This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/corrections-approved.md
T

42 KiB
Raw Blame History

Approved corrections — apply these on the website database

Sofia's decision on each, taken one by one. Nothing here has been applied automatically. Evidence for every item is in research-results.json and fact-check-findings.json.


Spreadsheet fixes (not the database)

Row 259 — URL is https://archive.is/El9EI, which is the Kharkiv snapshot. That same link correctly sits on row 262 (Kharkiv) and on DB id 258 (Kharkiv). The article saved in row 259 is the Europe 1 Val-de-Marne story, and DB id 362 already holds the correct Europe 1 URL. So the database is right and this row's URL is the mispaste. → Fix or clear the URL on row 259. Leave DB id 258 alone.

Row 18 — Scenario says Armed Robbery in Public Space. The article says the attack happened inside the victims' own apartment in the Busca neighbourhood of Toulouse. DB id 266 already says Home Invasion, which is closer. → Fix the sheet.

Row 252 — URL points to cryptonews.com/.../french-crypto-trader-kidnapped-near-paris, a different case in France. The article saved in that row is a Phuket robbery in Thailand. Trusting this URL would have filed the article under DB id 350. → Re-find the correct source. This case is also absent from the database entirely; see cases-missing-from-database.json.


DB id 307 — Salford, October 2023

description duplicates id 354 (incident 1, the door knock) and notes describes incident 2. Date, location, scenario and flags already fit incident 4. Confirmed by elimination: five sheet rows, five DB records, four pairs settled independently.

→ Rewrite to incident 4, quoting the source in notes:

"Days later, the gang turned up at the victim's house again, demanding more money. They took him to Egret Drive, the address he was later found at by police, and placed a bag over his head."


DB id 321 — Recife, 21 March 2025

victim reads Crypto manager, but the person kidnapped was his mother. The record already contradicts itself: the description reads "Crypto manager surveilled, mother kidnapped, ransomed for 5 BTC".

→ Change victim to the mother.


DB id 456 — Serra, Espírito Santo, 11 June 2026

Drug-trafficking network claim — DELETE. The summary states the investigation "led to broader operation against a drug trafficking and money laundering network in Espírito Santo and Bahia". No source makes this claim. It traces to an unrelated teaser headline sitting inside the Sim Notícias page, about a street sweeper in a different case.

Pistol-whipping — DELETE, but keep violence_torture = 1. No source contains "coronhada". Serra Noticiário, sourced to the police who processed him, says his only injuries were "escoriações causadas pela queda durante a fuga". The flag stays on the basis of one early A Tribuna line attributed to unnamed residents: "A vítima teria tentado resistir ao sequestro, mas foi agredida." Record that as the basis, alongside the police account of his injuries.

Vehicle count — CORRECT to two attacker vehicles. Keep the eight-suspect figure, which the victim's own account supports. Drop the third vehicle and the invented per-attacker role breakdown. Lt. Tavares: "conseguimos identificar dois carros que emparelharam com a Porsche, um HB20 branco e um Celta prata." Also record: both attacker vehicles carry São Paulo plates registered to the same owner (Serra Noticiário) — relevant to whether an attack was organised or opportunistic.

"as of June 16, 2026" — REMOVE the date, keep the rest. No article dated 16 June or later exists; every source found is dated 11 or 12 June. The count stands as "one arrested, seven at large", with no date attached.


Detention flag (kidnappings) — accepted 2026-09-06

Rule: README-START-HERE.md, "Definitions". The field is the detention flag; rename it detention on the website. Evidence per case: merge-output/detention-flag-review.md.

→ Set kidnappings to 1 on these records: 4, 19, 25, 28, 29, 41, 43, 46, 63, 64, 82, 139, 143, 147, 152, 167, 169, 171, 180, 181, 182, 183, 200, 209, 229, 253, 301, 353, 380, 419.

Rule clarified the same day: detention used on anyone (guards, staff, a concierge, a relative) to force submission or execute the theft counts as 1, whether or not the record's named victim was present. Case 301 (guards tied up) is therefore in the list above.

→ Set kidnappings to 0 on 354, 355 (currently null) and 124 (decided 2026-09-07).

Withdrawn 2026-09-07, these stay 1: 242, 273, 413, 422, 423, 215, 298. Rule: forced entry into the victim's space followed by beating or holding them there is detention, however short. No open items.


Batch 01 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-01.md; evidence in batches/batch-01.json.

  • DB id 295 (John Forsyth) — keep one record for the February 2022 kidnapping: date → February 2022, scenario stays Kidnapping, theft → 0 (wallet, passport, laptop and phones were left in the car). Note the 21–30 May 2023 disappearance and death in status; police said foul play did not appear to be a factor.
  • DB id 241 (Bangkok, 30 June 2025) — notes: say "several prior deals" (the Bangkok Post counts two, of 200,000 and 300,000 baht; the record counted five). kidnappings → 1 (held in the car at knifepoint). violence_torture rests on threats only.
  • DB id 216 (Vietnam) — description: "extorts" → "demands 600,000 USDT" (nothing paid, plan foiled by police). amount → 600,000 USDT from the article body; discard the headline's $400,000.
  • DB id 215 (Jeju hotel suite) — description: "lured to perform a trade" → "went to buy crypto" (Yonhap's wording). Scenario sequence: P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (control taken at the attackers' hotel suite; Armed Robbery in Public Space dropped). kidnappings stays 1.
  • DB id 213 (Estepona) — date → 1 February 2025 (police informed that day). status: he escaped by jumping from the balcony before police moved in; the friend alerted his mother, who called police. weapons → 1 (two firearms, three knives found).
  • DB id 354 (Salford, first visit) — theft → 1; the GMP sentencing statement says the victim transferred the money.
  • DB id 355 (Salford, Povey visit) — theft → 1 as an inference (escalating returns, £100,000 aggregate for the earlier incidents, Povey's robbery conviction); no source ties a payment to this visit.
  • DB id 212 (Nigeria, brother as organiser) — no DB change; vocabulary gap confirmed: prior personal ties / acquaintance as the initiation needs a label or attribute.

Batch 02 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-02.md; evidence in batches/batch-02.json.

  • DB id 211 — accept all: description → the two attackers took the victims' phones and made transfers totalling $16,000, coached by an accomplice by telephone; attackers → two; weapons → 1 (gun-butt blows, 'coronhadas na cabeça'); add the stolen car (recovered next day) to notes.
  • DB id 210 — accept: location → Sainte-Savine (suburb of Troyes); sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping; note the sheet's mistranslation ('mineur de cryptomonnaies' = crypto miner).
  • DB id 208 — accept: date → 16 January 2025; amount → $580,000 in crypto, cash taken back is a separate unquantified sum; notes → 'several prior deals' (article counts seven); violence_torture → 1.
  • DB id 207 — accept: date → 15 January 2025; notes → forced into another vehicle, bound and blindfolded (no assault reported); status → abandoned by the kidnappers and found by villagers, not rescued; no ransom demand reported.
  • DB id 206 — accept: drop the $290,000 (no source; keep 'large amount'); notes → police suspect he knew his attackers, entry method not stated. NEW ATTRIBUTE: flag prior acquaintance = suspected (police inference); the schema needs a prior-acquaintance / insider attribute (see also 212).
  • DB id 205 — accept: description → kidnap-for-crypto-ransom plot opened by a fake watches-for-crypto meeting, four arrested in Broward County per a federal affidavit (no FBI named); money_wanted → 2,000,000 USD in crypto; weapons → 1 (planned firearms, knife carried on the day).
  • DB id 204 — accept: money_wanted → 120,000 USD (demanded); cash stolen → note both article figures ($20,000 vs 60–70 hundred-dollar bills); attackers → one on site, two Russian suspects charged incl. absent mastermind; weapons → 0. Prior acquaintance = yes (business dispute).
  • DB id 202 — accept: money_wanted → 340,000 USD, coin_type USDT; keep both accounts of the transfer (Dawn: in his presence near FIA Saddar; Guardian: after the phone was taken) and of the route; weapons → 1; violence_torture → threat only; sequence Authority Misuse → Express Kidnapping.
  • DB id 201 — accept: date → 20 December 2024 (the Friday before VRT's 24 Dec report); attackers → four suspects, one a minor; victim name unsupported on file (keep only with a source); notes → injured in the crash, not 'ok'; location → Brussels, crash in Bruges; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping.
  • DB id 200 — keep the case; rename the victim to Dr Kwadwo Agyapong Berry (19 December, Botchway's office, thirteen hours); open a second record for Benjamin Appiah Boateng's detention at Laboma Beach from 14 December by Berry, Botchway and Burke; kidnappings → 1; theft → 0; money_wanted → the $1.6 million in dispute, not a ransom; sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping. NEW ATTRIBUTE: insider dispute (prior acquaintance = yes, co-investors).

Batch 03 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-03.md; evidence in batches/batch-03.json.

  • DB id 199 — accept: attackers → nine-member group (Russia, Uzbekistan, Ukraine); amount → US$214,424; drop 'Binance'; arrests → one man detained and released, nobody in custody, police doubt the complaint; location → South Kuta (held at villas in Kuta Selatan and Ubud); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping; mark low-confidence (single self-contradicting source).
  • DB id 197 — accept: year unresolved (source says 2025; 2024 unsupported) — find a second source; money_wanted → 6 BTC (~$400,000), coin_type BTC; kidnappings → 1 (barged into the hotel room, held until the transfer).
  • DB id 197 — addendum: sequence Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (the gang barged into the room he was in, so the hotel room is treated as the victim's private space); venue_of_control → victim's private space.
  • DB id 196 — drugs_alcohol stays 1 (owner keeps the drugging); notes → watch, phone and wallet taken, card and crypto drained afterwards with the phone (no cash); money_wanted → ~300,000 USD; weapons → 1; kidnappings stays 1; sequence Malicious Invitation → Armed Robbery in Public Space.
  • DB id 195 — keep the case; kidnappings → 0 (no person held); description → dog theft alleged, sourced to screenshots posted on X; scenario: none of the eleven fits (doxing / online retaliation, pet as leverage unverified).
  • DB id 194 — accept: weapons → 1 (hammer and knife); money_wanted → 500,000 USDT demanded, 250,000 USDT transferred, coin_type USDT; scenario → Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (held in a third party's hotel room), prior acquaintance = yes (the suspect's earlier P2P purchases from him); date 8 November is by inference only.
  • DB id 193 — accept: violence_torture → unconfirmed (found uninjured); amount stays $1 million ransom, note $3.6 million total cost to the company; coin_type stays empty (paid electronically, form unstated); reports → second article is The Logic, not CBC.
  • DB id 190 — accept: weapons → 1; location → Chicago (held in Forest Park and a second house); coin_type → BTC/ETH; $15M is the amount transferred, no demanded sum on file; sequence Home Invasion → Kidnapping; ruse attribute (garage-damage pretext).
  • DB id 189 — accept: description → confronted by two men and assaulted by one of them (not 'punched by attackers'); coin_type → USDT (the trade), S$32,000 cash is the sum at risk; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Dodged Attack.

Batch 04 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-04.md; evidence in batches/batch-04.json.

  • DB id 186 — accept: date → 13 August 2024 (Tuesday night before the 16 August report); location → Pathum Thani (golf-course house, Muang district); coin_type stays unspecified crypto.
  • DB id 185 — accept: drop the security guard and '10+ BTC' (loss $700,000 in bitcoin per Teletica); victim → eleven Israelis (residence unclear); date approximate (report of 8 August gives none); kidnappings → 1 (gagged, moved from place to place); weapons → unconfirmed; sequence Authority Misuse → Armed Robbery in Public Space (attackers wore what appear to be police uniforms); insider leak suspected.
  • DB id 184 — victim → 'Crypto billionaire' (name removed at the victim's request); remove the name from the summary and the dossier file name when the record is updated.
  • DB id 184 — venue → stairwell of his own apartment building in Tallinn (not a rental home; the rented property was the sauna house he was to be taken to). Other points (day in July unsupported, 30 BTC Telegram demand for money_wanted, weapons unconfirmed, Tallinn spelling) left as proposals.
  • DB id 183 — accept: kidnappings → 1; money_wanted → 3 BTC (~$170,000), coin_type BTC; date unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate); location → Kyiv, Solomianskyi district, held in Kyiv region; weapons → unconfirmed (beating and strangling only).
  • DB id 182 — accept: kidnappings → 1, weapons → 1, theft → 1; money_wanted → Rs 16,02,510 in USDT (drop the unsourced $18,000 or mark it a conversion), coin_type USDT; location → Pune (Bavdhan, driven to Shikrapur); sequence Malicious Invitation → Express Kidnapping.
  • DB id 181 — accept: kidnappings → 1, violence_torture → 1, weapons → 1 (stun gun), theft → 1; venue → Phra Khanong, Khlong Toei, Bangkok; money_wanted → ~3 million baht in valuables (phones, watches, card, cash), no crypto taken; sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping.
  • DB id 180 — accept: one victim, six charged (gang of 18); money_wanted → 1,007,696 USDT, coin_type USDT; drop 'shootout with police' (four gang members shot dead 3 August in separate encounters, noted as related); location → KL–Putrajaya expressway exit; kidnappings → 1; theft → unconfirmed; life_taken stays 0 (separate encounters).
  • DB id 179 — accept: date → 10 July 2024 (related incidents 4 June and 17 July); money_wanted → 10,000 EUR demanded on 10 July, 12,500 EUR total taken over the series; attackers → two on 10 July, three convicted incl. the victim's friend; violence_torture → threat only; coin unspecified. Repeat victimisation + prior acquaintance = yes.
  • DB id 178 — accept: money_wanted stays HK$5 million, note US$660,000 USDT (HKFP), coin_type USDT; location → Tseung Kwan O.
  • DB id 176 — accept: location → King Albert Park, Singapore (residential unit); scenario → Home Invasion, venue = victim's private space (the residential unit; owner strikes 'venue uncertain'); money_wanted → SGD 4.34M (~USD 3.19M) in currency, crypto and watches; weapons stays 1.

Batch 05 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-05.md; evidence in batches/batch-05.json.

  • DB id 175 — accept: description keeps ฿1.8m (headline and charge), money_wanted notes the body's ฿112m estimate; date 15 March = complaint date, robbery date unstated; attackers → one arrested, six alleged by the victim; label Mugging kept as closest, gap noted (targeted, no weapon, no holding).

  • DB id 174 — accept: violence_torture → 1 (facial injuries); attackers → four arrested, others possibly involved; amount → nearly $25,000 in crypto, credit cards and goods; outcome unknown (article does not say how they got free).

  • DB id 173 — accept: date → March 2024 (earliest of a March–December 2024 series, series noted); amount → more than $300,000 ($200k was the bond); scenario → Malicious Invitation / Social Engineering. Attacker stays 'fake Uber driver': NBC says he pretended to be an Uber driver and picked up customers who had ordered a real ride outside a hotel; he asked for the phone 'to connect to the Uber app'.

  • DB id 173 — addendum: scenario stays Authority Misuse — owner rules that authority is not only police; a driver's position used to obtain the phone is misuse of a position of trust (clarification added to DEFINITIONS.md).

  • DB id 172 — accept: amount → US$901,200 (~31M baht); date → 29 January 2024 (Monday before the 2 Feb report); location → Phuket, Muang district, both scene accounts noted; weapons → 1 (knives, tape, rope recovered from the gang's second vehicle); label Kidnapping kept per the charge, Express Kidnapping noted as the closer pattern.

  • General ruling 2026-09-30 (Authority Misuse) — authority is not only police: a claimed worker, driver, delivery or uniformed role used to gain access or compliance is Authority Misuse as the initiation label. Applied to cases [19, 44, 109, 118, 136, 150, 164, 184, 196, 229, 248, 334, 360, 370, 371, 402, 403, 413, 423, 424, 426, 429, 438, 442, 444, 447, 448, 451, 479] (sequence prefixed with Authority Misuse). Reference: DEFINITIONS.md.

  • DB id 171 — accept: cut 'doused in diesel' and 'force-fed alcohol' (not in the article; the alcohol reading is his own drink-driving); theft → gave up the access code on his own account, no transfer reported (theft unconfirmed); mark the case DISPUTED (police found nothing on cameras); amount → 950,000 lei (~$200,000); kidnappings → 1 and violence_torture → 1 with the hedge (severed finger seen by police).

  • DB id 170 — status stays 'police intervened' (swift action = intervention; owner reading); drugs_alcohol stays 1 (drugs used as leverage: threat to plant them); money_wanted → 15 million RUB (~$166,000) demanded of the brother, coin_type empty; weapons → 0.

  • DB id 169 — accept: kidnappings → 1, violence_torture → 1, weapons → 1; money_wanted stays the campaign total with a note. CAMPAIGN RULE: the Salford series (354, 355, 307, 162, 169) is one campaign; drugs_alcohol → 1 on every record of the series (morphine used during the campaign), each record notes the series link.

  • DB id 168 — accept: abducted off the street near his residence (apartment searched by the others); beaten and abandoned taped to a post in a field in Banks, password used later that day (not 'revealed under torture'); freed by a passer-by; all four charged.

  • DB id 167 — accept: kidnappings → 1, theft → 1; money_wanted → 12.5M USD in USDT (11.8M recovered), coin_type USDT; victim → executives of a Binance VIP client; date unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate); add CZ / Binance Support X posts as sources before green.

  • DB id 166 — accept: date unverified on file (keep 6 Nov); money_wanted empty, coin_type BTC; note the syndication chain (CryptoPotato ← Eric Wall ← LT / Aftonbladet); fetch LT and Aftonbladet as extra sources.


Batch 06 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-06.md; evidence in batches/batch-06.json.

  • DB id 164 — accept: attackers → several men, seven charged (two arrested, five in absentia); amount → up to $900,000 on site plus several million in crypto via the seized servers; kidnappings → 1 (staff and clients' movement restricted); weapons stays 1 ('supposedly' seen on footage).
  • DB id 162 — accept: location → Cadishead; weapons stays 1 as a campaign flag (machetes and pistol across the series); drugs_alcohol → 1 (campaign); money_wanted stays the campaign total.
  • DB id 161 — Ledger: The Phuket News (English-language) writes 'the location of a drive containing a ledger of cryptocurrency', which reads as the police report's description of a Ledger hardware wallet; keep 'Ledger hardware wallet (as the record has it; the article's wording is a paraphrase)'. No second source found. Remaining proposals (three Kazakh men in the villa, twins as phone organisers; resort villa not hotel room) await the owner.
  • DB id 161 — accept: attackers → three Kazakh men in the villa (fled to Dubai) plus the twins arrested as the organisers directing by phone; venue → resort villa.
  • DB id 160 — accept: violence_torture → 1 (tased and tied); coin_type → crypto (unspecified), property list moved to notes; money_wanted → $20,000 cash + $20,000 crypto.
  • DB id 158 — accept: attackers → seven suspects (no gender); time differs between ABC13 (before 5 am) and Protos (6 am); scenario → Dodged Attack, attempted theft of the Bitcoin ATM (no weapon, nobody present; infrastructure case).
  • DB id 157 — accept: violence_torture stays 1 (minor bruising per one article; 'unharmed' per another, noted); alarm raised by a friend calling from Hungary, reported in person at Benalmádena police HQ; location → Málaga province (villa in Málaga, police in Benalmádena); amount €1M.
  • DB id 156 — verified: 'posing as construction workers' confirmed by the affidavit (WRAL conviction story) and the federal complaint (NBC): reflective vests, 'check the pipes'. amount → more than $156,000 (charging documents; initial report $150,000; drop $250,000); notes → assaulted, zip-tied, threatened with mutilation and rape (not 'tortured'); sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion; arrests → convicted (St Felix 47 years; 12 sentenced in the conspiracy).
  • DB id 154 — accept: attackers → three kidnappers plus the couple who paid them; money_wanted → the $51,000 is the kidnappers' fee, move to notes (crypto taken not quantified); weapons → unconfirmed; gap: attack commissioned by aggrieved investors.
  • DB id 153 — accept: theft → 1 (jewellery, watch, chain, phones, cash; no crypto obtained); drugs_alcohol → 1 (narcotics, IPC 328); date → night of 20/21 March 2023; prior acquaintance = yes (the hosts were his friends).
  • DB id 152 — accept: kidnappings → 1, violence_torture → 1, weapons → 1; victim → associate of the intended target Tran Dinh; age 26 vs 29 across reports (note); duration six days per police; sequence Home Invasion → Kidnapping; money_wanted $5M demanded of Tran Dinh, coin_type empty; targeting vector = insider tip-off (government-agency insider); the 1 March driveway attack may need its own record.

Batch 07 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-07.md; evidence in batches/batch-07.json.

  • DB id 151 — accept: amount → $20,000 in BTC (the '1' was a footnote marker); kidnappings → 0 (unconscious, not held); the lure stands: the offer of sex is the invitation that brought her into his apartment (Malicious Invitation kept, description keeps 'lured').
  • DB id 150 — accept: add Ekateryna Khmelenko as second victim; violence_torture → 1 (beating per crypto.ro; threats per Coconuts); sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (police uniform).
  • DB id 147 — accept: foiled at the building entrance (offices not reached); victim → crypto company (target), building concierge (assaulted); kidnappings → 1 (concierge gagged and bound); violence_torture → 1 (struggle, lesiones charge); sequence Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack, attempted Armed Robbery (one posed as a client).
  • DB id 145 — traced: the description is Jameson Lopp's list entry verbatim, citing a Border Report indictment story that carries neither the hardware wallet nor $1.4m (Wayback copy now in the dossier). The hardware-wallet element is real per Bloomberg's 2026 feature (blocked; search snippets: crew led him outside to dig up his hardware wallet, he fled over the fence), but no source gives $1.4m: keep 'sought his buried hardware wallet; he escaped over the fence' and drop the $1.4m unless Bloomberg confirms it. coin_type → empty (cash and jewellery only), money_wanted $150,000 cash; targeting vector: SIM-swapped exchange accounts (account compromise); link to the crew's other records (138, 156).
  • DB id 144 — amount → $45,000 ($20,000 cash + $25,000 crypto wallet); venue unknown (only 'Soi Cherng Talay 16 at about 1am'; no home or room in any source) so Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, Home Invasion to apply only if a source places it at their residence; kidnappings stays 1 ('tied hands', Telegram).
  • DB id 143 — accept: description → responded to a Marktplaats ad to buy bitcoin; kidnappings → 1 (beaten at the address until he transferred); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery kept.
  • DB id 142 — accept: attackers → masked men, number unstated; weapons → 0; money_wanted → 250 BTC (~$17m), coin_type BTC.
  • DB id 141 — accept: ransom → a large amount of Canadian currency, unquantified; weapons → 1; date → 5 December 2022; targeting vector = business counterparty (his own investors).
  • DB id 139 — accept: scenario → Mugging (surrounded at a café table, nothing taken anywhere), gap noted; money_wanted → $3M demanded, $50,000 (1.878M baht) transferred; kidnappings → 1 (held at the table until the transfer); targeting: claimed prior acquaintance; possible link to 175 (Samui, Russians, 2024).
  • DB id 138 — accept: description is Lopp's line; Border Report and DOJ say only 'two victims held at gunpoint in their home'; theft → unconfirmed (jewellery/electronics/cash/Gemini attempt unsourced, likely from the indictment); victim → two victims; coin_type → empty; targeting vector: SIM-swapped exchange accounts; link to 145, 156 (same crew).

Batch 08 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-08.md; evidence in batches/batch-08.json.

  • DB id 137 — accept: coin_type → empty with note 'cash brought to buy BTC' (whether it was taken is not stated; theft rests on the charge); date 12 Sept inferred, keep; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Express Kidnapping.
  • DB id 136 — accept: weapons → 1 (imitation firearm, taser, bat in the boot, charged); note both uniform accounts (police: in the boot; victim: worn at the door); status → charged, not jailed; targeting vector: rival in his own online scene (violence-as-a-service).
  • DB id 134 — accept: money_wanted → Rs 1.3 crore in BTC (drop '8 BTC', unsourced); weapons → 1 (pistol, shots fired); location → Lucknow (held at a house in Barabanki); sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping.
  • DB id 133 — accept: date → 7 August 2022; description → two men waiting inside (entered from the back), beaten, zip-tied to a chair, tasered, no knife; violence_torture → 1; loss → iPhone 13 and two gold bracelets, no bitcoin; replace the bits.media link with Giornale di Brescia (plus Il Giorno, BresciaToday); targeting vector = former collaborator with a pay grievance (business counterparty / insider); one arrested, instigator at large.
  • DB id 130 — accept: attackers → son of the former Mitsubishi Electric CEO plus seven; amount $0.75M (100 million yen per Bunshun); location → Osaka (gym), holding place unknown, arrests by Kyoto police; targeting vector = insider tip-off (gym operator).
  • DB id 128 — accept: kidnappings stays 1 (owner: six men entering and beating him in his own home is detention; nobody admits attackers willingly); date 1 May unsupported on file (keep); coin_type → empty, money_wanted → watches, ring (Dh390,000 / $200,000) and cash; five arrested, one at large, six sentenced; targeting vector = business counterparty (his investors).
  • DB id 126 — accept: weapons → 1 (armed robbery per SVT); date unverifiable on file (keep); both tied and beaten, only the man forced to transfer; follow-up in Swedish reporting pending.
  • DB id 124 — accept: kidnappings → 0 (already ruled); weapons → 1; date → March 2022, day unknown; description → three men, 'armed' resting on the ABC quote; victim name is Krebs's inference; targeting vector = rival (Iza) hiring men; the November 2021 LASD-deputies attempt deserves its own record (Authority Misuse).
  • DB id 123 — accept: attackers → one gunman plus a female accomplice driving a BMW; case kept (crypto link = occupation; watch was the target); targeting vector = public profile / surveillance; outcome note: victim shot five times, survived.
  • DB id 122 — keep as Authority Misuse; date → December 2021 (precision month; original_date 'nearly three months before the 4 March 2022 report'); notes → 'not paid, as far as reported: he reported her and the article states no transfer' (comment, not a sourced fact); no physical element, kept as the pure extortion-by-authority case.

Batch 09 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-09.md; evidence in batches/batch-09.json.

  • DB id 121 — accept: amount → ~$1M total per the victim (watch ~$400K; crypto unquantified, transfer unconfirmed: the phone with the wallet app was taken); kidnappings → 1 (gun to his face, ordered to the ground: not there voluntarily); targeting vector = surveillance of his address.
  • DB id 118 — accept: violence_torture 1 stands firmly (kicked in the face), drop the note's hedge; amount $350,000 (captions say >$300,000); location → Brighton Beach, Brooklyn; sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (package ruse); no crypto taken.
  • DB id 117 — accept: date → 4 February 2022 (day after the 3 Feb drive to Surat); amount → Rs 2 crore in cash brought to the trade (~$260K conversion); attackers → nine or more (Jha plus around eight); violence_torture → 1; weapons → unconfirmed (dacoity, no weapon described); sequence Malicious Invitation → P2P Trade Gone Wrong; targeting vector = acquaintance.
  • DB id 116 — accept: date → 14 January 2022 (2 February is the arrests report); location → Pimpri Chinchwad, Pune (victim of Tathawade; hotel not located); amount → bitcoin worth Rs 300 crore, the police value of his holdings (drop the $50M, the record's own conversion); weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); theft → unconfirmed (released for fear of arrest, no transfer reported); sequence Kidnapping kept, Authority Misuse not applied; targeting vector = insider (constable in the Pune cybercrime cell).
  • DB id 114 — accept: traced; the record's date (26 January 2022) and description (insurance ruse, pushed out, locked the door, video) hold per freelanceinfos.fr of 27 January 2022 (https://freelanceinfos.fr/hasheur-agresse-domicile-cryptomonnaies/), TF1's 'two years ago' is loose; add freelanceinfos as a source and rewrite the summary from it (pending: pull the page into the dossier, checker pass); weapons stays 1 with note 'reported fake' (fibo-crypto timeline, on file under 473); violence_torture stays 0; sequence Costly Fame → Dodged Attack, attempted: Authority Misuse (insurance ruse at the door) and armed extortion at the victim's home.
  • DB id 113 — accept: date → Friday 14 January 2022 (inferred: HLN's report of Thursday 20 January places the arrests at the house on 'Friday morning' and a fourth arrest 'on Wednesday'; the date itself is not printed); victim → 34-year-old man and his 61-year-old mother (visiting); add the companion HLN article as a source for 'teacher' (https://www.hln.be/antwerpen/leraar-34-en-moeder-thuis-overvallen-en-mishandeld-daders-willen-codes-van-kluis-met-3-miljoen-euro-aan-bitcoins~ab232aa8/; pending: pull into the dossier); scenario and flags unchanged; outcome foiled, both victims hospitalised.
  • DB id 111 — accept: location → Lahore; amount → 20 million rupees demanded, 2.5 million rupees paid in bitcoin (about 9 BTC per CCN); description: replace "Over 60 BTC" (CCN sub-headline, does not match the body) with the body figures, 60 BTC logged as unresolved; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (official green plate, three police officials in the ransom); arrests → some (three police officials and two exchangers; Faisal Yousuf named, no arrest stated); outcome empty (release not reported); flags unchanged.
  • DB id 110 — accept: theft → unconfirmed (the release says the victims were "allegedly forced to make phone calls to transfer crypto currency"; no completed transfer stated; charge is Extortion); description → add "allegedly", "cells" plural; sequence Kidnapping kept (forced into cells and held about 30 hours; Kidnapping and Forcible Confinement both charged); whose cells they were is not stated, venue → cells in the same jail, ownership not stated (owner's reading: taken by force from where they were housed and held elsewhere in the jail); attackers are "11 inmates at the Thunder Bay District jail", victims are "two male victims" in a reported "inmate-on-inmate assault"; other flags unchanged; outcome: separated by correctional officers, all 11 charged.
  • DB id 108 — accept: attackers → four (Nicola, a former employee, and Gregory arrested; one Polish and one Russian man wanted); amount → Rp 5.8 billion, drop the $400k (no dollar figure in the source; CNN Indonesia uses Rp 5.8 billion both for the total loss including cash and for the crypto transfers, logged as unresolved); date kept at 11 December 2021 with the conflict logged ("Kamis (11/12)" in the Indonesian text, but 11 December 2021 was a Saturday; the English rendering reads "(12/11)"); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged; targeting vector = insider (former employee); held duration not stated.
  • DB id 112 — parked: waits on the disputed-scenarios decision (see the unlabelled cases section below and disputed-scenarios.md).

Unlabelled cases — owner, 2026-09-30

  • DB ids 399, 409, 468, 11 — keep in the database (owner). They have no scenario only for lack of evidence on file; the label for each is still to be set.
  • 19 disputed cases (3, 6, 10, 57, 62, 66, 101, 105, 112, 198; 21, 349; 99, 383, 449, 450; 24, 45, 195) — pending: owner consulting colleagues on removal versus a new category. See disputed-scenarios.md. Case 112 of batch 09 waits on this.

Batch 10 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-10.md; evidence in batches/batch-10.json.

  • DB id 106 — accept: description → a van with several armed LASD deputies arrived and tried to force E.Z. to hand over his phone; he escaped unharmed and called 911 (November 2021, per the federal complaint as reported); sequence Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack, attempted forcible seizure of his phone; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 0); victim → "E.Z." (identified by the Los Angeles Times as Enzo Zelocchi through court records and interviews); reports → LA Times and KrebsOnSecurity (Article 2 is the Krebs piece, not LA Times); link to 124 (same victim, same instigator Adam Iza, second attempt in March 2022). This is the November 2021 incident the 124 ruling asked to have its own record; no new record needed. Possible further records from the same articles, undecided: R.C. (August 2021, $25,000), L.A. (October 2022, $127,000), D.D. (December 2021 badge visit).
  • DB id 124 — amendment: the victim's identification as Enzo Zelocchi is sourced to the Los Angeles Times (on file under 106), replacing 'Krebs's inference'.
  • DB id 105 — parked: on the disputed-scenarios list (disputed-scenarios.md).
  • DB id 104 — accept: violence_torture → 1 (beaten with hammers, leg fractures requiring hospital treatment, per SCMP's source); theft → unconfirmed (forced to reveal bank and crypto passwords; police: "We believe he suffered a loss ... We are still investigating"); location → Kowloon Bay industrial unit (lure), then a container yard, then a village house in Tai Po; amount HK$30 million kept (raised from HK$8 million), add the HK$4 million Tether trade as the lure; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (trade lure, as ruled in 117); Costly Fame not applied, targeting vector = displayed wealth (supercar and watches, per a police source); outcome rescued (climbed out of a window as police raided on the sixth day); seven arrested, about eight sought.
  • DB id 103 — accept: description → attackers tortured him for access to a wallet holding 500 BTC and failed to open it (a joint action with his manager was needed); remove 'take tens of millions of euros in bitcoin'; theft → 1 (five Rolex watches valued at 68,400 euros and two bank cards); money_wanted → 500 BTC (25 million euros per the sentencing report), none obtained; coin_type → BTC; add the maintenance technician as second victim (struck, pepper-sprayed, tied to a chair, held nearly four hours); sequence: Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (posed as a friend of a friend to arrange a meeting at his home); other flags unchanged; four men sentenced to nine years after a plea deal (each or in total not stated); pending: find and link the URL of the sentencing report (sheet credits 'El Pais, Iustel', no URL), the only source for the weapons, the 500 BTC, the Rolexes and the technician.
  • DB id 102 — accept: description → at least five people came to steal the mining machines; the miners opened fire to stop them and one miner (Pachial R.G., in custody) shot his own friend dead at close range, per the prosecutor's statement; location → village of Aatsy, Abkhazia; victim Ardzibna kept, variant spelling Ardzinba noted; violence_torture stays 1 (owner: a man shot dead counts, as the fatal stabbing in 215); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 1); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, attempted theft of mining equipment, gap: the death came from a defender's gun; arrests: none of the raiders reported; kept in the database regardless of the disputed-scenarios decision on 21 and 349 (people present, one death).
  • DB ids 101, 99 — parked: on the disputed-scenarios list (disputed-scenarios.md).
  • DB id 97 — accept, with the owner's ruling on the death: stabbed and drowned (owner). Source basis: stabbed more than twenty times, no blow fatal in itself, 'agonizing when thrown into the pond'; the article states no cause of death, so the summary keeps the article's wording and the notes carry 'stabbed and drowned' as the owner's reading. Attackers → five suspects, four men and one woman (the lover is a 33-year-old man; his twin brother and the brother's female companion charged with complicity); theft → unconfirmed (the five 'dreamed of stealing' the 200,000 euros; no loss reported), money_wanted 200,000 EUR kept as the sum targeted; drugs_alcohol stays 1, alleged (three suspects' account, toxicology pending); location → lured to a home in Plancher-les-Mines, body found in a pond in Plancher-Bas; sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (lured to the attackers' premises), gap: holding and transport not described; other flags unchanged; targeting vector = intimate partner; all five in custody.
  • DB id 96 — accept: violence_torture → 1 (hit by at least four bullets; consistent with 102 and 215); add the second victim, a passenger injured and taken to hospital; date 8 August 2021 kept, unverified (CryptoNews gives no date for the killing); description keeps the hedge (the social-media link is the outlet's argument, no police statement); sequence Costly Fame kept, resting on that hedge; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 1); arrests none reported; kept in the database, flagged 'motive not established' (nothing demanded, nothing taken).
  • DB id 94 — accept: amount → about HK$3.29 million in cash (the bag's contents per SCMP), kept in Hong Kong dollars; the article's '(US$128,500)' does not match HK$3 million at the peg (roughly US$385,000) and is not used; date 28 July 2021 kept (the article says 'Wednesday'; 28 July 2021 was a Wednesday); victim → 39-year-old South Korean trader; location → Astoria Building, Ashley Road, Tsim Sha Tsui; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1); coin_type stays fiat (cash brought to the trade); no arrests.

Batch 11 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30

Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-11.md; evidence in batches/batch-11.json.

  • DB id 93 — accept: kidnappings → 1 (pushed into a cell at the FCID Annex and held for hours); violence_torture → 1 (beaten at the roadside and again at the station); amount → N22 million in bitcoin transferred, N20 million demanded as bail, drop '$50K USD' (the article deals only in naira); victims → Morakinyo Tobiloba Peter and Yusuf Samson Dayo; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (owner: held at a fixed place the attackers control, so not Express Kidnapping; see the rule adopted below), gap: opportunistic traffic stop, same-night extraction from the victims' own account; other flags unchanged (weapons 1, theft 1); single source, the victims' account to SaharaReporters; no arrest or discipline reported; outcome 'released' inferred.
  • Rule adopted (owner, 2026-09-30), Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping — Express Kidnapping: seized in public and made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle. Kidnapping: taken to a fixed place the attackers control, or a ransom demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label.
  • Rule widened (owner, 2026-09-30) — Kidnapping: taken to a place away from the public where the attackers hold them (a building or a remote outdoor spot), or transported over a long distance, or a ransom demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. Under this wording 217, 168, 295, 386, 214 and 203 stay Kidnapping.
  • Express Kidnapping → Kidnapping (owner) — DB ids 93 (cell at the officers' station), 224 (warehouse in Steel Town), 491 (shack in woodland).
  • Kidnapping → Express Kidnapping (owner) — DB ids 172 (van, own funds; supersedes 'Kidnapping kept per the charge'), 80 (taken on a drive and made to transfer), 7 (held in vehicles until morning), 19 (held in a van for two hours while his apartment was emptied).
  • Stay Express Kidnapping (owner, borderline cases) — DB ids 279 (forced to call his brother to move 1,000 BTC), 367 (14 BTC demanded within 24 hours), 462 (driven to Cravinhos; holding place not stated).
  • Not screened under the rule: the 24 Kidnapping cases with no venue recorded and the first 70 verified cases, which carry no venue field.