# Batch 22 decisions (2026-10-01) Cases 462 to 453. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/contradictions-22.md`, `batches/batch-22.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json` (no new label changes are made in these decisions). ## Approved (DA) - **DB id 462** (DA) — amount: R$750,000 kept (Livecoins body), about R$800,000 noted (ACidade ON, from the police inquiry); drop "(~135,000 USD)" (the record's own conversion) and Livecoins' headline "US$ 750 mil"; description: "escorted the victim to a regular vehicle" → handcuffed and put in the back seat of an unmarked car (Livecoins) or in the boot (ACidade ON), both noted; location → hotel in Ribeirão Preto, driven to Cravinhos where the transfer was forced (ACidade ON); attackers → two men in Polícia Civil clothing; the one arrested is named by Livecoins as Matheus Vinícius de Jesus dos Santos, ACidade ON says the identities were not released; violence_torture null → 0 (no assault described); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (owner, 2026-10-01: routine followed on social media); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1: empty gun case in the boot, the man said the gun was under the seat, the driver exchanged fire with police; theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration not stated; targeting vector = social media (police: the pair followed his routine through his posts); arrests: one arrested, the driver escaped after a shootout in Pirassununga; source notes: url_2 is a YouTube video, not transcribed. - **DB id 461** (DA) — no correction: record and article agree on date, time, place, victims' ages and the demand for a "cryptocurrency ledger"; sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: Armed Robbery in Public Space; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1: "three armed men", theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: none, Crime Stoppers bulletin of 9 July with stills, reward up to $3,500; source notes: the site summary's "at gunpoint" and "EUR 0 obtained" are not in the file and should not be published; the x.com link is the police bulletin itself (Hoodline quotes it); Hoodline's wrench-attack background not used. - **DB id 460** (DA) — money_wanted: "$4.9M to $5M" → US$5 million (about Rp 90 billion) per the victim's Instagram interview reported by Bali Discovery; police have released no figure ("Police have yet to share the amount of money lost"); notes: drop "Villa Ukulele" (Bali Discovery does not name the villa) → the attackers took his villa keys from his motorcycle, entered his rented villa and took a second phone; victim: "Artem I." kept with attribution: police identify him only as AI, 41; the name Artem Ivanov comes from the Instagram interview via KOMPAS and NusaBali; weapons null → unconfirmed (police are considering "armed robbery" among the charges; no weapon described); drugs_alcohol → 0; held about 30 hours, dumped at about 4 a.m. on 4 July outside Udayana University Hospital; sequence Kidnapping kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: none, the black Nissan Serena identified; source notes: url_3 (CoinDesk) and url_5 (Yahoo) syndicate BeInCrypto; the victim's account is unverified per The Bali Times. - **DB id 459** (DA) — victim: remove "Stephanie Mau-Asum and Astrid Robinson" (no source names either woman) → two foreign women, from the Netherlands and Venezuela (Geo News, Abb Takk) or the Netherlands and Spain (Daily Pakistan, ProPakistani), both noted; description: two accounts kept side by side: the FIR (invited by Muhammad Raza Dar, visas arranged, taken at gunpoint on arrival in Lahore on 29 June to a house in Y-Block, Defence) and DIG Faisal Kamran (voluntary travel after meeting the main suspect in Singapore, joint travel to Islamabad and Murree, then a house rented for the purpose and an abduction to recover money he claimed he was owed; a staged kidnapping with the main suspect posing as a victim); date 29 June 2026 kept (ProPakistani: "alleged abduction on June 29"; police informed 2 July); notes: "recovered within ~2 hours" → rescued within two hours of the father's call to the 15 helpline, not of the abduction; arrests → four arrested (ProPakistani), five held per the Geo News headline and five named in the FIR, both noted; five-day physical remand; money_wanted → $1.5 million (about Rs450 million) ransom, nothing paid; coin_type → empty (the crypto is the investment in dispute, nothing transferred); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (held at a house in Y-Block, Defence); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); gap: sexual violence (rape alleged, medical reports awaited) has no violence category; targeting vector = business counterparty (crypto investment partnership, profit dispute). - **DB id 457** (DA) — notes: drop "The plate led investigators to the same four men" (no source says so; Cryptopolitan: the plate "podría ser la clave", Journal du Coin: the four arrested that weekend are suspected of orchestrating the whole expedition); description: "four individuals" → intruders, number not stated, who banged violently on the door at about 3 a.m.; the family barricaded themselves in and the intruders fled before police arrived, leaving only their registration; date 13 June 2026 kept (La Provence and Journal du Coin "samedi 13 juin"; Cryptopolitan's "sábado 14 de junio" is the wrong weekday, 13 June 2026 was the Saturday); victim → the parents; the target was an absent son who made crypto gains and sold his holdings more than a year earlier (La Provence, Cryptopolitan); weapons null → 0 (none described; the intruders never reached the occupants); money_wanted: nothing demanded on record, crypto is the presumed motive; sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: Home Invasion, and extortion of crypto the absent son no longer held (La Provence); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (investigators believe out-of-date information); arrests: some, four men arrested over the night's addresses, roles not established; linked to 458. - **DB id 456** (DA) — applies the owner's rulings of 2026-09-30 (drug network claim, pistol-whipping and "as of June 16" removed; two attacker vehicles; same-owner São Paulo plates); amount: R$15,000 (Military Police, Lt Tavares) and 3,700 USDT, about R$20,000 (Serra Noticiário), both noted; drop "(~$3,000 USD)" (no source); coin_type → USDT per Serra Noticiário, transfer details unresolved; description: "from his Porsche 718 ... by three armed men" → two of about eight armed men (the victim's account) took him out of his Porsche and forced him into the Celta; drop "718" (no source gives the model); notes: located 40 minutes after the abduction (A Tribuna), one hour (A Gazeta) or hours (Sim Notícias follow-up), all noted; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Costly Fame; now Costly Fame → Kidnapping (owner, 2026-10-01); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 on A Tribuna's resident-sourced line, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = public profile (victim's belief, not established); arrests: one 25-year-old detained in Jardim Carapina, his part to be confirmed after statements; source notes: seizure reported as two pistols, one magazine and five phones (Serra Noticiário, preliminary) or three magazines (the other four pieces). - **DB id 455** (DA) — theft 0 → 1 (gold chain with pendant, R$3,500 cash, documents and phone taken, plus five life vests and a ball per the second piece; only the Bitcoin extortion failed; as 153); coin_type → BTC (keys demanded), the property list moves to notes; money_wanted → access keys to his Bitcoin, no amount; date 15 October 2019 kept ("Esse caso ocorreu no dia 15 de outubro de 2019"), the same piece's opening "Em dezembro de 2019" noted; description: add how it ended: escaped from the boot at the Cemetron hospital car park and ran to the guards (third piece), or abandoned in the street after hours of driving (second piece), both noted, outcome escaped per the fuller account; attackers: three hooded armed men got out of the red car, or one armed man (another passage), both noted; organiser Elcione José Sales, a municipal traffic officer and his friend of over twenty years; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (taken from the friend's house to scrubland, a motel and a car boot); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); held more than twelve hours (third piece); targeting vector = acquaintance (friend of twenty years); arrests: Elcione (20 years) and Helton dos Santos Moura (16 years) sentenced in 2021, a third defendant acquitted, a fourth man arrested in Florianópolis on "segunda-feira (15)", not named by Livecoins; the site summary's "Valdinei Dias dos Santos per court records" and 15 June 2026 have no source; threats after the release to make him drop the complaint noted. - **DB id 454** (DA) — description: "to a garage" → shut in a room with five men (Journal du Coin, ICI, Orange: "une pièce"); notes: funds collected from his partner and a friend (ICI, Journal du Coin) or his partner and friends (Orange), both noted; money_wanted / coin_type → 14,000 euros in three crypto transfers, coin not named; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1: blade, handgun shown, bolt cutters, theft 1, life_taken 0); held from shortly before 11 a.m. to about 9.30 p.m.; targeting vector = acquaintance / tip-off (he recognised the name of a Thann second-hand car dealer who knew he invested in crypto); arrests: four men aged 29 to 44 charged and remanded on 3 June (five were in the room); source notes: Cryptoast's Moroccan sentencing paragraphs not used. - **DB id 453** (DA) — date → August 2025, day unknown (Demócrata: "las 03.00 horas del pasado lunes", no report date on file; police: investigation opened in August 2025); amount: two inventories kept side by side: police (1.5 million euros in watches and jewellery, 200,000 euros cash, 1.3 million euros crypto transfer) and Romillo's complaint per Demócrata (210,000 euros cash, jewellery, more than 30 watches worth over half a million euros, 20 gold coins worth 60,000 euros); attackers: five masked armed men "de origen latinoamericano" coached by a sixth by phone (Demócrata); the Tren de Aragua attribution is the Policía Nacional's, from the arrest of six over three robberies in May 2026; victim name kept with attribution: Demócrata names Romillo, Infobae via "fuentes cercanas a la investigación", the police release names no one; drugs_alcohol → 0 (the MDMA and ketamine were seized at the suspects' homes); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); held nearly five hours, freed themselves about 7 a.m.; targeting vector = surveillance (police: the cell selected people of high purchasing power and watched them first); the attackers' claim to be hired to recover money he was accused of stealing noted; arrests: all six identified members detained, three remanded; source notes: the shot to the face happened at a holiday flat in one of the other two robberies, not here; the site summary's age 40, the 260 to 300 million euro figure and Madeira Invest Club have no source on file. ## Needs owner decision ### DB id 458 (owner) TL;DR: on the night of 13 June 2026 several men held two women, one in her sixties, in a Gignac-la-Nerthe villa to make them transfer a relative's crypto; police caught them mid-transaction and arrested four. Settled (DA): description "Four suspects broke into" → several men entered; four arrested; notes "all four arrested on the spot" → four arrested during the sequestration (La Provence), whether every intruder was taken is not stated; date 13 June 2026 kept (Cryptopolitan's "sábado 14" is the wrong weekday); violence_torture → 0 ("saines et sauves"); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed ("braquage" only in La Provence's headline); theft 0 → unconfirmed (surprised "en pleine transaction", no amount or completed transfer reported); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings 1, life_taken 0 unchanged; targeting vector = unknown (chosen for a relative's crypto gains); arrests: all four arrests rest on Cryptopolitan's "los cuatro hombres que retenían a dos mujeres"; linked to 457. Question: Journal du Coin describes a series of three attacks or attempts that night; La Provence places the expedition "entre Marseille, Gardanne et Gignac" and Cryptopolitan names Gardanne as a further attack. No record on file covers Gardanne. Open a record for it? DA recommendation: yes, once a source describing the Gardanne incident itself is found; the file has only the mention.