This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-12.md

11 KiB

Batch 12 decisions (2026-10-01)

Criteria: batches/DECISION-RULES.md. Evidence: batches/contradictions-12.md, batches/batch-12.json, the dossiers in sources/. DB id 82 was decided earlier and is recorded in corrections-approved.md; it is not repeated here.

Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's scenario field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in scenario-sequences.json.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 81 (DA) — money_wanted → 100 BTC demanded at first, lowered to 50 and then 6; 4.78 BTC transferred by his business partner (the record's "4,78 bitcoins" is the sum sent, not the demand); notes → drop "broke into the business building": reception staff were paid 7,000 reais "to help the kidnappers enter the building with the victim", one of them supplied his routine and car, and two security guards were bribed (O Globo); "torture" → tied up, punched in the mouth, two teeth broken; holding place and duration not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected through insider information, so Kidnapping under the rule of 2026-10-01 whatever the holding place); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = insider tip-off (reception staff and bribed guards); arrests → ten people indicted, no arrest or criminal conviction stated, court ordered 250,000 reais in moral damages; outcome "released" is inferred (no line says he was let go); first sheet article is a Livecoins-sourced piece filed under O Globo, the O Globo page is on-case (WEAK anchor is a false positive).
  • DB id 80 (DA) — location → Lahore (taken from a five-star hotel there; Gujranwala is where the two arrests were made); description → drop "$93k" (in no source; it reads as the record's own conversion of Rs14.7 million): the two foreigners were taken hostage at gunpoint on a drive "to show them the city" and made to transfer Rs14.7 million of cryptocurrency, reported as bitcoin; money_wanted Rs14.7 million kept (both reports, twice in the second); the second report's opening "over $10 million" contradicts its own body and is not used (as with the sub-headline in 111); date February 2021 kept, unverified (neither report dates the incident or the arrests); victim count: the FIR's "along with three others" leaves open whether three more people were taken, noted; drugs_alcohol stays 1 (heroin sprinkled on them with a threat to expose them as drug smugglers: drugs used as leverage, as ruled in 170); sequence was Malicious Invitation; now Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (owner ruling of 2026-10-01: invited to Lahore, pre-selected); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (invited to Lahore to invest; how the contact began not stated); arrests → two arrested in Gujranwala, prime suspect Rana Irfan at large; outcome not stated; Daily Times URL blocked on fetch, the sheet text is the only copy.
  • DB id 79 (DA) — description → three people (two men, one woman) tricked the couple into opening the door ("They knock and deceive the victims into letting them in"), went in with a pistol and a knife, stayed 20 to 30 minutes and forced them to transfer bitcoin "worth millions" (unnamed sources to Aftonbladet; no currency; police would not comment on the loot); drop "1M+ SEK" (no source); notes → drop "money, jewelry, watches" as items taken (Åkermark's remark is general: "they were after money, jewelry, watches, or other valuables"); location → residential area in the northern part of Stockholm County (southern Roslagen police area); date 4 February 2021 kept, unverified (article says "last Thursday evening"; 4 February 2021 was a Thursday but the report's own date is not on file); sequence Home Invasion kept, gap: entry by an unspecified deception at the door (no claimed role shown, so Authority Misuse not applied, as in 397); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (police still examining what the perpetrators knew beforehand); arrests → all three caught, two men in custody, the woman released, police say more people may stand behind them; one source (Aftonbladet, THIN on fetch).
  • DB id 78 (DA) — date → 22 January 2021 (Cointelegraph: "around 7 p.m. local time on Jan. 22"; 23 January is the date of the local report and of the reward); victim → two FlyingAtom employees, a man and a woman, one in a medically induced coma; money_wanted → gold worth 450,000 PLN (about $120,000 per Cointelegraph), coin_type Gold kept, no crypto taken; case kept (target was a bitcoin-and-gold exchange office, a crypto business under the glossary's Armed Robbery; crypto link by occupation, as in 123); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, gap: a private office on the fourth floor of an office tower; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests → one man detained in Bydgoszcz who "may be related to the attack", FlyingAtom thanked police for the capture of the suspect, no charge or court step on file; first sheet block is a Polish local report filed under CT.
  • DB id 77 (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("He said the four fled after locking the victim in the office": locked in, explicit quote; control was gained at knifepoint before the lock-in, so clarification 3 does not apply); description and money_wanted HK$3.5 million in cash kept (the proceeds of a completed USDT sale), plus her iPhone; coin_type Cash kept, the tokens she delivered were USDT; sequence was P2P Trade Gone Wrong; now Malicious Invitation → P2P Trade Gone Wrong (police say the gang "lured" her and may have done three earlier deals of HK$600,000 to HK$700,000 to win her trust; same order as 117); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); attackers → four (the buyer and three men from a back room with a knife or a rod); targeting vector = business counterparty (repeat buyer); arrests none; held duration not stated; one source (SCMP, two copies).
  • DB id 76 (DA) — weapons → 0 (no weapon appears anywhere in the report; four men jumped into the car and took the banknotes and two phones); description → drop "US$387,000" (the record's conversion): two buyers he had traded with before drove him from North Point and, after he transferred 15 bitcoins, four accomplices took back the HK$3 million in cash and two phones on a hillside near Shan Tsui Court, Tai Tam Road, and he was put out of the car; money_wanted → 15 BTC transferred plus HK$3 million in cash taken back (the report's own figures do not close: 15 at HK$235,000 each is HK$3.525 million, noted); date → January 2021, day unknown (the robbery was on "Monday"; the record's 5 January 2021 was a Tuesday and the report's date is not on file); location → Tai Tam Road near Shan Tsui Court, Chai Wan, Hong Kong (picked up in North Point); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (HK$1 million online trade the night before); arrests none, six suspects at large; one source (The Standard, two copies).
  • DB id 74 (DA) — date → December 2020, day unknown, before the 24 December report (the report says another kidnapper "was caught a day and a half after the crime"); victim → a Kyiv-based man in a cryptocurrency-related business, plus his wife as second victim (taken in another car, found held in a Ternopil hotel, no physical force used); money_wanted → $800,000 demanded under threat of death (victim's account), no payment or transfer reported (the headlines' "extorted $800,000" is not borne out by the bodies), coin_type → not stated; theft stays 1 on the stolen Toyota Camry (found a few kilometres away), no crypto taken; sequence Kidnapping kept (blocked by three cars, handcuffed into a car boot, held and tortured overnight); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; arrests → four of seven (two arrested, one caught a day and a half later, the organiser surrendered), three sought, one reportedly abroad; how his captivity ended is not stated; LB.ua teaser tail (Kyiv brothers, Irpin gang) not used.

Needs owner decision

DB id 73 (owner)

TL;DR: four men assaulted three would-be bitcoin buyers carrying Dh500,000 in cash in an Al Barsha office, Dubai; the victims screamed and the four fled with nothing. Settled (DA): date → August 2019 (second report: "The incident dates back to August 2019"; December 2020 is a court or report date); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted robbery of the Dh500,000; violence_torture stays 1 (both reports say the four assaulted the victims); kidnappings 0, theft 0; all four arrested and charged with attempted robbery; attackers "four Ukrainian defendants" (Gulf News) / "a four-member European gang" (second report), compatible. Question: weapons. For 1: Gulf News, "The four defendants physically assaulted the victims and sprayed a deodorant directly on to the victims' faces" (a spray in the face reads as in 89). For 0: the second report, "one of them had used his body deodorant to spray on the robbers' faces" (the spray was the victims' defence). DA recommendation: weapons → unconfirmed, both accounts in notes, and the description's "attack Bitcoin buyer with deodorant" reworded to "assaulted the buyers".

DB id 72 (owner)

TL;DR: a Riga man planning to abduct, torture and kill a crypto holder for about 500,000 euros was detained by the Omega squad on 7 October 2020 while lying in wait; nobody was touched. Settled (DA): date → 7 October 2020 (detention; plot intercepted in September; 22 October is the report date); victim → two intended victims (police later learned of a second planned abduction and murder); money_wanted → about 500,000 euros, cryptocurrency (ForkLog) / cryptocurrency and cash (State Police via Sputnik); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping plus extortion and planned killings; kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, theft 0, life_taken 0; arrests: the organiser, who confessed and is held by court order, accomplices not identified; the OFF-CASE? flag on the ForkLog page is a matcher artefact (Riga and Latvia appear only in Russian), the article is the right one. Question: weapons. For 1: "The criminal also prepared torture tools intended to be used if the victim refused to provide passwords" (prepared weapons in a foiled plot, as 205 and 213). For 0: the tools are not named, and no source says they were seized or carried on the day (205 had a knife carried on the day; 213 had weapons found). DA recommendation: weapons → 0, prepared torture tools in notes; set 1 if the owner reads "prepared" as present.