempted ATM theft, nobody present, ruled Dodged Attack) or add the case to disputed group A (crypto ATM thefts with nobody confronted)? The list notes that the group decision should cover 158 too.
DA recommendation: add 54 to group A so one decision covers it with 57 and 158; until then Dodged Attack with the attempted ATM theft listed, as in 158.
+14
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"50": ["Authority Misuse", "Home Invasion"],
"48": ["Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Kidnapping"],
"44": ["Authority Misuse", "Home Invasion"],
"43": ["Home Invasion"],
"41": ["Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "P2P Trade Gone Wrong"]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"43": ["theft of the design framework for the skycoin ecosystem, which the article says the gang attempted and failed"]
},
"parked": [45],
"owner": [49, 46, 42, 40]
}
+40
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
# Batch 15 decisions — 2026-10-01
Triage of `batches/contradictions-15.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-15.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Case 45 is on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 50** (DA) — victim → Bitcoin trader, identity withheld by police ("Police did not reveal the identity of the victim"); the record's "Tjeerd H." is in no source on file and is removed (restore only with a source); location → Drenthe, Netherlands (village not named; Drouwenerveen is in no source on file); date 10 February 2019 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the report gives no date for the raid); description → three robbers disguised as police entered his home, attacked him with a drill in front of his four-year-old daughter and threatened him with firearms during an hour-long ordeal, then fled in an escape vehicle; "it is not believed any cryptocurrency was stolen"; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (police disguise at the door, as 150); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, held an hour in his own home, clarification 1; violence_torture 1; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 0; life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests none reported, investigation ongoing (Northern Netherlands Police); one source (The Independent relaying De Telegraaf); the round-up tail (Richards 2015, Lerner 2017, Aston 2018) not used.
- **DB id 48** (DA) — location → Soweto, Johannesburg ("The crime took place in Soweto"; Lanseria is the victim's home town); money_wanted → Bitcoin worth approximately 900,000 rand ($65,984) transferred, plus two mobile phones, two laptops and 3,000 rand in cash taken; coin_type → BTC; the sub-headline's "hundreds of thousands of dollars" contradicts the body and is not used (as with 216 and 111); weapons → 1 ("burned him with a hot iron"; the glossary counts other tools used as weapons, as the sand-filled glove in 86); victim "Andrew" kept as the article quotes it (may be a pseudonym), of Lanseria; date 16 November 2018 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate); attackers → five people at the second house, plus the man met on Facebook who invited him (whether he was among the five is not stated); sequence was Malicious Invitation - SocialEng; now Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping (invited to give a presentation at a private residence, knocked out with a chemical-soaked cloth, woke in a different house; taken to a place the attackers held, so Kidnapping); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); outcome released (dumped blindfolded at a roadside, in intensive care for burns); held duration not stated; targeting vector = online lure (met on Facebook, then in person); arrests not stated; single second-hand source (Finance Magnates relaying Soweto Urban), no police source; the round-up tail of the fetched page not used.
- **DB id 44** (DA) — description "$250,000" → approximately 210,000 euros in cryptocurrency (both sources), transferred by one perpetrator, plus jewellery, gold coins, electronic devices and designer clothing; money_wanted 210,000 EUR kept; coin_type "eur" → cryptocurrency, coin not named (Unzensuriert: "access codes to his Bitcoin wallets"; CT-de: "various online exchanges"); victim → Turkish Bitcoin trader (Unzensuriert); his partner and their baby were also tied up in the bedroom; date 19 June 2018 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the reports cover the trial and place the attack in "the previous year"); attackers → five men tried for kidnapping, aggravated robbery, coercion and extortion, most confessed per their lawyers; mastermind a 21-year-old Upper Austrian who planned it with his father (tried separately); Unzensuriert: two Austrian main perpetrators hired three Chechens; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (fake postal workers at the door; 44 is named in the general ruling of 2026-09-30, so the writer's proposal to drop Authority Misuse is not taken); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, trader taped to a chair in a storage room; violence_torture 1, threatened with knives for an hour and a half, and Unzensuriert: wife "dragged by her hair and abused", threat to kidnap the nine-month-old; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 1; life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (one defendant "had apparently invested a five-digit sum with the robbed crypto trader and lost it" and called it debt collection); arrests → five on trial, verdict not on file; source notes: Unzensuriert has no URL in the sheet and is the sole source for the hair-dragging, the threat to the baby and the Chechen hires (find a URL); the CT-de page is this case despite the WEAK anchor, its closing round-up of two Russian cases not used.
- **DB id 43** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("They proceeded to hold Synth and his wife against their will for 6 hours"); violence_torture → 1 ("they threatened, beat and robbed them"); theft → 1 ("only able to extract 18.88 Bitcoin and 6466 skycoins"); victim "Skycoin architect" → Skycoin CEO known as Synth, and his wife; attackers → nine individuals, members of Skycoin's China-based marketing team (per the company); location: the article places the marketing team in China and does not say where the home is; date 13 June 2018 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the only dates are the blog post of 18 June and press time 19 June); sequence was Kidnapping; now Home Invasion, attempted: theft of the design framework for the Skycoin ecosystem (held six hours in their own home, no relocation reported; the glossary keeps Kidnapping for victims moved elsewhere, as 176 and 197 were set to Home Invasion for the victim's own space); other flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, life_taken 0); outcome not stated; targeting vector = insider (the company's own marketing team); arrests not stated; single source, the company's own blog post relayed by Bitcoinist, no police statement, mark low-confidence (as 199).
- **DB id 41** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("assaulted the two and tied their hands, locked them inside the room"); violence_torture → 1 ("assaulted and robbed two Asian brothers at gun point"); weapons → 1 (same quote); theft → 1 ("stole AED7m ($1.9m)"; the money was recovered and returned to the brothers); location → Al Muraqabbat, Dubai (a trading office the gang leader got the key to by posing as a buyer of the office); money_wanted → AED 7 million in cash brought to buy Bitcoin ($1.9m per Arabian Business), coin_type → cash (AED); attackers → gang of ten led by a Gulf national, six inside the office and the rest outside; date 25 April 2018 confirmed; sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → P2P Trade Gone Wrong (the gang "lured the two, claiming that they can sell Bitcoin", and engineered the meeting in an office obtained by deceiving its owner, so Malicious Invitation first, as ruled in 117); other flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); status → all ten arrested within 48 hours, money returned; held duration and how they got out not stated; targeting vector = trade lure, how contact was made not stated; source notes: Article 2 (byline Amira Agarib) has no URL in the sheet and is the sole source for the tied hands, the locked room and the deceived office owner (find a URL); the deceived office owner is a further victim with no field.
- **DB id 45** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 49 (owner) — Witbank and Middelburg, Mpumalanga, May and August 2018
TL;DR: one record holds two incidents by the same two suspects: a 13-year-old boy snatched near his Witbank home on 20 May 2018 and held for a ransom in bitcoin, and a failed attempt on a 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg, on 21 August 2018.
Settled (DA): date → 20 May 2018 (the record's 17 January 2019 is the TimesLive report date); description: the girl was "dragged into their vehicle" and escaped when "a group of people working nearby" came to her aid, not the police; money_wanted R1.5m in BTC kept ("ransom in the form of Bitcoins", "the equivalent of R1.5m"); theft → unconfirmed (police "had not disclosed whether any ransom had been paid"); attackers → two men aged 30 and 31 per the body (the caption says both 37), arrested in November (Germiston) and on 30 December (Ladysmith), bail R1,000 each; sequence Kidnapping → Dodged Attack kept (boy reunited unharmed days later; ransom note left for the parents, so Kidnapping); other flags unchanged.
Question: split the 21 August 2018 attempt on the girl into its own record? For: different victim, date and town. Against: same suspects and one police statement, and the attempt is already carried as the attempted entry.
DA recommendation: split, as the owner asked for 124's November 2021 incident; this record keeps the boy's kidnapping.
### DB id 46 (owner) — New York, Nicholas Truglia, 7 September 2018
TL;DR: four friends allegedly escorted a drunk Truglia to his West 42nd Street apartment at 2:50 a.m., held his head underwater, punched him and threw hot wax on him for his crypto logins, and left about two hours later with his laptop, two phones and a thumb drive; the defence says he has recanted.
Settled (DA): notes → laptop, two mobile phones and a thumb drive with his crypto account information (the iPhone and laptop allegedly returned); kidnappings → 1 as alleged (head held underwater, restrained); status → Orso, Leica, Dorn and David each charged with second-degree burglary, released without bail; complaint does not say whether any crypto was taken; targeting vector = acquaintance / friend.
Question 1, scenario: record Malicious Invitation; verified Home Invasion. For Home Invasion: control taken and held in his own flat for about two hours. Against: no forced entry, they walked him in. For Malicious Invitation: no lure is described. DA recommendation: Home Invasion with the gap (entry by trust), and mark the case DISPUTED (recanted, defence audio given to the DA), as 171.
Question 2, drugs_alcohol 1: rests on "after a night of drinking" and "a soused Truglia"; nothing says the men supplied the drink. DA recommendation: 0 (the writer proposed unconfirmed).
### DB id 42 (owner) — Milan, 22-year-old seller, 6 June 2018
TL;DR: two men and a woman tried to pay for Bitcoin with a suitcase of counterfeit notes in an office rented for an hour on Viale Abruzzi; when he spotted it and tried to leave he was beaten and a blank pistol was fired; the woman fled with 50,000 euros from the earlier trade.
Settled (DA): one victim, a 22-year-old (not "victims"); one earlier trade, 7 BTC for 50,000 euros in a bar in the Quadrilatero (not two); weapons 1 kept, the gun "later revealed to be a blank pistol" (as the imitation firearm in 136); theft 1: 50,000 euros in cash, no Bitcoin left his wallet, coin_type → cash (EUR); violence_torture 1 (broken nose, 14-day prognosis); attackers → a 33-year-old Serbian and a 35-year-old Cuban arrested, a woman fled; targeting vector = business counterparty (introduced through a Russian friend he often does business with); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept, attempted: the counterfeit payment.
Question: kidnappings 0 → 1? For: "he closed his computer and tried to leave the room but was attacked", in an office the attackers rented (glossary: "prevented from leaving"). Against: not tied or locked in, minutes long, could read as an attack in passing (clarification 3).
DA recommendation: 1 (stopped from leaving by force while the money was taken).
### DB id 40 (owner) — Miami, Ryan Rice, April 2018
TL;DR: Rice and a companion brought $30,000 cash to buy Bitcoin from an unidentified dealer, handed the cash over in their car, then while escorting the dealer through a garage stairwell Marcarrous Clark grabbed at a backpack with the cash; Rice shot him; Clark is charged with strong-arm attempted robbery.
Settled (DA): victims → Ryan Rice and an unidentified companion; date 11 April 2018 unsupported on file ("last week", "still hospitalized Monday"; keep, mark approximate); Clark hospitalised, condition unknown, no death; violence_torture 0, kidnappings 0 unchanged.
Question 1, weapons 1: the only weapon is the victim's gun. 84 kept weapons 1 on the attackers' pepper spray, not on the victim's pistol. DA recommendation: 0, with the victim's firearm in notes.
Question 2, theft and frame: the charge is attempted robbery, but Rice had handed over the $30,000 and the file never says whether the Bitcoin arrived or whether the dealer was in on it. DA recommendation: theft → unconfirmed; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Dodged Attack kept (as 189), gap: the dealer's role is not stated.
+13
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"34": ["Express Kidnapping"],
"28": ["Armed Robbery in Public Space", "Dodged Attack"],
"32": ["Authority Misuse", "Kidnapping"]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"30": ["a break-in at a Forsyth County home to steal nearly $1 million in Bitcoin"],
"28": ["an outbound cryptocurrency transaction from the exchange, forced on the bound employees"]
},
"parked": [],
"owner": [38, 33, 32]
}
+28
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
# Batch 16 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-01
Cases 39, 38, 35, 34, 33, 32, 30, 29, 28, 27. Evidence in `batches/contradictions-16.md`, `batches/batch-16.json` and `sources/`. Rules in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 39** (DA) — description → robbed of $365,000 in cash brought to buy bitcoin, no crypto taken (Straits Times: "robbed of $365,000 in cash instead"); the currency of the $365,000 is not stated, so no conversion; weapons → 0 (no weapon in either report; the charge is robbery with hurt); victim → Pang Joon Hau, plus the Singaporean broker he brought, also assaulted and not named; attackers → two men charged with robbery with hurt, Mohd Abdul Rahman Mohamad (Cointelegraph spells it Mohama) and Syed Mokhtar Syed Yusope, and Abdul Rahman's former wife charged with receiving stolen property; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (cash only); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (a claimed seller and a claimed broker arranged the meeting; how they found him is not stated); arrests → both men arrested 9 and 10 April and charged; two reports on file (Cointelegraph and a Straits Times court report), the second report's list of the accused's earlier unrelated offences not used.
- **DB id 35** (DA) — money_wanted → about 100 BTC (approximately $1,020,000 at Cointelegraph's press time), coin_type → BTC; description keeps the double hedge (Cointelegraph relaying Forklog, "local sources report"); date 23 February 2018 kept (Cointelegraph: "today, Feb. 23"); sequence Assault - Mugging kept, gap: the file says nothing about planning either way; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; no arrests; single source; the closing paragraphs on the St Petersburg blogger (25), the Forklog raid and Pavel Lerner (22) not used.
- **DB id 34** (DA) — date → 23 February 2018, about 10 pm (Forklog via Cointelegraph; the record's 26 February is the Forklog publication date); weapons → 0 (no weapon anywhere in the report; four men, a car and a beating); money_wanted → 300 BTC (a little over $3 million per Cointelegraph), $20,000 in cash and three iPhones, plus the laptop giving access to the wallet; coin_type → BTC; sequence was Kidnapping; now Express Kidnapping (seized on Isakovskogo Street, beaten while driven around the city in a Mercedes, released the same night; no holding place described; rule of 2026-10-01: the sources do not say how he was chosen, so Express is the default and the gap is noted; he is named as the creator of PRIZM, and a source showing pre-selection would move him to Kidnapping); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1 for the pill forced down with vodka before release, per Mash via Cointelegraph, theft 1, life_taken 0); no arrests; the account rests on Mayorov's own allegations relayed by Forklog and Mash; the article's closing paragraphs on other cases not used.
- **DB id 30** (DA) — description → drop "armed" (no weapon in the report; the men carried zip ties, latex gloves, duct tape and bandanas and were charged with residential strong arm robbery): five men arrested over a planned robbery of a Forsyth County homeowner said to hold nearly $1 million in Bitcoin; date 29 January 2018 kept (night of the hotel contact; arrests ran from 30 January to 11 May 2018); attackers → five: Trivette Adams, Robert South (the narrative says Jacob South), Matthew Schwartz, Michael McDermott (the narrative says McDermont), Justin Ellison; money_wanted → nearly $1 million in Bitcoin as the target, no demand made; coin_type → BTC; sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted: a break-in at the home to steal the Bitcoin (foiled before any contact, as ruled in 84 and 147); flags unchanged (all 0); arrests → all five charged and held without bond; single source (11Alive), victim not named.
- **DB id 29** (DA) — date → 22 January 2018 (Business Insider: "on January 22"; the Telegraph of Sunday 28 January: police called "at around 9.40am on Monday"); kidnappings → 1 (door kicked down, a woman tied up, the occupants threatened with what appeared to be a firearm while a transfer was demanded; clarification 1); weapons → 1 (police: "with what appeared to be a firearm", hedge kept); victim → Danny Aston and Amy Jay, noting a third occupant: police say "the two men and a woman" were inside, and the man struck on the head was treated at John Radcliffe Hospital and discharged; money_wanted → an unknown quantity of bitcoin, coin_type → BTC; theft 0 kept (police: "the attempted transaction of bitcoins failed", "Nothing was stolen"); sequence Home Invasion kept (control of the house was taken; the transfer failed technically, so not a dodged attack); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); notes → baby kept outside in a pram (Mail on Sunday via the Telegraph); targeting vector = unknown (police: "may be a targeted incident"); no arrests; two reports on file (Telegraph, Business Insider).
- **DB id 28** (DA) — victim → "Canadian Bitcoins" removed: neither report names the business ("The authorities have not revealed the name of the cryptocurrency exchange"); victim → five employees of a Bitcoin business on Concourse Gate, Ottawa, name not revealed; kidnappings → 1 (three men "gained control over four employees and bound them"; five counts of forcible confinement; clarification 2); attackers → three armed with handguns: a 19-year-old from Ottawa arrested (named by The Hacker News as Jimmy St-Hilaire), two still sought; sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Armed Robbery in Public Space → Dodged Attack, attempted: an outbound crypto transaction forced on the bound staff (a hidden fifth employee called police and the suspects fled empty-handed; as ruled in 84 and 147); date 23 January 2018 kept (the Tuesday before the 24 January police release); flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, an employee struck on the head with a gun and taken to hospital; weapons 1; theft 0; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (no amount or coin named); two reports on file (CBC, The Hacker News), the Hacker News closing paragraphs on EXMO and Louis Meza not used.
- **DB id 27** (DA) — violence_torture → 1 (pushed to the floor; minor hand and leg injuries, bandaged at the scene; same reading as 89); location → King's Road, North Point (the lure began at the Starbucks on Hennessy Road, Wan Chai); attackers → five sought: two who posed as sellers and three masked men who attacked; money_wanted → HK$1.4 million in cash (US$180,000 per SCMP) plus a mobile phone, kept in Hong Kong dollars; coin_type → cash (HKD), the lure being five bitcoin at a five per cent discount; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, attacked from behind and the bag snatched; weapons 0, "Police said no weapon was used"; theft 1; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); targeting vector = online lure (contacted through WeChat); no arrests; single source (SCMP), promotional headlines in the fetched copy not used.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 38** (owner) — two bear-spray robberies of Bitcoin ATMs inside petrol-station shops, Irving (22 March 2018) and Mesquite (28 March 2018), held in one record.
- Settled (DA): drugs_alcohol → 0 (bear spray is a weapon, not a drug); weapons → 1 (bear spray and a crowbar, Fox 4; as in 84 and 160); violence_torture 1, kidnappings 0, theft 1 (cash cassettes, amount not disclosed) kept; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty; no arrests.
- Q1: split into two records? For: two businesses in two cities six days apart ("Six days later, a similar robbery took place at the Exxon"). Against: same pair, one Fox 4 story. DA recommends split (Irving 22 March, Mesquite 28 March).
- Q2: the target was ATM cash and the victims were clerks. Group A of `disputed-scenarios.md` (crypto ATM thefts) is pending. For keeping it as Armed Robbery in Public Space: the clerks were present and sprayed, the same reasoning that kept 84 in. DA recommends keep and include it when the group A decision is made.
**DB id 33** (owner) — three men posing as bitcoin buyers lured trader Tai to Taichung, assaulted him and his friend, moved 18 BTC (NT$5 million) off his phone and forced Kaoliang liquor on him.
- Settled (DA): violence_torture → 1 ("assaulted him and his friend"; "bloodstains at the scene"); weapons → 0 (none in either report); money_wanted → 18 BTC (NT$5 million), coin_type → BTC; date → February 2018, day unknown (the report says "earlier this month" and puts Britain's first bitcoin armed robbery "last month"; 21 February is not printed); attackers → three at the scene plus Shih, the alleged mastermind, detained later; friend added as second victim; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; drugs_alcohol 1 kept; all four detained.
- Q: detention. For 1: the attackers kept control through the assault, the transfer from his phone and the forced drinking (139: held at the table until the transfer = 1). For 0: no restraint, holding or place is described. DA recommends 1.
**DB id 32** (owner) — Gujarat police officers and a CBI officer summoned Surat builder Shailesh Bhatt, beat him, held him at a farmhouse at gunpoint and extorted bitcoin; 14 convicted, 11 of them police.
- Settled (DA): sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (held at Keshav Farms by the officers; as 111 and 93); location → Gandhinagar, Gujarat (CBI office, fuel station, Keshav Farms), the officers from Amreli district; attackers → FIR against ten police incl. Amreli SP Jagdish Patel and inspector Anant Patel, plus Sunil Nair, Kirit Paladiya and ex-MLA Nalin Kotadiya; 14 sentenced to life; notes → "the only one who knew" becomes Paladiya "knew about my investment" (Bhatt's allegation), and "accused of kidnapping two others earlier that same year" becomes accused of kidnapping two BitConnect promoters after the BitConnect collapse, undated, arrested 13 August 2024 (separate incident); targeting vector = business counterparty (former partner, per Bhatt); flags unchanged.
- Q: which amount does the record carry? India Today (Bhatt's 2018 allegation): Rs 13 crore in bitcoin (200 BTC) to Paladiya's account plus Rs 5 crore cash via hawala; the CID said the bitcoin payment was not confirmed. The Block (trial): 176 BTC plus Rs 32 crore demanded, 34 BTC sold and about $150,000 transferred, cash delivery fell through. DA recommends the trial figures as money_wanted, Bhatt's figures in notes as his allegation, and "200 BTC" dropped from the description; theft 1 stays either way.
+10
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"26": ["Authority Misuse", "Home Invasion"],
"25": ["Costly Fame", "Home Invasion"],
"23": ["Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Authority Misuse", "Home Invasion"]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [24, 21],
"owner": [20, 18, 16]
}
+29
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
# Batch 17 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-01
Cases 26, 25, 24, 23, 22, 21, 20, 19, 18, 16. Evidence in `batches/contradictions-17.md`, `batches/batch-17.json` and `sources/`. Rules in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 26** (DA) — victim → Maxsim Latsoka, 23, and Anna Nikurina, 28 (AseanNow), noting the second report's spelling Maxim Lastovka and Anna Nikulina; coin_type → BTC, the other losses (iPhone X, iPad, MacBook Pro, credit cards, passports) moved to notes; money_wanted 100,000 EUR in BTC kept (AseanNow body), noting "nearly 4 million baht" (AseanNow opening line) and "approximately" / "over $100,000" (second report); location → Mueang (Muang) district, Phuket, fourth-floor condo (second report: Lago Naiharn Beach); held five hours (Thai Rath via AseanNow) or six hours (second report), both noted; summary → drop "Gang of 10 perpetrators" (three men described, no total given); sequence was Home Invasion; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (the men said they were "Interpol from Russia investigating Bitcoin irregularities"; Authority Misuse ruling of 2026-09-30); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0 with threats only, drugs_alcohol 0 since the injection was threatened only, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = surveillance (second report: the gang had been tracking the couple, and Lastovka recognised one member from hanging around the apartment); no arrests, an international arrest warrant issued and the gang believed to be in Malaysia; the WEAK fetched block (site furniture) and the second report's advice section not used.
- **DB id 25** (DA) — description → masked men tied and beat him at home and took a safe holding 24 million rubles ($425,000 per Cointelegraph) in cash and documents; no crypto transfer reported (he "has yet to find out if his accounts have been hacked"); kidnappings → 1 (tied in his own home; clarification 1); weapons → unconfirmed ("armed" appears only in NTV's "criminal case ... on the armed assault"; no weapon described); money_wanted → 24 million RUB in cash (~$425,000 per Cointelegraph), coin_type → cash (RUB); notes → the laptop he traded on was taken (NTV) and all electronic equipment destroyed (ForkLog); location Leningrad Oblast kept, the opening line's "St. Petersburg" noted; sequence was Costly Fame; now Costly Fame → Home Invasion (held and beaten in his own home; Costly Fame as the targeting, as in 86 and 201); flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = public profile / media (boasted of his wealth online and at blogger meetings; crypto-trading YouTube channel per ForkLog); no arrests, criminal case opened; Cointelegraph's pointers to cases 22 and the ForkLog raid not used.
- **DB id 23** (DA) — date → 2 September 2018, about 1:45 a.m. (the record's "September I, 2018" is an OCR of 1, and 1 September was the dinner the evening before); month field → 9 (record holds 1 against quarter 2018-Q3); violence_torture → 1 (Taylor "handcuffed, and assaulted"; Iza "assaulted Woody and Masters"; the trigger pulled, the gun did not fire); drugs_alcohol → 1 as alleged ("Zelocchi and Iza forced pills into Taylor's mouth"); money_wanted → approximately 7,100 BTC plus some altcoins, about $284,500,000 at the complaint's filing value (Krebs, summarising the same suit: more than $200 million), coin_type → BTC; victim → T.W. (Troy Woody Jr.) plus Eric Taylor (attacked in the lobby) and the girlfriend (complaint: Michelle Masters; Krebs: Tomi Masters); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Malicious Invitation → Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (a dinner arranged by Zelocchi on the pretext of crypto investing and a call bringing Taylor down to the lobby, as in 103; Iza claimed to be an FBI agent and flashed a badge to enter, Authority Misuse ruling of 2026-09-30; occupants handcuffed in the apartment); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, 9mm handgun; theft 1; life_taken 0, Masters' death in Manila in December 2018 is a separate matter); arrests → none for this robbery (reported to police 4 September 2018); the whole account is Woody's civil complaint, allegation framing kept; link to 106 and 124 (same Adam Iza; in those records Enzo Zelocchi is Iza's victim, here his co-defendant); the Krebs PDF byte stream and the passages on other victims not used.
- **DB id 22** (DA) — description → analyst at the EXMO exchange kidnapped outside his Kyiv office and released after a ransom of more than $1 million in bitcoin ("owner" dropped: Reuters calls him "an employee", EXMO "an analytics manager"; only the Cointelegraph article filed under 35 calls him CEO); weapons → 1 on Strana.ua's report as relayed by Reuters ("six gun-toting men"), not confirmed by police or EXMO; money_wanted → more than $1 million in bitcoins, paid as ransom (Gerashchenko to Reuters), who paid not stated; notes → vehicle a minibus with stolen number plates (Strana.ua) or a black Mercedes-Benz (BBC), both noted; location → Obolon district, Kyiv; where he was held not stated; reports → Reuters (Pavel Polityuk) added beside BBC; sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, "no physical harm inflicted on him"; drugs_alcohol 0; theft 1; life_taken 0); held duration not stated (release reported on the Friday after 26 December); no arrests, criminal investigation opened.
- **DB id 19** (DA) — weapons → 1 (Colon "popped out with what appeared to be a gun"; "drove the victim around for two hours at gunpoint"; Colon told investigators it was a BB gun, noted); theft → 1 ("stole $1.8 million" in Ether, moved with the stolen memory stick; most of it recovered); violence_torture → threat only (gun stuck in his ribs and a hood over his head, no injury reported; as 179 and 202; owner may set 1 for the contact); kidnappings 1 per the ruling of 2026-09-06 (held captive in the van two hours; Meza pleaded guilty to second-degree kidnapping); description → lured by a friend into a fake Uber and held at gunpoint in a van for two hours while accomplices took his wallet from his apartment, $1.8M in ETH moved, most recovered; money_wanted $1.8 million in ETH kept (two NY Post reports), noting "nearly $2 million" (June 2018 report); sequence Authority Misuse → Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping kept as already ruled (2026-09-30 and 2026-10-01); other flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); arrests → Meza pleaded guilty on 5 September 2018 to first-degree grand larceny and second-degree kidnapping, Guzman, Nunez and Colon pleaded not guilty and were pending in the latest report; targeting vector = acquaintance (Meza, the victim's friend); gap: the burglary of his apartment ran at the same time; defence material on bail and charity work not used.
- **DB id 24** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
- **DB id 21** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 20** (owner) — five men posing as police stopped a businessman's car in Merter, Istanbul, and forced his online-banking passwords out of him at gunpoint; cybercrime police say 450 BTC ($2.83 million) were robbed.
- Settled (DA): kidnappings → 1 (held at gunpoint in his stopped car); location → Merter district, Istanbul; date → incident date not stated, 15 November 2017 is the Wednesday of the reports (keep, mark approximate); description → banking passwords forced at gunpoint, how the 450 BTC moved not stated; sequence Authority Misuse kept; other flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1); arrests → the gang detained, no charge reported.
- Q: the same suspects "had also stolen bitcoin mining devices from three different people in Esenler district". Separate records? For: three further victims named by police. Against: the file gives no date, place or method, and nothing shows a person confronted. DA recommends no new record until a source describes them; if made, they belong with disputed group B (mining hardware).
**DB id 18** (owner) — the "Discount Bitcoin Bandits", Fitzgerald and Hall, advertised discount bitcoin online and robbed buyers of the cash they brought, October 2017 to February 2018; one record for five or six victims.
- Settled (DA): date → October 2017 to February 2018 (series); description → drop "5 robberies at gunpoint" (no gun is placed at a particular meeting, and one count was a money transfer with no bitcoin delivered); money_wanted → $87,125 in cash from six people (charging release), restitution of $85,715 and $29,900 ordered; coin_type → cash; victims five (plea release) or six (charging release), both noted; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, weapons 1 on the handgun admissions, theft 1); both convicted on no-contest pleas.
- Q1: scenario. Writer: Malicious Invitation → P2P Trade Gone Wrong. Precedents: a crypto trade as the lure → P2P Trade Gone Wrong first (117, 104); a weapon at the trade → P2P → Armed Robbery in Public Space (143, 94). No public place appears in the file. DA recommends P2P Trade Gone Wrong alone.
- Q2: keep one series record or split per victim? The releases do not separate the robberies, so a split has no facts to fill it. DA recommends one record with the series noted.
**DB id 16** (owner) — a false hostage-and-bomb 911 call at Jameson Lopp's Durham home drew armed police; the caller demanded $60,000 of the dispatcher; nobody was hurt.
- Settled (DA): description → drop "extorted" (no demand was put to Lopp and nothing was paid); arrests → none, the caller untraced and police had not confirmed swatting; date → the article says only "Monday morning" and carries no date, so 16 October 2017 is kept, marked unverified (as 183); sequence Swatting kept; other flags unchanged (all 0).
- Q1: crypto link. The article says he "works for a software company" and mentions no cryptocurrency; "Bitcoin developer" rests on material outside the file. DA recommends keep, and add a source on file for his Bitcoin work before publishing.
- Q2: weapons for swatting. For 1: armed officers attended. For 0: no attacker weapon existed, and the caller's rifle and explosives were false. DA recommends 0 (the glossary's Weapons entry describes weapons used in the attack), applied to swatting cases generally.
+8
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"7": ["Express Kidnapping"]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [10, 6],
"owner": [15, 12, 11, 8]
}
+38
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,38 @@
# Batch 18 decisions — 2026-10-01
Triage of `batches/contradictions-18.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-18.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Cases 10 and 6 are on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 14** (DA) — date → 18 June 2017 (Tokyo Reporter: she disappeared after the 18 June seminar in Kasugai and police believe she was killed shortly after boarding the vehicle that night; the record's 17 June is in no source); location → last seen boarding Nishida's vehicle at JR Ogaki Station, Gifu; body found buried in a forest in Taga, Shiga; victim a Nagoya resident, seminar in Kasugai City, Aichi; description → "Woman strangled, attacker takes 100,000 yen worth of BTC" becomes: killed by pressure to the neck (autopsy), body buried around 20 June; in early July Nishida is believed to have posed as her online to obtain her bitcoin, valued at more than 100,000 yen; her smartphone and bag were found in his vehicle and residence; kidnappings → unconfirmed (she boarded the vehicle after saying she was going to meet an acquaintance; no source describes her being held); violence_torture → 1 (fatal pressure to the neck; a killing counts, as in 215, 102, 96); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept, gap: the pretext used is not described and the crypto was taken online after her death; flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 1); attackers → Ichiya Nishida, 20, and an unnamed 18-year-old from Shiga; targeting vector = acquaintance (met at a virtual-currency seminar); arrests: both arrested and prosecuted for abandoning the body, then charged with murder and robbery, no verdict on file; sources are three Tokyo Reporter items (citing TBS, Nikkan Sports, Chunichi Shimbun).
- **DB id 13** (DA) — attackers → three Emirati men (aged 19, 27 and 20) charged with kidnap, impersonation and online misappropriation, plus four Indian accomplices (21 to 47) accused of possessing Dh250,000 of apparently ill-gotten money; money_wanted → 25 BTC, moved with the victims' own laptop to the 27-year-old defendant's account in Japan; coin_type → BTC; money and mobile phones also taken (unquantified); description keeps both accounts of the approach (prosecution: conned into riding in the attackers' car after being told they were wanted by the authorities; a victim: "a car intercepted them after 10pm. The suspects pulled us out of the car"), then taken to a remote desert spot off Al Barsha; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (claimed authority, then held at a remote outdoor spot; victims pre-selected through the recruited driver, so Kidnapping under the 2026-10-01 rule); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration and how the night ended not stated; targeting vector = insider tip-off (the trader's Yemeni driver, recruited by the 19-year-old posing as a security official, reported his movements); arrests: all three charged, trial continuing 13 December, no verdict on file; one source (Khaleej Times).
- **DB id 9** (DA) — date 14 August 2016 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the article dates only the first robbery, to February with no year, and the arrests to an unnamed Friday); notes → "5 to 6 teenagers stabbed people" becomes: three teenage boys (16 and 17) arrested in connection with three robberies, two to three other teen suspects sought; one stabbing reported, of the victim of the first robbery in February (stabbed twice, hospital, non-life-threatening); series noted (one record for three robberies, as with 173 and 179); weapons → 1 (stabbed twice, so a blade was used; the report names no weapon); loss → cash and other property, no crypto (the suspects offered bitcoins they did not have), amount not stated; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); location → north Scarborough, Toronto; targeting vector = online lure (the suspects answered the victims' Kijiji ads offering cash for bitcoin and arranged meetings by email and text); arrests: three; one source (Toronto.com).
- **DB id 7** (DA) — money_wanted → 52 BTC (104,000 euros) he was pressed to transfer; when the attackers could not get his login details they demanded 300,000 euros; coin_type → BTC; property taken → a rucksack (Lithuanian "kuprinę", not "a safe") holding a phone, computer, cash, documents and payment cards, plus a wristwatch worth 10,000 euros and a gold bracelet of similar value, total damage nearly 27,000 euros (kept in notes, separate from money_wanted); location → near a car wash (Lithuanian "automobilių plovykla", not "service station") on Kaunakiemio Street, Kaunas; date 11 July kept (the article prints no year; 2016 rests on the record); violence_torture stays 0 (pushed into the van and hands restrained, threats to gouge out his eyes, impale his children and burn his car, no blow or injury reported; same reading as 207); sequence was Kidnapping in the record and batch file; now Express Kidnapping (owner ruling 2026-10-01: 7 stays Express Kidnapping, the sources do not say how he was chosen, gap noted; already in scenario-sequences.json); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); outcome not stated; arrests: four detained (E. J., R. G., M. Š., Š. P.), pre-trial custody of one month for three and 15 days for Š. P.; the article's background on his alleged bitcoin frauds is not part of this attack; one source (Kauno diena, Lithuanian original preferred over the sheet's English rendering).
- **DB id 10** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
- **DB id 6** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 15 (owner) — Kyiv, Santa Muerte club, 4 September 2017
TL;DR: crypto consultant lured by a fake investor to a second meeting, held about three hours in a room of the club and beaten for 10-12 BTC; escaped by getting an SOS sent from his phone.
Settled (DA): victim → Alexey Sherstnev (record drops the final "v"); weapons → 0 (no weapon anywhere in the report: "Three strong men. They beat and threatened to kill him", as with 142 and 204); theft → 1 (his phone was taken during the beating, not reported returned; no crypto moved, as with 153); money_wanted 10-12 BTC kept (about $44,000 in the body, nearly $50,000 in the headline); description → "held about three hours and beaten for a 10-12 BTC transfer that was never made" in place of "tortured for $50k"; flags kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0 unchanged; no arrest reported; single source, the victim's own Facebook post relayed by Oboz; targeting vector = lure through a fake consultation client (channel of first contact not stated).
Question: does the hold make this Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping? For: 194 (lured, held in a third party's hotel room) was ruled Kidnapping, and the Russian text says he was grabbed "при попытке покинуть комнату" (trying to leave the room) and held "в баре" for about three hours. Against: the club is not stated to be the attackers', he arrived of his own accord, and 139 (held at a café table) was not made Kidnapping.
DA recommendation: Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping per 194, venue = third-party room, ownership of the club not stated.
### DB id 12 (owner) — Florianópolis, wife of Rocelo Lopes (CoinBR), 2017
TL;DR: holder's wife seized in the street near home, taken to a house in Cangaíba, São Paulo, freed by police on the Saturday; no ransom paid.
Settled (DA): sequence Kidnapping kept; flags kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0 ("did not suffer any physical aggression"), drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 0 unchanged; victim unnamed in every source; record note "corrupted banker sold him out" appears in no source on file (drop unless sourced); targeting: handpicked after at least nine months of planning (delegate Anselmo Cruz), route not stated.
Question 1, life_taken: Business Insider (2022 round-up) says police freed her and arrested "many of the conspirators, killing one in the process"; the Brazilian account and CCN say one man arrested (a caretaker) and report no death. DA recommendation: keep 0, note Business Insider's claim as unconfirmed by the contemporary reports.
Question 2, date, ransom and coin: Brazilian text "last Thursday (26)" and "last Saturday (29)"; CCN "on Wednesday" with the daughter's birthday "Saturday, the 29th"; Business Insider "April 2017"; Bitcoin World Tour URL dated 2017/05/11. Ransom R$115m cut to R$5m in Zcash and Monero (Folha via the sheet) versus $40m to $2m in the same coins (BI) versus bitcoin plus an unnamed coin (CCN). DA recommendation: date → April 2017, seized on the Wednesday or Thursday before Saturday 29 April, record's 26 February matches no source; money_wanted → R$115 million demanded, reduced to R$5 million, unpaid; coin_type → Zcash and Monero (two sources), CCN's bitcoin noted.
### DB id 11 (owner) — London, "Josoj", 16 February 2017
TL;DR: record-only case; the sole source is an untranscribed Bitcoin Uncensored podcast (go.ivoox.com/rf/17187103) said to carry the victim's and the robber's accounts.
Settled (DA): kept in the database by owner ruling of 2026-09-30; all six flags (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0) marked unverified, nothing on file to test them; money_wanted and coin_type not stated.
Question: which label to set. The record's own description ("robbery during Localbitcoins trade") supports P2P Trade Gone Wrong and nothing else.
DA recommendation: set P2P Trade Gone Wrong as provisional, resting on the record's description only, and transcribe the podcast before marking the case verified.
### DB id 8 (owner) — West Palm Beach, Steve Manos, July 2016
TL;DR: cash-for-bitcoin deal with two men he had traded with before; in his own car the front passenger pressed a knife to his chest after the $28,000 was handed over, the back-seat man grabbed for Manos's own gun, both ran with the cash.
Settled (DA): description → "robbed of $28,000 at knifepoint" (the only gun in the report is Manos's own, in his door pocket); money_wanted → $28,000 cash brought to buy bitcoin, coin_type → cash, no crypto taken (as with 94 and 137); date 25 July 2016 kept ("early Monday" in a report published 27 July 2016 per the URL); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; weapons 1, theft 1 unchanged; targeting vector = business counterparty (several prior trades); arrests: Andre Allen arrested next day (armed robbery, burglary, battery), second man not identified; one source (Sun Sentinel).
Question 1, detention: for 1, knife pressed to his chest inside his car with two men in it, the owner's 241 ruling ("held in the car at knifepoint"); for 0, the cash was already handed over when the knife appeared, nobody was restrained and he chased them across the car park (clarification 3, as in 82). DA recommendation: 1, per 241.
Question 2, violence_torture: "a struggle ensued as the backseat passenger tried to grab Manos' gun" and a battery charge, no injury described. DA recommendation: 1, resting on the struggle and the battery charge.
+6
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [3],
"owner": [5, 1, 485, 483]
}
+38
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,38 @@
# Batch 19 decisions — 2026-10-01
Triage of `batches/contradictions-19.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-19.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Case 3 is on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 4** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("When the person arrived, he held Mr. Katz up at gunpoint and forced him to transfer $8,500 worth of bitcoin": held at gunpoint to execute the theft); money_wanted → $8,500 in BTC transferred plus $3,500 cash taken ($12,000 total, of which only $8,500 was crypto); coin_type BTC kept; location → Queens, New York ("a secure location" the caller came to, type of place not stated); date February 2015 kept, approximate (the article gives no date; it rests on the Observer byline of 20 February 2015 and the caller's wish "to gamble during the Super Bowl"); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (a caller who had heard of his trading service online or through a referral); no arrest reported; one source (Observer round-up, Katz passage only; CNBC repeats it under 5).
- **DB id 2** (DA) — date → 3 November 2015 (Cointelegraph: "On November 3"; CoinDesk report of 4 November: "Tuesday night"); theft → 1 (the Lamassu ATM, unit valued at US$7,000, holding about US$2,000 in cash; no crypto reachable, so money_wanted and coin_type stay empty); victim → the Village Smoke Shop, Juniper Street, Midtown Atlanta (Amanda McCollum is the store manager or employee who confronted the robbers; the machine's owner is not named); attackers → suspects inside (number not stated in the police account; "two robbers" per Cointelegraph citing Clatl.com) plus two more waiting in a red Chevrolet Cavalier; reports → CoinDesk (first article, filed under the Cointelegraph URL) and Cointelegraph; sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept (handgun brandished and fired into the floor when staff confronted them; the glossary's Armed Robbery entry names crypto ATM locations); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, life_taken 0); the reconnaissance visit the week before and the wallet stolen from the office noted, not a separate record (no crypto, nobody attacked); no arrests, "no leads"; the Amsterdam ATM passage at the end of both articles belongs to 3 and was not used.
- **DB id 487** (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed ("armed" rests only on the prosecutor's qualification "extorsion avec arme"; no report describes a weapon); money_wanted → a crypto account worth about USD 25,000, reachable through access codes on one of the stolen phones; whether it was emptied is not stated (franceinfo and actu17 headlines say "dérobé", Var Actu says nothing more was disclosed); coin_type not stated; date 6 September 2026 kept ("dimanche 6 septembre", no year printed, pages retrieved 9 September 2026); reports → franceinfo, actu17, Var Actu (one account: same source close to the case); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1: overpowered, tied up and held inside, investigation includes "séquestration"; violence_torture 0; drugs_alcohol 0; theft 1: wallet, passport and two phones; life_taken 0); attackers → two men in balaclavas; how the victims got free not stated; no arrests; investigation by the SIPJ of Nice; round-up tails (PNACO count, Dompierre-sur-Mer, Yvelines) not used.
- **DB id 486** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 (held at gunpoint in the suspect's parked car while transferring crypto, "continuously told him that he would kill him if he didn't comply", then escaped); money_wanted → $562,155 in crypto transferred, plus a watch, chain and bracelet totalling about $413,500 (nearly $1 million together); coin_type not stated; date 8 December kept, year 2025 not printed in the kept text (verify with a second source); location → 5801 Biscayne Blvd, Miami; attackers → one, Dontae Lamar Johnson, 28, of Royal Palm Beach (alias Buckfiddy in the headline only); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept, gap: the report does not say the December meeting was set up as a trap; flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1: handgun, Ruger LCP .380 found in his console, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = acquaintance (met at the Kiki on the River nightclub in October, kept in contact); arrests: Johnson arrested on an armed robbery charge, held pending a pre-trial detention hearing; one source (VE Media, quoting the Miami PD report).
- **DB id 484** (DA) — weapons → 1 ("armed intruders" in the body of all three accounts, weapon type not stated; same basis as 124); date 13 January 2026 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; no source dates the attack, he returned to streaming after about five months); attackers → armed intruders, number three only per trendsmask.com (aggregator, self-described secondhand); held duration → hours, per trendsmask ("about four hours") and tradersunion relaying a deleted Lopp post ("for hours"), secondhand; theft 1 stands with the loss named: Pokémon cards, car keys and identity documents, no crypto obtained (he held none they could take); arrests → not established: spilled.gg reports no public confirmation, tradersunion relays Lopp's claim of two arrests; sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1: forced entry, beating and holding, clarification 1; violence_torture 1: fractured fingers, bruising, a blow to the head, gasoline poured on him; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); victim → "RATIRL" and his father, legal name not stated; targeting vector = public profile (assumed a known streamer held crypto); how they found him not stated; url_2 (x.com/lopp) and url_4 (bo3.gg) not used.
- **DB id 3** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 5 (owner) — New York, record "Dwayne Richards", 2015
TL;DR: the record mixes two incidents. Date, $1,100 and BTC match CNBC's 27 May 2015 Crown Heights robbery of an unnamed 28-year-old (Craigslist ad, held at gunpoint in the buyer's car, transferred, phone taken). Name, firefighter, stabbing and "kidnapped" come from the Observer's February 2015 story (on file under 4) naming Dwayne Richards, stabbed and robbed meeting bitcoin buyers in Williamsburg; CNBC says police called that 9 February robbery "not bitcoin related".
Settled (DA) for the 27 May robbery: location → Crown Heights, Brooklyn; kidnappings 1 (held at gunpoint to transfer), weapons 1, theft 1; violence_torture → 0 (no violence in the 27 May robbery); no arrest; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong (no abduction described).
Question 1: split into a 27 May record (unnamed victim) and a 9 February Richards record, or keep one? Observer names Richards and ties his robbery to bitcoin; police via CNBC deny the bitcoin link. DA recommendation: rewrite this record to the 27 May robbery with victim "28-year-old man" (no source names him), and open a Richards record only if the owner keeps cases police call not crypto-related (he is named in a source, so the name moves there, not deleted).
Question 2: if the Richards incident stays out, the stabbing, "firefighter" and "kidnapped" leave this record entirely. DA recommendation: yes.
### DB id 1 (owner) — Santa Barbara, Hal Finney, 2014
TL;DR: a year-long 1,000 BTC extortion campaign ended in a spoofed 911 call claiming a double murder; SWAT team and helicopter at the Finney home; nothing paid.
Settled (DA): date → 2014, month and day unknown (days after Elliot Rodger's killings near UCSB, before Finney's death in August; 29 December 2014 is WIRED's publication date); money_wanted → 1,000 BTC demanded ("worth more than $400,000 at the time"), coin_type BTC, nothing paid; sequence Swatting kept; flags kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0 unchanged (his death in August is attributed to his illness, not the attack); caller never identified; FBI believed several holders were extorted the same way; single source (WIRED, Fran Finney narrating).
Question: weapons in swatting cases. For 0: no weapon is attributed to the caller; the only arms are the police response. For 1: the hoax exists to bring "an armed police response to the victim's home" (WIRED). The answer sets the rule for every Swatting record.
DA recommendation: 0, weapons recording arms brought or used by the attackers; note the armed police response in the description.
### DB id 485 (owner) — Czeladź, Sylwester Suszek (BitBay), 10 March 2022
TL;DR: exchange founder vanished after meeting an associate at a fuel depot; car found abandoned; family received messages claiming captors wanted bitcoin; associate later charged with kidnapping and has himself vanished; never found.
Settled (DA): location → fuel depot in Czeladź, Poland ("near Katowice, Silesia" is in no source; u.today gives Katowice only as his birthplace); description → messages received by the family (crypto.news citing the NYT), not "his sister received"; attackers → Marian W., named Marian Wszolek by crypto.news and u.today; violence_torture → threat only (captors threatening to cut off his fingers, per the messages); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (the ax on his Ferrari is an earlier, separate incident); life_taken → unconfirmed (no body, no court ruling of death); theft 0 kept; money_wanted empty (no ransom figure in any source; the 4,500 BTC is an exchange reserve question).
Question: keep as a Kidnapping, or mark it unestablished? For: ransom messages, kidnapping charge against the associate. Against: crypto.news says the messages "do not establish what ultimately happened to him"; the load-bearing reporting is a New York Times investigation not on file.
DA recommendation: keep Kidnapping, mark low-confidence (as 199), fetch the NYT piece before green.
### DB id 483 (owner) — Ufa, traffic police officer, 2022
TL;DR: an officer seized detainees' phones during police actions, opened the crypto wallets on them and moved the bitcoin to his own accounts; seven years, rank stripped, compensation ordered.
Settled (DA): date → 2022, month unknown (record's "March" is in no source); money_wanted → bitcoin worth about 20 million rubles at the rate on the report's date (the article equates it to $700,000), coin_type BTC; weapons → 0 (none in the report); violence_torture 1 kept ("he used physical violence against detainees during the process"); theft 1 kept; sequence Authority Misuse kept; officer unnamed, number of victims not stated; single weak source (Analytics Insight; TASS and the X post unread).
Question: detention flag when the holding was lawful police custody that the officer turned into the means of theft. For 1: clarification 2 (detention used to execute the theft counts, whoever is held), and 93 (officers' cell) is 1. Against: these were real arrests in a legal process, not a holding staged by the attackers.
DA recommendation: 1, with a note that the custody itself was lawful.
+26
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"479": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Home Invasion"
],
"477": [
"Home Invasion",
"Kidnapping"
],
"476": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
],
"475": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Home Invasion"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
482,
473
]
}
+30
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
# Batch 20 decisions (2026-10-01)
Cases 482 to 473. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/contradictions-20.md`, `batches/batch-20.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json` (no new label changes are made in these decisions).
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 481** (DA) — description: drop "around 30 million pesos in bitcoin allegedly taken from the home" (in no source); money_wanted → a cold wallet the attackers believed held "cantidades millonarias de dolares en Bitcoins" (FGJEM via El Financiero, Diario de Mexico), $1.5 million per local media relayed by cryptonews.net, plus a memory device said at the hearing to give access to close to 3 million pesos in crypto, which investigators could not find; coin_type → BTC; theft → unconfirmed (device not located, no transfer reported; robbery is a line of inquiry per Infobae); drugs_alcohol → 0; attackers → two detained, Diego Sebastian 'N' (Argentine national, business associate of Melendez who used the relationship to get into the flat) and Gerardo 'N' (promised 2 million pesos per Diario de Mexico and El Financiero; "nearly $120,000" per cryptonews.net); motive noted as not officially established: FGJEM's line is the cold wallet, cryptonews.net has Harfuch announcing the arrests "over a debt dispute", Infobae relays an unconfirmed 300,000-peso dispute (journalist Carlos Jimenez); victim → surviving son six (Infobae) or about five (Diario de Mexico); sequence Home Invasion kept, gap: entry through a trusted associate with no forced entry; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, life_taken 5: four homicides plus the charged termination of pregnancy, the dog not counted); targeting vector = business counterparty (associate); arrests: two in preventive custody, binding-over decision set for 9 September (past the file's retrieval date, status needs a refresh before publication); source notes: url_3 (cryptodigicurrency.com) is a stub of the cryptonews.net story, not used; Infobae's tail of unrelated Estado de Mexico items not used.
- **DB id 480** (DA) — description: "broke into" → "entered" (the reports say only 's'est introduit' / 'fait irruption'; mode of entry and attacker count not released); victim → the tenants, described only as a family, not the property owner the attackers were after; weapons 0 → unconfirmed (Renseignement Economique: weapons are among the details not made public); sequence Home Invasion kept, gap: wrong target, the crypto holder was absent; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; targeting vector = unknown (how the owner's address was obtained is under investigation); arrests: none reported as of 5 September; source notes: all four reports relay one Ouest-France story (url_2, Ouest-France itself, refused the request); the Ploudalmezeau case in the Journal du Coin and Le Tribunal du Net tails is DB id 431, not used here.
- **DB id 479** (DA) — kidnappings 0 → 1 (pistol-whipped and threatened inside his own home to force access to the wallet, FOX 4; owner's detention rule 1); weapons 0 → 1 ("pistol-whipping him"; prosecutors: "a premeditated armed home invasion", FOX 4); attackers → three: Abdias Espinoza, 19, of Dallas (pleaded guilty, 45 years), Rodney Hill, 18, of Dallas (awaiting trial when FOX 4 published), a 17-year-old juvenile; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (owner ruling 2026-09-30, DoorDash ruse); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: all three caught the same night; Espinoza convicted; police support credited to Fort Worth PD's helicopter and a K9 (FOX 4) or Fort Worth and Watauga PDs and Air One (Hoodline); source notes: url_3 is a Tarrant County DA Facebook post, not transcribed; Hoodline taken only where FOX 4 agrees.
- **DB id 478** (DA) — date: 29 August 2026 kept, marked approximate (every source says only "samedi" / "Saturday" around 5 a.m., after the 23 to 24 August Jouy-en-Josas case; no report date on file fixes the day); description: "more than two hours" (CryptoCompass, COINTURK) against "plusieurs heures" (Objectif Sud), both noted; victim: nothing on file confirms the couple held any crypto (Journal du Coin); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1: handgun and knife, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: none, both still sought; outcome: the two fled as police arrived after neighbours called; source notes: Objectif Sud paywalled at 20 per cent; the closing passages on Jouy-en-Josas (482) and Rion-des-Landes (477) not used.
- **DB id 477** (DA) — date → night of 10 to 11 August 2026 (crypto.news, from Actu Landes); description: "threatening them to extract Bitcoin" → sought access to what the report called a large amount of Bitcoin and other digital assets, no amount and no confirmation anything was obtained; weapons 1 → unconfirmed (no weapon described; "Authorities have also not said ... whether officers recovered weapons"); theft null → unconfirmed ("Actu Landes did not report whether any cryptocurrency was transferred"); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Home Invasion; now Home Invasion → Kidnapping (held at home, then taken to separate locations, the woman found in a vehicle in another department); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1: man found naked with several cuts, life_taken 0); outcome not stated (whether released or freed by police is not reported); held duration not stated; targeting vector = unknown; arrests: two men arrested, no charges announced; case taken by the JIRS Bordeaux (PNACO); source notes: both sources relay one Actu Landes report of 20 August; DiarioBitcoin carries an AI-writer notice; the national context paragraphs not used.
- **DB id 476** (DA) — amount: 35,000 USDT kept, about 1.2 million baht (Thaiger, Bangkok Post, Mitrade) or about 1.3 million baht (AseanNow, Chiang Rai Times), both noted; attackers → four Russian men at the house (AseanNow: "three accomplices"), plus Dmitrii Glushko as the suspected decoy who made the call, plus driver Stolbov Gleb; date 26 August 2025 kept (Bangkok Post's "Tuesday"; warrant 27 August, arrest 28 August per Chiang Rai Times); location Chalong kept; arrest at Lipa Noi ferry terminal (Thaiger, Chiang Rai Times, AseanNow) or Nathon Pier (Bangkok Post, Mitrade); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (none mentioned in five sources); sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (lured to and held at premises the attackers controlled); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = lure by telephone (how Glushko knew the victim is not stated); arrests: some (Glushko charged under Section 340; the four at the house left Thailand); source notes: the URL stored with the AseanNow text (cryptonews.com, french-crypto-trader-kidnapped-near-paris) belongs to DB id 350 and needs correcting; this is the Phuket robbery listed as sheet row 252 in `cases-missing-from-database.json`, which DB id 476 now covers; url_4 (cryptopolitan) refused; Chiang Rai Times and Mitrade tails not used.
- **DB id 475** (DA) — description → befriended by four men during a night out in Shoreditch on 3 July 2025, forced back to his home, held there against his will, assaulted and made to access his financial accounts including Coinbase; woke with facial injuries and no memory of the incident; drop the wrench, the beating to unconsciousness, facial recognition and "City worker" (in no source; "wrench attack" is Hertfordshire Constabulary's label for the category); location → met in Shoreditch, east London; held at his home in Hertfordshire (town not stated); drugs_alcohol 1 → unconfirmed (no source mentions drugging; the amnesia is reported without a cause); weapons 1 → unconfirmed (no weapon named); money_wanted → more than £10,000 from bank and crypto accounts plus cash, crypto and watches; Coinbase traced £1,900 in crypto; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (held in his own home); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (befriended on the night; whether pre-selected is not stated); arrests: four convicted in February of conspiracy to rob, kidnap and false imprisonment (Stephenson 5.5 years, Kareem 6.5 years in total, Denton 6 years, Campbell 3.5 years), Keena convicted of money laundering (two-year community order; 150 days unpaid work and £500 compensation per Royston Crow), sentenced 18 May; source notes: url, url_3 and url_4 refused, the police statement is on file only as quoted by Cryptoadventure and Royston Crow; Cryptoadventure's tail (including the Melendez case, 481) not used.
- **DB id 474** (DA) — description → three hooded men armed with handguns rang the bell, held the family member who opened at gunpoint, tied the couple and the grandmother with cable ties, threatened them and struck them repeatedly, and demanded the father's phone and an immediate crypto transfer; he refused and freed himself, and they fled; drop the throat grab, the rifle butt, the shower and the baby in the father's arms (in none of the four sources); amount: drop €200,000 (no figure in any source); theft 0 → 1 (a family phone taken as they fled, Fibo and Journal du Coin; the phone led investigators to two suspects; no crypto moved); drugs_alcohol → 0; victim → family of five: couple, two children (four years and seven months) and the maternal grandmother; duration: "plusieurs dizaines de minutes" (ICI) against "plusieurs heures" (Fibo), both noted; date 31 October 2025 kept (ICI); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (father targeted as a crypto holder; how he was identified is not stated); arrests: two arrested 15 December 2025, sentenced 23 February 2026 to nine and five years; which defendant got which term differs (Cryptonaute and Journal du Coin: nine for the 19-year-old; Fibo's body: nine for the 24-year-old; Fibo's FAQ reverses it again); third man and the commissioner not identified; source notes: the ICI tail and the Cryptonaute and Fibo padding not used.
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 482 (owner)
TL;DR: three hooded men tied, gagged and beat a 47-year-old in his Jouy-en-Josas house for about two hours for codes to a supposed 6 million euros.
Settled (DA): weapons null → unconfirmed (no weapon named; the scarifications imply a blade, no source says so); date 24 August 2026 kept (CNEWS about 4.30 a.m., Europe 1 between 2 and 4 a.m.), tv78 and Journal du Coin's "nuit du lundi 24 au mardi 25" noted; description "escaped and raised the alarm" kept with Journal du Coin's version (freed himself after the group left) noted; sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); arrests none; targeting vector = unknown (investigators tracing the leak); url and url_3 are the same CNEWS page; tv78 tail (Le Chesnay-Rocquencourt = DB id 414, Montigny-le-Bretonneux = DB id 469) not used.
Question: theft. For 0: CNEWS "Aucun degat ni aucun vol n'a ete constate"; tv78 says only that the accounts held about 3,000 euros. For 1: Journal du Coin "les sommes transferees n'ont atteint que quelques milliers d'euros ... emportant environ 3 000 euros"; CryptoCompass and COINTURK (under 478) also say the attackers left with 3,000 euros.
DA recommendation: theft → unconfirmed, both accounts in notes; CNEWS cites police sources, the crypto outlets do not say where the 3,000 euros figure comes from.
### DB id 473 (owner)
TL;DR: four hooded men with crowbars tried to break into a crypto worker's home in Bry-sur-Marne on 24 January 2026 and fled without getting in.
Settled (DA): victim → man working in crypto and his family (Cryptoast) / crypto portfolio manager (Fibo); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted forced entry with crowbars; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, weapons 1: "armes de pieds-de-biche", theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests not stated; targeting vector = unknown.
Question: the record's 1 a.m. time, door camera and neighbour's call to police are in neither source; both sources are one-sentence entries in round-up timelines, so a fuller report may exist (as in 114). Trace a source first, or cut the description now to "four hooded men armed with crowbars tried to break in and fled without entering"?
DA recommendation: cut now, restore the details only if a dedicated report is found.
+36
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"467": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
],
"466": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
],
"464": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
],
"463": [
"Costly Fame",
"Kidnapping"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"472": [
"forced entry into the couple's home to extort cryptocurrency they do not hold; the four-man team carried a crowbar, balaclavas and cable ties"
],
"470": [
"forced entry into the couple's home to extort the cryptocurrency of the previous owners"
],
"469": [
"theft of the shopkeeper's cryptocurrency; police intelligence described a planned séquestration and the file was opened as attempted theft in an organised gang"
]
},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
468,
465
]
}
+30
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
# Batch 21 decisions (2026-10-01)
Cases 472 to 463. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/contradictions-21.md`, `batches/batch-21.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json` (no new label changes are made in these decisions).
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 472** (DA) — location → a small village near Montdidier, Somme (ICI; the ICI article path names the commune Grivesnes); victim → the same couple as 470 and 471, near thirty, a farmer and a bank executive, with no crypto of their own (they bought the house of a retired couple whose tax record and address had leaked on the darkweb, per their lawyer); money_wanted stays empty; the Telegram fee offered to the hired hand goes to notes: 15,000 to 30,000 euros (ICI) or 15,000 to 20,000 euros (Cryptoast); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons null → 1 (a crowbar, balaclavas and cable ties in the passengers' bag, ICI; carried and not used, as the knife carried in 205 and the crowbars in 473; DA call, owner may set unconfirmed); sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: forced entry into the couple's home to extort crypto they do not hold, the team carrying a crowbar, balaclavas and cable ties; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = data leak / breach (obsolete darkweb file; three teams at one address in under a month, repeat victimisation noted, linked to 470 and 471); arrests: two of the four-man team arrested and detained 7 August, tried at Amiens on 11 August 2026 (three years with 18 months to serve; 18 months with nine to serve), whoever commissioned the raid not identified; source notes: url_2 and url_4 are the same Bourse Inside page; the ICI tail (including the Revelles case, DB id 474) not used.
- **DB id 471** (DA) — description: drop "to a remote mastermind" (ICI says only "L'agression est même filmée en direct sur Snpachat"; no recipient named); violence: ICI has one victim tied and the other beaten, Cryptoast one victim tied and beaten, both noted; location → village near Montdidier, Somme (Grivesnes per the ICI article path); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (none mentioned for the 26 June team; the crowbar belongs to 472); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); the team left when it saw the victims did not fit the profile; held duration not stated; targeting vector = data leak / breach (same darkweb file as 470 and 472); arrests: none reported for this team; source notes as 472.
- **DB id 470** (DA) — description: drop "seeking €1 million in cryptocurrency" from this record (the figure is in the ICI headline only and covers the series); description → a first team came to the couple's home on 24 June 2026 and was turned back by the household's dogs (ICI) or dog (Cryptoast); whether they crossed the threshold is not stated; location → village near Montdidier, Somme (Grivesnes per the ICI article path); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (none mentioned for the 24 June team); sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: forced entry into the couple's home to extort the previous owners' crypto; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = data leak / breach (darkweb file listing the previous owners); arrests: none reported for this team; source notes as 472.
- **DB id 469** (DA) — description → three men got into the flat of a shopkeeper reported to hold crypto, intending to leave with her crypto assets; police, acting on intelligence about a planned séquestration, arrived while they were still searching the flat; drop the glass bay window and the ground-floor flat (in none of the four articles); whether she was at home is not stated; date → night of Monday 3 to Tuesday 4 August 2026 (InfosYvelines, Journal du Coin); violence_torture null → unconfirmed ("tentative de cambriolage avec violence" is the legal qualification only, no act described; as 88); weapons null → unconfirmed ("braqueurs" in Journal du Coin's lead only, no weapon described); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: theft of her crypto, with a planned séquestration per police intelligence (file opened as attempted theft in an organised gang); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, theft 0: "zéro butin", life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: one man in his twenties arrested at the scene, two at large; file opened for "tentative de vol en bande organisée"; source notes: the Le Chesnay-Rocquencourt case in three of the pages is DB id 414; the Val-de-Marne IT engineer in the Cryptoast round-up is a separate case (check against the Val-de-Marne records 362, 405, 428); national figures are context; the InfosYvelines page carries a paywall marker.
- **DB id 467** (DA) — date → 18 January 2024 (landed 2.30 p.m. after transiting Hong Kong; last message about 4 p.m., then no response, Caixin); victim → Li Jia and Zhao Dong, both pseudonyms per Caixin ("Notably, Li Jia and Zhao Dong are pseudonyms"), flag wherever published; Li's employer given both as "a Chinese company in Germany" and "a German company" on the same page; description: "have not been heard from since" → messages from Li's phone until about 5 a.m. on 26 January and calls from "big brother" until 6 February 2024, no contact from either man since; money_wanted → 1.5 million USDT demanded; 190,000 USDT paid by Li's family, Zhao's family paid nothing; coin_type → USDT; violence_torture null → unconfirmed (no injury described; "sounded weak ... as kidnappers threatened him"); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0; life_taken null → unconfirmed (both missing, no body reported); sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (abducted after landing); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1); outcome: missing, which none of the six values carries; venue not stated; targeting vector = acquaintance (the sister suspects "big brother", who introduced Li to a woman linked to Philippine investment projects); arrests: none; source notes: only usable source is a Caixin digest behind a paywall; url (CCN) blocked; url_3 and url_4 returned almost nothing; linked to 466.
- **DB id 466** (DA) — victim: "Sun Jing" matches no source → the second victim as the sources name him: "Jimmy Sing Sun" (Philstar), "Jimmy Jing Sun" (BenarNews), 孙某, a US citizen of Chinese origin (The Paper), age 45; nationality fields follow; Xia Kefu, 39, kept; location → picked up at Ninoy Aquino International Airport, Manila; bodies found 24 June in Camarines Sur (Barangay Patitinan, Sagnay per Philstar; Tigaon per BenarNews); date 20 June 2024 kept (arrival and abduction; bodies found 24 June); money_wanted → 5 million yuan demanded, negotiated to 3 million yuan and paid (PNP via Philstar and BenarNews), and separately 15 million yuan to be converted into USDT demanded of the colleague on 21 June (The Paper); kept as two figures, not merged; coin_type → USDT for The Paper's demand, form of the 3 million yuan payment not stated; weapons 1 → unconfirmed (no weapon in any article; cause of death unknown when The Paper published); drugs_alcohol → 0; description: the lure is an invitation from a distributor calling herself "Li Na" with a Medev invitation letter (Ms Yang via The Paper); the AI summary's identification of "Li Na" (Chen Yu-hsuan, Seoul arrest) has no source and stays out; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (picked up at the airport and held for ransom); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1: killed by the kidnappers per Philstar, theft 1, life_taken 2); venue not stated; targeting vector = fake business contact ("Li Na"); arrests: some (a culprit surnamed Liu arrested in the US in October 2024 and repatriated to Beijing on 20 July 2026, per the Ministry of Public Security); source notes: the thepaper.cn page is on-case despite the WEAK anchor flag; BenarNews tail of other Philippine kidnappings not used; Ms Yang's recollection that a man said her husband "had lost money at their place" noted, not used as motive.
- **DB id 464** (DA) — description: "Maz's accomplice asked to borrow his phone" → one of the two asked to use his phone, supposedly to exchange Telegram details; police say Maz (Nolan Emmanuel) threatened him with the knife, taped his wrists and forced the transfer while Nisar Armaan stayed in the room; amount → 9,782 GBP in Ethereum, drop "(around $13,000)" (the database's own conversion, no source gives one); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (lured to and held at an attacker's room); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = acquaintance (he had shown the two his crypto portfolio, per Pol Lt Col Sudej Imjai); arrests: both arrested and charged (Armaan at the flat; Emmanuel at a hotel in Soi Phra Tamnak 5 per Crime Asia, near Pattaya beach per ASEAN NOW and Thailand News), police see no wider network; source notes: the last two Crime Asia paragraphs belong to 465; Thailand News headline links not used.
- **DB id 463** (DA) — date → July 2025, day unknown (no day in any article on file); description: drop "lured to Shadwell" → the pair drove from Kensington to east London intending to buy cannabis and were ambushed after parking in Shadwell by three masked men with a firearm and a knife (no source says the purchase was arranged by the gang); location Canning Town kept (held 52 hours at a flat at Rathbone East); money_wanted → about $150,000 demanded, about $30,000 in digital assets transferred; drugs_alcohol → 0; victim: a third man escaped during the initial attack; outcome: one victim released, the second believed he had been "sold" to another group; arrests: convicted at Inner London Crown Court, six per IBTimes (Borges, Osman, Adebisi, George, Bakoya, Sineen) or five per Coin-Turk and Crypto Economy, Coin-Turk adding Yasir Mohamed; both counts noted, court report needed before publication; jurors cleared kidnap, imitation-firearm possession and sexual assault; directed remotely by Ibrahim Mohamed ("Nino"), not arrested; sequence was Costly Fame; now Costly Fame → Kidnapping (driven to a flat and held 52 hours; Costly Fame rests on the prosecutor's hedged "may well have attracted unwanted attention"); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1 with the imitation-firearm acquittal noted, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = public profile / social media (prosecutor, hedged); source notes: url_2 (Cryptopolitan) blocked; other-case passages (Balland, St Albans, Bajou, Duplessie and Woeltz) not used.
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 468 (owner)
TL;DR: crypto founder Harry Chun Tak Yeh found dead at about 04:30 on Friday 7 August 2026 at the foot of Jade Park, Asunción, his 30th-floor flat open and turned over; police running accident, suicide and homicide in parallel.
Settled (DA): kidnappings → 0; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0; violence_torture → unconfirmed; theft → unconfirmed (flat "completamente revuelto" per Extra, nothing reported missing); life_taken 1 kept; description: the $2.4 billion AUM is self-reported and unaudited (crypto.news, IBTimes); the 30th floor and Odaily's "early hours of last Tuesday" are police preliminary estimates; no arrests; url_2 (Dim Sum Daily) blocked; Odaily's other-case passages not used.
Question: label. The record's Home Invasion has no support (crypto.news: "No official finding ... has accused another person of involvement"); none of the eleven labels fits an unexplained death, and the owner has kept the case (ruling of 2026-09-30).
DA recommendation: leave the scenario empty, mark "cause of death undetermined, pending autopsy", and hold it out of published counts until a finding exists.
### DB id 465 (owner)
TL;DR: Ashley James O'Brien, 34, allegedly held at gunpoint in his rented Koh Samui villa in April 2026 by three Britons who took a Rolex and bitcoin "worth £250,000".
Settled (DA): date → April 2026, day unknown (warrants issued 30 April); amount → £250,000 for the Rolex and bitcoin together, drop the £70,000 transfer and the ~94,000 USD conversion; attackers → three Britons named in warrants (Marco George Cameron Diamantis, 33, Myles Rees Lapierre, 35, Samantha Dorothy Tilley, 38), at large; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); sequence Home Invasion kept; targeting vector = unknown.
Question: the only source is two sentences inside the Crime Asia report on 464. The unlocked door, two masked men, sofa, pre-dawn hour, face-down position, ransacking and the record's other detail are in no source on file (url, a Crime Asia Facebook post, was not transcribed). Trace Thai press or the Facebook post first, as in 114, or cut the record to the two sentences now?
DA recommendation: cut now to what Crime Asia states; restore details only from a traced source.
+33
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"462": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Kidnapping"
],
"459": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
],
"456": [
"Costly Fame",
"Kidnapping"
],
"455": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"461": [
"Armed Robbery in Public Space"
],
"457": [
"Home Invasion",
"extortion of cryptocurrency the family's absent son no longer held, per La Provence"
]
},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
458
]
}
+25
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
# Batch 22 decisions (2026-10-01)
Cases 462 to 453. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/contradictions-22.md`, `batches/batch-22.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json` (no new label changes are made in these decisions).
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 462** (DA) — amount: R$750,000 kept (Livecoins body), about R$800,000 noted (ACidade ON, from the police inquiry); drop "(~135,000 USD)" (the record's own conversion) and Livecoins' headline "US$ 750 mil"; description: "escorted the victim to a regular vehicle" → handcuffed and put in the back seat of an unmarked car (Livecoins) or in the boot (ACidade ON), both noted; location → hotel in Ribeirão Preto, driven to Cravinhos where the transfer was forced (ACidade ON); attackers → two men in Polícia Civil clothing; the one arrested is named by Livecoins as Matheus Vinícius de Jesus dos Santos, ACidade ON says the identities were not released; violence_torture null → 0 (no assault described); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (owner, 2026-10-01: routine followed on social media); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1: empty gun case in the boot, the man said the gun was under the seat, the driver exchanged fire with police; theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; targeting vector = social media (police: the pair followed his routine through his posts); arrests: one arrested, the driver escaped after a shootout in Pirassununga; source notes: url_2 is a YouTube video, not transcribed.
- **DB id 461** (DA) — no correction: record and article agree on date, time, place, victims' ages and the demand for a "cryptocurrency ledger"; sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: Armed Robbery in Public Space; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1: "three armed men", theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: none, Crime Stoppers bulletin of 9 July with stills, reward up to $3,500; source notes: the site summary's "at gunpoint" and "EUR 0 obtained" are not in the file and should not be published; the x.com link is the police bulletin itself (Hoodline quotes it); Hoodline's wrench-attack background not used.
- **DB id 460** (DA) — money_wanted: "$4.9M to $5M" → US$5 million (about Rp 90 billion) per the victim's Instagram interview reported by Bali Discovery; police have released no figure ("Police have yet to share the amount of money lost"); notes: drop "Villa Ukulele" (Bali Discovery does not name the villa) → the attackers took his villa keys from his motorcycle, entered his rented villa and took a second phone; victim: "Artem I." kept with attribution: police identify him only as AI, 41; the name Artem Ivanov comes from the Instagram interview via KOMPAS and NusaBali; weapons null → unconfirmed (police are considering "armed robbery" among the charges; no weapon described); drugs_alcohol → 0; held about 30 hours, dumped at about 4 a.m. on 4 July outside Udayana University Hospital; sequence Kidnapping kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: none, the black Nissan Serena identified; source notes: url_3 (CoinDesk) and url_5 (Yahoo) syndicate BeInCrypto; the victim's account is unverified per The Bali Times.
- **DB id 459** (DA) — victim: remove "Stephanie Mau-Asum and Astrid Robinson" (no source names either woman) → two foreign women, from the Netherlands and Venezuela (Geo News, Abb Takk) or the Netherlands and Spain (Daily Pakistan, ProPakistani), both noted; description: two accounts kept side by side: the FIR (invited by Muhammad Raza Dar, visas arranged, taken at gunpoint on arrival in Lahore on 29 June to a house in Y-Block, Defence) and DIG Faisal Kamran (voluntary travel after meeting the main suspect in Singapore, joint travel to Islamabad and Murree, then a house rented for the purpose and an abduction to recover money he claimed he was owed; a staged kidnapping with the main suspect posing as a victim); date 29 June 2026 kept (ProPakistani: "alleged abduction on June 29"; police informed 2 July); notes: "recovered within ~2 hours" → rescued within two hours of the father's call to the 15 helpline, not of the abduction; arrests → four arrested (ProPakistani), five held per the Geo News headline and five named in the FIR, both noted; five-day physical remand; money_wanted → $1.5 million (about Rs450 million) ransom, nothing paid; coin_type → empty (the crypto is the investment in dispute, nothing transferred); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (held at a house in Y-Block, Defence); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); gap: sexual violence (rape alleged, medical reports awaited) has no violence category; targeting vector = business counterparty (crypto investment partnership, profit dispute).
- **DB id 457** (DA) — notes: drop "The plate led investigators to the same four men" (no source says so; Cryptopolitan: the plate "podría ser la clave", Journal du Coin: the four arrested that weekend are suspected of orchestrating the whole expedition); description: "four individuals" → intruders, number not stated, who banged violently on the door at about 3 a.m.; the family barricaded themselves in and the intruders fled before police arrived, leaving only their registration; date 13 June 2026 kept (La Provence and Journal du Coin "samedi 13 juin"; Cryptopolitan's "sábado 14 de junio" is the wrong weekday, 13 June 2026 was the Saturday); victim → the parents; the target was an absent son who made crypto gains and sold his holdings more than a year earlier (La Provence, Cryptopolitan); weapons null → 0 (none described; the intruders never reached the occupants); money_wanted: nothing demanded on record, crypto is the presumed motive; sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: Home Invasion, and extortion of crypto the absent son no longer held (La Provence); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (investigators believe out-of-date information); arrests: some, four men arrested over the night's addresses, roles not established; linked to 458.
- **DB id 456** (DA) — applies the owner's rulings of 2026-09-30 (drug network claim, pistol-whipping and "as of June 16" removed; two attacker vehicles; same-owner São Paulo plates); amount: R$15,000 (Military Police, Lt Tavares) and 3,700 USDT, about R$20,000 (Serra Noticiário), both noted; drop "(~$3,000 USD)" (no source); coin_type → USDT per Serra Noticiário, transfer details unresolved; description: "from his Porsche 718 ... by three armed men" → two of about eight armed men (the victim's account) took him out of his Porsche and forced him into the Celta; drop "718" (no source gives the model); notes: located 40 minutes after the abduction (A Tribuna), one hour (A Gazeta) or hours (Sim Notícias follow-up), all noted; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Costly Fame; now Costly Fame → Kidnapping (owner, 2026-10-01); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 on A Tribuna's resident-sourced line, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = public profile (victim's belief, not established); arrests: one 25-year-old detained in Jardim Carapina, his part to be confirmed after statements; source notes: seizure reported as two pistols, one magazine and five phones (Serra Noticiário, preliminary) or three magazines (the other four pieces).
- **DB id 455** (DA) — theft 0 → 1 (gold chain with pendant, R$3,500 cash, documents and phone taken, plus five life vests and a ball per the second piece; only the Bitcoin extortion failed; as 153); coin_type → BTC (keys demanded), the property list moves to notes; money_wanted → access keys to his Bitcoin, no amount; date 15 October 2019 kept ("Esse caso ocorreu no dia 15 de outubro de 2019"), the same piece's opening "Em dezembro de 2019" noted; description: add how it ended: escaped from the boot at the Cemetron hospital car park and ran to the guards (third piece), or abandoned in the street after hours of driving (second piece), both noted, outcome escaped per the fuller account; attackers: three hooded armed men got out of the red car, or one armed man (another passage), both noted; organiser Elcione José Sales, a municipal traffic officer and his friend of over twenty years; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (taken from the friend's house to scrubland, a motel and a car boot); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); held more than twelve hours (third piece); targeting vector = acquaintance (friend of twenty years); arrests: Elcione (20 years) and Helton dos Santos Moura (16 years) sentenced in 2021, a third defendant acquitted, a fourth man arrested in Florianópolis on "segunda-feira (15)", not named by Livecoins; the site summary's "Valdinei Dias dos Santos per court records" and 15 June 2026 have no source; threats after the release to make him drop the complaint noted.
- **DB id 454** (DA) — description: "to a garage" → shut in a room with five men (Journal du Coin, ICI, Orange: "une pièce"); notes: funds collected from his partner and a friend (ICI, Journal du Coin) or his partner and friends (Orange), both noted; money_wanted / coin_type → 14,000 euros in three crypto transfers, coin not named; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1: blade, handgun shown, bolt cutters, theft 1, life_taken 0); held from shortly before 11 a.m. to about 9.30 p.m.; targeting vector = acquaintance / tip-off (he recognised the name of a Thann second-hand car dealer who knew he invested in crypto); arrests: four men aged 29 to 44 charged and remanded on 3 June (five were in the room); source notes: Cryptoast's Moroccan sentencing paragraphs not used.
- **DB id 453** (DA) — date → August 2025, day unknown (Demócrata: "las 03.00 horas del pasado lunes", no report date on file; police: investigation opened in August 2025); amount: two inventories kept side by side: police (1.5 million euros in watches and jewellery, 200,000 euros cash, 1.3 million euros crypto transfer) and Romillo's complaint per Demócrata (210,000 euros cash, jewellery, more than 30 watches worth over half a million euros, 20 gold coins worth 60,000 euros); attackers: five masked armed men "de origen latinoamericano" coached by a sixth by phone (Demócrata); the Tren de Aragua attribution is the Policía Nacional's, from the arrest of six over three robberies in May 2026; victim name kept with attribution: Demócrata names Romillo, Infobae via "fuentes cercanas a la investigación", the police release names no one; drugs_alcohol → 0 (the MDMA and ketamine were seized at the suspects' homes); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); held nearly five hours, freed themselves about 7 a.m.; targeting vector = surveillance (police: the cell selected people of high purchasing power and watched them first); the attackers' claim to be hired to recover money he was accused of stealing noted; arrests: all six identified members detained, three remanded; source notes: the shot to the face happened at a holiday flat in one of the other two robberies, not here; the site summary's age 40, the 260 to 300 million euro figure and Madeira Invest Club have no source on file.
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 458 (owner)
TL;DR: on the night of 13 June 2026 several men held two women, one in her sixties, in a Gignac-la-Nerthe villa to make them transfer a relative's crypto; police caught them mid-transaction and arrested four.
Settled (DA): description "Four suspects broke into" → several men entered; four arrested; notes "all four arrested on the spot" → four arrested during the sequestration (La Provence), whether every intruder was taken is not stated; date 13 June 2026 kept (Cryptopolitan's "sábado 14" is the wrong weekday); violence_torture → 0 ("saines et sauves"); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed ("braquage" only in La Provence's headline); theft 0 → unconfirmed (surprised "en pleine transaction", no amount or completed transfer reported); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings 1, life_taken 0 unchanged; targeting vector = unknown (chosen for a relative's crypto gains); arrests: all four arrests rest on Cryptopolitan's "los cuatro hombres que retenían a dos mujeres"; linked to 457.
Question: Journal du Coin describes a series of three attacks or attempts that night; La Provence places the expedition "entre Marseille, Gardanne et Gignac" and Cryptopolitan names Gardanne as a further attack. No record on file covers Gardanne. Open a record for it?
DA recommendation: yes, once a source describing the Gardanne incident itself is found; the file has only the mention.
+28
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"451": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Home Invasion"
],
"447": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Dodged Attack"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"447": [
"the abduction of Borget's wife from her home by six men, an attempt police link to cryptocurrency"
]
},
"parked": [
450,
449
],
"owner": [
448,
446,
445,
444,
443
]
}
+33
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
# Batch 23 decisions (2026-10-01)
Triage of `batches/contradictions-23.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-23.json` and `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's `scenario` stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 452** (DA) — location kept: Phnom Penh, Dangkao district (BeInCrypto and Crypto Economy write Dangkao, Cryptonews.net, Coin Edition and CryptoAdventure write Dangkor; spelling variant noted); drugs_alcohol → 0 (no drug or alcohol use in any article); sequence Kidnapping kept (forced into a vehicle in his building's parking area at about 8 p.m. on 29 May, held about 14 hours, $2 million in crypto demanded from his wife by phone); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1: torture, beating, stabbing and suffocation in the early findings; weapons 1: knives found in and around the car; theft 0: the wife could not raise the funds, no payment reported; life_taken 1); targeting vector unknown (investigators are pursuing a 2014 business dispute that allegedly resurfaced in 2025, no motive established); arrests none, the three men at large; five articles, all relaying one police account (the 8 p.m. time and the 14 hours come from Mothership via BeInCrypto and Crypto Economy).
- **DB id 451** (DA) — description: keep the delivery-driver ruse, the binding, the beating and the filming; add the outcome: €30,000 in Bitcoin and Ethereum extorted (Laminute.info), paid by her son after the ransom demand (franceinfo and ICI relaying France Inter); notes → serious injuries incl. a knee injury needing long recovery and 90 days' ITT (Laminute.info), which replaces the summary's "no injuries beyond bruising"; arrests → two men arrested 7 and 13 September 2023, both denied the facts, charged on Friday 15 September with "séquestration et extorsion"; notes: "part of the same criminal proceedings as the TeufeurS/Cures kidnapping" → France Inter puts the same group at the heart of the Élancourt investigation, a similar procedure and not part of the Cures assize referral (Badiss B. and Djelloul C. belong to the Cures file; the Élancourt link stays at "the same people under investigation"); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (no weapon in any article; binding, beating and a death threat); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (delivery ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30; held in her own home), gap: ransom demanded from her son, not from the person held; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; link to 448 (same group); targeting vector unknown (the son is described as a well-known influencer and YouTuber).
- **DB id 450** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
- **DB id 449** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
- **DB id 447** (DA) — location kept: Villenoy, Seine-et-Marne (Decrypt's text names it; Cointelegraph says only Île-de-France); weapons → 1 (the two arrested carried "a fake handgun, zip-tie restraints, and balaclavas", as the gear recovered in 172; no weapon reported as shown to her); violence_torture → 0 (dragged by force in the courtyard, "reportedly uninjured", no blow described; DA call, owner may set 1); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Dodged Attack; now Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack, attempted: abduction of Borget's wife into a waiting Citroën C3, broken off when neighbours intervened; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 0: never put in the car, control never gained, clarification 3; theft 0; life_taken 0); attackers → six per police sources cited by Le Journal du Dimanche, two teenagers from Pantin arrested (born 2009 and 2010), four at large; victim's own name withheld by every source; targeting vector: relative of a public crypto executive (Borget, co-founder and COO of The Sandbox), how the attackers chose her is not stated; all five articles trace back to Le Journal du Dimanche.
## Needs owner decision
- **DB id 448** (owner) — Cures abduction of TeufeurS's father, August 2023: the record's most specific details are in no source on file.
- Settled (DA): theft 1 (€1.7 million transferred to crypto wallets); kidnappings 1 ("enlèvement et séquestration", taken away by force in a stolen van); drugs_alcohol → 0; violence_torture → unconfirmed (no violence described); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (fake Amazon delivery man); prosecutor seeks an assize trial for six; link to 451.
- Q1: trace the France 3 / franceinfo piece (came back THIN) before cutting, or cut now? Record: 24 August, a ransom video showing him bound and taped with an automatic weapon at his head, released the next day unharmed. File: ICI (France Inter) says only "août 2023", no video, no weapon, nothing on the release or his condition. DA recommends: trace first (as 145, 138, 114); until then date → August 2023, day unknown; weapons → unconfirmed; the video and the release go to "not stated".
- Q2: victim name "Killian Desnos" appears in no source on file (ICI says only "le père de TeufeurS"). DA recommends: remove the civil name unless the France 3 piece prints it.
- **DB id 446** (owner) — Ottrott, second day (11 May 2026) of a foiled abduction; possible duplicate of 445.
- Settled (DA): description → one operation over 10 and 11 May, gendarmerie alerted on 11 May, five people from the Paris region arrested (the sources describe no separate second approach); violence_torture → unconfirmed ("violences aggravées" appears only in the Saverne prosecutor's charge list); weapons → 0 ("commandos masqués et armés" is the sources' general wording about French crypto abductions); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted abduction and unlawful detention; targeting vector: data leak (theft of data on his crypto transactions).
- Q: keep 445 and 446 as two records or merge into one 10 to 11 May record? For two: Cryptoast speaks of two attempts ("deux tentatives d'enlèvement"). For one: all five sources rest on one paragraph and none tells the Sunday from the Monday; the DNA original would be needed to split them. DA recommends: merge into 445 with the dates 10 to 11 May 2026 unless the DNA original separates the two approaches.
- **DB id 445** (owner) — Ottrott, first day (10 May 2026); same question as 446.
- Settled (DA): description → targeted after a theft of data about his crypto transactions (Journal du Coin, CoinAcademy), not after "transactions conducted in the Alsace region"; violence_torture → unconfirmed (charge list only); weapons → 0; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Dodged Attack kept; arrests "all" covers the five taken on 11 May, nobody was caught on the 10th.
- Q: merge with 446 (see 446). DA recommends: keep this record as the merged one, date → 10 to 11 May 2026.
- **DB id 444** (owner) — Strasbourg woman of 25 seized at her door by a fake delivery man, found tied in a van; the only usable article disagrees with the record on six points.
- Settled (DA): kidnappings 1 (tied and gagged in the back of a van); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Kidnapping; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (pre-selected, taken away); theft 0; two suspects (22 and 19) charged by the Nancy JIRS with abduction, unlawful detention, death threats, conspiracy and attempted extortion, remanded.
- Q1: correct the record to DNA, or trace the France 3 piece (THIN) first? Record: wife of a crypto investor, held in a parked van in Neudorf, found on rue du Jura with both suspects inside, a threat video to the husband, 31 March. DNA (12 May 2026): a wealthy friend living in Dubai, found tied in a van in the Neuhof forest, €600,000 demanded of the friend with a threat to cut off a finger, no video, suspects arrested afterwards, no date for the abduction. DA recommends: correct to DNA now (victim → 25-year-old woman, target her wealthy friend; amount → €600,000 demanded, currency of the demand not stated; date → not stated, before 12 May 2026), restore any record detail the France 3 piece confirms.
- Q2: violence_torture 1 → 0 (tied, gagged, finger threat; found "saine et sauve", no assault described) and weapons 1 → unconfirmed (no weapon named). DA recommends: accept both.
- **DB id 443** (owner) — Naiping Hou, 74, missing since March 2025, $1 million drained; no abduction established and the crypto link is the son's wealth.
- Settled (DA): date → March 2025, day unknown, last seen on a family fishing trip from San Pedro Pier (home in Rancho Cucamonga); description → someone was reportedly trying to sell his vehicles and rent out his home (attempt, not a completed sale); the kidnapping is the Sheriff's Department's working hypothesis ("possible kidnapping") and the crypto motive is the family's belief (ABC7); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0; theft 1 (more than $1 million withdrawn to buy physical gold online and crypto).
- Q: does the case stay in the database, and under what flags? For: deputies treat it as a possible kidnapping, the FBI joined, possible foul play suspected, impersonation by text for more than a month. Against: no body, no suspect, no ransom demand, no source says he was held, and the victim held no crypto himself. DA recommends: keep, with kidnappings, violence_torture and life_taken → unconfirmed and sequence Kidnapping marked as a police hypothesis, flagged "motive not established" as in 96.
+23
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"442": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Home Invasion"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"433": [
"Kidnapping",
"torture to force him to reveal the password to his cryptocurrency wallet, which he says police concluded after investigating"
]
},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
441,
440,
439,
438,
436,
434
]
}
+31
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
# Batch 24 decisions (2026-10-01)
Triage of `batches/contradictions-24.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-24.json` and `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's `scenario` stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 442** (DA) — description → prosecutors say Brown posed as a food delivery driver and someone inside opened the door; Brown, Franklin and Chambers forced their way in with loaded firearms, joined by two unidentified co-conspirators, held the victim about an hour and "used firearms to physically restrain the victim", demanding access to the safe, the computer and the online accounts; they then met Osama, Khiell Dukes, Ramsey and others, who searched them "to make sure all of the robbery proceeds were collected" (Chicago Sun-Times); drop "six men including Osama forced their way in": Osama's lawyer says he was not present and did not set up the robbery; theft → unconfirmed (demand only, no transfer, amount or coin; "robbery proceeds" is the prosecutors' word, nothing itemised; DA call, owner may set 1); violence_torture → 0 (restraint by firearm, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (food-delivery ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30); flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); arrests → six charged (three on 23 March, three more incl. Osama by superseding indictment on 16 April), all pleaded not guilty and ordered detained; a seventh man arrested with charges pending; targeting vector unknown; url_2 (justice.gov, EDNY, Dukes's 2022 machinegun case) is background on Osama, not this incident; the Sun-Times paragraphs on Osama's Christmas gifts not used.
- **DB id 437** (DA) — date → Wednesday 6 May 2026 (Le Parisien of 9 May, per its URL, says "mercredi"; 7 May is a Thursday and has no source; Revolution Magazine's "ce matin" is undated); coin_type → none: no cryptocurrency held or taken (Le Parisien: the search found none, "Sans succès"); money_wanted → crypto sought, none existed; notes → the suspects were reportedly located in the 18th arrondissement shortly after but escaped the BAC (Le Parisien, crediting Actu17); theft → unconfirmed (computers and a smartphone: Le Parisien says the haul was left at the scene, Generation-NT says it was carried off and abandoned during the escape; no loss either way; DA call, owner may set 0 or 1); violence: Le Parisien states beaten, tied and a punch to the face, Revolution Magazine hedges ("auraient été menacées et violentées", circumstances still to be established), both readings kept; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1: a handgun displayed, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown, wrong target per Generation-NT; arrests none; the Balland kidnapping and the trend paragraphs on all three pages not used.
- **DB id 435** (DA) — description → a kidnapping linked to crypto-assets committed in November 2025 at Challes-les-Eaux (Savoie); three men aged 25 to 30, all previously convicted, were charged (not convicted) with arrest, abduction and unlawful confinement as an organised gang, extortion and organised-gang money laundering, and remanded; PNACO recalls the presumption of innocence; arrests → the week before Friday 24 April 2026 (PNACO statement relayed by Actu17 and ICI), not "late April", by the Chambéry gendarmerie research section and the UNPJ; theft → unconfirmed (extortion and laundering charges only, no transfer, amount or coin anywhere); violence_torture → unconfirmed and weapons → unconfirmed (no account of the incident exists on file; PNACO mentions violence only across all 135 facts it counts; DA call, writer proposed 0); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Kidnapping kept, resting on the charge wording alone, gap: victim, venue, duration and method not reported; link to 381 (Dompierre-sur-Mer, December 2025: two of the same accused charged); the PNACO tally passages and the ICI teaser headlines not used.
- **DB id 433** (DA) — description → two stages: on 4 November two men in surgical masks approached him at his home and fled when he shut the door (La Presse; Atlas21 says they threatened him outside his home); on 8 November four hooded suspects in a black Kia without plates waited by his house, three fled on foot after the car swerved, the driver came up to him and he says he tried to spray him with bear spray, and a few moments later another suspect pointed a handgun at him; he stayed on the phone to police; notes → the torture kit (a two-foot tarp with a hole and clamps "to cut off a limb and stop the bleeding") is the victim's own description, not a police find; money_wanted → per the victim, police said the attackers thought he held 2.5 million bitcoins after posts on a Facebook page he moderates; he puts his actual holding at about $10,000; violence_torture → 0, threat only (handgun pointed, no blow or injury; kit never used); drugs_alcohol → 0; arrests → all four arrested, two adults charged in November 2024 with conspiracy to kidnap and possession and pointing of prohibited firearms, two minors also arrested; accused released to house arrest pending trial (La Presse; Coingape says "the duo", noted); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted added: Kidnapping and torture for his wallet password; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector: public profile / social media (Facebook page he moderates); url_4 (cryptoast.fr) is a different incident, the rue Pache attempt in Paris (record 230), and comes off this record; La Presse's round-up tail of other Canadian cases and Lopp's aggregate count in Atlas21 not used.
## Needs owner decision
- **DB id 441** (owner) — third of three foiled attempts on the Montreal family's house in early March 2026; the three records 439, 440 and 441 rest on one undifferentiated sentence.
- Settled (DA): date → early March 2026, day unknown (the Journal de Montréal gives no dates or order); attackers → not identified, and the source does not say the March suspects were a separate group from 28 January; arrests → none reported (the SPVM "could" track other individuals; nothing says they were identified); victim → the household as described for 28 January, who was home in March not stated; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (the firearms belong to 438); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Home Invasion; noovo.info (about 438) and the ctvnews.ca headline block come off as off-case.
- Q: keep three records or merge into one record with a count of three attempts? For three: the source says three attempts on three consecutive days. For one: no date, order or detail separates them, and the created_at stamps (17:12, 17:15, 17:17 on 2026-05-25) suggest a hand split at import. DA recommends: merge into 439 with "three attempts on three consecutive days, early March 2026", delete 440 and 441.
- **DB id 440** (owner) — second of the three early-March attempts; same settled points and question as 441. DA recommends: merge into 439.
- **DB id 439** (owner) — first of the three early-March attempts; same settled points and question as 441. DA recommends: keep as the merged record; on 11 March the family left the house for safety reasons.
- **DB id 438** (owner) — Montreal, 28 January 2026: four men from the Toronto area entered on a parcel ruse, one fired and hit an accomplice; the detention flag is thin.
- Settled (DA): notes → they fled leaving several pieces of evidence (drop "fled before completing the robbery due to the accidental shooting": no source links the shot to the flight or says a robbery was under way); description → the 28 January incident only (the record's text covers all four incidents); theft → 0 (nothing taken, no transfer); drugs_alcohol → 0; violence_torture 1 kept (light arm injury, not from the gunshot); weapons 1; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (parcel ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30); arrests → Christopher Ethan Prince, 20, and a 17-year-old arrested in Ajax and Toronto (reported 7 May 2026), two sought incl. a 16-year-old; four children and a music teacher in the house; targeting vector: contract accepted over social media.
- Q: kidnappings 1 or 0? For 1: forced entry into the home and a confrontation with an injury, clarification 1 and the 128 ruling ("nobody admits attackers willingly"). For 0: no holding, restraint or duration described; entry, confrontation on the stairs, a shot, flight, which reads as control never gained (clarification 3). DA recommends: keep 1 on clarification 1, with the note that no holding is described.
- **DB id 436** (owner) — Péchabou, 23 March 2026: €68,000 in crypto transferred under duress during a violent sequestration; the record's victim profile and entry method trace only to a blocked page.
- Settled (DA): theft 1 (€68,000 transferred to the network's wallets); kidnappings 1; violence_torture 1 ("une séquestration violente"); weapons 1 ("plusieurs auteurs armés et cagoulés" at the house; the two loaded assault weapons were found in the car after the chase of 30 to 31 March, not at the house); drugs_alcohol → 0; attackers → several armed hooded men, number not given; five men aged 17 to 24 charged, one mentioned DZ Mafia recruitment; the planned Nîmes reprisal is a separate intended crime, kept in status.
- Q1: "57-year-old woman", "four men", "posed as a delivery driver", jewellery and the hacking claim appear in neither Le Figaro nor ICI (both say "un particulier"); they trace to the gendarmerie page, BLOCKED with no text on file. DA recommends: fetch that page first; if it cannot be read, cut the record back to Le Figaro and ICI (victim → private individual near Toulouse; coin_type → crypto only, jewellery dropped).
- Q2: scenario. Record: Authority Misuse; sequence file: Home Invasion (no entry method on file). DA recommends: Home Invasion unless the gendarmerie page confirms the delivery ruse, in which case Authority Misuse → Home Invasion under the 2026-09-30 ruling.
- **DB id 434** (owner) — Karachi passenger taken at gunpoint from a ride-hail car, $8,600 moved from his digital account; much of the record is in no readable source.
- Settled (DA): kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 (physically assaulted, per the father), weapons 1 (four armed men, at gunpoint), theft 1 ($8,600 plus phone, laptop and belongings); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Express Kidnapping kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-01: 434 stays Express); date → the night of Wednesday 22 April 2026 or after (ProPakistani and The Asian Mirror, both 24 April, say he left home on Wednesday night); attackers → four armed men (both reports, father's account only).
- Q1: Sharea Faisal, the white vehicle, the road blockade, the false pretext, the iPhone/MacBook/Samsung brands, the victim's own two-attacker account, the 1.5 hours, Gulistan-e-Jauhar and SSP Pirzada's statement come only from the site summary; both readable reports give a petrol-pump stop, four armed men, no officer named, and The Asian Mirror says no official statement was issued. DA recommends: trace a third source; failing that, cut those details and rewrite to the two reports.
- Q2: duration ("more than an hour", ProPakistani, against "several hours", The Asian Mirror) and coin ("digital currency" in ProPakistani's headline only; bodies say "digital account"). DA recommends: keep both durations; coin_type → digital account, crypto not confirmed.
+48
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"429": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Home Invasion",
"Dodged Attack"
],
"428": [
"Home Invasion",
"Kidnapping"
],
"426": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Dodged Attack"
],
"424": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Home Invasion"
],
"423": [
"Authority Misuse",
"Dodged Attack"
],
"425": [
"P2P Trade Gone Wrong",
"Kidnapping"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"429": [
"extortion of the crypto-active father's holdings — the file records no demand being made before the father fought the intruder off"
],
"426": [
"a fake-delivery entry at a home, apparently to rob a young cryptocurrency investor, at an address the crew had wrong"
],
"424": [
"extortion of the victim's cryptocurrency — the intruders saw his holdings but fled before any transfer"
],
"423": [
"a home invasion robbery of the resident's cryptocurrency, using a fake DoorDash coffee delivery to get through the door"
]
},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
430,
427
]
}
+26
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
# Batch 25 decisions (2026-10-01)
Triage of `batches/contradictions-25.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-25.json` and `sources/`.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's `scenario` stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`, except 425, where the DA applies the 117/104 trade-lure ruling.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 432** (DA) — coin_type → cryptocurrency, coin not named (the $3M figure moves to the amount: US$10 million demanded in crypto, US$3 million transferred by the victim's friends to the suspects' crypto account before the rescue, US$2.46 million frozen across three accounts; FMT says "friends", Malay Mail "friend"); description → tailed and intercepted while driving alone from Genting Highlands to Kuala Lumpur on 17 April, pulled from his car, beaten, tied up and taken to a homestay in Melaka, held until the police raid of 21 April (drop "four days", in neither article); weapons 1 kept, replica (an object resembling a pistol, later found to be fake, seized with ropes and tape; as the imitation firearm in 136); drugs_alcohol → 0; quarter → 2026-Q2 (record field reads Q1 for an April date); sequence Kidnapping kept (taken to a homestay and held four days); flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → three South Korean nationals aged 28 to 40, entry records differ (FMT: two of three on social passes in March of the previous year; Malay Mail: all but one), all three arrested and remanded under the Kidnapping Act 1961; victim holds an Interpol Red Notice, wanted in South Korea for organised crime and illegal gambling (FMT) or illegal gambling (Malay Mail); targeting vector: surveillance / following (tailed before the interception).
- **DB id 431** (DA) — description: "held for over three hours" → the sequestration allegedly lasted the whole morning, several hours (Le Tribunal du Net citing Le Télégramme); "extorted the digital wallet password and transferred approximately €700,000" → the two men "sont parvenus à soustraire un portefeuille numérique", loss still being assessed per the deputy prosecutor, about €700,000 according to Le Télégramme (second-hand: Le Télégramme was BLOCKED, France 3 Bretagne THIN); bound and gagged (Coinacademy); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Home Invasion kept, gap: the holder was absent and his family held in his place; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0: no blow or injury in either article, weapons 1: "deux individus armés", theft 1, life_taken 0); outcome → found tied up by neighbours, who alerted the gendarmerie (nobody says the attackers freed them); arrests none, case with the Rennes JIRS; attribution differs (Le Tribunal du Net: Rennes deputy prosecutor Matthieu Thomas; Coinacademy: the Brest prosecutor), noted; targeting vector unknown; Coinacademy's national-context passages not used.
- **DB id 429** (DA) — description → add: during the struggle the father started, a shot went off, showing the gun was loaded; nobody in the family was hurt and the attacker fled empty-handed (actu.fr); violence_torture → threat only (handgun brandished, shot fired in the struggle, no injury; as in 179 and 202); drugs_alcohol → 0; arrests → a man of about 25 from the Hérault identified, arrested on Tuesday 14 April, charged and jailed in a Bouches-du-Rhône prison (actu.fr); Generation-NT's "arrested in Marseille within a few hours" noted as the other account; a commissioning party not ruled out; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion → Dodged Attack (delivery ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30); flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1: father, mother and children held at gunpoint and grouped in one room, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; targeting vector unknown (the father specialises in crypto transactions, per actu.fr); Generation-NT's other cases in its round-up not used.
- **DB id 428** (DA) — victim → mother and son, and the father: tied to a chair at home, beaten and threatened with mutilation (Paris prosecutor via France Bleu); location → taken from the family home in the Yonne (Burgundy), held in a hotel room at Boissy-Saint-Léger (Val-de-Marne); money_wanted → US$400,000 transfer in crypto demanded (prosecutor), "several hundred thousand euros" per franceinfo, both noted, nothing paid; theft → 1 (€10,000 cash, jewellery, small silver ingots and the shotgun taken; no crypto moved); violence_torture → 1 (father beaten); weapons → 1 (shotgun used to threaten the victims); drugs_alcohol → 0; held about 20 hours, son about ten (body text; a France Bleu teaser on the same abduction says 24 hours, a son of 11, noted); arrests → three men arrested at the hotel and four afterwards, seven in custody (franceinfo: at least four); the same page's teaser says six aged 17 to 20 were later charged in Paris; sequence was Kidnapping; now Home Invasion → Kidnapping (seven-day transfer delay made them take the mother and child away); flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, life_taken 0); outcome rescued by the GIGN at 6 a.m. on 14 April, both in good health; case with the Paris JIRS; targeting vector unknown; the page's unrelated teasers not used.
- **DB id 426** (DA) — date → 29 March 2026 (Le Parisien's charge wording, "le 29 mars 2026", and "dimanche" both fall on 29 March; the same article prints "dimanche 28, vers 23h45", and 28 March 2026 was a Saturday; conflict noted); notes → the four were transferred to the Paris brigade de répression du banditisme (not the anti-gang squad or BAC), charged on 2 April at Nanterre with criminal conspiracy; weapons 1 kept (knife found in the car, never shown; as 172); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Dodged Attack; now Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack (hi-vis fake delivery man, ruling of 2026-09-30), attempted fake-delivery entry at a home, apparently to rob a young crypto investor, at an address the crew had wrong; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); victim approached → houseboat resident in his fifties with no reported crypto link; intended target a 23-year-old maths enthusiast who invests in crypto (a source close to the case); targeting vector unknown (a phone held his photo and an address near the arrest site); surfcoastnews.com.au came back THIN.
- **DB id 425** (DA) — date → February 2025, day unknown ("fevereiro do ano passado" in April 2026 reporting); money_wanted → no ransom figure on file; R$70.8 million is the sum the gang failed to launder (part of a R$146 million theft from Itaú, per the SSP via Cointelegraph Brasil), the stated motive, and the "~$14 million USD" has no source (dropped); violence_torture → threat only (heavy threats and a revolver used to subdue him, no assault or injury); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (replaces the Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping in `scenario-sequences.json`; a face-to-face meeting with a false business partner to close a bitcoin transaction is a crypto trade used as the lure, as ruled in 117 and 104; pre-selected and driven off, so Kidnapping), gap: kidnapping to recover blocked laundering proceeds; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1: revolver recovered, theft 0, life_taken 0); notes → the victim is himself said to be involved in a larger fraud scheme (Rapido no Ar); Livecoins calls it an attempted kidnapping, Cointelegraph Brasil and Rapido no Ar a kidnapping; Operação Criptonita on 7 April 2026: five arrest warrants, four arrests incl. a municipal guard from Indaiatuba, search warrants 13 (SSP) or 14 (Rapido no Ar); no suspect is named in any source, so the name in the site's AI summary goes; held duration not stated; targeting vector: business counterparty.
- **DB id 424** (DA) — description → order of events kept in both versions (Chronicle: password given, then the voice on the phone ordered the pair to cut off his fingers until he showed the "real amount"; KTLA: the finger threat prompted the password); one suspect picked up a knife; both fled on hearing a helicopter; violence_torture 1 kept on the Chronicle's line "zip-tied, duct-taped and beaten" plus the finger threat with a knife in hand (the Chronicle's longer Brentwood account does not mention a beating; noted, as the single-line basis in 456); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Dodged Attack; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (package-delivery ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30; bound at gunpoint inside his home, control gained), attempted extortion of his crypto, fled before any transfer; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → Elijah Armstrong and Jayden Rucker (Tennessee) after a car chase, charged with robbery, burglary, assault with a firearm and attempted extortion; third person on the phone not identified; a woman hiding in the pantry slipped out and called 911; link to 423 (Rucker) and 422 (California series); targeting vector: a San Francisco suspect phone called him six times on 22 November, "seeking intel" per Sgt. Ryan Hart; the San Francisco, San Jose and Sunnyvale passages not used here.
- **DB id 423** (DA) — kidnappings → 0 ("After the victim pushed back, the man ran away"; control never gained, clarification 3); violence_torture → 0 (pushed in and aimed a gun, the victim pushed back, no blow or injury); victim → the resident who answered the door; the crypto holding was reported to police eight days later, when another unordered coffee arrived; sequence was Dodged Attack; now Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack (DoorDash coffee ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30), attempted home-invasion robbery; flags otherwise unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → Nino Chindavanh, 21, of Tennessee, charged with attempted robbery and burglary; police believe the second man was Jayden Rucker (wallet in the car, footage of the later coffee delivery), police belief only; victim's age and gender not stated; link to 424; targeting vector: surveillance (four fake-delivery approaches in two hours, another coffee eight days later).
## Needs owner decision
- **DB id 430** (owner) — St Felix crew: Florida victim abducted from his home, taken 120 miles and beaten; everything else on the record is in no source on file.
- Settled (DA): kidnappings 1 and violence_torture 1 ("abducted from his home, taken 120 miles away, and beaten while being held hostage", DOJ via Decrypt); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Home Invasion; now Home Invasion → Kidnapping; St Felix convicted on nine counts incl. kidnapping and brandishing a firearm, 47 years.
- Q1: trace first? The date (15 September 2022), Homestead, "takes jewelry, electronics", "failed to find his bitcoin" and "found 120 miles away in Stuart, Florida" are in neither Decrypt nor Fortune; the cited Fox 5 San Diego page was refused and the DOJ release came back THIN. The description has the shape of Lopp's list entries already traced for 138 and 145. DA recommends: trace (DOJ release, Lopp's list) before green; until then date → September 2022 to July 2023 range, location → Florida, theft → unconfirmed, weapons → unconfirmed for this incident; reports → Decrypt and Fortune.
- Q2: possible overlap with the crew's other records (138 Delray Beach, 145 Little Elm, 156 Durham). DA recommends: link all four; no merge, the incidents differ in place.
- **DB id 427** (owner) — Anglet, 10 April 2026: five hooded men broke into a villa looking for an absent crypto-holding businessman; the one usable extract stops at the entry.
- Settled (DA): date, place, five hooded men, target absent (Cryptoast relaying France 3 Nouvelle-Aquitaine); drugs_alcohol → 0; no crypto taken; sequence Home Invasion kept.
- Q: the hour-long holding, the household (couple in their seventies, son, partner, two children), violence on two victims and the jewellery and two phones taken are in the record's notes only; France 3 Nouvelle-Aquitaine came back THIN. DA recommends: fetch France 3 (or the full Cryptoast page) first; until then kidnappings, violence_torture, weapons and theft → unconfirmed, as the writer proposes.
+6
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [],
"owner": [419]
}
+22
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
# Batch 26 decisions (2026-10-01)
DA triage under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Evidence in `batches/contradictions-26.md`, `batches/batch-26.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. "Verified sequence" is the sequence in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 422** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing on file); date 17 December 2025 kept (neither article prints the year; 2025 fits the series order SF 22 November, San Jose 17 December, Sunnyvale 22 December, LA New Year's Eve); description kept, add: he believed his crypto holdings had been leaked, and reported earlier odd contacts (two unordered pizza deliveries on 6 December, a free driveway-cleaning offer on 15 December); targeting vector = data leak (victim's belief, per police report) and surveillance (prior approaches); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted: Home Invasion; kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list: ordered at gunpoint into his garage and struck); flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests none attributed to this incident (the three charged belong to other incidents in the series); source notes: the Chronicle and KTLA pieces are series round-ups, only the San Jose paragraphs used (423 and 424 share the article).
- **DB id 421** (DA) — attackers → four men aged 21 and 22 from Stains and Garges-lès-Gonesse (Actu Crypto; Cryptoast: Garges-lès-Gonesse, three tried as adults, the fourth a minor tried separately); time → about 5 a.m. per Cryptoast, about 5:20 a.m. per Actu Crypto (when the concierge noticed the car); notes → the concierge's alert has three accounts (strangers reading the resident list weeks earlier and a knife in a flower pot, Cryptoast; the Peugeot 208 prowling the boulevard, Actu Crypto; an alarm set off at the building door, Time News); police arrived in under ten minutes (eight per Time News), two caught in the car, two in the courtyard; the court dropped séquestration and enlèvement because the kit stayed in the car and the victims were never touched; commissioned by an unidentified person for a reward of 200 euros (defendants' account); targeting vector = surveillance (resident list scrutinised weeks before); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted: Home Invasion, Kidnapping; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 for knives carried, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → convicted, three adults sentenced on 1 April 2026 to two years, 18 months and 10 months for criminal conspiracy and attempted aggravated theft, the minor's outcome not stated; source notes: Time News is an aggregator, its extra detail (Snapchat sequence, sentencing requests) is single-sourced.
- **DB id 420** (DA) — location → Maidenhead, Berkshire (Daily Mail); victim → Oliver von Landsberg-Sadie, his wife Sarah and their two children (all restrained, Daily Mail); date 2 April 2026 kept (Daily Mail), note Crypto Briefing's "on Friday" does not match (2 April 2026 was a Thursday); description → four men broke in at about 10 p.m., threatened him at knifepoint, restrained the family and demanded the keycode to his wallet; theft → 1 (cash, silver and jewellery taken; no crypto: "I securely kept zero crypto"); violence_torture → 0 (restraint and knifepoint threats, no injury: "I am ok, my family are ok"); drugs_alcohol → 0; notes: drop "victim did not disclose whether crypto was stolen"; targeting vector = unknown (how he was selected is not stated; his own warning addresses people "with any public profile at all in the crypto space"); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); arrests none; source notes: the LinkedIn post text has been removed and the link is not usable; Daily Mail and Crypto Briefing carry the account.
- **DB id 418** (DA) — victim → Canadian businessman, 33, working in cryptocurrency, unnamed; drop "residing in Mallorca" (in no article; the gang followed him from Barcelona to Madrid); attackers → three Serbians (OK Diario), two arrested aged 33 and 45 (OK Diario) or between 32 and 45 (El Debate, El Español), the third at large; date 16 March 2026 kept (OK Diario: Monday night about 11 p.m.; El Español's report of 17 March fixes the Monday as 16 March); description → ambushed leaving Lobito de Mar (Claudio Coello and Jorge Juan, Salamanca district), beaten, pepper-sprayed, forced into a Ford Transit with swapped plates, tied with cable ties, given pills; van's GPS set for Petrer, Alicante, where OK Diario says they meant to torture him for his wallet keys; violence: drop "broken nose" (in no article; "graves heridas" kept); notes → two accounts of the police alert (witnesses on the street and balconies, OK Diario; the taxi driver who carried him afterwards, El Español), both kept; he freed himself in the abandoned van and took a taxi to La Princesa hospital; attempt on his 100,000-euro watch failed, he kept his belongings; drop fake passports and spat-out pills (site summary only); coin_type → crypto (the watch moves to notes as a failed attempt); targeting vector = surveillance (followed from Barcelona; investigators believe they knew of his crypto deal); sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected and taken for transport over a long distance, rule of 2026-10-01; Spanish sources' "secuestro exprés" noted as the press term); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1 as alleged, weapons 1 for pepper spray at the scene and firearms reported found in the van, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some (two of three).
- **DB id 417** (DA) — date → night of 15 to 16 March 2026, about 3 a.m. (so 16 March; Ouest-France); location → a commune north of Nantes, Loire-Atlantique (not Nantes itself); description → two armed men (one with a handgun), not "at least two"; struck on the head (Le Figaro relaying Ouest-France; the Ouest-France extract is cut mid-sentence); notes → the house's alarm, not a building's, drove them off; the Nantes prosecutor handed the case to the JIRS of Rennes (prosecutor Frédéric Teillet); investigation opened for attempted kidnapping; kidnappings → 1 (forced entry into his home followed by a blow, clarification 1; checker revised it as in 413); drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector unknown (not stated); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted: Kidnapping; flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests none.
- **DB id 416** (DA) — description matches L'Essor (about 6 a.m. Tuesday 10 March 2026, two masked men with small explosives trying to get in); notes → "victim's quick intervention" is Journal du Coin's wording; add: the Evry prosecutor treats this attempt and the Vaires-sur-Marne séquestration about 30 minutes later as one case (link to 415); victim targeted for a supposed cryptocurrency holding (prosecutor); targeting vector = unknown beyond that; sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted: Home Invasion; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 for the small explosives and the "avec arme" counts, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → all three occupants of the car intercepted at Bourgoin-Jallieu (a man of 35 and two adolescents of 15 and 17) charged, no conviction yet; source notes: the France 3 link yielded almost no text (THIN), the case rests on L'Essor and Journal du Coin.
- **DB id 415** (DA) — description → two hooded men forced the front door (conditional in TF1 Info) about 6:30 a.m. and woke the mother; notes → the third man on the phone was an instigator giving orders (commanditaire), not an accomplice on the ground; the name they cited was the former owner of the house, who left in August 2020; the family held no crypto (targeted by mistake, Meaux prosecutor); coin_type → crypto (unspecified; a wallet key was demanded), the €3,000 cash, jewellery and two phones move to notes (as 160); drugs_alcohol → 0; held duration not stated; link to 416 (same crew, same morning; arrests reported under 416's file, none in this file); targeting vector = wrong address (outdated information about the former owner); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 for gagging, tying and mutilation threats without injury, weapons 1 for the kitchen knife, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests none as of these reports.
- **DB id 414** (DA) — victim → couple in their sixties per Le Parisien ("petite soixantaine" for the wife) or fifties per AFP; both kept; money_wanted → about 900,000 EUR in BTC, drop the record's own "(~$980,000 USD)" conversion; description → wife thrown to the floor on opening the door (Le Parisien says she already had an injured shoulder; L'essentiel/AFP says lightly injured afterwards; both noted); notes kept (cable, white van, two phones are in Le Parisien); add: a fourth man directed the three by phone (Le Parisien only); charges differ (séquestration en bande organisée and extorsion avec arme per Le Parisien; séquestration, vol avec arme en bande organisée and association de malfaiteurs per the Versailles prosecutor to AFP); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse (record); now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (verified: police claim to get the door opened, then held in their home through the transfer; ruling of 2026-09-30); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests none at that stage.
- **DB id 413** (DA) — attackers → Ian Blair, 31, of Auburn (drop the middle name Alexander, in no article); money_wanted → 10 bitcoins (The Seattle Times via My Northwest), drop "(~$650,000)" (no source); notes → drop strangling of the wife and fractured bones (in no article); he forced his way in and assaulted the homeowner and his wife; the homeowner was taken to hospital for chest pain; drop the $1 million bail, 27 February charging date, "Prius is here" text and possible accomplice (site summary only); location → Phinney Ridge, Seattle, 300 block of North 74th Street (near Greenwood Avenue North); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Dodged Attack (record); now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion → Dodged Attack (owner ruling of 2026-09-30, postal-uniform ruse), attempted: the extortion of 10 bitcoins; kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list); flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, weapons 1 for the tasers in his postal bag, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → arrested at the scene, charged with first-degree burglary, two counts of second-degree assault, extortion and criminal impersonation; source notes: all four articles rest on the SPD blotter; the YouTube link is a video, not used.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 419** (owner) — Nancy, 8 March 2026: hooded men posing as police approached a woman at her door; the file stops at the doorstep.
- Settled (DA): drugs_alcohol → 0; time about 9 a.m. (L'Est Républicain); attackers "three or four" (L'Est Républicain), four (Cryptoast); sequence Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack, attempted Home Invasion; weapons 1 (at least one firearm).
- Question 1: the record's dog walk, forced entry, beating of husband and wife, daughters upstairs, Uzi, zip ties, arrest and June indictment appear in no source on file (L'Est Républicain is paywalled and cut mid-sentence; Cryptoast gives three sentences). Trace a fuller source before the record keeps them? DA recommends: trace first (as 145, 138, 114), meanwhile cut those details from the description.
- Question 2: kidnappings. Owner set 419 to 1 on 2026-09-06; the verifier now proposes unconfirmed because no article describes entry or holding. Same for violence_torture (record 1; Cryptoast says only "violente"). DA recommends: both unconfirmed until the fuller source is found, then re-rule.
+8
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"410": ["Authority Misuse", "Home Invasion"]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [],
"owner": [412, 409, 408, 406]
}
+32
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
# Batch 27 decisions (2026-10-01)
DA triage under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Evidence in `batches/contradictions-27.md`, `batches/batch-27.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. "Verified sequence" is the sequence in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 411** (DA) — location → Bali, abducted while riding a motorcycle; the rental car was traced to a villa in Tabanan (Jimbaran appears in no source); description → "tortured" rests on the ransom video only; "dismembered remains with matching tattoos found February 26" → body parts found at the mouth of the Wos River, about 30 km from Tabanan, partial tattoo match, DNA testing under way, police have not confirmed the body is Komarov's; discovery date differs (17 February per Bored Panda, 26 February per Pravda), both noted; victim spelling of the girlfriend: Eva (IBTimes) or Yeva (Bored Panda) Mishalova; whether Petrovsky was also taken differs (Pravda: both taken, Petrovsky escaped; IBTimes: Petrovsky and Mishalova escaped), both noted; attackers → not identified; one man ("CH") who rented the car on a false passport arrested, six foreign nationals named as suspects by initials RM, BK, AS, VN, SM, DH; drop the Nigerian name, the ramming, the Alphard and the stabbing (site summary only); money_wanted → $10 million in crypto, framed by the captors as repayment of money his family allegedly took; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon named; injuries imply an implement); life_taken → unconfirmed (identification not confirmed; coroner: identification impossible from decomposition); mark low-confidence (IBTimes: no authority has confirmed the kidnapping, ransom or injuries, and some journalists suggest staging), as 199; targeting vector = social media (companion's geotagged post, as reported) and a criminal debt dispute (as claimed in the video); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 on the video account, theft 0); arrests → some (one).
- **DB id 410** (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (no source mentions a weapon; gang robbery charge under Section 395, as 117); violence_torture → 0 (threats of arrest and immigration action only); drugs_alcohol → 0; notes → raid about 11:10 p.m. on 5 February 2026, officers left about 12:30 a.m. after the transfer was confirmed (about one hour twenty minutes, not 1.5 hours); RM400,000 demanded, RM200,000 accepted, paid as 50,000 USDT; drop the record's "($102,500)" conversion (no source); drop "one victim allowed to contact employer in China (conglomerate owner)" (in no source); description: "corrupt officers" stays an allegation (twelve officers arrested and released on bail, no charge reported; investigated as gang robbery, the victims' lawyer argues extortion); arrests → all twelve arrested (seven first, five more on 8 February 2026), released on bail; targeting vector = unknown (not stated); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (serving officers raided the rented bungalow and held the eight there until the transfer; the 2026-09-30 ruling puts the attack label after Authority Misuse, as 150 and 414); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); source notes: the NST link returned almost no text; The Block's closing paragraphs are context only.
- **DB id 407** (DA) — location → abducted in Granadilla de Curridabat (ESPN; San Pedro was the 5Dimes office), held at a house in La Trinidad de Moravia (casino.org); description: drop "at gunpoint" (no weapon in any source): two traffic officers pulled him over about 10 p.m., four men in a rented grey pickup took him; the officers took the Porsche; money_wanted kept "$5M demanded, about $1M paid in Bitcoin" (ESPN, Tico Times, TechnoLlama; casino.org about $950,800; gambling911 says the full amount, noted as the outlier); notes → remains found almost a year later in Quepos (a cemetery per ESPN and casino.org, a shallow grave per the Tico Times, a grave in a suspect's grandmother's backyard per gambling911), identified by the OIJ; cause of death not determined; said at trial he was killed after recognising a former employee; drop the Diario Extra torture video (in no source on file); violence_torture → unconfirmed (no violence in captivity described; the killing sits in life_taken; no rule covers an unknown cause of death); weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); drugs_alcohol → 0; arrests → convicted: nine sentenced in May 2022 by the Goicoechea court, 515 years in total with 65 for Morales Vega (casino.org, ESPN), against the Tico Times "most received a maximum of 35 years" under a plea deal (both noted), a tenth acquitted; Morales Vega fled overland to Panama, then El Salvador (casino.org) and Cuba, arrested in Spain on 11 January 2021; targeting vector = insider (his own inner circle at 5Dimes and their relatives, a plan of more than a year); sequence was Kidnapping (record); now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (verified: serving traffic officers made the stop, as 93 and 111); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1, life_taken 1).
- **DB id 405** (DA) — date → 12 February 2026, about 7 a.m. per RTL, about 6 a.m. per Cryptoast (both noted); location → Val-de-Marne; an apartment building per RTL, a house in Saint-Mandé per Cryptoast (both noted); victim → David Princay (The Block) or Prinçay (Cryptobriefing), head of Binance France, absent; add the neighbour whose door they forced to have the right apartment pointed out (unnamed); kidnappings → 1 (detention used on a third party to execute the attack, clarification 2); drugs_alcohol → 0; coin_type → crypto (unspecified), the two stolen phones move to notes (as 160); attackers → three hooded men, reportedly armed, aged 18, 20 and 21 (Cryptoast); one carried a handgun when arrested; arrests → all three in police custody, picked up at Lyon-Perrache (RTL) or Part-Dieu (Cryptoast), no charge reported; Cryptoast (citing Le Progrès) says at least one of the targets suffered harm, without saying which; link to 406 (same trio, same morning); targeting vector = unknown (how the trio found his address is not stated); sequence was Home Invasion (record); now Home Invasion → Dodged Attack, attempted: the home-jacking of the head of Binance France (foiled attempt, as 147 and 84); flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); source notes: bitcoinethereumnews.com refused the request, no text; the RTL trailer for the David Balland series and Cryptoast's trend paragraphs not used.
- **DB id 404** (DA) — victim → a couple and their daughter, 20 per RTL's standfirst, "in her twenties" in the body; notes → mother held on the ground by the neck while the daughter was taken to another room (not harmed, prosecutor); a person in their fifties was threatened with a key and a screwdriver for the codes (RTL's sentence does not settle whether the mother or the father: feminine subject, masculine agreement); no crypto transfer obtained (Meaux prosecutor); at least five hooded, gloved men; coin_type → BTC (a transfer from the father's Ledger key was demanded), the computers and phones taken move to notes (as 160); date 6 February 2026 kept (RTL: early morning of Friday 6 February; 6 February 2026 was a Friday); drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector unknown (not stated); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1 for the key and screwdriver used as threats, theft 1 for the devices, life_taken 0); arrests none reported; source notes: RTL's closing paragraph on Dompierre-sur-Mer is another case, not used.
- **DB id 403** (DA) — attackers → three teenagers from Sheffield, aged 16 and 17 at the time; Decrypt names none and says one cannot be named for legal reasons, so no names enter the record (Faris Hassan and Mikyle Bethune are site-summary only); money_wanted → $4.3 million in crypto and the victim's BMW (drop "X3" and the £3.1 million figure, in no source); notes → the stolen car triggered an ANPR camera on the M1 less than three hours later and was stopped on the M6 after a pursuit; when the three were arrested is not stated; crypto recovered within 72 hours and returned two weeks later (Met); drop ZachXBT, chat logs, Ring footage, the two Ethereum addresses and the ENS domain (in no source on file); sentencing date not stated; violence_torture → 0 (knifepoint threats, no injury); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse (record); now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (owner ruling of 2026-09-30, delivery-driver ruse at the door; 403 is on the ruling's list); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests → convicted, all three pleaded guilty, 16 years youth detention in total, 46 to 80 months each; source notes: the YouTube link is a video, not transcribed; the BlockSec commentary in Decrypt is context only.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 412** (owner) — Hung Hom, 7 March 2026: a 25-year-old mainland Chinese man attacked at a hotel by three men and a woman, crypto taken from his account, then taken to an industrial unit where silver was seized.
- Settled (DA): amount → HK$5.3 million in crypto and HK$800,000 in silver, about HK$6.1 million total (SCMP, the primary; The Bit Gazette HK$5m/HK$1m from the same statement, noted); drop the 42 kg and the dollar conversions; injuries to hands, ear and mouth; date 7 March kept (report at 3:52 a.m. Saturday); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed; no arrests.
- Question: the record's lure (fake business meeting), the victim's silver-trader occupation and the 42 kg of silver rest only on the CCN article, which refused the request and has no text on file. Readable sources support Kidnapping (moved to the industrial unit; listed as blackmail and false imprisonment). Drop Malicious Invitation now, or re-fetch CCN first? DA recommends: re-fetch CCN; if it carries the lure, Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping; if not, Kidnapping alone.
**DB id 409** (owner) — "Sillytuna", March 2026: about $24 million in aEthUSDC drained; on his own X posts he fought off four armed attackers ("axes over your hands and feet"). Owner has kept the case; no label is set.
- Settled (DA): location "Hun Hom, Hong Kong" → not stated (in no source); amount → about $24 million in aEthUSDC (Coinpedia: $23.6 million); date 4 March 2026 is the date of his X posts (a Wednesday), the attack date is not stated; drugs_alcohol → 0; no arrest, no police confirmation.
- Question 1 (label): no source gives a venue, so Home Invasion, Kidnapping and Armed Robbery cannot be supported. DA recommends: leave the sequence empty until a source places the attack.
- Question 2 (central fact): The Block carries his account of a physical attack; PeckShield-based coverage (Coinpedia/TradingView, BeInCrypto) calls it a suspected address-poisoning attack "with violent threats". DA recommends: keep, marked uncorroborated (victim's own account, no police statement), and do not publish flags as confirmed until a second source settles it.
**DB id 408** (owner) — Istanbul, January 2026: Chinese businessman Yong Wang (Yun Wang in London CLUP), 38, reported missing from Bakırköy on 24 January, found buried bound with packing tape in a field in Baklalı, Arnavutköy.
- Settled (DA): date → 24 January 2026 is the missing-person report, attack date not stated; location → disappeared in Bakırköy, body found in Arnavutköy; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed (a "hard object" per London CLUP's belief; the pickaxe and shovels were burial tools); ten suspects identified, Interpol notice, detained in China; drop "fled to China" and "including decoy woman".
- Question 1 (scenario and source): the dinner lure, the named woman, the four-man team outside a Fatih restaurant, the live upright burial, strangulation and skull trauma come only from en.haberler.com, which returned no text. Readable sources support Kidnapping (vanished and found bound elsewhere). DA recommends: re-fetch en.haberler.com before ruling; until then Kidnapping, and cut those details.
- Question 2 (theft): London CLUP believes his crypto wallet was taken; Turkiye Today says he was killed in an attempted robbery. DA recommends: theft → unconfirmed, both accounts in notes.
**DB id 406** (owner) — Vaucresson, 12 February 2026, 9:15 a.m.: the same trio as 405 struck a woman on the head with pistol butts at the wrong address, said "X. lives at another number" and fled.
- Settled (DA): kidnappings → 0 (blows and immediate flight, no entry or holding described; clarification 3; checker revised); drugs_alcohol → 0; description: drop the name "Stéphane" (RTL writes only "X."); drop the attackers' ages and "injuries" (not in RTL); arrests → in police custody at Lyon-Perrache, no charge reported; link to 405.
- Question: RTL describes no entry into her home and no control, so Home Invasion has nothing to rest on. Keep Home Invasion, or switch to Dodged Attack with the home-jacking of "X." listed as attempted (as 416, door never breached)? DA recommends: Dodged Attack, attempted Home Invasion, with the gap that she was a bystander at the wrong address.
+8
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"397": ["Authority Misuse", "Kidnapping"]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [],
"owner": [400, 399]
}
+25
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
# Batch 28 decisions (2026-10-01)
DA triage under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Evidence in `batches/contradictions-28.md`, `batches/batch-28.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. "Verified sequence" is the sequence in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 402** (DA) — victim → two adults restrained, plus a third person who hid at the back of the home, called 911 and never met the intruders; description: "posed as FedEx drivers" → arrived with a box and a dolly claiming to be delivery drivers (one had bought FedEx-style uniforms earlier; UPS-style clothing found at the scene); notes → restrained the two adults with duct tape (zip ties were only found lying in the home and backyard); threw the male victim to the ground and, when he said he had no bitcoin, allegedly forced his head into the ground; LaPaille denied assaulting anyone; the pair said they were extorted over Signal by "Red" and "8", who supplied the target and $1,000 for supplies; weapons → 1 (a 3D-printed gun, unloaded, working state unknown, found at the scene; no source says it was pointed at anyone); targeting vector = tip-off from unidentified handlers ("Red" and "8"); sequence was Authority Misuse (record); now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (owner ruling of 2026-09-30, delivery ruse; 402 is on the ruling's list); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some: both teens arrested at the scene about 11:35 a.m., to be tried as adults, eight felonies each, released on $50,000 bonds with ankle monitors; "Red" and "8" not identified; source notes: bitcoinethereumnews.com blocked, no text; "the mother" tipped police is not on file (the Tribune says "a parent", Gizmodo "one of the teens' mothers").
- **DB id 401** (DA) — date 5 February 2026 kept (break-in about 3 a.m. Thursday; Le Dauphiné Libéré: night of Wednesday to Thursday); original_date → night of 4 to 5 February 2026; victim → a 35-year-old magistrate at the Grenoble appeal court and her 66-year-old mother (Le Monde), the younger woman the partner of an executive of a Lyon crypto company (Le Dauphiné Libéré); description: "released after 30 hours" → freed on Friday 6 February by a passer-by who heard banging behind a garage door in Bourg-lès-Valence, 90 km away; held tied and gagged; duration more than 24 hours (Le Monde) or 30 hours (Le Dauphiné Libéré headline), both noted; ransom demand likely (Le Monde), amount not stated, nothing paid; theft → 0; weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); drugs_alcohol → 0; the dossier's AI summary details (three attackers, broken front door, blows to the face, blood stains, JIRS Lyon, the startup acquisition) are in no block on file and stay out of the record; targeting vector = unknown (the women were leverage on the partner's crypto business; how they were selected is not stated); sequence was Home Invasion (record); now Home Invasion → Kidnapping (verified: forced into a car and held 90 km away, rule of 2026-10-01); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 for "found alive but injured", life_taken 0); arrests not stated; source notes: both blocks are hard-trimmed, a fuller extract from staging is worth pulling; Cryptoast under 405 refers to this case.
- **DB id 398** (DA) — description: drop "BitConnect's developer and administrator" and "access to over 25,000 Bitcoin" (in no source); victim → Dhaval Mavani, "also attached with the bankrupt firm" BitConnect (CID chief Ashish Bhatia, The Hindu); attackers → Shailesh Bhatt's men; drop "nine accomplices" (no count in any source); named: Nikunj Bhatt (The Hindu), Nikunj Bhatt and Sanjay Kotadia (India Today); money_wanted → keep both accounts: 2,256 bitcoins worth Rs 131 crore plus another 166 bitcoins worth Rs 9.64 crore plus Rs 14.50 crore in cash (The Hindu, CID) against 2,254 bitcoins, 11,000 Litecoins and Rs 14.5 crore in cash (India Today, ED); drop the record's dollar conversions (no source); notes: drop the farmhouse, 1 to 4 February captivity, Gujarat warning, UAE deportation and FBI inquiry (site summary only; where and how long he was held is not stated); violence_torture → threat only (gunpoint kidnapping, no assault on Mavani; the beating in The Hindu is of Bhatt by Amreli police, another case), as 179 and 202; drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector = business counterparty (a defrauded BitConnect investor recovering his losses); link to 397 (same operation, second victim); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests → some (nephew Nikunj Bhatt arrested by the CID at the time; ED arrested Shailesh Bhatt, then Nikunj Bhatt and Kotadia in January 2026).
- **DB id 397** (DA) — reports: add The Hindu (https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/bitcoin-extortion-case-complainant-now-becomes-an-accused/article23956811.ece, on file under 398), which states: "Bhatt's accomplices first kidnapped Piyush Savalia by posing as Income Tax officials ... Mr. Savalia was confined in a farm house at gun-point for three days in January-end", and that Bhatt "paid ₹34.50 lakh to Piyush Savalia to keep mum and give a false statement that he was never kidnapped"; description kept on that basis (Income Tax ruse, farm house, gunpoint, three days); duration: three days per the CID (The Hindu), "released two days later" per the Congress spokesperson (New Indian Express), both noted; attackers: drop "nine accomplices" (no count in any source); victim spelling Savaliya / Savalia; violence_torture → 0 (no assault described); drugs_alcohol → 0; theft stays 0 (nothing on file obtained from Savaliya); targeting vector = business counterparty (defrauded investor; Savalia worked for BitConnect); link to 398; sequence was Authority Misuse (record), verified Kidnapping; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (claimed official role on the approach, ruling of 2026-09-30; the ruling's note left 397 out only because no impersonation was on its own file, and The Hindu now supplies it); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); arrests not stated for this kidnapping.
- **DB id 396** (DA) — money_wanted → 3,000,000 EUR in cryptocurrency (Le Dauphiné Libéré: "Une rançon de 3 millions d'euros en cryptomonnaies"); description: drop "amount unknown"; notes: "70-year-old" → 74 (headline and body; 70 is the URL slug); "freed in the early hours of Monday" → freed a little before midnight on Sunday night, near Loriol (Drôme), by the Lyon BRI; date 25 January 2026 kept (taken from his home in Voiron after 6 a.m. on Sunday; the 26 January report fixes the Sunday); victim → the father of an expatriate whose supposed crypto wallet was the target; the son received threats; weapons → unconfirmed (abduction not described); drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector = unknown (the father was leverage on the son's supposed holdings; selection not stated); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 for the serious hand injury, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some (three men in custody in Lyon); source notes: the kept block is paragraphs 20 to 23 of 42; the 18-hour duration and the mutilation reference may be in dropped paragraphs, worth a fuller extract.
- **DB id 395** (DA) — victim stays "17-year-old" (Nice-Matin's "Arthur" is a pseudonym and stays out of the database); attackers → two hooded men at the scene (one with a knife, one with a revolver); ten days later the BRI arrested several individuals, all minors, free under judicial supervision pending trial; notes kept; add the campaign that followed (50,000 euros in crypto demanded of the brother in Dubai by a fake Snapchat account, threats to the mother and sister; while the family was abroad, the flat's lock was forced and a video showed petrol poured on the door); those follow-on acts attacked no person and stay in this record's notes; targeting vector = unknown (the boy was leverage on his brother, who works in crypto; selection not stated); sequence Kidnapping kept (forced at knifepoint up about ten floors and held, never taken out of his building; gap noted); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some.
- **DB id 394** (DA) — victim → "Maxence", a reported first name ("un certain Maxence", Journal du Coin; "soi disant prénommée Maxence", ActuCrypto), an alleged crypto scammer; weapons → 0 (none mentioned); notes kept with the hedge (Journal du Coin keeps the account in the conditional); no ransom demand or transfer reported; motive: recovering money the three say they lost to his fake crypto investments ("expédition punitive", ActuCrypto); targeting vector = business counterparty (alleged fraud victims; he was recognised in the street); sequence Express Kidnapping kept (owner, 2026-10-01: stays Express, recognised by chance in the street); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → all three in pre-trial detention; trial set for 27 February 2026, outcome not on file, status needs a refresh; source notes: both blocks retell Le Bien Public, the primary is not on file; the Haute-Savoie paragraph in both is another case, not used.
- **DB id 393** (DA) — description kept with Ouest-France's conditional ("aurait été séquestré"; actu.fr states it flatly); violence_torture → unconfirmed ("On ignore si une personne a été blessée"; the gendarmerie canvass was for "un cambriolage avec violences"); weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); theft → unconfirmed (neither article says whether the code was obtained); how the 40 minutes ended is not stated; the AI summary's PNACO and parallel investigations are in no block on file and stay out; quarter field "Q1-2026" → "2026-Q1"; targeting vector unknown (not stated); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); arrests not stated (a gendarmerie canvass a week later, on 15 January 2026); source notes: the Ouest-France block's other lines concern two other incidents (Saint-Léger-sous-Cholet, 9 January; a couple with two children assaulted the same day), not used here.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 400** (owner) — Tucson, 31 January 2026: Nancy Guthrie, 84, mother of Savannah Guthrie, taken from her home at night per detectives; the only crypto element is a bitcoin ransom note of unconfirmed authenticity sent to TMZ (a second to KOLD).
- Settled (DA): drop the 9:30 p.m. drop-off and the ~2 a.m. pacemaker timeframe (PCSD has released no timeframes); blood trail kept with Raw Story's hedge (whose blood is unclear); weapons → unconfirmed; drugs_alcohol → 0; cameras including a Ring doorbell removed from the property; status dated 3 February 2026, needs a refresh.
- Question: does the case belong in the database? For: a ransom note demanding bitcoin "in the millions" to a real address (TMZ). Against: the AP's source says investigators do not believe it was a kidnapping-for-ransom plot, and police have not said whether the note is from the kidnappers or a hoax. DA recommends: keep it flagged "crypto link unconfirmed" until the investigation settles the note, as 96 was kept flagged "motive not established".
**DB id 399** (owner) — Dominican Republic, 31 October 2025: a young trader lured to an apartment for a cash trade, ambushed by five men, lost $750,000 in crypto. Reported directly to Gart Research by the victim; no article on file. Owner has kept the case; no label is set.
- Settled (DA): the dossier's long AI-summary narrative (bank transfer, Telegram group, towel strangulation, car) has no source on file and stays unpublished.
- Question 1 (label): the record's own description reads as P2P Trade Gone Wrong (a cash trade as the lure, ruling 117/104) or Malicious Invitation, followed by Kidnapping if he was held at the attackers' apartment. DA recommends: P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping once confirmed, not before.
- Question 2 (evidence): all six flags are unverified because nothing is on file. DA recommends: get the victim's account written into the dossier as a dated statement (with his consent on naming), then verify flags and label against it.
+11
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [
383
],
"owner": [
390,
386
]
}
+27
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
# Batch 29 decisions (2026-10-01)
Taken from `batches/contradictions-29.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-29.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Rules: `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`.
"Sequence ... kept" and "sequence was A; now B" compare with the verified sequence in `scenario-sequences.json`; where the record's own `scenario` field differs, the line says so. `decisions-29.json` lists changes against `scenario-sequences.json` only.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 392** (DA) — date → night of Wednesday 14 to Thursday 15 January 2026 (Le Dauphiné Libéré, franceinfo), found the evening of Friday 16 January at Montélimar; money_wanted → 8 million euros per Cryptoast and Le Dauphiné Libéré, franceinfo says only "plusieurs millions d'euros"; only Cryptoast says the demand was in cryptocurrency (note both); description: drop the unsourced "(~$8.4 million)" conversion; notes: drop "~300km away" (in no article on file); drugs_alcohol → 0, weapons → 0 (none in the three reports); theft → unconfirmed (ransom demanded of the son, no payment reported); sequence Kidnapping kept (taken from their home, held about two days, ransom demanded from a third party); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 "sérieusement blessés", life_taken 0); targeting vector = family of a holder (the son works in crypto; Cryptoast and Le Dauphiné say the offenders were well informed, how they found the couple not stated); outcome not stated ("finalement retrouvés", no rescue, escape or release described); arrests none; the franceinfo round-up tail (Yvelines, Dompierre-sur-Mer, other cases) not used.
- **DB id 391** (DA) — location → Barangay 13, Roxas Boulevard, Pasay City (ABS-CBN); money_wanted → USD 1 million demanded as a claimed debt the victim denies, about USD 400,000 in crypto plus USD 14,000 transferred; date 15 January 2026 kept (attack began around noon Thursday, rescue Friday 16 January, both weekdays match the calendar); drugs_alcohol stays 1 as a threat only: an unidentified injection found in the bin was "used to intimidate him", the report does not say he was injected (same reading as 170, drugs used as leverage); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 belt marks, weapons 1 knives, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → four, two arrested, two fled (notes' "2 arrested" is partial, arrests = some); targeting vector = acquaintance / insider access (one suspect had access to the unit and let the others in; claimed debt); single source, the ABS-CBN text pasted in the record's notes (the fetched page kept only boilerplate).
- **DB id 389** (DA) — description: drop "in connection with a cryptocurrency dispute" → kidnapped at his home, cryptocurrency the possible motive ("La cryptomonnaie pourrait être la raison", Alouette); victim → man of 43, software architect engineer (Ouest-France via Alouette); weapons → 0 (none in the three reports); theft → unconfirmed ("On ne sait pas quelles étaient les sommes en jeu ni les montants que les attaquants ont pu dérober", Cryptoast); date 9 January 2026 kept (about 8.30 a.m.); location: seized at Saint-Léger-sous-Cholet, released at Basse-Goulaine (Loire-Atlantique), place held not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected: the family had been the target of several attempted burglaries over the Christmas holidays; taken away by force); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 "violenté", found injured, CHU de Nantes; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); targeting vector = surveillance / repeat targeting (earlier attempted burglaries, no detail on file); arrests none, JIRS Rennes investigating; all three reports trace to one Ouest-France story; round-up tails in Alouette and Cryptoast not used.
- **DB id 388** (DA) — description: drop "Unknown amount of crypto stolen" (neither report says anything was taken); theft → unconfirmed ("Les enquêteurs explorent donc la piste d'un cambriolage prémédité", Mantes Actu); notes: "clamps" → cable ties ("colliers de serrage"); neighbours raised the alarm (Actu17), the family did not call police themselves; date kept 10 January 2026 with the conflict logged (Actu17 "ce vendredi soir" = 9 January; Mantes Actu "soirée du 10 janvier"; the record's Le Parisien translation "evening of Friday to Saturday 10 January"); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, all four tied; violence_torture 1, both parents struck several times; weapons 1, handgun; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); attackers → three, armed with a handgun, fled towards the station; targeting vector = professional profile (investigators link the targeting to the father's role heading a crypto-investment group; how he was found not stated); arrests none; Le Parisien blocked, both usable reports credit it, so one underlying source; Charente-Maritime and Balland tails not used.
- **DB id 387** (DA) — description: "after being robbed of cryptocurrency" → three hooded men tied her up, threatened her with a handgun, slapped her and left with a USB key containing data (Le Parisien); money_wanted → USB key containing data (Decrypt: her partner's crypto data), "Le préjudice financier n'a pas été évalué", no amount or coin; coin_type → not stated (drop "Crypto" as a stolen asset); theft stays 1 (the USB key, a device, was taken); victim → young woman living in the house, the cryptocurrency was her partner's; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1 "ils attachent et séquestrent la jeune femme", violence_torture 1 slap, Le Parisien says not injured; weapons 1 handgun; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); outcome escaped (untied herself after a few minutes); date 5 January 2026 kept (Monday about 7.30 p.m.); arrests none; Decrypt relays Le Parisien and adds only the investigating services.
- **DB id 385** (DA) — location → seized at the 14 Residence Hotel, Suksawat 66 Road, Phra Pradaeng, Samut Prakan; held in a suspect's room at a hotel on Pracharat Bampen Road, Huai Khwang, Bangkok (Bangkok Post); description: "kidnapped from Bangkok hotel" → from his hotel in Samut Prakan; money_wanted → ransom in a cryptocurrency worth about 2 million baht demanded of a relative in China, about 400,000 baht paid by his elder brother in two transactions early Tuesday; drop both dollar conversions (not in the report); victim → Lyu Chenglong, 25; violence_torture → 0, drugs_alcohol → 0 (none described); weapons stays 1 (air gun, stun gun and handcuffs seized in Watcharapol's room; use on him not stated; as 213, weapons found); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Authority Misuse alone; claimed to be CIB officers accusing him of being a scammer; held in the attackers' hotel room); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); date 29 December 2025 kept, unverified (report says "Monday night", no publication date on file); arrests some (Watcharapol Pimpila and Japing sae Liu charged with kidnapping and impersonating police; "other Thai men" not accounted for); single source, two garbled phrases in the retrieved text read as a demand on a relative and payment by the brother.
- **DB id 384** (DA) — victim → two employees of a Japanese company specialising in cryptocurrency and luxury goods, not named (SCMP); kept in the database on the precedent of 123 (crypto link = occupation, a non-crypto asset as the target) and 94 (cash, not crypto, taken); money_wanted → 1 billion yen (US$6.3 million per SCMP, about HK$50 million), not US$6.4 million; coin_type → cash (yen banknotes in four suitcases), no crypto taken; date 18 December 2025 kept, unverified ("Thursday last week" against a Monday briefing; no calendar date in the text); location → outside the currency exchange shop on Wing Lok Street, Sheung Wan; notes: "beef knife" → 20cm butcher knife (Supt Sin Kwok-ming); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, a snatch in passing per clarification 3; violence_torture 0; weapons 1; theft 1; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); attackers → three men from a private car, 15 arrested (11 men, four women, aged 20 to 69, several with triad backgrounds), arrests = some; the bulk AI summary's details (19 December, seven charged, backup vehicle, Jervois Street, seven-seater, arrests on 22 December) are in no text on file, drop them; archive.is mirror blocked.
- **DB id 383** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 390 (owner)** — Zoersel, Belgium: woman of 60 tied, beaten and threatened with a firearm at home; the crypto link survives only in a dead GVA link's headline.
- Settled (DA): weapons → 1 ("bedreigden haar met een vuurwapen", VRT NWS, NNieuws; In de Gazette); victim → woman of 60 (no occupation in any text on file); date 10 January 2026 kept (Saturday evening; In de Gazette's "zaterdagavond 11 januari" does not match the calendar, 11 January 2026 is a Sunday); attackers → several (VRT NWS, NNieuws) or two (In de Gazette), both logged; sequence Home Invasion kept; theft 1 "beperkte buit"; NNieuws is a reprint of VRT, not independent.
- Q1: Does the case count as a crypto attack before GVA is re-sourced? For: the GVA URL slug reads "gangsters zoeken naar cryptomunten en binden bewoonster (60) vast". Against: none of the three retrieved reports mentions crypto; prosecutors qualify it as attempted extortion, theft with violence and deprivation of liberty. DA recommends: keep, mark the crypto link unverified, trace GVA from an archive.
- Q2: "physician" and "after a hardware wallet, did not find one" are in no text on file. DA recommends: drop both unless the GVA trace confirms them.
**DB id 386 (owner)** — John Forsyth, February 2022: zip-tied, driven to a bridge and threatened, on his brother's second-hand account. This is the same incident as DB id 295, already ruled in batch 01 ("keep one record for the February 2022 kidnapping").
- Settled (DA, if kept): violence_torture → threat only, drugs_alcohol → 0, weapons → 0, theft → unconfirmed; description: the brother learned of it from a friend the night John went missing; replace the off-case Forbes URL on ARTICLE 1.
- Q: Delete 386 as a duplicate of 295, or keep both? Evidence: same victim, same month, same quotes (Fox News, Daily Mail); 295's ruling already carries the 2023 death in status. DA recommends: delete 386 and move any missing detail (Fox News, Daily Mail as sources) onto 295.
+16
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"375": [
"P2P Trade Gone Wrong",
"Armed Robbery in Public Space"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
381,
376,
374,
373
]
}
+33
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
# Batch 30 decisions (2026-10-01)
Taken from `batches/contradictions-30.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-30.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Rules: `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`.
"Sequence ... kept" and "sequence was A; now B" compare with the verified sequence in `scenario-sequences.json`; where the record's own `scenario` field differs, the line says so. `decisions-30.json` lists changes against `scenario-sequences.json` only.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 382** (DA) — victim → Yu, 46, male proprietor, and Lee, 37, a female employee (Dimsum Daily; "his wife" is in no source); attackers → four to five men armed with knives (notes' "three suspects" dropped); notes: "closing the shop at around 8:00 p.m." → staff threatened in a stairwell of W Plaza, 608 Nathan Road, officers alerted at 8.43 p.m. by a security guard; Yu treated at Kwong Wah Hospital for a finger injury; date 13 December 2025 kept (Saturday night); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Armed Robbery in Public Space (raid faltered when the owner resisted; as 147, 189); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1 hand injury in the struggle, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 knives, theft 0 "no financial losses and no property was taken", life_taken 0); classified as attempted robbery, no arrests; single source (Dimsum Daily, Wayback copy), url_2 thin, url_3 dead, url_4 blocked.
- **DB id 380** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("feita refém no local", "O roubo durou cerca de uma hora", Livecoins); violence_torture → 0 (no assault or injury described); victim → a woman crypto investor ("uma investidora de criptomoedas"); money_wanted and coin_type swapped back: money_wanted → about R$300,000 in cryptocurrency forcibly transferred, plus a pickup worth R$200,000, phones and laptops taken; coin_type → BTC per the record, cryptocurrency per the article; drop the unsourced "(approximately $50,000 USD)"; attackers → two armed men inside, a third waiting in a vehicle, a fourth instructing the transfer by phone, five more laundering; eight arrested (six men, two women), one at large; venue: Livecoins calls it both her office and a residence, Home Invasion covers either; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 "ambos estavam armados", toy gun among items seized; theft 1; life_taken 0); targeting vector = insider tip-off (renovation workers heard her mention Bitcoin three to four months earlier; DEFINITIONS lists 380 under this value); outcome released (inferred); Operação Cryptonita; YouTube links not transcribed.
- **DB id 379** (DA) — scenario: record's Costly Fame → sequence Kidnapping kept (verified sequence; no source on file says the attackers found or chose him through his public profile, as in 104 where Costly Fame was not applied; targeting vector = public profile suspected, not established: La Presse calls him "richissime influenceur", CBC documents his Telegram group and the AMF order); weapons → 1 ("enlevés par des inconnus encagoulés et armés", La Presse); theft → unconfirmed (they demanded his phone code; no source says anything was obtained); notes: "A drug addict lent her basement" → Joanie Lepage admitted renting the basement of her mobile home to an acquaintance who wanted to steal his wallet (diary: "3000 $"); "The 3 were freed the next day" → the three others were found hours later near a bus stop in Montreal's west end (CBC) or the following day in western Montreal (Global News), both logged; victim → Kevin Mirshahi, 25, plus three abducted friends (two women, one man); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 beaten to death, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 1); venue: seized at his Old Montreal condo's parking garage, held in Lepage's basement in Les Cèdres; arrests some (Lepage pleaded guilty to forcible confinement of the three friends on 11 December 2025; Perry and Hickey charged; Nobert sought; La Presse: three other men charged); CTV link on-case by headline but empty, not used.
- **DB id 377** (DA) — location → Mijas, Málaga province (Tekedia, CoinDesk); Madrid and Málaga are where the raids took place; victim → a man of Dutch origin, 37, and his Colombian partner, 29 (Tekedia only); drugs_alcohol → 0 (none mentioned); theft → 0 (the Spanish suspects face a charge of "attempted theft"; no asset reported obtained); scene: Blockonomi has them assaulted at home and forced into a nearby house, CoinDesk has them ambushed and taken by vehicle to a house; both logged, Kidnapping holds either way (held hours in a house that was not theirs); site summary: drop the Lamborghini / "Operación Lambo-Urus" and the luxury-lifestyle claim (in none of the four articles); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 shot in the leg and "signs of violence", weapons 1 handguns, life_taken 1); outcome: woman released around midnight, man found dead in a wooded area in Mijas, homicide; arrests some (five arrested in Spain, four charged in Denmark, announced mid-December 2025: TRT World "Wednesday", CoinDesk "Thursday", 14 December); Blockonomi's trend paragraphs and CoinDesk's framing not used.
- **DB id 375** (DA) — description: "Armed Robbers Steal $85K in Trinidad Crypto Ambush" → two armed men robbed a buyer of $85,800 in cash (currency not stated) and the occupants' mobile phones at a car park during an in-person crypto purchase; no crypto taken; site summary: drop "forcibly transferred" and "physically assaulted" (no transfer or assault described); victim → 52-year-old Arouca resident; location → SuperPharm parking lot, Trincity Central Road; sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space (cash brought to a cash-for-crypto trade with a two-year trading partner, robbed at gunpoint, as 94; gap: the report does not say whether the 33-year-old partner took part, as 83); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 "two armed men", theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown, business counterparty possible (investigators have not said whether the partner was involved); date 29 November 2025 kept; arrests none; the Cryptonews round-up (vehicle thefts, Lopp statistics, British Columbia, San Francisco, New York, Chicago, Balland) not used.
- **DB id 366** (DA) — weapons → 1 (gasoline bought at a Wagramer Strasse station and used to set him alight; melted canister recovered; glossary: "other tools used as weapons"; DA call, owner may set 0); date 25 November 2025 kept (attack began hours before the blaze at about 12.30 a.m. on 26 November; family reported him missing on 25 November); money_wanted → not stated ("authorities declined to specify the total sum stolen"); victim → Danylo K., 21, Ukrainian student, son of Kharkiv's deputy mayor; location → seized in the underground garage of the Sofitel SO/Vienna, Praterstraße; killed in the car on Marlen-Haushofer-Weg, Donaustadt; sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected by a fellow student, held in a vehicle and driven away); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1 accounts emptied, life_taken 1); targeting vector = acquaintance (fellow student, 19); arrests all (two suspects arrested in Ukraine on 29 November; case transferred to Ukrainian jurisdiction); single source (Cryptonews citing local reports); trailing round-up not used.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 381 (owner)** — La Rochelle area, 18 December 2025: crypto investor and partner tied up at home around 5 a.m., transfers made. Le Parisien (the only article in this dossier) says three attackers, amount unknown, no violence; round-up tails in other dossiers say more.
- Settled (DA): weapons → 0 (none described); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings 1, theft 1 "plusieurs virements"; drop "four criminals" and "data leak" (no source on file says either).
- Q1: Location, amount and violence. For the record (Dompierre-sur-Mer, 8 million, beaten): franceinfo in 392 "à Dompierre-sur-Mer ... huit millions d'euros de cryptomonnaies"; Cryptoast in 389 "séquestré et agressé un couple ... à Dompierre-sur-Mer ... environ 8 millions d'euros"; Actu17 in 388 "les avoir frappés pendant près de deux heures"; 404's article "Dompierre-sur-Mer le 18 décembre". Against: Le Parisien "à leur domicile de La Rochelle", "Le montant ... n'est pas connu", no assault. DA recommends: location → Dompierre-sur-Mer near La Rochelle, money_wanted → about 8 million euros in crypto (not $10 million), violence_torture stays 1, citing those tails, and fetch a dedicated report (The Big Whale, which Le Parisien cites).
**DB id 376 (owner)** — Maiduguri, Nigeria, 4 to 7 November 2025: eight-year-old girl kidnapped from school by a gang her uncle organised; ransom of 3 million naira paid via a cryptocurrency account.
- Settled (DA): notes: drop "held in a hotel" (no hotel in the article; where she was held not stated), dates 4 to 7 November; weapons → 0; summary: drop "targeting the family's cryptocurrency holdings" (no holdings mentioned); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 1 alleged, theft 1); five arrested; targeting vector = family (uncle as organiser).
- Q: Does a case belong in the database when crypto is only the payment rail and nobody is a crypto holder? Keep: the ransom was "paid via cryptocurrency", Mustapha Mohammed "received the 3 million naira ransom through a cryptocurrency account". Remove: no crypto asset was targeted. DA recommends: remove from the holder count, or keep under a "crypto as payment rail" mark if the owner wants that pattern tracked.
**DB id 374 (owner)** — Chalon-sur-Saône, 22 November 2025: six men, two of them minors, arrested in the act of an attempted kidnapping of a crypto investor; the article says earlier attempts on the same target failed.
- Settled (DA): weapons → 0 (none mentioned); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping; description: "for the fourth time" keeps its hedge (headline and the JSL post say fourth; the body says four earlier attempts, then describes three); flags unchanged (all 0); arrests all; the Morocco-mastermind opening not used.
- Q: Open records for the earlier attempts on the same man? For: the body says the first two operations failed and the third was stopped by a police intervention without arrests. Against: no date, place or detail for any of them. DA recommends: no new records; note the series on 374 (repeat victimisation, as 179).
**DB id 373 (owner)** — Val-d'Oise, 1 December 2025: father of a 19-year-old in Dubai seized by several men, filmed bound, gagged and beaten to extort his son; hospitalised in critical condition.
- Settled (DA): weapons → 0; theft → 0 (a large sum demanded, nothing reported paid); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1.
- Q1: Keep without an established crypto motive? Entrevue (single source): the son is "possibly also" skilled in cryptocurrency; police weigh an extortion over the son's digital skills, a financial dispute, or family tensions. DA recommends: keep, flagged "motive not established" as 96.
- Q2: "four men in black, balaclavas, gloves, a van" and "He was released" are in no text on file; Entrevue says only several individuals, a vehicle, and hospitalised in critical condition. DA recommends: drop both unless the source behind them is traced.
+17
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
{
"sequence_changes": {
"361": [
"Dodged Attack"
]
},
"attempted_changes": {
"361": [
"Armed Robbery in Public Space",
"a transfer of the exchange office's cryptocurrency holdings to a wallet the attacker named"
]
},
"parked": [],
"owner": [
260
]
}
+23
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
# Batch 31 decisions (2026-10-01)
Taken from `batches/contradictions-31.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-31.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Rules: `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`.
"Sequence ... kept" and "sequence was A; now B" compare with the verified sequence in `scenario-sequences.json`; where the record's own `scenario` field differs, the line says so. `decisions-31.json` lists changes against `scenario-sequences.json` only.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 363** (DA) — description: "LAPD officer & man tied to Israeli mob" → Eric Halem, a former LAPD officer still serving as a reserve officer, and a crew wearing police vests and claiming to execute a search warrant; Gabby Ben named by the Los Angeles Times and the Independent (Deputy DA Brownstone: "ties to the Israeli mafia"), not in the DA's charging release; the waterboarding threat kept with attribution (the Independent; Halem's attorney says the threats came from an unidentified sixth man); violence_torture → threat only ("subdued", cuffed, threatened to shoot and waterboard; no beating or injury; as 202 and 179); weapons → 1 ("Everyone was armed", Brownstone; "held a teenage crypto owner at gunpoint", Decrypt); attackers: two entering per the DA, four per the LA Times, six per the Independent, all logged; coin_type: keep both accounts unmerged ($350,000 in bitcoin on a thumb drive from a safe per trial testimony; transfer from the crypto account plus cash and jewellery per the DA release); victim → Daniel, 17, and his girlfriend; sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion kept (record's scenario: Home Invasion; police vests and claimed warrant; ruling of 2026-09-30); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1 both handcuffed about 25 minutes, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); date 28 December 2024 kept (about 2.30 a.m., DA); arrests: Halem found guilty of kidnapping and robbery (LA Times, 2 March 2026), Banuelos, Louis and Mann await trial; targeting vector = insider (access code from the conspirator who rented him the unit); url_4 refused the request.
- **DB id 361** (DA) — violence_torture → 0 (no assault or injury; bomb technicians said the devices "не могут причинить серьезный ущерб"); notes: "nobody was hurt" → no injury reported, devices could not cause serious damage; weapons stays 1, noted as airsoft replicas (as 114 "reported fake" and 136 imitation firearm); sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space → Dodged Attack; now Dodged Attack, attempted: Armed Robbery in Public Space, transfer of the exchange office's cryptocurrency to a wallet he named (foiled at the scene by patrol officers and Rosgvardia; as 84, 147, 158); victim → exchange office in an apart-hotel at 43/12 Khersonskaya Street and its staff; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); money_wanted stays empty (no amount); arrests all (21-year-old detained, robbery case under part 3 of article 162); single source, RBC St Petersburg via Wayback; the WEAK trimmer flag is a false alarm, the article is the right one.
- **DB id 360** (DA) — money_wanted → $11 million in cryptocurrency plus the victim's phone and laptop (San Francisco Chronicle police report; KRON4 repeats it); drop "$10M BTC + $3M ETH = $13M" (no coin split in either report); description: $13 million → $11 million; violence_torture → 1 (officers "found the victim suffering from non-life-threatening injuries", paramedics dispatched); location → unit block of Dorland Street, Mission Dolores (Chronicle; KRON4 says Mission District); sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion kept (record's scenario: Home Invasion; courier ruse at the door; ruling of 2026-09-30 applied to 360); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1 duct tape, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 gun brandished, theft 1, life_taken 0); date 22 November 2025 kept (early Saturday evening; officers at about 6.45 p.m.); outcome released (suspect fled; how he got free not stated); arrests none; KRON4's advice section and teasers not used.
- **DB id 358** (DA) — decided on the batch 31 file; the case is also in batch 33 (re-sourced dossier: the record's URL now resolves to the right Thaiger report and a Nate report is on file; the Thaiger and Khaosod disagree on the order of arrests, Lee on 10 November versus 23 November), so batch 33 should only add to this line. date → 1 November 2025 (Khaosod English: attacked "on Nov. 1"; 10 November is an arrest date); drugs_alcohol → 0, weapons → 0 (no substance or weapon; punching and beating only); attackers → three men in the car (two Thai, one South Korean), four charged in all (Lee, 46, and Nattapong, Chanon, Tanaphat); money_wanted → 50,000 baht cash and 9,375 USDT, more than $10,000 combined per Khaosod; reports: replace the off-case Thaiger flood-story link with the correct Thaiger report and add Khaosod English (23 November 2025); sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected: Lee says the victim owed him money; held at an underground car park at an unknown location); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty, claimed (debt claim, which Lee uses in his denial; untested); arrests all, charged with robbery using a vehicle, illegal detention and assault.
- **DB id 357** (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (neither PA/Yahoo nor BBC names a weapon; "masked", "men clad in face coverings"; arrests on suspicion of robbery and kidnap, no firearm offence); location → Oxford (taken in the car on the afternoon of 4 November, left in the Five Mile Drive area of Oxford; police appeal covers Yarnton Road and Sandy Lane between Kidlington and Yarnton); money_wanted → two separate losses, a watch worth about £450,000 and about £1.1 million in cryptocurrency transferred out of one victim's account, plus the phones; description: replace the PA headline with the facts; PA has the victims left in Five Mile Drive, BBC has the robbers leaving the vehicle there, both logged; sequence Express Kidnapping kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-01: sources do not say how the victims were chosen, gap noted); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1 about 30 minutes, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests some (four men arrested and bailed, no charge on file).
- **DB id 352** (DA) — scenario: record's Home Invasion → sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, attempted theft of some of the 11 mining machines (armed raid on a crypto-mining farm under construction, no residence, nobody held; same pattern as 102); violence_torture stays 1 (two men shot dead in the exchange of fire, one wounded; the owner kept the flag on a man shot dead in 102, so the writer's note that 102 dropped it is wrong); victim: Mario Ramón Chávez Rivas, 35, kept; Última Hora calls him both the owner and the caretaker, note both; add Sabino Peralta Vega, 24, wounded (brother-in-law of the farm's owner, came with a firearm); attackers → four in a grey Toyota Premio, three entered; Rodrigo David Ayala Cano, 32, killed at the scene; three fled unidentified; location → km 9, Monday side, Ciudad del Este, Alto Paraná (Las Palmeras); date 5 November 2025 kept, unverified (early hours of a Wednesday, no calendar date in the text); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 0 "sin haberse llevado nada", life_taken 2); whose shot killed Chávez Rivas not stated; arrests none; kept in the database regardless of the empty-premises decision (people present, deaths), as 102.
- **DB id 318** (DA) — location → Quebec, town not stated (no report on file names Victoriaville; it appears only in the unverified AI summary; keep Victoriaville only if a source is found); date → November 2024, day unknown ("early November 2024"; the record's 4 and 8 November are in no source); sequence Costly Fame → Dodged Attack kept (record's scenario: Dodged Attack), attempted kidnapping and torture for his bitcoin (police found the attackers believed he held 2.5 million BTC "based on his social media activity" as a forum moderator; as 86, targeted through public posts); money_wanted kept as the attackers' belief, add his actual holdings of about $10,000; flags unchanged (all 0; the handgun, the spray and the torture kit belong to the second stage, record 433); arrests: two adults (conspiracy to kidnap, prohibited firearms) and two juveniles arrested, all four released on house arrest; whether charges were laid or to come differs by source, logged; link to 433 (second stage, 8 November per that record; pepper spray per The Block, bear spray per Coingape); all three reports retell one La Presse story; Mirshahi and Skurka tails and Coingape's author block not used.
- **DB id 259** (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon in the report; cause of death not stated); description: drop "Victim previously accused of stealing £380 from crypto investors" (nothing in the file); date → October 2025, day unknown (Metro of 8 November: vanished "a month ago"; the record's 2 October is in no source); location → last seen driving to meet "unidentified investors" by a lake in Hatta, Dubai; bodies found buried in the desert; three suspects detained in St Petersburg and the Stavropol and Krasnodar regions; money_wanted → a "large ransom", amount not stated, "not paid" (Metro's hedged wording); sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Malicious Invitation alone; meeting with "unidentified investors", then reported kidnapped for ransom; venue and duration not stated); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1 on Metro's hedge, violence_torture 1 dismembered, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 2); arrests some; single short Metro extract: a fuller source pass (Russian and Emirati reporting) is needed before publication, for the ransom figure, the dates and the suspects.
- **DB id 258** (DA) — money_wanted → 14,600 euros in cash taken plus more than 83,000 dollars in USDT transferred (national police: over 97,000 dollars in cash and crypto; Bolvinov: "майже 15 тисяч євро"); attackers → three detained (aged 30, 34, 39, one a serviceman), at least five involved per police; description: the men got out of a black van, introduced themselves as territorial recruitment centre (TCC) staff, used pepper spray, bound him with plastic ties, drove him about two hours, beat and threatened him with weapons, held him in a basement until the transfer, released at Bezliudivka; victim → 32-year-old man who works in cryptocurrency and handles other people's money (Bolvinov); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (record's scenario: Kidnapping alone; TCC impersonation on the approach, ruling of 2026-09-30; pre-selected and held in a basement); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = surveillance (watched for several days, routes tracked); date 10 October 2025 kept; arrests some (three in custody, suspicion under art. 146 part 2 and art. 187 part 4); reports: add Ukrinform, Hromadske Radio, Sud.ua and ATN (all 17 October 2025); the archive.is link stays (Kharkiv snapshot, per the spreadsheet ruling on row 259); the WEAK anchor flags are false alarms; Kryvyi Rih, cash-courier and Ternopil tails not used.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 260 (owner)** — Singapore, Token2049, 3 October 2025: Nate Geier woke in hospital with facial injuries and says he "must have gotten jumped walking home"; passport and ring gone; no memory, no police statement on file.
- Settled (DA): description: "Phone and passport stolen" → passport and ring gone (Mothership quotes "Passport and ring gone"); drugs_alcohol → unconfirmed (only other users "speculated" he was "inebriated"); weapons → unconfirmed (none in the file); victim → Nate Geier, co-founder of a software development company ("bitte.ai" is from his X display name); violence_torture 1 and theft 1 stand; date: 3 October is the post and police-report date, the 11 p.m. attack not tied to a day; add the Mothership report as a source.
- Q: Keep in the database? For: a crypto founder hurt and robbed on the way home from a crypto conference (crypto link by occupation, as 123). Against: nothing crypto taken, the assault is the victim's own inference, and Mothership reports public doubt. DA recommends: keep as Mugging, flagged "motive not established" and "victim's account only", as 96.
+1
View File
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
{"sequence_changes": {}, "attempted_changes": {}, "parked": [], "owner": [255, 223, 188]}
+29
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
# Batch 32 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-01
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-32.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-32.json` and `sources/<id>_*.txt`. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Sequences are compared with the DB record's `scenario`; the verified sequences are already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 257** (DA) — date → September 2025, day unknown (SVT: 'I september förra året'; Aftonbladet: 'I slutet av september'; 27 September is in no source); violence_torture → 1 ('Familjen i Tobo blev bundna och skenavrättades' and 'tvingades offren under vapenhot och våld föra över 2,5 miljoner kronor', SVT); weapons → 1 ('under vapenhot', SVT; no weapon type named, as ruled for 126 'armed robbery per SVT'); description → five masked people got into two neighbouring villas in Tobo, bound the family with cable ties and tape, subjected them to mock executions and forced a transfer of 2.5 million kronor in cryptocurrency; drop the axe, knife and fake pistol, the 10 p.m. start, 'Bitcoin demanded but other cryptocurrency transferred' and the '~$235,000' conversion (none in any source on file); money_wanted → 2.5 million SEK in cryptocurrency taken (no demand figure stated), coin_type → crypto, coin not named; victim → family in two neighbouring villas ('Farmer' is in no source); status → broken off after 1.5 hours when a victim raised relatives over a game-chat microphone and his father and brother arrived and shouted, outcome rescued; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown (not stated); arrests → convicted: four men sentenced to six years each for aggravated robbery, the fifth at large and suspected abroad, two men and a woman convicted of laundering part of the proceeds (SVT, verdict undated); source notes: the Aftonbladet URL is a rolling live blog, only its pinned Tierp entry is used and the link will rot; SVT is the substantive article; the police chase with gunfire, the April 2026 verdict date and Uppsala district court are in no source on file.
- **DB id 254** (DA) — money_wanted → 500 BTC demanded (about $55 million, per the indictment as reported by Calcalistech and DL News); amount taken → $547,260 in Bitcoin and about $42,248 in USDT transferred, plus a Rolex (about 189,800 shekels, about $50,000), a laptop, a Trezor wallet, about 5,000 euros and several thousand shekels in cash (indictment); note DL News's version (nearly 5 BTC worth about $610,000 at its date, over 42,000 USDT, the password to an Exodus wallet) and the headline totals ($650,000 DL News, $600,000 Calcalistech and the third article); coin_type → BTC, USDT (the loot inventory moves to notes); attackers → Murad Mahajna, 46, of Tel Aviv (spelled Mahajneh by DL News), indicted, plus two accomplices at large, two of the three masked; notes → follow-up threat call two days later demanding more codes and coins; date 7 September 2025 kept (8:10 a.m., indictment); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 (kitchen knife held to his neck), theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown (the indictment says the three learned he owned Bitcoin; how is not stated); arrests → some (Mahajna arrested 10 September; accomplices at large); source notes: Calcalistech and the third article are pasted in the sheet with no URL recorded, add their URLs; DL News's Las Vegas and French New Year's Eve passages and Eyal Gruper's comment are other cases or commentary, not used.
- **DB id 209** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ('She was in a vehicle, tied up but in good health', Le Monde; Balland held at a rented villa near Châteauroux guarded by two men); violence_torture → 1 ('his kidnappers had cut off his finger and sent the video of the mutilation to Ledger', Le Monde; charge of acts of torture or barbarism); weapons → 1 ('plusieurs hommes armés entrent dans la propriété', Zero Bullshit; charge of extortion with weapons); theft → 1 (400 ETH, 1.2 million euros, sent and close to 3 million euros in total per Zero Bullshit; most was frozen and seized and only 40 ETH, 122,000 euros, cashed out; the flag notes that the theft was largely undone); location → Méreau, near Vierzon (Le Monde and the Fortune caption; Zero Bullshit says the southern outskirts of Vierzon); money_wanted → a little over 10 million euros in Bitcoin demanded (Zero Bullshit), coin_type → ETH paid, BTC demanded; description → 'later seized via Tether' → most of the payment was frozen within hours (USDT blacklist, KuCoin, Binance, MEXC) and seized by the courts; notes keep 'investigators sent one bitcoin to buy time and trace it' (Le Monde); date 21 January 2025 kept for the abduction, Balland freed the night of 22 January, his wife on 23 January at Étampes; victim → David Balland and his wife (named only by the Zero Bullshit newsletter; keep her unnamed); ransom demand went to co-founder Eric Larchevêque; sequence was Kidnapping; now Home Invasion → Kidnapping (armed entry to their home, then both taken to separate places, as ruled for 152 and 190); drugs_alcohol and life_taken stay 0; targeting vector not stated (a police source says the aim was probably his professional circle); arrests → some: ten in custody, organisers not identified per Zero Bullshit; the traffic stop is credited to the Vierzon BAC (Le Monde) and the Bourges BAC (Zero Bullshit), both noted; source notes: Le Monde's closing paragraph is case 203, Fortune's Skurka and UnitedHealthcare passages, Cointelegraph's statistics and Zero Bullshit's company history not used.
- **DB id 203** (DA) — date → 31 December 2024 (Cryptoast: 'dans la nuit du réveillon'; DL News: 'Incident took place on December 31, 2024'; 1 January is when the father was found); attackers → two broke in (Cryptoast), five arrested aged 16 to 42 (DL News); drop '4-5 armed, masked' (no source says armed; Cryptoast calls the two in the car hooded); weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon in either article); distance → 500 km (Cryptoast) and about 700 km (DL News), both noted; father's age 56 (Cryptoast's subheading says 50); victims → father taken, wife and daughter tied up at the house (Cryptoast; DL News's later line 'found his partner tied up at the scene' agrees, its earlier 'along with his partner' in the trunk is noted as a contradiction inside DL News); sequence was Home Invasion; now Home Invasion → Kidnapping (father driven hundreds of kilometres in a car boot; transported over a long distance, rule of 2026-10-01, as 152 and 190); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); ransom amount and coin not stated, payment not stated (police did not comment, DL News); targeting vector not stated (the son is a Dubai-based crypto influencer; no source says how the family was chosen); arrests → some (five arrested per DL News; the March 2026 second wave is in the unverified site summary only, drop); source notes: Cryptoast's Winkel and Canada passages and DL News's three context cases are other matters, not used.
- **DB id 177** (DA) — money_wanted → empty, no demand reported; loss → over $4.1 million in crypto, mainly ETH, UNI and LINK (CoinTab, from the transaction record Nair shared); description → drop '1,000+ ETH' (no ETH quantity in the source); notes → 'They knew I had crypto and knew where I lived', forced to open his Ledger and transfer everything (Nair's post, via CoinTab); date 17 June 2024 kept as the date of the post ('This just happened'), no independent date; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0 ('Luckily I didn't get stabbed'), drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 (machetes), theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown; arrests none reported; source notes: single outlet built on the victim's own posts, no police or court source; 'blockchain developer', 'former Ethereum Foundation coder', 'Kickback co-founder' and the deleted post are in the unverified site summary only, drop; a second source is worth fetching but is not needed for these corrections.
- **DB id 109** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ('die hielden een pistool op mijn hoofd en zeiden, Bitcoin, Bitcoin', AT5: held at gunpoint inside his home; precedent 121); description → three men got in by pretending to have a parcel ('omdat ze net deden alsof ze een pakketje hadden'), one in a DHL jacket per Everts's tweet; drop 'when his daughter opened door' (AT5 does not say who opened the door); attackers → three young men, aged 17 to 19 per the Burgernet descriptions, '20 of jonger' per Everts's tweet; weapons stays 1 (a pistol; the record-side claim that he later called it not real is in no source on file, drop); sequence was Costly Fame; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion → Dodged Attack, attempted forced Bitcoin transfer (Authority Misuse by the ruling of 2026-09-30, already applied to 109; Costly Fame not carried by the article, as 104; Halsema's social-media remark is general); flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown; arrests none (police investigation continuing); source notes: the YouTube link is a reference, not transcribed; AT5's closing paragraphs on other Amsterdam robberies are context.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 255** (owner) — Grant, Minnesota, 19 September 2025: two armed brothers held a husband, wife and adult son for nine hours; the husband was driven three hours to the family's cabin in Grand Rapids to transfer more.
- Settled (DA): violence_torture → unconfirmed (no blow or injury described; each brother charged with three counts of first-degree assault during a burglary with a firearm; as ruled for 88); amount → at least $36,000 at the house plus at least another $36,000 at the cabin (charging documents, CBS) and $8 million total (U.S. Attorney's press release and headlines), recorded as the loss, no demand figure, so money_wanted no longer reads $8 million as a demand; victim → husband, wife and adult son; start about 7:45 a.m. (CBS also says 'shortly before 8 a.m.'); notes → a third party fed account details by phone, unidentified; gags found at the brothers' home; targeting vector = data leak / breach, the husband's belief only; arrests some; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); CBS links are Wayback copies, NBC's closing statistics not used.
- Question: keep Home Invasion alone, or Home Invasion → Kidnapping for the husband's forced three-hour drive? For Kidnapping: the rule of 2026-10-01 counts 'transported over a long distance', and 203 in this batch gets Home Invasion → Kidnapping for a father driven 500 to 700 km. For Home Invasion alone: he was taken to the family's own cabin, a private space of the victim, and the wife and son never left the house (verifier's reading).
- DA recommendation: Home Invasion → Kidnapping; the rule names long-distance transport and does not depend on who owns the destination.
**DB id 223** (owner) — Anson Que, 51, and his driver Armanie Pabillo seized 29 March 2025, held almost 11 days, ransom paid in crypto, both found dead on 9 April 2025 in Rodriguez, Rizal.
- Settled (DA): weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon in any article; bodies bound with nylon rope, duct tape, signs of strangulation); attackers → five suspects: Richardo Austria David, Raymart Catequista and David Tan Liao charged with two counts of kidnapping with homicide, Gong Wenli (Kelly Tan Lim) arrested later, Jonin Lin at large (arrests some); money_wanted $20 million demanded kept (police, via Rappler); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 2 unchanged; the ABS-CBN fetch holds only a headline and boilerplate.
- Question 1: which account sets location and ransom paid? Police via Rappler: seized in a house in Barangay Langka, Meycauayan, Bulacan; around 200 million pesos paid through crypto in several tranches. Ramon Tulfo column (the sheet's Article 1, pasted under the ABS-CBN URL, citing 'trusted sources'): abducted while dining at a seafood restaurant on Macapagal Avenue, Pasay City; 160 million pesos paid (60 million, then 100 million). DA recommendation: follow the police account and note the column's version.
- Question 2: the record's woman used as a lure, planning from January and the 28 March meeting date are in no source on file. Trace first (as 145, 138, 114) or drop? DA recommendation: drop them from the description until a source is found, and replace 'received over $3M' and the '$4 million (~P200 million)' conversion with 'around 200 million pesos paid in crypto' (no dollar figure in Rappler).
**DB id 188** (owner) — Danbury, Connecticut, 25 August 2024: the Chetal couple were rear-ended, beaten (the man with a baseball bat), bound with duct tape and driven off in a van that crashed minutes later; the plot aimed at a ransom from their son Veer Chetal.
- Settled (DA): drop '$243M heist thieves' from the description and the notes' '$342M': the $243 million (Krebs), more than $230 million (court documents) and $245 or nearly $250 million (News Times) belong to the separate online theft a week earlier; money_wanted → empty (no demand was made); victim → Radhika and Suchil Chetal (Krebs, which also writes 'Sushil'; the complaint uses R.C. and S.C.); attackers → six Florida men charged (Borrero as payer and organiser, Diaz, Pena, Romero, Estrada, Rivas) and James Schwab federally charged with conspiracy; three St Louis men appear only in sidebar headlines; targeting → prosecutors: the co-conspirators believed the son had access to significant digital currency; Schwab had an altercation with 'V.C.' at a Miami nightclub; arrests convicted (five federal guilty pleas, Diaz awaiting trial); kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0 unchanged; air rifles, walkie-talkies, the FBI agent, Iza and Faiq are in no source on file, drop.
- Question 1: theft flag for a car taken and recovered. For 1: every source calls it a carjacking and police 'recovered the abandoned Lamborghini from a wooded area' (Krebs). For 0: nothing was obtained from the couple and the car was abandoned. The same question arises in 495 (phone taken, found nearby). DA recommendation: one rule for both: an item seized in passing and recovered at or near the scene sets theft 0 with a note, since the glossary's theft flag records whether the attackers achieved their financial objective (cf. 295).
- Question 2: sequence. Verifier: Kidnapping → Dodged Attack (attempted ransom demand). Against: 113 (control gained, plan failed, both hospitalised) stays Home Invasion with the attempt listed and no Dodged Attack, and here the man was beaten with a bat. DA recommendation: Kidnapping with the attempted ransom demand listed, Dodged Attack dropped, matching 113.
+1
View File
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
{"sequence_changes": {"491": ["Kidnapping"]}, "attempted_changes": {}, "parked": [], "owner": []}
+15
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
# Batch 33 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-01
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-33.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-33.json` and `sources/<id>_*.txt`. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Sequences are compared with the DB record's `scenario`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 491** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (no drug or alcohol in the attack; the two men stopped nearby who said they were there to buy drugs were not recognised by the victim); location → seized in Jundiaí (inside his own mechanic's workshop, A Voz de Jundiaí; jr.jor.br says his place of work, SP Diario in front of a commercial premises), held in a shack in woodland at Chácaras Campo Limpo, Campo Limpo Paulista (jr.jor.br places the whole kidnapping in Campo Limpo Paulista; both noted); notes → items taken: two gold bracelets, a silver Tissot watch, a Victorinox wallet with documents and cards, about R$300 plus guarani notes and the Hyundai Azera key (jr.jor.br); SP Diario lists two gold chains, a watch, a wallet and the car key; Pix transfers to several accounts until the bank blocked the account, then attempted 'Cripto-Pix' operations; no completed crypto transfer reported; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (no amount in any source); crypto link marked thin (attempted 'Cripto-Pix' only); captivity ended when a lookout ('olheiro') phoned a police warning, outcome escaped; sequence was Express Kidnapping; now Kidnapping (owner ruling 2026-09-30, shack in woodland; `batch-33.json` still reads Express Kidnapping, so the sequence is restated in the JSON); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 (blows to the head), weapons 1 (revolvers), theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector not stated; arrests → some: SP Diario of 17 September reports nobody arrested; one man caught in the act on 24 September with the car used and identified by the victim (A Voz de Jundiaí); source notes: the tvsmais.com.br URL is THIN and nothing rests on it; SP Diario and A Voz de Jundiaí teasers not used.
- **DB id 490** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing in any of the three articles); money_wanted → about 100 euros in crypto from the wallet the codes opened, two transfers of 450 euros from the mother (made per Cryptoast, 'vont forcer la mère de famille à effectuer'; demanded per Journal du Coin, 'exigent de l'épouse'; both readings noted), plus computers, phones, jewellery and a few hundred euros; coin_type → not stated (no coin in any source); victim → couple and their 10-year-old child (Cryptoast says son); date 13 July 2026 kept (in daylight); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 (taser shocks to the father), weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = data leak / breach (the January 2026 Waltio tax-report leak, balances as of 31 December 2024, per the Pontoise prosecutor via Le Parisien); notes → suspected organiser already imprisoned at Auxerre, said to have set up the job from his cell; arrests → some: six charged on 11 September 2026 with organised-gang armed theft and extortion, unlawful detention and conspiracy, three in pre-trial detention, none convicted; source notes: no Le Parisien article on file, every prosecutor quotation is second-hand; Journal du Coin's closing passage on a Paris attempted abduction linked to the Waltio data is another case, not used (may already be a separate record, not checked).
- **DB id 489** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing in any of the three articles); date → night of 19 to 20 September 2026, entry about 4 a.m. (BFMTV, Cryptoast); 20 September kept with that note; victims → a couple (father 40, IT specialist working in crypto; partner 41, per La Voix du Nord via Bitcoin.com News) and their children aged 8 and 12; notes → the 12-year-old daughter was struck in the face or head with car keys (BFMTV, Cryptoast, Bitcoin.com News); a fifth person stayed on the phone with the crew throughout, allegedly speaking Arabic (local reporting via Bitcoin.com News); duration more than three hours (Cryptoast) against two hours and two to three hours (Bitcoin.com News), held_duration hours; weapons stays 1 (at least a knife and an iron bar, La Voix du Nord via Bitcoin.com News, single-sourced; BFMTV and Cryptoast name no weapon); amount → about 40,000 euros in crypto, coin not disclosed; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown; arrests none (four suspects at large); source notes: La Voix du Nord and Le Parisien are not on file directly; Bitcoin.com News's national statistics not used.
- **DB id 488** (DA) — theft → unconfirmed (Journal du Coin: 'Aucun renseignement n'a été communiqué sur son identité, le montant des cryptoactifs recherchés ou l'éventuel butin emporté'; the charge is an attempted extortion); drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing in any article); description keeps the failed attempt to take her away in her own vehicle as attempted, outcome escaped (she reached a neighbour, who alerted the gendarmerie); notes → still suffering serious injuries when the arrests were announced; announcement date 14 September 2026 (Journal du Coin) and 'lundi' (La Gazette France, Europe 1) agree, 14 September 2026 being a Monday; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (amount sought not released); sequence Home Invasion kept with the attempted abduction and attempted extortion listed; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1 (one attacker armed with a knife), life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown (her link to cryptoassets not disclosed); arrests → some: five arrested on 7 and 8 September 2026, four charged, three in pre-trial detention; source notes: the three articles relay one gendarmerie statement; Journal du Coin's national statistics and Europe 1's teasers not used.
- **DB id 358** — see batch 31 decision; batch 33 re-sourcing notes: the record's url now resolves to the correct Thaiger report (FETCHED ARTICLE 5), and Khaosod English (23 November 2025) and a Korean Nate report are also on file, so the case is no longer single-sourced; url_3 and url_4 are the same Nate link (duplicate); The Thaiger adds the 10.30am start on 1 November while he waited for a taxi on Maha Set Road, the report to Bang Rak police on 8 November, a white Toyota C-HR with plate 9 Kor Hor 5427 (Khaosod: a Toyota sedan), transfers of 1,500 USDT at 11.48am and 7,875 USDT at 12.05pm (9,375 USDT, about 353,656 baht), release at about 12.20pm at Soi Saen Suk by Maleenont Tower on Rama IV Road, and the full name Lee In Han, 46; the arrest sequence conflicts (The Thaiger: Lee on 10 November at his Sukhumvit Soi 24 condominium, Nattapong at Suvarnabhumi on 12 November, Chanon and Thanapat surrendering at Bang Rak on 18 November; Khaosod: Nattapong at Suvarnabhumi on 10 November, Chanon on 12 November, Tanaphat on 18 November, Lee last on 23 November); the record's original_date of 10 November matches only The Thaiger's disputed Lee arrest date; weapons null → 0 proposed (no weapon in any report; charges are robbery using a vehicle, unlawful detention and assault causing physical or mental harm); drugs_alcohol null → 0 proposed; Khaosod puts the cash at about $1,540 and the combined loss at more than $10,000; Nate gives 50,000 baht as about 2.3 million won and the crypto as about 350,000 baht, some 16 million won; Lee denies the charges and says the victim owed him money (the suspects' debt-collection claim); the verifier notes the two-hour hold in a car and car park also reads as Express Kidnapping; the OFF-CASE Thaiger flood dog-reunion link is a wrong article, not used.
## Needs owner decision
None in this batch.
+1
View File
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
{"sequence_changes": {}, "attempted_changes": {}, "parked": [], "owner": [495]}
+17
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
# Batch 34 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-01
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-34.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-34.json` and `sources/<id>_*.txt`. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Sequences are compared with the DB record's `scenario`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 496** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing in any of the three reports); attackers → three men in the house plus a fourth directing them by video call ('Four people planned this', Alan Edwards of Crimestoppers, via Decrypt; all thought to be in their twenties); location → Smith's Wood, Solihull kept (BBC and Decrypt; the Crimestoppers appeal says 'in Birmingham', noted); notes → the men also left with a number of high-value watches, in a car believed to be a black BMW X3; the husband suffered 'significant injuries', his pregnant wife was threatened with a knife; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (no amount, coin or watch value in any source); date 13 December 2025, about 17:20 GMT, kept; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown (detectives call it 'a planned and targeted attack'; no source says how the couple were identified); arrests none; status → Crimestoppers reward of up to £10,000 announced 24 September 2026 for information leading to arrest and conviction; source notes: Decrypt's CertiK figures and its 'just this week' attack, the BBC's crypto-crime links and DESIblitz's reward items are other material, not used.
- **DB id 494** (DA) — victim → the victim, identity not stated (the record's 'French man' is the accused: 'Un Français est soupçonné d'avoir participé à une violente agression', 20 minutes; no source gives the victim's name, age, sex or nationality); weapons → 0 and drugs_alcohol → 0 (none in the report; blows and tying up only); date → March 2025, day unknown (kept at month precision); attackers → one French national accused, arrested in Spain, extradited, in pre-trial detention at Orbe; he denies the aggravated robbery charge through his lawyer Xavier de Haller; attacker count not stated; description keeps the conditional ('aurait été attirée dans un piège, frappée, ligotée puis contrainte de donner accès à ses comptes'; accounts emptied of about 200,000 dollars, funds said to have passed through accounts linked to the accused); coin not named; sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept, no second label (where the victim was held is not stated); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown; arrests → some (one accused in custody); source notes: single 20 minutes item summarising a 24 heures article that was dead on retrieval; 'La Croisée prison' and the 13 April 2026 publication date are in the unverified site summary only, drop until 24 heures is retrieved; the 20 minutes tail on a Vaudois held near Valence is another case.
- **DB id 493** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing in either report); weapons stays 1 ('trois individus cagoulés et armés', Cryptoast; Journal du Coin does not say armed; no weapon type in either, as ruled for 126); description kept: three hooded men aged 19, 30 and 38 climbed the fence at about 5 a.m. on 29 September 2026 and fled when the perimeter alarm went off, never entering the house ('Le trio n'a jamais mis un pied dans la maison', Journal du Coin); nothing demanded or taken; mark 'motive not established' (the crypto motive is inferred by both outlets from the April attack; Journal du Coin: 'Aucun lien entre les deux expéditions n'a été établi officiellement à ce stade'), kept in the database as 96 was; link to DB 429 (11 April 2026 attack on the same family at Saint-Jean-de-Védas), repeat victimisation noted; sequence Dodged Attack kept with the attempted entry listed; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown; arrests → all three stopped shortly after, no charge reported; investigation with the Castelnau-le-Lez research brigade; source notes: both outlets credit Ouest-France as the only origin, add Ouest-France to the record when found; the Midi Libre and Cointelegraph details on the April attacker belong on 429; Cryptoast's ministerial and data-leak context and Journal du Coin's PNACO count and Taverny case are not used.
- **DB id 492** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (nothing in the account of this episode); money_wanted → 170,000 dollars in crypto transferred from two wallets to the organiser's wallet (7.06 million hryvnias), plus 130,000 dollars in cash collected the same afternoon from his flat, relatives, two friends and the Yevropark shopping centre (5.4 million hryvnias), plus a standing demand for half his business's monthly profit (368.media, from the case file); coin not named; attackers → four men: Oleksii Steshak, an officer of the 1st Assault Battalion, with Artem Havrylov, Andrii Hordieiev and Artem Faifor; weapons stays 1 (Steshak chambered a round and aimed the pistol; his unit's issue Fort-20 and AK-74 noted); sequence Kidnapping kept, Authority Misuse not applied (the law-enforcement legend and military-pattern uniform are the group's stated method, not described on 15 May; DEFINITIONS.md: not applied where the file does not show the role being used, as 397); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown (the group targeted people who trade crypto and addressed him by first name and patronymic; source of that knowledge not stated); arrests → all four taken on 12 October 2025, Steshak held without bail, no conviction; source notes: single source written from the prosecution's case materials (pre-trial); the article's second episode (Kharkiv, 10 October 2025, exchange on Nauky street, basement, about 83,620 USDT) matches DB 258 (Kharkiv, 10 October 2025, basement, 83,000 USDT), so link 258 and 492 as two victims of the same group; no new record.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 495** (owner) — Irvine, California, 23 September 2025, about 3:30 a.m.: intruders broke in, held two men at gunpoint with hands and mouths duct-taped, brought two women downstairs; a third woman locked herself in with her children and called 911; the intruders fled with her phone, found nearby; no crypto stolen.
- Settled (DA): violence_torture → 0, threat and restraint only (no blow, injury or treatment in the Orange County Register); drugs_alcohol → 0; money_wanted → $3.8 million in crypto, only as Davis's alleged account in court papers (Deputy DA Gerard Gully), not a demand; attackers → three intruders in the house, seven charged (Walker, Davis, Ware, Ford, Garner, Sin as alleged ringleader, Bonam-Hillman); arrests all, none convicted; sequence Home Invasion kept with the attempted crypto theft listed (control gained and the plan failed, as 113); kidnappings 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0 unchanged; targeting vector unknown (DA's office: 'The house was targeted'); CBS link dead and the DA's press release blocked, so the Register of 9 December 2025 is the only usable source; the Laguna Niguel burglary is a different incident.
- Question: theft flag for the phone. For 1: 'an intruder took her phone and ran out of the home with both of the other intruders', and all seven are charged with first-degree robbery in concert. For 0: 'No cryptocurrency was stolen during the takeover' (Irvine Police) and 'The phone was found nearby'. Same question as the Lamborghini in 188 (batch 32).
- DA recommendation: one rule for both cases; an item seized in passing and recovered at or near the scene sets theft 0 with a note, since the glossary's theft flag records whether the attackers achieved their financial objective.