This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/contradictions-39.md
StellarCrow 41766c68a2 chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step
label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of
2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch
(scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of
2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added
to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore).

The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on
2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
2026-10-17 10:47:37 +02:00

24 KiB

Batch 39 — contradictions, flag proposals and notes for Sofia (2026-10-07)

case 270

  • amount — record: money_wanted '1 500 000 UAH (about $57,000), mobile phone, jewelry'; description 'rob buyer of 1.5 Million UAH' | article (Bizlim): 'stole his mobile phone, jewelry, and money. Through these criminal actions, the robbers caused the citizen damage amounting to nearly 1,500,000 UAH (about 57,000 USD)' - the figure is the total damage, phone and jewellery included, and it is 'nearly' 1.5 million
  • notes — record: they invited the victim to their "house" | article (Bizlim): 'the criminals rented an apartment on General Petrova Street in Odessa for a short term and arranged a meeting with a potential client' - a flat rented short-term for the meeting, not the attackers' home
  • description — record: Several men pose as bitcoin sellers | article (Bizlim): the article says 'electronic currency' and 'cryptocurrency' throughout ('to buy and sell electronic currency'); bitcoin is not named, and the number of men is not given ('the assailant and his accomplices')
  • label gaps: unarmed robbery by assault at the attackers' venue has no label (Armed Robbery needs a weapon, Mugging is street)
  • note: One source, the Bizlim report of the Odessa prosecutor's indictment; the sheet copy is an English translation and the fetched block is the Russian original, and they agree. Two wording points: the sheet translation's 'deceived a cryptocurrency buyer' is, in the Russian, 'lured him to his place by deceit' ('obmannym putem zavlek k sebe'), which is closer to the record's note; and the Russian speaks of 'electronic currency', never bitcoin. The 1.5 million UAH is the total damage, phone and jewellery included. The article does not say whether the man was held in the flat or how the encounter ended, so I left the detention flag at 0, the held duration and the outcome empty. If the owner reads 'lured to the attackers' flat and beaten there' as detention, the flag changes; the file itself does not settle it. The article carries no publication date and does not say when the suspect was arrested.

case 271

  • description — record: another woman who had opened a "Bitcoin account" in the name of one of the attackers and used it to steal her money | article (Yahoo (second article)): 'Police said Delannoy-Jodoin wanted passwords and money she said was stolen from her' - the theft from the account is the suspect's claim as relayed by police, not an established fact
  • victim — record: Undisclosed woman | article (Yahoo (second article)): several occupants: 'used an electric cattle prod on one occupant and pistol-whipped another in the head', the female renter was chased into a bathroom, and the charges include 'risk of injury to a child', 'five counts of first-degree threatening and four counts of second-degree reckless endangerment'
  • attackers — record: 2 women invaded home | article (Yahoo (second article); the CCN text has 'recognize two of the home invaders'): 'the female renter of the home recognized two of the people that reportedly forced entry into the home' - two were recognised and two arrested; the wording leaves open that more people entered
  • verified summary — record: which a suspect tried to break into with a hammer before she escaped | article (Yahoo (second article)): 'one of the home invaders used a hammer to break in, according to police, but she was able to escape to a neighbor's house' - the second article has the door broken; only the garbled CCN sentence can be read as a failed attempt
  • OFF-CASE link: the CCN text mentions 'a shooting in downtown Miami in connection with a bitcoin deal gone awry' earlier that year - a different incident, not used
  • OFF-CASE link: the tail of the fetched Yahoo Finance page carries unrelated teaser headlines (Khashoggi, Bay Area housing); not used
  • label gaps: acquaintance or insider as the initiation has no label
  • note: Two texts on file: the CCN story syndicated on Yahoo Finance (the linked URL) and a second, fuller local report pasted in the sheet with no URL. The second one is the better source; the CCN text has a garbled sentence about the bathroom door. The record's victim field names one woman, but the reports describe several occupants (one pistol-whipped, one cattle-prodded, the renter chased into a bathroom, a child implied by the charge), and the record states as fact that the renter used the account to steal the money, which the reports give only as what Delannoy-Jodoin told police. Neither text states the year; March 2018 fits the archive snapshot of 18 October 2018 and nothing more, and the day in March is not given. The arrests were announced on 'Monday', months after the attack by the snapshot date. money_wanted and coin_type are empty: the demand was 'passwords and money' tied to a bitcoin account, with no amount in the file. The verified summary's Violence Used line does not open with 'Detention', although the detention flag of 1 is supported under rule 1 (forced entry followed by beating). I set arrests to 'some' because the reports do not say whether the two arrested women were the only intruders.

case 272

  • weapons — record: weapons 1 | article (Ain.UA): no weapon appears in the account: 'put a sack over his head, forcibly pushed him into a car ... They threatened to kill him'
  • violence — record: violence_torture 0 | article (Ain.UA): 'forcibly pushed him into a car, and took him outside the city. They threatened to kill him and thereby obtained the keys to his apartment'
  • description — record: Miner kidnapped, extorted for $50,000 | article (Ain.UA): the prosecutors say he was kidnapped 'to demand a ransom', but what follows is that the men 'obtained the keys to his apartment, as well as information about where he kept his money' and took $50,000 from him; the charge is 'robbery by prior conspiracy ... under Part 4 of Article 187', not extortion or kidnapping
  • coin — record: coin_type Crypto | article (Ain.UA): the loss is given only as '$50,000', obtained through 'the keys to his apartment' and 'information about where he kept his money'; the article does not say cryptocurrency was taken, and crypto enters only through the victim's occupation ('a cryptocurrency miner')
  • flag violence_torture = 0 -> propose 1: 'put a sack over his head, forcibly pushed him into a car ... They threatened to kill him' - physical force and death threats; no beating or injury is reported (Ain.UA)
  • flag weapons = 1 -> propose 0: no weapon is named anywhere in the article; the account has a sack, a car and threats to kill (Ain.UA)
  • OFF-CASE link: auto-trim-review.md lists the ain.ua fetched block as OFF-CASE? ('no case term appears anywhere on the page'). The page is the Russian original of the sheet article, same headline and same six paragraphs, so the flag comes from the language and the link is on-case. I still quoted only from the sheet's ARTICLE 1
  • OFF-CASE link: the tail of the untrimmed ain.ua block carries unrelated items (a Porsche Panamera test drive, martial law and the banks, Elon Musk on Mars, retirement countries, time management); not used
  • note: One source, the Ain.UA relay of the Kyiv prosecutor's press release (26 November 2018 by the URL). Two flags to change: weapons is 1 in the record and the article names no weapon at all, so I proposed 0; violence is 0 although he was hooded with a sack, shoved into a car by force and threatened with death, so I proposed 1 (there is no beating or injury in the file, so the owner may prefer to keep 0 if threats and manhandling do not count). The coin type 'Crypto' is not supported: the men got his apartment keys and learned where he kept his money, and the article gives only '$50,000', which reads as cash from the flat, though it does not say so. The article does not say how long he was held or where the threats were made beyond the car ride out of the city. 'Caught 8 months later' is the record's arithmetic from March to the late-November report; the article says 'detained' and that a custody petition went to the Podilsky court, no conviction. The OFF-CASE? entry for this case in auto-trim-review.md is a false alarm.

case 273

  • theft — record: theft 0 | article (Vice): 'In the end, the thieves took Kez's laptop, phone and his dog, Rambo'
  • amount — record: money_wanted 'dog worth an estimated £1,000, his Apple MacBook laptop, gold bracelets and a gold wedding ring' | article (Vice): 'the thieves took Kez's laptop, phone and his dog, Rambo. Kez made posters and offered £1,000 for Rambo's return' - the Vice text has a laptop, a phone and the dog; the £1,000 is the reward he offered, and gold bracelets, a wedding ring and the MacBook make are not in it
  • verified summary — record: the attackers made off with his dog (worth about £1,000), his Apple MacBook, gold bracelets and a gold wedding ring | article (Vice): 'the thieves took Kez's laptop, phone and his dog, Rambo. Kez made posters and offered £1,000 for Rambo's return' - the summary follows the record's list, which the article on file does not carry, and leaves out the phone
  • verified summary — record: no arrest is recorded in the source | article (Vice): 'One of the attackers - since jailed - had been prodding and lightly stabbing Kez with the knife'
  • description — record: The Instagrammer and crypto trader stabbed and robbed after posting his lavish life online | article (Vice): the men demanded 'money, drugs and watches' and he believes he was 'tracked and targeted as a cash-rich drug dealer'; no cryptocurrency was asked for, and 'Before the robbery, Kez had been a cryptocurrency trader'
  • flag theft = 0 -> propose 1: 'In the end, the thieves took Kez's laptop, phone and his dog, Rambo' (Vice); the record's own money_wanted and notes list stolen items
  • OFF-CASE link: the Vice piece refers in passing to other incidents (the influencer Hitham mugged in London, PewDiePie's home robbed, John Terry's burglary, Kim Kardashian in Paris, a Houston mayoral candidate's art) - different incidents, not used
  • OFF-CASE link: the record's reports field names TheSun, but no Sun link or text is on file
  • note: The theft flag is wrong on the record's own evidence: it is 0 while money_wanted lists what was taken and Vice says the thieves left with his laptop, phone and dog. I proposed 1. The item list needs a source: the dog's £1,000 value, the Apple MacBook, the gold bracelets and the wedding ring are not in the Vice text, where £1,000 is the reward he offered for the dog. They may come from The Sun, which the record cites and the file does not hold. The verified summary repeats that list and also says no arrest is recorded, while Vice says one of the attackers has 'since' been 'jailed'; both lines of the summary need a second look. I set arrests to 'some' because the article says jailed without naming the offence or mentioning the second man. The article gives no date for the attack, so November 2018 rests on something outside the file. The link to cryptocurrency is the victim's trading income only: the attackers wanted cash, drugs and watches. How long they were in the house is not stated.

case 279

  • drugs — record: drugs_alcohol 1 | article (VnExpress): 'threatening them with a syringe tinged with what they said was HIV contaminated blood (actually red ink)' - a threat, with nothing administered
  • location — record: Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam | article (VnExpress): 'They used cars to reach Dau Giay Town in Dong Nai in the middle and intercepted Le's' - the seizure was in Dong Nai province on the road from Bao Loc; the family was dropped 'by the side of a road in District 2'
  • description — record: Cops used fake gun and fake HIV syringe to rob $1.6M in bitcoin | article (VnExpress): the plot was businessman Ho Ngoc Tai's ('Tai's group ... plotted to steal his bitcoins'), who 'enlisted the help of' the two officers; the article says 'the group' used the gun and syringe and does not say who held them. Seventeen people are charged: the two officers, Tai 'and 14 others'
  • notes — record: Hired detectives to locate victim, who dodged first attacks but then at gunpoint succumbed | article (VnExpress): one earlier attempt is described: on May 12 'Phot ran his motorbike into Le's car ... The group intended to wait until Le got off the car to kidnap him, but Le simply drove away'. The gun was 'a fake gun'. The article has 'a private investigator for VND25 million' and 'Mai Xuan Phot, a detective hired by Tai' without saying whether they are one person or two
  • flag drugs_alcohol = 1 -> propose 0: the only substance in the article is a threat prop: 'threatening them with a syringe tinged with what they said was HIV contaminated blood (actually red ink)'; nobody was drugged or made to drink (VnExpress)
  • note: One source, VnExpress International, on file twice (sheet copy and fetched page) with the same text. The drugs flag should go to 0: the syringe held red ink and was shown to the wife and children as a threat, and nobody was drugged. The weapons flag stands only in the sense that a fake gun and the syringe were used to threaten; say 'fake' wherever the record says gunpoint. The victim's full name 'Le Duc Nguyen' is not in the article, which calls him only 'Le', so the name needs another source or should be cut back. The location is better given as Dau Giay, Dong Nai (interception) to District 2, HCMC (release). 'Cops used' overstates the officers' part: the article makes businessman Ho Ngoc Tai the organiser and the two officers enlisted helpers among 17 accused. The date of 17 May is the article's 'five days later' counted from 12 May. The article says the culprits were arrested 'in June' and that no trial date was set; it does not state the year of the arrests or its own publication date, so the verified summary's 'June 2020' is a reading and the status will be out of date.

case 285

  • description — record: $700,000 stolen in front of him | article (Times of Malta): the report keeps it alleged throughout: 'allegedly siphoned', 'the swindle allegedly took place', Milton 'is pleading not guilty' and 'claimed that Attard had done something wrong when both phones were in his possession'. 'The case continues.'
  • notes — record: suspect asked the victim to help him with a crypto investment. victim handed over his phone | article (Times of Malta): 'Milton sought help to make a €5,000 blockchain investment on the phone'; the contact began the other way round, 'after the victim had stumbled across a blockchain project while exploring the options of a cryptocurrency loan', followed by phone calls and 'a meeting at a Burmarrad office'
  • verified summary — record: Attard snatched his phone back | article (Times of Malta): 'when I took the mobile back and saw that my wallet balance was zero ... I just snatched the phone. He didn't resist ... he had placed both phones next to each other' and 'His first thought had been to redirect the funds from the accused's mobile'; later 'the suspect fraudster had taken back possession of his phone'. The testimony reads as Attard taking his own phone back and then grabbing Milton's; the summary has only the first
  • label gaps: non-violent fraud at an in-person meeting; borderline for a physical-attack database
  • note: One source, a Times of Malta court report of the victim's testimony; the sheet copy is complete and the archived fetch stops after nine paragraphs, so the sheet copy is the one to read. All six flags stand. This is a non-violent alleged fraud at a restaurant table, and every statement of what Milton did is the alleged victim's evidence in a case that was still running: the record's 'stolen' and any published text should keep 'allegedly'. The article gives 16 June with no year; 2021 is not stated in the file. The amount is '$700,000' in the headline and 424,670.97 Unizen tokens in the testimony. The article does not use the word arrested; Milton was at the restaurant when police arrived and is charged, which I recorded as arrests 'all' for the one accused. His business partner appears only at an earlier office meeting and is not accused of anything in the file.

case 288

  • notes — record: the son drugged him and took the dad's BTC | article (Washington Post, CoinMarketCap, Futurism): the father 'made his son a partner in a $100,000 investing account'; the article speaks of 'their bitcoin holdings' and 'their investment accounts', on which the father 'had put the two-step lock'. CoinMarketCap has 'their crypto wallets', Futurism 'his father's cryptocurrency holdings' and 'the joint crypto holdings'
  • violence — record: violence_torture 0 | article (Washington Post): 'He pleaded guilty to felony assault'; the prosecutor called it 'a domestic violence case' and 'cited past instances when the younger Ghershony had assaulted his father'
  • OFF-CASE link: the sheet's Article 2 (CoinMarketCap) and Article 3 (Futurism) have no URL recorded; both are rewrites of the Washington Post story and add nothing of their own
  • OFF-CASE link: the sheet copy of the Washington Post text ends with 'a job waiting tables at a restaurant in Rockville' and the archived copy of 24 July 2025 with 'a job at a take-out deli'; the page was edited between the two copies
  • label gaps: insider or family perpetrator has no label; drugging as the approach has no label
  • note: The Washington Post is the only original source; the other two texts restate it, and CoinMarketCap gets the first charge wrong (it was attempted first-degree murder). The date of 1 May 2021 is not in the file: the one date given is 14 May, when the mother called police, and the year appears nowhere in the text (the URL is dated 3 February 2022). The flags stand as recorded, with two judgement calls for the owner. Detention is 0: the father lay unconscious for two days but nobody held him, the son left. Violence is 0 in the sense of no blows, yet the conviction is first-degree assault, for the drugging itself, and the prosecutor mentioned earlier unreported assaults on the father. The ownership of the money is less simple than 'the dad's BTC': the son was a partner on the account and the reports call the holdings theirs. The article does not say whether the father got the $400,000 back. The sentence was 125 days in jail, two months of residential treatment and 20 years of suspended time.

case 290

  • weapons — record: weapons 0; notes 'They were robbed at knifepoint, not gunpoint' | article (Gulf Today): 'robbery under knife-point' in the court's charge and the women's complaint, against the victim's account of 'four persons threatening them with blunt objects'
  • amount — record: description '$100,000'; money_wanted 'Dhs342,000' | article (Gulf Today): three figures in one article: headline 'Dhs350,000'; 'the bag that contained Dhs300,000, in addition to another containing Dhs63,000, other valuable items and their passports'; and a joint fine of 'Dhs342,000', 'a fine equal to the stolen money'. No dollar figure is given
  • attackers — record: 4 Africans | article (Gulf Today): four were sentenced, 'including a fugitive'; the women were 'surprised by four persons', while their driver 'saw two Africans threatening the three women'; police arrested one man and then 'two others'
  • flag weapons = 0 -> propose 1: 'over the charges of robbery under knife-point'; 'surprised by four persons threatening them with blunt objects' (Gulf Today); the record's own note says 'robbed at knifepoint'
  • note: One source, Gulf Today's report of the Dubai Criminal Court judgment. The weapons flag is 0 while the record's own note says knifepoint; the article has 'robbery under knife-point' as the charge and 'blunt objects' in the victim's statement, so I proposed 1 and left the kind of weapon as the article has it, both versions. The amounts do not add up inside the article: Dhs350,000 in the headline, Dhs300,000 plus Dhs63,000 in the two bags, and a fine of Dhs342,000 described as equal to the stolen money. The record's '$100,000' is in no source on file. Four men were sentenced, one of them a fugitive, and the article reports three arrests; the driver saw two men at the car where the victim counted four. Detention and violence stay at 0 on the file: the women sat in their own car, were threatened and had the bags snatched, and the article reports no injury and no holding. The verified summary's Attack Method line has a typo, 'An man'. I left it as given because the six fields are copied unchanged.

case 292

  • weapons — record: description 'Armed Robbers attack Miner at his Home' | article (Bitcoin.com (citing Bits.media)): 'an object resembling a gun' in the account of the attack, against 'stolen from the owner at gunpoint, authorities said' in the lead and 'Armed Robbery' in the subheading - the article does not settle whether the gun was real
  • notes — record: the 2 assailants stopped him while he was leaving his house and brought him back into the house | article (Bitcoin.com): 'One of them threatened him with an object resembling a gun and brought him back inside his apartment. Then, his accomplice came in' - one man took him back in and the second came in afterwards; the home is an apartment
  • OFF-CASE link: the article's closing paragraph mentions two other Russian incidents (armed robbers at a mining farm near Moscow in July 2021, $1 million in tether taken from a trader in Moscow) - different incidents, not used
  • note: One source, Bitcoin.com retelling a Bits.media report of the Tomsk prosecutor's charges; the sheet copy and the fetched page carry the same text. All six flags stand. The weapon is 'an object resembling a gun' in the detailed account and 'at gunpoint' in the lead, so 'armed' in the record should keep that hedge. The record could carry the fiat value (more than 360 million roubles, over $4.8 million at the time) and the 35 million roubles one suspect returned. The article does not say how long the miner was held, how the attack ended or how the men knew about his holdings, so duration and outcome are empty. Both men are in custody and charged; one pleaded guilty, and the trial at the Kirovsky Court had not taken place when the article was written. The article carries no publication date.

case 293

  • amount — record: money_wanted '3 bitcoin miners and 150,000 roubles ($2,040) in cash'; coin_type 'BTC / Roubles' | article (Reuters): 'three servers and 150,000 roubles ($2,040) in cash' - the article says servers, which the context makes mining servers; no bitcoin or other coin was taken
  • OFF-CASE link: the Reuters feature covers several other incidents: the overnight theft of 20 servers from Valeri's garage, the October shooting at a country house in which five armed men 'accidentally killed one of their own', the attempted break-in at Victor's warehouse, and the shots fired at the Chernomorenergo headquarters. None was used; only the one sentence on the Sukhumi home concerns this case
  • note: The whole case rests on one sentence in a Reuters feature about Abkhazia's illegal miners, attributed to the police; the record's notes field quotes it almost word for word. All six flags stand on that sentence. Three things the sentence does not say and the record or summary should not add: that the family were miners (the article places the raid in a list of thefts from miners and leaves it at that), how long they were held, and whether anyone was hurt. 'December 2021' is the month of the police statement as counted back from the 6 January 2022 dateline. 'Bitcoin miners' in money_wanted and 'BTC' in coin_type go beyond the article's 'three servers'; no coin was taken. Do not carry the 'one man was killed' line from the article's summary bullets into this case: it belongs to the October country-house shooting.