feat(verify): apply Kidnapping/Express rule (224, 491, 93 to Kidnapping; 172, 80, 7, 19 to Express); 104 and 114 sequences per owner rulings

This commit is contained in:
StellarCrow
2026-09-30 18:55:35 +02:00
parent 483a1addf0
commit 005b95db8a
3 changed files with 25 additions and 19 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -113,6 +113,6 @@ This absorbs the "prior acquaintance / insider" attribute proposed earlier today
The two glossary entries overlap on duration ("minutes to hours" against "hours to weeks"). The owner's rule settles the overlap: The two glossary entries overlap on duration ("minutes to hours" against "hours to weeks"). The owner's rule settles the overlap:
- **Express Kidnapping**: the victim is seized in public and made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle. - **Express Kidnapping**: the victim is seized in public and made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle.
- **Kidnapping**: the victim is taken to a fixed place the attackers control, or a ransom is demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. - **Kidnapping**: the victim is taken to a place away from the public where the attackers hold them (a building or a remote outdoor spot), or transported over a long distance, or a ransom is demanded from third parties, whatever the duration.
Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label. First applied to case 93 (held in a cell at the officers' station: Kidnapping). Cases whose label changes under the rule are listed in corrections-approved.md as they are ruled on. Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label. First applied to case 93 (held in a cell at the officers' station: Kidnapping). Cases whose label changes under the rule are listed in corrections-approved.md as they are ruled on.
+5
View File
@@ -269,3 +269,8 @@ Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-10.md`; evidence in `batches/bat
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-11.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-11.json`. Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-11.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-11.json`.
- **DB id 93** — accept: kidnappings → 1 (pushed into a cell at the FCID Annex and held for hours); violence_torture → 1 (beaten at the roadside and again at the station); amount → N22 million in bitcoin transferred, N20 million demanded as bail, drop '$50K USD' (the article deals only in naira); victims → Morakinyo Tobiloba Peter and Yusuf Samson Dayo; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (owner: held at a fixed place the attackers control, so not Express Kidnapping; see the rule adopted below), gap: opportunistic traffic stop, same-night extraction from the victims' own account; other flags unchanged (weapons 1, theft 1); single source, the victims' account to SaharaReporters; no arrest or discipline reported; outcome 'released' inferred. - **DB id 93** — accept: kidnappings → 1 (pushed into a cell at the FCID Annex and held for hours); violence_torture → 1 (beaten at the roadside and again at the station); amount → N22 million in bitcoin transferred, N20 million demanded as bail, drop '$50K USD' (the article deals only in naira); victims → Morakinyo Tobiloba Peter and Yusuf Samson Dayo; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (owner: held at a fixed place the attackers control, so not Express Kidnapping; see the rule adopted below), gap: opportunistic traffic stop, same-night extraction from the victims' own account; other flags unchanged (weapons 1, theft 1); single source, the victims' account to SaharaReporters; no arrest or discipline reported; outcome 'released' inferred.
- **Rule adopted (owner, 2026-09-30), Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping** — Express Kidnapping: seized in public and made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle. Kidnapping: taken to a fixed place the attackers control, or a ransom demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label. - **Rule adopted (owner, 2026-09-30), Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping** — Express Kidnapping: seized in public and made to pay from their own funds while held on the spot or in a vehicle. Kidnapping: taken to a fixed place the attackers control, or a ransom demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. Duration and the size of the sum do not decide the label.
- **Rule widened (owner, 2026-09-30)** — Kidnapping: taken to a place away from the public where the attackers hold them (a building or a remote outdoor spot), or transported over a long distance, or a ransom demanded from third parties, whatever the duration. Under this wording 217, 168, 295, 386, 214 and 203 stay Kidnapping.
- **Express Kidnapping → Kidnapping (owner)** — DB ids 93 (cell at the officers' station), 224 (warehouse in Steel Town), 491 (shack in woodland).
- **Kidnapping → Express Kidnapping (owner)** — DB ids 172 (van, own funds; supersedes 'Kidnapping kept per the charge'), 80 (taken on a drive and made to transfer), 7 (held in vehicles until morning), 19 (held in a van for two hours while his apartment was emptied).
- **Stay Express Kidnapping (owner, borderline cases)** — DB ids 279 (forced to call his brother to move 1,000 BTC), 367 (14 BTC demanded within 24 hours), 462 (driven to Cravinhos; holding place not stated).
- Not screened under the rule: the 24 Kidnapping cases with no venue recorded and the first 70 verified cases, which carry no venue field.
+18 -17
View File
@@ -41,12 +41,12 @@
"224": { "224": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [], "gaps": [],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Posed as FIA and CTD officials (Authority Misuse); abducted to a warehouse and released the same day (Express Kidnapping)." "rationale": "Posed as FIA and CTD officials (Authority Misuse); abducted to a warehouse and released the same day (Express Kidnapping). Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): taken to a warehouse, a place the attackers control."
}, },
"228": { "228": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
@@ -1724,7 +1724,7 @@
}, },
"172": { "172": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Kidnapping" "Express Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -1732,7 +1732,7 @@
"no holding place other than the van is reported, so the 'unknown or controlled environment' in the Kidnapping definition has nothing behind it" "no holding place other than the van is reported, so the 'unknown or controlled environment' in the Kidnapping definition has nothing behind it"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "The couple were cut off on their motorcycle, forced into a van, taken away, beaten into transferring crypto and released elsewhere; the Bangkok Post calls it an abduction and the charge is illegal detention.", "rationale": "The couple were cut off on their motorcycle, forced into a van, taken away, beaten into transferring crypto and released elsewhere; the Bangkok Post calls it an abduction and the charge is illegal detention. Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a van and made to transfer from their own funds, no ransom from third parties.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,
@@ -1939,6 +1939,7 @@
"Dodged Attack" "Dodged Attack"
], ],
"attempted": [ "attempted": [
"Authority Misuse (insurance ruse at the door)",
"armed extortion of cryptocurrency at the victim's home" "armed extortion of cryptocurrency at the victim's home"
], ],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -1946,7 +1947,7 @@
"Dodged Attack does not record how the attack was dodged — here the victim physically fought the man off at his home" "Dodged Attack does not record how the attack was dodged — here the victim physically fought the man off at his home"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "An armed subscriber came to the influencer's home to extort cryptocurrency and was fought off with nothing taken (Dodged Attack), having found and followed him because of his public crypto profile (Costly Fame).", "rationale": "An armed subscriber came to the influencer's home to extort cryptocurrency and was fought off with nothing taken (Dodged Attack), having found and followed him because of his public crypto profile (Costly Fame). Attempted Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the attacker posed as someone settling an insurance matter (freelanceinfos.fr, 27 January 2022).",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "none", "venue_of_control": "none",
"held_duration": "none", "held_duration": "none",
@@ -2257,7 +2258,7 @@
"93": { "93": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -2265,7 +2266,7 @@
"the whole account is the two victims' as given to one outlet; the labels cannot mark that no police or court record corroborates it" "the whole account is the two victims' as given to one outlet; the labels cannot mark that no police or court record corroborates it"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Serving officers used a traffic stop, a cell and a bail demand to extract bitcoin the same night, which is Authority Misuse as the initiation and Express Kidnapping as the operational pattern; no label captures that the holding place was the officers' own station.", "rationale": "Serving officers used a traffic stop, a cell and a bail demand to extract bitcoin the same night, which is Authority Misuse as the initiation and Express Kidnapping as the operational pattern; no label captures that the holding place was the officers' own station. Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a cell at the officers' own station.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space", "venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",
@@ -2492,7 +2493,7 @@
}, },
"104": { "104": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "P2P Trade Gone Wrong",
"Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
@@ -2501,7 +2502,7 @@
"a victim moved through three separate holding places over six days reads as one Kidnapping label" "a victim moved through three separate holding places over six days reads as one Kidnapping label"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "He was lured to an industrial unit for a Tether transaction, assaulted there, then driven away and held in a container yard and a village house for nearly a week while a ransom was demanded from his family (Kidnapping).", "rationale": "He was lured to an industrial unit for a Tether transaction, assaulted there, then driven away and held in a container yard and a village house for nearly a week while a ransom was demanded from his family (Kidnapping). Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the lure was a Tether trade, so the first step is P2P Trade Gone Wrong (as in 117).",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space", "venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space",
"held_duration": "days", "held_duration": "days",
@@ -3475,7 +3476,7 @@
"80": { "80": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping" "Express Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -3484,7 +3485,7 @@
"with no holding place and no duration on file, Kidnapping and Express Kidnapping cannot be told apart" "with no holding place and no duration on file, Kidnapping and Express Kidnapping cannot be told apart"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "An investment invitation brought two foreigners to Lahore (Malicious Invitation), after which they were taken from their hotel at gunpoint on a sightseeing drive and made to transfer crypto, which is Kidnapping on the file's own wording.", "rationale": "An investment invitation brought two foreigners to Lahore (Malicious Invitation), after which they were taken from their hotel at gunpoint on a sightseeing drive and made to transfer crypto, which is Kidnapping on the file's own wording. Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a vehicle on a drive and made to transfer from their own funds.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": null, "held_duration": null,
@@ -3770,7 +3771,7 @@
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Authority Misuse", "Authority Misuse",
"Malicious Invitation - SocialEng", "Malicious Invitation - SocialEng",
"Kidnapping" "Express Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -3778,7 +3779,7 @@
"two hours of mobile detention in a vehicle reads as Express Kidnapping, but the operation was planned around a known holder, which that label excludes" "two hours of mobile detention in a vehicle reads as Express Kidnapping, but the operation was planned around a known holder, which that label excludes"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "A friend lured him into a fake Uber where a man was waiting with a gun, and he was held in the van for two hours while accomplices emptied his apartment (Malicious Invitation as the lure, Kidnapping as the operation). Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the posed as the Uber driver is a misuse of a claimed worker, driver or delivery position (DEFINITIONS.md, Authority Misuse clarification).", "rationale": "A friend lured him into a fake Uber where a man was waiting with a gun, and he was held in the van for two hours while accomplices emptied his apartment (Malicious Invitation as the lure, Kidnapping as the operation). Authority Misuse added 2026-09-30 by owner ruling: the posed as the Uber driver is a misuse of a claimed worker, driver or delivery position (DEFINITIONS.md, Authority Misuse clarification). Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in a van for two hours, no fixed holding place and no ransom from third parties.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",
@@ -4584,7 +4585,7 @@
}, },
"7": { "7": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Kidnapping" "Express Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [], "attempted": [],
"gaps": [ "gaps": [
@@ -4593,7 +4594,7 @@
"the file never says how the detention ended" "the file never says how the detention ended"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "He was forced into a van in the street, restrained, blindfolded, moved to a second vehicle and held there until morning while transfers and then cash were demanded (Kidnapping).", "rationale": "He was forced into a van in the street, restrained, blindfolded, moved to a second vehicle and held there until morning while transfers and then cash were demanded (Kidnapping). Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held in vehicles while transfers and cash were demanded of him, no ransom from third parties.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion", "venue_of_control": "vehicle in motion",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",
@@ -7016,7 +7017,7 @@
}, },
"491": { "491": {
"sequence": [ "sequence": [
"Express Kidnapping" "Kidnapping"
], ],
"attempted": [ "attempted": [
"\"Cripto-Pix\" transfers after the bank blocked the account; no article says any crypto transfer went through" "\"Cripto-Pix\" transfers after the bank blocked the account; no article says any crypto transfer went through"
@@ -7027,7 +7028,7 @@
"a lookout phoning the crew a police warning is the detail that ended the captivity and no field holds it" "a lookout phoning the crew a police warning is the detail that ended the captivity and no field holds it"
], ],
"v1_label_supported": true, "v1_label_supported": true,
"rationale": "Three armed men grabbed him off the street into a car, held him about three hours in a shack and worked through the funds they could reach by Pix before abandoning him, which is Express Kidnapping by the glossary's letter.", "rationale": "Three armed men grabbed him off the street into a car, held him about three hours in a shack and worked through the funds they could reach by Pix before abandoning him, which is Express Kidnapping by the glossary's letter. Changed 2026-09-30 by owner ruling (Kidnapping versus Express Kidnapping rule, DEFINITIONS.md): held about three hours in a shack in woodland.",
"facts": { "facts": {
"venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space", "venue_of_control": "attacker's or third-party space",
"held_duration": "hours", "held_duration": "hours",