Archived
264 lines
40 KiB
Markdown
264 lines
40 KiB
Markdown
# Approved corrections — apply these on the website database
|
||
|
||
Sofia's decision on each, taken one by one. Nothing here has been applied automatically.
|
||
Evidence for every item is in `research-results.json` and `fact-check-findings.json`.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Spreadsheet fixes (not the database)
|
||
|
||
**Row 259** — `URL` is `https://archive.is/El9EI`, which is the Kharkiv snapshot. That same
|
||
link correctly sits on row 262 (Kharkiv) and on DB id 258 (Kharkiv). The article saved in
|
||
row 259 is the Europe 1 Val-de-Marne story, and DB id 362 already holds the correct
|
||
Europe 1 URL. So the database is right and this row's URL is the mispaste.
|
||
→ **Fix or clear the URL on row 259. Leave DB id 258 alone.**
|
||
|
||
**Row 18** — `Scenario` says `Armed Robbery in Public Space`. The article says the attack
|
||
happened inside the victims' own apartment in the Busca neighbourhood of Toulouse. DB id
|
||
266 already says `Home Invasion`, which is closer.
|
||
→ **Fix the sheet.**
|
||
|
||
**Row 252** — `URL` points to `cryptonews.com/.../french-crypto-trader-kidnapped-near-paris`,
|
||
a different case in France. The article saved in that row is a Phuket robbery in Thailand.
|
||
Trusting this URL would have filed the article under DB id 350.
|
||
→ **Re-find the correct source.** This case is also absent from the database entirely; see
|
||
`cases-missing-from-database.json`.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## DB id 307 — Salford, October 2023
|
||
|
||
`description` duplicates id 354 (incident 1, the door knock) and `notes` describes
|
||
incident 2. Date, location, scenario and flags already fit incident 4. Confirmed by
|
||
elimination: five sheet rows, five DB records, four pairs settled independently.
|
||
|
||
→ **Rewrite to incident 4, quoting the source in notes:**
|
||
> "Days later, the gang turned up at the victim's house again, demanding more money. They
|
||
> took him to Egret Drive, the address he was later found at by police, and placed a bag
|
||
> over his head."
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## DB id 321 — Recife, 21 March 2025
|
||
|
||
`victim` reads `Crypto manager`, but the person kidnapped was his mother. The record already
|
||
contradicts itself: the description reads "Crypto manager surveilled, mother kidnapped,
|
||
ransomed for 5 BTC".
|
||
|
||
→ **Change `victim` to the mother.**
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## DB id 456 — Serra, Espírito Santo, 11 June 2026
|
||
|
||
**Drug-trafficking network claim — DELETE.** The summary states the investigation "led to
|
||
broader operation against a drug trafficking and money laundering network in Espírito Santo
|
||
and Bahia". No source makes this claim. It traces to an unrelated teaser headline sitting
|
||
inside the Sim Notícias page, about a street sweeper in a different case.
|
||
|
||
**Pistol-whipping — DELETE, but keep `violence_torture` = 1.** No source contains
|
||
"coronhada". Serra Noticiário, sourced to the police who processed him, says his only
|
||
injuries were "escoriações causadas pela queda durante a fuga". The flag stays on the basis
|
||
of one early A Tribuna line attributed to unnamed residents: "A vítima teria tentado
|
||
resistir ao sequestro, mas foi agredida." Record that as the basis, alongside the police
|
||
account of his injuries.
|
||
|
||
**Vehicle count — CORRECT to two attacker vehicles.** Keep the eight-suspect figure, which
|
||
the victim's own account supports. Drop the third vehicle and the invented per-attacker
|
||
role breakdown. Lt. Tavares: "conseguimos identificar dois carros que emparelharam com a
|
||
Porsche, um HB20 branco e um Celta prata."
|
||
Also record: **both attacker vehicles carry São Paulo plates registered to the same owner**
|
||
(Serra Noticiário) — relevant to whether an attack was organised or opportunistic.
|
||
|
||
**"as of June 16, 2026" — REMOVE the date, keep the rest.** No article dated 16 June or
|
||
later exists; every source found is dated 11 or 12 June. The count stands as "one arrested,
|
||
seven at large", with no date attached.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Detention flag (`kidnappings`) — accepted 2026-09-06
|
||
|
||
Rule: README-START-HERE.md, "Definitions". The field is the detention flag; rename it `detention`
|
||
on the website. Evidence per case: merge-output/detention-flag-review.md.
|
||
|
||
→ **Set `kidnappings` to 1 on these records:** 4, 19, 25, 28, 29, 41, 43, 46, 63, 64, 82, 139, 143, 147, 152, 167, 169, 171, 180, 181, 182, 183, 200, 209, 229, 253, 301, 353, 380, 419.
|
||
|
||
Rule clarified the same day: detention used on anyone (guards, staff, a concierge, a relative) to
|
||
force submission or execute the theft counts as 1, whether or not the record's named victim was
|
||
present. Case 301 (guards tied up) is therefore in the list above.
|
||
|
||
→ **Set `kidnappings` to 0 on 354, 355 (currently null) and 124** (decided 2026-09-07).
|
||
|
||
Withdrawn 2026-09-07, these stay 1: 242, 273, 413, 422, 423, 215, 298. Rule: forced entry into the
|
||
victim's space followed by beating or holding them there is detention, however short. No open items.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 01 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-01.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-01.json`.
|
||
|
||
- **DB id 295 (John Forsyth)** — keep one record for the February 2022 kidnapping: `date` → February 2022, `scenario` stays Kidnapping, `theft` → 0 (wallet, passport, laptop and phones were left in the car). Note the 21–30 May 2023 disappearance and death in `status`; police said foul play did not appear to be a factor.
|
||
- **DB id 241 (Bangkok, 30 June 2025)** — `notes`: say "several prior deals" (the Bangkok Post counts two, of 200,000 and 300,000 baht; the record counted five). `kidnappings` → 1 (held in the car at knifepoint). `violence_torture` rests on threats only.
|
||
- **DB id 216 (Vietnam)** — `description`: "extorts" → "demands 600,000 USDT" (nothing paid, plan foiled by police). `amount` → 600,000 USDT from the article body; discard the headline's $400,000.
|
||
- **DB id 215 (Jeju hotel suite)** — `description`: "lured to perform a trade" → "went to buy crypto" (Yonhap's wording). Scenario sequence: P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (control taken at the attackers' hotel suite; Armed Robbery in Public Space dropped). `kidnappings` stays 1.
|
||
- **DB id 213 (Estepona)** — `date` → 1 February 2025 (police informed that day). `status`: he escaped by jumping from the balcony before police moved in; the friend alerted his mother, who called police. `weapons` → 1 (two firearms, three knives found).
|
||
- **DB id 354 (Salford, first visit)** — `theft` → 1; the GMP sentencing statement says the victim transferred the money.
|
||
- **DB id 355 (Salford, Povey visit)** — `theft` → 1 as an inference (escalating returns, £100,000 aggregate for the earlier incidents, Povey's robbery conviction); no source ties a payment to this visit.
|
||
- **DB id 212 (Nigeria, brother as organiser)** — no DB change; vocabulary gap confirmed: prior personal ties / acquaintance as the initiation needs a label or attribute.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 02 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-02.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-02.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 211** — accept all: description → the two attackers took the victims' phones and made transfers totalling $16,000, coached by an accomplice by telephone; attackers → two; weapons → 1 (gun-butt blows, 'coronhadas na cabeça'); add the stolen car (recovered next day) to notes.
|
||
- **DB id 210** — accept: location → Sainte-Savine (suburb of Troyes); sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping; note the sheet's mistranslation ('mineur de cryptomonnaies' = crypto miner).
|
||
- **DB id 208** — accept: date → 16 January 2025; amount → $580,000 in crypto, cash taken back is a separate unquantified sum; notes → 'several prior deals' (article counts seven); violence_torture → 1.
|
||
- **DB id 207** — accept: date → 15 January 2025; notes → forced into another vehicle, bound and blindfolded (no assault reported); status → abandoned by the kidnappers and found by villagers, not rescued; no ransom demand reported.
|
||
- **DB id 206** — accept: drop the $290,000 (no source; keep 'large amount'); notes → police suspect he knew his attackers, entry method not stated. NEW ATTRIBUTE: flag prior acquaintance = suspected (police inference); the schema needs a prior-acquaintance / insider attribute (see also 212).
|
||
- **DB id 205** — accept: description → kidnap-for-crypto-ransom plot opened by a fake watches-for-crypto meeting, four arrested in Broward County per a federal affidavit (no FBI named); money_wanted → 2,000,000 USD in crypto; weapons → 1 (planned firearms, knife carried on the day).
|
||
- **DB id 204** — accept: money_wanted → 120,000 USD (demanded); cash stolen → note both article figures ($20,000 vs 60–70 hundred-dollar bills); attackers → one on site, two Russian suspects charged incl. absent mastermind; weapons → 0. Prior acquaintance = yes (business dispute).
|
||
- **DB id 202** — accept: money_wanted → 340,000 USD, coin_type USDT; keep both accounts of the transfer (Dawn: in his presence near FIA Saddar; Guardian: after the phone was taken) and of the route; weapons → 1; violence_torture → threat only; sequence Authority Misuse → Express Kidnapping.
|
||
- **DB id 201** — accept: date → 20 December 2024 (the Friday before VRT's 24 Dec report); attackers → four suspects, one a minor; victim name unsupported on file (keep only with a source); notes → injured in the crash, not 'ok'; location → Brussels, crash in Bruges; sequence Costly Fame → Kidnapping.
|
||
- **DB id 200** — keep the case; rename the victim to Dr Kwadwo Agyapong Berry (19 December, Botchway's office, thirteen hours); open a second record for Benjamin Appiah Boateng's detention at Laboma Beach from 14 December by Berry, Botchway and Burke; kidnappings → 1; theft → 0; money_wanted → the $1.6 million in dispute, not a ransom; sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping. NEW ATTRIBUTE: insider dispute (prior acquaintance = yes, co-investors).
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 03 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-03.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-03.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 199** — accept: attackers → nine-member group (Russia, Uzbekistan, Ukraine); amount → US$214,424; drop 'Binance'; arrests → one man detained and released, nobody in custody, police doubt the complaint; location → South Kuta (held at villas in Kuta Selatan and Ubud); sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping; mark low-confidence (single self-contradicting source).
|
||
- **DB id 197** — accept: year unresolved (source says 2025; 2024 unsupported) — find a second source; money_wanted → 6 BTC (~$400,000), coin_type BTC; kidnappings → 1 (barged into the hotel room, held until the transfer).
|
||
- **DB id 197** — addendum: sequence Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (the gang barged into the room he was in, so the hotel room is treated as the victim's private space); venue_of_control → victim's private space.
|
||
- **DB id 196** — drugs_alcohol stays 1 (owner keeps the drugging); notes → watch, phone and wallet taken, card and crypto drained afterwards with the phone (no cash); money_wanted → ~300,000 USD; weapons → 1; kidnappings stays 1; sequence Malicious Invitation → Armed Robbery in Public Space.
|
||
- **DB id 195** — keep the case; kidnappings → 0 (no person held); description → dog theft alleged, sourced to screenshots posted on X; scenario: none of the eleven fits (doxing / online retaliation, pet as leverage unverified).
|
||
- **DB id 194** — accept: weapons → 1 (hammer and knife); money_wanted → 500,000 USDT demanded, 250,000 USDT transferred, coin_type USDT; scenario → Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (held in a third party's hotel room), prior acquaintance = yes (the suspect's earlier P2P purchases from him); date 8 November is by inference only.
|
||
- **DB id 193** — accept: violence_torture → unconfirmed (found uninjured); amount stays $1 million ransom, note $3.6 million total cost to the company; coin_type stays empty (paid electronically, form unstated); reports → second article is The Logic, not CBC.
|
||
- **DB id 190** — accept: weapons → 1; location → Chicago (held in Forest Park and a second house); coin_type → BTC/ETH; $15M is the amount transferred, no demanded sum on file; sequence Home Invasion → Kidnapping; ruse attribute (garage-damage pretext).
|
||
- **DB id 189** — accept: description → confronted by two men and assaulted by one of them (not 'punched by attackers'); coin_type → USDT (the trade), S$32,000 cash is the sum at risk; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Dodged Attack.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 04 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-04.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-04.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 186** — accept: date → 13 August 2024 (Tuesday night before the 16 August report); location → Pathum Thani (golf-course house, Muang district); coin_type stays unspecified crypto.
|
||
- **DB id 185** — accept: drop the security guard and '10+ BTC' (loss $700,000 in bitcoin per Teletica); victim → eleven Israelis (residence unclear); date approximate (report of 8 August gives none); kidnappings → 1 (gagged, moved from place to place); weapons → unconfirmed; sequence Authority Misuse → Armed Robbery in Public Space (attackers wore what appear to be police uniforms); insider leak suspected.
|
||
- **DB id 184** — victim → 'Crypto billionaire' (name removed at the victim's request); remove the name from the summary and the dossier file name when the record is updated.
|
||
- **DB id 184** — venue → stairwell of his own apartment building in Tallinn (not a rental home; the rented property was the sauna house he was to be taken to). Other points (day in July unsupported, 30 BTC Telegram demand for money_wanted, weapons unconfirmed, Tallinn spelling) left as proposals.
|
||
- **DB id 183** — accept: kidnappings → 1; money_wanted → 3 BTC (~$170,000), coin_type BTC; date unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate); location → Kyiv, Solomianskyi district, held in Kyiv region; weapons → unconfirmed (beating and strangling only).
|
||
- **DB id 182** — accept: kidnappings → 1, weapons → 1, theft → 1; money_wanted → Rs 16,02,510 in USDT (drop the unsourced $18,000 or mark it a conversion), coin_type USDT; location → Pune (Bavdhan, driven to Shikrapur); sequence Malicious Invitation → Express Kidnapping.
|
||
- **DB id 181** — accept: kidnappings → 1, violence_torture → 1, weapons → 1 (stun gun), theft → 1; venue → Phra Khanong, Khlong Toei, Bangkok; money_wanted → ~3 million baht in valuables (phones, watches, card, cash), no crypto taken; sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping.
|
||
- **DB id 180** — accept: one victim, six charged (gang of 18); money_wanted → 1,007,696 USDT, coin_type USDT; drop 'shootout with police' (four gang members shot dead 3 August in separate encounters, noted as related); location → KL–Putrajaya expressway exit; kidnappings → 1; theft → unconfirmed; life_taken stays 0 (separate encounters).
|
||
- **DB id 179** — accept: date → 10 July 2024 (related incidents 4 June and 17 July); money_wanted → 10,000 EUR demanded on 10 July, 12,500 EUR total taken over the series; attackers → two on 10 July, three convicted incl. the victim's friend; violence_torture → threat only; coin unspecified. Repeat victimisation + prior acquaintance = yes.
|
||
- **DB id 178** — accept: money_wanted stays HK$5 million, note US$660,000 USDT (HKFP), coin_type USDT; location → Tseung Kwan O.
|
||
- **DB id 176** — accept: location → King Albert Park, Singapore (residential unit); scenario → Home Invasion, venue = victim's private space (the residential unit; owner strikes 'venue uncertain'); money_wanted → SGD 4.34M (~USD 3.19M) in currency, crypto and watches; weapons stays 1.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 05 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-05.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-05.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 175** — accept: description keeps ฿1.8m (headline and charge), money_wanted notes the body's ฿112m estimate; date 15 March = complaint date, robbery date unstated; attackers → one arrested, six alleged by the victim; label Mugging kept as closest, gap noted (targeted, no weapon, no holding).
|
||
- **DB id 174** — accept: violence_torture → 1 (facial injuries); attackers → four arrested, others possibly involved; amount → nearly $25,000 in crypto, credit cards and goods; outcome unknown (article does not say how they got free).
|
||
- **DB id 173** — accept: date → March 2024 (earliest of a March–December 2024 series, series noted); amount → more than $300,000 ($200k was the bond); scenario → Malicious Invitation / Social Engineering. Attacker stays 'fake Uber driver': NBC says he pretended to be an Uber driver and picked up customers who had ordered a real ride outside a hotel; he asked for the phone 'to connect to the Uber app'.
|
||
- **DB id 173** — addendum: scenario stays Authority Misuse — owner rules that authority is not only police; a driver's position used to obtain the phone is misuse of a position of trust (clarification added to DEFINITIONS.md).
|
||
- **DB id 172** — accept: amount → US$901,200 (~31M baht); date → 29 January 2024 (Monday before the 2 Feb report); location → Phuket, Muang district, both scene accounts noted; weapons → 1 (knives, tape, rope recovered from the gang's second vehicle); label Kidnapping kept per the charge, Express Kidnapping noted as the closer pattern.
|
||
|
||
- **General ruling 2026-09-30 (Authority Misuse)** — authority is not only police: a claimed worker, driver, delivery or uniformed role used to gain access or compliance is Authority Misuse as the initiation label. Applied to cases [19, 44, 109, 118, 136, 150, 164, 184, 196, 229, 248, 334, 360, 370, 371, 402, 403, 413, 423, 424, 426, 429, 438, 442, 444, 447, 448, 451, 479] (sequence prefixed with Authority Misuse). Reference: DEFINITIONS.md.
|
||
- **DB id 171** — accept: cut 'doused in diesel' and 'force-fed alcohol' (not in the article; the alcohol reading is his own drink-driving); theft → gave up the access code on his own account, no transfer reported (theft unconfirmed); mark the case DISPUTED (police found nothing on cameras); amount → 950,000 lei (~$200,000); kidnappings → 1 and violence_torture → 1 with the hedge (severed finger seen by police).
|
||
- **DB id 170** — status stays 'police intervened' (swift action = intervention; owner reading); drugs_alcohol stays 1 (drugs used as leverage: threat to plant them); money_wanted → 15 million RUB (~$166,000) demanded of the brother, coin_type empty; weapons → 0.
|
||
- **DB id 169** — accept: kidnappings → 1, violence_torture → 1, weapons → 1; money_wanted stays the campaign total with a note. CAMPAIGN RULE: the Salford series (354, 355, 307, 162, 169) is one campaign; drugs_alcohol → 1 on every record of the series (morphine used during the campaign), each record notes the series link.
|
||
- **DB id 168** — accept: abducted off the street near his residence (apartment searched by the others); beaten and abandoned taped to a post in a field in Banks, password used later that day (not 'revealed under torture'); freed by a passer-by; all four charged.
|
||
- **DB id 167** — accept: kidnappings → 1, theft → 1; money_wanted → 12.5M USD in USDT (11.8M recovered), coin_type USDT; victim → executives of a Binance VIP client; date unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate); add CZ / Binance Support X posts as sources before green.
|
||
- **DB id 166** — accept: date unverified on file (keep 6 Nov); money_wanted empty, coin_type BTC; note the syndication chain (CryptoPotato ← Eric Wall ← LT / Aftonbladet); fetch LT and Aftonbladet as extra sources.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 06 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-06.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-06.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 164** — accept: attackers → several men, seven charged (two arrested, five in absentia); amount → up to $900,000 on site plus several million in crypto via the seized servers; kidnappings → 1 (staff and clients' movement restricted); weapons stays 1 ('supposedly' seen on footage).
|
||
- **DB id 162** — accept: location → Cadishead; weapons stays 1 as a campaign flag (machetes and pistol across the series); drugs_alcohol → 1 (campaign); money_wanted stays the campaign total.
|
||
- **DB id 161** — Ledger: The Phuket News (English-language) writes 'the location of a drive containing a ledger of cryptocurrency', which reads as the police report's description of a Ledger hardware wallet; keep 'Ledger hardware wallet (as the record has it; the article's wording is a paraphrase)'. No second source found. Remaining proposals (three Kazakh men in the villa, twins as phone organisers; resort villa not hotel room) await the owner.
|
||
- **DB id 161** — accept: attackers → three Kazakh men in the villa (fled to Dubai) plus the twins arrested as the organisers directing by phone; venue → resort villa.
|
||
- **DB id 160** — accept: violence_torture → 1 (tased and tied); coin_type → crypto (unspecified), property list moved to notes; money_wanted → $20,000 cash + $20,000 crypto.
|
||
- **DB id 158** — accept: attackers → seven suspects (no gender); time differs between ABC13 (before 5 am) and Protos (6 am); scenario → Dodged Attack, attempted theft of the Bitcoin ATM (no weapon, nobody present; infrastructure case).
|
||
- **DB id 157** — accept: violence_torture stays 1 (minor bruising per one article; 'unharmed' per another, noted); alarm raised by a friend calling from Hungary, reported in person at Benalmádena police HQ; location → Málaga province (villa in Málaga, police in Benalmádena); amount €1M.
|
||
- **DB id 156** — verified: 'posing as construction workers' confirmed by the affidavit (WRAL conviction story) and the federal complaint (NBC): reflective vests, 'check the pipes'. amount → more than $156,000 (charging documents; initial report $150,000; drop $250,000); notes → assaulted, zip-tied, threatened with mutilation and rape (not 'tortured'); sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion; arrests → convicted (St Felix 47 years; 12 sentenced in the conspiracy).
|
||
- **DB id 154** — accept: attackers → three kidnappers plus the couple who paid them; money_wanted → the $51,000 is the kidnappers' fee, move to notes (crypto taken not quantified); weapons → unconfirmed; gap: attack commissioned by aggrieved investors.
|
||
- **DB id 153** — accept: theft → 1 (jewellery, watch, chain, phones, cash; no crypto obtained); drugs_alcohol → 1 (narcotics, IPC 328); date → night of 20/21 March 2023; prior acquaintance = yes (the hosts were his friends).
|
||
- **DB id 152** — accept: kidnappings → 1, violence_torture → 1, weapons → 1; victim → associate of the intended target Tran Dinh; age 26 vs 29 across reports (note); duration six days per police; sequence Home Invasion → Kidnapping; money_wanted $5M demanded of Tran Dinh, coin_type empty; targeting vector = insider tip-off (government-agency insider); the 1 March driveway attack may need its own record.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 07 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-07.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-07.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 151** — accept: amount → $20,000 in BTC (the '1' was a footnote marker); kidnappings → 0 (unconscious, not held); the lure stands: the offer of sex is the invitation that brought her into his apartment (Malicious Invitation kept, description keeps 'lured').
|
||
- **DB id 150** — accept: add Ekateryna Khmelenko as second victim; violence_torture → 1 (beating per crypto.ro; threats per Coconuts); sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (police uniform).
|
||
- **DB id 147** — accept: foiled at the building entrance (offices not reached); victim → crypto company (target), building concierge (assaulted); kidnappings → 1 (concierge gagged and bound); violence_torture → 1 (struggle, lesiones charge); sequence Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack, attempted Armed Robbery (one posed as a client).
|
||
- **DB id 145** — traced: the description is Jameson Lopp's list entry verbatim, citing a Border Report indictment story that carries neither the hardware wallet nor $1.4m (Wayback copy now in the dossier). The hardware-wallet element is real per Bloomberg's 2026 feature (blocked; search snippets: crew led him outside to dig up his hardware wallet, he fled over the fence), but no source gives $1.4m: keep 'sought his buried hardware wallet; he escaped over the fence' and drop the $1.4m unless Bloomberg confirms it. coin_type → empty (cash and jewellery only), money_wanted $150,000 cash; targeting vector: SIM-swapped exchange accounts (account compromise); link to the crew's other records (138, 156).
|
||
- **DB id 144** — amount → $45,000 ($20,000 cash + $25,000 crypto wallet); venue unknown (only 'Soi Cherng Talay 16 at about 1am'; no home or room in any source) so Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, Home Invasion to apply only if a source places it at their residence; kidnappings stays 1 ('tied hands', Telegram).
|
||
- **DB id 143** — accept: description → responded to a Marktplaats ad to buy bitcoin; kidnappings → 1 (beaten at the address until he transferred); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery kept.
|
||
- **DB id 142** — accept: attackers → masked men, number unstated; weapons → 0; money_wanted → 250 BTC (~$17m), coin_type BTC.
|
||
- **DB id 141** — accept: ransom → a large amount of Canadian currency, unquantified; weapons → 1; date → 5 December 2022; targeting vector = business counterparty (his own investors).
|
||
- **DB id 139** — accept: scenario → Mugging (surrounded at a café table, nothing taken anywhere), gap noted; money_wanted → $3M demanded, $50,000 (1.878M baht) transferred; kidnappings → 1 (held at the table until the transfer); targeting: claimed prior acquaintance; possible link to 175 (Samui, Russians, 2024).
|
||
- **DB id 138** — accept: description is Lopp's line; Border Report and DOJ say only 'two victims held at gunpoint in their home'; theft → unconfirmed (jewellery/electronics/cash/Gemini attempt unsourced, likely from the indictment); victim → two victims; coin_type → empty; targeting vector: SIM-swapped exchange accounts; link to 145, 156 (same crew).
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 08 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-08.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-08.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 137** — accept: coin_type → empty with note 'cash brought to buy BTC' (whether it was taken is not stated; theft rests on the charge); date 12 Sept inferred, keep; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Express Kidnapping.
|
||
- **DB id 136** — accept: weapons → 1 (imitation firearm, taser, bat in the boot, charged); note both uniform accounts (police: in the boot; victim: worn at the door); status → charged, not jailed; targeting vector: rival in his own online scene (violence-as-a-service).
|
||
- **DB id 134** — accept: money_wanted → Rs 1.3 crore in BTC (drop '8 BTC', unsourced); weapons → 1 (pistol, shots fired); location → Lucknow (held at a house in Barabanki); sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping.
|
||
- **DB id 133** — accept: date → 7 August 2022; description → two men waiting inside (entered from the back), beaten, zip-tied to a chair, tasered, no knife; violence_torture → 1; loss → iPhone 13 and two gold bracelets, no bitcoin; replace the bits.media link with Giornale di Brescia (plus Il Giorno, BresciaToday); targeting vector = former collaborator with a pay grievance (business counterparty / insider); one arrested, instigator at large.
|
||
- **DB id 130** — accept: attackers → son of the former Mitsubishi Electric CEO plus seven; amount $0.75M (100 million yen per Bunshun); location → Osaka (gym), holding place unknown, arrests by Kyoto police; targeting vector = insider tip-off (gym operator).
|
||
- **DB id 128** — accept: kidnappings stays 1 (owner: six men entering and beating him in his own home is detention; nobody admits attackers willingly); date 1 May unsupported on file (keep); coin_type → empty, money_wanted → watches, ring (Dh390,000 / $200,000) and cash; five arrested, one at large, six sentenced; targeting vector = business counterparty (his investors).
|
||
- **DB id 126** — accept: weapons → 1 (armed robbery per SVT); date unverifiable on file (keep); both tied and beaten, only the man forced to transfer; follow-up in Swedish reporting pending.
|
||
- **DB id 124** — accept: kidnappings → 0 (already ruled); weapons → 1; date → March 2022, day unknown; description → three men, 'armed' resting on the ABC quote; victim name is Krebs's inference; targeting vector = rival (Iza) hiring men; the November 2021 LASD-deputies attempt deserves its own record (Authority Misuse).
|
||
- **DB id 123** — accept: attackers → one gunman plus a female accomplice driving a BMW; case kept (crypto link = occupation; watch was the target); targeting vector = public profile / surveillance; outcome note: victim shot five times, survived.
|
||
- **DB id 122** — keep as Authority Misuse; date → December 2021 (precision month; original_date 'nearly three months before the 4 March 2022 report'); notes → 'not paid, as far as reported: he reported her and the article states no transfer' (comment, not a sourced fact); no physical element, kept as the pure extortion-by-authority case.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 09 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-09.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-09.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 121** — accept: amount → ~$1M total per the victim (watch ~$400K; crypto unquantified, transfer unconfirmed: the phone with the wallet app was taken); kidnappings → 1 (gun to his face, ordered to the ground: not there voluntarily); targeting vector = surveillance of his address.
|
||
- **DB id 118** — accept: violence_torture 1 stands firmly (kicked in the face), drop the note's hedge; amount $350,000 (captions say >$300,000); location → Brighton Beach, Brooklyn; sequence Authority Misuse → Home Invasion (package ruse); no crypto taken.
|
||
- **DB id 117** — accept: date → 4 February 2022 (day after the 3 Feb drive to Surat); amount → Rs 2 crore in cash brought to the trade (~$260K conversion); attackers → nine or more (Jha plus around eight); violence_torture → 1; weapons → unconfirmed (dacoity, no weapon described); sequence Malicious Invitation → P2P Trade Gone Wrong; targeting vector = acquaintance.
|
||
- **DB id 116** — accept: date → 14 January 2022 (2 February is the arrests report); location → Pimpri Chinchwad, Pune (victim of Tathawade; hotel not located); amount → bitcoin worth Rs 300 crore, the police value of his holdings (drop the $50M, the record's own conversion); weapons → unconfirmed (none mentioned); theft → unconfirmed (released for fear of arrest, no transfer reported); sequence Kidnapping kept, Authority Misuse not applied; targeting vector = insider (constable in the Pune cybercrime cell).
|
||
- **DB id 114** — accept: traced; the record's date (26 January 2022) and description (insurance ruse, pushed out, locked the door, video) hold per freelanceinfos.fr of 27 January 2022 (https://freelanceinfos.fr/hasheur-agresse-domicile-cryptomonnaies/), TF1's 'two years ago' is loose; add freelanceinfos as a source and rewrite the summary from it (pending: pull the page into the dossier, checker pass); weapons stays 1 with note 'reported fake' (fibo-crypto timeline, on file under 473); violence_torture stays 0; sequence Costly Fame → Dodged Attack, attempted: Authority Misuse (insurance ruse at the door) and armed extortion at the victim's home.
|
||
- **DB id 113** — accept: date → Friday 14 January 2022 (inferred: HLN's report of Thursday 20 January places the arrests at the house on 'Friday morning' and a fourth arrest 'on Wednesday'; the date itself is not printed); victim → 34-year-old man and his 61-year-old mother (visiting); add the companion HLN article as a source for 'teacher' (https://www.hln.be/antwerpen/leraar-34-en-moeder-thuis-overvallen-en-mishandeld-daders-willen-codes-van-kluis-met-3-miljoen-euro-aan-bitcoins~ab232aa8/; pending: pull into the dossier); scenario and flags unchanged; outcome foiled, both victims hospitalised.
|
||
- **DB id 111** — accept: location → Lahore; amount → 20 million rupees demanded, 2.5 million rupees paid in bitcoin (about 9 BTC per CCN); description: replace "Over 60 BTC" (CCN sub-headline, does not match the body) with the body figures, 60 BTC logged as unresolved; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (official green plate, three police officials in the ransom); arrests → some (three police officials and two exchangers; Faisal Yousuf named, no arrest stated); outcome empty (release not reported); flags unchanged.
|
||
- **DB id 110** — accept: theft → unconfirmed (the release says the victims were "allegedly forced to make phone calls to transfer crypto currency"; no completed transfer stated; charge is Extortion); description → add "allegedly", "cells" plural; sequence Kidnapping kept (forced into cells and held about 30 hours; Kidnapping and Forcible Confinement both charged); whose cells they were is not stated, venue → cells in the same jail, ownership not stated (owner's reading: taken by force from where they were housed and held elsewhere in the jail); attackers are "11 inmates at the Thunder Bay District jail", victims are "two male victims" in a reported "inmate-on-inmate assault"; other flags unchanged; outcome: separated by correctional officers, all 11 charged.
|
||
- **DB id 108** — accept: attackers → four (Nicola, a former employee, and Gregory arrested; one Polish and one Russian man wanted); amount → Rp 5.8 billion, drop the $400k (no dollar figure in the source; CNN Indonesia uses Rp 5.8 billion both for the total loss including cash and for the crypto transfers, logged as unresolved); date kept at 11 December 2021 with the conflict logged ("Kamis (11/12)" in the Indonesian text, but 11 December 2021 was a Saturday; the English rendering reads "(12/11)"); sequence Home Invasion kept; flags unchanged; targeting vector = insider (former employee); held duration not stated.
|
||
- **DB id 112** — parked: waits on the disputed-scenarios decision (see the unlabelled cases section below and `disputed-scenarios.md`).
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Unlabelled cases — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
- **DB ids 399, 409, 468, 11** — keep in the database (owner). They have no scenario only for lack of evidence on file; the label for each is still to be set.
|
||
- **19 disputed cases** (3, 6, 10, 57, 62, 66, 101, 105, 112, 198; 21, 349; 99, 383, 449, 450; 24, 45, 195) — pending: owner consulting colleagues on removal versus a new category. See `disputed-scenarios.md`. Case 112 of batch 09 waits on this.
|
||
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Batch 10 decisions — owner, 2026-09-30
|
||
|
||
Taken case by case from `batches/contradictions-10.md`; evidence in `batches/batch-10.json`.
|
||
- **DB id 106** — accept: description → a van with several armed LASD deputies arrived and tried to force E.Z. to hand over his phone; he escaped unharmed and called 911 (November 2021, per the federal complaint as reported); sequence Authority Misuse → Dodged Attack, attempted forcible seizure of his phone; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 0, weapons 1, theft 0); victim → "E.Z." (identified by the Los Angeles Times as Enzo Zelocchi through court records and interviews); reports → LA Times and KrebsOnSecurity (Article 2 is the Krebs piece, not LA Times); link to 124 (same victim, same instigator Adam Iza, second attempt in March 2022). This is the November 2021 incident the 124 ruling asked to have its own record; no new record needed. Possible further records from the same articles, undecided: R.C. (August 2021, $25,000), L.A. (October 2022, $127,000), D.D. (December 2021 badge visit).
|
||
- **DB id 124** — amendment: the victim's identification as Enzo Zelocchi is sourced to the Los Angeles Times (on file under 106), replacing 'Krebs's inference'.
|
||
- **DB id 105** — parked: on the disputed-scenarios list (`disputed-scenarios.md`).
|
||
- **DB id 104** — accept: violence_torture → 1 (beaten with hammers, leg fractures requiring hospital treatment, per SCMP's source); theft → unconfirmed (forced to reveal bank and crypto passwords; police: "We believe he suffered a loss ... We are still investigating"); location → Kowloon Bay industrial unit (lure), then a container yard, then a village house in Tai Po; amount HK$30 million kept (raised from HK$8 million), add the HK$4 million Tether trade as the lure; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Kidnapping (trade lure, as ruled in 117); Costly Fame not applied, targeting vector = displayed wealth (supercar and watches, per a police source); outcome rescued (climbed out of a window as police raided on the sixth day); seven arrested, about eight sought.
|
||
- **DB id 103** — accept: description → attackers tortured him for access to a wallet holding 500 BTC and failed to open it (a joint action with his manager was needed); remove 'take tens of millions of euros in bitcoin'; theft → 1 (five Rolex watches valued at 68,400 euros and two bank cards); money_wanted → 500 BTC (25 million euros per the sentencing report), none obtained; coin_type → BTC; add the maintenance technician as second victim (struck, pepper-sprayed, tied to a chair, held nearly four hours); sequence: Malicious Invitation → Home Invasion (posed as a friend of a friend to arrange a meeting at his home); other flags unchanged; four men sentenced to nine years after a plea deal (each or in total not stated); pending: find and link the URL of the sentencing report (sheet credits 'El Pais, Iustel', no URL), the only source for the weapons, the 500 BTC, the Rolexes and the technician.
|
||
- **DB id 102** — accept: description → at least five people came to steal the mining machines; the miners opened fire to stop them and one miner (Pachial R.G., in custody) shot his own friend dead at close range, per the prosecutor's statement; location → village of Aatsy, Abkhazia; victim Ardzibna kept, variant spelling Ardzinba noted; violence_torture stays 1 (owner: a man shot dead counts, as the fatal stabbing in 215); other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 1); sequence Armed Robbery in Public Space kept, attempted theft of mining equipment, gap: the death came from a defender's gun; arrests: none of the raiders reported; kept in the database regardless of the disputed-scenarios decision on 21 and 349 (people present, one death).
|
||
- **DB ids 101, 99** — parked: on the disputed-scenarios list (`disputed-scenarios.md`).
|
||
- **DB id 97** — accept, with the owner's ruling on the death: stabbed and drowned (owner). Source basis: stabbed more than twenty times, no blow fatal in itself, 'agonizing when thrown into the pond'; the article states no cause of death, so the summary keeps the article's wording and the notes carry 'stabbed and drowned' as the owner's reading. Attackers → five suspects, four men and one woman (the lover is a 33-year-old man; his twin brother and the brother's female companion charged with complicity); theft → unconfirmed (the five 'dreamed of stealing' the 200,000 euros; no loss reported), money_wanted 200,000 EUR kept as the sum targeted; drugs_alcohol stays 1, alleged (three suspects' account, toxicology pending); location → lured to a home in Plancher-les-Mines, body found in a pond in Plancher-Bas; sequence Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping (lured to the attackers' premises), gap: holding and transport not described; other flags unchanged; targeting vector = intimate partner; all five in custody.
|
||
- **DB id 96** — accept: violence_torture → 1 (hit by at least four bullets; consistent with 102 and 215); add the second victim, a passenger injured and taken to hospital; date 8 August 2021 kept, unverified (CryptoNews gives no date for the killing); description keeps the hedge (the social-media link is the outlet's argument, no police statement); sequence Costly Fame kept, resting on that hedge; other flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, weapons 1, theft 0, life_taken 1); arrests none reported; kept in the database, flagged 'motive not established' (nothing demanded, nothing taken).
|
||
- **DB id 94** — accept: amount → about HK$3.29 million in cash (the bag's contents per SCMP), kept in Hong Kong dollars; the article's '(US$128,500)' does not match HK$3 million at the peg (roughly US$385,000) and is not used; date 28 July 2021 kept (the article says 'Wednesday'; 28 July 2021 was a Wednesday); victim → 39-year-old South Korean trader; location → Astoria Building, Ashley Road, Tsim Sha Tsui; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong → Armed Robbery in Public Space; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, weapons 1, theft 1); coin_type stays fiat (cash brought to the trade); no arrests.
|