Archived
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
20 lines
3.8 KiB
JSON
20 lines
3.8 KiB
JSON
[
|
|
{"id":219,"kind":"contradiction","index":3,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the record value is not a record field but an inference ('scenario implies the counterparty'); the record does not state who the attacker was, so there is no disagreement with the article"},
|
|
{"id":221,"kind":"contradiction","index":7,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the disagreement is inside the article (handcuffed versus tied); the record says nothing about restraint, so there is no record-versus-article disagreement"},
|
|
{"id":221,"kind":"flag","flag":"violence_torture","verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the evidence line itself says no blow or injury is described; restraint, sedation and harassment are detention and drugs, not physical violence, and the same file logic marks threat-only cases (224) unconfirmed","proposed":"unconfirmed"},
|
|
{"id":222,"kind":"contradiction","index":2,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the miscount of detainees is an internal slip in the article; the record has no arrest count, so nothing disagrees with the record"},
|
|
{"id":224,"kind":"contradiction","index":1,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"'Gang poses as police' and 'posing as officials of FIA, CTD and intelligence agencies' do not disagree; only wording differs"},
|
|
{"id":224,"kind":"contradiction","index":3,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record 'Ismail' and article 'Mohammed Ismail' are the same person; no disagreement"},
|
|
{"id":224,"kind":"contradiction","index":4,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the record's 'PIB Colony, Pakistan' and the article's PIB Colony do not disagree; omitting Karachi is not a contradiction"},
|
|
{"id":224,"kind":"contradiction","index":6,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the record has no ransom value; the CTD line about releasing people after ransom is about the gang in general, so there is no record-versus-article disagreement"},
|
|
{"id":228,"kind":"contradiction","index":7,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the record says tortured with a chainsaw and both articles say he was cut with a small chainsaw; the ABC/Reuters difference in recovered items is article against article, not against the record"},
|
|
{"id":229,"kind":"contradiction","index":3,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record 'BTC & XRP' agrees with the article (XRP and Bitcoin wallets drained, plus smaller coins); no real disagreement"},
|
|
{"id":229,"kind":"contradiction","index":5,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record 'London' agrees with the article (Soho, Golders Green and Westminster are all in London); the Soho/Westminster difference is inside the article"},
|
|
{"id":230,"kind":"contradiction","index":1,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record weapons 1 is consistent with both articles (a handgun, later said to be Airsoft, and blunt objects); the real versus fake difference is article against article"},
|
|
{"id":230,"kind":"contradiction","index":4,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the record gives no van detail ('a van'); the Chronopost versus fake-logo difference is between the two articles, not against the record"},
|
|
{"id":231,"kind":"contradiction","index":4,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record 'Coronel Bogado' agrees with the article, which places the company in Coronel Bogado; whether the farm is the mining site is not a record disagreement"},
|
|
{"id":232,"kind":"contradiction","index":0,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"the record says the assailants impersonated military and the article says they posed as UPDF operatives; the 'rogue officers' tension is inside the article"},
|
|
{"id":232,"kind":"contradiction","index":2,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record coin 'Crypto' does not disagree with the article, which only adds detail (Afro Token, unclear for the rest)"},
|
|
{"id":232,"kind":"contradiction","index":3,"verdict":"unsupported","reason":"record $500,000 matches the article's $500,000; the Afro Token sale being additional is not a disagreement"}
|
|
]
|