# Batch 21 decisions (2026-10-01) Cases 472 to 463. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`; evidence in `batches/contradictions-21.md`, `batches/batch-21.json` and the dossiers in `sources/`. Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's `scenario` field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in `scenario-sequences.json` (no new label changes are made in these decisions). ## Approved (DA) - **DB id 472** (DA) — location → a small village near Montdidier, Somme (ICI; the ICI article path names the commune Grivesnes); victim → the same couple as 470 and 471, near thirty, a farmer and a bank executive, with no crypto of their own (they bought the house of a retired couple whose tax record and address had leaked on the darkweb, per their lawyer); money_wanted stays empty; the Telegram fee offered to the hired hand goes to notes: 15,000 to 30,000 euros (ICI) or 15,000 to 20,000 euros (Cryptoast); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons null → 1 (a crowbar, balaclavas and cable ties in the passengers' bag, ICI; carried and not used, as the knife carried in 205 and the crowbars in 473; DA call, owner may set unconfirmed); sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: forced entry into the couple's home to extort crypto they do not hold, the team carrying a crowbar, balaclavas and cable ties; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = data leak / breach (obsolete darkweb file; three teams at one address in under a month, repeat victimisation noted, linked to 470 and 471); arrests: two of the four-man team arrested and detained 7 August, tried at Amiens on 11 August 2026 (three years with 18 months to serve; 18 months with nine to serve), whoever commissioned the raid not identified; source notes: url_2 and url_4 are the same Bourse Inside page; the ICI tail (including the Revelles case, DB id 474) not used. - **DB id 471** (DA) — description: drop "to a remote mastermind" (ICI says only "L'agression est même filmée en direct sur Snpachat"; no recipient named); violence: ICI has one victim tied and the other beaten, Cryptoast one victim tied and beaten, both noted; location → village near Montdidier, Somme (Grivesnes per the ICI article path); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (none mentioned for the 26 June team; the crowbar belongs to 472); sequence Home Invasion kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); the team left when it saw the victims did not fit the profile; held duration not stated; targeting vector = data leak / breach (same darkweb file as 470 and 472); arrests: none reported for this team; source notes as 472. - **DB id 470** (DA) — description: drop "seeking €1 million in cryptocurrency" from this record (the figure is in the ICI headline only and covers the series); description → a first team came to the couple's home on 24 June 2026 and was turned back by the household's dogs (ICI) or dog (Cryptoast); whether they crossed the threshold is not stated; location → village near Montdidier, Somme (Grivesnes per the ICI article path); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (none mentioned for the 24 June team); sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: forced entry into the couple's home to extort the previous owners' crypto; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector = data leak / breach (darkweb file listing the previous owners); arrests: none reported for this team; source notes as 472. - **DB id 469** (DA) — description → three men got into the flat of a shopkeeper reported to hold crypto, intending to leave with her crypto assets; police, acting on intelligence about a planned séquestration, arrived while they were still searching the flat; drop the glass bay window and the ground-floor flat (in none of the four articles); whether she was at home is not stated; date → night of Monday 3 to Tuesday 4 August 2026 (InfosYvelines, Journal du Coin); violence_torture null → unconfirmed ("tentative de cambriolage avec violence" is the legal qualification only, no act described; as 88); weapons null → unconfirmed ("braqueurs" in Journal du Coin's lead only, no weapon described); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Dodged Attack kept; attempted list added: theft of her crypto, with a planned séquestration per police intelligence (file opened as attempted theft in an organised gang); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, theft 0: "zéro butin", life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests: one man in his twenties arrested at the scene, two at large; file opened for "tentative de vol en bande organisée"; source notes: the Le Chesnay-Rocquencourt case in three of the pages is DB id 414; the Val-de-Marne IT engineer in the Cryptoast round-up is a separate case (check against the Val-de-Marne records 362, 405, 428); national figures are context; the InfosYvelines page carries a paywall marker. - **DB id 467** (DA) — date → 18 January 2024 (landed 2.30 p.m. after transiting Hong Kong; last message about 4 p.m., then no response, Caixin); victim → Li Jia and Zhao Dong, both pseudonyms per Caixin ("Notably, Li Jia and Zhao Dong are pseudonyms"), flag wherever published; Li's employer given both as "a Chinese company in Germany" and "a German company" on the same page; description: "have not been heard from since" → messages from Li's phone until about 5 a.m. on 26 January and calls from "big brother" until 6 February 2024, no contact from either man since; money_wanted → 1.5 million USDT demanded; 190,000 USDT paid by Li's family, Zhao's family paid nothing; coin_type → USDT; violence_torture null → unconfirmed (no injury described; "sounded weak ... as kidnappers threatened him"); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0; life_taken null → unconfirmed (both missing, no body reported); sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (abducted after landing); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1); outcome: missing, which none of the six values carries; venue not stated; targeting vector = acquaintance (the sister suspects "big brother", who introduced Li to a woman linked to Philippine investment projects); arrests: none; source notes: only usable source is a Caixin digest behind a paywall; url (CCN) blocked; url_3 and url_4 returned almost nothing; linked to 466. - **DB id 466** (DA) — victim: "Sun Jing" matches no source → the second victim as the sources name him: "Jimmy Sing Sun" (Philstar), "Jimmy Jing Sun" (BenarNews), 孙某, a US citizen of Chinese origin (The Paper), age 45; nationality fields follow; Xia Kefu, 39, kept; location → picked up at Ninoy Aquino International Airport, Manila; bodies found 24 June in Camarines Sur (Barangay Patitinan, Sagnay per Philstar; Tigaon per BenarNews); date 20 June 2024 kept (arrival and abduction; bodies found 24 June); money_wanted → 5 million yuan demanded, negotiated to 3 million yuan and paid (PNP via Philstar and BenarNews), and separately 15 million yuan to be converted into USDT demanded of the colleague on 21 June (The Paper); kept as two figures, not merged; coin_type → USDT for The Paper's demand, form of the 3 million yuan payment not stated; weapons 1 → unconfirmed (no weapon in any article; cause of death unknown when The Paper published); drugs_alcohol → 0; description: the lure is an invitation from a distributor calling herself "Li Na" with a Medev invitation letter (Ms Yang via The Paper); the AI summary's identification of "Li Na" (Chen Yu-hsuan, Seoul arrest) has no source and stays out; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (picked up at the airport and held for ransom); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1: killed by the kidnappers per Philstar, theft 1, life_taken 2); venue not stated; targeting vector = fake business contact ("Li Na"); arrests: some (a culprit surnamed Liu arrested in the US in October 2024 and repatriated to Beijing on 20 July 2026, per the Ministry of Public Security); source notes: the thepaper.cn page is on-case despite the WEAK anchor flag; BenarNews tail of other Philippine kidnappings not used; Ms Yang's recollection that a man said her husband "had lost money at their place" noted, not used as motive. - **DB id 464** (DA) — description: "Maz's accomplice asked to borrow his phone" → one of the two asked to use his phone, supposedly to exchange Telegram details; police say Maz (Nolan Emmanuel) threatened him with the knife, taped his wrists and forced the transfer while Nisar Armaan stayed in the room; amount → 9,782 GBP in Ethereum, drop "(around $13,000)" (the database's own conversion, no source gives one); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (lured to and held at an attacker's room); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = acquaintance (he had shown the two his crypto portfolio, per Pol Lt Col Sudej Imjai); arrests: both arrested and charged (Armaan at the flat; Emmanuel at a hotel in Soi Phra Tamnak 5 per Crime Asia, near Pattaya beach per ASEAN NOW and Thailand News), police see no wider network; source notes: the last two Crime Asia paragraphs belong to 465; Thailand News headline links not used. - **DB id 463** (DA) — date → July 2025, day unknown (no day in any article on file); description: drop "lured to Shadwell" → the pair drove from Kensington to east London intending to buy cannabis and were ambushed after parking in Shadwell by three masked men with a firearm and a knife (no source says the purchase was arranged by the gang); location Canning Town kept (held 52 hours at a flat at Rathbone East); money_wanted → about $150,000 demanded, about $30,000 in digital assets transferred; drugs_alcohol → 0; victim: a third man escaped during the initial attack; outcome: one victim released, the second believed he had been "sold" to another group; arrests: convicted at Inner London Crown Court, six per IBTimes (Borges, Osman, Adebisi, George, Bakoya, Sineen) or five per Coin-Turk and Crypto Economy, Coin-Turk adding Yasir Mohamed; both counts noted, court report needed before publication; jurors cleared kidnap, imitation-firearm possession and sexual assault; directed remotely by Ibrahim Mohamed ("Nino"), not arrested; sequence was Costly Fame; now Costly Fame → Kidnapping (driven to a flat and held 52 hours; Costly Fame rests on the prosecutor's hedged "may well have attracted unwanted attention"); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1 with the imitation-firearm acquittal noted, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = public profile / social media (prosecutor, hedged); source notes: url_2 (Cryptopolitan) blocked; other-case passages (Balland, St Albans, Bajou, Duplessie and Woeltz) not used. ## Needs owner decision ### DB id 468 (owner) TL;DR: crypto founder Harry Chun Tak Yeh found dead at about 04:30 on Friday 7 August 2026 at the foot of Jade Park, Asunción, his 30th-floor flat open and turned over; police running accident, suicide and homicide in parallel. Settled (DA): kidnappings → 0; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0; violence_torture → unconfirmed; theft → unconfirmed (flat "completamente revuelto" per Extra, nothing reported missing); life_taken 1 kept; description: the $2.4 billion AUM is self-reported and unaudited (crypto.news, IBTimes); the 30th floor and Odaily's "early hours of last Tuesday" are police preliminary estimates; no arrests; url_2 (Dim Sum Daily) blocked; Odaily's other-case passages not used. Question: label. The record's Home Invasion has no support (crypto.news: "No official finding ... has accused another person of involvement"); none of the eleven labels fits an unexplained death, and the owner has kept the case (ruling of 2026-09-30). DA recommendation: leave the scenario empty, mark "cause of death undetermined, pending autopsy", and hold it out of published counts until a finding exists. ### DB id 465 (owner) TL;DR: Ashley James O'Brien, 34, allegedly held at gunpoint in his rented Koh Samui villa in April 2026 by three Britons who took a Rolex and bitcoin "worth £250,000". Settled (DA): date → April 2026, day unknown (warrants issued 30 April); amount → £250,000 for the Rolex and bitcoin together, drop the £70,000 transfer and the ~94,000 USD conversion; attackers → three Britons named in warrants (Marco George Cameron Diamantis, 33, Myles Rees Lapierre, 35, Samantha Dorothy Tilley, 38), at large; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); sequence Home Invasion kept; targeting vector = unknown. Question: the only source is two sentences inside the Crime Asia report on 464. The unlocked door, two masked men, sofa, pre-dawn hour, face-down position, ransacking and the record's other detail are in no source on file (url, a Crime Asia Facebook post, was not transcribed). Trace Thai press or the Facebook post first, as in 114, or cut the record to the two sentences now? DA recommendation: cut now to what Crime Asia states; restore details only from a traced source.