This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/LABEL-RULES.md
T
StellarCrow 41766c68a2 chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step
label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of
2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch
(scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of
2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added
to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore).

The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on
2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
2026-10-17 10:47:37 +02:00

14 KiB

Label tests for the four-step structure (updated 2026-10-16)

One test per label, for the seven step fields of stats2. This file and section 6 of gart-io/databases/stats2/DB-GUIDE.md carry the same text; change both together.

Where the rules come from: the research paper's glossary (DEFINITIONS.md), the owner's rulings (dated in the text and listed in section 9), and the tests the DA wrote on 2026-10-07 to apply them, which the owner has ruled with since. Items marked [proposed] or [check] have no owner source yet (no invented definitions: DB-GUIDE.md, rule 3.0).

Changes from the version of 2026-10-07, which this replaces:

  • Label names follow the live labels table, in sentence case: "P2P trade", "Social engineering: ...", "Authority misuse: ...", "Organised by a relative or partner", "Express kidnapping".
  • Who was attacked has "Wrong person or address" and "Bystanders or neighbours" (added 2026-10-15 with case_people).
  • Outcome Released covers victims found alive with no rescue described (owner, 2026-10-15).
  • Any object used as a weapon counts (owner, 2026-10-16).
  • The owner's precedents are listed in section 9.

Flags (detention, violence, drugs, weapons, theft, deaths) are in FLAG-RULES.md: yes = it occurred, no = it surely did not, empty = unknown, unconfirmed = alleged or disputed and not established (owner, 2026-10-16).

Names below are the exact names in the live labels table (2026-10-15 copy). Each label belongs on a case only when the text passes its test.

General rules:

  • Every label rests on words in the sources (for existing cases: the verified summary, or the dossier where the summary is silent). Nothing is inferred from what usually happens.
  • "Unknown" is right when the texts do not say. It never stands beside another label in the same step.
  • Several labels are allowed in targeting, who was attacked, approach, attack and obtained. Outcome and targeting accuracy take one.
  • There is no "failed" label. An attack that got nothing after someone was held or hurt takes the outcome that happened to the victim, and obtained says Nothing.

1. targeting: how the attackers knew of the victim

Label Passes when the text says
Data leak the attackers had the victim's details from a leaked or stolen customer, tax or exchange database. A victim's or police suspicion counts only if the text presents it as the working explanation
Public records legally available records (address or tax registers, company filings)
Insider tip-off someone with inside access passed on holdings or movements: employee, driver, guard, contractor, bank or agency staff, a handler who supplied the target
Organised by a relative or partner a relative or partner of the victim organised or enabled the attack. Not when the victim is a relative of a holder (that is who was attacked)
Acquaintance a friend or social contact took part or pointed the attackers to the victim
Business counterparty the attackers knew the victim from trades, investments, a business or debt dispute, or were clients, investors or partners
Public profile known as a crypto holder: executive, founder, influencer, streamer, interviewed or listed as wealthy
Social media the attack followed specific posts or streams (wealth shown, location revealed)
Visible wealth cars, watches, spending or lifestyle seen offline are given as the reason
Online contact or advert the attackers answered the victim's advert, listing or profile on a platform, or first met them through one
Surveillance followed, watched or tracked before the attack. It says how they prepared: add the label for how they first knew the victim when the text gives it
Opportunistic the text shows no prior selection
Other a stated reason that fits none of the above; say which in the evidence
Unknown the texts do not say how the victim was chosen

Wrong address and assumed wealth are targeting accuracy, never targeting.

2. targeting_accuracy (one)

Label Passes when
Correct the victim held crypto or assets roughly as sought: crypto taken, transferred, shown, or confirmed as theirs
Wealth overestimated the victim held far less than the attackers believed, or none
Wrong person or address the attackers hit someone other than the intended holder (moved out, previous owner, namesake, wrong flat)
Unknown none of the above is shown. A foiled attack with nothing known about the holdings is Unknown

3. who_was_attacked

Label Passes when
Holder the person believed to hold the crypto or assets was confronted, held, hurt or threatened in person, or was the target of a remote attack
Relative or partner a relative or partner was present at the attack or in the attackers' custody: confronted, held or hurt in person. A couple or family attacked together is Holder plus Relative or partner
Employee or guard staff of the holder or of a crypto business were confronted, restrained or hurt
Wrong person or address someone attacked in place of the intended holder, usually because the attackers had an outdated address (previous owner or tenant)
Bystanders or neighbours others present who were not family or staff: friends, co-occupants, a neighbour, a passenger, customers in a shop
Business premises or machine a shop, exchange office, mining site or ATM was the target (no people row)
Other anyone the other labels do not cover, or the sources do not say who was attacked

Owner's rule (2026-10-07, restated 2026-10-08): a family member who was not present and not in the attackers' custody was not attacked. A relative who only received the ransom call, negotiated, paid or made the transfer does not count, and a threat spoken to the victim about absent family does not count. Applied to 60, 81, 86, 195, 238.

4. approach: how they got to the victim

Label Passes when
Social engineering: business or investment meeting drawn to a meeting, trip or call by a business, investment, job or consulting pretext
Social engineering: sale / purchase lure a sale or purchase of something other than crypto (car, property, goods)
Social engineering: dating or sexual lure a romantic or sexual pretext (dating app, a date, a pickup)
Social engineering: social invitation a friend or acquaintance invited them (dinner, party, night out, a visit)
Social engineering: pretext at the door a story told at the door with no claimed role (wrong address, asking for someone, damage to report)
Social engineering: other pretext another deception; say which
Social engineering: lure not described the text says lured or tricked, not how
P2P trade an arranged meeting to exchange crypto or cash, whether or not the other side meant to trade. Only this label for that meeting: never add a Social engineering label for it
Authority misuse: fake police or official posed as police, agents, military or officials
Authority misuse: serving police or official serving officers or officials using their position
Authority misuse: service ruse (delivery, driver, worker) posed as delivery, courier, taxi or rideshare driver, technician, worker. Fake rides and fake deliveries go here only, never under Social engineering
Authority misuse: other claimed role another claimed role the victim deferred to (client with an appointment, colleague). [proposed] also a bank or exchange employee or a concierge: DEFINITIONS.md names them as Authority misuse; the sub-label is the DA's placement
Seized in the street or a public place grabbed or attacked in a street, car park, shop, restaurant or other public place, with no deception
Seized at or outside the home grabbed at the door, gate, garage or building entrance without the attackers entering
Taken from the workplace taken at or from the office or business
Vehicle intercepted on the road the vehicle was blocked, rammed or stopped
Walked in into a shop, exchange office or ATM site open to the public
Forced entry broke or pushed into a home, hotel room, office or shop. A home invasion does not prove it: the text must show force or a break-in
Let in by an insider someone inside opened the door, gave a code or key, or delivered the victim
Break-in, nobody present broke into empty premises
Remote, no contact no physical approach (swatting, threats or extortion from a distance)
Unknown the texts do not say

Authority misuse (owner, 2026-09-30) covers any real or claimed service position the victim defers to, including a claimed role used only to get a door or gate opened (fake parcel, courier, food delivery, painter, postal or construction uniform) and a police uniform worn on the approach. Reference case: 173 (fake Uber driver, Scottsdale). It is not applied where the file does not show the role being used (397, 434).

5. attack: what they did

Label Passes when
Kidnapping taken away or held at a place the attackers control, and pre-selected, or held away from the public, or moved a long distance, or a ransom asked of third parties. Also a failed attempt at this
Express kidnapping all three: not pre-selected, seized in public, made to pay from own funds on the spot or in a vehicle. If the text says nothing on how the victim was chosen and the other two hold, Express kidnapping stands (note the gap)
Home invasion occupants confronted or held in their own home, hotel room or office. Also an attempt at the home
Armed robbery theft or attempted theft by force with a weapon reported, without extended holding. Any object used as a weapon counts (owner, 2026-10-16: cars, a Toblerone bar in case 64)
Robbery without a weapon theft or attempted theft by force or assault, no weapon reported (fists and restraints are not weapons)
Mugging an opportunistic street robbery
Burglary theft from premises, a machine or an empty home with nobody confronted (owner, 2026-10-06). A person threatened or held makes it Armed robbery (staff) or Home invasion (occupants)
Extortion without detention demands backed by threats, in person or remote, nobody held
Theft by deception assets taken by trickery or drugging, no force
Swatting a false emergency report sent armed police to the victim
No label fits none of the above; raise an admin point

A foiled or fought-off attempt carries the label of the attack that was attempted. Duration and the size of the sum do not decide Kidnapping versus Express kidnapping (owner, 2026-10-01).

6. outcome (one)

Label Passes when
Foiled stopped before the attackers had anyone under control and without a physical fight: arrested beforehand, plan uncovered, door not opened, an alarm or third party interrupting, theft interrupted with nobody confronted. An attack that got nothing after holding or hurting someone is not foiled
Fought off the victim, or someone with them, resisted physically (struggled, hit back, bit, shot) and the attackers gave up and fled, also after briefly holding the victim
Escaped the victim got away by their own action (ran, jumped, slipped out, drove off). The victim left; the attackers did not flee
Rescued freed by police or other people, or the attackers fled because someone else arrived. Only when the sources describe a rescue
Released the attackers let the victim go or left of their own accord, including when the victim refused and they ran, or left the victim tied up. Owner's rule (2026-10-15): abducted victims later found alive, with no rescue described, are Released (being found means the attackers abandoned them). Do not raise Rescued as an alternative
Killed the victim died as a result of the attack. A later death not linked to it does not count
Nobody held or hurt burglary, swatting or remote cases where no person was confronted
Unknown the texts do not say how it ended

7. obtained: what the attackers got

Label Passes when
Crypto cryptocurrency transferred or taken
Cash banknotes or bank money (transfers, withdrawals)
Devices or seed phones, computers, hardware wallets, seed phrases
Valuables watches, jewellery, cars, mining machines, an ATM, other goods
Nothing the text shows nothing was taken. Stands alone
Unconfirmed a taking is alleged or charged and not established, or the sources disagree. Stands alone
Unknown the sources do not say what, if anything, the attackers got. Stands alone (added 2026-10-17 on the owner's decision, so that unknown and unconfirmed stay apart, as for the flags)

8. Changing the vocabulary

New labels, renames and definitions are the owner's decision. To propose one, give the label, the step, a one-line test and the cases it would apply to. Once approved, it goes in by SQL (section 10).

9. Owner rulings that work as precedent

Apply these without asking. The full record is DB-cleanup/merge-output/step-rulings.json, corrections-approved.md and closed-by-precedent.json.

Rule Cases
Absent relatives were not attacked (6.3) 60, 81, 86, 195, 238
Found alive, no rescue described: Released 477, 174, 392
A crypto trade meeting is P2P trade only standing
Fake rides and fake deliveries are Authority misuse: service ruse only standing
A claimed service role, or a uniform used only to get in, is Authority misuse 173 and 29 others
Express kidnapping needs all three conditions; everything else is Kidnapping 91, 279, 334, 182, 202, 137, 462, 456, 80, 19, 367 moved; 229, 253, 34, 434, 394, 357, 172, 7 stayed
Burglary: nobody confronted; a failed attempt is Burglary plus outcome Foiled 3, 6, 10, 54, 57, 62, 66, 71, 101, 105, 112, 158, 198, 21, 349, 99, 383, 449, 450
A weapon found later and never shown to the victims: weapons no 72, 233, 421, 426, 447, 472
The victim got away and was never held: Escaped; "failed" is not a value 52
Theft interrupted with nobody confronted: Foiled 54
The attackers fled because the husband shot at them: Fought off 218
A knife attack in the street that the victim fought off: Armed robbery, Fought off 222
Same incident reported twice: merge into the earlier record 386 into 295, 446 into 445, 440 and 441 into 439, 365 into 323, 296 into 290
One record that holds two attacks: split 38 (into 38 and 504), 49 (into 49 and 505)
Sources are not chased for existing cases; an unconfirmed record detail stays 235, 231