feat(verify): DA triage of batches 12-34: 158 lines approved or parked, 60 cases escalated to owner; 4 sequences set

This commit is contained in:
StellarCrow
2026-10-01 11:42:07 +02:00
parent 967e69e8a1
commit e6e1f09aab
49 changed files with 1362 additions and 8 deletions
+35
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
# Batch 14 decisions — 2026-10-01
Triage of `batches/contradictions-14.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-14.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Case 57 is on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 60** (DA) — date → 16 January 2020 (LancsLive: "In January 2020" he had reached his withdrawal limit; the meeting was "on Sunday January 16"), conflict logged: 16 January 2020 was a Thursday and a Sunday 16 January fits 2022, so the year rests on the article's "In January 2020" (as with 108); location → Preston: the meeting was moved from the Travelodge in New Hall Lane to the Winckley Square apartments, paid for by Rahman, which the same report also calls "the hotel room"; he was let out of the car boot in Chorley; money_wanted → £20,000 demanded ("They said they knew he had £20,000"), his withdrawal limit was £10,000, nothing reported paid or transferred; coin_type stays empty (no coin named); attackers → four: Tasmina Rhaman, 21 (spelled Rahman in the later paragraphs), her 16-year-old cousin (machete), Takudzwa Murombedzi, 20 (balaclava), Albert Kahiya, 19 (driver); theft 1 rests on "his mobile phone taken from him" and the robbery pleas, no crypto reported taken; sequence was Malicious Invitation - SocialEng; now Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping (approached through a fake Snapchat profile, restrained in premises the attacker paid for, then driven around in a car boot; pre-selected, so Kidnapping under the rule of 2026-10-01); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; targeting vector = online lure (fake Snapchat profile; his success was "common knowledge"); arrests → convicted: Murombedzi and the 16-year-old pleaded guilty to robbery and conspiracy to kidnap (six years and five years, concurrent), Kahiya to conspiracy to kidnap (four years), Rahman to conspiracy to kidnap, sentencing set for 16 January; one source (LancsLive, two copies that match).
- **DB id 59** (DA) — location → Lucas area, along the Police Station axis of Abraka, Ethiope East local government area, Delta State (his residence); date January 2020 kept, day unknown (Vanguard's February 2020 report says "last month"; HeraldSheets dates the police confirmation of the arrests to 25 February 2020); money_wanted → $10,000 in BTC is the balance the attackers expected to find, per their confessional statements ("disappointed to find out that what was left when they struck was $400"), not a sum demanded of him; whether the $400 was taken is not stated; theft 1 rests on "They eventually left with the phone"; description keeps "shot dead", the suspects say they shot him twice "as he made an attempt to identify them while they were trying to open his account through his phone"; victim → Iroro Wisdom Ovie, father of two, PDP member; attackers → eight members of the Vikings confraternity named by police, four arrested including the victim's close friend and the local Vikings leader; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, beaten and held at his residence while they tried to open his account, clarification 1; violence_torture 1, a man shot dead as in 215, 102, 96; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 1; life_taken 1); targeting vector = leak from the victim's circle (his "bosom friend" told one suspect about the $10,000 in his Bitcoin wallet); arrests → some (four of eight in custody); sources: Vanguard and the HeraldSheets rewrite crediting Punch carry the same police-source quotes, so nothing is independently corroborated; HeraldSheets' closing safety advice not used.
- **DB id 55** (DA) — description "Man raided in office" → two masked men rang his office door late in the evening, forced him inside when he opened it, demanded money and cryptocurrency; he handed over cash and had to transfer cryptocurrency from his computer; they bound him with cable and duct tape and left him in the office; he freed himself and called police; notes → "armed with a pistol and a rubber truncheon" (the record omits the truncheon); victim → 30-year-old man; money_wanted "unknown" kept (ORF: "The amount is not yet known"); date 26 July 2019 kept, unverified on file (ORF says only "in the evening"); sequence Home Invasion kept (his office is his own space; the glossary's Home Invasion entry names an office, and the State Criminal Investigation Office called it the pattern of a home invasion); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, no blow or injury, he suffered shock; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 1; life_taken 0); outcome escaped (freed himself); held duration not stated; targeting vector = unknown; arrests none reported; the ORF page is the right one despite the WEAK anchor in auto-trim-review.md (the German original matches line for line); a follow-up report would be needed for the sum.
- **DB id 53** (DA) — money_wanted → 80 BTC (₹8 crore, $1.2 million per Newsweek) demanded for Luftan Shaikh and Mohammad Shazad, plus ₹10 lakh ($15,000) demanded from Malang Shah's family, both carried; coin_type → BTC (the ₹10 lakh demand names no coin); notes "two weeks" → held captive for 15 days in a flat in a high-rise building (the same report also says "more than two weeks"); victims → Luftan Shaikh, 19, Mohammad Shazad, 36, Malang Shah, 44 (Shah taken two days after the other two); attackers → seven arrested: Jitendra Kumar, Deepak Kumar, Anupam Soni, Pawan Kumar, Bhawani Singh, Lokendra Singh, Rahul Kumar; police found the flat after a suspect seen carrying a pistol in Bhakrota was caught; date 30 June 2019 kept, unverified on file (a Sunday, matching "the police operation on Sunday"; no calendar date printed in the report, and the captivity began about 15 days earlier); sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (lured by gang members "who claimed to be selling bitcoins at a low price", so the trade was the approach and P2P comes first, as 104 and 143; then held in the gang's flat); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 "beaten or tortured", drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 guns seized, theft 0 nothing reported paid, life_taken 0); outcome rescued; held duration days; targeting vector = trade lure (offer of cheap bitcoin), how the victims were found not stated; arrests some (seven); one source (Newsweek relaying the Hindustan Times and NDTV); the closing passage on a South African case not used.
- **DB id 52** (DA) — description kept ("Bitcoin millionaire escapes armed home invader by jumping off balcony"): on the afternoon of 14 May a man with a sawed-off shotgun forced his way into the apartment when the victim opened the door and said "Get down, or I'll shoot"; the victim ran onto the balcony and jumped from the second floor; "The robber did not get any valuables"; whether he was injured is unknown; victim → man in his 40s who has worked with cryptocurrency for nearly ten years, worth over 100 million kroner per his company's accounts; date 14 May 2019 kept (TV 2: "May 14 this year"); sequence was Home Invasion; now Dodged Attack, attempted: a home invasion of his Oslo apartment and armed robbery of his valuables at shotgun point (foiled attempt, as 147 and 84); kidnappings stays 0 (control never gained, he fled at once; clarification 3; DA call, owner may set 1); flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, threat only; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 0; life_taken 0); no crypto demand appears in the file, case kept on the victim's occupation (as 123); targeting vector = public profile (he "has previously appeared in public due to his success in making money with cryptocurrency"; the article does not link this to the attack); arrests → one man charged by the Oslo Public Prosecutor's Office, denies guilt, trial set for 17 and 18 October, arrest not stated; one source (TV 2, Norwegian original matches).
- **DB id 51** (DA) — weapons → 1 ("one threatened staff with a curved machete while the other smashed a Bitcoin machine off the shop wall with a sledgehammer"; the record's own notes already say machete); victim → staff of the Costcutter shop on St Leonard's Road, Far Cotton, Northampton (the Bitcoin machine was the target; Article 2: "threatened a shopkeeper with a machete"); date 12 March 2019 confirmed ("At around 8.30pm on Tuesday, March 12"); attackers → three masked men, one waiting outside; description → two went in, one held staff off with a machete while the other broke the machine off the wall, and they left on foot with it; amount in the machine not stated; sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept (glossary: armed robbery of a crypto ATM location, staff threatened); kidnappings stays 0 (staff threatened, no restraint or holding described; DA call as in 82, owner may set 1); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, threat only; drugs_alcohol 0; theft 1; life_taken 0); people were present and threatened, so the case is outside the disputed ATM group; targeting vector = unknown; arrests none reported; three copies of one police appeal on file, Article 2's sidebar teasers not used.
- **DB id 57** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
## Needs owner decision
### DB id 58 (owner) — Lørenskog, Anne-Elisabeth Hagen, 31 October 2018
TL;DR: wife of a property and energy investor vanished from home; ransom note, €9m in Monero demanded per Verdens Gang; by June 2019 police's main hypothesis is that she was killed and the kidnapping possibly staged.
Settled (DA): location → Lørenskog, about 20 km from Oslo; money_wanted €9m in Monero kept, sourced to Verdens Gang (police refused to confirm the sum, advised the family not to pay; nothing paid); life_taken 1 rests on lead investigator Tommy Brøske's "our main hypothesis has been modified – Anne-Elisabeth was killed", no body or arrest on file; violence_torture → unconfirmed (no assault described).
Question: does the case stay, and under what? For keeping: a ransom note and a Monero demand at a wealthy family's home. Against: no captivity was ever established ("unable to confirm that those people were holding Hagen"), police think the kidnapping was staged to disguise a murder, motive not established.
DA recommendation: keep, mark DISPUTED (as 171), kidnappings → unconfirmed, sequence Kidnapping kept as the police's first theory with the staging hypothesis as a gap.
### DB id 56 (owner) — Dehradun, Abdul Shakoor, 2019
TL;DR: alleged operator of a Rs 485 crore bitcoin investment scheme tortured to death in his rented house by five associates who wanted his account password.
Settled (DA): weapons → 0 (no weapon named: "beaten to death by five of his associates"); notes "pretending his wallet ... got hacked" → "allegedly told them that his bitcoin account had been hacked"; date 26 August 2019 unsupported on file (NDTV gives only "Thursday night" and "Friday"; keep, mark approximate); five arrested (unnamed), five more aides sought (Ashique, Arshad, Yasin, Rehaab, Muneef); kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, life_taken 1, theft 0 unchanged.
Question 1, inclusion: the victim is himself an alleged fraudster and the attackers his own associates chasing investors' money. DA recommendation: keep (crypto credentials extracted by torture is the attack the database records), targeting vector = business counterparty, gap noted.
Question 2, scenario: record Kidnapping; verified Home Invasion ("They arrived in Dehradun, where Shakoor had been living in a rented house, and pressured him for the password"; the only journey is his killers taking him to two hospitals afterwards). Entry method not stated. DA recommendation: Home Invasion, venue = victim's private space.
### DB id 54 (owner) — Birmingham, Bitcoin exchange, 15 July 2019
TL;DR: masked gang ransacked a Bitcoin exchange and tried to pull out its Bitcoin ATM with a rope tied to their car; police say nothing of value was stolen; nobody was confronted.
Settled (DA): theft → 0 ("confirmed that nothing of value was stolen from the business"); weapons → 0 (only "a rope attached to their car"); location → Birmingham (Sparkhill is in no source); description "hold up ... in front of dozens of witnesses" → raided and ransacked the building while witnesses looked on, then sped away; the cash motive is the owner Adam Gramowski's belief ("There are no BTC in the machine"); business name unresolved (URL slug "bitcoin-embassy", body "Bitcoin exchange"); the closing sentence on a February attack is another case.
Question: follow 158 (attempted ATM theft, nobody present, ruled Dodged Attack) or add the case to disputed group A (crypto ATM thefts with nobody confronted)? The list notes that the group decision should cover 158 too.
DA recommendation: add 54 to group A so one decision covers it with 57 and 158; until then Dodged Attack with the attempted ATM theft listed, as in 158.