This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/lopp-pr234/work/out/L098.json
T
StellarCrow 41766c68a2 chore: final state before the move to gart/gart-databases
Commits the work done since 2026-10-01 that was still local: the four-step
label and flag passes, the triage and recheck files, the v1 exports of
2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, the split dossiers, and the Lopp PR 234 batch
(scripts, agent prompts, reader and checker files, the flag re-read of
2026-10-17, the review workbook and the import set of the 57 cases added
to stats2 as 506 to 562). Raw HTML and node_modules stay out (.gitignore).

The stats2 material in use was copied to gart/gart-databases (stats2/) on
2026-10-17; README-START-HERE.md now says so. This repo is closed.
2026-10-17 10:47:37 +02:00

44 lines
10 KiB
JSON

{"key": "L098", "status": "new", "duplicate_of": null, "duplicate_evidence": "", "scope_reason": "",
"new_sources_for_existing": [],
"pages": [
{"file": "work/articles/L098-1.txt", "keep": "2, 14-22, 41-44, 54-55, 58-60, 65-67, 69, 80, 89, 100, 102, 110, 116", "reason": "Taiwan High Court Taichung Branch judgment 112 原上訴 47 (November 21, 2023). Kept: case heading, operative part, findings of fact, the co-defendants' and victim's testimony on the attack, the court's finding on the shove, the legal qualification and the sentences. Cut: party list, evidence-admissibility reasoning, the defendant's long defence and the girlfriend's testimony on the later handling of the cash, the juvenile-aggravation and mitigation discussion, appeal formalities and the appended statute text."}
],
"values": {"date": "October 12, 2022", "victim": "A USDT buyer", "location": "Taichung HSR station, Taichung", "country": "Taiwan",
"description": "A gang directed over Telegram staged a sale of 60,000 USDT at Taichung high-speed rail station; after the buyer handed over NT$1,912,800 in cash to be counted and was shown a fake transfer screenshot, one man snatched the bag and ran while an accomplice shoved the buyer. The buyer caught the accomplice, and three defendants were convicted of group snatch-theft.",
"summary": "On October 12, 2022, at Taiwan High Speed Rail's Taichung station in Taiwan, a buyer came to meet a seller he had dealt with in a Telegram group to buy 60,000 USDT for NT$1,912,800 in cash. The seller was a front: a ringleader known on Telegram as 'Huoshan Baofa' directed a team of five at the station. At about 6:45 p.m. one of them met the buyer at the seats beside a Mister Donut shop, counted the cash and showed him a fake screenshot of the crypto transfer, then snatched the bag of cash from between the buyer's feet and ran. As the buyer chased him, an accomplice standing at the shop entrance shoved him hard into the counter. The thief got away to a waiting car with two lookouts; the buyer caught the accomplice and handed the accomplice to police. The cash was never recovered. On appeal in November 2023 the Taiwan High Court's Taichung branch upheld sentences of 4 years 6 months and 4 years 2 months and gave the accomplice 4 years 2 months for group snatch-theft.",
"case_details": "**Victims:** One buyer of USDT, anonymised in the judgment as 戊○○ (告訴人). He testified that he was 175 cm tall and weighed 80 kg at the time.\n\n**Attackers:** A Telegram-organised group: \"泽霖\", who posed as the seller in the Telegram group \"泽霖买卖U\"; \"火山爆發\", who directed the team remotely; 甲○○ (\"en\"), who checked the team on site, reported to \"火山爆發\" and received the cash in the car; 丁○○ (\"雙天\"), who took the cash; 丙○○ (\"女\"), hired as driver, who shoved the victim; 林鑫甫 (\"馬卡\", left Taiwan, prosecuted separately) and the juvenile 曾○○ (\"財寶\", referred to juvenile court) as lookouts and back-up. Five were at the station.\n\n**Attack Method:** \"由「泽霖」假意與戊○○交易虛擬貨幣,再由「火山爆發」遠程指示甲○○、丁○○、丙○○、林鑫甫及少年曾○○至交易現場下手行搶\". \"泽霖\" offered to sell 60,000 USDT for NT$1,912,800; the meeting was set at the seating area beside MISTER DONUT in the Taichung HSR station. 丁○○ counted the cash and showed a fake screenshot sent by \"火山爆發\"; the victim testified: \"它應該只是1個偽造的截圖,只是要讓我誤以為幣有轉出\". Then \"丁○○即趁戊○○不及防備之際,奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋,並迅速逃離\".\n\n**Violence Used:** No detention: a snatch and run. As the victim chased 丁○○, \"丙○○當場推撞跑經其身旁之戊○○,戊○○因未及防備且突遭丙○○大力衝撞,雖未跌倒,仍因身體朝MISTER DONUT甜甜圈店櫃檯方向歪斜\". The victim testified to a struggle in which his glasses and hat fell off. The court called the push a 施暴行為 but held it was brief, slight and did not make resistance impossible, so it convicted of group snatch-theft (結夥三人以上搶奪罪), not quasi-robbery as the prosecutors charged. No weapon, no injury.\n\n**Crypto Demanded/Stolen:** No demand. Taken: NT$1,912,800 in cash, the buyer's purchase money for 60,000 USDT. No crypto was transferred. The court found the whole sum passed to 甲○○, who handed about NT$200,000 to 林鑫甫 and the juvenile and kept NT$1,712,800, ordered confiscated.\n\n**Status:** The victim caught 丙○○ and handed him to police at the station. Taichung District Court first instance May 25, 2023 (111 原訴 118). Taiwan High Court Taichung Branch, November 21, 2023 (112 原上訴 47): 丙○○ 4 years 2 months for group snatch-theft as a recidivist (first-instance quasi-robbery conviction reversed); 甲○○ 4 years 6 months upheld, NT$1,712,800 confiscated from him; 丁○○ 4 years 2 months upheld. 林鑫甫 had left Taiwan; the juvenile went to juvenile court; \"火山爆發\" and \"泽霖\" were not tried here.",
"detention": "no", "violence_torture": "yes", "drugs_alcohol": "no", "weapons": "no", "theft": "yes", "life_taken": "0",
"venue_of_control": "none", "held_duration": "none", "arrests": "convicted",
"demanded_amount": null, "demanded_currency": null, "demanded_usd_stated": null, "demanded_as_stated": "no demand; the cash was snatched",
"taken_amount": 1912800, "taken_currency": "TWD", "taken_usd_stated": null, "taken_as_stated": "NT$1,912,800 in cash brought to buy 60,000 USDT",
"targeting": ["Online contact or advert"], "targeting_accuracy": "Correct", "who_was_attacked": ["Holder"], "approach": ["P2P trade"], "attack": ["Robbery without a weapon"], "outcome": "Released", "obtained": ["Cash"],
"people": [{"role": "Holder", "people": 1, "at_least": 0, "detail": "the buyer who brought the cash"}],
"sources": ["https://judgment.judicial.gov.tw/FJUD/data.aspx?ty=JD&id=TCHM%2C112%2C%E5%8E%9F%E4%B8%8A%E8%A8%B4%2C47%2C20231121%2C1"], "name_withheld": 0},
"support": {
"date": "嗣於111年10月12日下午5時許",
"detention": "奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋,並迅速逃離",
"violence_torture": "丙○○當場推撞跑經其身旁之戊○○,戊○○因未及防備且突遭丙○○大力衝撞",
"drugs_alcohol": "丁○○即趁戊○○不及防備之際,奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋",
"weapons": "丙○○當場推撞跑經其身旁之戊○○",
"theft": "致告訴人戊○○受有191萬2800元之鉅額財產損害",
"life_taken": "丙○○當場推撞跑經其身旁之戊○○,戊○○因未及防備且突遭丙○○大力衝撞,雖未跌倒",
"venue_of_control": "奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋,並迅速逃離",
"held_duration": "奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋,並迅速逃離",
"arrests": "丙○○犯結夥三人以上搶奪罪,累犯,處有期徒刑肆年貳月。",
"demanded_amount": "奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋",
"taken_amount": "任意搶奪告訴人戊○○現金191萬2800元",
"targeting: Online contact or advert": "先由「泽霖」在通訊軟體Telegram「泽霖买卖U」群組訊息中假意向戊○○佯稱欲販售6萬顆虛擬貨幣USDT(泰達幣)",
"targeting_accuracy": "俟戊○○於同日下午6時30分許將欲購買上開虛擬貨幣之現金191萬2800元以米色布袋裝好",
"who_was_attacked: Holder": "奪取戊○○放於兩腳中間裝有上開現金之米色布袋",
"approach: P2P trade": "雙方並協議於民國000年00月00日下午6時45分許,在臺灣高鐵臺中站之MISTER DONUT甜甜圈店旁座椅區交易",
"attack: Robbery without a weapon": "丙○○當場推撞跑經其身旁之戊○○",
"outcome": "因判斷已無法即刻追躡搶回裝有現金米色布袋之丁○○,隨即轉而追躡丙○○,並將丙○○擒獲後交予警方逮捕",
"obtained: Cash": "現金191萬2800元",
"people: Holder": "證人即告訴人戊○○"
},
"open_points": [
{"field": "outcome", "detail": "A snatch and run: the victim was never held, the thief got away with the cash, and the victim caught one accomplice. No outcome label fits cleanly. Released is set because the attackers left with the money of their own accord; Nobody held or hurt is the alternative, since nobody was held and nobody was injured, though the victim was confronted and shoved.", "first_value": "Released", "second_value": "Nobody held or hurt", "quote": "因判斷已無法即刻追躡搶回裝有現金米色布袋之丁○○,隨即轉而追躡丙○○,並將丙○○擒獲後交予警方逮捕"}
],
"notes": "Single source: the appeal judgment of the Taiwan High Court Taichung Branch (112 原上訴 47, November 21, 2023), primary record; the first-instance Taichung District Court judgment (111 原訴 118, May 25, 2023) was not fetched. The page is about 36,000 characters, read in full. Date: the facts section redacts the agreed date ('民國000年00月00日') but gives 111年10月12日 (October 12, 2022) for the gathering and the snatch. Location: inside the Taichung HSR station (the court notes the seating area is not a boarding area); one witness calls it 烏日高鐵站 (the station is in Wuri). Victim anonymised as 戊○○; Lopp's 'victim' field is this placeholder. Violence yes: the court itself calls the hard push a '施暴行為' though it found it too slight for quasi-robbery; no injury. Attack Robbery without a weapon: theft by force with a shove, no weapon; the court's charge is snatch-theft (搶奪). Targeting Online contact or advert: the fake seller approached him through the Telegram trading group. Accuracy Correct: he brought the full cash sum and it was taken. Defendant names: 黃宥甯, 涂耿銘 and 黃震宇 appear as appellants in the heading; the body uses 丙/甲/丁○○ and the mapping is not stated, so names are not used.",
"lopp_differences": ["Lopp: the buyer 'handed her to police'; the judgment does not state the accomplice's sex (his Telegram nickname was 「女」, 'female'), and the victim's testimony refers to him as 他.", "Lopp: 'several convictions for group snatch-theft were handed down on appeal'; on appeal one conviction was changed from quasi-robbery to group snatch-theft and two sentences were upheld."]}