[ {"id": 1, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["public profile"], "quote": "one of the world's first bitcoin users", "reason": "The public profile test is met by a victim known as a crypto holder, and the text presents him as a noted early bitcoin user who was extorted for 1,000 bitcoin."}, {"id": 16, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["public profile"], "quote": "vocal in the Bitcoin scaling and hard-fork debate", "reason": "The text shows him as a publicly known Bitcoin figure, which is what the public profile test asks for; both motives he suggests run through that profile."}, {"id": 41, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The text states how the gang reached the brothers (they were looking for a bitcoin seller and the gang offered to sell), so a stated reason exists and unknown does not clearly pass better."}, {"id": 53, "field": "who_was_attacked", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["holder", "relative or partner"], "reason": "Owner's rule: family members who were not present were not attacked, and the text also says the families were unaware of the abduction."}, {"id": 53, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The text gives a stated route to the victims (traders drawn by a cheap bitcoin offer), so unknown does not clearly pass better than other."}, {"id": 69, "field": "approach", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["forced entry"], "quote": "eight men stormed his student accommodation and held him there at knifepoint", "reason": "The victim was not invited anywhere, so social invitation fails its test, while the text has the group storming his accommodation."}, {"id": 73, "field": "outcome", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["fought off"], "quote": "confessed to being engaged in a fight with the victims", "reason": "There was a physical fight with the victims, which rules out foiled, and the attackers then gave up and fled without the money."}, {"id": 86, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["social media"], "quote": "after seeing social media posts that suggested he had made", "reason": "The only stated selection reason is the social media posts; nothing shows the 14-year-old was otherwise publicly known as a crypto holder."}, {"id": 89, "field": "attack", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["Armed Robbery"], "quote": "sprayed an unknown liquid into his eyes before snatching his green bag", "reason": "Police say he was targeted and a three-man team with a getaway car used a spray on him, so the opportunistic test for Mugging fails and theft by force with a weapon fits."}, {"id": 114, "field": "outcome", "verdict": "keep", "value": "fought off", "reason": "The text never says the attacker gave up and fled; the victim hit him and then withdrew behind a locked door."}, {"id": 114, "field": "outcome", "verdict": "apply", "value": "escaped", "quote": "je suis rentré et je me suis enfermé à clé", "reason": "A physical struggle rules out foiled, and the victim ended it by his own action, going inside and locking the door while the attacker was not described as fleeing."}, {"id": 138, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["unknown"], "quote": "not named or otherwise described in the file", "reason": "Neither the summary nor the dossier states how these two victims were chosen, so other has no stated reason to rest on."}, {"id": 144, "field": "attack", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["Kidnapping", "Armed Robbery"], "reason": "Only a partner's Telegram post uses the word kidnapping; no text shows the two being taken away or held at a place the attackers controlled."}, {"id": 188, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["acquaintance", "surveillance"], "quote": "Missouri men stalked the family before the plot", "reason": "The file records a federal allegation that co-charged men stalked this family before the kidnapping, which meets the surveillance test."}, {"id": 203, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["public profile"], "quote": "a Dubai-based influencer and crypto entrepreneur", "reason": "The holder from whom the ransom was demanded is described as a crypto influencer and entrepreneur, which satisfies the public profile test."}, {"id": 209, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["correct"], "reason": "The crypto was sent by company executives and investigators, which does not show the victim held assets roughly as sought."}, {"id": 236, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["correct"], "reason": "The ransom was paid by a friend, which shows nothing about the couple's own holdings."}, {"id": 240, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["business counterparty"], "reason": "The attackers met him only through the arranged trade itself; no prior trade, investment or dispute is described."}, {"id": 263, "field": "who_was_attacked", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["holder", "relative or partner"], "reason": "Owner's rule: the family was not present and was reached only through forced calls, so it was not attacked."}, {"id": 358, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["correct"], "quote": "which he was coerced into transferring to the South Korean's account in two transactions", "reason": "Crypto was transferred from the victim's own holdings, which is the test for correct."}, {"id": 370, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["correct"], "quote": "ultimately transferred about US$1.6 million in cryptocurrency before fleeing", "reason": "About US$1.6 million in crypto was taken from the holder, which shows he held assets roughly as sought."}, {"id": 397, "field": "who_was_attacked", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["holder"], "quote": "allegedly extorted cryptocurrencies and cash worth over Rs 155 crore (US$22 million) at gunpoint from Dhaval Mavani and Piyush Savaliya of BitConnect", "reason": "The text has him as a person the crypto and cash were extorted from, and nowhere calls him an employee."}, {"id": 397, "field": "obtained", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["unconfirmed"], "quote": "Neither article says anything was obtained from Savaliya.", "reason": "The sources do not say whether anything was taken from him, which is the test for unconfirmed; nothing requires the text to show nothing was taken."}, {"id": 402, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["wealth overestimated"], "reason": "The only support is the victim's own denial to his attackers, and one source says the victims had none or refused access, so his holdings are not shown."}, {"id": 408, "field": "approach", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["Social Engineering: social invitation", "seized in the street or a public place"], "reason": "The seizure outside the restaurant followed a planned lure, and the public-place label requires no deception."}, {"id": 424, "field": "outcome", "verdict": "keep", "value": "rescued", "reason": "The text does not say whose helicopter it was or that anyone reached the house before the two men left."}, {"id": 447, "field": "outcome", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["rescued"], "quote": "Neighbours who heard her screaming confronted the group, which abandoned the attempt and scattered", "reason": "She had been seized and dragged by force, so the attackers had control of her, and they fled because other people arrived."}, {"id": 451, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["public profile"], "reason": "The son is described as a well-known influencer, but no text shows he was known as a crypto holder or how the attackers chose the family."}, {"id": 453, "field": "targeting", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["public profile", "surveillance"], "quote": "the financial businessman known as CryptoSpain", "reason": "The text shows him as a publicly known crypto figure, which satisfies the public profile test alongside the stated surveillance."}, {"id": 454, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["correct"], "reason": "The 14,000 euros came after he was forced to ask his partner and a friend for funds, so the transfers do not show his own holdings."}, {"id": 456, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["correct"], "quote": "the criminals obtained a transfer of R$15,000 in cryptocurrency", "reason": "Crypto was transferred from the victim's own funds, which is the test for correct, and the text does not say what larger sum the attackers believed he held."}, {"id": 457, "field": "approach", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The text does describe how the intruders came at the house (violent banging on the door at night), so unknown does not clearly pass better."}, {"id": 463, "field": "who_was_attacked", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["holder", "other"], "quote": "A third man travelling with them escaped during the initial attack", "reason": "A companion who was present and had to escape the initial attack was among those confronted."}, {"id": 468, "field": "attack", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["no label fits"], "quote": "nothing in the file describes anyone entering on him, confronting him or holding him", "reason": "No text shows occupants confronted or held at home, and no other attack label is supported."}, {"id": 468, "field": "outcome", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["unknown"], "quote": "no cause of death had been established", "reason": "Killed requires a death resulting from an attack, and the file leaves accident, suicide and homicide all open."}, {"id": 470, "field": "approach", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["unknown"], "quote": "Whether the men crossed the threshold is not stated.", "reason": "The text gives no description of how the first team came at the house, so neither force nor a break-in is shown."}, {"id": 472, "field": "approach", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The text does say how they meant to get in (a crowbar and a man tasked with opening the door), so unknown does not clearly pass better."}, {"id": 473, "field": "approach", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The text describes four men with crowbars attempting to break into the home, so unknown does not clearly pass better."}, {"id": 492, "field": "approach", "verdict": "apply", "value": ["seized in the street or a public place", "Authority Misuse: fake police or official"], "quote": "they were employees of a law-enforcement structure, with military-pattern uniform", "reason": "The case file gives posing as law-enforcement staff as the group's cover story for these seizures, which meets the fake police or official test."}, {"id": 493, "field": "approach", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The text says the three climbed the property fence before the alarm drove them off, so the way they came is described and unknown does not clearly pass better."}, {"id": 497, "field": "targeting_accuracy", "verdict": "keep", "value": ["unknown"], "reason": "The robbers demanded cash and the shop had none on site, which fits wealth overestimated at least as well as unknown."} ]