[ {"key": "7514bb6db7da4c91", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "4b1b557663833959", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "ccea71e2372e3eb7", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "9d597e711fbf4490", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "0163689172bf2caf", "verdict": "reject", "reason": "the ruling quote is a merge label (precedent 8 territory), not a stated description value; the current description already says three attempted break-ins on consecutive days in early March, so the rewrite is not ordered and the second reader's objection stands"}, {"key": "13c57799debaa75a", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "c24b65029eca1e2d", "verdict": "reject", "reason": "the owner's accepted ruling on 444 sets violence_torture to 0 ('saine et sauve'); changing it to threat only overrides an explicit ruling, so the owner should confirm that threat only supersedes 0"}, {"key": "2964a46cf2f15d01", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "acc604aeb037fdd0", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "609520c95a5574da", "verdict": "reject", "reason": "the ruling says 'amount' without naming a field; the second reader flagged coin_type versus money_wanted as unclear and the change moves the loot inventory into the demand field while coin_type keeps the old inventory, so the field choice needs the owner"}, {"key": "23e50d400781cd37", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "a8e97cf05cc94759", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "2fe13ff0281d0564", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "cc96b55d56457d31", "verdict": "reject", "reason": "the ruling orders the plate sentence dropped, which an append to notes cannot do; the appended text leaves the false sentence in place and adds a source position the ruling only quotes in parentheses, so a person should delete the sentence"}, {"key": "2659347c9b9c806e", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "dcccfcd881125577", "verdict": "confirm"}, {"key": "da4824354b67cad1", "verdict": "confirm"} ]