Archived
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
205 lines
32 KiB
Plaintext
205 lines
32 KiB
Plaintext
====================================================================================================
|
||
LOPP L162 | Li Kuo-hsiang | March 22, 2024 | Taiwan
|
||
====================================================================================================
|
||
|
||
STATUS new
|
||
|
||
PROPOSED RECORD [new case from Lopp's list, PR 234; read by two readers; flags and obtained re-read 2026-10-17 under the owner's definitions (empty = unknown); no operator has reviewed it; no stats2 id yet]
|
||
date March 22, 2024
|
||
victim Li Kuo-hsiang
|
||
location Xitun District, Taichung
|
||
country Taiwan
|
||
description A man who had learned in a Telegram group that Li Kuo-hsiang wanted to buy TWD 6.42 million in cryptocurrency arranged a fake sale at Li's studio in Taichung and, with an accomplice, tried to snatch the cash; Li was concussed in the fight and pepper-sprayed, and the victims pinned one attacker while the organiser fled. Three men were convicted of attempted aggravated snatch theft.
|
||
detention no
|
||
violence_torture yes
|
||
drugs_alcohol (unknown)
|
||
weapons yes
|
||
theft unconfirmed
|
||
life_taken 0
|
||
venue_of_control none
|
||
held_duration none
|
||
arrests convicted
|
||
demanded no demand; the attackers tried to snatch the TWD 6.42 million trade cash
|
||
taken nothing taken, as the court found; the victims had first said about TWD 840,000 was missing
|
||
notes Single source: the first-instance judgment of the Taichung District Court (113 訴 755, December 11, 2024), primary record, read in full (about 15,700 characters). Victim's name is given in full in the published judgment. Location: the studio address is redacted; the car waited at the corner of Chongqing Road and Qinghai Road in Xitun District, below the studio. Approach P2P trade: a crypto-for-cash meeting the organiser arranged through two Telegram contacts. Targeting Online contact or advert: the organiser learned of Li's wish to buy in a Telegram group. Attack Armed robbery: attempted theft by force with a weapon (pepper spray), no holding; the court's offence is snatch theft, attempted. Outcome Fought off: the two victims resisted, pinned one attacker and the organiser fled. Who was attacked Other for 簡思修: present, sprayed and fought; the judgment does not say whether he is staff, a partner or a friend (the defence witness calls the people who gathered the cash 'their two colleagues', which may or may not include him). Nobody died.
|
||
|
||
CHANGES OF 2026-10-17
|
||
drugs_alcohol: no -> (empty)
|
||
theft: no -> unconfirmed
|
||
obtained: Nothing -> Unconfirmed
|
||
re-read note: Theft is disputed: the victims told police TWD 840,000 was missing; the court could not confirm it and, giving the defendants the benefit of the doubt, found the robbery attempted only (未遂). Owner call: unconfirmed (the sources disagree) or no (the court's finding, the old value). Detention no: a grab at the cash bags that the victims fought; the only person held was an attacker, pinned by the victims. Pepper spray counted as a weapon (the court calls it 兇器), not as a drug.
|
||
|
||
FOUR-STEP LABELS
|
||
targeting Online contact or advert
|
||
targeting_accuracy Correct
|
||
who_was_attacked Holder; Other
|
||
approach P2P trade
|
||
attack Armed robbery
|
||
outcome Fought off
|
||
obtained Unconfirmed
|
||
|
||
PEOPLE ATTACKED
|
||
Holder: 1 (the studio manager buying the crypto); Other: 1 (a second man in the studio who handled the cash)
|
||
|
||
PUBLIC SUMMARY [plain English, the text the site shows]
|
||
On March 22, 2024, Li Kuo-hsiang, manager of a studio in Xitun District, Taichung, Taiwan, was to
|
||
buy TWD 6.42 million in cryptocurrency. A man who had learned of the planned purchase in a Telegram
|
||
group arranged the trade at the studio, intending to snatch the cash, and brought two accomplices;
|
||
one waited in a car below. He brought no crypto. At about 18:44, as Li and a second man bagged the
|
||
counted cash, he gave a signal, his accomplice overturned the table and the two tried to seize the
|
||
bags, which tore and spilled the cash. In the fight Li suffered a concussion and a wrist injury, and
|
||
the organiser pepper-sprayed both victims. They pinned down the accomplice while the organiser fled
|
||
in the waiting car. All three were arrested by the next day. The court found no cash was taken and
|
||
in December 2024 sentenced the three to between 1 year and 1 year 6 months.
|
||
|
||
CASE DETAILS [internal evidence record, quotations in the original language]
|
||
**Victims:** 李國祥 (Li Kuo-hsiang), manager (店長) of the 「橘子與熊工作室」 studio where the trade took place,
|
||
who wanted to buy cryptocurrency worth TWD 6.42 million. A second man, 簡思修, was in the studio with
|
||
him, helped pack the cash and was sprayed too; the judgment does not state his role. A partner of
|
||
the victim (被害人合夥人) is mentioned in the police scene report.
|
||
**Attackers:** 蔡佳佑 (organiser; brought a POLICE-brand pepper spray without telling the others), 林鈺倫
|
||
(entered the studio with him), 張君緯 (drove from Kaohsiung and waited in the car below to pick them
|
||
up). 蔡佳佑 contacted 李國祥 through two Telegram contacts nicknamed 「劉德華」 and 「飛」, who did not know of
|
||
the plan ("進而透過不知計畫之「劉德華」、「飛」聯絡李國祥").
|
||
**Attack Method:** 蔡佳佑 learned in a Telegram group that 李國祥 wanted to buy TWD 6.42 million of crypto
|
||
and planned to pose as a seller and snatch the cash ("即萌生以兜售虛擬貨幣為名、實則搶奪交易現金之計畫"). The trade was set
|
||
for the afternoon of March 22 at the studio. 蔡佳佑 and 林鈺倫 put on masks and entered at about 18:23;
|
||
蔡佳佑 brought no crypto. After the cash was counted and split into two kraft-paper bags, 蔡佳佑 gave the
|
||
agreed hand signal, 林鈺倫 overturned the table and they tried to seize the bags; 簡思修 grabbed the bags
|
||
and 李國祥 intervened; the bags tore and the cash spilled.
|
||
**Violence Used:** No detention: nobody was brought under the attackers' control; the attackers
|
||
fought the two victims, and 林鈺倫 was himself pinned down by them. 李國祥 suffered a contusion of the
|
||
left side of the head with concussion and abrasions to the right wrist ("左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪、右側腕部擦挫傷之傷勢");
|
||
蔡佳佑 sprayed pepper spray in the faces of both victims. 林鈺倫 punched 李國祥 in the back of the head and
|
||
neck, by Li's police statement; 簡思修 told police Li was hit on the head with an object from the
|
||
office. 蔡佳佑 alone was convicted of the form aggravated by carrying a weapon ("結夥攜帶兇器搶奪未遂罪"), the
|
||
pepper spray; the court found the victims were not rendered unable to resist, so the offence was
|
||
snatch theft (搶奪), not robbery (強盜) as charged.
|
||
**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Target: TWD 6,420,000 in trade cash. Li and 簡思修 told police and
|
||
prosecutors that about TWD 840,000 (or 700,000 to 800,000) was missing after 蔡佳佑 grabbed cash from
|
||
the floor; at trial both said they could not confirm he took any. On the CCTV and the doubts, the
|
||
court held that he took none ("應認蔡佳佑於本案衝突後並未拿取現場之交易現金84萬元,而本案搶奪應僅止於未遂階段").
|
||
**Status:** 林鈺倫 was arrested at the scene that evening; 蔡佳佑 was detained at 04:02 and 張君緯 at 10:40
|
||
the next day. On December 11, 2024 the Taichung District Court sentenced 蔡佳佑 to 1 year 6 months for
|
||
attempted aggravated snatch theft by a group carrying a weapon, 林鈺倫 to 1 year 2 months and 張君緯 to 1
|
||
year for attempted group snatch theft. All three had settled with 李國祥 and paid compensation.
|
||
|
||
OPEN QUESTIONS FOR THE OWNER
|
||
1. (theft) The court found, on the CCTV and in favour of the accused, that no cash was taken, and theft no / obtained Nothing follow the judgment. But the victims told police and prosecutors that about TWD 840,000 was missing after the organiser grabbed cash from the floor, and the police scene report records the partner's claim of about 840,000 snatched; the court's finding is a benefit-of-the-doubt ruling, not a positive finding that nothing went missing.
|
||
set to: no (obtained Nothing) | alternative: unconfirmed (obtained Unconfirmed)
|
||
evidence: 依「有疑利益歸被告」原則,應認蔡佳佑於本案衝突後並未拿取現場之交易現金84萬元
|
||
|
||
SECOND READER
|
||
rewritten after the second reader: summary: cut from about 935 to about 870 characters (shortened
|
||
the bagging clause, merged the arrest sentence into 'All three were arrested by the next day')
|
||
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: dropped the para 40 quote and the 'not shown to
|
||
have taken part' claim, replaced with para 23's statement that the two Telegram contacts did not
|
||
know of the plan; dropped 'Appealable' (para 120, cut); the weapon ruling now rests on the operative
|
||
charge in para 98 instead of the cut reasoning in paras 48 to 51
|
||
|
||
LOPP'S ENTRY
|
||
March 22 2024 | Li Kuo-hsiang | Taichung, Xitun District, Taiwan
|
||
Tsai Chia-yu set up a fake sale to buyer Li Kuo-hsiang of TWD 6,420,000 in crypto at a Taichung
|
||
studio with two accomplices and pepper spray; on the signal an accomplice overturned the table to
|
||
grab the cash bags, the victims resisted and the money spilled, and Li was injured in the struggle.
|
||
Li and a friend pinned one attacker until police arrived; Tsai fled but was arrested hours later,
|
||
along with the driver.
|
||
differs: Lopp: 'Li and a friend pinned one attacker'; the judgment names the second man (簡思修) without stating his relationship to Li.
|
||
differs: Lopp: 'Tsai fled but was arrested hours later, along with the driver'; the judgment says Tsai was detained at 04:02 and the driver at 10:40 the next day, March 23.
|
||
differs: Lopp: 'an accomplice overturned the table to grab the cash bags, the victims resisted and the money spilled'; matches. Lopp does not mention the court's finding that nothing was taken.
|
||
|
||
LINKED SOURCES
|
||
1. https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TCDM%2C113%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C755%2C20241211%2C5
|
||
|
||
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
FETCHED ARTICLE 1
|
||
Source judgment.judicial.gov.tw
|
||
URL https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TCDM%2C113%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C755%2C20241211%2C5
|
||
Published (not given)
|
||
Retrieved 2026-10-16T14:29:49Z via raw HTTP retrieval (status 200); page furniture cut by paragraph range (kept 2, 17-23, 28, 52-66, 88-95, 97-101, 104-105, 109, 115 of 155), article text unchanged
|
||
Language as published (kept in the original language, not translated)
|
||
Length 7,577 chars
|
||
Integrity sha256 556b6e5aece72c439fac18703ce9fb5c91956d3c4899fdb43f85c6f7cb1547ba
|
||
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
臺灣臺中地方法院 113 年度訴字第 755 號刑事判決
|
||
|
||
上列被告等因強盜等案件,經檢察官提起公訴(113 年度偵字第17340 號),本院判決如下:
|
||
|
||
主 文
|
||
|
||
一、蔡佳佑犯結夥攜帶兇器搶奪未遂罪,處有期徒刑壹年陸月。扣案之辣椒水噴霧劑壹瓶及藍色iPhone廠牌手機壹支(含門號0000000000號SIM 卡壹張)沒收。
|
||
|
||
二、林鈺倫犯結夥搶奪未遂罪,處有期徒刑壹年貳月。
|
||
|
||
三、張君緯犯結夥搶奪未遂罪,處有期徒刑壹年。
|
||
|
||
犯罪事實
|
||
|
||
蔡佳佑於民國113 年3 月22日前某日,在其與真實姓名年籍不詳綽號「劉德華」、「飛」之即時通訊軟體TELEGRAM群組內,得知李國祥欲購買價值新臺幣(下同)642 萬元之虛擬貨幣之訊息,即萌生以兜售虛擬貨幣為名、實則搶奪交易現金之計畫,進而透過不知計畫之「劉德華」、「飛」聯絡李國祥,與李國祥約定於同年3 月22日下午,在臺中市○○區○○路00號5 樓之3 李國祥擔任店長之「橘子與熊工作室」內交易虛擬貨幣。蔡佳佑為能遂行其搶奪計劃,乃於同年3 月21日晚間某時,邀林鈺倫、張君緯共同參與,約定於同年3 月22日前往「橘子與熊工作室」;蔡佳佑並準備客觀上足供作兇器使用之POLICE廠牌辣椒水噴霧劑1 瓶,供己行搶時使用(惟準備辣椒水噴霧劑乙事並未讓林鈺倫、張君緯知悉)。同年3 月22日12時許,張君瑋駕駛車牌號碼000-0000號自小客車,搭載蔡佳佑及林鈺倫,自高雄市○○區○○街00號18樓之1 其3 人平日聚會所出發,前往「橘子與熊工作室」。途中,坐在副駕駛座之蔡佳佑向林鈺倫及張君緯表明將搶奪虛擬貨幣交易現金之計畫,而駕駛小客車之張君緯及坐在駕駛座後方座位之林鈺倫旋均聽聞且知悉上揭搶奪計畫內容。3 人於同日18時14分許,抵達臺中市西屯區重慶路與青海路路口(即「橘子與熊工作室」所在之1 樓路邊),張君緯即依蔡佳佑指示,駕車在該處等待,隨時準備接應蔡佳佑及林鈺倫。蔡佳佑及林鈺倫則於同日18時23分許戴上口罩,步入「橘子與熊工作室」,準備與工作室內之李國祥、簡思修交易虛擬貨幣(蔡佳佑當日並未攜虛擬貨幣到場)。過程中,蔡佳佑乘其與林鈺倫至工作室外抽菸時,告知林鈺倫:稍後如見其手勢(手掌朝上比一下)示意,即由林鈺倫掀桌、2 人共同搶錢等語。其後,同日18時44分許,蔡佳佑與林鈺倫返回上開工作室內,蔡佳佑偕當時在工作室內之李國祥、簡思修清點交易虛擬貨幣之現金642 萬元,而李國祥、簡思修將現金分裝至2 個牛皮紙袋,且等待蔡佳佑交付虛擬貨幣時,蔡佳佑突向林鈺倫以約定之手勢示意,林鈺倫旋依約掀桌,欲搶奪該2 個裝有現金之牛皮紙袋。簡思修見狀,迅速抓住該2 個牛皮紙袋;李國祥並上前阻止現金遭搶;該2 個牛皮紙袋因雙方拉扯而破損,致袋內之現金散落一地。過程中,蔡佳佑、林鈺倫與李國祥、簡思修發生肢體衝突、扭打,致李國祥受有左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪、右側腕部擦挫傷之傷勢,蔡佳佑復自口袋內取出預先備好之前揭辣椒水噴霧劑1 瓶,朝李國祥、簡思修臉部噴灑(林鈺倫此時方知蔡佳佑攜帶並使用辣椒水噴霧劑);李國祥、簡思修雖因此受刺激而眼睛無法完全張開,李國祥並略覺頭暈,惟2 人仍能目視現場情況,簡思修旋以手扣住林鈺倫脖子,並與李國祥將林鈺倫壓制在地,蔡佳佑見狀則乘機衝出「橘子與熊工作室」,下樓逃上張君緯駕駛等候接應之前揭自小客車,離開臺中市。蔡佳佑與林鈺倫終未搶得李國祥交易虛擬貨幣之現金,因而其等搶奪未得逞。嗣蔡佳佑於同日19時12分許撥打電話報警,佯稱友人在「橘子與熊工作室」交易虛擬貨幣久未回覆,擔心其人身安全,須警前往查看云云;經警於同日19時58分後某時,到場逮捕遭壓制之林鈺倫,再持臺灣臺中地方檢察署檢察官核發之拘票,於翌(23)日4 時2 分許,至其平時聚會所前址拘提蔡佳佑,扣得其聯絡林鈺倫、張君緯使用之藍色iPhone廠牌手機1 支(IMEI:000000000000000,含門號0000000000號SIM卡1 張),並在本案車輛內扣得蔡佳佑行搶時所用之辣椒水噴霧劑1 瓶;另持臺灣臺中地方檢察署檢察官核發之拘票,於翌(23)日10時40分許,在臺中市西屯區市○路000 號拘提張君緯。
|
||
|
||
犯罪事實欄所示之客觀事實,業據蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯於本院準備程序及審理時坦承不諱(蔡佳佑部分見偵卷第47至57、243 至251 頁、聲羈卷第29至35、39至40頁、本院卷一第51至58、127 至139 、441 至527 頁、本院卷二第15至129 頁、本院卷三第107 頁;林鈺倫部分見偵卷第69至71、79至80、81至83、89至94、255 至260 、311 至313 頁、聲羈卷第25至29、39至40頁、本院卷一第59至64、127 至139 、441 至527 頁、本院卷二第15至129 頁、本院卷三第107 頁;張君緯部分見偵卷第99至105 、263 至265 頁、聲羈卷第35至40頁、本院卷一第65至69、127 至139 、441 至527 頁、本院卷二第15至129 、341 至344 頁、本院卷三第107 頁),核與如附表所示證人之證述相符(證據出處各如附表所示),復有如附表所示之非供述證據在卷可佐(證據出處各如附表所示),該部分事實,堪先予認定。
|
||
|
||
㈢、本案搶奪應僅止於未遂階段
|
||
|
||
⒈經查:
|
||
|
||
⑴李國祥
|
||
|
||
①於警詢時證稱:蔡佳佑趁我跟簡思修被林鈺倫攻擊時,掙脫後就拿走散落地板的一部分現金,後來經清點,被拿走84萬元,然後從門口逃走等語(偵卷第112 頁);於偵查時證稱:對方趁機去把牛皮紙袋撕破(可能是簡思修有跟他互相搶紙袋),蔡佳佑就抱一把現金直接走了,林鈺倫被簡思修制止,我就趕快幫簡思修一起拖住他,馬上報警,後來警方到場,我們點鈔票,發現短少84萬元等語(偵卷第318 頁)。
|
||
|
||
②惟於本院審理時改證稱:我沒辦法確認當時蔡佳佑手上有無抱現金走;清點被拿走84萬元,這是我們同仁跟警方在現場清點,我後續才知道;我不知是誰去點錢;我沒有清點,清點時我不在現場;我知道84萬元,是警方跟我說的;我看到蔡佳佑拿錢袋的動作,一開始他們就是去搶奪錢袋,後來我看到他有疑似抱著東西的動作,所以主觀上判斷他抱著金錢而不是其他東西;蔡佳佑是雙手環抱的手勢;我也沒辦法確定蔡佳佑有無打開後背包把錢放進去等語(本院卷一第458 頁)。證人李國祥前後所述顯有不一,且其並未參與清點現場之現金,亦無法確認蔡佳佑是否取走現場交易現金中之84萬元。
|
||
|
||
⑵簡思修
|
||
|
||
①於警詢時證稱:李國祥有被對方拿公司內的東西毆打,好像有打頭部,之後蔡佳佑掙脫我,抓取地上散落之現金一把(詳細金額我不清楚),就往門外逃跑等語(偵卷第126 頁);於偵查時證稱:李國祥被噴辣椒水後有點無力、頭暈,就把手放開,蔡佳佑看到李國祥鬆手,我手上又攔了一個人,就經過我旁邊去拿現金離開;我有看到蔡佳佑從地板上用雙手抱起一把現金離開,現場太混亂,我不知道他拿走多少;事後有點鈔,有70、80萬元不見等語(偵卷第319 頁)。
|
||
|
||
②惟於本院審理時先證稱:我把林鈺倫扣住後,蔡佳佑就進來往地上抓一把錢,也不知道多少,就往外跑等語(本院卷一第497 頁;嗣又改證稱:從蔡佳佑拿錢噴辣椒水後,我不能確定有看到他手上拿著錢;我有看到他蹲下去拿錢的動作,但他跑出去的當下,我不能確定他手上到底有沒有錢,也不知道他有沒有放進他的背包裡;錢可能在蔡佳佑的背包裡,但這是我的推測,我並沒有看到;事後是誰去清點現場還剩多錢,我不知道;我去樓下叫救護車,所以清點時我不在場;我也不清楚錢是警察在場時清點的,還是警察還沒來之前就清點完了等語(本院卷一第501 至504 、522 頁)。足見簡思修雖目睹蔡佳佑有蹲下取物之動作,但並未清點現場之現金,亦無法確認蔡佳佑是否確實取走現場之交易現金84萬元。
|
||
|
||
⒉參以:
|
||
|
||
⑴林鈺倫於本院審理時證稱:⑴我在走廊上被李國祥、簡思修壓制,我被李國祥打,後來他們將我再帶回工作室裡,李國祥叫我坐在椅子上;我當時雖然氣喘發作,但我坐在椅子上,工作室裡的情況我看得清楚;當時他們有兩位同事,將散落地上的錢給撿走;警方來的時候,沒有人將錢交給警方,因為他們兩個同事已將錢拿走了;現場也沒有人告訴警方總共被搶走多少錢;⑵蔡佳佑跑走前,我看到他有要去摸錢的動作,但沒有看到他抱一把錢,然後跑走;從我們進到工作室到蔡佳佑跑走,他的後背包都一直背著,即使在等交易的過程,也沒有拿下來等語(本院卷二第59至61頁)。足見林鈺倫並未目擊蔡佳佑有拿取現場之交易現金,而警方到場前,現場之交易現金亦已由工作室之人員取走。
|
||
|
||
⑵張淙榆於本院審理時證稱:我到工作室現場時,沒有看到現金,現金已經被他們撿起來,清點完畢了;我到現場,有聽到李國祥說錢有少,但他們因被噴辣椒水,沒有辦法清點到底不見多少錢;金額到底被搶走80萬元還是84萬元,要問李國祥,因為是他們清點的;我只能確定確實有人搶走了錢,這是現場發生後,李國祥他們立刻跟我說的等語(本院卷三第64至65頁)。可見張淙榆案發後亦未清點交易之現金,現金有無短少乙事,係聽聞自李國祥。
|
||
|
||
⑶臺中市政府警察局第六分局刑案現場勘察報告關於「現場勘察所見情形」記載略以:由被害人合夥人徐國豪等指出另名白衣嫌犯搶奪現金約84萬元後逃逸而去等情,有第六分局刑案現場勘察報告在卷可查(本院卷一第201 頁),惟據徐國豪於警詢時證稱:我不知現場損失如何等語(偵卷第136 頁)。而上揭勘察報告亦記載:現場辦公桌傾倒,物品凌亂顯有打鬥跡象,地面遺留些許血跡乙節,對照現場照片,未見有何鈔票散落工作室現場,有第六分局刑案現場勘察報告暨刑案現場照片存卷可參(本院卷一第201 、208 至210 頁)。互核可見徐國豪不知案發時有無損失及損失之情形,而員警抵達工作室時,現場亦無遺留交易現金。
|
||
|
||
⑷員警職務報告關於「何人撿拾並清點鈔票」記載雖以:本分局接獲民眾報案後,前往「橘子與熊工作室」時,現場未有散落鈔票,且現場員工李國祥表示,散落鈔票已撿拾整理後清算金額等情,有員警職務報告及本院電話紀錄表附卷可稽(本院卷二第211 、230-1 頁),然據李國祥於本院審理中之前揭證述,足見李國祥並未參與清點現場之現金,亦無法確認蔡佳佑是否取走現場交易現金中之84萬元。
|
||
|
||
⑸本院勘驗「橘子與熊工作室所在辦公室(走廊)及電梯監視器影像光碟」結果顯示:監視器顯示時間19時6 分29秒至19時6 分42秒間,可見李國祥帶著蔡佳佑走進工作室,林鈺倫跟在蔡佳佑後方;於監視器顯示時間19時12分34秒至19時15分14秒,可見蔡佳佑背著後背包自工作室跑出來,跑動時雙手在身體兩側隨著擺動,後方李國祥將林鈺倫壓制在地上,兩人均倒在地上;蔡佳佑背著後背包步出玻璃門,左手沒有拿東西,右手呈握住東西的姿態,拿著一個底部圓形之物,應可確定不是紙鈔等情,有本院勘驗筆錄在卷可稽(本院卷一第446 至448 頁)。顯見蔡佳佑跑出工作室至走廊時,並無李國祥於警詢時證述之「抱一把現金」或於審判時證述之「雙手環抱」之手勢,亦無簡思修於警詢時證稱之「用雙手抱起一把現金」之動作;衡以,自蔡佳佑步入工作室至跑出工作室,期間約6 分鐘,復依李國祥於本院審理時證稱:從蔡佳佑去拿錢到他逃走跑出走廊,這中間大概過1 分鐘左右等語(本院卷一第459 頁),假設蔡佳佑有如李國祥、簡思修於警偵中所證述已取得現場之交易現金,實殊難想像蔡佳佑於1 分鐘內,跑出工作室之同時,又能將84萬元如此大筆之現金放入背包內。
|
||
|
||
⑹參合以觀,復依「有疑利益歸被告」原則,應認蔡佳佑於本案衝突後並未拿取現場之交易現金84萬元,而本案搶奪應僅止於未遂階段。
|
||
|
||
㈦、至公訴意旨雖認蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯本案所為係成立刑法第330 條第1 項之結夥三人以上強盜罪等語。經查:
|
||
|
||
⒈搶奪與強盜雖同具不法得財之意思,然搶奪係乘人不備,公然掠取他人之財物,如施用強暴脅迫,至使不能抗拒而取其財物或令其交付者,則為強盜罪。亦即,行為人取得動產之行為,如係當場直接侵害動產之持有人之自由意思,然其所使用之不法腕力,客觀上尚未達完全抑制動產之持有人自由意思之程度者,應成立搶奪罪。
|
||
|
||
⒉本院之判斷
|
||
|
||
⑴林鈺倫於偵查中以證人身分證述:蔡佳佑把手掌往上比,示意我翻桌,我翻桌了,蔡佳佑跟對方2 個就打起來,並噴辣椒水,我把他們拉開,蔡佳佑跑了,我就被留下來等語(偵卷第259 頁);其本院審理中以證人身分證述:翻桌後對方與蔡佳佑扭打在一起,我把對方跟蔡佳佑拉開;那時蔡佳佑就突然對著他們噴一罐不明物體,李國祥他們被蔡佳佑噴液體後,有繼續抵抗、扭打;蔡佳佑離開工作室現場時,我被壓制,被拉到走廊,我被李國祥打等語(本院卷二第29至60頁)。
|
||
|
||
⑵李國祥於警詢時證稱:林鈺倫直接翻桌,蔡佳佑就掏出不明之噴霧,向我及簡思修的臉部噴灑;該噴霧噴到眼睛內,我感覺刺痛,鼻子吸入不明噴霧後感覺暈眩;我跟簡思修一開始先控制住蔡佳佑,跟他拉扯時,袋中之現金就散落至地板,林鈺倫就用拳頭攻擊我後腦杓及脖子,試圖將我拉開蔡佳佑身邊,之後蔡佳佑趁我跟簡思修被林鈺倫攻擊時掙脫,順勢之從門口逃走,我跟簡思修就改壓制林鈺倫等語(偵卷第112 頁);於偵查中結證:我衝上前抱住其中一人,錢由簡思修護著,另一個就瘋狂打我頭部,簡思修看到我被毆打,就上前幫我制止另一個,錢就放在原地,我抱住的那個人,看到簡思修上來制止林鈺倫,就趁機從口袋拿出一小罐噴霧型的液體,朝我臉部噴射,也噴到我的眼睛,我吸到那個液體,開始發暈,就把手放開,開始四肢無力,對方就趁機去把牛皮紙袋撕破,另一個人被簡思修制止,我趕快去幫簡思修一起拖住等語(偵卷第318 頁);於本院審理中證稱:蔡佳佑拿出不明噴霧噴我的臉部,我當下有點神智不清,但還是有稍微的力氣,當下眼睛不會有不適,只是會頭暈暈眩,但後續我還是有做一些阻止的動作;被噴完後大約30秒至2 分鐘不能睜開眼睛,看得模糊暈眩,被噴完後倒在地上,但還是有餘力可以去控制,所以我當時有跟簡思修一起去控制林鈺倫;蔡佳佑逃走後,我追到門口,指示其他剛進來的同事,幫我追趕蔡佳佑等語(本院卷一第457 至485 頁)。
|
||
|
||
⑶簡思修於警詢時證稱:李國祥有被對方拿公司內的東西毆打頭部,之後蔡佳佑掙脫我,往門外逃跑,我有被噴到辣椒水,所以眼睛張不太開,我叫一名同事去追蔡佳佑;我因為擔心李國祥,所以回辦公室跟他一起抓住林鈺倫等語(偵卷第126 頁);於偵查中證稱:蔡佳佑突然拿出一瓶東西噴我跟李國祥的臉 ,我有即時擋住,沒有受傷,李國祥被噴了之後就有點無力、頭暈,就把手放開,蔡佳佑看到李國祥鬆手了,我手上又攔著一個人,就經過我旁邊走去拿現金離開等語(偵卷第319 頁);於本院審理時證稱:噴霧有點刺鼻味,眼睛有被噴到,但沒有感覺,沒有不舒服,有點暈暈,被噴到的當下,眼睛確實張不開,就像汗水或雨水那樣的感覺;林鈺倫當時沒什麼反抗,因為我一隻手扣住他,一直壓制住他;李國祥被噴後,就衝出去追人,主要壓制林鈺倫的人是我等語(本院卷一第499 至525 頁)。
|
||
|
||
⑷本院勘驗「橘子與熊工作室所在辦公室(走廊)及電梯監視器影像光碟」結果亦顯示:蔡佳佑自工作室跑出來,後方李國祥將林鈺倫壓制在地,嗣兩人爬起後,簡思修以左手肘壓制林鈺倫之頸部,李國祥則示意一名從外面進來之男子往外追,李國祥自己也往外追;後續可見簡思修以左手肘勾著林鈺倫之頸部,李國祥又上前毆打林鈺倫數拳,有本院勘驗筆錄附卷可稽(本院卷一第446 至447 頁)。與上揭李國祥、簡思修所述互核,益堪認李國祥、簡思修在工作室中,雖受蔡佳佑以辣椒水噴霧劑噴灑臉部及眼睛,但仍均能壓制林鈺倫,李國祥亦能追趕蔡佳佑,其等實有意思自由,而均未達「至使不能抗拒」或「難以抗拒」之程度,自與強盜罪之要件不符。
|
||
|
||
㈧、綜上,本案事證明確,蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯之犯行堪以認定,應予依法論科。
|
||
|
||
㈠、罪名
|
||
|
||
⒈蔡佳佑所為,係犯刑法第326 條第2 項、第1 項之結夥攜帶兇器搶奪未遂罪(即具有同法第321 條第1 項第3 款、第4 款之加重事由)。
|
||
|
||
⒉林鈺倫、張君緯所為,均係犯刑法第326 條第2 項、第1 項之結夥搶奪未遂罪(即具有同法第321 第第1 項第4 款之加重事由)。
|
||
|
||
⒊公訴意旨雖認其等所為係犯刑法第330 條第1 項之結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜罪(下稱加重強盜罪),然蔡佳佑、林鈺倫尚無完全抑制李國祥、簡思修之自由意思而至使其等不能抗拒之程度,自不能令蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯擔負加重強盜罪責,業如前述,公訴意旨此部分容有誤會,惟社會基本事實相同,且經本院於審理時已當告知此部分罪名,無礙蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯之訴訟防禦權,爰依法變更起訴法條。
|
||
|
||
⒋蔡佳佑、林鈺倫於搶奪過程中與李國祥發生肢體衝突、扭打,固係一種暴行行為,惟係屬蔡佳佑、林鈺倫實施搶奪行為在掠奪之際所為之暴行之範圍,雖李國祥因此受有左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪、右側腕部擦挫傷之傷勢,惟其等並無另有傷害李國祥之犯意,此項傷害行為,應吸收於搶奪行為之內,不另為罪。
|
||
|
||
㈢、未遂犯
|
||
|
||
蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯雖已著手實施搶奪犯行,惟因其未取得財物而僅止於未遂階段,所生損害較既遂犯為輕,爰依刑法第25條第2 項規定,按既遂犯之刑減輕之。
|
||
|
||
爰以行為人之責任為基礎,審酌:⒈蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯正值青壯,不思循正當途徑賺取財物,竟以兜售虛擬貨幣為名、實則搶奪交易款項之方式結夥搶奪財物,蔡佳佑更攜帶辣椒水噴霧劑為之,對交易安全、社會治安損害甚鉅,所為應嚴予非難;⒉蔡佳佑始終坦承加重搶奪未遂犯行、林鈺倫始終坦承共同搶奪未遂犯行(否認結夥攜帶兇器情節),張君緯先否認嗣坦認幫助搶奪未遂犯行等犯後態度,暨蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯業與李國祥達成調解並均給付賠償完畢,有本院臺中簡易庭調解事件報告書(本院卷一第579 至582 頁)及本院調解筆錄在卷可查(本院卷一第435 、436 頁、本院卷二第389 至390 頁、本院卷三第189 至190 頁;⒊蔡佳佑、林鈺倫、張君緯之素行(有臺灣高等法院被告前案紀錄表在卷可查)、本案犯罪手段、未搶得現金、其等於本院供承之智識程度、工作、生活與家庭經濟狀況等一切情狀(本院卷三第109 頁)、李國祥、張淙榆於本院表示之意見(李國祥部分見本院卷一第527 頁、張淙榆部分見本院卷三第95頁)及蔡佳佑之健康暨其家庭成員狀況(本院卷二第345 至349 、421 至426 頁),分別量處如主文所示之刑。
|
||
|
||
中 華 民 國 113 年 12 月 11 日
|