This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-28.md

12 KiB

Batch 28 decisions (2026-10-01)

DA triage under batches/DECISION-RULES.md. Evidence in batches/contradictions-28.md, batches/batch-28.json and the dossiers in sources/. "Verified sequence" is the sequence in scenario-sequences.json.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 402 (DA) — victim → two adults restrained, plus a third person who hid at the back of the home, called 911 and never met the intruders; description: "posed as FedEx drivers" → arrived with a box and a dolly claiming to be delivery drivers (one had bought FedEx-style uniforms earlier; UPS-style clothing found at the scene); notes → restrained the two adults with duct tape (zip ties were only found lying in the home and backyard); threw the male victim to the ground and, when he said he had no bitcoin, allegedly forced his head into the ground; LaPaille denied assaulting anyone; the pair said they were extorted over Signal by "Red" and "8", who supplied the target and $1,000 for supplies; weapons → 1 (a 3D-printed gun, unloaded, working state unknown, found at the scene; no source says it was pointed at anyone); targeting vector = tip-off from unidentified handlers ("Red" and "8"); sequence was Authority Misuse (record); now Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (owner ruling of 2026-09-30, delivery ruse; 402 is on the ruling's list); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some: both teens arrested at the scene about 11:35 a.m., to be tried as adults, eight felonies each, released on $50,000 bonds with ankle monitors; "Red" and "8" not identified; source notes: bitcoinethereumnews.com blocked, no text; "the mother" tipped police is not on file (the Tribune says "a parent", Gizmodo "one of the teens' mothers").
  • DB id 401 (DA) — date 5 February 2026 kept (break-in about 3 a.m. Thursday; Le Dauphiné Libéré: night of Wednesday to Thursday); original_date → night of 4 to 5 February 2026; victim → a 35-year-old magistrate at the Grenoble appeal court and her 66-year-old mother (Le Monde), the younger woman the partner of an executive of a Lyon crypto company (Le Dauphiné Libéré); description: "released after 30 hours" → freed on Friday 6 February by a passer-by who heard banging behind a garage door in Bourg-lès-Valence, 90 km away; held tied and gagged; duration more than 24 hours (Le Monde) or 30 hours (Le Dauphiné Libéré headline), both noted; ransom demand likely (Le Monde), amount not stated, nothing paid; theft → 0; weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); drugs_alcohol → 0; the dossier's AI summary details (three attackers, broken front door, blows to the face, blood stains, JIRS Lyon, the startup acquisition) are in no block on file and stay out of the record; targeting vector = unknown (the women were leverage on the partner's crypto business; how they were selected is not stated); sequence was Home Invasion (record); now Home Invasion → Kidnapping (verified: forced into a car and held 90 km away, rule of 2026-10-01); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 for "found alive but injured", life_taken 0); arrests not stated; source notes: both blocks are hard-trimmed, a fuller extract from staging is worth pulling; Cryptoast under 405 refers to this case.
  • DB id 398 (DA) — description: drop "BitConnect's developer and administrator" and "access to over 25,000 Bitcoin" (in no source); victim → Dhaval Mavani, "also attached with the bankrupt firm" BitConnect (CID chief Ashish Bhatia, The Hindu); attackers → Shailesh Bhatt's men; drop "nine accomplices" (no count in any source); named: Nikunj Bhatt (The Hindu), Nikunj Bhatt and Sanjay Kotadia (India Today); money_wanted → keep both accounts: 2,256 bitcoins worth Rs 131 crore plus another 166 bitcoins worth Rs 9.64 crore plus Rs 14.50 crore in cash (The Hindu, CID) against 2,254 bitcoins, 11,000 Litecoins and Rs 14.5 crore in cash (India Today, ED); drop the record's dollar conversions (no source); notes: drop the farmhouse, 1 to 4 February captivity, Gujarat warning, UAE deportation and FBI inquiry (site summary only; where and how long he was held is not stated); violence_torture → threat only (gunpoint kidnapping, no assault on Mavani; the beating in The Hindu is of Bhatt by Amreli police, another case), as 179 and 202; drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector = business counterparty (a defrauded BitConnect investor recovering his losses); link to 397 (same operation, second victim); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); arrests → some (nephew Nikunj Bhatt arrested by the CID at the time; ED arrested Shailesh Bhatt, then Nikunj Bhatt and Kotadia in January 2026).
  • DB id 397 (DA) — reports: add The Hindu (https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/bitcoin-extortion-case-complainant-now-becomes-an-accused/article23956811.ece, on file under 398), which states: "Bhatt's accomplices first kidnapped Piyush Savalia by posing as Income Tax officials ... Mr. Savalia was confined in a farm house at gun-point for three days in January-end", and that Bhatt "paid ₹34.50 lakh to Piyush Savalia to keep mum and give a false statement that he was never kidnapped"; description kept on that basis (Income Tax ruse, farm house, gunpoint, three days); duration: three days per the CID (The Hindu), "released two days later" per the Congress spokesperson (New Indian Express), both noted; attackers: drop "nine accomplices" (no count in any source); victim spelling Savaliya / Savalia; violence_torture → 0 (no assault described); drugs_alcohol → 0; theft stays 0 (nothing on file obtained from Savaliya); targeting vector = business counterparty (defrauded investor; Savalia worked for BitConnect); link to 398; sequence was Authority Misuse (record), verified Kidnapping; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (claimed official role on the approach, ruling of 2026-09-30; the ruling's note left 397 out only because no impersonation was on its own file, and The Hindu now supplies it); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, weapons 1, life_taken 0); arrests not stated for this kidnapping.
  • DB id 396 (DA) — money_wanted → 3,000,000 EUR in cryptocurrency (Le Dauphiné Libéré: "Une rançon de 3 millions d'euros en cryptomonnaies"); description: drop "amount unknown"; notes: "70-year-old" → 74 (headline and body; 70 is the URL slug); "freed in the early hours of Monday" → freed a little before midnight on Sunday night, near Loriol (Drôme), by the Lyon BRI; date 25 January 2026 kept (taken from his home in Voiron after 6 a.m. on Sunday; the 26 January report fixes the Sunday); victim → the father of an expatriate whose supposed crypto wallet was the target; the son received threats; weapons → unconfirmed (abduction not described); drugs_alcohol → 0; targeting vector = unknown (the father was leverage on the son's supposed holdings; selection not stated); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 for the serious hand injury, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some (three men in custody in Lyon); source notes: the kept block is paragraphs 20 to 23 of 42; the 18-hour duration and the mutilation reference may be in dropped paragraphs, worth a fuller extract.
  • DB id 395 (DA) — victim stays "17-year-old" (Nice-Matin's "Arthur" is a pseudonym and stays out of the database); attackers → two hooded men at the scene (one with a knife, one with a revolver); ten days later the BRI arrested several individuals, all minors, free under judicial supervision pending trial; notes kept; add the campaign that followed (50,000 euros in crypto demanded of the brother in Dubai by a fake Snapchat account, threats to the mother and sister; while the family was abroad, the flat's lock was forced and a video showed petrol poured on the door); those follow-on acts attacked no person and stay in this record's notes; targeting vector = unknown (the boy was leverage on his brother, who works in crypto; selection not stated); sequence Kidnapping kept (forced at knifepoint up about ten floors and held, never taken out of his building; gap noted); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → some.
  • DB id 394 (DA) — victim → "Maxence", a reported first name ("un certain Maxence", Journal du Coin; "soi disant prénommée Maxence", ActuCrypto), an alleged crypto scammer; weapons → 0 (none mentioned); notes kept with the hedge (Journal du Coin keeps the account in the conditional); no ransom demand or transfer reported; motive: recovering money the three say they lost to his fake crypto investments ("expédition punitive", ActuCrypto); targeting vector = business counterparty (alleged fraud victims; he was recognised in the street); sequence Express Kidnapping kept (owner, 2026-10-01: stays Express, recognised by chance in the street); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 0, life_taken 0); arrests → all three in pre-trial detention; trial set for 27 February 2026, outcome not on file, status needs a refresh; source notes: both blocks retell Le Bien Public, the primary is not on file; the Haute-Savoie paragraph in both is another case, not used.
  • DB id 393 (DA) — description kept with Ouest-France's conditional ("aurait été séquestré"; actu.fr states it flatly); violence_torture → unconfirmed ("On ignore si une personne a été blessée"; the gendarmerie canvass was for "un cambriolage avec violences"); weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); theft → unconfirmed (neither article says whether the code was obtained); how the 40 minutes ended is not stated; the AI summary's PNACO and parallel investigations are in no block on file and stay out; quarter field "Q1-2026" → "2026-Q1"; targeting vector unknown (not stated); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); arrests not stated (a gendarmerie canvass a week later, on 15 January 2026); source notes: the Ouest-France block's other lines concern two other incidents (Saint-Léger-sous-Cholet, 9 January; a couple with two children assaulted the same day), not used here.

Needs owner decision

DB id 400 (owner) — Tucson, 31 January 2026: Nancy Guthrie, 84, mother of Savannah Guthrie, taken from her home at night per detectives; the only crypto element is a bitcoin ransom note of unconfirmed authenticity sent to TMZ (a second to KOLD).

  • Settled (DA): drop the 9:30 p.m. drop-off and the ~2 a.m. pacemaker timeframe (PCSD has released no timeframes); blood trail kept with Raw Story's hedge (whose blood is unclear); weapons → unconfirmed; drugs_alcohol → 0; cameras including a Ring doorbell removed from the property; status dated 3 February 2026, needs a refresh.
  • Question: does the case belong in the database? For: a ransom note demanding bitcoin "in the millions" to a real address (TMZ). Against: the AP's source says investigators do not believe it was a kidnapping-for-ransom plot, and police have not said whether the note is from the kidnappers or a hoax. DA recommends: keep it flagged "crypto link unconfirmed" until the investigation settles the note, as 96 was kept flagged "motive not established".

DB id 399 (owner) — Dominican Republic, 31 October 2025: a young trader lured to an apartment for a cash trade, ambushed by five men, lost $750,000 in crypto. Reported directly to Gart Research by the victim; no article on file. Owner has kept the case; no label is set.

  • Settled (DA): the dossier's long AI-summary narrative (bank transfer, Telegram group, towel strangulation, car) has no source on file and stays unpublished.
  • Question 1 (label): the record's own description reads as P2P Trade Gone Wrong (a cash trade as the lure, ruling 117/104) or Malicious Invitation, followed by Kidnapping if he was held at the attackers' apartment. DA recommends: P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping once confirmed, not before.
  • Question 2 (evidence): all six flags are unverified because nothing is on file. DA recommends: get the victim's account written into the dossier as a dated statement (with his consent on naming), then verify flags and label against it.