Archived
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
27 lines
24 KiB
Markdown
27 lines
24 KiB
Markdown
# Batch 41 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-07
|
|
|
|
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-41.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-41.json` and `sources/<id>_*.txt`. Criteria in `batches/DECISION-RULES.md`. These cases already have a verified scenario sequence; no sequence is changed here.
|
|
|
|
## Approved (DA)
|
|
|
|
- **DB id 312** (DA) — date → late May or early June 2023, day unknown (Finance Magnates of Thursday 15 June 2023: 'robbed of his digital assets at gunpoint in his Tel Aviv home two weeks ago, according to the Israeli financial site, Globes on Wednesday'; no text prints the day, so the record's 'June 2023' may be a month late); description → an Israeli crypto entrepreneur told police that robbers broke into his Tel Aviv apartment, beat him and forced him at gunpoint to transfer all his crypto holdings to their wallets (hedges kept: 'Was Allegedly Robbed', 'was reportedly robbed', 'told police'; the account is his report to police relayed from Globes); notes → the wallet provider froze the transfers and conversions as suspicious, so 'neither the robbers nor the entrepreneur has access to the cryptocurrencies'; he left Israel and 'remains nearly penniless'; 'Today, a severed animal head was placed near the entrepreneur's door, along with a hateful graffiti message. The Israel Police announced that an investigation has been opened regarding this incident' (ARTICLE 1; the text does not say who placed it, so 'They later left an animal head' is replaced); money_wanted undisclosed kept (no amount in either text); coin_type crypto kept (coin not named); victim kept (identity not revealed); location kept (his apartment in Tel Aviv); sequence Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1 (broke in, beat him, held at gunpoint until the transfer; clarification 1), violence_torture stays 1 ('beat him mercilessly'), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 ('at gunpoint', both texts), theft stays 1 (the transfer was made; the flag notes that the funds were frozen afterwards, as 209), life_taken stays 0; arrests → not stated (the number of robbers, how the robbery ended and how long he was held are not stated either); targeting vector unknown; source notes: ARTICLE 2 and the fetched block are the same Finance Magnates page; ARTICLE 1 is filed under that URL but is a different text ('Gun threat: Crypto entrepreneur robbed at his home in Tel Aviv') whose origin is not recorded, and it is the only text with the animal head and the graffiti, so find and link its source; the second half of the Finance Magnates page (Wallingford, Iowa, Oxfordshire 2018, the Russian blogger, Pavel Lerner, the New Jersey man) is other cases, not used.
|
|
- **DB id 317** (DA) — date → 13 October 2024, about 5 a.m. ('The 59-year-old victim was abducted outside his home at 5am on October 13', Malay Mail of 30 October 2024); location → Iskandar Puteri, Johor ('the businessman's kidnapping in Iskandar Puteri on October 13'; Johor Baru is the dateline and the place of the police press conference and the remand hearings); victim → 59-year-old Johor businessman, not named; description → abducted outside his home while preparing to take a ride-hailing car to Senai International Airport for a business trip; released after a ransom of RM20 million was 'allegedly paid'; money_wanted → RM30 million demanded at first, 'reportedly lowered after negotiations'; RM20 million 'allegedly paid'; RM7.2 million recovered by police; coin_type → not stated for the payment; the recovered part was RM1.95 million in cash, S$1 million (RM3.3 million) in foreign currency and 400,000 USDT (about RM1.75 million); notes → 'cash and 400k USDT taken' becomes: the cash and the 400,000 Tether are what police recovered, the form of the RM20 million payment is not stated; the three recovered parts add to RM7.0 million against the RM7.2 million stated (logged); suspects organised in three groups (planning and abduction, disposal of items, ransom handling); police declined to comment on 'the alleged family ties between one of the suspects and the victim'; where he was held and the day of release are not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept; weapons → 1 ('police seized a Beretta pistol, 250 live bullets and a pair of handcuffs from the suspects'; the article does not say the pistol was used in the abduction; weapon confirmed through the arrests, as 213 and 385); violence_torture → unconfirmed (no blow, injury or treatment in captivity described; as 435 and 407); drugs_alcohol → 0 (none reported); kidnappings stays 1, theft stays 1 (payment reported with 'allegedly'), life_taken stays 0; arrests → some: all on remand, none charged at publication, one suspect at large; the article's counts differ (11 local suspects including a woman plus two men and a woman from Vietnam; remand extended for 10 local suspects including two women, plus a local man arrested in Senai; '10 men and three women' per the Johor police chief a week earlier), all logged; investigated under Section 3(1) of the Kidnapping Act 1961; targeting vector unknown (possible family tie to a suspect, not confirmed by police); crypto link: 400,000 USDT inside the recovered ransom, no crypto holding of the victim reported, tag 'crypto as extraction rail' as ruled for 376; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and the fetched block are the same Malay Mail page, the Versa advertisement and the Google prompt not used.
|
|
- **DB id 321** (DA) — victim → retired teacher, mother of a man who works in cryptocurrency management and lives in Portugal ('Uma professora aposentada foi sequestrada'; 'a mulher sequestrada é mãe de um homem que trabalha com gestão de criptomoedas'; owner ruling on 321 already says change the victim to the mother); weapons → 1 ('mantida em cativeiro por mais de 12 horas, sob a mira de arma de fogo', g1 Pernambuco); location → seized leaving the Fórum Desembargador Benildes de Souza Ribeiro, Imbiribeira, Recife; held in Olinda; released near the Ouro Preto neighbourhood, Olinda; money_wanted → 5 BTC paid by the son (R$3.3 million at the rate of the time; the g1 headline rounds to R$3 million; the sheet translation's '$' is R$); coin_type → BTC; reports → g1 Pernambuco (the record says 'Pernambuco'); date 21 March 2025 kept ('O sequestro aconteceu no dia 21 de março de 2025'); notes → at least two men in the car, a vehicle with a cloned plate; the two women arrested 'teriam recebido parte do pagamento do resgate em criptoativos'; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; violence_torture stays 0 (gun threat only, no blow or injury reported; threat-only cases stand at 0 in 420, 403 and 442; DA call, owner may set 1 under the glossary's 'threats and physical intimidation'), kidnappings stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 0, theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; arrests → four people arrested on temporary warrants, announced 13 August 2025 (two in Abreu e Lima and Olinda, two in Extremoz, RN; two of them women), charged with extortion through kidnapping and money laundering; police call them 'os quatro responsáveis' and say investigations continue; targeting vector = social media and surveillance ('passaram a monitorar diariamente as redes sociais desse negociador de criptoativos'; her addresses and routine identified); source notes: ARTICLE 1 is a machine translation of the g1 page in the fetched block, the Portuguese original used where they differ ('Reef' for Recife); the page's video list, newsletter block and unrelated teasers not used.
|
|
- **DB id 322** (DA) — theft → unconfirmed ('Les malfaiteurs auraient réclamé entre 5 à 7 millions d'euros sous forme de virement en échange de sa libération'; a demand only, no payment or loss stated, and he 'a finalement été libéré lors d'une opération' of the police; DA call, the writer proposed 0 and the owner may set 0 as in 396 and 401); weapons → unconfirmed ('armed' rests only on the charge 'extorsion en bande organisée avec arme'; no weapon described and what severed the finger is not stated; as 487 and 411; DA call, owner may keep 1); money_wanted → 5 to 7 million euros demanded, in the conditional, as a transfer; nothing reported paid (the record's '$5M' and the description's '5M EUR' are both off the source); coin_type → not stated ('sous forme de virement'; no coin named, drop BTC); victim → man in his fifties, father of a French cryptocurrency entrepreneur who heads a company based in Malta and France (drop 'millionaire', not in the article); description → abducted about 10:30 a.m. on Thursday 1 May 2025 in the 14th arrondissement of Paris, held for ransom, found with a severed finger and freed on the night of Saturday 3 May in Palaiseau (Essonne) in an operation coordinated by the BRI of the Paris judicial police with the BRB and the brigade criminelle; location → Paris, 14th arrondissement (seized); freed in Palaiseau, Essonne; date 1 May 2025 kept (Le Parisien of Saturday 3 May: 'jeudi vers 10h30'); notes → the dwelling where he was held 'était calfeutré, probablement en vue de réaliser des vidéos de mise en scène de l'otage'; summary artefacts to fix: 'BIS' is the BRI, and 'apartment ... being sealed off' renders 'le logement ... était calfeutré' (dwelling, not apartment); sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 ('retrouvé avec un doigt sectionné'), drugs_alcohol stays 0, life_taken stays 0; arrests → some (four suspects arrested and placed in custody; whether that is the whole group is not stated; investigation opened for organised-gang abduction, hostage-taking and extortion); targeting vector = family of a holder (the son's crypto business; how the father was chosen is not stated, as 392 and 396); reports → Le Parisien (3 May 2025, confirming Actu17); source notes: ARTICLE 1 is a machine translation of the Le Parisien page in the fetched block (Wayback snapshot of 18 May 2025), one source; the closing paragraph on David Balland is another case (209), not used.
|
|
- **DB id 334** (DA) — theft → 1 ('No total, eles conseguiram somente R$ 6.813,28 via Pix', Livecoins; only the crypto theft failed, as 455 and 153); money_wanted → 2 to 4 million reais in cryptocurrency targeted, none obtained ('a vítima não possuía acesso à sua carteira de criptomoedas no local'); R$6,813.28 obtained via Pix; coin_type → cryptocurrency, coin not named (targeted); the sum taken was reais via Pix; description → lured to Goiânia for a business meeting by Josemar Alencar Linhares de Oliveira, held at gunpoint in a car by two armed men while the driver posed as a fellow victim, beaten and made to try transfers for about an hour and a half; the crypto theft failed and R$6,813.28 was taken via Pix; thrown from the car at about 30 km/h during a police chase on the GO-020 (three ribs fractured, internal bleeding); two attackers died in the confrontation with police; the alleged mastermind was arrested on arrival in the USA ('foi preso assim que chegou nos EUA'; drop 'Miami', no city in the source; 'Attack failed' holds for the crypto only); date → June 2025, day unknown, between 24 and 30 June ('chegou em Goiânia no dia 24 de junho' is the arrival; the attack came 'Logo após saírem do hotel' with no day given; Josemar flew out 'no dia 30 de junho, uma segunda-feira, logo após o ocorrido'); victim → businessman from São Paulo, not named; location Goiânia kept (GO-020 towards Bela Vista); notes → the testimony also holds a debt reading: 'a vítima supostamente devia R$ 500 mil por uma comissão de assessoramento de uma transação de criptomoeda com um terceiro. Portanto, poderia se tratar de uma cobrança de dívida por Josemar'; Josemar 'se apresentou como assessor do então presidente da Assembleia Legislativa de Goiás', and the article does not say the claim was false, so the summary's 'posed as' becomes 'introduced himself as' (only Gabriel is 'outro suposto assessor'); Livecoins calls the crime a 'sequestro relâmpago'; sequence Authority Misuse → Malicious Invitation - SocialEng → Kidnapping kept (owner rulings of 2026-09-30 and 2026-10-01; the glossary's Authority Misuse covers 'real or fabricated positions', so the unproven falsity of the advisor claim does not contradict the label; flagged for the owner's information); kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 ('dando socos em sua cabeça'; thrown from the moving car), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (two firearms, per the sentence), life_taken stays 2 (two attackers, Gabriel Pires de Lima and Tiago Oliveira Rocha, killed in the confrontation with police; the victim survived); arrests → convicted: Josemar sentenced on Wednesday 24 September 2025 to 12 years and 9 months for extortion as intellectual author (he denies involvement); two attackers dead; the third man in the car never identified; targeting vector = business counterparty (approached in February; an alleged commission debt); outcome: put out of the moving car by the attackers and picked up by a truck driver; source notes: ARTICLE 1 is an English translation of the Livecoins page in the fetched block, one source written from the court file; the WhatsApp, OKX and social-link lines not used.
|
|
- **DB id 340** (DA) — date → 18 October 2025, about 10:30 p.m. (The Jakarta Post of Friday 24 October 2025: 'the incident occurred on Saturday at around 10:30 p.m.', as the Bali Police spokesperson said 'on Tuesday'; the Saturday before that Tuesday is 18 October; the record's 23 October is a Thursday and has no source; inferred, noted); description → Russian influencer says he was forced into an Alphard by two men in black ski masks near Sanur Beach, taken to a house in Jimbaran, allegedly beaten and tased, and made to hand over his phone and transfer about US$4,600 in cryptocurrency; three more men arrived and demanded US$1 million, which he said he could not pay; released several hours later (hedges kept: 'has claimed', 'According to Sergei's statement to police', 'allegedly', 'Sergei further claimed'); money_wanted → about US$4,600 in cryptocurrency transferred, plus his mobile phone; US$1 million ransom demanded afterwards, not paid; coin_type Crypto kept (coin not named); location → seized near Sanur Beach, Bali; held at a house in Jimbaran, South Kuta; released in a field near the Apurva Kempinski Hotel, South Kuta; victim Sergei Domogatskii kept (named by Bali Police); notes → he says the attacker was another Russian; injuries to his right arm; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1 ('allegedly beaten and tased'; arm injuries), drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 1 (taser, on his statement; as 160 and 181), theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; arrests → not stated (the text on file ends after five paragraphs of a Premium article); targeting vector = public profile (popular influencer; how he was chosen is not stated); source notes: ARTICLE 1 and the fetched block are the same Jakarta Post page, quoting Bali Police through Kompas.com; arrests, suspects and police findings may sit behind the paywall, so a second source is worth fetching.
|
|
- **DB id 349** (DA) — date → autumn 2021, month not stated (Reuters of 6 January 2022: 'one autumn morning'; the record's September is an assumption and the year is inferred from the article date; keep September only as an approximate placeholder); notes → quarter field reads 2021-Q2 beside month 9 and does not match the record's own date (2021-Q3 for September); Reuters gives him the pseudonym Valeri ('preferred not to use his real name'); he could not go to the police because the mining was illegal and 'tried to track down the thieves himself but to no avail'; victim 'Unidentified 31 y/o' kept (the pseudonym stays out of the victim field, as 395); description kept ('Thieves had broken in overnight, taking with them 20 mining servers worth about $10,000'; the garage door was 'bust open', nobody present); money_wanted kept (20 mining servers worth about $10,000); coin_type stays empty (hardware, no crypto taken); location Abkhazia kept (town not stated); sequence Burglary kept (owner ruling of 2026-10-06, group B: mining hardware, nobody present; the record's scenario field still reads Armed Robbery in Public Space); kidnappings stays 0, violence_torture stays 0, drugs_alcohol stays 0, weapons stays 0 (the guns in the article belong to other incidents), theft stays 1, life_taken stays 0; arrests → none (no police report; nobody identified); targeting vector unknown; source notes: ARTICLE 1 and the fetched block (Wayback snapshot of 1 December 2023) are the same Reuters feature on the whole wave; its other incidents are not used here and are already records: the October country-house shooting is DB 102 and the Sukhumi family held at gunpoint is DB 293; Victor's botched warehouse burglary and the shots at Chernomorenergo are context; format point for `summary-overrides.json`: the Violence Used line opens with 'None' where the procedure asks for the opening 'No detention', so `batches/validate.py` reports this case.
|
|
- **DB id 350** (DA) — description → a 35-year-old former cryptocurrency trader was kidnapped and held between Paris and Saint-Germain-en-Laye; the kidnappers sent a photo of him on his knees with his hands tied to an acquaintance in Algeria and demanded 10,000 euros from that contact, who alerted police; nothing was paid and he was found walking home at about 4 a.m. on the Wednesday (replaces 'from his wife': no wife appears in any text; 'the victim's acquaintance', Cryptonews citing Le Parisien); money_wanted → 10,000 EUR demanded, not paid ('failed to extract a €10,000 ransom'; the record's '$10,000' is euros); coin_type → not stated (no text says the ransom was asked in cryptocurrency; the crypto link is his former trade, as 123); notes → the demand was made of the contact ('demanded €10,000 from the contact'; the lead says 'from his contacts'), not of the victim; drop '10k USD'; his phone was geolocated to the 10th arrondissement; 'investigators work to verify his statements about the incident circumstances' (hedge kept); forensic traces taken from his clothing and skin; weapons → 0 (none mentioned in the three texts; hands tied and strangled; DA call, the abduction itself is not described); drugs_alcohol → 0 (none mentioned); date 26 August 2025 kept (police alerted on Tuesday night, found Wednesday about 4 a.m.; ARTICLE 2 is dated Thursday 28 August 2025, which fixes the Tuesday as 26 August; when he was seized is not stated); victim → Alexandre, 35, former crypto trader (first name only; 'Alexander' in ARTICLE 2); location → between Paris and Saint-Germain-en-Laye, place of holding not stated; sequence Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1 ('on his knees with his hands tied'), violence_torture stays 1 ('facial swelling and injuries after being strangled'), theft stays 0, life_taken stays 0; arrests → none ('no strong leads' at the time of ARTICLE 2); targeting vector unknown; source notes: both texts are rewrites of a Le Parisien story that is not on file, worth fetching; ARTICLE 2 has no URL recorded and is another outlet's write-up (bylined Manmit Kahlon, 28 August 2025), find and link it; the second half of the cryptonews.com page is other cases, not used (the poker player's father in Paris is DB 322, Balland is 209); this cryptonews URL is also stored by mistake with the AseanNow text of DB 476 (batch 20).
|
|
|
|
## Needs owner decision
|
|
|
|
**DB id 315** (owner) — Södertälje, Sweden, autumn 2023: a Bitcoin holder tied up and abused at home for his Bitcoin; 315's only source is a Cointelegraph round-up of Eric Wall's X post that never says which of its incidents is Södertälje.
|
|
- Settled (DA): no duplicate and no swap with 166. 166 is the Rönninge couple of Monday 6 November 2023 (four masked men, kitchen knives, helicopter), and LT, on file under 166, treats Södertälje as the earlier, separate robbery: 'Rånet mot paret i Rönninge begicks på samma sätt som ett rån i Södertälje för en dryg månad sedan. I båda fallen bands offren i sina bostäder och rånarna var ute efter Bitcoin'. sequence Costly Fame → Home Invasion kept; kidnappings stays 1, violence_torture stays 1, weapons stays 1 ('masked, armed men', Wall), drugs_alcohol stays 0, life_taken stays 0; money_wanted stays empty (no amount); coin_type → BTC (as ruled for 166); arrests → none reported (Cointelegraph asked the Swedish police and prints no answer); targeting vector = social media / livestream and public records (Wall's belief); the 2022 apartment break-in in the article is another incident, not used.
|
|
- Question 1, date and sourcing. Proposed: date → 3 October 2023, and reports → add Telgenytt, LT and CryptoPotato (all on file under 166). For: Telgenytt, citing LT: 'ett rån som inträffade i Södertälje för över en månad sedan, tisdagen den 3 oktober. Även där band inbrottstjuvarna offren och rånade dem i sitt hem'; 3 October 2023 was a Tuesday and fits the record's 'October ?'. Against: nothing in 315's own dossier gives a date; the only dated incident there is the couple's Monday. DA recommendation: accept. With it, theft stays 1 on 'rånade dem' (what was taken is not stated); without it, theft → unconfirmed as the writer proposed.
|
|
- Question 2, who the victim is and whether a second record is needed. CryptoPotato (under 166): 'just last month in Södertälje, two prominent figures in the bitcoin and crypto world fell victim to similar home invasions by masked, armed men. One of them suffered three hours of physical abuse, while the other narrowly escaped because their spouse was the only one at home.' That reads as two homes; Telgenytt describes one robbery in which the victims ('offren') were tied and robbed. Option (a): victim → one of two well-known Bitcoin profiles in Södertälje, abused for about three hours at home, sex not stated (the description's 'his' goes), with the second home (spouse alone, the holder absent) in notes. Option (b): a second record for the second home. DA recommendation: (a); no new record until a Swedish report describes the second visit.
|
|
|
|
**DB id 323** (owner) — Las Vegas, November 2024: three Florida teenagers are accused of forcing a man who had hosted a crypto event that night into a car at gunpoint at his apartment complex, hooding him, driving him more than 70 miles to White Hills, Arizona, and taking $4 million in cryptocurrency and NFTs.
|
|
- Settled (DA): date → November 2024, day unknown ('Last November, a man called police'; the record's 1 May 2025 belongs to the court hearings; the year is not printed and rests on the June preliminary hearing and on 365's record); weapons → 1 ('Three teenagers are accused of kidnapping a man at gunpoint'); notes → 'crypto dinner' becomes a 'cryptocurrency-related event at a business in Downtown Las Vegas'; seized after he 'returned to his apartment complex and parked his car', not on the way home; a fourth person directed the three by speakerphone; left in the desert, he walked five miles to a gas station; all at accusation stage; money_wanted → $4 million in cryptocurrency and NFTs taken, per prosecutors; coin_type → cryptocurrency and NFTs; arrests → some (Belal Ashraf and Austin Fletcher, both 16, certified as adults and charged with robbery, kidnapping and extortion; the third teenager has left the United States); sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping kept; kidnappings stays 1, theft stays 1, drugs_alcohol stays 0, life_taken stays 0; targeting vector = public profile (crypto event host; a suspect vehicle was tracked from Florida to his apartment).
|
|
- Question 1, duplicate of DB 365. For a merge: 365's link is the MSN syndication of this same 8 News Now article (same headline), with the same place, month, three teenagers and $4 million; `scenario-sequences.json` already calls 365 'Duplicate of 323'. Against: nothing on file. DA recommendation: merge into 323, dated November 2024, and delete 365 (as 386 into 295); 323 holds the full article, 365 only a thin MSN link and an AI-generated Defiant item, whose extra line ('over $200,000 of the stolen funds have been frozen', 22 felony counts) goes into notes as single-sourced.
|
|
- Question 2, violence_torture, record 1. For 1: the glossary's range starts at 'threats and physical intimidation'; 'if he did not comply, they had his dad and would kill him'; 'had a towel placed over his head'. For 0: no blow or injury is reported, and threat-only cases stand at 0 (420, 403, 442, and 321 in this batch), with 19 (gun and hood, no injury) marked 'threat only, owner may set 1'. DA recommendation: violence_torture → 0, the same call as 321; if the owner keeps 1 here, 321 becomes 1 as well.
|