Archived
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch (scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of 2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore). The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on 2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
46 lines
11 KiB
JSON
46 lines
11 KiB
JSON
{"key": "L162", "status": "new", "duplicate_of": null, "duplicate_evidence": "", "scope_reason": "",
|
|
"new_sources_for_existing": [],
|
|
"pages": [
|
|
{"file": "work/articles/L162-1.txt", "keep": "2, 17-23, 28, 52-66, 88-95, 97-101, 104-105, 109, 115", "reason": "Taichung District Court judgment 113 訴 755 (December 11, 2024). Kept: case heading, operative sentences, facts, admission of facts, the court's findings on whether any cash was taken, on snatch versus robbery, the charges, attempt, sentencing considerations and the date. Cut: party and counsel list, evidence-admissibility boilerplate, defence arguments, legal reasoning on accomplices and group size, confiscation, appeal notice, statute text and evidence list"}
|
|
],
|
|
"values": {"date": "March 22, 2024", "victim": "Li Kuo-hsiang", "location": "Xitun District, Taichung", "country": "Taiwan",
|
|
"description": "A man who had learned in a Telegram group that Li Kuo-hsiang wanted to buy TWD 6.42 million in cryptocurrency arranged a fake sale at Li's studio in Taichung and, with an accomplice, tried to snatch the cash; Li was concussed in the fight and pepper-sprayed, and the victims pinned one attacker while the organiser fled. Three men were convicted of attempted aggravated snatch theft.",
|
|
"summary": "On March 22, 2024, Li Kuo-hsiang, manager of a studio in Xitun District, Taichung, Taiwan, was to buy TWD 6.42 million in cryptocurrency. A man who had learned of the planned purchase in a Telegram group arranged the trade at the studio, intending to snatch the cash, and brought two accomplices; one waited in a car below. He brought no crypto. At about 18:44, while Li and a second man packed the counted cash into two paper bags, he gave a signal, his accomplice overturned the table and the two tried to seize the bags, which tore and spilled the cash. In the fight Li suffered a head contusion with concussion and a wrist injury, and the organiser pepper-sprayed both victims. They pinned down the accomplice while the organiser fled in the waiting car. Police arrested the pinned man that evening and the other two the next day. The court found no cash was taken and in December 2024 sentenced the three to between 1 year and 1 year 6 months.",
|
|
"case_details": "**Victims:** 李國祥 (Li Kuo-hsiang), manager (店長) of the 「橘子與熊工作室」 studio where the trade took place, who wanted to buy cryptocurrency worth TWD 6.42 million. A second man, 簡思修, was in the studio with him, helped pack the cash and was sprayed too; the judgment does not state his role. A partner of the victim (被害人合夥人) is mentioned in the police scene report.\n\n**Attackers:** 蔡佳佑 (organiser; brought a POLICE-brand pepper spray without telling the others), 林鈺倫 (entered the studio with him), 張君緯 (drove from Kaohsiung and waited in the car below to pick them up). The Telegram contacts 「劉德華」 and 「飛」, through whom the trade was arranged, were not shown to have taken part (\"本案並無證據足認「劉德華」、「飛」參與搶奪計畫\").\n\n**Attack Method:** 蔡佳佑 learned in a Telegram group that 李國祥 wanted to buy TWD 6.42 million of crypto and planned to pose as a seller and snatch the cash (\"即萌生以兜售虛擬貨幣為名、實則搶奪交易現金之計畫\"). The trade was set for the afternoon of March 22 at the studio. 蔡佳佑 and 林鈺倫 put on masks and entered at about 18:23; 蔡佳佑 brought no crypto. After the cash was counted and split into two kraft-paper bags, 蔡佳佑 gave the agreed hand signal, 林鈺倫 overturned the table and they tried to seize the bags; 簡思修 grabbed the bags and 李國祥 intervened; the bags tore and the cash spilled.\n\n**Violence Used:** No detention: nobody was brought under the attackers' control; the attackers fought the two victims, and 林鈺倫 was himself pinned down by them. 李國祥 suffered a contusion of the left side of the head with concussion and abrasions to the right wrist (\"左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪、右側腕部擦挫傷之傷勢\"); 蔡佳佑 sprayed pepper spray in the faces of both victims. 林鈺倫 punched 李國祥 in the back of the head and neck, by Li's police statement; 簡思修 told police Li was hit on the head with an object from the office. The court ruled the pepper spray a weapon (兇器) but found the victims were not rendered unable to resist, so the offence was snatch theft (搶奪), not robbery (強盜) as charged.\n\n**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** Target: TWD 6,420,000 in trade cash. Li and 簡思修 told police and prosecutors that about TWD 840,000 (or 700,000 to 800,000) was missing after 蔡佳佑 grabbed cash from the floor; at trial both said they could not confirm he took any. On the CCTV and the doubts, the court held that he took none (\"應認蔡佳佑於本案衝突後並未拿取現場之交易現金84萬元,而本案搶奪應僅止於未遂階段\").\n\n**Status:** 林鈺倫 was arrested at the scene that evening; 蔡佳佑 was detained at 04:02 and 張君緯 at 10:40 the next day. On December 11, 2024 the Taichung District Court sentenced 蔡佳佑 to 1 year 6 months for attempted aggravated snatch theft by a group carrying a weapon, 林鈺倫 to 1 year 2 months and 張君緯 to 1 year for attempted group snatch theft. All three had settled with 李國祥 and paid compensation. Appealable.",
|
|
"detention": "no", "violence_torture": "yes", "drugs_alcohol": "no", "weapons": "yes", "theft": "no", "life_taken": "0",
|
|
"venue_of_control": "none", "held_duration": "none", "arrests": "convicted",
|
|
"demanded_amount": null, "demanded_currency": null, "demanded_usd_stated": null, "demanded_as_stated": "no demand; the attackers tried to snatch the TWD 6.42 million trade cash",
|
|
"taken_amount": null, "taken_currency": null, "taken_usd_stated": null, "taken_as_stated": "nothing taken, as the court found; the victims had first said about TWD 840,000 was missing",
|
|
"targeting": ["Online contact or advert"], "targeting_accuracy": "Correct", "who_was_attacked": ["Holder", "Other"], "approach": ["P2P trade"], "attack": ["Armed robbery"], "outcome": "Fought off", "obtained": ["Nothing"],
|
|
"people": [{"role": "Holder", "people": 1, "at_least": 0, "detail": "the studio manager buying the crypto"}, {"role": "Other", "people": 1, "at_least": 0, "detail": "a second man in the studio who handled the cash"}],
|
|
"sources": ["https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TCDM%2C113%2C%E8%A8%B4%2C755%2C20241211%2C5"], "name_withheld": 0},
|
|
"support": {
|
|
"date": "與李國祥約定於同年3 月22日下午",
|
|
"detention": "林鈺倫旋依約掀桌,欲搶奪該2 個裝有現金之牛皮紙袋",
|
|
"violence_torture": "致李國祥受有左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪、右側腕部擦挫傷之傷勢",
|
|
"drugs_alcohol": "蔡佳佑、林鈺倫與李國祥、簡思修發生肢體衝突、扭打",
|
|
"weapons": "蔡佳佑復自口袋內取出預先備好之前揭辣椒水噴霧劑1 瓶,朝李國祥、簡思修臉部噴灑",
|
|
"theft": "蔡佳佑與林鈺倫終未搶得李國祥交易虛擬貨幣之現金,因而其等搶奪未得逞",
|
|
"life_taken": "致李國祥受有左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪、右側腕部擦挫傷之傷勢",
|
|
"venue_of_control": "簡思修見狀,迅速抓住該2 個牛皮紙袋;李國祥並上前阻止現金遭搶",
|
|
"held_duration": "簡思修見狀,迅速抓住該2 個牛皮紙袋",
|
|
"arrests": "蔡佳佑犯結夥攜帶兇器搶奪未遂罪,處有期徒刑壹年陸月",
|
|
"demanded_amount": "實則搶奪交易現金之計畫",
|
|
"taken_amount": "應認蔡佳佑於本案衝突後並未拿取現場之交易現金84萬元",
|
|
"targeting: Online contact or advert": "即時通訊軟體TELEGRAM群組內,得知李國祥欲購買價值新臺幣(下同)642 萬元之虛擬貨幣之訊息",
|
|
"targeting_accuracy": "蔡佳佑偕當時在工作室內之李國祥、簡思修清點交易虛擬貨幣之現金642 萬元",
|
|
"who_was_attacked: Holder": "致李國祥受有左側頭部挫傷併腦震盪",
|
|
"who_was_attacked: Other": "朝李國祥、簡思修臉部噴灑",
|
|
"approach: P2P trade": "與李國祥約定於同年3 月22日下午,在臺中市○○區○○路00號5 樓之3 李國祥擔任店長之「橘子與熊工作室」內交易虛擬貨幣",
|
|
"attack: Armed robbery": "蔡佳佑犯結夥攜帶兇器搶奪未遂罪",
|
|
"outcome": "簡思修旋以手扣住林鈺倫脖子,並與李國祥將林鈺倫壓制在地,蔡佳佑見狀則乘機衝出「橘子與熊工作室」",
|
|
"obtained: Nothing": "蔡佳佑與林鈺倫終未搶得李國祥交易虛擬貨幣之現金",
|
|
"people: Holder": "李國祥擔任店長之「橘子與熊工作室」",
|
|
"people: Other": "準備與工作室內之李國祥、簡思修交易虛擬貨幣"
|
|
},
|
|
"open_points": [
|
|
{"field": "theft", "detail": "The court found, on the CCTV and in favour of the accused, that no cash was taken, and theft no / obtained Nothing follow the judgment. But the victims told police and prosecutors that about TWD 840,000 was missing after the organiser grabbed cash from the floor, and the police scene report records the partner's claim of about 840,000 snatched; the court's finding is a benefit-of-the-doubt ruling, not a positive finding that nothing went missing.", "first_value": "no (obtained Nothing)", "second_value": "unconfirmed (obtained Unconfirmed)", "quote": "依「有疑利益歸被告」原則,應認蔡佳佑於本案衝突後並未拿取現場之交易現金84萬元"}
|
|
],
|
|
"notes": "Single source: the first-instance judgment of the Taichung District Court (113 訴 755, December 11, 2024), primary record, read in full (about 15,700 characters). Victim's name is given in full in the published judgment. Location: the studio address is redacted; the car waited at the corner of Chongqing Road and Qinghai Road in Xitun District, below the studio. Approach P2P trade: a crypto-for-cash meeting the organiser arranged through two Telegram contacts. Targeting Online contact or advert: the organiser learned of Li's wish to buy in a Telegram group. Attack Armed robbery: attempted theft by force with a weapon (pepper spray), no holding; the court's offence is snatch theft, attempted. Outcome Fought off: the two victims resisted, pinned one attacker and the organiser fled. Who was attacked Other for 簡思修: present, sprayed and fought; the judgment does not say whether he is staff, a partner or a friend (the defence witness calls the people who gathered the cash 'their two colleagues', which may or may not include him). Nobody died.",
|
|
"lopp_differences": ["Lopp: 'Li and a friend pinned one attacker'; the judgment names the second man (簡思修) without stating his relationship to Li.", "Lopp: 'Tsai fled but was arrested hours later, along with the driver'; the judgment says Tsai was detained at 04:02 and the driver at 10:40 the next day, March 23.", "Lopp: 'an accomplice overturned the table to grab the cash bags, the victims resisted and the money spilled'; matches. Lopp does not mention the court's finding that nothing was taken."]}
|