This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/lopp-pr234/work/out/L112.json
T
StellarCrow 41766c68a2 chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step
label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of
2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch
(scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of
2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added
to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore).

The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on
2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
2026-10-17 10:47:37 +02:00

45 lines
12 KiB
JSON

{"key": "L112", "status": "new", "duplicate_of": null, "duplicate_evidence": "", "scope_reason": "",
"new_sources_for_existing": [],
"pages": [
{"file": "work/articles/L112-1.txt", "keep": "2-22, 33-49, 53-56, 58, 61, 64-68, 71, 102-120", "reason": "Taoyuan District Court judgment 112 原訴 165; kept the parties, sentences, facts, findings, the acquittal reasoning on the cash and the second knife, the date and the schedule of seized items; cut procedural evidence rulings, legal standards, appeal notice and statute text"}
],
"values": {"date": "January 3, 2023", "victim": "A USDT seller", "location": "Zhongli, Taoyuan", "country": "Taiwan",
"description": "Four men posing as buyers of 166,000 USDT for TWD 5,146,000, paying with toy banknotes, pulled the seller into their car in Zhongli, Taoyuan, held a machete to his neck and demanded money while driving off. He struggled, his companion chased and rammed the car, and he jumped out; all four were convicted of attempted aggravated robbery.",
"summary": "On January 1, 2023, a man using the Telegram name Tommy Shelby contacted a USDT seller in Taoyuan, Taiwan, claiming to want to buy 150,000 USDT for TWD 4.5 million. He called that meeting off when he saw the seller had come with friends in four cars. He then arranged a second deal for January 3, 2023: 166,000 USDT for TWD 5,146,000. He brought a bag of toy banknotes and a hidden machete, and three other men came with him in a car. At about 4:35 p.m. in Zhongli, when the seller leaned into the car to check the cash, one man pulled him onto the back seat, another kicked him in, and the car sped off. In the car the organiser held the machete to his neck and demanded money. The seller struggled and suffered cuts to his left hand, while the friend who had driven him chased the car and rammed it several times. At about 4:44 p.m. the attackers gave up and he jumped out. Their car broke down soon after and the four ran off. The Taoyuan District Court on April 16, 2026 convicted all four of attempted aggravated robbery and sentenced them to between 3 years 10 months and 5 years 2 months in prison.",
"case_details": "**Victims:** One USDT seller, anonymised in the judgment as A2 (告訴人), who testified that he usually traded all day and reported to a boss (\"老闆\"). His companion A03 drove him to the meeting and was not attacked. The judgment does not name him; Lopp's \"Mr. Zhang\" is not in the text read.\n\n**Attackers:** Four defendants: 王浚羽, 祝郁珉, 林俊雄 and 曾棨煒 (listed in the header; the body anonymises them as A04 to A07). A04 organised the deal over Telegram (nickname 「湯米‧謝爾米」), prepared the toy banknotes and the machete and sat in the left rear seat; A05 supplied the rented car and sat in front; A06 drove (promised NT$30,000, by his account); A07, a friend of A04, sat in the right rear seat.\n\n**Attack Method:** Fake purchase of USDT. A first meeting in Zhongli on January 1, 2023 (150,000 USDT for NT$4.5 million) was called off by A04 when he saw the seller had brought friends in four cars. For January 3 he arranged to buy 166,000 USDT for NT$5,146,000 (\"欲向A2以514萬6千元購買16萬6千顆USDT\"), with six bundles of NT$1,000 and two of NT$100 toy notes in a black bag. The seller testified the meeting moved from Taoyuan HSR station to a convenience store; the address is redacted (\"桃園市○○區○○路0段00號\"). At about 16:35, when the seller leaned into the open rear door to see the cash and saw the notes marked \"玩具鈔\", A04 pulled him in, A07 kicked him in and got in, and A06 drove off on A04's order. The seller testified that A04 told the driver to head for the coast (\"開去海邊\"), and A04 admitted it.\n\n**Violence Used:** Detention: he was pulled and kicked into the car and held in the moving car between A04 and A07 from about 16:35 until he jumped out at about 16:44 on Zhiyuan 1st Road, Zhongli. A04 held the machete to his neck (\"持預藏之前開開山刀抵住A2頸部\") and demanded money; the seller testified: \"叫我趕快給他錢,不然就要對我不利\" and \"錢給我拿出來\". In the struggle he suffered multiple lacerations to his left hand (\"左手多處撕裂傷\"). In the investigation he said A07 also held a knife to his neck; at trial he said A07 used no object on him, and the court did not find it. A hammer and a gold-handled short knife owned by A05 were seized from the car, but the court did not link them to the attack.\n\n**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Money demanded in the car, no figure. The planned fraud was to obtain 166,000 USDT for toy notes. The seller testified that NT$200,000 in cash was taken from his jeans pocket in the car; the court found this not proven (no cash seized, none seen on CCTV, defendants deny it) and found the robbery attempted, with no property handed over. His phone was left in the car and seized by police; the court found no robbery of the phone.\n\n**Status:** Convicted. Taiwan Taoyuan District Court, 112年度原訴字第165號, judgment of April 16, 2026 (民國115年4月16日): attempted robbery by three or more persons carrying weapons (結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪). Sentences: A04 5 years 2 months, A05 3 years 11 months, A06 3 years 10 months, A07 3 years 11 months. The machete, bag, toy notes and the car were confiscated. A06 turned himself in, per his defence. The judgment was open to appeal.",
"detention": "yes", "violence_torture": "yes", "drugs_alcohol": "no", "weapons": "yes", "theft": "no", "life_taken": "0",
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "held_duration": "minutes", "arrests": "convicted",
"demanded_amount": null, "demanded_currency": null, "demanded_usd_stated": null, "demanded_as_stated": "money, no figure given (the fake purchase was for 166,000 USDT at TWD 5,146,000)",
"taken_amount": null, "taken_currency": null, "taken_usd_stated": null, "taken_as_stated": "nothing taken per the court; the victim said TWD 200,000 cash was taken, found not proven",
"targeting": ["Online contact or advert"], "targeting_accuracy": "Unknown", "who_was_attacked": ["Holder"], "approach": ["P2P trade"], "attack": ["Kidnapping"], "outcome": "Fought off", "obtained": ["Nothing"],
"people": [{"role": "Holder", "people": 1, "at_least": 0, "detail": "the USDT seller pulled into the car"}],
"sources": ["https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TYDM%2C112%2C%E5%8E%9F%E8%A8%B4%2C165%2C20260416%2C1"], "name_withheld": 0},
"support": {
"date": "A04等4人於112年1月3日16時35分許,抵達上開地點後",
"detention": "A04便將A2拉進車內後座,A07則同時將A2踢入車內,並隨即上車,A04復指示A06駕車加速駛離現場",
"violence_torture": "致A2受有左手多處撕裂傷之傷害",
"drugs_alcohol": "A04遂在車內持預藏之前開開山刀抵住A2頸部",
"weapons": "A04遂在車內持預藏之前開開山刀抵住A2頸部",
"theft": "上開詐欺取財、強盜等行為亦因而止於未遂",
"life_taken": "在本案車輛行經桃園市中壢區致遠一路某處時趁機跳車",
"venue_of_control": "A04、A07及A2即在本案車輛高速行駛途中在車內後座發生扭打",
"held_duration": "嗣A2於同日16時44分許,在本案車輛行經桃園市中壢區致遠一路某處時趁機跳車",
"arrests": "A04犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪,處有期徒刑5年2月。",
"demanded_amount": "A04當時手上拿著砍刀,叫我趕快給他錢,不然就要對我不利",
"taken_amount": "因告訴人跳車逃逸而未發生交付財物之結果",
"targeting: Online contact or advert": "向A2佯稱欲購買虛擬貨幣USDT",
"targeting_accuracy": "欲向A2以514萬6千元購買16萬6千顆USDT",
"who_was_attacked: Holder": "A04便將A2拉進車內後座",
"approach: P2P trade": "欲向A2以514萬6千元購買16萬6千顆USDT",
"attack: Kidnapping": "被告4人以此方式剝奪告訴人之行動自由",
"outcome": "僅因告訴人在車上不斷掙扎,進而與被告A04、A07發生肢體衝突,證人A03又駕車於後不斷追撞本案車輛,被告A04、A06、A07始放棄奪取財物,使告訴人得以跳車",
"obtained: Nothing": "尚無從認定被告4人有強盜告訴人所有之20萬元現金犯行",
"people: Holder": "A04便將A2拉進車內後座"
},
"open_points": [
{"field": "outcome", "detail": "The court finds that the attackers gave up because the victim kept struggling and his companion kept ramming their car, and that this let him jump out; the facts section says he took the chance to jump (趁機跳車), and by his testimony they said 'let him get out' before he jumped. Fought off (resistance by him and by the person with him made them give up) and Escaped (he jumped from the moving car) both fit the text.", "first_value": "Fought off", "second_value": "Escaped", "quote": "被告A04、A06、A07始放棄奪取財物,使告訴人得以跳車"},
{"field": "obtained", "detail": "The victim and his companion testified that he carried NT$200,000 in cash in his jeans and that it was taken in the car; the prosecution charged it; the court found it not proven and held the robbery attempted. Set by the court's finding; the alternative treats the record as disputed (theft unconfirmed).", "first_value": "Nothing (theft no)", "second_value": "Unconfirmed (theft unconfirmed)", "quote": "尚無從認定被告4人有強盜告訴人所有之20萬元現金犯行"}
],
"notes": "Single source: the Taoyuan District Court first-instance judgment (112年度原訴字第165號, April 16, 2026), primary record; the archive.is link Lopp lists was not fetched because the original loaded. All parties are anonymised in the body (A2 victim, A03 his companion, A04 to A07 defendants); the header names the four defendants but the body does not map names to codes, so no attacker is named in the summary. Attack Kidnapping: he was pulled into the car and driven off, pre-selected through the fake trade, and held in the moving car with a machete at his neck, with the organiser telling the driver to head for the coast; Armed robbery was the alternative but the test excludes taking the victim away. Targeting Online contact or advert: A04 approached him on Telegram posing as a buyer; the judgment does not say how A04 found him. Targeting accuracy Unknown: the judgment never shows the seller's USDT. held_duration minutes: 16:35 to 16:44. Location: the meeting address is redacted; the first meeting was in Zhongli District, he jumped out on Zhiyuan 1st Road, Zhongli, and the cars stopped at Xinsheng Road section 2 and Yongqing Street, Zhongli. The court found that the hammer and gold-handled knife in the car were not shown to be linked to the attack and that the claimed cash and the phone were not robbed. The first approach was fraud (toy notes), raised to robbery at the scene by the court's finding.",
"lopp_differences": ["Lopp victim 'Mr. Zhang': the judgment anonymises the victim as A2 and gives no surname.", "Lopp 'Qingxi Road in Zhongli': the meeting address is redacted in the judgment (○○路); Zhongli District is confirmed.", "Lopp 'carrying toy banknotes, a hammer, a knife and a concealed machete': the court found only the toy notes and the machete part of the plan; the hammer and short knife belonged to A05, sat in the car and were not linked to the attack.", "Lopp 'Wang and three accomplices': the header lists 王浚羽 first among four defendants but the body does not say he is the organiser A04."]}