This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-30.md

11 KiB

Batch 30 decisions (2026-10-01)

Taken from batches/contradictions-30.md; evidence in batches/batch-30.json and the dossiers in sources/. Rules: batches/DECISION-RULES.md.

"Sequence ... kept" and "sequence was A; now B" compare with the verified sequence in scenario-sequences.json; where the record's own scenario field differs, the line says so. decisions-30.json lists changes against scenario-sequences.json only.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 382 (DA) — victim → Yu, 46, male proprietor, and Lee, 37, a female employee (Dimsum Daily; "his wife" is in no source); attackers → four to five men armed with knives (notes' "three suspects" dropped); notes: "closing the shop at around 8:00 p.m." → staff threatened in a stairwell of W Plaza, 608 Nathan Road, officers alerted at 8.43 p.m. by a security guard; Yu treated at Kwong Wah Hospital for a finger injury; date 13 December 2025 kept (Saturday night); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Armed Robbery in Public Space (raid faltered when the owner resisted; as 147, 189); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1 hand injury in the struggle, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 knives, theft 0 "no financial losses and no property was taken", life_taken 0); classified as attempted robbery, no arrests; single source (Dimsum Daily, Wayback copy), url_2 thin, url_3 dead, url_4 blocked.
  • DB id 380 (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ("feita refém no local", "O roubo durou cerca de uma hora", Livecoins); violence_torture → 0 (no assault or injury described); victim → a woman crypto investor ("uma investidora de criptomoedas"); money_wanted and coin_type swapped back: money_wanted → about R$300,000 in cryptocurrency forcibly transferred, plus a pickup worth R$200,000, phones and laptops taken; coin_type → BTC per the record, cryptocurrency per the article; drop the unsourced "(approximately $50,000 USD)"; attackers → two armed men inside, a third waiting in a vehicle, a fourth instructing the transfer by phone, five more laundering; eight arrested (six men, two women), one at large; venue: Livecoins calls it both her office and a residence, Home Invasion covers either; sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 "ambos estavam armados", toy gun among items seized; theft 1; life_taken 0); targeting vector = insider tip-off (renovation workers heard her mention Bitcoin three to four months earlier; DEFINITIONS lists 380 under this value); outcome released (inferred); Operação Cryptonita; YouTube links not transcribed.
  • DB id 379 (DA) — scenario: record's Costly Fame → sequence Kidnapping kept (verified sequence; no source on file says the attackers found or chose him through his public profile, as in 104 where Costly Fame was not applied; targeting vector = public profile suspected, not established: La Presse calls him "richissime influenceur", CBC documents his Telegram group and the AMF order); weapons → 1 ("enlevés par des inconnus encagoulés et armés", La Presse); theft → unconfirmed (they demanded his phone code; no source says anything was obtained); notes: "A drug addict lent her basement" → Joanie Lepage admitted renting the basement of her mobile home to an acquaintance who wanted to steal his wallet (diary: "3000 $"); "The 3 were freed the next day" → the three others were found hours later near a bus stop in Montreal's west end (CBC) or the following day in western Montreal (Global News), both logged; victim → Kevin Mirshahi, 25, plus three abducted friends (two women, one man); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 beaten to death, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 1); venue: seized at his Old Montreal condo's parking garage, held in Lepage's basement in Les Cèdres; arrests some (Lepage pleaded guilty to forcible confinement of the three friends on 11 December 2025; Perry and Hickey charged; Nobert sought; La Presse: three other men charged); CTV link on-case by headline but empty, not used.
  • DB id 377 (DA) — location → Mijas, Málaga province (Tekedia, CoinDesk); Madrid and Málaga are where the raids took place; victim → a man of Dutch origin, 37, and his Colombian partner, 29 (Tekedia only); drugs_alcohol → 0 (none mentioned); theft → 0 (the Spanish suspects face a charge of "attempted theft"; no asset reported obtained); scene: Blockonomi has them assaulted at home and forced into a nearby house, CoinDesk has them ambushed and taken by vehicle to a house; both logged, Kidnapping holds either way (held hours in a house that was not theirs); site summary: drop the Lamborghini / "Operación Lambo-Urus" and the luxury-lifestyle claim (in none of the four articles); sequence Kidnapping kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1 shot in the leg and "signs of violence", weapons 1 handguns, life_taken 1); outcome: woman released around midnight, man found dead in a wooded area in Mijas, homicide; arrests some (five arrested in Spain, four charged in Denmark, announced mid-December 2025: TRT World "Wednesday", CoinDesk "Thursday", 14 December); Blockonomi's trend paragraphs and CoinDesk's framing not used.
  • DB id 375 (DA) — description: "Armed Robbers Steal $85K in Trinidad Crypto Ambush" → two armed men robbed a buyer of $85,800 in cash (currency not stated) and the occupants' mobile phones at a car park during an in-person crypto purchase; no crypto taken; site summary: drop "forcibly transferred" and "physically assaulted" (no transfer or assault described); victim → 52-year-old Arouca resident; location → SuperPharm parking lot, Trincity Central Road; sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space (cash brought to a cash-for-crypto trade with a two-year trading partner, robbed at gunpoint, as 94; gap: the report does not say whether the 33-year-old partner took part, as 83); flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1 "two armed men", theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown, business counterparty possible (investigators have not said whether the partner was involved); date 29 November 2025 kept; arrests none; the Cryptonews round-up (vehicle thefts, Lopp statistics, British Columbia, San Francisco, New York, Chicago, Balland) not used.
  • DB id 366 (DA) — weapons → 1 (gasoline bought at a Wagramer Strasse station and used to set him alight; melted canister recovered; glossary: "other tools used as weapons"; DA call, owner may set 0); date 25 November 2025 kept (attack began hours before the blaze at about 12.30 a.m. on 26 November; family reported him missing on 25 November); money_wanted → not stated ("authorities declined to specify the total sum stolen"); victim → Danylo K., 21, Ukrainian student, son of Kharkiv's deputy mayor; location → seized in the underground garage of the Sofitel SO/Vienna, Praterstraße; killed in the car on Marlen-Haushofer-Weg, Donaustadt; sequence Kidnapping kept (pre-selected by a fellow student, held in a vehicle and driven away); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1 accounts emptied, life_taken 1); targeting vector = acquaintance (fellow student, 19); arrests all (two suspects arrested in Ukraine on 29 November; case transferred to Ukrainian jurisdiction); single source (Cryptonews citing local reports); trailing round-up not used.

Needs owner decision

DB id 381 (owner) — La Rochelle area, 18 December 2025: crypto investor and partner tied up at home around 5 a.m., transfers made. Le Parisien (the only article in this dossier) says three attackers, amount unknown, no violence; round-up tails in other dossiers say more.

  • Settled (DA): weapons → 0 (none described); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings 1, theft 1 "plusieurs virements"; drop "four criminals" and "data leak" (no source on file says either).
  • Q1: Location, amount and violence. For the record (Dompierre-sur-Mer, 8 million, beaten): franceinfo in 392 "à Dompierre-sur-Mer ... huit millions d'euros de cryptomonnaies"; Cryptoast in 389 "séquestré et agressé un couple ... à Dompierre-sur-Mer ... environ 8 millions d'euros"; Actu17 in 388 "les avoir frappés pendant près de deux heures"; 404's article "Dompierre-sur-Mer le 18 décembre". Against: Le Parisien "à leur domicile de La Rochelle", "Le montant ... n'est pas connu", no assault. DA recommends: location → Dompierre-sur-Mer near La Rochelle, money_wanted → about 8 million euros in crypto (not $10 million), violence_torture stays 1, citing those tails, and fetch a dedicated report (The Big Whale, which Le Parisien cites).

DB id 376 (owner) — Maiduguri, Nigeria, 4 to 7 November 2025: eight-year-old girl kidnapped from school by a gang her uncle organised; ransom of 3 million naira paid via a cryptocurrency account.

  • Settled (DA): notes: drop "held in a hotel" (no hotel in the article; where she was held not stated), dates 4 to 7 November; weapons → 0; summary: drop "targeting the family's cryptocurrency holdings" (no holdings mentioned); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 1 alleged, theft 1); five arrested; targeting vector = family (uncle as organiser).
  • Q: Does a case belong in the database when crypto is only the payment rail and nobody is a crypto holder? Keep: the ransom was "paid via cryptocurrency", Mustapha Mohammed "received the 3 million naira ransom through a cryptocurrency account". Remove: no crypto asset was targeted. DA recommends: remove from the holder count, or keep under a "crypto as payment rail" mark if the owner wants that pattern tracked.

DB id 374 (owner) — Chalon-sur-Saône, 22 November 2025: six men, two of them minors, arrested in the act of an attempted kidnapping of a crypto investor; the article says earlier attempts on the same target failed.

  • Settled (DA): weapons → 0 (none mentioned); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping; description: "for the fourth time" keeps its hedge (headline and the JSL post say fourth; the body says four earlier attempts, then describes three); flags unchanged (all 0); arrests all; the Morocco-mastermind opening not used.
  • Q: Open records for the earlier attempts on the same man? For: the body says the first two operations failed and the third was stopped by a police intervention without arrests. Against: no date, place or detail for any of them. DA recommends: no new records; note the series on 374 (repeat victimisation, as 179).

DB id 373 (owner) — Val-d'Oise, 1 December 2025: father of a 19-year-old in Dubai seized by several men, filmed bound, gagged and beaten to extort his son; hospitalised in critical condition.

  • Settled (DA): weapons → 0; theft → 0 (a large sum demanded, nothing reported paid); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1.
  • Q1: Keep without an established crypto motive? Entrevue (single source): the son is "possibly also" skilled in cryptocurrency; police weigh an extortion over the son's digital skills, a financial dispute, or family tensions. DA recommends: keep, flagged "motive not established" as 96.
  • Q2: "four men in black, balaclavas, gloves, a van" and "He was released" are in no text on file; Entrevue says only several individuals, a vehicle, and hospitalised in critical condition. DA recommends: drop both unless the source behind them is traced.