[ { "id": 24, "kind": "flag check: change the first reader missed", "field": "violence_torture", "proposed": "threat only", "quote": "pulled out a silver handgun and pointed it at Dallas", "detail": "a shot struck a stove vent and no one is reported hit or injured, so no physical violence against a person is reported; weapon pointed and fired is a threat" }, { "id": 66, "kind": "flag check: change the first reader missed", "field": "life_taken", "proposed": "0", "quote": "names nobody who was held, threatened or hurt", "detail": "no death is reported anywhere in the record, so the 'unconfirmed' test (a death reported and not established) is not met; outcome is 'nobody held or hurt'" }, { "id": 91, "kind": "flag check: change the first reader missed", "field": "weapons", "proposed": "yes", "quote": "the conviction under Article 162 is rendered in the release as \"armed robbery\"", "detail": "FLAG-RULES.md says 'armed robbery' in the reporting is enough for weapons yes; the first reader left it unconfirmed on the strength of the Russian original, which the rules do not ask to be preferred" }, { "id": 139, "kind": "flag check: change rejected by the second reader", "field": "violence_torture", "proposed": "threat only", "quote": "fearing physical harm, transferred $50,000", "detail": "the article says only that the six threatened them to transfer crypto and that they feared being harmed; no threat of harm is quoted or reported, so the text does not establish a threat against the person (the first reader calls it the weakest change)" }, { "id": 170, "kind": "flag check: change rejected by the second reader", "field": "violence_torture", "proposed": "threat only", "quote": "threatening severe repercussions if their demands were not met", "detail": "the dossier only says 'severe repercussions' and a threat to plant drugs and hand him to police; no threat of physical harm is reported, and the first reader flags this as weak" }, { "id": 188, "kind": "flag check: change the first reader missed", "field": "theft", "proposed": "no", "quote": "Nothing was obtained from the couple.", "detail": "the text says nothing was obtained and no ransom was paid; unconfirmed applies only when the text does not say whether anything was taken" }, { "id": 188, "kind": "flag check: change rejected by the second reader", "field": "theft", "proposed": "yes", "quote": "They also recovered the abandoned Lamborghini from a wooded area.", "detail": "the dossier says the Lamborghini was rammed and later found abandoned in woods, and the text states nothing was obtained from the couple; a car recovered abandoned is not clear evidence the attackers got it, so yes is not supported" }, { "id": 255, "kind": "flag check: change rejected by the second reader", "field": "violence_torture", "proposed": "threat only", "quote": "held the wife and son at gunpoint", "detail": "the state charges include three counts of first-degree assault during a burglary with a firearm per brother, which raises physical violence without the articles describing it; that is the unconfirmed case, so the current value stands" } ]