This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-19.md
T

11 KiB

Batch 19 decisions — 2026-10-01

Triage of batches/contradictions-19.md under batches/DECISION-RULES.md; evidence in batches/batch-19.json and the dossiers in sources/. Case 3 is on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 4 (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("When the person arrived, he held Mr. Katz up at gunpoint and forced him to transfer $8,500 worth of bitcoin": held at gunpoint to execute the theft); money_wanted → $8,500 in BTC transferred plus $3,500 cash taken ($12,000 total, of which only $8,500 was crypto); coin_type BTC kept; location → Queens, New York ("a secure location" the caller came to, type of place not stated); date February 2015 kept, approximate (the article gives no date; it rests on the Observer byline of 20 February 2015 and the caller's wish "to gamble during the Super Bowl"); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = business counterparty (a caller who had heard of his trading service online or through a referral); no arrest reported; one source (Observer round-up, Katz passage only; CNBC repeats it under 5).
  • DB id 2 (DA) — date → 3 November 2015 (Cointelegraph: "On November 3"; CoinDesk report of 4 November: "Tuesday night"); theft → 1 (the Lamassu ATM, unit valued at US$7,000, holding about US$2,000 in cash; no crypto reachable, so money_wanted and coin_type stay empty); victim → the Village Smoke Shop, Juniper Street, Midtown Atlanta (Amanda McCollum is the store manager or employee who confronted the robbers; the machine's owner is not named); attackers → suspects inside (number not stated in the police account; "two robbers" per Cointelegraph citing Clatl.com) plus two more waiting in a red Chevrolet Cavalier; reports → CoinDesk (first article, filed under the Cointelegraph URL) and Cointelegraph; sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept (handgun brandished and fired into the floor when staff confronted them; the glossary's Armed Robbery entry names crypto ATM locations); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, life_taken 0); the reconnaissance visit the week before and the wallet stolen from the office noted, not a separate record (no crypto, nobody attacked); no arrests, "no leads"; the Amsterdam ATM passage at the end of both articles belongs to 3 and was not used.
  • DB id 487 (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed ("armed" rests only on the prosecutor's qualification "extorsion avec arme"; no report describes a weapon); money_wanted → a crypto account worth about USD 25,000, reachable through access codes on one of the stolen phones; whether it was emptied is not stated (franceinfo and actu17 headlines say "dérobé", Var Actu says nothing more was disclosed); coin_type not stated; date 6 September 2026 kept ("dimanche 6 septembre", no year printed, pages retrieved 9 September 2026); reports → franceinfo, actu17, Var Actu (one account: same source close to the case); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1: overpowered, tied up and held inside, investigation includes "séquestration"; violence_torture 0; drugs_alcohol 0; theft 1: wallet, passport and two phones; life_taken 0); attackers → two men in balaclavas; how the victims got free not stated; no arrests; investigation by the SIPJ of Nice; round-up tails (PNACO count, Dompierre-sur-Mer, Yvelines) not used.
  • DB id 486 (DA) — kidnappings → 1 (held at gunpoint in the suspect's parked car while transferring crypto, "continuously told him that he would kill him if he didn't comply", then escaped); money_wanted → $562,155 in crypto transferred, plus a watch, chain and bracelet totalling about $413,500 (nearly $1 million together); coin_type not stated; date 8 December kept, year 2025 not printed in the kept text (verify with a second source); location → 5801 Biscayne Blvd, Miami; attackers → one, Dontae Lamar Johnson, 28, of Royal Palm Beach (alias Buckfiddy in the headline only); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept, gap: the report does not say the December meeting was set up as a trap; flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1: handgun, Ruger LCP .380 found in his console, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = acquaintance (met at the Kiki on the River nightclub in October, kept in contact); arrests: Johnson arrested on an armed robbery charge, held pending a pre-trial detention hearing; one source (VE Media, quoting the Miami PD report).
  • DB id 484 (DA) — weapons → 1 ("armed intruders" in the body of all three accounts, weapon type not stated; same basis as 124); date 13 January 2026 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; no source dates the attack, he returned to streaming after about five months); attackers → armed intruders, number three only per trendsmask.com (aggregator, self-described secondhand); held duration → hours, per trendsmask ("about four hours") and tradersunion relaying a deleted Lopp post ("for hours"), secondhand; theft 1 stands with the loss named: Pokémon cards, car keys and identity documents, no crypto obtained (he held none they could take); arrests → not established: spilled.gg reports no public confirmation, tradersunion relays Lopp's claim of two arrests; sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1: forced entry, beating and holding, clarification 1; violence_torture 1: fractured fingers, bruising, a blow to the head, gasoline poured on him; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); victim → "RATIRL" and his father, legal name not stated; targeting vector = public profile (assumed a known streamer held crypto); how they found him not stated; url_2 (x.com/lopp) and url_4 (bo3.gg) not used.
  • DB id 3 — parked: disputed-scenarios list

Needs owner decision

DB id 5 (owner) — New York, record "Dwayne Richards", 2015

TL;DR: the record mixes two incidents. Date, $1,100 and BTC match CNBC's 27 May 2015 Crown Heights robbery of an unnamed 28-year-old (Craigslist ad, held at gunpoint in the buyer's car, transferred, phone taken). Name, firefighter, stabbing and "kidnapped" come from the Observer's February 2015 story (on file under 4) naming Dwayne Richards, stabbed and robbed meeting bitcoin buyers in Williamsburg; CNBC says police called that 9 February robbery "not bitcoin related". Settled (DA) for the 27 May robbery: location → Crown Heights, Brooklyn; kidnappings 1 (held at gunpoint to transfer), weapons 1, theft 1; violence_torture → 0 (no violence in the 27 May robbery); no arrest; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong (no abduction described). Question 1: split into a 27 May record (unnamed victim) and a 9 February Richards record, or keep one? Observer names Richards and ties his robbery to bitcoin; police via CNBC deny the bitcoin link. DA recommendation: rewrite this record to the 27 May robbery with victim "28-year-old man" (no source names him), and open a Richards record only if the owner keeps cases police call not crypto-related (he is named in a source, so the name moves there, not deleted). Question 2: if the Richards incident stays out, the stabbing, "firefighter" and "kidnapped" leave this record entirely. DA recommendation: yes.

DB id 1 (owner) — Santa Barbara, Hal Finney, 2014

TL;DR: a year-long 1,000 BTC extortion campaign ended in a spoofed 911 call claiming a double murder; SWAT team and helicopter at the Finney home; nothing paid. Settled (DA): date → 2014, month and day unknown (days after Elliot Rodger's killings near UCSB, before Finney's death in August; 29 December 2014 is WIRED's publication date); money_wanted → 1,000 BTC demanded ("worth more than $400,000 at the time"), coin_type BTC, nothing paid; sequence Swatting kept; flags kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0 unchanged (his death in August is attributed to his illness, not the attack); caller never identified; FBI believed several holders were extorted the same way; single source (WIRED, Fran Finney narrating). Question: weapons in swatting cases. For 0: no weapon is attributed to the caller; the only arms are the police response. For 1: the hoax exists to bring "an armed police response to the victim's home" (WIRED). The answer sets the rule for every Swatting record. DA recommendation: 0, weapons recording arms brought or used by the attackers; note the armed police response in the description.

DB id 485 (owner) — Czeladź, Sylwester Suszek (BitBay), 10 March 2022

TL;DR: exchange founder vanished after meeting an associate at a fuel depot; car found abandoned; family received messages claiming captors wanted bitcoin; associate later charged with kidnapping and has himself vanished; never found. Settled (DA): location → fuel depot in Czeladź, Poland ("near Katowice, Silesia" is in no source; u.today gives Katowice only as his birthplace); description → messages received by the family (crypto.news citing the NYT), not "his sister received"; attackers → Marian W., named Marian Wszolek by crypto.news and u.today; violence_torture → threat only (captors threatening to cut off his fingers, per the messages); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → 0 (the ax on his Ferrari is an earlier, separate incident); life_taken → unconfirmed (no body, no court ruling of death); theft 0 kept; money_wanted empty (no ransom figure in any source; the 4,500 BTC is an exchange reserve question). Question: keep as a Kidnapping, or mark it unestablished? For: ransom messages, kidnapping charge against the associate. Against: crypto.news says the messages "do not establish what ultimately happened to him"; the load-bearing reporting is a New York Times investigation not on file. DA recommendation: keep Kidnapping, mark low-confidence (as 199), fetch the NYT piece before green.

DB id 483 (owner) — Ufa, traffic police officer, 2022

TL;DR: an officer seized detainees' phones during police actions, opened the crypto wallets on them and moved the bitcoin to his own accounts; seven years, rank stripped, compensation ordered. Settled (DA): date → 2022, month unknown (record's "March" is in no source); money_wanted → bitcoin worth about 20 million rubles at the rate on the report's date (the article equates it to $700,000), coin_type BTC; weapons → 0 (none in the report); violence_torture 1 kept ("he used physical violence against detainees during the process"); theft 1 kept; sequence Authority Misuse kept; officer unnamed, number of victims not stated; single weak source (Analytics Insight; TASS and the X post unread). Question: detention flag when the holding was lawful police custody that the officer turned into the means of theft. For 1: clarification 2 (detention used to execute the theft counts, whoever is held), and 93 (officers' cell) is 1. Against: these were real arrests in a legal process, not a holding staged by the attackers. DA recommendation: 1, with a note that the custody itself was lawful.