This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-39.md
StellarCrow 41766c68a2 chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step
label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of
2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch
(scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of
2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added
to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore).

The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on
2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
2026-10-17 10:47:37 +02:00

23 lines
21 KiB
Markdown

# Batch 39 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-39.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-39.json` and `sources/<id>_*.txt`. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. These cases carry a verified scenario sequence, so every sequence is kept as verified. Each flag is stated once per case in the form the export script reads.
## Approved (DA)
- **DB id 270** (DA) — description → an Odessa man who came to buy cryptocurrency was beaten and robbed by a suspect and his accomplices at a flat rented for the meeting, damage nearly 1,500,000 UAH (Bizlim: 'the assailant and his accomplices beat the man and stole his mobile phone, jewelry, and money'; drop 'Several men', the number is not given, and drop 'bitcoin', the article says only 'electronic currency' and 'cryptocurrency'); money_wanted → nearly 1,500,000 UAH, about 57,000 USD per Bizlim, as the total damage covering the money, the mobile phone and the jewellery ('caused the citizen damage amounting to nearly 1,500,000 UAH'; the split is not stated); coin_type → cash, no crypto taken (the coin he came to buy is not named); notes → the attackers rented an apartment on General Petrova Street for a short term and arranged the meeting there, so the flat was not their home ('rented an apartment on General Petrova Street in Odessa for a short term'; the Russian original has the suspect luring him 'к себе' by deceit); location → General Petrova Street, Odessa, Ukraine; victim → Odessa resident, not named; date January 2018 kept, day unknown; reports Bizlim kept (the English sheet copy and the Russian original agree); arrests → some (main suspect in custody without bail and indicted under Article 187 part 4, accomplices still sought, no arrest date given); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept (the order differs from 117, 41 and 77, where Malicious Invitation comes first; left as verified and listed for the label audit); kidnappings stays 0 (beaten and robbed in the rented flat, the article does not say he was held or how the encounter ended; DA call, owner may set 1 as in 143 if a beating in the attackers' flat is read as holding); violence_torture stays 1 ('beat the man'); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0 (none named); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure, how contact was made not stated; source notes: one source, a report of the Odessa prosecutor's indictment with no publication date.
- **DB id 271** (DA) — victim → the occupants of a rented home on Ballouville Road, none named: the female renter, an occupant pistol-whipped on the head, an occupant attacked with an electric cattle prod, and a child implied by the charge 'risk of injury to a child' (second report, which also lists 'five counts of first-degree threatening and four counts of second-degree reckless endangerment'); description → two Rhode Island women were arrested over a March home invasion in Killingly in which occupants were pistol-whipped and attacked with an electric cattle prod, and police say it stemmed from a Bitcoin account the renter had opened in the name of one suspect, who 'wanted passwords and money she said was stolen from her' (the stealing is Delannoy-Jodoin's claim relayed by police, so drop 'used it to steal her money' as fact; '2 women invaded' becomes two recognised and arrested, since 'two of the people that reportedly forced entry' leaves the number of intruders open); notes → the renter was chased into a bathroom, an intruder used a hammer to break in, and she escaped to a neighbour's house, one suspect told the other to 'shoot the victims', and the account dispute keeps 'allegedly'; money_wanted → passwords and money tied to the Bitcoin account demanded, no amount stated, and money, cell phones and a television taken; coin_type → BTC (the account in dispute; no crypto reported taken); location → Ballouville Road, Killingly, Connecticut; date March 2018 kept, day unknown (neither text prints the year; 2018 fits the archive snapshot of 18 October 2018 and nothing more); reports → Yahoo Finance, which syndicates the CCN story, plus a second and fuller local report pasted in the sheet with no URL (find its URL); arrests → some (Monique Delannoy-Jodoin, 59, of Manville and Beatriz Viruet, 38, of Providence arrested and charged, bonds of $250,000 and $100,000, whether they were the only intruders is not stated); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (forced entry followed by beating, clarification 1); violence_torture stays 1 ('pistol-whipped and attacked with an electric cattle prod'); drugs_alcohol stays 0 (the narcotics inquiry into Delannoy-Jodoin is a separate Rhode Island matter); weapons stays 1 (pistol, electric cattle prod, hammer); theft stays 1 ('The suspects stole money, cell phones and a television'); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = acquaintance (the renter recognised two intruders and had opened the account in one suspect's name); source notes: the site summary's 'tried to break into with a hammer' follows the garbled CCN sentence, the second report has the door broken; the CCN paragraph on a Miami shooting and the Yahoo teaser headlines are other matters, not used.
- **DB id 272** (DA) — description → a Kyiv cryptocurrency miner was seized near his home in the Podilsky district, hooded with a sack, forced into a car and driven out of the city, gave up his apartment keys and where he kept his money under death threats, lost $50,000 and was released in Brovary (Ain.UA; 'extorted' goes: prosecutors say he was kidnapped 'to demand a ransom', the charge is 'robbery by prior conspiracy' under Article 187 part 4; 'caught 8 months later' becomes two brothers detained, reported on 26 November 2018 by the URL date); money_wanted → $50,000 taken, form not stated; coin_type → not stated (the article gives only '$50,000', reached through 'the keys to his apartment' and 'information about where he kept his money'; no cryptocurrency is said to be taken); location → Podilsky district, Kyiv, driven outside the city and released in Brovary; victim → cryptocurrency miner, Kyiv resident, not named; date March 2018 kept, day unknown ('in March of this year'); reports Ain.UA kept; arrests → all (two brothers born in 1988 and 1984 detained and charged, custody petition sent to the Podilsky court, no conviction); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('put a sack over his head, forcibly pushed him into a car, and took him outside the city'); violence_torture stays 0 (hooded, pushed into a car and threatened with death, no blow or injury reported; same reading as 7, 207 and 19, so the writer's proposed 1 is not taken; owner may set 1); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons → 0 (no weapon appears anywhere in the article, as 76 and 34); theft stays 1 ('After taking $50,000 from the victim'); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown (they waited near his home; how they knew of his money is not stated); case kept on the victim's occupation, as 123; source notes: the OFF-CASE? flag on the ain.ua page is a matcher artefact, the Russian page is the right article; the page's teaser tail (Porsche, martial law, Musk, retirement, time management) not used.
- **DB id 273** (DA) — theft → 1 ('In the end, the thieves took Kez's laptop, phone and his dog, Rambo', Vice; the dog came back a year later through its microchip, so the recovered-items rule of 188 and 495 does not apply); money_wanted → laptop, phone and the dog Rambo per Vice, with the record's list (dog worth an estimated £1,000, Apple MacBook, gold bracelets, gold wedding ring) kept and marked pending source trace (owner rule of 2026-10-01: The Sun is cited in the record and is not on file; in Vice the £1,000 is the reward he offered for the dog); notes → two machete-wielding men demanded 'money, drugs and watches' and ordered him to empty a safe and flip his mattress, one walked him around the house prodding him with a knife, punched him three times and stabbed him, leaving a machete wound in his arm, and no cryptocurrency was asked for; description kept, with 'crypto trader' as his occupation before the robbery ('Before the robbery, Kez had been a cryptocurrency trader'); victim → Kieran 'Kez' Hamilton, 21; location Manchester, England kept; date November 2018 kept, unsupported on file (the article gives no date for the attack; mark approximate); reports → Vice on file, The Sun cited with no link or text on file (trace it); arrests → some ('One of the attackers - since jailed', offence not named, second man not mentioned); sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (owner, 2026-09-07 withdrawn list); violence_torture stays 1; drugs_alcohol stays 0 (the attackers demanded drugs, none was used on him); weapons stays 1 (machetes, knife); life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = public profile / social media, as the victim believes ('I got stabbed because of my Instagram presence'), together with local rumours that he was a cash-rich drug dealer; case kept on the victim's occupation, as 123 and 52; source notes: the site summary's 'no arrest is recorded' and its loot list need redoing from this line; Vice's passages on Hitham, PewDiePie, John Terry, Kim Kardashian and the Houston art case are other incidents, not used.
- **DB id 279** (DA) — drugs_alcohol → 0 (the only substance is a threat prop, 'a syringe tinged with what they said was HIV contaminated blood (actually red ink)', and nobody was drugged; red ink passed off as blood is no drug, so the leverage reading of 170 and 391 does not reach it; DA call, owner may set 1); victim → 'Le', an HCMC businessman and bitcoin investor, with his wife, children and brother-in-law (VnExpress calls him only 'a man named Le'; the record's full name Le Duc Nguyen is in no source on file and is marked pending source trace); location → intercepted at Dau Giay Town, Dong Nai province, on the road from Bao Loc, driven two hours and dropped by a road in District 2, Ho Chi Minh City; description → a group organised by businessman Ho Ngoc Tai, which included two serving HCMC police officers, intercepted his family's car, threatened them with a fake gun and a syringe of red ink said to be HIV-contaminated blood, beat him during a two-hour drive and took 168 bitcoins worth about $1.63 million ('Cops used' goes: Tai 'enlisted the help of' the two officers, the article says 'the group' used the gun and syringe, and seventeen people are charged); notes → one earlier attempt on 12 May 2020, when Mai Xuan Phot ran his motorbike into Le's car on the Thoi Dai Bridge and Le drove away, a 'private investigator' hired for VND25 million and 'Mai Xuan Phot, a detective hired by Tai' appear without the article saying whether they are one person, 'at gunpoint' becomes a fake gun, and phones and cameras were taken to destroy evidence; money_wanted → 1,000 BTC demanded through a call to his brother, 168 BTC worth around VND37 billion, $1.63 million per VnExpress, plus other property worth around VND45 million taken; coin_type BTC kept; date 17 May 2020 kept ('Five days later', counted from 12 May); reports VnExpress International kept (sheet copy and fetched page carry the same text); arrests → all ('The culprits were arrested in June', year not printed, the two officers, Tai and 14 others face robbery charges, no trial date set, so the status needs a refresh before publication); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (owner, 2026-10-01; gap: the article does not say the officers used their office during the seizure); kidnappings stays 1; violence_torture stays 1 ('the group beat Le'); weapons stays 1 (fake gun and syringe shown as threats, noted as fake, as 136, 432 and 361); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = business counterparty (Tai's group traded with Le and blamed his advice for their 2018 losses) and surveillance (a hired detective mapped the family's routines); source notes: one source.
- **DB id 288** (DA) — violence_torture → unconfirmed ('He pleaded guilty to felony assault', a first-degree assault plea for the drugging itself, 'an intent to inflict serious bodily injury by the drugging'; no blow in the account, and the drugging is already carried by the drugs flag, as ruled in 88; the earlier assaults the prosecutor cited are other occasions); date → May 2021, day unknown (the record's 1 May is in no source; the only date printed is 14 May, when the mother called police, some days after he was found; the year is not printed, the article is dated 3 February 2022 by its URL); notes → the father had made his son a partner in the investing account, and the Washington Post speaks of 'their bitcoin holdings' and 'their investment accounts', on which the father had put the two-step lock, so 'the dad's BTC' becomes bitcoin from the account they shared, two-thirds converted to Ethereum, and whether the father got the $400,000 back is not stated; description → son drugs his father's tea with a benzodiazepine and moves $400,000 in bitcoin out of the account they shared; money_wanted $400,000 kept ('he moved $400,000 of bitcoin to an account he could control'); coin_type BTC kept; victim → the father, surname Ghershony, first name withheld at his request (Washington Post); location → Bethesda, Maryland, his loft apartment in the Bethesda Row district; reports → Washington Post is the only original source, CoinMarketCap and Futurism are rewrites with no URL in the sheet, and CoinMarketCap misstates the first charge, which was attempted first-degree murder; arrests → convicted (Liam Ghershony pleaded guilty to first-degree assault: 125 days in jail, two months of residential treatment, 20 years of suspended time); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept; kidnappings stays 0 (unconscious two days, not held: 'left his dad passed out and alone in the apartment', as 151, 124 and 88); drugs_alcohol stays 1 ('the powder was a benzodiazepine'); weapons stays 0; theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0 (four days in hospital with severe dehydration and acute organ dysfunction); targeting vector = family / partner (his son, a partner on the account); source notes: the sheet copy ends with a job 'waiting tables at a restaurant in Rockville' and the archived copy of 24 July 2025 with 'a job at a take-out deli', so the page was edited between the two.
- **DB id 290** (DA) — weapons → 1 ('robbery under knife-point' in the court's charge and in the women's complaint, and 'threatening them with blunt objects' in one victim's statement; both versions of the kind of weapon kept; the record's own note already says knifepoint); description → four men robbed three women of the cash they had brought to a fake Bitcoin deal in Al Nahda, Dubai (drop '$100,000', which is in no source on file; Gulf Today gives no dollar figure; 'Africans' is Gulf Today's own description of the gang); money_wanted → a bag with Dhs300,000 brought for the deal plus a second bag with Dhs63,000, other valuable items and the women's passports (article body); the joint fine of Dhs342,000, called 'a fine equal to the stolen money', and the headline's Dhs350,000 do not match the body and are logged as unresolved, as in 76 and 108; coin_type → cash (AED), no crypto taken; notes → the conviction and the complaint say knifepoint and one victim describes blunt objects, the women counted four men and their driver 'saw two Africans threatening the three women', and the driver wrote down the getaway car's plate; location → Al Nahda, Dubai, UAE; victim → three women, not named, one the buyer and two friends she brought; date August 2021 kept, day unknown ('Earlier in last August', in a report dated 14 February 2022 by its URL); reports Gulf Today kept; arrests → convicted (four sentenced to one year in jail, a joint fine of Dhs342,000 and deportation, one of them a fugitive; three arrests are reported); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space kept; kidnappings stays 0 (threatened in their own car and the bags snatched, no holding described, clarification 3; DA call, owner may set 1); violence_torture stays 0 (threats only, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0; theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = trade lure (a man offered her cryptocurrency for Dhs300,000; how contact was made is not stated); source notes: one source; the site summary's Attack Method line has the typo 'An man'.
- **DB id 292** (DA) — description → two men attacked a cryptocurrency miner as he was leaving his home in Tomsk, one threatened him with an object resembling a gun and brought him back inside his apartment, the accomplice came in, and they forced him to transfer 86 BTC out of a wallet holding 90 ('Armed' keeps the article's hedge: 'an object resembling a gun' in the account, 'at gunpoint, authorities said' in the lead); notes → one man took him back in and the second came in afterwards, the home is an apartment, the suspect caught in St Petersburg pleaded guilty and returned 35 million roubles, close to $479,000 per Bitcoin.com, and how long he was held and how it ended are not stated; money_wanted → 86 BTC transferred, worth more than 360 million roubles at the time, over $4.8 million per Bitcoin.com; coin_type BTC kept; location Tomsk, Russia kept; victim → cryptocurrency miner, Tomsk resident, not named; date October 2021 kept, day unknown ('The crime took place in October 2021'); reports → Bitcoin.com, relaying Bits.media; arrests → all (both men in custody and charged with robbery by a group on an especially large scale, one pleaded guilty, trial at the Kirovsky Court of Tomsk still to come); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (brought back inside at the threat of a gun-like object and made to log in and transfer); violence_torture stays 0 (threat and coercion only, no blow or injury reported); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('an object resembling a gun', hedge kept as in 29); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = unknown (how the men knew of his holdings is not stated); source notes: one source with no publication date; its closing paragraph on a mining farm near Moscow and a tether robbery in Moscow covers other incidents, not used.
- **DB id 293** (DA) — money_wanted → three servers and 150,000 roubles ($2,040) in cash (Reuters: 'three servers and 150,000 roubles ($2,040) in cash'; '3 bitcoin miners' is the record's reading of 'servers'); coin_type → cash (RUB) and mining hardware, no coin taken ('BTC' goes); victim → a family in Sukhumi, not identified (the article places the raid in a list of robberies of miners and does not say the family mined); description kept (it matches the Reuters sentence); notes kept (the Reuters sentence, attributed to police); location Sukhumi, Abkhazia kept; date December 2021 kept, day unknown ('last month', counted from the 6 January 2022 dateline, is the month of the police statement); reports Reuters kept; arrests → some ('police said they made one arrest', two masked men); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('held a family at gunpoint'); violence_torture stays 0 (no blow or injury in the one sentence on this case); drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 1 ('at gunpoint'); theft stays 1; life_taken stays 0 (the article's 'One man was killed' bullet belongs to the October country-house shooting and stays out of this record); targeting vector = unknown; source notes: the case rests on one sentence of a Reuters feature; the garage break-in, the October shooting, the warehouse attempt and the Chernomorenergo shots are other incidents, not used; held duration not stated.
## Needs owner decision
**DB id 285** (owner) — Sliema, Malta, 16 June (year not printed): at a restaurant lunch Dillon Attard handed his phone to Luke Milton to scan a wallet barcode and, he testified, 424,670.97 Unizen tokens ($700,000) left his wallet within seconds. No force, threat, drugging or holding; Milton pleads not guilty and blames Attard.
- Settled (DA): description → the victim told the court that $700,000 in Unizen tokens was allegedly siphoned from his wallet in front of him ('allegedly siphoned', 'The case continues'); notes → contact began when Attard came across a blockchain project while looking into a crypto loan, then phone calls and a meeting at a Burmarrad office with Milton and his business partner, and at the lunch Milton sought help with a €5,000 investment; money_wanted → 424,670.97 Unizen tokens, $700,000 per the headline; coin_type → Unizen; date 16 June 2021 kept, year unverified on file; arrests → not stated (Milton is charged and the article never says arrested); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept; kidnappings stays 0; violence_torture stays 0; drugs_alcohol stays 0; weapons stays 0; theft stays 1, as alleged; life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = business counterparty.
- Question: does this case belong in a database of physical attacks? For keeping: the owner kept 122 ('no physical element, kept as the pure extortion-by-authority case') and the drugging cases 151, 88 and 92, and the meeting was set up face to face to get hold of the phone. For removing: 122 had coercion and the drugging cases had an assault on the body; here Times of Malta reports a 'swindle' with 'He didn't resist' and Milton acting 'as though everything was normal', and the charges are misappropriation and fraud.
- DA recommendation: take it out of the attack counts. It fits neither half of the glossary's wrench attack ('Physical violence or coercion'). If the owner wants the file kept, tag it 'in-person fraud, no coercion, alleged' so it stays out of the headline figures.