# Batch 13 decisions (2026-10-01) Criteria: `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. Evidence: `batches/contradictions-13.md`, `batches/batch-13.json`, the dossiers in `sources/`. Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json`. ## Approved (DA) - **DB id 71** (DA) — scenario: a failed attempt just after 3 a.m. to take the Bitcoin ATM from the back wall of the closed Mike's Produce; nothing taken ("the suspects were unsuccessful in taking the Bitcoin ATM", Kelowna RCMP); sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Dodged Attack, attempted theft of the Bitcoin ATM (as ruled for 158; the group A decision in `disputed-scenarios.md` should cover this case with 158); victim → Mike's Produce (host of the ATM), with L&D Meats and Deli next door losing its front wall to the getaway truck; money_wanted → none (nothing taken); site summary: delete "Threats/intimidation" (no person appears in any account); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); attackers → two, not identified, white GMC Sierra; targeting vector = unknown (the machine, not a holder, was the target); arrests none; the Cointelegraph closing line about an earlier British Columbia ATM break-in is a different incident, not used. - **DB id 70** (DA) — description → three serving SBU Cyber Department officers seized a crypto-trading businessman near a pub on Mykhailivska Street, Kyiv, beat him and held him until his wife transferred 7 BTC ("Police" → "SBU officers"); notes → pushed into a Volkswagen T5, his iPhone and apartment keys taken, two officers used the keys to take two laptops and a tablet from his flat, beaten with blunt hard objects for about an hour and a half, driven to a forest near Parkova Road, then held unrecorded at the Shevchenkivskyi police department; money_wanted → $200,000 demanded (refused), lowered to $80,000; 7 BTC paid from the wife's wallet (the equivalent of $80,000 then); date 1 October 2020 kept (court ruling of 28 August 2021 as reported); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (real officers abusing their posts are in the glossary's Authority Misuse; held at a building the attackers control, as 93); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 on the blunt hard objects, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = not stated (the officers "had reliable information" that he held significant funds); arrests → three officers charged, under house arrest and suspended, involvement of eight officers examined, no conviction reported; outcome "released" is the nearest value (one account says how he got free is unclear); a false detention report for extradition was filed afterwards; ForkLog's closing line on a staged blogger kidnapping is a different incident, not used. - **DB id 69** (DA) — money_wanted → Bitcoin worth £6,000 at the time of the robbery plus £3,000 of grant money (mother: "nearly £10,000"); the record's £68,000 is the coins' value when The Sun wrote, keep only as a note; date → 2020, month not stated (the article says "last year" and "first week at university"; the record's September is unsourced; the article's own date is not on file, the copy is a Wayback snapshot of 26 September 2022); location → Canterbury, Kent (Canterbury Christ Church University accommodation); attackers → eight in the mother's account, three suspects refused charge per Kent Police; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (a new friend drew out his crypto holdings and, his mother alleges, invited eight friends who stormed his accommodation and held him at knifepoint for 20 minutes; as 197, and clarification 1 for the room); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0 with The Sun's "violent mugging" noted, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1 incl. a mobile phone, life_taken 0); targeting vector = acquaintance / friend (as 153, 179); arrests → none charged, case dropped after eight months on the evidential test; the friend's role is the mother's allegation, keep the hedge. - **DB id 68** (DA) — weapons → 1 ("robbed of approximately $800,000 in Bitcoin at gunpoint"); theft → 1 ("forced to transfer the funds to the attacker's wallet"); location → not stated (country UK rests on "a Bitcoin trader from the United Kingdom", which describes the trader, not the scene); date June 2020 kept (month only, per the paragraph); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); attackers → one, not identified; arrests → "later arrested and sentenced to ten years in prison", no name, court or jurisdiction given; targeting vector = business counterparty (arranged sale to a buyer); source: one paragraph in a crypto.ro round-up whose subject is the Boytsov robbery in Bali (Lerner and Meza paragraphs not used); pending: re-source before green (no primary report on file). - **DB id 67** (DA) — victim → residents of a family home in Irvington-on-Hudson; remove the name Ellis Pinsky and "hacker" (no source on file names the victims or uses the word; restore only if a source naming him is added); description → two men indicted for planning a night-time home-invasion robbery for cash and the code to what they believed was tens of millions of dollars in Bitcoin; no entry or contact took place; notes → "kidnap" → robbery plan; date → May 2020, 18 to 24 May (the indictment's conspiracy window; the record's 23 May falls inside it); location → Irvington-on-Hudson, Westchester County, NY (record's "Irvinton" misspelt); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted night-time home-invasion robbery; flags unchanged (all 0); attackers → Dominic Pineda and Shon Morgan, both 21, of Virginia; arrests → both arrested on 23 June and charged with conspiracy to commit Hobbs Act robbery (year of arrest not stated); targeting vector = unknown; one source (Daily Voice), the record's second link to the same page refused on fetch. - **DB id 64** (DA) — kidnappings → 1 (three men entered the home, one with a machete, forced the homeowner to transfer his Bitcoin, and a woman was "thrown into a bedroom": forced entry followed by beating or holding, clarification 1); victim → a man (the homeowner) and a woman in the home, relationship not stated (drop "siblings"); description → drop "$200,000" (no source); money_wanted → the homeowner's Bitcoin, worth "anywhere between £100,000 and £1.2m when stolen" per the court; 23.5 BTC later converted and seized as £109,601; coin_type → BTC; notes → one man armed with a machete, another struck the woman repeatedly on the head with a personalised Toblerone bar until it was covered in blood; the homeowner's Audi was taken; date 18 March 2020 kept (BBC); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → three men in the house, not identified, plus the accomplice who received the coins, named John Ross Rennie, 29, in one BBC report and John Ross D'Alfonso, 28, in the other (both noted; the record carries no attacker name); arrests → only the accomplice convicted, of reset, cleared of robbery and assault; the three raiders not reported caught; BBC sidebar links not used. - **DB id 61** (DA) — money_wanted → US$1 million in Bitcoin demanded; 1.4 million baht (S$62,400) in Bitcoin paid (AsiaOne: "more than $60,000", currency unstated); coin_type → BTC; date → January 2020, day unknown (the source gives only weekdays: arrival on a Thursday, report the next Friday, Lee arrested on the Sunday; the record's 8 January 2020 was a Wednesday); location → seized at a petrol kiosk on the way from Suvarnabhumi Airport, held at four places in forested areas and a hut in a paddy field, reported at Ongkharak Police Station, about 60 km from Bangkok; sequence was Kidnapping; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (an acquaintance allegedly persuaded him to fly in for a business deal and chose the stop; as 210 and 80); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → masked men, not identified; Kim Lee Yao Wei, first reported as a fellow hostage, named by Thai police as the alleged mastermind; targeting vector = acquaintance / friend (known through Bitcoin dealings); arrests → Lee arrested and charged; the masked men not; the actor said to own the car a person of interest; the account of the ordeal is Cheng's own (keep "allegedly", "Cheng claimed"); he was on bail on cheating charges in Singapore at the time. - **DB id 66** — parked: disputed-scenarios list - **DB id 62** — parked: disputed-scenarios list ## Needs owner decision ### DB id 63 (owner) TL;DR: two masked men with a starter pistol and a knife held two men in a Carlisle house in February 2020, moved money between their bank accounts and tried to open crypto exchange accounts in the victims' names to deposit £3,500. Settled (DA): kidnappings → 1 (both admitted two counts of false imprisonment); victim → two men (drop "couple"; the intended target was a third man living there); date → February 2020, day unknown; description → the exchange accounts were never authenticated (police alerted first), attempted £3,500 deposit; theft 1 on the games console, iPhone and moved cash; weapons 1 (starter pistol, knife); violence_torture 0; sequence Home Invasion kept; both convicted (six years nine months and six years). Question: does the case belong in the database? For removal: the court heard the house was targeted because Barrett believed a man living there caused a crash that injured his girlfriend; no cryptocurrency was held, demanded or obtained, and money_wanted and coin_type are null. For keeping: the attackers forced the victims to open crypto exchange accounts to launder the money, which Cumbria Police call a first before a UK court. DA recommendation: remove from the attack statistics (victims were not crypto holders and crypto was not the motive); if kept, flag it "crypto as laundering route only".