Archived
11 KiB
11 KiB
Batch 16 decisions — DA triage, 2026-10-01
Cases 39, 38, 35, 34, 33, 32, 30, 29, 28, 27. Evidence in batches/contradictions-16.md, batches/batch-16.json and sources/. Rules in batches/DECISION-RULES.md.
Approved (DA)
- DB id 39 (DA) — description → robbed of $365,000 in cash brought to buy bitcoin, no crypto taken (Straits Times: "robbed of $365,000 in cash instead"); the currency of the $365,000 is not stated, so no conversion; weapons → 0 (no weapon in either report; the charge is robbery with hurt); victim → Pang Joon Hau, plus the Singaporean broker he brought, also assaulted and not named; attackers → two men charged with robbery with hurt, Mohd Abdul Rahman Mohamad (Cointelegraph spells it Mohama) and Syed Mokhtar Syed Yusope, and Abdul Rahman's former wife charged with receiving stolen property; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (cash only); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown (a claimed seller and a claimed broker arranged the meeting; how they found him is not stated); arrests → both men arrested 9 and 10 April and charged; two reports on file (Cointelegraph and a Straits Times court report), the second report's list of the accused's earlier unrelated offences not used.
- DB id 35 (DA) — money_wanted → about 100 BTC (approximately $1,020,000 at Cointelegraph's press time), coin_type → BTC; description keeps the double hedge (Cointelegraph relaying Forklog, "local sources report"); date 23 February 2018 kept (Cointelegraph: "today, Feb. 23"); sequence Assault - Mugging kept, gap: the file says nothing about planning either way; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0); targeting vector = unknown; no arrests; single source; the closing paragraphs on the St Petersburg blogger (25), the Forklog raid and Pavel Lerner (22) not used.
- DB id 34 (DA) — date → 23 February 2018, about 10 pm (Forklog via Cointelegraph; the record's 26 February is the Forklog publication date); weapons → 0 (no weapon anywhere in the report; four men, a car and a beating); money_wanted → 300 BTC (a little over $3 million per Cointelegraph), $20,000 in cash and three iPhones, plus the laptop giving access to the wallet; coin_type → BTC; sequence was Kidnapping; now Express Kidnapping (seized on Isakovskogo Street, beaten while driven around the city in a Mercedes, released the same night; no holding place described; rule of 2026-10-01: the sources do not say how he was chosen, so Express is the default and the gap is noted; he is named as the creator of PRIZM, and a source showing pre-selection would move him to Kidnapping); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 1 for the pill forced down with vodka before release, per Mash via Cointelegraph, theft 1, life_taken 0); no arrests; the account rests on Mayorov's own allegations relayed by Forklog and Mash; the article's closing paragraphs on other cases not used.
- DB id 30 (DA) — description → drop "armed" (no weapon in the report; the men carried zip ties, latex gloves, duct tape and bandanas and were charged with residential strong arm robbery): five men arrested over a planned robbery of a Forsyth County homeowner said to hold nearly $1 million in Bitcoin; date 29 January 2018 kept (night of the hotel contact; arrests ran from 30 January to 11 May 2018); attackers → five: Trivette Adams, Robert South (the narrative says Jacob South), Matthew Schwartz, Michael McDermott (the narrative says McDermont), Justin Ellison; money_wanted → nearly $1 million in Bitcoin as the target, no demand made; coin_type → BTC; sequence Dodged Attack kept, attempted: a break-in at the home to steal the Bitcoin (foiled before any contact, as ruled in 84 and 147); flags unchanged (all 0); arrests → all five charged and held without bond; single source (11Alive), victim not named.
- DB id 29 (DA) — date → 22 January 2018 (Business Insider: "on January 22"; the Telegraph of Sunday 28 January: police called "at around 9.40am on Monday"); kidnappings → 1 (door kicked down, a woman tied up, the occupants threatened with what appeared to be a firearm while a transfer was demanded; clarification 1); weapons → 1 (police: "with what appeared to be a firearm", hedge kept); victim → Danny Aston and Amy Jay, noting a third occupant: police say "the two men and a woman" were inside, and the man struck on the head was treated at John Radcliffe Hospital and discharged; money_wanted → an unknown quantity of bitcoin, coin_type → BTC; theft 0 kept (police: "the attempted transaction of bitcoins failed", "Nothing was stolen"); sequence Home Invasion kept (control of the house was taken; the transfer failed technically, so not a dodged attack); other flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0); notes → baby kept outside in a pram (Mail on Sunday via the Telegraph); targeting vector = unknown (police: "may be a targeted incident"); no arrests; two reports on file (Telegraph, Business Insider).
- DB id 28 (DA) — victim → "Canadian Bitcoins" removed: neither report names the business ("The authorities have not revealed the name of the cryptocurrency exchange"); victim → five employees of a Bitcoin business on Concourse Gate, Ottawa, name not revealed; kidnappings → 1 (three men "gained control over four employees and bound them"; five counts of forcible confinement; clarification 2); attackers → three armed with handguns: a 19-year-old from Ottawa arrested (named by The Hacker News as Jimmy St-Hilaire), two still sought; sequence was Armed Robbery in Public Space; now Armed Robbery in Public Space → Dodged Attack, attempted: an outbound crypto transaction forced on the bound staff (a hidden fifth employee called police and the suspects fled empty-handed; as ruled in 84 and 147); date 23 January 2018 kept (the Tuesday before the 24 January police release); flags unchanged (violence_torture 1, an employee struck on the head with a gun and taken to hospital; weapons 1; theft 0; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); money_wanted and coin_type stay empty (no amount or coin named); two reports on file (CBC, The Hacker News), the Hacker News closing paragraphs on EXMO and Louis Meza not used.
- DB id 27 (DA) — violence_torture → 1 (pushed to the floor; minor hand and leg injuries, bandaged at the scene; same reading as 89); location → King's Road, North Point (the lure began at the Starbucks on Hennessy Road, Wan Chai); attackers → five sought: two who posed as sellers and three masked men who attacked; money_wanted → HK$1.4 million in cash (US$180,000 per SCMP) plus a mobile phone, kept in Hong Kong dollars; coin_type → cash (HKD), the lure being five bitcoin at a five per cent discount; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, attacked from behind and the bag snatched; weapons 0, "Police said no weapon was used"; theft 1; drugs_alcohol 0; life_taken 0); targeting vector = online lure (contacted through WeChat); no arrests; single source (SCMP), promotional headlines in the fetched copy not used.
Needs owner decision
DB id 38 (owner) — two bear-spray robberies of Bitcoin ATMs inside petrol-station shops, Irving (22 March 2018) and Mesquite (28 March 2018), held in one record.
- Settled (DA): drugs_alcohol → 0 (bear spray is a weapon, not a drug); weapons → 1 (bear spray and a crowbar, Fox 4; as in 84 and 160); violence_torture 1, kidnappings 0, theft 1 (cash cassettes, amount not disclosed) kept; money_wanted and coin_type stay empty; no arrests.
- Q1: split into two records? For: two businesses in two cities six days apart ("Six days later, a similar robbery took place at the Exxon"). Against: same pair, one Fox 4 story. DA recommends split (Irving 22 March, Mesquite 28 March).
- Q2: the target was ATM cash and the victims were clerks. Group A of
disputed-scenarios.md(crypto ATM thefts) is pending. For keeping it as Armed Robbery in Public Space: the clerks were present and sprayed, the same reasoning that kept 84 in. DA recommends keep and include it when the group A decision is made.
DB id 33 (owner) — three men posing as bitcoin buyers lured trader Tai to Taichung, assaulted him and his friend, moved 18 BTC (NT$5 million) off his phone and forced Kaoliang liquor on him.
- Settled (DA): violence_torture → 1 ("assaulted him and his friend"; "bloodstains at the scene"); weapons → 0 (none in either report); money_wanted → 18 BTC (NT$5 million), coin_type → BTC; date → February 2018, day unknown (the report says "earlier this month" and puts Britain's first bitcoin armed robbery "last month"; 21 February is not printed); attackers → three at the scene plus Shih, the alleged mastermind, detained later; friend added as second victim; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; drugs_alcohol 1 kept; all four detained.
- Q: detention. For 1: the attackers kept control through the assault, the transfer from his phone and the forced drinking (139: held at the table until the transfer = 1). For 0: no restraint, holding or place is described. DA recommends 1.
DB id 32 (owner) — Gujarat police officers and a CBI officer summoned Surat builder Shailesh Bhatt, beat him, held him at a farmhouse at gunpoint and extorted bitcoin; 14 convicted, 11 of them police.
- Settled (DA): sequence was Authority Misuse; now Authority Misuse → Kidnapping (held at Keshav Farms by the officers; as 111 and 93); location → Gandhinagar, Gujarat (CBI office, fuel station, Keshav Farms), the officers from Amreli district; attackers → FIR against ten police incl. Amreli SP Jagdish Patel and inspector Anant Patel, plus Sunil Nair, Kirit Paladiya and ex-MLA Nalin Kotadiya; 14 sentenced to life; notes → "the only one who knew" becomes Paladiya "knew about my investment" (Bhatt's allegation), and "accused of kidnapping two others earlier that same year" becomes accused of kidnapping two BitConnect promoters after the BitConnect collapse, undated, arrested 13 August 2024 (separate incident); targeting vector = business counterparty (former partner, per Bhatt); flags unchanged.
- Q: which amount does the record carry? India Today (Bhatt's 2018 allegation): Rs 13 crore in bitcoin (200 BTC) to Paladiya's account plus Rs 5 crore cash via hawala; the CID said the bitcoin payment was not confirmed. The Block (trial): 176 BTC plus Rs 32 crore demanded, 34 BTC sold and about $150,000 transferred, cash delivery fell through. DA recommends the trial figures as money_wanted, Bhatt's figures in notes as his allegation, and "200 BTC" dropped from the description; theft 1 stays either way.