This repository has been archived on 2026-10-19. You can view files and clone it. You cannot open issues or pull requests or push a commit.
Files
DB-cleanup/merge-output/batches/decisions-18.md
T

11 KiB

Batch 18 decisions — 2026-10-01

Triage of batches/contradictions-18.md under batches/DECISION-RULES.md; evidence in batches/batch-18.json and the dossiers in sources/. Cases 10 and 6 are on the disputed-scenarios list and parked.

Approved (DA)

  • DB id 14 (DA) — date → 18 June 2017 (Tokyo Reporter: she disappeared after the 18 June seminar in Kasugai and police believe she was killed shortly after boarding the vehicle that night; the record's 17 June is in no source); location → last seen boarding Nishida's vehicle at JR Ogaki Station, Gifu; body found buried in a forest in Taga, Shiga; victim a Nagoya resident, seminar in Kasugai City, Aichi; description → "Woman strangled, attacker takes 100,000 yen worth of BTC" becomes: killed by pressure to the neck (autopsy), body buried around 20 June; in early July Nishida is believed to have posed as her online to obtain her bitcoin, valued at more than 100,000 yen; her smartphone and bag were found in his vehicle and residence; kidnappings → unconfirmed (she boarded the vehicle after saying she was going to meet an acquaintance; no source describes her being held); violence_torture → 1 (fatal pressure to the neck; a killing counts, as in 215, 102, 96); sequence Malicious Invitation - SocialEng kept, gap: the pretext used is not described and the crypto was taken online after her death; flags unchanged (drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 1); attackers → Ichiya Nishida, 20, and an unnamed 18-year-old from Shiga; targeting vector = acquaintance (met at a virtual-currency seminar); arrests: both arrested and prosecuted for abandoning the body, then charged with murder and robbery, no verdict on file; sources are three Tokyo Reporter items (citing TBS, Nikkan Sports, Chunichi Shimbun).
  • DB id 13 (DA) — attackers → three Emirati men (aged 19, 27 and 20) charged with kidnap, impersonation and online misappropriation, plus four Indian accomplices (21 to 47) accused of possessing Dh250,000 of apparently ill-gotten money; money_wanted → 25 BTC, moved with the victims' own laptop to the 27-year-old defendant's account in Japan; coin_type → BTC; money and mobile phones also taken (unquantified); description keeps both accounts of the approach (prosecution: conned into riding in the attackers' car after being told they were wanted by the authorities; a victim: "a car intercepted them after 10pm. The suspects pulled us out of the car"), then taken to a remote desert spot off Al Barsha; sequence Authority Misuse → Kidnapping kept (claimed authority, then held at a remote outdoor spot; victims pre-selected through the recruited driver, so Kidnapping under the 2026-10-01 rule); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); held duration and how the night ended not stated; targeting vector = insider tip-off (the trader's Yemeni driver, recruited by the 19-year-old posing as a security official, reported his movements); arrests: all three charged, trial continuing 13 December, no verdict on file; one source (Khaleej Times).
  • DB id 9 (DA) — date 14 August 2016 unsupported on file (keep, mark approximate; the article dates only the first robbery, to February with no year, and the arrests to an unnamed Friday); notes → "5 to 6 teenagers stabbed people" becomes: three teenage boys (16 and 17) arrested in connection with three robberies, two to three other teen suspects sought; one stabbing reported, of the victim of the first robbery in February (stabbed twice, hospital, non-life-threatening); series noted (one record for three robberies, as with 173 and 179); weapons → 1 (stabbed twice, so a blade was used; the report names no weapon); loss → cash and other property, no crypto (the suspects offered bitcoins they did not have), amount not stated; sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; flags unchanged (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); location → north Scarborough, Toronto; targeting vector = online lure (the suspects answered the victims' Kijiji ads offering cash for bitcoin and arranged meetings by email and text); arrests: three; one source (Toronto.com).
  • DB id 7 (DA) — money_wanted → 52 BTC (104,000 euros) he was pressed to transfer; when the attackers could not get his login details they demanded 300,000 euros; coin_type → BTC; property taken → a rucksack (Lithuanian "kuprinę", not "a safe") holding a phone, computer, cash, documents and payment cards, plus a wristwatch worth 10,000 euros and a gold bracelet of similar value, total damage nearly 27,000 euros (kept in notes, separate from money_wanted); location → near a car wash (Lithuanian "automobilių plovykla", not "service station") on Kaunakiemio Street, Kaunas; date 11 July kept (the article prints no year; 2016 rests on the record); violence_torture stays 0 (pushed into the van and hands restrained, threats to gouge out his eyes, impale his children and burn his car, no blow or injury reported; same reading as 207); sequence was Kidnapping in the record and batch file; now Express Kidnapping (owner ruling 2026-10-01: 7 stays Express Kidnapping, the sources do not say how he was chosen, gap noted; already in scenario-sequences.json); flags unchanged (kidnappings 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 1, life_taken 0); outcome not stated; arrests: four detained (E. J., R. G., M. Š., Š. P.), pre-trial custody of one month for three and 15 days for Š. P.; the article's background on his alleged bitcoin frauds is not part of this attack; one source (Kauno diena, Lithuanian original preferred over the sheet's English rendering).
  • DB id 10 — parked: disputed-scenarios list
  • DB id 6 — parked: disputed-scenarios list

Needs owner decision

DB id 15 (owner) — Kyiv, Santa Muerte club, 4 September 2017

TL;DR: crypto consultant lured by a fake investor to a second meeting, held about three hours in a room of the club and beaten for 10-12 BTC; escaped by getting an SOS sent from his phone. Settled (DA): victim → Alexey Sherstnev (record drops the final "v"); weapons → 0 (no weapon anywhere in the report: "Three strong men. They beat and threatened to kill him", as with 142 and 204); theft → 1 (his phone was taken during the beating, not reported returned; no crypto moved, as with 153); money_wanted 10-12 BTC kept (about $44,000 in the body, nearly $50,000 in the headline); description → "held about three hours and beaten for a 10-12 BTC transfer that was never made" in place of "tortured for $50k"; flags kidnappings 1, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, life_taken 0 unchanged; no arrest reported; single source, the victim's own Facebook post relayed by Oboz; targeting vector = lure through a fake consultation client (channel of first contact not stated). Question: does the hold make this Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping? For: 194 (lured, held in a third party's hotel room) was ruled Kidnapping, and the Russian text says he was grabbed "при попытке покинуть комнату" (trying to leave the room) and held "в баре" for about three hours. Against: the club is not stated to be the attackers', he arrived of his own accord, and 139 (held at a café table) was not made Kidnapping. DA recommendation: Malicious Invitation → Kidnapping per 194, venue = third-party room, ownership of the club not stated.

DB id 12 (owner) — Florianópolis, wife of Rocelo Lopes (CoinBR), 2017

TL;DR: holder's wife seized in the street near home, taken to a house in Cangaíba, São Paulo, freed by police on the Saturday; no ransom paid. Settled (DA): sequence Kidnapping kept; flags kidnappings 1, violence_torture 0 ("did not suffer any physical aggression"), drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 0, theft 0 unchanged; victim unnamed in every source; record note "corrupted banker sold him out" appears in no source on file (drop unless sourced); targeting: handpicked after at least nine months of planning (delegate Anselmo Cruz), route not stated. Question 1, life_taken: Business Insider (2022 round-up) says police freed her and arrested "many of the conspirators, killing one in the process"; the Brazilian account and CCN say one man arrested (a caretaker) and report no death. DA recommendation: keep 0, note Business Insider's claim as unconfirmed by the contemporary reports. Question 2, date, ransom and coin: Brazilian text "last Thursday (26)" and "last Saturday (29)"; CCN "on Wednesday" with the daughter's birthday "Saturday, the 29th"; Business Insider "April 2017"; Bitcoin World Tour URL dated 2017/05/11. Ransom R$115m cut to R$5m in Zcash and Monero (Folha via the sheet) versus $40m to $2m in the same coins (BI) versus bitcoin plus an unnamed coin (CCN). DA recommendation: date → April 2017, seized on the Wednesday or Thursday before Saturday 29 April, record's 26 February matches no source; money_wanted → R$115 million demanded, reduced to R$5 million, unpaid; coin_type → Zcash and Monero (two sources), CCN's bitcoin noted.

DB id 11 (owner) — London, "Josoj", 16 February 2017

TL;DR: record-only case; the sole source is an untranscribed Bitcoin Uncensored podcast (go.ivoox.com/rf/17187103) said to carry the victim's and the robber's accounts. Settled (DA): kept in the database by owner ruling of 2026-09-30; all six flags (kidnappings 0, violence_torture 1, drugs_alcohol 0, weapons 1, theft 1, life_taken 0) marked unverified, nothing on file to test them; money_wanted and coin_type not stated. Question: which label to set. The record's own description ("robbery during Localbitcoins trade") supports P2P Trade Gone Wrong and nothing else. DA recommendation: set P2P Trade Gone Wrong as provisional, resting on the record's description only, and transcribe the podcast before marking the case verified.

DB id 8 (owner) — West Palm Beach, Steve Manos, July 2016

TL;DR: cash-for-bitcoin deal with two men he had traded with before; in his own car the front passenger pressed a knife to his chest after the $28,000 was handed over, the back-seat man grabbed for Manos's own gun, both ran with the cash. Settled (DA): description → "robbed of $28,000 at knifepoint" (the only gun in the report is Manos's own, in his door pocket); money_wanted → $28,000 cash brought to buy bitcoin, coin_type → cash, no crypto taken (as with 94 and 137); date 25 July 2016 kept ("early Monday" in a report published 27 July 2016 per the URL); sequence P2P Trade Gone Wrong kept; weapons 1, theft 1 unchanged; targeting vector = business counterparty (several prior trades); arrests: Andre Allen arrested next day (armed robbery, burglary, battery), second man not identified; one source (Sun Sentinel). Question 1, detention: for 1, knife pressed to his chest inside his car with two men in it, the owner's 241 ruling ("held in the car at knifepoint"); for 0, the cash was already handed over when the knife appeared, nobody was restrained and he chased them across the car park (clarification 3, as in 82). DA recommendation: 1, per 241. Question 2, violence_torture: "a struggle ensued as the backseat passenger tried to grab Manos' gun" and a battery charge, no injury described. DA recommendation: 1, resting on the struggle and the battery charge.