Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
25 KiB
Batch 37 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
Taken case by case from batches/contradictions-37.md; evidence in batches/batch-37.json and sources/<id>_*.txt. Criteria in batches/DECISION-RULES.md. Every case in this batch already has a verified scenario sequence; none is changed here.
Approved (DA)
- DB id 234 (DA) — victim → ten Korean men invited to the meeting, two of them taken up to the room and tied, none named (Cointelegraph: 'invited 10 Korean men to the hotel. Two were called to the room while the others waited in the lobby'; the record's 'Unidentified man' counts one); location → hotel in Gangseo District, Seoul ('at a hotel in Seoul's Gangseo District'); description → three Russian nationals posed as parties to a peer-to-peer crypto deal, invited ten Korean men to a hotel, ambushed the two called up to the room with a replica handgun and a telescopic baton, tied their hands with cable ties and tried to take 1 billion won in cash; one of the victims escaped and raised the alarm and the suspects fled without the cash (Cointelegraph, relaying JoongAng Daily; 'allegedly' kept); money_wanted → 1 billion won in cash, approximately $730,000 per Cointelegraph, the sum the suspects tried to take, nothing taken ('they tried to steal 1 billion won (approximately $730,000) in cash'); coin_type → cash (KRW), no cryptocurrency demanded or moved (the crypto deal was the pretext; as 94, 41 and 27); notes → one man in his 20s arrested in Busan on 27 May on charges of assault and attempted robbery, the other two left South Korea before the exit ban was filed the next morning, Interpol's help requested; police found a replica firearm, batons, vests and a money counter in the suspects' room; reports → Cointelegraph, relaying JoongAng Daily (the JoongAng report is not on file); arrests → some (one of three); date 21 May 2025 kept ('occurred on May 21'; the year is the record's, the report's own date is not on file); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('tying their hands with cable ties'); violence_torture stays 1 ('ambushed the victims with a replica handgun and a telescopic baton'; police 'found one man bleeding in the lobby', whom the article does not identify as one of the two tied up; charge of assault); weapons stays 1 (replica handgun and telescopic baton; replica noted, as 136 and 432); theft stays 0 ('prompting the suspects to flee without the cash'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated; targeting vector = trade lure (staged P2P deal; how the contact was made is not stated); source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same Cointelegraph page; its context items (the Manhattan case, the Noizat family attempt of 13 May, the bodyguard-demand item) are other matters, not used.
- DB id 236 (DA) — date → 23 May 2025 (TN, dated 28 May 2025 in the text and in its URL: 'El hecho ocurrió el viernes por la noche'; 28 May 2025 was a Wednesday, so the Friday before it is 23 May; the record's 27 May was a Tuesday); location → Palermo, Buenos Aires, a first-floor apartment at Ravignani 1596, at Gorriti ('en un edificio de la calle Ravignani 1596, en la intersección con Gorriti'); victim → Russian couple who run a cryptocurrency business, a woman of 30 and her partner of 27, not named (TN); description → two Chechens who had rented a first-floor apartment for the previous two nights invited the couple to dinner on the Friday night and tied them up; a ransom of 43,000 dollars in digital currency was paid by a compatriot friend who lives in Partido de la Costa, after a conversation with the captors; the two suspects are reported to have flown from Ezeiza to the United Arab Emirates in the hours after (TN hedges kept: 'habrían pagado un rescate' in the subheading, 'habrían tomado un vuelo'); money_wanted → 43,000 USD in digital currency, paid as ransom by a friend (TN: '43 mil dólares en moneda digital', US dollars, not pesos; the sum first demanded is not stated); coin_type → digital currency, coin not named (TN: 'moneda digital'); notes → around 11 p.m. the woman called for help in English from the balcony, staff of the neighbouring restaurant called 911 and City Police found the couple tied ('habían sido maniatados'); TN also calls the couple 'liberada' after the payment, both accounts noted; the two main suspects were identified and carry Interpol red notices, TN prints no names; case with the PFA's Departamento Antisecuestros Sur under judge María Romilda Servini; arrests → none (both suspects left the country); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('maniatados'); violence_torture stays 0 (no blow or injury described); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); theft stays 1 (ransom paid by the friend); life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated (dinner on Friday night, cries at about 11 p.m.); targeting vector unknown (the couple worked in crypto; how they knew the two men is not stated); summary: 'both were named as the main suspects' → identified by police, not named; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same TN page; the two 'Leé también' teasers are unrelated, not used.
- DB id 237 (DA) — violence_torture → 1 ('He was also beaten during the incident'; 'the trader has been given six days of French work incapacity benefits, according to Europe 1', Cointelegraph via MSN); theft → unconfirmed (he 'was released on Saturday after he revealed he couldn't pay and showed the kidnappers the low balance in his account'; no transfer or loss is stated, and the article does not say the balance was left untouched; the writer proposed 0, the rule for an unstated loss is unconfirmed, as 116 and 392); money_wanted → 50,000 EUR in crypto demanded, $57,000 per Cointelegraph, nothing reported paid ('demanding he hand over 50,000 euros ($57,000) in crypto'); coin_type → crypto, coin not named; victim → 26-year-old crypto trader who makes TikTok content, 40,000 followers, not named; description → a crypto trader who makes TikTok content was reportedly seized by four men on the Friday night as he returned home to Juvisy-sur-Orge, forced into a stolen vehicle and beaten, with 50,000 euros in crypto demanded; he was released on the Saturday after he said he could not pay and showed the low balance in his account ('reportedly' kept; the record's 'after opening his wallet and finding a tiny balance' is replaced by the article's wording); notes → six days of work incapacity; France's Organised and Specialised Crime Division is investigating; where he was kept between Friday night and Saturday is not stated beyond the stolen vehicle; reports → Cointelegraph (Stephen Katte), syndicated on MSN, relaying a Europe 1 report that is not on file; arrests → none reported; date 13 June 2025 kept ('snatched on Friday night'; 13 June 2025 was a Friday; the MSN copy carries no date, so the day rests on the record); location Juvisy-sur-Orge kept; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('forced the trader into a stolen vehicle'; 'released on Saturday'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = public profile / social media (TikTok trader; the article does not say that is how he was chosen); summary: 'nothing was taken' → no transfer or taking reported; source notes: the msn.com link is THIN on fetch, the sheet's copy of the MSN page is the only text.
- DB id 238 (DA) — weapons → unconfirmed (no weapon anywhere in Entrevue, and the seizure itself is not described; the only line on force is 'aurait subi des violences pour livrer ces informations'; writer proposed 0; DA call, as 396 and 401 where the abduction is not described; owner may set 0); money_wanted → a Ledger key plus 5,000 EUR in cash, demanded and handed over ('déposer une clé Ledger ... accompagnée de 5 000 euros en espèces, dans un sac à remettre devant l'immeuble'; 'impossible de savoir si la clé contenait effectivement des fonds'; the record's 'unknown amount' is replaced, the unknown being what the key held); coin_type → crypto on a Ledger key, contents unknown, and cash (EUR); description → a 23-year-old man was abducted on Tuesday 17 June 2025 in Maisons-Alfort while looking for a parking space; his partner, drawn home by a message about a work emergency, was told by video call to leave a Ledger key and 5,000 euros in cash in a bag in front of the building; an accomplice collected it and the man was released in Créteil several hours later, at about 5 p.m. ('from his wife' → from his partner: Entrevue says 'sa compagne' and 'la jeune femme', never wife); notes → planned abduction by well-informed captors ('très informés'); the partner followed the instructions without telling the authorities ('wife cooperated' → partner); investigators say he 'aurait subi des violences' to give up the details, and he came back 'sain et sauf' (conditional kept); Val-de-Marne judicial police seized for 'enlèvement et séquestration en bande organisée'; where and how he was seized and where he was held are not stated; arrests → none reported in this case (the article's 'interpellations' are in other files of the same kind); date 17 June 2025 kept ('mardi'; Entrevue is dated Friday 20 June 2025, so the Tuesday is 17 June); location Maisons-Alfort kept, released in Créteil; victim '23 y/o man' kept; sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('a été séquestré mardi à Maisons-Alfort'; 'relâché à Créteil'); violence_torture stays 1 on the hedged line ('aurait subi des violences', single-line basis as 456); drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 1 ('Un complice passe récupérer le sac'); life_taken stays 0; held duration hours ('plusieurs heures plus tard, vers 17 heures'); targeting vector unknown (how the captors knew of the key is not stated); summary: 'organised detention' → séquestration en bande organisée; source notes: single source, Entrevue of 20 June 2025; ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same page; the Vaulx-en-Velin teaser is unrelated, not used.
- DB id 240 (DA) — kidnappings → 1 ('The gang then locked Sriharsha, Benjamin, and others inside the shop before fleeing the scene'; 'The complainant and others managed to get out by opening the shop's shutters', Yes Punjab; locked in, explicit quote, after control was gained at knifepoint, as 77); description → Sriharsha V. brought Rs 2 crore in cash to a shop at MS Palya Circle, Vidyaranyapura, to have it converted into USDT through a middleman, Benjamin Harsha; while the money was being counted, six to seven men (six in the headline) barged in at about 4.30 p.m., two pulled knives and threatened to kill, took the mobile phones and the cash and locked the group in the shop (drop '$240,000': no dollar figure appears in the article, the conversion is the record's own); victim → Sriharsha V., 33, businessman from Kengeri New Town, with two friends (named in the article from his police complaint); location → a shop at MS Palya Circle, Vidyaranyapura, Bengaluru; coin_type → cash (INR), no cryptocurrency changed hands (the cash was to be converted into USDT); notes → he had raised the Rs 2 crore from savings and loans to buy machinery in Germany for a cold-pressed oil business; a friend introduced him to Benjamin Harsha, who asked him to bring the cash; after the group got out through the shutters, 'Benjamin and two of his associates fled the scene, according to the FIR'; the article does not state that Benjamin was part of the gang; the gang warned the victims not to go to the police; Sriharsha says he saw the attackers' faces; arrests → Benjamin Harsha and one other person detained and questioned, no arrest or charge reported ('detained Benjamin and another individual, and questioning them'); money_wanted Rs 2 crore kept ('Rs 2 crore in cash' throughout); date 25 June 2025 kept ('The incident occurred on June 25'; report dated 27 June 2025); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space kept; violence_torture stays 0 (knives drawn and death threats, no blow or injury described; the lede's 'attacked a businessman with a knife' noted); weapons stays 1 ('two of the assailants pulled out knives'); theft stays 1 ('snatched their mobile phones and stuffed the Rs 2 crore cash into a gunny bag'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration not stated; targeting vector = business counterparty (the meeting was arranged through the middleman; whether he tipped off the gang is not established); summary: remove Benjamin Harsha from 'Attackers', the article has him locked in with the others and then detained for questioning; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same Yes Punjab agency copy; trailing site content not used.
- DB id 242 (DA) — weapons → 1 ('l'un d'eux soit interpellé, en possession d'un hachoir', BFMTV; 'arrested nearby, in possession of two knives and a hachoir', the English write-up in the sheet's first column; a cleaver in both, the two knives in one; no source says a blade was shown inside the home, so the flag rests on what the attacker carried when arrested after the attack, as 172 and 213; DA call, owner may set unconfirmed); notes → targeted through social media over the couple's cryptocurrency holdings, on the arrested man's own statement ('il dit avoir ciblé le couple, via les réseaux sociaux'); the two got into her home and one punched her about ten times in the face while, per the English write-up, the other tried to reach the flat's private rooms; aim reported as her wallet credentials (English write-up only); drop 'demanded ransom' (no ransom in either text; the inquiry is for 'tentative de vol avec violence'); 'husband and police helped' → BFMTV has the husband and children witnessing the scene and the two fleeing, the English write-up credits the husband's intervention and the arrival of the police, both noted; taken to hospital 'en urgence relative', then filed a complaint; victim → a woman who owns cryptocurrencies, attacked at home in front of her husband and children, not named; reports → BFMTV, plus an English write-up by another outlet filed in the sheet under the BFMTV label and URL ('According to BFMTV reports and confirmed by Le Figaro'), outlet and URL to be found; arrests → some (one man arrested nearby, the second still sought); description kept ('une dizaine de coups de poing au visage', 'devant son mari et ses enfants'); date 7 July 2025 kept ('ce lundi 7 juillet'; 7 July 2025 was a Monday); location Suresnes kept; coin_type crypto kept; money_wanted stays empty (no amount in either text); sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list: entry into the home followed by a beating; no restraint or duration in any source); violence_torture stays 1; theft stays 0 (attempted robbery; nothing reported taken); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = social media (the arrested man's statement); summary: 'the attackers fled when the husband appeared' matches neither text and goes; 'forced entry' → got into her home, method not stated ('ont réussi à rentrer dans son domicile'); the batch file's outcome 'foiled' is for the outcome recheck under the ruling of 2026-10-07 (she was beaten inside her home); source notes: ARTICLE 2 is the English translation of the fetched BFMTV page, one source; the English write-up's 'tailing and home invasion' method, its link to a coming wave of extortion and its advice sections are that outlet's commentary, not used; the Balland, Palaiseau and Paris 11th passages are other cases.
- DB id 243 (DA) — weapons → 1 ('he was set upon by six men, who tased him in the chest', Daily News; the glossary's Weapons entry lists tasers; as the stun gun in 181); money_wanted → about 900,000 yen, 'equivalent to more than $6,000' per the Daily News, wired from a bank account and sent from a cryptocurrency account (the record's flat '$6000' loses the source currency and the 'more than'); description → a 38-year-old man told the NYPD that six men set upon him at his car in Flushing on 8 July 2025, tased him, drove him to an unknown location, handcuffed him at some point and held him for 10 days until he gave them about 900,000 yen, more than $6,000, by bank wire and from a cryptocurrency account ('$6,000' → about 900,000 yen); location → Flushing, Queens, New York, at 31st Rd. and Union St. where his car was parked, held at 'an unknown location'; notes → the whole account is the victim's statement to police ten days after he was taken ('he tells NYPD' in the headline); he was dropped back at his car on the morning of Friday 18 July 2025, drove to NewYork-Presbyterian Queens, called 911 just before 5 a.m. and decided he did not need treatment; 'It was not clear why the suspects targeted the victim or how wealthy they believed he was'; arrests → none reported; date 8 July 2025 kept ('on July 8', the day he was taken; report of 18 July 2025); victim '38 y/o man' kept; coin_type 'wire and crypto' kept, coin not named; sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('drove him in their car to an unknown location'; 'He was handcuffed at some point'; 'held him for 10 days'); violence_torture stays 1 (tased in the chest); theft stays 1 ('he gave them about 900,000 yen'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration days; targeting vector unknown; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and FETCHED ARTICLE 1 are the same Daily News page; its closing paragraphs on the May Manhattan case (Woeltz and Duplessie) are another incident, not used.
- DB id 244 (DA) — description → four police constables of Mata Ka Than Police Station allegedly took over Dilip Gaud's car while he and Ramesh Sharma were parking on 14 July 2025, drove the two to the station, held them from about 4 p.m. to about 8.30 p.m. and, under threat of false criminal charges, extorted Rs 2 lakh in cash and had cryptocurrency transferred from Dilip's phone, about Rs 8.6 lakh in USDT per Subkuz; the four were suspended after a departmental inquiry and arrested on Thursday 17 July 2025 (drop '$9,000 USD': no dollar figure in either report; drop 'fired': 'were suspended following a departmental inquiry', 'All the suspended policemen were attached to the Police Lines', and no source reports a dismissal; 'allegedly' and 'reportedly' kept, the account is Dilip's complaint); notes → the four are Narsingh Ram, Rakesh Poonia, Laduram and Jagmal Ram; 'later were fired' → suspended and arrested, no dismissal reported; cash: Rs 50,000 from each of the two, then Rs 1 lakh withdrawn by Ramesh with Dilip's wife's ATM card (report by Dinesh Bothra), given by Subkuz as Rs 1 lakh in cash and Rs 1 lakh from the wife's ATM; the crypto went 'to an associate of the policemen'; the two were made to sign documents; Dilip's iPhone was held for a time and no arrest notice or written action was shown to him (Subkuz); case registered at Mahamandir Police Station under the BNS; the reports differ and both versions are kept: the complainant's surname and address (Dilip Gaur of Ramdev Nagar in the Bothra report, Dilip Gaud of Banar Road in Subkuz), the place (a mall near Manji Ka Hatha against a showroom in Pawta), the uniforms (Jagmal in uniform with three or four others in plain clothes, against four uniformed policemen in a white car) and Rakesh's part (one of the four and present at the station in the Bothra report, 'another constable' at the station in Subkuz); victim → Dilip Gaud & Ramesh Sharma kept, with the spelling Gaur (Bothra report) noted as a variant; location → Jodhpur, Rajasthan: seized while parking at a mall near Manji Ka Hatha (Bothra report) or a showroom in Pawta (Subkuz), held at Mata Ka Than Police Station; reports → Subkuz, plus the report by Dinesh Bothra of 17 July 2025 quoting DCP (East) Alok Srivastava, filed in the sheet under the Subkuz label and URL, its own outlet and URL to be found; arrests → some (the four constables arrested on 17 July 2025; 'another police officer, currently posted elsewhere, is a suspect in the case too', not yet arrested); money_wanted kept (Rs 8.6 lakh in USDT, Subkuz only; Rs 1 lakh in cash and Rs 1 lakh from the wife's ATM card); coin_type 'USDT, cash' kept; date 14 July 2025 kept (both reports); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('allegedly abducting and unlawfully detaining two people'; 'took Gaur and Sharma to Mata Ka Than Police Station'; 'released around 8.30 pm'); violence_torture stays 0 (intimidation and threats; Dilip 'forcibly removed' from the driver's seat, no blow or injury described); weapons stays 0 (none mentioned); theft stays 1; drugs_alcohol stays 0; life_taken stays 0; held duration hours; targeting vector unknown (neither report says why the two were picked); summary: the surname is recorded as Gaud with Gaur as the variant, not the other way round; source notes: ARTICLE 2 is a three-line stub of the Subkuz page; the fetched Subkuz page is interleaved with unrelated headlines and ends in editorial comment, not used.
Needs owner decision
DB id 233 (owner) — Normandy, France, 2025: a 46-year-old mother and her 22-year-old son, a crypto trader, reported on 18 May that a team was watching their home to abduct them; on 11 June the BRI of Rouen and OFAST Le Havre intercepted the team's cars near the home and arrested five. Nobody was touched.
- Settled (DA): victim → a 46-year-old mother and her 22-year-old son, a cryptocurrency trader (Europe 1); description → a team planning to abduct the pair and cut off a knuckle of the mother's finger to make the son empty his wallet was intercepted near their home on 11 June; a GPS beacon had been placed under the family car; arrests → some (five suspects aged 18 to 24 arrested, indicted and jailed; Europe 1 does not say they were the whole team); location Normandie kept, town not stated; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty; sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping; kidnappings stays 0; violence_torture stays 0; drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 0; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = surveillance (GPS beacon, home visited; how he was picked is not stated); the year is the record's; 'told police' rests on the sheet's English text ('present a message to the police'), the French paragraph is not in the fetched block.
- Question 1, weapons: Europe 1 says 'Dans les voitures, un couteau et un rouleau de ruban adhésif ont été retrouvés'; the knife was never shown to the victims. For 1: owner ruling on 205 (foiled plot, knife carried on the day) and the DA lines on 426 and 421 (knife found in the car, never shown). For 0: owner ruling on 72 of 2026-10-01 ('weapons → 1 only if the victim saw the tools; the plot was intercepted before contact, so weapons → 0').
- Question 2, date: 18 May is the day the family went to the police ('The case dates back to May 18'); the interception was on 11 June ('le 11 juin dernier ... en fin d'après-midi').
- DA recommendation: weapons stays 0 under the later and more general ruling on 72, with the knife and tape in notes; if the owner prefers 1, the same answer should cover 426, 421 and 472. Date stays 18 May 2025 as the first dated point of the plot (as 30, where the first contact was kept and the arrests noted), with 11 June in notes as the interception.
DB id 235 (owner) — near Nantes, France, late May 2025: BRB officers watched two vans holding ten hooded men they believed were about to kidnap a crypto entrepreneur. The only text on the plot is 552 characters of TF1 INFO copy that ends before the police act; the linked source is a YouTube video that was never transcribed.
- Settled (DA): description → 'in balaclavas' becomes hooded, gloved and dressed in black, in two vans ('ten men, hooded, gloved and dressed in black'); location → near Nantes, Loire-Atlantique ('somewhere around Nantes'); date 26 May 2025 kept, unverified ('Monday morning'; 26 May 2025 was a Monday, no report date on file); sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted Kidnapping; kidnappings stays 0; violence_torture stays 0; drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 as recorded (none mentioned in the text on file); theft stays 0; life_taken stays 0; the sheet's 'Article 2' is an English wire story on Bajjou's arrest in Tangier with no URL, filed under TF1 INFO, and never mentions Nantes.
- Question 1, the arrests: the record's 'Police arrest 10 men' and the summary's 'all were arrested' have no line in any text on file; the untranscribed video may carry it.
- Question 2, the ringleader: the record says 'Ringleader was later arrested'. Article 2 calls Bajjou 'suspected of being one of the masterminds' of the January Balland kidnapping and says authorities 'are also probing Bajjou's possible involvement in the series of kidnappings or attempted kidnappings in May'; a second organiser 'remains at large'.
- DA recommendation: apply the ruling of 2026-10-01 on record details in no source: keep the ten arrests marked 'pending source trace' and transcribe the TF1 video (arrests stays empty until then). Reword the ringleader sentence to the article's hedge (a suspected organiser of the Balland kidnapping, arrested in Tangier, whose possible involvement in the May series is under investigation), and take 'this case's mastermind' out of the summary.