# Approved corrections — apply these on the website database Sofia's decision on each, taken one by one. Nothing here has been applied automatically. Evidence for every item is in `research-results.json` and `fact-check-findings.json`. --- ## Spreadsheet fixes (not the database) **Row 259** — `URL` is `https://archive.is/El9EI`, which is the Kharkiv snapshot. That same link correctly sits on row 262 (Kharkiv) and on DB id 258 (Kharkiv). The article saved in row 259 is the Europe 1 Val-de-Marne story, and DB id 362 already holds the correct Europe 1 URL. So the database is right and this row's URL is the mispaste. → **Fix or clear the URL on row 259. Leave DB id 258 alone.** **Row 18** — `Scenario` says `Armed Robbery in Public Space`. The article says the attack happened inside the victims' own apartment in the Busca neighbourhood of Toulouse. DB id 266 already says `Home Invasion`, which is closer. → **Fix the sheet.** **Row 252** — `URL` points to `cryptonews.com/.../french-crypto-trader-kidnapped-near-paris`, a different case in France. The article saved in that row is a Phuket robbery in Thailand. Trusting this URL would have filed the article under DB id 350. → **Re-find the correct source.** This case is also absent from the database entirely; see `cases-missing-from-database.json`. --- ## DB id 307 — Salford, October 2023 `description` duplicates id 354 (incident 1, the door knock) and `notes` describes incident 2. Date, location, scenario and flags already fit incident 4. Confirmed by elimination: five sheet rows, five DB records, four pairs settled independently. → **Rewrite to incident 4, quoting the source in notes:** > "Days later, the gang turned up at the victim's house again, demanding more money. They > took him to Egret Drive, the address he was later found at by police, and placed a bag > over his head." --- ## DB id 321 — Recife, 21 March 2025 `victim` reads `Crypto manager`, but the person kidnapped was his mother. The record already contradicts itself: the description reads "Crypto manager surveilled, mother kidnapped, ransomed for 5 BTC". → **Change `victim` to the mother.** --- ## DB id 456 — Serra, Espírito Santo, 11 June 2026 **Drug-trafficking network claim — DELETE.** The summary states the investigation "led to broader operation against a drug trafficking and money laundering network in Espírito Santo and Bahia". No source makes this claim. It traces to an unrelated teaser headline sitting inside the Sim Notícias page, about a street sweeper in a different case. **Pistol-whipping — DELETE, but keep `violence_torture` = 1.** No source contains "coronhada". Serra Noticiário, sourced to the police who processed him, says his only injuries were "escoriações causadas pela queda durante a fuga". The flag stays on the basis of one early A Tribuna line attributed to unnamed residents: "A vítima teria tentado resistir ao sequestro, mas foi agredida." Record that as the basis, alongside the police account of his injuries. **Vehicle count — CORRECT to two attacker vehicles.** Keep the eight-suspect figure, which the victim's own account supports. Drop the third vehicle and the invented per-attacker role breakdown. Lt. Tavares: "conseguimos identificar dois carros que emparelharam com a Porsche, um HB20 branco e um Celta prata." Also record: **both attacker vehicles carry São Paulo plates registered to the same owner** (Serra Noticiário) — relevant to whether an attack was organised or opportunistic. **"as of June 16, 2026" — REMOVE the date, keep the rest.** No article dated 16 June or later exists; every source found is dated 11 or 12 June. The count stands as "one arrested, seven at large", with no date attached. --- ## Detention flag (`kidnappings`) — accepted 2026-09-06 Rule: README-START-HERE.md, "Definitions". The field is the detention flag; rename it `detention` on the website. Evidence per case: merge-output/detention-flag-review.md. → **Set `kidnappings` to 1 on these records:** 4, 19, 25, 28, 29, 41, 43, 46, 63, 64, 82, 139, 143, 147, 152, 167, 169, 171, 180, 181, 182, 183, 200, 209, 229, 253, 301, 353, 380, 419. Rule clarified the same day: detention used on anyone (guards, staff, a concierge, a relative) to force submission or execute the theft counts as 1, whether or not the record's named victim was present. Case 301 (guards tied up) is therefore in the list above. → **Set `kidnappings` to 0 on 354, 355 (currently null) and 124** (decided 2026-09-07). Withdrawn 2026-09-07, these stay 1: 242, 273, 413, 422, 423, 215, 298. Rule: forced entry into the victim's space followed by beating or holding them there is detention, however short. No open items. --- ## Batch 01 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30 Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-01.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-01.json`. - **DB id 295 (John Forsyth)** — keep one record for the February 2022 kidnapping: `date` → February 2022, `scenario` stays Kidnapping, `theft` → 0 (wallet, passport, laptop and phones were left in the car). Note the 21–30 May 2023 disappearance and death in `status`; police said foul play did not appear to be a factor. - **DB id 241 (Bangkok, 30 June 2025)** — `notes`: say "several prior deals" (the Bangkok Post counts two, of 200,000 and 300,000 baht; the record counted five). `kidnappings` → 1 (held in the car at knifepoint). `violence_torture` rests on threats only. - **DB id 216 (Vietnam)** — `description`: "extorts" → "demands 600,000 USDT" (nothing paid, plan foiled by police). `amount` → 600,000 USDT from the article body; discard the headline's $400,000. - **DB id 215 (Jeju hotel suite)** — `description`: "lured to perform a trade" → "went to buy crypto" (Yonhap's wording). Scenario sequence: P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (control taken at the attackers' hotel suite; Armed Robbery in Public Space dropped). `kidnappings` stays 1. - **DB id 213 (Estepona)** — `date` → 1 February 2025 (police informed that day). `status`: he escaped by jumping from the balcony before police moved in; the friend alerted his mother, who called police. `weapons` → 1 (two firearms, three knives found). - **DB id 354 (Salford, first visit)** — `theft` → 1; the GMP sentencing statement says the victim transferred the money. - **DB id 355 (Salford, Povey visit)** — `theft` → 1 as an inference (escalating returns, £100,000 aggregate for the earlier incidents, Povey's robbery conviction); no source ties a payment to this visit. - **DB id 212 (Nigeria, brother as organiser)** — no DB change; vocabulary gap confirmed: prior personal ties / acquaintance as the initiation needs a label or attribute.