Archived
feat(verify): DA triage of batches 12-34: 158 lines approved or parked, 60 cases escalated to owner; 4 sequences set
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
|
||||
# Batch 15 decisions — 2026-10-01
|
||||
|
||||
Triage of `batches/contradictions-15.md` under `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-15.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Case 45 is on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.
|
||||
|
||||
Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`.
|
||||
|
||||
## Approved (DA)
|
||||
|
||||
- **DB id 50** (DA) — victim → Bitcoin trader, identity withheld by police ("Police did not reveal the identity of the victim"); the record's "Tjeerd H." is in no source on file and is removed (restore only with a source); location → Drenthe, Netherlands (village not named; Drouwenerveen is in no source on file); date 10 February 2019 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the report gives no date for the raid); description → three robbers disguised as police entered his home, attacked him with a drill in front of his four-year-old daughter and threatened him with firearms during an hour-long ordeal, then fled in an escape vehicle; "it is not believed any cryptocurrency was stolen"; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (police disguise at the door, as 150); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, held an hour in his own home, clarification 1; violence_torture 1; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 0; life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests none reported, investigation ongoing (Northern Netherlands Police); one source (The Independent relaying De Telegraaf); the round-up tail (Richards 2015, Lerner 2017, Aston 2018) not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 48** (DA) — location → Soweto, Johannesburg ("The crime took place in Soweto"; Lanseria is the victim's home town); money_wanted → Bitcoin worth approximately 900,000 rand ($65,984) transferred, plus two mobile phones, two laptops and 3,000 rand in cash taken; coin_type → BTC; the sub-headline's "hundreds of thousands of dollars" contradicts the body and is not used (as with 216 and 111); weapons → 1 ("burned him with a hot iron"; the glossary counts other tools used as weapons, as the sand-filled glove in 86); victim "Andrew" kept as the article quotes it (may be a pseudonym), of Lanseria; date 16 November 2018 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate); attackers → five people at the second house, plus the man met on Facebook who invited him (whether he was among the five is not stated); sequence was Malicious Invitation - SocialEng; now Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping (invited to give a presentation at a private residence, knocked out with a chemical-soaked cloth, woke in a different house; taken to a place the attackers held, so Kidnapping); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); outcome released (dumped blindfolded at a roadside, in intensive care for burns); held duration not stated; targeting vector = online lure (met on Facebook, then in person); arrests not stated; single second-hand source (Finance Magnates relaying Soweto Urban), no police source; the round-up tail of the fetched page not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 44** (DA) — description "$250,000" → approximately 210,000 euros in cryptocurrency (both sources), transferred by one perpetrator, plus jewellery, gold coins, electronic devices and designer clothing; money_wanted 210,000 EUR kept; coin_type "eur" → cryptocurrency, coin not named (Unzensuriert: "access codes to his Bitcoin wallets"; CT-de: "various online exchanges"); victim → Turkish Bitcoin trader (Unzensuriert); his partner and their baby were also tied up in the bedroom; date 19 June 2018 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the reports cover the trial and place the attack in "the previous year"); attackers → five men tried for kidnapping, aggravated robbery, coercion and extortion, most confessed per their lawyers; mastermind a 21-year-old Upper Austrian who planned it with his father (tried separately); Unzensuriert: two Austrian main perpetrators hired three Chechens; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (fake postal workers at the door; 44 is named in the general ruling of 2026-09-30, so the writer's proposal to drop Authority Misuse is not taken); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, trader taped to a chair in a storage room; violence_torture 1, threatened with knives for an hour and a half, and Unzensuriert: wife "dragged by her hair and abused", threat to kidnap the nine-month-old; drugs_alcohol 0; weapons 1; theft 1; life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (one defendant "had apparently invested a five-digit sum with the robbed crypto trader and lost it" and called it debt collection); arrests → five on trial, verdict not on file; source notes: Unzensuriert has no URL in the sheet and is the sole source for the hair-dragging, the threat to the baby and the Chechen hires (find a URL); the CT-de page is this case despite the WEAK anchor, its closing round-up of two Russian cases not used.
|
||||
- **DB id 43** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("They proceeded to hold Synth and his wife against their will for 6 hours"); violence_torture → 1 ("they threatened, beat and robbed them"); theft → 1 ("only able to extract 18.88 Bitcoin and 6466 skycoins"); victim "Skycoin architect" → Skycoin CEO known as Synth, and his wife; attackers → nine individuals, members of Skycoin's China-based marketing team (per the company); location: the article places the marketing team in China and does not say where the home is; date 13 June 2018 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the only dates are the blog post of 18 June and press time 19 June); sequence was Kidnapping; now Home Invasion, attempted: theft of the design framework for the Skycoin ecosystem (held six hours in their own home, no relocation reported; the glossary keeps Kidnapping for victims moved elsewhere, as 176 and 197 were set to Home Invasion for the victim's own space); other flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, life_taken 0); outcome not stated; targeting vector = insider (the company's own marketing team); arrests not stated; single source, the company's own blog post relayed by Bitcoinist, no police statement, mark low-confidence (as 199).
|
||||
- **DB id 41** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("assaulted the two and tied their hands, locked them inside the room"); violence_torture → 1 ("assaulted and robbed two Asian brothers at gun point"); weapons → 1 (same quote); theft → 1 ("stole AED7m ($1.9m)"; the money was recovered and returned to the brothers); location → Al Muraqabbat, Dubai (a trading office the gang leader got the key to by posing as a buyer of the office); money_wanted → AED 7 million in cash brought to buy Bitcoin ($1.9m per Arabian Business), coin_type → cash (AED); attackers → gang of ten led by a Gulf national, six inside the office and the rest outside; date 25 April 2018 confirmed; sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → P2P Trade Gone Wrong (the gang "lured the two, claiming that they can sell Bitcoin", and engineered the meeting in an office obtained by deceiving its owner, so Malicious Invitation first, as ruled in 117); other flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); status → all ten arrested within 48 hours, money returned; held duration and how they got out not stated; targeting vector = trade lure, how contact was made not stated; source notes: Article 2 (byline Amira Agarib) has no URL in the sheet and is the sole source for the tied hands, the locked room and the deceived office owner (find a URL); the deceived office owner is a further victim with no field.
|
||||
- **DB id 45** — parked: disputed-scenarios list
|
||||
|
||||
## Needs owner decision
|
||||
|
||||
### DB id 49 (owner) — Witbank and Middelburg, Mpumalanga, May and August 2018
|
||||
TL;DR: one record holds two incidents by the same two suspects: a 13-year-old boy snatched near his Witbank home on 20 May 2018 and held for a ransom in bitcoin, and a failed attempt on a 13-year-old girl in Aerorand, Middelburg, on 21 August 2018.
|
||||
Settled (DA): date → 20 May 2018 (the record's 17 January 2019 is the TimesLive report date); description: the girl was "dragged into their vehicle" and escaped when "a group of people working nearby" came to her aid, not the police; money_wanted R1.5m in BTC kept ("ransom in the form of Bitcoins", "the equivalent of R1.5m"); theft → unconfirmed (police "had not disclosed whether any ransom had been paid"); attackers → two men aged 30 and 31 per the body (the caption says both 37), arrested in November (Germiston) and on 30 December (Ladysmith), bail R1,000 each; sequence Kidnapping → Dodged Attack kept (boy reunited unharmed days later; ransom note left for the parents, so Kidnapping); other flags unchanged.
|
||||
Question: split the 21 August 2018 attempt on the girl into its own record? For: different victim, date and town. Against: same suspects and one police statement, and the attempt is already carried as the attempted entry.
|
||||
DA recommendation: split, as the owner asked for 124's November 2021 incident; this record keeps the boy's kidnapping.
|
||||
|
||||
### DB id 46 (owner) — New York, Nicholas Truglia, 7 September 2018
|
||||
TL;DR: four friends allegedly escorted a drunk Truglia to his West 42nd Street apartment at 2:50 a.m., held his head underwater, punched him and threw hot wax on him for his crypto logins, and left about two hours later with his laptop, two phones and a thumb drive; the defence says he has recanted.
|
||||
Settled (DA): notes → laptop, two mobile phones and a thumb drive with his crypto account information (the iPhone and laptop allegedly returned); kidnappings → 1 as alleged (head held underwater, restrained); status → Orso, Leica, Dorn and David each charged with second-degree burglary, released without bail; complaint does not say whether any crypto was taken; targeting vector = acquaintance / friend.
|
||||
Question 1, scenario: record Malicious Invitation; verified Home Invasion. For Home Invasion: control taken and held in his own flat for about two hours. Against: no forced entry, they walked him in. For Malicious Invitation: no lure is described. DA recommendation: Home Invasion with the gap (entry by trust), and mark the case DISPUTED (recanted, defence audio given to the DA), as 171.
|
||||
Question 2, drugs_alcohol 1: rests on "after a night of drinking" and "a soused Truglia"; nothing says the men supplied the drink. DA recommendation: 0 (the writer proposed unconfirmed).
|
||||
|
||||
### DB id 42 (owner) — Milan, 22-year-old seller, 6 June 2018
|
||||
TL;DR: two men and a woman tried to pay for Bitcoin with a suitcase of counterfeit notes in an office rented for an hour on Viale Abruzzi; when he spotted it and tried to leave he was beaten and a blank pistol was fired; the woman fled with 50,000 euros from the earlier trade.
|
||||
Settled (DA): one victim, a 22-year-old (not "victims"); one earlier trade, 7 BTC for 50,000 euros in a bar in the Quadrilatero (not two); weapons 1 kept, the gun "later revealed to be a blank pistol" (as the imitation firearm in 136); theft 1: 50,000 euros in cash, no Bitcoin left his wallet, coin_type → cash (EUR); violence_torture 1 (broken nose, 14-day prognosis); attackers → a 33-year-old Serbian and a 35-year-old Cuban arrested, a woman fled; targeting vector = business counterparty (introduced through a Russian friend he often does business with); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept, attempted: the counterfeit payment.
|
||||
Question: kidnappings 0 → 1? For: "he closed his computer and tried to leave the room but was attacked", in an office the attackers rented (glossary: "prevented from leaving"). Against: not tied or locked in, minutes long, could read as an attack in passing (clarification 3).
|
||||
DA recommendation: 1 (stopped from leaving by force while the money was taken).
|
||||
|
||||
### DB id 40 (owner) — Miami, Ryan Rice, April 2018
|
||||
TL;DR: Rice and a companion brought $30,000 cash to buy Bitcoin from an unidentified dealer, handed the cash over in their car, then while escorting the dealer through a garage stairwell Marcarrous Clark grabbed at a backpack with the cash; Rice shot him; Clark is charged with strong-arm attempted robbery.
|
||||
Settled (DA): victims → Ryan Rice and an unidentified companion; date 11 April 2018 unsupported on file ("last week", "still hospitalized Monday"; keep, mark approximate); Clark hospitalised, condition unknown, no death; violence_torture 0, kidnappings 0 unchanged.
|
||||
Question 1, weapons 1: the only weapon is the victim's gun. 84 kept weapons 1 on the attackers' pepper spray, not on the victim's pistol. DA recommendation: 0, with the victim's firearm in notes.
|
||||
Question 2, theft and frame: the charge is attempted robbery, but Rice had handed over the $30,000 and the file never says whether the Bitcoin arrived or whether the dealer was in on it. DA recommendation: theft → unconfirmed; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Dodged Attack kept (as 189), gap: the dealer's role is not stated.
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user