This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-24.md

12 KiB

Batch 24 decisions (2026-10-01)

Triage of batches/contradictions-24.md under batches/DECISION-RULES.md; evidence in batches/batch-24.json and sources/.

Sequence wording: "kept" means the record's scenario stays; "was A; now B" compares with the record's scenario field. Every new sequence below is the verified sequence already in scenario-sequences.json.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 442 (DA) — description → prosecutors say Brown posed as a food delivery driver and someone inside opened the door; Brown, Franklin and Chambers forced their way in with loaded firearms, joined by two unidentified co-conspirators, held the victim about an hour and "used firearms to physically restrain the victim", demanding access to the safe, the computer and the online accounts; they then met Osama, Khiell Dukes, Ramsey and others, who searched them "to make sure all of the robbery proceeds were collected" (Chicago Sun-Times); drop "six men including Osama forced their way in": Osama's lawyer says he was not present and did not set up the robbery; theft → unconfirmed (demand only, no transfer, amount or coin; "robbery proceeds" is the prosecutors' word, nothing itemised; DA call, owner may set 1); violence_torture → 0 (restraint by firearm, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (food-delivery ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30); flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); arrests → six charged (three on 23 March, three more incl. Osama by superseding indictment on 16 April), all pleaded not guilty and ordered detained; a seventh man arrested with charges pending; targeting vector unknown; url_2 (justice.gov, EDNY, Dukes's 2022 machinegun case) is background on Osama, not this incident; the Sun-Times paragraphs on Osama's Christmas gifts not used.
  • DB id 437 (DA) — date → Wednesday 6 May 2026 (Le Parisien of 9 May, per its URL, says "mercredi"; 7 May is a Thursday and has no source; Revolution Magazine's "ce matin" is undated); coin_type → none: no cryptocurrency held or taken (Le Parisien: the search found none, "Sans succès"); money_wanted → crypto sought, none existed; notes → the suspects were reportedly located in the 18th arrondissement shortly after but escaped the BAC (Le Parisien, crediting Actu17); theft → unconfirmed (computers and a smartphone: Le Parisien says the haul was left at the scene, Generation-NT says it was carried off and abandoned during the escape; no loss either way; DA call, owner may set 0 or 1); violence: Le Parisien states beaten, tied and a punch to the face, Revolution Magazine hedges ("auraient été menacées et violentées", circumstances still to be established), both readings kept; drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1: a handgun displayed, life_taken 0); targeting vector unknown, wrong target per Generation-NT; arrests none; the Balland kidnapping and the trend paragraphs on all three pages not used.
  • DB id 435 (DA) — description → a kidnapping linked to crypto-assets committed in November 2025 at Challes-les-Eaux (Savoie); three men aged 25 to 30, all previously convicted, were charged (not convicted) with arrest, abduction and unlawful confinement as an organised gang, extortion and organised-gang money laundering, and remanded; PNACO recalls the presumption of innocence; arrests → the week before Friday 24 April 2026 (PNACO statement relayed by Actu17 and ICI), not "late April", by the Chambéry gendarmerie research section and the UNPJ; theft → unconfirmed (extortion and laundering charges only, no transfer, amount or coin anywhere); violence_torture → unconfirmed and weapons → unconfirmed (no account of the incident exists on file; PNACO mentions violence only across all 135 facts it counts; DA call, writer proposed 0); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Kidnapping kept, resting on the charge wording alone, gap: victim, venue, duration and method not reported; link to 381 (Dompierre-sur-Mer, December 2025: two of the same accused charged); the PNACO tally passages and the ICI teaser headlines not used.
  • DB id 433 (DA) — description → two stages: on 4 November two men in surgical masks approached him at his home and fled when he shut the door (La Presse; Atlas21 says they threatened him outside his home); on 8 November four hooded suspects in a black Kia without plates waited by his house, three fled on foot after the car swerved, the driver came up to him and he says he tried to spray him with bear spray, and a few moments later another suspect pointed a handgun at him; he stayed on the phone to police; notes → the torture kit (a two-foot tarp with a hole and clamps "to cut off a limb and stop the bleeding") is the victim's own description, not a police find; money_wanted → per the victim, police said the attackers thought he held 2.5 million bitcoins after posts on a Facebook page he moderates; he puts his actual holding at about $10,000; violence_torture → 0, threat only (handgun pointed, no blow or injury; kit never used); drugs_alcohol → 0; arrests → all four arrested, two adults charged in November 2024 with conspiracy to kidnap and possession and pointing of prohibited firearms, two minors also arrested; accused released to house arrest pending trial (La Presse; Coingape says "the duo", noted); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted added: Kidnapping and torture for his wallet password; flags otherwise unchanged (kidnappings 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); targeting vector: public profile / social media (Facebook page he moderates); url_4 (cryptoast.fr) is a different incident, the rue Pache attempt in Paris (record 230), and comes off this record; La Presse's round-up tail of other Canadian cases and Lopp's aggregate count in Atlas21 not used.

Needs owner decision

  • DB id 441 (owner) — third of three foiled attempts on the Montreal family's house in early March 2026; the three records 439, 440 and 441 rest on one undifferentiated sentence.
    • Settled (DA): date → early March 2026, day unknown (the Journal de Montréal gives no dates or order); attackers → not identified, and the source does not say the March suspects were a separate group from 28 January; arrests → none reported (the SPVM "could" track other individuals; nothing says they were identified); victim → the household as described for 28 January, who was home in March not stated; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (the firearms belong to 438); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Home Invasion; noovo.info (about 438) and the ctvnews.ca headline block come off as off-case.
    • Q: keep three records or merge into one record with a count of three attempts? For three: the source says three attempts on three consecutive days. For one: no date, order or detail separates them, and the created_at stamps (17:12, 17:15, 17:17 on 2026-05-25) suggest a hand split at import. DA recommends: merge into 439 with "three attempts on three consecutive days, early March 2026", delete 440 and 441.
  • DB id 440 (owner) — second of the three early-March attempts; same settled points and question as 441. DA recommends: merge into 439.
  • DB id 439 (owner) — first of the three early-March attempts; same settled points and question as 441. DA recommends: keep as the merged record; on 11 March the family left the house for safety reasons.
  • DB id 438 (owner) — Montreal, 28 January 2026: four men from the Toronto area entered on a parcel ruse, one fired and hit an accomplice; the detention flag is thin.
    • Settled (DA): notes → they fled leaving several pieces of evidence (drop "fled before completing the robbery due to the accidental shooting": no source links the shot to the flight or says a robbery was under way); description → the 28 January incident only (the record's text covers all four incidents); theft → 0 (nothing taken, no transfer); drugs_alcohol → 0; violence_torture 1 kept (light arm injury, not from the gunshot); weapons 1; sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (parcel ruse, ruling of 2026-09-30); arrests → Christopher Ethan Prince, 20, and a 17-year-old arrested in Ajax and Toronto (reported 7 May 2026), two sought incl. a 16-year-old; four children and a music teacher in the house; targeting vector: contract accepted over social media.
    • Q: kidnappings 1 or 0? For 1: forced entry into the home and a confrontation with an injury, clarification 1 and the 128 ruling ("nobody admits attackers willingly"). For 0: no holding, restraint or duration described; entry, confrontation on the stairs, a shot, flight, which reads as control never gained (clarification 3). DA recommends: keep 1 on clarification 1, with the note that no holding is described.
  • DB id 436 (owner) — Péchabou, 23 March 2026: €68,000 in crypto transferred under duress during a violent sequestration; the record's victim profile and entry method trace only to a blocked page.
    • Settled (DA): theft 1 (€68,000 transferred to the network's wallets); kidnappings 1; violence_torture 1 ("une séquestration violente"); weapons 1 ("plusieurs auteurs armés et cagoulés" at the house; the two loaded assault weapons were found in the car after the chase of 30 to 31 March, not at the house); drugs_alcohol → 0; attackers → several armed hooded men, number not given; five men aged 17 to 24 charged, one mentioned DZ Mafia recruitment; the planned Nîmes reprisal is a separate intended crime, kept in status.
    • Q1: "57-year-old woman", "four men", "posed as a delivery driver", jewellery and the hacking claim appear in neither Le Figaro nor ICI (both say "un particulier"); they trace to the gendarmerie page, BLOCKED with no text on file. DA recommends: fetch that page first; if it cannot be read, cut the record back to Le Figaro and ICI (victim → private individual near Toulouse; coin_type → crypto only, jewellery dropped).
    • Q2: scenario. Record: Authority Misuse; sequence file: Home Invasion (no entry method on file). DA recommends: Home Invasion unless the gendarmerie page confirms the delivery ruse, in which case Authority Misuse → Home Invasion under the 2026-09-30 ruling.
  • DB id 434 (owner) — Karachi passenger taken at gunpoint from a ride-hail car, $8,600 moved from his digital account; much of the record is in no readable source.
    • Settled (DA): kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 (physically assaulted, per the father), weapons 1 (four armed men, at gunpoint), theft 1 ($8,600 plus phone, laptop and belongings); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence Express Kidnapping kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-01: 434 stays Express); date → the night of Wednesday 22 April 2026 or after (ProPakistani and The Asian Mirror, both 24 April, say he left home on Wednesday night); attackers → four armed men (both reports, father's account only).
    • Q1: Sharea Faisal, the white vehicle, the road blockade, the false pretext, the iPhone/MacBook/Samsung brands, the victim's own two-attacker account, the 1.5 hours, Gulistan-e-Jauhar and SSP Pirzada's statement come only from the site summary; both readable reports give a petrol-pump stop, four armed men, no officer named, and The Asian Mirror says no official statement was issued. DA recommends: trace a third source; failing that, cut those details and rewrite to the two reports.
    • Q2: duration ("more than an hour", ProPakistani, against "several hours", The Asian Mirror) and coin ("digital currency" in ProPakistani's headline only; bodies say "digital account"). DA recommends: keep both durations; coin_type → digital account, crypto not confirmed.