This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/contradictions-32.md
StellarCrowandClaude Fable 5.1 6cfa0b19c9 feat(verify): batch 32 verified (257-109); verification complete for all 389 cases
Checker: five CLEAN, four minor fixes (255 evidence wording, 209 flag count
and source hedge plus the Vierzon/Bourges brigade discrepancy, 188 arrest
timing, 109 contradiction attribution). summary-overrides.json and
scenario-sequences.json now hold one entry per DB case. Report and export
regenerated.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01GZZENdTLzNGsbNy4DyF1yt
2026-09-30 12:34:49 +02:00

109 lines
28 KiB
Markdown

# Batch 32 — contradictions, flag proposals and notes for Sofia (2026-09-30)
## case 257
- **weapons** — record: weapons = 0, with the description naming an axe, a knife and a fake pistol | article (SVT): tvingades offren under vapenhot och vald att fora over 2,5 miljoner kronor i kryptovaluta (weapons threatened, but no type named anywhere in this file)
- **violence** — record: violence_torture = 0 | article (SVT): Familjen i Tobo blev bundna och skenavrattades - sedan ranades den pa kryptovaluta till ett varde av 2,5 miljoner kronor
- **money_wanted** — record: money_wanted 'millions of USD'; description '2.5 million Swedish kronor (~$235,000 USD)' and Bitcoin demanded but other cryptocurrency transferred | article (SVT): kryptovaluta till ett varde av 2,5 miljoner kronor (no dollar conversion, no coin, and no mention of Bitcoin being asked for specifically)
- **date** — record: September 27, 2025 | article (SVT, Aftonbladet): I september forra aret tog fem maskerade personer sig in i tva grannvillor i Tobo (SVT gives the month only; Aftonbladet says 'i slutet av september')
- flag `violence_torture` = 0 -> propose **1**: 'tvingades offren under vapenhot och vald att fora over 2,5 miljoner kronor' and 'Familjen i Tobo blev bundna och skenavrattades' (SVT)
- flag `weapons` = 0 -> propose **1**: 'under vapenhot' - under threat of weapons (SVT); no weapon type is named in any article on file
- OFF-CASE link: url (aftonbladet.se) is a rolling live-news page; only the pinned entry about the Tierp robbery concerns this case, and the rest of the fetched block (a Greek military plane crash, a car rollover near Nassjo, Ukraine, a Dover blockade) plus the outlet's tip-line boilerplate is other news and was not used
- label gaps: two households entered in one operation are held as one record, with one location and one victim field; the attack was ended by relatives arriving, not by police, and no field records who broke it off; a game-chat microphone used as an alarm is the interesting detail here and no field holds it
- note: Two flag changes: weapons and violence_torture are 0 on a record whose own source says the victims were bound, mock-executed and forced to transfer under threat of weapons and violence. Both should be 1. Everything specific in the record's description beyond the bare outline - the axe, the knife, the fake pistol, the 10 p.m. start, Bitcoin being demanded while another coin was transferred, the ~$235,000 conversion, the police chase with gunfire, the April 2026 verdict date and the Uppsala district court - is in the record and the unverified site summary only; nothing in this file supports any of it, so it should not be treated as sourced. The Aftonbladet URL is a live blog and will rot; the SVT page is the only substantive article here and it is cut to 13 paragraphs. Outcome is set to 'rescued' because relatives, not police, ended it.
## case 255
- **money_wanted** — record: description '$36,000 in crypto'; money_wanted '$8 million in cryptocurrency' | article (CBS Minnesota): the victim was 'forced at gunpoint to transfer at least $36,000 to an unknown cyberwallet from his accounts' and 'forced to transfer at least another $36,000' at the cabin, against the same outlet's headline 'accused of stealing $8M in crypto'
- **time** — record: September 19, 2025 (no time) | article (CBS Minnesota (two reports)): 'the two suspects ran up to one of the victims around 7:45 a.m. on Sept. 19' against 'starting shortly before 8 a.m. Friday'
- **victim** — record: victim 'Family' | article (NBC News, CBS Minnesota): 'holding a husband, wife, and their adult son hostage in their Grant, Minnesota, home' (NBC News); CBS calls the man forced to transfer 'the caller's father'
- **violence** — record: violence_torture = null | article (CBS Minnesota): each brother is charged with 'three counts of first-degree assault during a burglary with a firearm' (no assault or injury is described anywhere in the three articles)
- flag `violence_torture` = null -> propose **unconfirmed**: no assault or injury is described in any article; the state charges include 'three counts of first-degree assault during a burglary with a firearm' for each brother
- OFF-CASE link: the NBC News block closes with the outlet's own trend statistics, a Chainalysis projection and a reference to a May case in which two crypto traders were charged over a kidnapping and torture in a New York apartment; those are other cases and context, and were not used
- OFF-CASE link: url_2 and url_3 (cbsnews.com) are both Wayback copies from December 2025 because the live pages were dead on the first pass
- label gaps: the husband was driven three hours to a second property and forced to transfer there, a kidnapping leg inside a home invasion that one scenario field cannot carry; a remote third party feeding account information to the men in the house by phone has no field; the loss runs from at least $72,000 in the charging documents to $8 million in the prosecutors' statement, and there is one amount field
- note: The amount field needs a ruling. The charging documents in this file support at least $36,000 plus at least $36,000; the $8 million in the record's money_wanted comes from the U.S. Attorney's press release and the headlines, and it is a loss figure, not a demand. The record puts $36,000 in the description and $8 million in money_wanted, so the two figures are already split across fields with no note that they are the same event. violence_torture is null: nothing in this file describes a blow, but each brother faces three counts of first-degree assault, hence 'unconfirmed' rather than 0. The victims' belief that the targeting followed a data breach, the third party coaching the brothers by phone, and the gags found in their home are all in the file and in no field. All three suspects named or implied are charged, not convicted, so arrests is 'some' rather than 'all': the third party on the phone was not identified.
## case 254
- **money_wanted** — record: $650,000 | article (Calcalistech): demanded 500 Bitcoins, worth approximately $55 million (the record's figure is the loss, not the demand)
- **amount** — record: coin_type '$547,260 in Bitcoin and approximately $42,248 in USDT' plus the Rolex, laptop, Trezor, euros and cash | article (DL News): nearly 5 Bitcoin, worth about $610,000 in today's price, and over 42,000 USDT; headline totals of $650,000 (DL News) against $600,000 (Calcalistech and the third article)
- **attackers** — record: (record names nobody) | article (Calcalistech, DL News): Murad Mahajna, 46, a resident of Tel Aviv (Calcalistech and the third article) against Murad Mahajneh, 46 (DL News)
- **description** — record: robbed of $600,000 in digital assets | article (DL News, Calcalistech): the victim revealed the password to his Exodus crypto wallet (DL News) against the indictment's account that a Trezor crypto wallet was among the items stolen (Calcalistech)
- **amount** — record: about 5,000 euros | article (third article on file): approximately $5,300 in euros
- OFF-CASE link: the DL News block carries two other cases as context and neither was used: the May Las Vegas case in which three Florida teenagers drove a crypto event attendee into the Arizona desert, and the New Year's Eve French abduction over which five people were charged in June
- OFF-CASE link: Eyal Gruper's comment on how rare such attacks are in Israel, and the reference to Jameson Lopp's tracker, are commentary rather than reporting on this incident
- label gaps: the follow-up extortion call two days later is a second event held inside one record with one date; a demand of 500 BTC against a take of about $600,000 has one amount field, and the record used it for the take; the laundering leg through HTX and Kyrrex has no field
- note: Three fields to tidy. money_wanted holds the loss ($650,000) while the demand in the indictment was 500 BTC, about $55 million; the demand belongs in money_wanted. coin_type holds the entire inventory of loot including a watch, a laptop and cash, which is not a coin type. And the suspect's surname is spelled two ways across the three articles (Mahajna in Calcalistech and the third article, Mahajneh in DL News) - pick one and note the other. Outcome is set to 'released' for want of a better value: the robbers left him tied up and bleeding rather than freeing him, and the file does not say who untied him. held_duration 'hours' for one hour and ten minutes. The two accomplices are still at large, so arrests is 'some'.
## case 223
- **location** — record: Mecauayan, Bulacan, Phillipines | article (the sheet's Article 1 (Ramon Tulfo column) versus Rappler): a Chinese businessman, recently kidnapped in Pasay City ... He was reportedly abducted while dining at a seafood restaurant along Macapagal Avenue, against Rappler's account of a house in Barangay Langka, Meycauayan, Bulacan
- **amount** — record: description 'received over $3M'; coin_type '$4 million (~P200 million) via cryptocurrency' | article (the sheet's Article 1 versus Rappler): his family paying a total of P160 million in ransom ... first by paying P60 million, followed by another P100 million, against Rappler's 'around P200 million through cryptocurrency in several tranches'
- **description** — record: Businessman lured by woman to house & taken hostage; notes add that a Chinese female contact was used and that the meeting was first set for March 28 | article (Rappler): no article in this file mentions a woman, a lure or a planned meeting; Rappler has the two arriving in Barangay Langka at around 2 pm and being kidnapped in a house there
- **attackers** — record: (record names nobody) | article (Rappler): five suspects, of whom Richardo Austria David, Raymart Catequista and David Tan Liao were charged, Gong Wenli (Kelly Tan Lim) was arrested later, and Jonin Lin remains at large
- flag `weapons` = 1 -> propose **unconfirmed**: no weapon is mentioned anywhere in this file; the bodies were bound with nylon rope, wrapped in duct tape and showed signs of strangulation
- OFF-CASE link: the ABS-CBN fetch (url) returned only the headline and the outlet's corporate boilerplate, so it carries no facts; the text pasted into the sheet under that URL is a different piece, a Ramon Tulfo column, and its Pasay City restaurant account conflicts with the police version
- OFF-CASE link: the Rappler block ends with the outlet's unrelated headlines (international parental kidnapping under Philippine law, dirty money through PH crypto and casinos, a foreign student kidnapped in a case involving ex-POGOs) and an AI-generated summary disclaimer; none of that was used
- label gaps: a ransom paid twice and the hostages killed anyway has no field; the outcome column can only say killed; two victims, one of them an employee killed alongside his principal, sit on one record; the record's initiation - a woman used to lure the businessman to a house - appears in no article on file, so the label rests on the police account of a house in Meycauayan
- note: The sheet's Article 1 does not match the URL recorded beside it: the URL is the ABS-CBN report that three suspects are in custody, while the pasted text is a column giving a different abduction site (a seafood restaurant on Macapagal Avenue, Pasay City) and a different ransom total (P160 million against Rappler's P200 million). Sofia should decide which account the record follows, because location, ransom figure and possibly the date depend on it. The weapons flag has no support anywhere in this file - the injuries described are bruises and strangulation - so 1 is unconfirmed rather than wrong. The record's female lure, the planning from January and the 28 March meeting are unsourced here. Jonin Lin is still at large, so arrests is 'some' even though four people have been taken.
## case 209
- **location** — record: Vierzon, France | article (Le Monde, Zero Bullshit, Fortune): The couple had been abducted in the early hours of Tuesday, January 21, from their home in the town of Mereau in central France (Zero Bullshit puts the property in the southern outskirts of Vierzon; the Fortune photo caption has gendarmes in Mereau, near Vierzon)
- **detention** — record: kidnappings = 0, violence_torture = 0, weapons = 0, theft = 0 | article (Le Monde): found Balland alive but wounded ... his kidnappers had cut off his finger; his wife 'tied up but in good health'; charges of kidnapping in an organized gang accompanied by acts of torture or barbarism and extortion with weapons
- **money_wanted** — record: money_wanted null; coin_type 'crypto' | article (Zero Bullshit): un message exigeant un peu plus de 10M euros en Bitcoin, and a payment of 400 ETH followed by further transfers totalling close to 3 million euros
- **description** — record: Ransom was partially paid but later seized via Tether | article (Zero Bullshit): the 400 ETH was swapped to USDT, with 210K USDT to KuCoin, 112K to Binance and 640K to another wallet frozen after a few hours, 250 SOL frozen after a conversion through MEXC, and only 40 ETH cashed out; one wallet was blacklisted by USDT on the first evening
- **date** — record: January 21, 2025 (single date) | article (Cointelegraph, Le Monde): He was held captive until a police operation on the night of Jan. 22 (Cointelegraph), against Le Monde's account of a GIGN rescue 24 hours before the Thursday 23 January operation that freed his wife
- **victim** — record: David Balland & Wife | article (Zero Bullshit): David Balland et Amandine, sa compagne (the only source that names her; all the English-language sources say only 'his wife')
- **arrests** — record: (which unit made the traffic stop is not recorded) | article (Le Monde vs Zero Bullshit): Le Monde: 'the Vierzon anti-criminality brigade' made the stop that broke the case; Zero Bullshit: 'la BAC de Bourges'
- flag `kidnappings` = 0 -> propose **1**: 'She was in a vehicle, tied up but in good health' (Le Monde); Balland was found by the GIGN at an address near Chateauroux guarded by two men
- flag `violence_torture` = 0 -> propose **1**: 'his kidnappers had cut off his finger and sent the video of the mutilation to Ledger' (Le Monde); the charges include 'acts of torture or barbarism'
- flag `weapons` = 0 -> propose **1**: 'plusieurs hommes armes entrent dans la propriete' (Zero Bullshit); the charges include 'extortion with weapons' (Le Monde)
- flag `theft` = 0 -> propose **1**: 400 ETH (1.2 million euros) was sent and close to 3 million euros in total according to Zero Bullshit; only 40 ETH (122,000 euros) could be cashed out and the rest was frozen and seized
- OFF-CASE link: Le Monde's closing paragraph about the New Year's Eve abduction of a French crypto influencer's father, mother and sister in eastern France is a different case (record 203) and was not used; Le Monde itself says no link has been established
- OFF-CASE link: Fortune's closing paragraphs on Dean Skurka of WonderFi in Toronto and on the killing of a United Healthcare executive are other matters and were not used
- OFF-CASE link: Cointelegraph's ransomware payment statistics and its account of Changpeng Zhao's and Jameson Lopp's tweets about unconfirmed rumours are context, not reporting on the attack
- OFF-CASE link: the long Zero Bullshit passage on Ledger's founding, funding rounds, shareholder table and the Larcheveque-Gauthier dispute is company background, not this incident
- label gaps: two victims held at two separate locations about 200 kilometres apart sit on one record with one location field; a ransom paid, then frozen and seized, is a theft that was largely undone, and the theft flag cannot say so; the extortion target was a third party, another Ledger co-founder, not either of the people held
- note: Every flag on this record except life_taken is 0, on a case with a severed finger, two people tied up, armed entry, a multi-million-euro payment and ten people in custody. Four of the six need changing (detention, violence_torture, weapons, theft); drugs_alcohol and life_taken stay 0. The location field should also be settled: Le Monde and the Fortune photo caption put the house at Mereau, next to Vierzon, and only Zero Bullshit places it in Vierzon itself. The wife is named only by Zero Bullshit, a newsletter, so if the database avoids naming private victims she should stay unnamed. money_wanted is empty although Zero Bullshit reports a demand of a little over 10 million euros in Bitcoin. This single record carries the whole incident, both victims and both locations; there is no companion record for the wife in the sources directory. Arrests is 'some': ten are in custody but Zero Bullshit says the organisers have not been identified and Le Monde does not say either way.
## case 203
- **date** — record: January 1, 2025 | article (Cryptoast, DL News): dans la nuit du reveillon a Saint-Genis-Pouilly (Cryptoast); 'Incident took place on December 31, 2024' (DL News)
- **attackers** — record: 4-5 armed, masked men | article (Cryptoast, DL News): 2 malfaiteurs font irruption dans le domicile (Cryptoast), against DL News's five arrests with the youngest 16 and the oldest 42 at the time of the attack; neither article says anyone was armed or masked at the house
- **location** — record: Father doused in petrol and driven 700 km in car trunk; notes say police found him 500km away | article (Cryptoast, DL News): retrouver son pere a 500km de son domicile dans le coffre d'une voiture (Cryptoast) against 'Detectives found the man near the city of Le Mans, some 700 kilometres from his home' (DL News)
- **victim** — record: Father (age 56) and mother of Dubai-based crypto influencer, attacked in their home; notes say mother and daughter tied at home | article (DL News, Cryptoast): 'forced into the trunk of a car, along with his partner' against the same article's later 'They also found his partner tied up at the scene' (DL News); Cryptoast has the wife and the daughter tied up at the house
- **victim** — record: Father (age 56) | article (Cryptoast): 'Un homme de 50 ans retrouve dans le coffre d'une voiture' in the subheading against 'un homme de 56 ans' in the body
- flag `weapons` = 1 -> propose **unconfirmed**: no weapon is mentioned in either article; Cryptoast describes two hooded men and DL News describes a planned attack by people known to police, neither saying anyone was armed
- OFF-CASE link: Cryptoast's closing paragraphs about an entrepreneur whose wife was abducted a fortnight earlier, with Stephanie Winkel named, and about a CEO abducted in Canada in early November, are other cases and were not used
- OFF-CASE link: the DL News block carries three other matters as context - a 74-year-old tortured for 16 hours, two teens who stole jewellery from a female crypto holder and tried to enter another holder's house with explosive devices, and an attempted break-in at a Bitcoin company CEO's house in Nantes on 16 March - none of which was used
- OFF-CASE link: the Cryptoast page's reader comments, promotional inserts and unrelated site headlines were not used
- label gaps: three people held at the house and one driven hundreds of kilometres away sit on one record with one scenario field; the extortion target was the son abroad, not any of the people held, and no field records that; the two articles disagree on whether the partner was taken in the car or left tied at the house, and the victim field cannot hold the doubt
- note: The date is wrong by one day: both articles put the attack on New Year's Eve, 31 December 2024, and the record dates it 1 January 2025, which is when the father was found. The number of attackers in the record (4-5 armed, masked men) has no support here: Cryptoast says two broke in, DL News reports five arrests with ages 16 to 42, and no article says anyone was armed, which is also why the weapons flag reads as unconfirmed. Distance differs between sources, 500 against 700 kilometres. The two articles also disagree on whether the partner was forced into the car or left tied at the house; DL News contradicts itself within one piece. held_duration is 'hours' although the interval from the evening of 31 December to the night of 1-2 January runs past a day, kept for consistency with the other 24-to-30-hour cases. The record's second wave of arrests in March 2026 is in the unverified site summary only.
## case 188
- **amount** — record: description '$243M heist'; notes 'allegedly scammed of $342M in crypto' | article (News Times, KrebsOnSecurity): the theft and laundering of more than 4,000 Bitcoin from a man in Washington, D.C., valued at more than $230 million at the time of the theft, in a case News Times also calls a $245 million Bitcoin theft and a nearly $250 million theft, and Krebs calls a $243 million cyberheist
- **victim** — record: Radhika & Suchil Chetal | article (KrebsOnSecurity): KrebsOnSecurity uses both spellings in one article, 'his parents - Radhika Chetal and Suchil Chetal' and 'Sushil Chetal's LinkedIn profile'; the complaint names neither, using only the initials R.C. and S.C.
- **attackers** — record: (record names nobody) | article (News Times, KrebsOnSecurity): six Florida men aged 18-26 named and charged, plus James Schwab federally charged in January with planning and facilitating the attempt; a News Times sidebar headline adds three charged men from St Louis
- **theft** — record: theft = 0 | article (KrebsOnSecurity): Lamborghini Carjackers Lured by $243M Cyberheist ... They also recovered the abandoned Lamborghini from a wooded area
- flag `theft` = 0 -> propose **unconfirmed**: no cryptocurrency was obtained, but all three articles call this a carjacking and Krebs says police 'also recovered the abandoned Lamborghini from a wooded area', so the car was moved from the scene
- OFF-CASE link: the greater part of the Krebs article is about the $243 million online theft itself, about The Com, about Joel Ortiz's 2019 sentencing and about the 2022 shooting of Reynaldo Diaz in Miami; those passages are background on the actors rather than reports on this attack and were used only where they state the motive for it
- OFF-CASE link: the 36 reader comments appended to the Krebs page were not used
- OFF-CASE link: both News Times blocks carry unrelated local teaser headlines (a condo fire, a compressor station hearing, a strip-mall fire, a Flock camera moratorium, a stalking case, a mother's mental-health campaign, Danbury crime statistics) which were not used; the two sidebar headlines about the St Louis men and the Missouri surveillance do concern this case but come with no article text
- OFF-CASE link: url_2 and url_3 (newstimes.com) are Wayback copies from August 2026 because the live pages were thin on the first pass
- label gaps: a kidnapping that lasted from one crash to the next, minutes rather than hours, reads the same in the labels as a week-long captivity; the people held were leverage against their son, and no field records that the target was someone else; the record's crypto figure belongs to a separate online theft a week earlier, not to this attack, and the schema has one amount field
- note: Two things to rule on. First the theft flag: no crypto was obtained, but every source calls this a carjacking and the Lamborghini was recovered from a wooded area, so whether a briefly taken car counts as theft decides between 0 and 1; left as unconfirmed. Second the amount: the record's notes say $342M and the description $243M, while this file offers more than 4,000 Bitcoin, more than $230 million, $243 million, $245 million and nearly $250 million, all of it for the separate online theft a week earlier rather than for this attack, which took nothing. The record's victim spelling should also be settled, since Krebs writes both Suchil and Sushil in the same piece. The unverified site summary's air rifles, walkie-talkies, the two-day Missouri surveillance, the off-duty FBI agent and the masterminds Adam Iza and Saif Faiq appear nowhere in this file and should not reach the record from here. Arrests is 'convicted' because five of the six have pleaded guilty federally, though Diaz's trial was still pending and all five have pleaded not guilty at state level.
## case 177
- **money_wanted** — record: $4M | article (CoinTab): the hackers made away with over $4.1 million worth of cryptocurrencies (a loss figure; no demand figure is reported anywhere)
- **date** — record: June 17, 2024 | article (CoinTab): the quoted post is dated June 17, 2024 and opens 'This just happened', while CoinTab published on June 18; no source states the date of the attack independently of the post
- label gaps: the whole case rests on the victim's own posts relayed by one outlet, with no police or court source, and no field records that; how the attackers learned his address and that he held crypto is the question the case turns on, and no field holds it; the record gives no duration and neither does the article
- note: One article, one outlet, and it is built on the victim's own posts; there is no police or court source for anything here, including the date, which is the date of the post. The record's money_wanted of $4M is the rounded loss rather than a demand. Several claims in the unverified site summary have no support in this file and should not reach the record: that he is a blockchain developer, a former Ethereum Foundation coder and a co-founder of Kickback, and that he later deleted the post saying he had been advised to remove it while an investigation was ongoing. held_duration is null because CoinTab gives no duration. A re-fetch or a second source would be worth it before this case is treated as settled.
## case 109
- **description** — record: 3 armed attackers (ages 17-19) gained entry by posing as DHL delivery drivers when his daughter opened door | article (AT5): 'En ze waren binnengelaten omdat ze net deden alsof ze een pakketje hadden' - they were let in because they pretended to have a package; the article never says who opened the door, and mentions his children only as people the men threatened
- **attackers** — record: ages 17-19 | article (AT5): the Burgernet descriptions give men aged 17 to 19, while Everts's own tweet says '3 jongens van 20 of jonger' - three boys of 20 or younger
- **scenario** — record: Costly Fame | article (AT5): AT5 describes a fake-parcel entry and a demand for Bitcoin, and attributes the link between such robberies and 'het tentoonstellen van luxegoederen op social media' to Mayor Halsema speaking generally about well-known Amsterdammers, not to this victim
- **weapons** — record: site AI summary says Everts later stated he believed the gun was not a real weapon (the record's notes say only that he refused to comply, told them to shoot, and they fled) | article (AT5): 'die hielden een pistool op mijn hoofd' with no qualification anywhere in the article about whether the pistol was real
- flag `kidnappings` = 0 -> propose **1**: 'die hielden een pistool op mijn hoofd en zeiden, Bitcoin, Bitcoin' - held at gunpoint inside his home after the three gained entry, which the flag legend counts, though the article does not say he was restrained or for how long
- OFF-CASE link: url_2 is a YouTube video, recorded in the file as a source reference and explicitly not transcribed, so nothing was taken from it
- OFF-CASE link: AT5's closing paragraphs about other robberies of well-known Dutch people in Amsterdam over the previous year and Mayor Halsema's December remarks are context, not this incident
- label gaps: a fake parcel delivery used to get through the door has no label of its own; an attack the victim faced down inside his own home is both Home Invasion and Dodged Attack, and the record's single field holds neither; the attack was broadcast live to 2,000 viewers, which is the distinguishing fact of the case and has no field
- note: Two calls to make. The detention flag: they were inside the house and held a pistol to his head, which the flag legend counts, but the article never says he was restrained or prevented from leaving, so this sits between the owner's rule 1 and rule 3; proposed 1 with that caveat, and the Violence Used line was written on that reading. The scenario: the record says Costly Fame, but nothing here says his public profile was the targeting route, and the mayor's social-media remark is about well-known Amsterdammers in general; Home Invasion plus Dodged Attack is what the article supports. Two record details have no support in this file: that his daughter opened the door, and that he later said he believed the gun was not real. AT5 is the only article; the second link is a video. His remark that Bitcoin robbery is nonsense, 'as if you want to rob a bank account', is worth keeping for the paper.