This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-27.md

13 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Batch 27 decisions (2026-10-01)

DA triage under batches/DECISION-RULES.md. Evidence in batches/contradictions-27.md, batches/batch-27.json and the dossiers in sources/. "Verified sequence" is the sequence in scenario-sequences.json.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 411 (DA) — location → Bali, abducted while riding a motorcycle; the rental car was traced to a villa in Tabanan (Jimbaran appears in no source); description → "tortured" rests on the ransom video only; "dismembered remains with matching tattoos found February 26" → body parts found at the mouth of the Wos River, about 30 km from Tabanan, partial tattoo match, DNA testing under way, police have not confirmed the body is Komarov's; discovery date differs (17 February per Bored Panda, 26 February per Pravda), both noted; victim spelling of the girlfriend: Eva (IBTimes) or Yeva (Bored Panda) Mishalova; whether Petrovsky was also taken differs (Pravda: both taken, Petrovsky escaped; IBTimes: Petrovsky and Mishalova escaped), both noted; attackers → not identified; one man ("CH") who rented the car on a false passport arrested, six foreign nationals named as suspects by initials RM, BK, AS, VN, SM, DH; drop the Nigerian name, the ramming, the Alphard and the stabbing (site summary only); money_wanted → $10 million in crypto, framed by the captors as repayment of money his family allegedly took; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon named; injuries imply an implement); life_taken → unconfirmed (identification not confirmed; coroner: identification impossible from decomposition); mark low-confidence (IBTimes: no authority has confirmed the kidnapping, ransom or injuries, and some journalists suggest staging), as 199; targeting vector = social media (companion's geotagged post, as reported) and a criminal debt dispute (as claimed in the video); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 on the video account, theft 0); arrests → some (one).
  • DB id 410 (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (no source mentions a weapon; gang robbery charge under Section 395, as 117); violence_torture → 0 (threats of arrest and immigration action only); drugs_alcohol → 0; notes → raid about 11:10 p.m. on 5 February 2026, officers left about 12:30 a.m. after the transfer was confirmed (about one hour twenty minutes, not 1.5 hours); RM400,000 demanded, RM200,000 accepted, paid as 50,000 USDT; drop the record's "($102,500)" conversion (no source); drop "one victim allowed to contact employer in China (conglomerate owner)" (in no source); description: "corrupt officers" stays an allegation (twelve officers arrested and released on bail, no charge reported; investigated as gang robbery, the victims' lawyer argues extortion); arrests → all twelve arrested (seven first, five more on 8 February 2026), released on bail; targeting vector = unknown (not stated); sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (serving officers raided the rented bungalow and held the eight there until the transfer; the 2026-09-30 ruling puts the attack label after Authority Misuse, as 150 and 414); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); source notes: the NST link returned almost no text; The Block's closing paragraphs are context only.
  • DB id 407 (DA) — location → abducted in Granadilla de Curridabat (ESPN; San Pedro was the 5Dimes office), held at a house in La Trinidad de Moravia (casino.org); description: drop "at gunpoint" (no weapon in any source): two traffic officers pulled him over about 10 p.m., four men in a rented grey pickup took him; the officers took the Porsche; money_wanted kept "$5M demanded, about $1M paid in Bitcoin" (ESPN, Tico Times, TechnoLlama; casino.org about $950,800; gambling911 says the full amount, noted as the outlier); notes → remains found almost a year later in Quepos (a cemetery per ESPN and casino.org, a shallow grave per the Tico Times, a grave in a suspect's grandmother's backyard per gambling911), identified by the OIJ; cause of death not determined; said at trial he was killed after recognising a former employee; drop the Diario Extra torture video (in no source on file); violence_torture → unconfirmed (no violence in captivity described; the killing sits in life_taken; no rule covers an unknown cause of death); weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); drugs_alcohol → 0; arrests → convicted: nine sentenced in May 2022 by the Goicoechea court, 515 years in total with 65 for Morales Vega (casino.org, ESPN), against the Tico Times "most received a maximum of 35 years" under a plea deal (both noted), a tenth acquitted; Morales Vega fled overland to Panama, then El Salvador (casino.org) and Cuba, arrested in Spain on 11 January 2021; targeting vector = insider (his own inner circle at 5Dimes and their relatives, a plan of more than a year); sequence was Kidnapping (record); now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (verified: serving traffic officers made the stop, as 93 and 111); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, theft 1, life_taken 1).
  • DB id 405 (DA) — date → 12 February 2026, about 7 a.m. per RTL, about 6 a.m. per Cryptoast (both noted); location → Val-de-Marne; an apartment building per RTL, a house in Saint-Mandé per Cryptoast (both noted); victim → David Princay (The Block) or Prinçay (Cryptobriefing), head of Binance France, absent; add the neighbour whose door they forced to have the right apartment pointed out (unnamed); kidnappings → 1 (detention used on a third party to execute the attack, clarification 2); drugs_alcohol → 0; coin_type → crypto (unspecified), the two stolen phones move to notes (as 160); attackers → three hooded men, reportedly armed, aged 18, 20 and 21 (Cryptoast); one carried a handgun when arrested; arrests → all three in police custody, picked up at Lyon-Perrache (RTL) or Part-Dieu (Cryptoast), no charge reported; Cryptoast (citing Le Progrès) says at least one of the targets suffered harm, without saying which; link to 406 (same trio, same morning); targeting vector = unknown (how the trio found his address is not stated); sequence was Home Invasion (record); now Home Invasion → Dodged Attack, attempted: the home-jacking of the head of Binance France (foiled attempt, as 147 and 84); flags unchanged (violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); source notes: bitcoinethereumnews.com refused the request, no text; the RTL trailer for the David Balland series and Cryptoast's trend paragraphs not used.
  • DB id 404 (DA) — victim → a couple and their daughter, 20 per RTL's standfirst, "in her twenties" in the body; notes → mother held on the ground by the neck while the daughter was taken to another room (not harmed, prosecutor); a person in their fifties was threatened with a key and a screwdriver for the codes (RTL's sentence does not settle whether the mother or the father: feminine subject, masculine agreement); no crypto transfer obtained (Meaux prosecutor); at least five hooded, gloved men; coin_type → BTC (a transfer from the father's Ledger key was demanded), the computers and phones taken move to notes (as 160); date 6 February 2026 kept (RTL: early morning of Friday 6 February; 6 February 2026 was a Friday); drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector unknown (not stated); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, weapons 1 for the key and screwdriver used as threats, theft 1 for the devices, life_taken 0); arrests none reported; source notes: RTL's closing paragraph on Dompierre-sur-Mer is another case, not used.
  • DB id 403 (DA) — attackers → three teenagers from Sheffield, aged 16 and 17 at the time; Decrypt names none and says one cannot be named for legal reasons, so no names enter the record (Faris Hassan and Mikyle Bethune are site-summary only); money_wanted → $4.3 million in crypto and the victim's BMW (drop "X3" and the £3.1 million figure, in no source); notes → the stolen car triggered an ANPR camera on the M1 less than three hours later and was stopped on the M6 after a pursuit; when the three were arrested is not stated; crypto recovered within 72 hours and returned two weeks later (Met); drop ZachXBT, chat logs, Ring footage, the two Ethereum addresses and the ENS domain (in no source on file); sentencing date not stated; violence_torture → 0 (knifepoint threats, no injury); drugs_alcohol → 0; sequence was Authority Misuse (record); now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (owner ruling of 2026-09-30, delivery-driver ruse at the door; 403 is on the ruling's list); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests → convicted, all three pleaded guilty, 16 years youth detention in total, 46 to 80 months each; source notes: the YouTube link is a video, not transcribed; the BlockSec commentary in Decrypt is context only.

Needs owner decision

DB id 412 (owner) — Hung Hom, 7 March 2026: a 25-year-old mainland Chinese man attacked at a hotel by three men and a woman, crypto taken from his account, then taken to an industrial unit where silver was seized.

  • Settled (DA): amount → HK$5.3 million in crypto and HK$800,000 in silver, about HK$6.1 million total (SCMP, the primary; The Bit Gazette HK$5m/HK$1m from the same statement, noted); drop the 42 kg and the dollar conversions; injuries to hands, ear and mouth; date 7 March kept (report at 3:52 a.m. Saturday); drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed; no arrests.
  • Question: the record's lure (fake business meeting), the victim's silver-trader occupation and the 42 kg of silver rest only on the CCN article, which refused the request and has no text on file. Readable sources support Kidnapping (moved to the industrial unit; listed as blackmail and false imprisonment). Drop Malicious Invitation now, or re-fetch CCN first? DA recommends: re-fetch CCN; if it carries the lure, Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping; if not, Kidnapping alone.

DB id 409 (owner) — "Sillytuna", March 2026: about $24 million in aEthUSDC drained; on his own X posts he fought off four armed attackers ("axes over your hands and feet"). Owner has kept the case; no label is set.

  • Settled (DA): location "Hun Hom, Hong Kong" → not stated (in no source); amount → about $24 million in aEthUSDC (Coinpedia: $23.6 million); date 4 March 2026 is the date of his X posts (a Wednesday), the attack date is not stated; drugs_alcohol → 0; no arrest, no police confirmation.
  • Question 1 (label): no source gives a venue, so Home Invasion, Kidnapping and Armed Robbery cannot be supported. DA recommends: leave the sequence empty until a source places the attack.
  • Question 2 (central fact): The Block carries his account of a physical attack; PeckShield-based coverage (Coinpedia/TradingView, BeInCrypto) calls it a suspected address-poisoning attack "with violent threats". DA recommends: keep, marked uncorroborated (victim's own account, no police statement), and do not publish flags as confirmed until a second source settles it.

DB id 408 (owner) — Istanbul, January 2026: Chinese businessman Yong Wang (Yun Wang in London CLUP), 38, reported missing from Bakırköy on 24 January, found buried bound with packing tape in a field in Baklalı, Arnavutköy.

  • Settled (DA): date → 24 January 2026 is the missing-person report, attack date not stated; location → disappeared in Bakırköy, body found in Arnavutköy; drugs_alcohol → 0; weapons → unconfirmed (a "hard object" per London CLUP's belief; the pickaxe and shovels were burial tools); ten suspects identified, Interpol notice, detained in China; drop "fled to China" and "including decoy woman".
  • Question 1 (scenario and source): the dinner lure, the named woman, the four-man team outside a Fatih restaurant, the live upright burial, strangulation and skull trauma come only from en.haberler.com, which returned no text. Readable sources support Kidnapping (vanished and found bound elsewhere). DA recommends: re-fetch en.haberler.com before ruling; until then Kidnapping, and cut those details.
  • Question 2 (theft): London CLUP believes his crypto wallet was taken; Turkiye Today says he was killed in an attempted robbery. DA recommends: theft → unconfirmed, both accounts in notes.

DB id 406 (owner) — Vaucresson, 12 February 2026, 9:15 a.m.: the same trio as 405 struck a woman on the head with pistol butts at the wrong address, said "X. lives at another number" and fled.

  • Settled (DA): kidnappings → 0 (blows and immediate flight, no entry or holding described; clarification 3; checker revised); drugs_alcohol → 0; description: drop the name "Stéphane" (RTL writes only "X."); drop the attackers' ages and "injuries" (not in RTL); arrests → in police custody at Lyon-Perrache, no charge reported; link to 405.
  • Question: RTL describes no entry into her home and no control, so Home Invasion has nothing to rest on. Keep Home Invasion, or switch to Dodged Attack with the home-jacking of "X." listed as attempted (as 416, door never breached)? DA recommends: Dodged Attack, attempted Home Invasion, with the gap that she was a bystander at the wrong address.