Archived
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
173 lines
24 KiB
Plaintext
173 lines
24 KiB
Plaintext
====================================================================================================
|
|
LOPP L266 | A cryptocurrency buyer (A05 in the ruling) | October 15, 2025 | Taiwan
|
|
====================================================================================================
|
|
|
|
STATUS new
|
|
|
|
PROPOSED RECORD [new case from Lopp's list, PR 234; read by two readers; flags and obtained re-read 2026-10-17 under the owner's definitions (empty = unknown); no operator has reviewed it; no stats2 id yet]
|
|
date October 15, 2025
|
|
victim A cryptocurrency buyer (A05 in the ruling)
|
|
location Taichung
|
|
country Taiwan
|
|
description A cryptocurrency buyer lured online to a Taichung car park with TWD 2.44 million in cash was pepper-sprayed with a companion in the car and stabbed in the legs for refusing to let go of the money, then pushed the attacker out, and the robbers fled empty-handed. Five members of the group were sentenced in May 2026.
|
|
detention no
|
|
violence_torture yes
|
|
drugs_alcohol (unknown)
|
|
weapons yes
|
|
theft no
|
|
life_taken 0
|
|
venue_of_control none
|
|
held_duration none
|
|
arrests convicted
|
|
demanded no demand; robbery of the TWD 2,440,000 brought to buy cryptocurrency
|
|
taken nothing taken
|
|
notes Source: the Taichung District Court ruling 115年度訴字第126號 of May 14, 2026 (original court record). 114年10月15日 is October 15, 2025. Location: the district and street of the car park are redacted (臺中市○○區); the case was investigated by the Taichung police Taiping precinct (太平分局), which does not by itself place the car park in Taiping. Detention no: the attackers never gained control; the victims resisted at once and the attackers fled. Outcome Fought off: A05 held on to the bag and pushed A09 out of the car, and the court says the victims blocked the attackers to protect the money; the attackers then left in their car. Weapons yes: pepper spray, a knife and a stun baton. The ruling does not state the buyer's sex; the public texts avoid pronouns. Who was attacked: A06 was in the car and was sprayed; the ruling calls A06 a victim (被害人) and gives no relationship, so A06 is entered as a passenger under Bystanders or neighbours. Targeting Online contact or advert: the organiser found the buyer online. Arrests convicted: five sentenced; 徐湘博 tried separately (also a defendant in L265); the organiser '塔拉雷奧特拉拉' unidentified. Not a duplicate of L265 (October 14, 2025, a different victim at the Dali temple). No stats2 candidate in the period.
|
|
|
|
CHANGES OF 2026-10-17
|
|
drugs_alcohol: no -> (empty)
|
|
re-read note: Detention no: the attack in the victim's car was a spray, grab and stab that the victim ended by pushing the attacker out; no holding described.
|
|
|
|
FOUR-STEP LABELS
|
|
targeting Online contact or advert
|
|
targeting_accuracy Correct
|
|
who_was_attacked Holder; Bystanders or neighbours
|
|
approach P2P trade
|
|
attack Armed robbery
|
|
outcome Fought off
|
|
obtained Nothing
|
|
|
|
PEOPLE ATTACKED
|
|
Holder: 1 (the buyer carrying the cash, stabbed in the legs); Bystanders or neighbours: 1 (a second person in his car, pepper-sprayed)
|
|
|
|
PUBLIC SUMMARY [plain English, the text the site shows]
|
|
On October 15, 2025, at about 9 pm, a cryptocurrency buyer who had been found online by a Telegram
|
|
user posing as a seller brought TWD 2.44 million in cash to a car park in Taichung, Taiwan, for a
|
|
USDT trade. A crew directed through Telegram arrived by car. One of them got into the back of the
|
|
buyer's car and counted the cash as if trading; once the amount was confirmed, two others opened the
|
|
doors and pepper-sprayed the buyer and a second person in the car in the face. The attacker in the
|
|
back pulled at the bag of cash and, when the buyer held on, stabbed the buyer in both thighs and a
|
|
calf. The buyer threw the bag toward the driver's seat and pushed the attacker out of the car, and
|
|
the three fled in their getaway car without the money. On May 14, 2026, the Taichung District Court
|
|
sentenced five members of the group to 3 years 10 months to 5 years; a sixth man was tried
|
|
separately.
|
|
|
|
CASE DETAILS [internal evidence record, quotations in the original language]
|
|
**Victims:** A05, the complainant, a buyer of cryptocurrency who brought TWD 2,440,000 in cash, and
|
|
A06, a second victim in the same car ("持辣椒水朝車內A05及A06臉部噴灑"); the ruling does not say how A06 is
|
|
related to A05. A05's injuries: contact skin irritation from the spray (hospital certificate cited
|
|
by the court), and, in the prosecution's injury charge, 6 cm lacerations to the left and right
|
|
thighs and a 5 cm laceration to the right calf.
|
|
**Attackers:** A criminal group set up before September 23, 2025 by A07 (Telegram '十大通緝要犯劉俊榮') to
|
|
rob under cover of fake crypto trades, with members A08 ('王大陸') and A09 ('膽大吃四方'); A02 ('本山') and
|
|
A03 ('雅典那') joined before the robbery. Also 徐湘博 ('楊雙伍', tried separately) and the unidentified
|
|
Telegram user '塔拉雷奧特拉拉', who found the buyer online. The defendants listed are 王俊喻, 吳宸瑋, 許煒生, 楊淯翔
|
|
and 曾柏豪; the ruling does not match names to the A-codes. A09, A02, 徐湘博 and the driver A03 were at
|
|
the scene.
|
|
**Attack Method:** "先由「塔拉雷奧特拉拉」於網路上找尋欲購買虛擬貨幣之買家A05,誘騙A05攜帶新臺幣(下同)244萬元現金", meeting at 21:00 at a car
|
|
park in Taichung (address redacted). A03 drove the crew there; A09 got into the rear seat of the car
|
|
A05 was in and counted the cash "佯裝與A05進行交易"; A02 and 徐湘博 then opened the doors and sprayed pepper
|
|
spray into the faces of A05 and A06.
|
|
**Violence Used:** No detention: nobody was held; the attackers sprayed the victims and tried to
|
|
pull the bag away, A05 held on, and the attackers fled.
|
|
"A09見狀強行拉扯A05手中裝有現金之紙袋,因A05死守不放,A09竟持預藏之刀具刺擊A05腿部". A09 also carried a stun baton. A05's police
|
|
statement: "我把被告A09推下車後才發現我的左大腿、右大腿被刺傷". The court finds the victims drove the attackers off by
|
|
blocking them to protect the money ("奮不顧身攔阻").
|
|
**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** TWD 2,440,000 in cash targeted; the attackers fled "而未取得244萬元現金". The
|
|
court notes no actual property loss ("尚未生實際財產損害"). A07 had A08 pay TWD 2,000 to each participating
|
|
member.
|
|
**Status:** On May 14, 2026 (民國115年5月14日) the Taichung District Court (115年度訴字第126號) convicted the
|
|
five of attempted robbery by three or more persons carrying a weapon: A07 5 years, A08 4 years 8
|
|
months, A09 4 years, A02 4 years 4 months, A03 3 years 10 months. All five settled with the
|
|
complainant, who withdrew the separate injury complaint on March 11, 2026. 徐湘博 is tried separately;
|
|
'塔拉雷奧特拉拉' is unidentified.
|
|
|
|
OPEN QUESTIONS FOR THE OWNER
|
|
(none)
|
|
|
|
SECOND READER
|
|
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: removed the L265 cross-reference sentence (it stays
|
|
in the reader's notes)
|
|
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: 'his car' and 'related to him' replaced, since the
|
|
ruling says only the car A05 was riding in (搭乘) and does not state A05's sex
|
|
rewritten after the second reader: case_details: 'resisted at once' replaced with the sequence the
|
|
ruling gives; the lacerations attributed to the prosecution's injury charge (para 60)
|
|
|
|
LOPP'S ENTRY
|
|
October 15 2025 | Unidentified man | Taichung, Taiwan
|
|
A Telegram-directed cell lured a buyer with a fake cryptocurrency sale to a Taichung car park with
|
|
TWD 2,440,000 in cash; an accomplice counted the money, two others pepper-sprayed the victim and his
|
|
companion, and when the victim refused to let go of the bag he was stabbed in the leg before the
|
|
attackers fled without the money. The same cell had attempted a similar robbery in Dali the day
|
|
before.
|
|
differs: Lopp: 'stabbed in the leg'; the ruling gives lacerations to both thighs and the right calf.
|
|
differs: Lopp: victim 'Unidentified man'; the ruling calls him A05 and does not state his sex.
|
|
|
|
LINKED SOURCES
|
|
1. https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TCDM%2C115%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C126%2C20260514%2C2
|
|
|
|
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
FETCHED ARTICLE 1
|
|
Source judgment.judicial.gov.tw
|
|
URL https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TCDM%2C115%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C126%2C20260514%2C2
|
|
Published (not given)
|
|
Retrieved 2026-10-16T14:30:07Z via raw HTTP retrieval (status 200); page furniture cut by paragraph range (kept 2, 6, 8, 11, 13, 15, 19-29, 36, 38, 43-44, 48, 54-55, 58, 60, 62, 65 of 110), article text unchanged
|
|
Language as published (kept in the original language, not translated)
|
|
Length 5,491 chars
|
|
Integrity sha256 3e9f2fb33980a4dc17335b85c50681196e7de73892df74a1f734160569e425b8
|
|
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
臺灣臺中地方法院 115 年度訴字第 126 號刑事判決
|
|
|
|
被 告 王俊喻
|
|
|
|
被 告 吳宸瑋
|
|
|
|
被 告 許煒生
|
|
|
|
被 告 楊淯翔
|
|
|
|
被 告 曾柏豪
|
|
|
|
上列被告因強盜等案件,經檢察官提起公訴(114年度偵字第53201、63836、63864號),本院判決如下:
|
|
|
|
主 文
|
|
|
|
A07犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪,處有期徒刑伍年。
|
|
|
|
A08犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪,處有期徒刑肆年捌月。
|
|
|
|
A09犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪,處有期徒刑肆年。扣案之IPHONE手機(IMEI碼000000000000000號)壹支沒收;未扣案之犯罪所得新臺幣貳仟元沒收,於全部或一部不能沒收或不宜執行沒收時,追徵其價額。
|
|
|
|
A02犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪,處有期徒刑肆年肆月。
|
|
|
|
A03犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜未遂罪,處有期徒刑參年拾月。扣案之IPHONE 11綠色手機(IMEI碼000000000000000號)壹支沒收;未扣案之犯罪所得新臺幣貳仟元沒收,於全部或一部不能沒收或不宜執行沒收時,追徵其價額。
|
|
|
|
犯罪事實
|
|
|
|
一、A07(通訊軟體TELEGRAM暱稱「十大通緝要犯劉俊榮」)於民國114年9月23日前某日,發起以假交易虛擬貨幣為名、實施強盜之犯罪組織(下稱本案犯罪組織),A08(TELEGRAM暱稱「王大陸」)、A09(TELEGRAM暱稱「膽大吃四方」)亦為本案犯罪組織成員(A07、A08及A09所涉違反組織犯罪防制條例部分,非本件起訴範圍)。而A02(TELEGRAM暱稱「本山」)、A03(TELEGRAM暱稱「雅典那」)分別由A08、A07介紹,基於參與犯罪組織之犯意,於民國114年10月15日21時前某時,加入本案犯罪組織。
|
|
|
|
二、嗣A07、A08、A09、A02、A03、徐湘博(TELEGRAM暱稱「楊雙伍」,本院另行審理)及TELEGRAM暱稱「塔拉雷奧特拉拉」之人,共同意圖為自己不法之所有,基於結夥三人以上、攜帶兇器強盜之犯意聯絡,先由「塔拉雷奧特拉拉」於網路上找尋欲購買虛擬貨幣之買家A05,誘騙A05攜帶新臺幣(下同)244萬元現金,約定於114年10月15日21時許,至臺中市○○區○○○路000號前停車場進行交易,復由A07指示A08將上開地址傳送於本案犯罪組織建立之TELEGRAM群組內,另指示A03駕駛車牌號碼000-0000號自小客車,搭載A09、A02及徐湘博,前往上址,並於上開群組中指示A09購買客觀上足以對人之生命、身體、安全構成威脅之兇器辣椒水供A02及徐湘博使用。A03、A09、A02及徐湘博到達上址後,由A09另攜帶同屬於兇器之電擊棒、刀具等物(A07、A08、A02及A03對於A09攜帶刀具;A07、A08對於A09攜帶電擊棒均未能預見),進入A05搭乘之車牌號碼000-0000號自小客車副駕駛座後座,佯裝與A05進行交易而清點現金;A09確認款項後,A02及徐湘博隨即開啟該車車門,持辣椒水朝車內A05及A06臉部噴灑,以此強暴方式,至使A05、A06雙眼劇痛難以睜開而不能抗拒。A09見狀強行拉扯A05手中裝有現金之紙袋,因A05死守不放,A09竟持預藏之刀具刺擊A05腿部(傷害告訴業經撤回,詳後述),A05受傷後將現金紙袋丟往駕駛座方向。A09、A02及徐湘博見強取未果,且因現場騷動恐事跡敗露,遂由A03駕駛上開車輛接應3人逃離現場而未得逞。
|
|
|
|
三、案經A05訴由臺中市政府警察局太平分局報告臺灣臺中地方檢察署檢察官偵查起訴。
|
|
|
|
訊據被告A07、A09均坦承結夥三人、攜帶兇器強盜犯行;被告A03坦承加入本案犯罪組織及結夥三人、攜帶兇器強盜之犯行;被告A08固坦承有下揭無爭議之事實,惟否認有何結夥三人、攜帶兇器強盜之犯行,並辯稱:我只承認加重搶奪云云。被告A08之辯護人為其辯護稱:本案犯罪計畫應為被告A09清點現金後,由被告A02及另案被告徐湘博開車門,朝告訴人A05及被害人A06噴灑辣椒水,趁反應不及將現金搶走,告訴人及被害人A06尚未不能抗拒等語;被告A02固坦承有加入本案犯罪組織及下揭無爭議之事實,惟否認有何結夥三人、攜帶兇器強盜之犯行,並辯稱:我只承認加重搶奪,攜帶辣椒水係為防身云云。被告A02之辯護人為其辯護稱:噴灑辣椒水應僅造成告訴人及被害人A06暫時無法作強硬抵抗,尚非達至使不能抗拒的程度等語。惟查:
|
|
|
|
被告A02、A03加入本案犯罪組織,先由「塔拉雷奧特拉拉」於網路上找尋欲購買虛擬貨幣之買家即告訴人,誘騙告訴人攜帶244萬元現金,約定於114年10月15日21時許,至臺中市○○區○○○路000號前停車場進行交易。被告A07則指示被告A08將上開地址傳送於本案犯罪組織建立之TELEGRAM群組內,另指示被告A03駕駛車牌號碼000-0000號自小客車,搭載被告A09、A02及另案被告徐湘博,前往上址,並於上開群組中指示被告A09購買辣椒水。被告A03、A09、A02及另案被告徐湘博到達上址後,由被告A09攜帶電擊棒、刀具進入告訴人搭乘之車牌號碼000-0000號自小客車副駕駛座後座,佯裝與告訴人進行交易而清點現金;被告A09確認款項後,被告A02及另案被告徐湘博隨即開啟該車車門,持辣椒水朝車內告訴人及被害人A06臉部噴灑,被告A09見狀拉扯告訴人手中裝有現金之紙袋,因告訴人死守不放,被告A09持預藏之刀具刺擊告訴人A05腿部,告訴人受傷後將現金紙袋丟往駕駛座方向。被告A09、A02及另案被告徐湘博見強取未果,遂由被告A03駕駛上開車輛接應逃離現場而未取得244萬元現金等情,被告5人所不爭執,核與證人即告訴人及被害人A06分別於警詢時之證述(見偵53201卷第97-99、121-124頁、偵63836卷第207-210頁)、證人即另案被告徐湘博於警詢、偵查中之證述(見偵53201卷第163-181、371-375頁)、證人兼被告A03、A02於本院審理時之證述(見本院卷第324-342頁)情節相符,並有如附件所示之證據在卷可稽,此部分事實,首堪認定。
|
|
|
|
⑴按所謂兇器之種類並無限制,凡客觀上足對人之生命、身體、安全構成威脅,具有危險性之兇器均屬之。市售辣椒水噴霧係用於防身,其功能係噴出濃烈辛辣之氣體,使被噴者之感官遭受刺激,造成噴嚏、咳嗽、流淚、難以睜眼、紅腫疼痛等症狀,可藉此暫時壓抑被噴者之攻擊力,衡情一般人如突遭辣椒水噴灑,極可能因前述生理反應而無力抵抗,依一般社會觀念與經驗,該辣椒水客觀上顯已對他人生命、身體、安全構成威脅,而應具有危險性(最高法院108年度台上字第3122號判決意旨參照)。經查,告訴人於警詢中已陳明:我被噴辣椒水眼睛無法完全睜開等語(見偵53201卷第99頁),堪認被告A02及另案被告徐湘博持辣椒水朝告訴人、被害人A06之臉部噴灑,可造成上開說明之症狀,辣椒水即為客觀上足以對人之身體、安全構成威脅,自屬刑法第321條第1項第3款所稱之兇器無誤,是本案被告5人均知悉本案下手施行時使用辣椒水,均該當攜帶兇器之要件甚明。
|
|
|
|
⑵至公訴意旨認被告A09攜帶兇器電擊棒、刀具部分,分別均為被告A07、A08、A02、A03所能預見,然查被告A07指揮本案犯行時,固指示購買辣椒水,惟未要求被告A09攜帶其他兇器等情,業據證人兼被告A03於審理時證稱:我們只知道有辣椒水,案發前被告A09下車時有跟我拿電擊棒,車上的人都知道,但案發後被告A09再次上車時,我才知道被告A09有帶刀具等語(見本院卷第326-334頁)及證人兼被告A02於審理時證稱:被告A07一開始有說不要用刀,我知道下車時被告A09有拿電擊棒,但案發後被告A09再次上車時,我才知道被告A09有帶刀具(見本院卷第334-340頁)詳實,堪認被告A07、A08、A02、A03對於被告A09攜帶刀具均未能預見,且被告A09係下車犯案前,始向被告A03借用電擊棒,則被告A07、A08當時均未在場,亦難有預見,是公訴意旨此部分指訴容有誤會,先予敘明。
|
|
|
|
⑵本案被告A02及另案被告徐湘博開車門,朝告訴人及被害人A06噴灑辣椒水乙情,為被告5人不爭執,已如前述,而市售辣椒水噴霧原係用於防身,主要作用即係噴出濃烈辛辣之氣體,使被噴者之感官遭受刺激,造成噴嚏、咳嗽、流淚、難以睜眼、紅腫疼痛等症狀,可藉此暫時壓抑被噴者之攻擊力,俾使用者得以乘機脫身或報警處理等情,為眾所周知之事實;是衡之常情,一般人如處於突遭辣椒水噴灑之同一情境下,極可能因前述生理反應而無力抵抗,參以告訴人確受有接觸性皮膚刺激之傷害乙情,有告訴人之國軍臺中總醫院附設民眾診療服務處診斷證明書可證(見偵53201卷第119頁),被告A02亦自承:我知道一般人被潑灑辣椒水眼睛會很痛等語(見本院卷第359頁)相佐,足認被告A02所為客觀上已屬壓抑告訴人及被害人A06之意思自由之強暴手段,並已達於使其等難以抗拒之程度甚明。至告訴人及被害人A06嗣後雖仍得以驅離被告A09、A02及另案被告徐湘博,致被告未能攜帶欲強取之財物逃逸,惟此係因告訴人及被害人A06為防護財產而奮不顧身攔阻被告A09、A02及另案被告徐湘博,此由告訴人於警詢陳稱:我把被告A09推下車後才發現我的左大腿、右大腿被刺傷等語(見偵53201卷第98頁)即可明瞭,尚不能以此特殊情節遽認被告5人所為之強暴行為尚未達於使人難以抗拒之程度。是以,被告A08、A02所辯告訴人及被害人A06尚未達於不能抗拒之程度云云,實無可採。
|
|
|
|
㈣按刑法第59條規定犯罪之情狀可憫恕者,得酌量減輕其刑,所謂「犯罪之情狀」,與同法第57條規定科刑時應審酌之一切情狀,並非有截然不同之領域,於裁判上酌減其刑時,應就犯罪一切情狀(包括第57條所列舉之10款事項),予以全盤考量,審酌其犯罪有無可憫恕之事由,即有無特殊之原因與環境,在客觀上足以引起一般同情,以及宣告法定最低度刑,是否猶嫌過重等等,以為判斷(最高法院70年度第6次刑事庭會議決議意旨參照)。而刑法第328條第1項、第321條第1項第3、4款、第330條第1項之結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜罪,其法定刑係7年以上有期徒刑,然同為犯結夥三人以上攜帶兇器強盜犯行之人,其原因、動機不一,犯罪情節未必盡同,其行為所造成危害程度,自屬有異,法律科處此類犯罪,倘依其情狀處以適當徒刑,即足以懲儆,並可達防衛社會之目的者,自非不可依客觀之犯行與主觀之惡性二者加以考量其情狀,是否有可憫恕之處,適用刑法第59條之規定酌量減輕其刑,期使個案裁判之量刑,能斟酌至當,符合比例原則。本院審酌被告5人均坦承客觀犯行,因思慮未周致罹刑章,且均係因「塔拉雷奧特拉拉」提供情資始犯下本案犯行,又被告5人均與告訴人成立調解,告訴人亦同意撤回告訴,有本院調解筆錄附卷可參(見本院卷第291-293頁),且就本案犯行,尚未生實際財產損害,應認縱使量處被告法定最低本刑即有期徒刑7年,仍屬過苛,不符合罪刑相當原則,客觀上足以引起一般人之同情,爰均依刑法第59條規定酌減其刑,並依法遞減之。
|
|
|
|
㈤爰以行為人之責任為基礎,審酌被告5人正值青壯,不思循正當方式獲取金錢,被告A09、A02、A03分別受被告A07、A08之邀約,竟以佯裝泰達幣交易為名、實則欲以強盜方式奪取金錢,被告5人亦攜帶兇器為之,對交易安全、社會治安損害甚鉅,所為應嚴予非難;並斟酌被告A07、A09、A03犯後均坦承犯行,被告A08、A02於犯後僅坦認加重搶奪等較屬輕微之事實之犯後態度;另考量被告5人有與告訴人達成調解,已如前述;兼衡本案犯罪動機、目的、手段及被告5人於犯罪分工程度,暨其等於本院審理時自述之智識程度、家庭生活及經濟狀況(見本院卷第361頁)等一切情狀,分別量處如主文所示之刑。
|
|
|
|
㈡被告A07於審理時供承:我有請被告A08分別給付2,000元給參與的成員等語(見本院卷第358頁),堪認被告A09、A03分別獲有2,000元為其等之犯罪所得,均依刑法第38條之1第1項、第3項宣告沒收,於全部或一部不能沒收或不宜執行沒收時,追徵其價額。
|
|
|
|
一、公訴意旨略以:被告5人共同基於傷害之犯意聯絡,於於114年10月15日21時許,至臺中市○○區○○○路000號前停車場欲以假交易之形式,強盜告訴人所攜帶之244萬元現金(強盜部分詳見前開有罪部分),而被告A03、A09、A02及另案被告徐湘博到達上址後,由被告A09攜帶電擊棒、刀具進入告訴人搭乘之車牌號碼000-0000號自小客車副駕駛座後座,佯裝進行交易而清點現金;被告A09確認款項後,被告A02及另案被告徐湘博隨即開啟該車車門,持辣椒水朝車內告訴人及被害人A06臉部噴灑,致告訴人受有接觸性皮膚刺激之傷害;另被告A09見狀拉扯告訴人手中裝有現金之紙袋,因告訴人死守不放,被告A09持預藏之刀具刺擊告訴人A05腿部,致告訴人受有左大腿及右大腿6公分撕裂傷及右小腿5公分撕裂傷等傷害,因認被告5人另涉犯刑法第277條第1項之傷害罪嫌等語。
|
|
|
|
三、茲告訴人業於115年3月11日以聲請撤回告訴狀向本院聲請撤回對被告5人之傷害告訴乙節,有前揭告訴人提出之聲請撤回告訴狀在卷可按(見本院卷第217頁),依照前揭規定,此部分原應為不受理之諭知,惟公訴意旨認此若成立犯罪,與前開加重強盜有罪部分具有想像競合犯之裁判上一罪關係,爰不另為不受理之諭知。
|
|
|
|
中 華 民 國 115 年 5 月 14 日
|