{"key": "L329", "status": "out of scope", "duplicate_of": null, "duplicate_evidence": "", "scope_reason": "A murder under investigation with no crypto motive stated: police obtained his crypto futures trading records as part of the inquiry, but the article does not say he was attacked or chosen as a crypto holder, or that any crypto was taken. Passage: 'police obtained a four-year record through the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) of Ali’s involvement in “futures trading” of cryptocurrency on trading platform Binance.'", "new_sources_for_existing": [], "pages": [ {"file": "work/articles/L329-1.txt", "keep": "", "reason": "Cloudflare check page ('Just a moment...'), empty"}, {"file": "work/articles/L329-2.txt", "keep": "1-25", "reason": "web.archive.org copy of the Dawn article, all paragraphs are the article"} ], "values": {"date": "July 28, 2026", "victim": "Mir Raza Ali", "location": "Gulistan-i-Jauhar, Karachi", "country": "Pakistan", "description": "Mir Raza Ali, a 25-year-old Karachi businessman who traded crypto futures on Binance, went missing on July 28 and was found dead the next day with a gunshot wound to the back; the case was registered as kidnapping, a murder charge was added, and a second post-mortem ruled out suicide.", "summary": "Mir Raza Ali, a 25-year-old businessman in Karachi, went missing on July 28, 2026, and his body was found the next day in Gulistan-i-Jauhar with a gunshot wound. The case was registered at Ferozabad police station under kidnapping charges; police at first built it around suicide, and his family accused them of trying to bury the facts. After a court ordered his body exhumed, a second post-mortem found that he died of a firearm wound entering through his back and that the findings were inconsistent with suicide, and a murder charge was added. In September police said they had obtained four years of records of his crypto futures trading on Binance through the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency. A judicial commission is examining the investigation. No arrests are reported and no source links the killing to his crypto.", "case_details": "**Victims:** Mir Raza Ali, 25, businessman. Police obtained through the NCCIA a four-year record of his 'futures trading' of cryptocurrency on Binance; his friend Abdul Hasem told the judicial commission that he and Ali used to trade crypto and that Ali 'was doing well'.\n\n**Attackers:** Not identified in the source.\n\n**Attack Method:** Not described. 'Ali’s body was found a day after he went missing on July 28.' He 'was found dead with a gunshot wound in Gulistan-i-Jauhar in July.' The case was registered at Ferozabad Police Station 'under charges of kidnapping'; a murder charge was later added to the FIR.\n\n**Violence Used:** Detention unconfirmed: the kidnapping charge is the only sign that he was held; the source does not describe it. Second post-mortem: 'Death occurred due to cardiac rupture consequent to perforating firearm injury of the chest', entry wound on the back; 'The findings are inconsistent with suicide as the manner of death.'\n\n**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Nothing reported demanded or taken. Police sought NCCIA help to retrieve his 'digital records/WhatsApp account details' to ascertain anything suspicious.\n\n**Status:** Investigation moved to Zaman Town police station with a reconstituted team; a single-member judicial commission chaired by SHC Justice Omar Sial is examining the investigation and possible negligence. No arrests reported. Source: Dawn, September 9, 2026 (web.archive.org copy).", "detention": "unconfirmed", "violence_torture": "yes", "drugs_alcohol": "unconfirmed", "weapons": "yes", "theft": "unconfirmed", "life_taken": "1", "venue_of_control": "", "held_duration": "", "arrests": "", "demanded_amount": null, "demanded_currency": null, "demanded_usd_stated": null, "demanded_as_stated": "no demand reported", "taken_amount": null, "taken_currency": null, "taken_usd_stated": null, "taken_as_stated": "nothing reported taken", "targeting": ["Unknown"], "targeting_accuracy": "Unknown", "who_was_attacked": ["Holder"], "approach": ["Unknown"], "attack": ["Kidnapping"], "outcome": "Killed", "obtained": ["Unconfirmed"], "people": [{"role": "Holder", "people": 1, "at_least": 0, "detail": "the 25-year-old businessman found shot dead"}], "sources": ["https://www.dawn.com/news/2028618"], "name_withheld": 0}, "support": { "date": "Ali’s body was found a day after he went missing on July 28.", "detention": "where the case was registered under charges of kidnapping", "violence_torture": "found dead with a gunshot wound in Gulistan-i-Jauhar in July", "drugs_alcohol": "his death was caused by a gunshot wound to the back", "weapons": "perforating firearm injury of the chest", "theft": "police had sought the NCCIA’s expertise to retrieve Ali’s “digital records/WhatsApp account details” to ascertain anything suspicious", "life_taken": "who was found dead with a gunshot wound", "taken_amount": "police had sought the NCCIA’s expertise to retrieve Ali’s “digital records/WhatsApp account details”", "targeting: Unknown": "Ali’s body was found a day after he went missing on July 28.", "targeting_accuracy": "Hasem said he had left the trading after sustaining losses while Ali was doing well.", "who_was_attacked: Holder": "Ali’s involvement in “futures trading” of cryptocurrency on trading platform Binance", "approach: Unknown": "Ali’s body was found a day after he went missing on July 28.", "attack: Kidnapping": "where the case was registered under charges of kidnapping", "outcome": "The findings are inconsistent with suicide as the manner of death.", "obtained: Unconfirmed": "to ascertain anything suspicious", "people: Holder": "25-year-old businessman Mir Raza Ali" }, "open_points": [], "notes": "Single source: Dawn (September 9, 2026), original reporting from an anonymous police official, the judicial commission hearings and the post-mortem report; loaded only as a web.archive.org copy (raw retrieval hit a Cloudflare check). Date: he went missing on July 28 and the body was recovered on July 29; the year comes from the article's publication date in the page header (precedent L049). Location: the body was found in Gulistan-i-Jauhar, Karachi; Lopp's PECHS is not in the text. Scope out: no crypto motive is stated and nothing was reported taken. Attack Kidnapping rests only on the FIR charge; the abduction is not described, so detention, drugs and theft are unconfirmed (text too thin), and approach and targeting Unknown. Weapons yes: firearm wound. Arrests left empty: the article reports none and does not say whether anyone is held. The case was first treated as suicide by police; the second post-mortem rules that out.", "lopp_differences": ["Lopp: 'owner of a dessert shop'; the article calls him a 25-year-old businessman and does not mention a dessert shop.", "Lopp: disappeared 'from Karachi's PECHS neighborhood' and body found 'in bushes near a wedding hall'; the article says only that he was found dead in Gulistan-i-Jauhar.", "Lopp: 'a second autopsy concluding he had been tortured before being shot'; the article quotes the second post-mortem on the gunshot wound and the ruling-out of suicide, with no mention of torture.", "Lopp: 'six months of Binance data'; the article says a four-year record."]}