{"key": "L079", "status": "new", "duplicate_of": null, "duplicate_evidence": "", "scope_reason": "", "new_sources_for_existing": [], "pages": [ {"file": "work/articles/L079-1.txt", "keep": "1-18, 39-40", "reason": "Jiaocheng court public-education piece on thepaper.cn: introduction, case facts and judgment. Cut: the quoted statute text and doctrine on criminal preparation (19-38), which carry no fact about the case."} ], "values": {"date": "April 26, 2022", "victim": "Mr. Ruan", "location": "Ningde, Fujian", "country": "China", "description": "Two men recruited a team to seize 20 million Tether from a man surnamed Ruan in Ningde, planning to pose as epidemic-prevention workers and take him away; two recruits warned the victim and helped police arrest both organisers. Each was sentenced to 1 year 10 months for robbery at the preparation stage.", "summary": "In late December 2021 a man surnamed Zhou recruited a man surnamed Li and others through a foreign chat app to rob a man surnamed Ruan in Ningde, Fujian, of 10 million Tether by violence or coercion. They bought restraint straps, tape and gloves and scouted near Ruan's home, but Zhou called the plan off. In late April 2022 Zhou contacted Li again to seize 20 million Tether from Ruan. On April 26 Li and two recruits, surnamed Tang and Dai, were driven from Fuzhou to Ningde in a car Zhou arranged. The group scouted Ruan's home again and planned to pose as epidemic-prevention workers to seize or trick him and take him elsewhere to demand the Tether. Tang and Dai had joined only to claim a reward for reporting a crime. On April 27 they warned Ruan and helped police arrest Li in Jiaocheng district; Zhou was arrested the same day. The Jiaocheng court convicted both of robbery at the preparation stage and sentenced each to 1 year 10 months and a fine of 2,000 yuan.", "case_details": "**Victims:** A man surnamed Ruan (阮某某) in Ningde, said to hold a large amount of virtual currency ('二男子得知他人拥有大量虚拟币').\n\n**Attackers:** Defendants Zhou (周某), the organiser, and Li (李某某), who recruited the team for the second attempt, Li having a prior record. Recruits Tang (唐某某) and Dai (代某某) '为获取举报犯罪赏金,假意加入' (joined in pretence to obtain a reward for reporting the crime). Recruited through a foreign chat app ('境外聊天软件').\n\n**Attack Method:** Planned, never carried out. First attempt, end of December 2021: aim '劫取1000万“泰达币”', tools 约束带、透明胶带、手套, scouting near the victim's home; Zhou stopped it on hearing others planned to cut him out. Second attempt, end of April 2022: aim '劫取2000万“泰达币”'; on 26 April Li, Tang and Dai came from Fuzhou to Ningde in a car arranged by Zhou; they scouted near the home and planned '伪装成防疫人员以挟持或诱骗的方式,将阮某某带到他处索要“泰达币”'.\n\n**Violence Used:** No detention: the attackers never reached the victim. Items seized and confiscated: 手套、电击棒、透明胶带、防护面罩、口罩、绑带; the stun baton (电击棒) was never used on anyone.\n\n**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Planned seizure of 20 million Tether (10 million in the December plan). Nothing taken.\n\n**Status:** On 27 April 2022 Tang and Dai warned Ruan and helped police arrest Li in Jiaocheng district; Zhou was arrested the same day in the Dongqiao Economic Development Zone. The Jiaocheng court found robbery (抢劫罪) at the preparation stage (犯罪预备) and sentenced each to 1 year 10 months and a fine of RMB 2,000.", "detention": "no", "violence_torture": "no", "drugs_alcohol": "no", "weapons": "no", "theft": "no", "life_taken": "0", "venue_of_control": "none", "held_duration": "none", "arrests": "convicted", "demanded_amount": 20000000, "demanded_currency": "USDT", "demanded_usd_stated": null, "demanded_as_stated": "planned seizure of 20 million Tether (10 million in the December 2021 plan)", "taken_amount": null, "taken_currency": null, "taken_usd_stated": null, "taken_as_stated": "nothing taken", "targeting": ["Surveillance"], "targeting_accuracy": "Unknown", "who_was_attacked": ["Holder"], "approach": ["Authority misuse: fake police or official"], "attack": ["Kidnapping"], "outcome": "Foiled", "obtained": ["Nothing"], "people": [{"role": "Holder", "people": 1, "at_least": 0, "detail": "a man surnamed Ruan, the planned target"}], "sources": ["https://m.thepaper.cn/baijiahao_23018419"], "name_withheld": 0}, "support": { "date": "同月26日,被告人李某某与招募来的唐某某、代某某乘坐由被告人周某安排的车辆从福州市区来到宁德市区", "detention": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "violence_torture": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "drugs_alcohol": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "weapons": "扣押在案的手套、电击棒、透明胶带", "theft": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "life_taken": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "venue_of_control": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "held_duration": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "arrests": "被告人周某犯抢劫罪,判处有期徒刑一年十个月", "demanded_amount": "劫取2000万", "taken_amount": "于同月27日告知阮某某有人意图劫取其财物", "targeting: Surveillance": "到被害人阮某某住所附近踩点", "targeting_accuracy": "二男子得知他人拥有大量虚拟币", "who_was_attacked: Holder": "准备通过暴力、胁迫的方式从阮某某处劫取2000万", "approach: Authority misuse: fake police or official": "准备伪装成防疫人员以挟持或诱骗的方式", "attack: Kidnapping": "将阮某某带到他处索要", "outcome": "配合公安机关在宁德市蕉城区抓获被告人李某某", "obtained: Nothing": "系犯罪预备", "people: Holder": "准备通过暴力、胁迫的方式从阮某某处劫取2000万" }, "open_points": [], "notes": "Single source: a Jiaocheng court (蕉法君) public-education article reprinted on thepaper.cn, publication date not given; the web.archive.org copy was not needed. Date: 26 April 2022, the day the team reached Ningde; the arrests followed on 27 April. The December 2021 attempt is recorded in the details and not as a separate case. Approach: they planned to pose as epidemic-prevention workers (防疫人员); during the 2022 COVID controls these acted as officials, so I set fake police or official; service ruse is the alternative reading. Attack Kidnapping: the plan was to take him elsewhere and demand the Tether ('将阮某某带到他处索要'), and a foiled attempt carries the label of the attack attempted. Weapons no: the stun baton was seized, never shown to the victim (owner rulings on 72 and 233). Targeting Surveillance only: the article says they learned he held a lot of crypto without saying how. Who was attacked and people: the attackers never met Ruan; I kept Holder with one row as the planned target, which strains the rule 'no rows when the attackers met nobody'; owner may prefer empty steps for foiled plots. Targeting accuracy Unknown: foiled, holdings not confirmed.", "lopp_differences": ["Lopp: 'Indebted Zhou'; the article does not say Zhou was in debt.", "Lopp: 'sentenced ... for armed robbery at the preparatory stage'; the court convicted of robbery (抢劫罪), with no armed aggravation named.", "Lopp: 'his large USDT holdings'; the article says the plan was to seize 20 million Tether (10 million in December) and that the men learned he held a large amount of virtual currency."]}